Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:29793
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
F.A. No. 94 of 2026
1. Budhan Devi, aged about 62 years, W/o Late Gahnu Munda
2. Radha Munda, aged about 35 years, S/o Late Gahnu Munda,
3. Savitri Kumari, aged about 22 years, D/o Late Gahnu Munda,
4. Sunni Munda, aged about 19 years, S/o Late Gahnu Munda,
5. Munni Devi, aged about 35 years, W/o Late Chhotan Munda
6. Sitaram Munda, aged about 39 years, S/o Late Sanicharwa Munda
7. Etwa Munda, aged about 42 years S/o Late Sanicharwa Munda
All R/o Sukurhuttu, P.O + P.S.- Sukurhuttu, District-Ranchi
…
…
Claimants/Appellants
Versus
1. Daho Devi, D/o Late Bhuduwa Munda, R/o Sukurhuttu, P.O. +
P.S.- Sukurhuttu, District- Ranchi
2. The State of Jharkhand through District Land Acquisition Officer,
P.O.- GPO Ranchi, P.S. – Kotwali, Distt.- Ranchi
…
…
Opposite parties/Respondents
--CORAM :HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Appellants
: Mr. Rahul Gupta, Advocate
: Mr. Shubham Kumar, Advocate
For the Resp. No. 1
: Mr. Pradeep Kumar Deomani, Advocate
: Mr. Nilesh Kumar Gupta, Advocate
For Resp. No. 2 – State : Mr. Pankaj Kumar Choudhary,
AC to SC (L&C)-II
--C.A.V. on 08.06.2026
1.
Pronounced on 05.10.2026
This appeal has been filed against the judgment dated 31.10.2025
and award dated 06.11.2025 passed by learned Judicial Commissioner
cum Land Acquisition Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority, Ranchi
in Land Acquisition Case No. 2 of 2021 whereby the case of the
Claimants/appellants have been dismissed.
2.
The lands of late Sauna Munda, late Bhadwa Munda and late
Induwa Munda, all sons of late Soma Munda were acquired vide
notification no. 3966 dated 30.10.2015 wherein compensation was fixed.
Dispute arose when daughter in the lineage of late Induwa Munda, namely
Daho Devi and son of the daughter in the lineage of late Langda Munda
son of late Sauna Munda, namely, Mohan Munda claimed share/
entitlement in payment of compensation. The claimants, all in the lineage
of late Bandhan Munda son of late Sauna Munda, claimed exclusion of
2026:JHHC:29793
entitlement of daughters through inheritance by referring to tribal
customary law of Munda, Schedule tribe.
3.
The genealogy is not in dispute and has been mentioned in the latter
part of this judgement.
4.
The lands were acquired under the provisions of Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Act of 2013’)
and the award was prepared in the name of three awardees, late Sauna
Munda, late Bhadwa Munda and late Induwa Munda, all sons of late
Soma Munda.
5.
On account of aforesaid dispute regarding entitlement of daughters
in the family, the matter was referred to the learned court in terms of
section 64 of the aforesaid Act of 2013. The appellants herein claimed that
the females in the family are not entitled to inherit the property as per the
customary law governing the parties and the private respondent claimed
that they have been sufficiently hinduised and they are to be governed by
Hindu Succession Act in the matter of inheritance and succession.
6.
The learned court has rejected the claim of the claimants and has
allocated share in the compensation amount to the daughters/their
descendant. The case was dismissed. The claimants are in appeal before
this court.
7.
Both the parties have submitted their written notes of arguments.
The arguments made in open court and the submissions made through
written arguments have been duly recorded in the last order by which the
judgement was reserved. During the course of arguments, neither the
details of property, nor the genealogy has been disputed by either party.
8.
Gist of the Arguments of claimants/Appellants
A. Both the parties belong to the Munda Scheduled Tribe community
and are governed by customary tribal law in matters of succession
and inheritance. According to the customary law prevailing
amongst the Mundas, in the event a male dies leaving no male
issue, his widow and unmarried daughters are only entitled to
maintenance from the usufruct of the property during their lifetime
2026:JHHC:29793
or until remarriage, and after their death or remarriage the property
devolves upon the nearest male agnates of the deceased.
B. Appellants’ case is that the lands in question were ancestral raiyati
properties recorded in the Revisional Survey Record of Rights in
the names of Sauna Munda, Bhadwa Munda and Induwa Munda, all
sons of late Soma Munda, who were in possession thereof; Bhadwa
Munda died issueless, his share devolved upon his brothers Sauna
Munda and Induwa Munda in accordance with Munda customary
law. Thereafter, through successive inheritance in the male line, the
properties devolved upon the appellants and their predecessors. It is
further pleaded that Budhuwa Munda, the only son of Induwa
Munda, died without any male issue and consequently, under the
prevailing Munda custom, his interest devolved upon his nearest
male agnates, namely the surviving legal heirs of Sauna Munda
including the present appellants. Accordingly, the appellants claim
that they are in peaceful possession of the acquired lands and
possess absolute right, title, interest and share therein, and therefore
they alone are entitled to receive the compensation amount awarded
in respect of the acquired lands.
C. Submissions: a. The learned trial court, while solely relying on the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in “Ram Charan & Ors. vs.
Sukhram & Ors.” passed in Civil Appeal No. 9537/25 arising out
of SLP (C) No. 5559 of 2023 held that even in absence of proof of
any specific tribal custom excluding women from inheritance, tribal
women and their legal heirs are entitled to equal rights of
inheritance in ancestral property. The Court further observed that it
was an admitted fact that the parties belonged to the tribal
community and that the acquired lands stood recorded in the names
of the common ancestors/awardees, namely Late Sauna Munda,
Late Bhadwa Munda and Late Induwa Munda, all descendants of
common ancestor Soma Munda.
Accordingly, the Trial Court concluded that Daho Devi and Mohan
Munda (now dead), being successors-in-interest of the awardees
through the female line, were entitled to equal shares in the
acquired property. On that basis, the claim of the appellants was
rejected.
2026:JHHC:29793
b. The impugned judgment passed by the learned Trial Court is
completely erroneous on the ground that the learned court has
mentioned the case of respective parties and has summarised the
evidence of both the parties, but has not discussed the evidence nor
have any findings been recorded as to whether the parties were
sufficiently Hinduised so as to attract Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
c. The judgment which has been followed by the learned court to hold
that the parties would be governed by Hindu Succession Act does
not apply to the facts and circumstances of this case, inasmuch as, it
applied under those circumstances where the parties have failed to
prove the religion/custom which they are following and the
principle of equity and good conscience would be attracted only
under such circumstances. The learned trial court has not at all
discussed the evidences on record, both oral and documentary, and
has taken a wrong approach while deciding the case.
d. From the evidences, it would appear that the claim of the
Objectors/respondents is based on the fact that they have been
sufficiently Hinduised. The Objectors/respondents have not denied
that according to the custom they are following, widow and
daughters do not have inheritance right over the ancestral property,
rather, their specific case is that they are following Hindu custom
and they are sufficiently Hinduised and therefore they are entitled to
inherit as per the Hindu Succession Act over the ancestral property.
e. OPW-1, Manoj Munda, who is the own son of the Respondent no.1
in para 16 of his cross-examination, has admitted that under Munda
Customary law, widow and daughters do not have right over the
property (clearly referring to ancestral property). In para 21, he has
stated that they follow Sarna religion as well as Hindu Religion.
Daho Devi, who was the OPW-2, in para 10 of her crossexamination, has stated that her husband was buried after his
demise. In para 16, she has further stated that her father was buried,
however she again stated that he was cremated in funeral pyre.
However, again in para 17, she has stated that her own sister was
buried and not cremated in funeral pyre. Again, even with regard to
Gahnu Munda i.e., the original claimant and husband of Appellant
No. 1, it has also been stated that his last rite were performed in
Sukurhtu Masna.
f. It is submitted that from the evidences adduced on behalf of the
Respondent themselves, it shall transpire with regard to the mode of
final rites that after the death of family members, the deceased have
been buried and not cremated. In para 19 of evidence of OPW-2,
i.e., the Respondent no.1, she has stated that she is following Sarna
Dharam.
g. For the purpose of claiming the benefit of Hindu Succession Act, a
person has to prove that they have been sufficiently Hinduised. The
word "sufficiently Hinduised" means that by following Hindu
2026:JHHC:29793
religion, such parties are no longer following their original religion
and have thus been sufficiently Hinduised. Partially adopting
certain portions of Hindu religion would not mean that the parties
have been sufficiently Hinduised. This is more so in view of the bar
imposed in Section 2(2) of the Hindu Succession Act, which
specifically prohibits that the law of Hindu Succession Act would
not be applicable to Tribal people.
h. Further, from evidence of parties particularly Opposite Party
witnesses who have claimed their right over the property in dispute
on the ground that they have been sufficiently Hinduised, it would
be relevant to place the evidence of O.P.W-2 and O.P.W-1, who are
the Respondent no.1 and her son respectively, it would appear from
their evidence that the family of the parties originally belonged to
Sarna Dharm, i.e., Sarna religion. Sarna and Hinduism are two
different religions. And therefore, from their evidence it would
appear that for taking benefit of the properties of the Hindu
Succession Act, the Opposite Party/Respondent are trying to prove
that although they belong to Sarna religion originally but they have
now adopted Hinduism. The persons following Sarna religion,
celebrate Sarhul and Karma which is an important festival for them,
i.e., the persons following Sarna religion. Hindus may participate in
Sarhul and Karma only out of joy, but it is not their festival. In para
15 of evidence of O.P.W.-1 it has been stated that they celebrate
Sarhul and Karma and in para 21 he has stated that he and his
family were following both Sarna as well as Hindu religion. On the
other hand, O.P.W.-2, who is the opposite party herself, has very
categorically admitted that her father and sister were both buried in
Masna. Again, Masna is a place in which the persons following
Sarna religion are buried. Again, in para 19 of her cross
examination, O.P.W.-2 has stated that she is following Sarna
religion and she also celebrates Sarhul and Karma festivals.
i. A reference has been made to the evidence of O.P.W-3, namely
Mohan Munda who stated in para 17 of his cross examination that
they also celebrate Karma and Sarhul. He has further stated that
they also worship Karma and Sarhul. Worshiping Karma and Sarhul
is an important aspect of following Sarna religion. Again O.P.W.-4,
namely Babu Lal Munda in para 23 of his cross examination has
stated that Shiv Dayal Munda's (who was the husband of Opposite
Party Daho Devi) last rites have been done in Masna. In para 24,
again he has stated that the family of Shiv Dayal Munda and
Budhuwa Munda worship the festival of Karma and Sarhul.
O.P.W.-5, namely Mahabir Munda, in para 18 of his evidence, has
stated that after the death of Shiv Dayal Munda, his last rites were
done in Masna. In last rites of person following Sarna, there is no
2026:JHHC:29793
concept of cremation by funeral pyre rather they are buried. No
cremation therefore takes place at Masna and last rites having done
in Masna would mean burial in Masna.
j. It is submitted that a person cannot be allowed to get out of rigors
of a particular religion only for getting the benefit of the property
rights. In the instant case, unless the Objectors/respondents would
have proved that they have been sufficiently Hinduised, that means
that they have started following Hindu religion to such an extent
that they were no longer following Sarna religion, they cannot be
said to have been sufficiently Hinduised. A person who essentially
continues to follow traditional Sarna religion in their ways of life
particularly by burial in Masna and worshipping Karma and Sarhul,
would continue to be a member of Sarna religion and merely
because they have adopted certain ways of life from Hindus, that
would not mean that they have been sufficiently Hinduised. A
person cannot be allowed to get property rights under the Hindu
Succession Act on the ground that they have been sufficiently
Hinduised as they follow some of the ways of life of Hindus
whereas facts would go to show that they continue to follow the
essentials of Sarna religion.
k. Learned counsel for the appellants has referred to their pleading
before the learned court found at running page no. 307 of the
Records received from the court and submits that in paragraphs 3
and 4, it has been specifically pleaded that the parties are governed
by their customary law in the matter of succession and inheritance
and according to customary law prevalent amongst Munda
community, the females are excluded from inheriting the property
and they are entitled to maintenance under certain circumstances. It
has also been pleaded that the property of sonless Munda devolves
upon his nearest male agnates. Paragraphs 3 and 4 of the pleadings
are quoted as under:
“3. That the petitioner and opposite parties are by caste
Munda being members of Scheduled Tribe and are
governed by their customary law in the matter of
succession and inheritance.
4. That according to the customary law prevalent amongst
Munda community, if a male Munda dies leaving behind
no male issue, his widow and unmarried daughters
entitled to be maintained out of the usufructs of the
immoveable properties left by the last sonless male munda
so long the widow does not remarry and she does not
married so long she is alive and so long the unmarried
daughters are not married and if they are not married so
long they are alive and after the remarriage of the widow
2026:JHHC:29793
or after her death as the case may be and after the
marriage of the unmarried daughters and if they die
unmarried, the property of the last male sonless munda
devolve upon his nearest male agnates.”
l. Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the fact that the
parties are governed by customary law and that such customary law
was prevalent, was enough pleading on record to cover each of the
elements of customary law to be applied in the present case to
exclude the females from inheritance.
m. Learned counsel for the appellants has then referred to the petition
filed by the respondent at page no. 267 of the records received from
the concerned court. He has referred to paragraphs 20, 26 and 28 of
the aforesaid written statement, which are quoted as under:
“20. That the petitioner/claimant hereby states and
submits that she is performing Hindu Religions in all
kinds of festivals Deepawali, Holi festival just like Hindu
woman of Hindu Religion.
26. That the Petitioner/Claimant state and submit that
she is performing Hindu Religion in all kinds of festival
just like a Hindu Women in support of that filling
submitting affidavit.
27…
28. That in view of the facts and law points stated above
it is well proved that a Tribal woman has got right and
inherit the paternal and ancestral properties just as
Hindu women.”
n. However, from the perusal of the petition filed by the respondents,
it appears that no para-wise comment was filed.
o. Learned counsel for the appellants has also submitted that nonfiling of para-wise comments by either party with respect to the
pleadings could be on account of the reason that each of them
termed themselves as “petitioners/claimants”, although the
respondents in the present case had filed their petition after filing of
the petition filed by the appellants.
p. It is submitted that the approach of the learned trial court is
erroneous in law and the impugned judgement and award is fit to be
set-aside.
q. The appellants have relied upon the judgment reported in (2000) 8
SCC 587 (Labishwar Manjhi vs. Pran Manjhi & Others),
paragraph 5 and 6.
r. The learned counsel for the appellants has also referred to the
judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal
2026:JHHC:29793
No. 9537 of 2025 (Ram Charan & Ors. Vs. Sukhram & Ors.) and
submitted that this judgment has been relied upon by the learned
court, but the reliance is completely misplaced and therefore, the
said judgment does not apply to the facts and circumstances of this
case.
9.
Gist of Arguments of the respondent no.1
A. It is admitted by both the parties that the recorded tenant, Bhadwa
Munda had died issueless, and that the appellants are the
descendants of the recorded tenant, Sauna Munda, and the sole
private respondent is the descendant of the recorded tenant, Induwa
Munda. However, a dispute arose between the parties in respect of
the apportionment of the amount of compensation in lieu of the said
acquisition.
B. The appellants raised their objection before the District Land
Acquisition Officer, Ranchi, to the effect that the appellants and the
respondent are the members of the Scheduled Tribes, as they belong
to the Munda community, and that they are governed by the customs
in the matter of inheritance and succession. The appellants further
claim that they still follow Sarna religion and customs prevalent in
their Munda community and according to the custom prevalent in
their Munda community, if a male Munda dies, leaving no male
issue behind him, his widow does not inherit the landed property left
by him, but is entitled to be maintained out of the usufruct of such
immovable property till she remarries or till her life, as the case may
be, and likewise, his unmarried daughter also does not inherit the
landed property left by him, but is entitled to be maintained out of
the usufruct of such immovable property till she marries or till her
life, as the case may be. And after remarriage or death of his widow
and/or after marriage or death of his unmarried daughter, as the case
may be, the landed property left by him devolves upon his nearest
male agnates.
C. The appellants led oral as well as documentary evidences in support
of their case. It was the appellants who claimed existence of certain
custom relating to inheritance and succession in their Munda
community, and, therefore, the onus was upon them only to properly
plead and prove such custom as being ancient, certain, continuous
and acted upon in their community. However, the appellants totally
failed even to plead the basic necessary facts about such custom as
being ancient, certain, continuous and acted upon in their
community. And in absence of proper pleadings, the evidences led
by them are also lacking and shaky, which do not prove such custom
as being ancient, certain, continuous and acted upon in their
community.
2026:JHHC:29793
D. The case of the sole private respondent, Daho Devi, is that she
inherited the landed property left by her deceased father, which was
the only source of her income for her livelihood. The respondent
asserted that they have sufficiently been hinduized, as they celebrate
all Hindu festivals, follow all Hindu customs and rituals and keep
Hindu names amongst themselves; and, therefore, the Hindu
Succession Act, 1956 will be applicable.
E. The respondent no.1 also led oral evidence in support of her case
and the witnesses examined on her behalf have successfully
established that the appellants and the respondent have sufficiently
been hinduized, which can easily lead to the application of the
Hindu Succession Act, 1956 in their case.
It is relevant to mention here that though the witness no. 1 of the
respondent no.1, Manoj Munda, admits in the para no. 16 of his
cross examination that a widow or a daughter does not inherit and
succeed to the property left by her deceased husband or father, but
the same will not help the appellants for two reasons:
1) The appellants have to stand on their own legs and
they have totally failed in their duty of proving the
custom they claim to be in existence in their
community.
2) The respondent has been able to prove that the
appellants and the respondent have sufficiently been
hinduized.
F. Though the learned trial court has not discussed the evidences of the
parties on the record at length and discussed the same in a cursory
manner and has also not returned any clear finding based on the
same, but it is amply evident from the materials on the record that:
1) It was the appellants who claimed existence of
certain custom relating to inheritance and succession in
their Munda community, and, therefore, the onus was
upon them only to properly plead and prove such
custom as being ancient, certain, continuous and acted
upon in their community. However, the appellants
totally failed even to plead the basic necessary facts
about such custom as being ancient, certain, continuous
and acted upon in their community. And in absence of
proper pleadings, the evidences led by them are also
lacking and shaky, which do not prove such custom as
being ancient, certain, continuous and acted upon in
their community.
2026:JHHC:29793
2) The witnesses examined on behalf of the respondent
have successfully established that the appellants and the
respondent have sufficiently been hinduized, which can
easily lead to the application of the Hindu Succession
Act 1956 in their case.
In the above facts and circumstances, the learned court has
very aptly and rightly applied the ratio of Ram Charan
case to the case in hand.
G. With the aforesaid submissions, following points have been argued:i) That the appellants who claimed existence of certain
custom relating to inheritance and succession in their
Munda community, had the onus to properly plead and
prove the custom as being ancient, certain, continuous
and acted upon in their community. However, the
appellants totally failed even to plead the basic necessary
facts about such custom as being ancient, certain,
continuous and acted upon in their community.
ii) That in the given facts and circumstances, the case in
hand is squarely covered by Ram Charan case as reported
in 2025 SCC Online SC 1465.
iii) That in absence of proper pleadings, the evidences led by
the appellants are also lacking and shaky, which do not
prove such custom as being ancient, certain, continuous
and acted upon in their community in view of Ratanlal @
Babulal Chunilal Samsuka case as reported in 2017 (11)
SCR 28 as well as judgment in Baga Tirkey case of this
Hon'ble Court.
iv) That the witnesses examined on behalf of the respondent
no.1 have successfully established that the appellants and
the respondent have sufficiently been hinduized, which
can easily lead to the application of the Hindu Succession
Act, 1956 in their case in view of judgment in Labishwar
Manjhi case as reported in 2000 (8) SCC 587.
H. Evidences referred during the course of arguments by the learned
counsel for the respondents in particular are as under: From the Evidence of OPW-1 – Manoj Munda (para 4 )
4. यह कि उक्त वाद िे वादीगण गहनु मुण्डा वगैरह िे घर िे सामने सटा हुआ मेरा
घर है इसलिए हर वर्ष रामनवमी िे ददन बजरं ग बिी िा झंडा मंडप में िगािर
गहनु मुण्डा एंव एतवा मुण्डा िो रामनवमी िी पूजा िरते मैंने दे खा है ।
2026:JHHC:29793
From the Evidence of C.W.- 3 – Etwa Munda (para 13
of examination in chief and para 23 of crossexamination)
13. यह कि हम आवेदिगण एवं आपततिर्त्ाष मण्
ु डा समाज िे परम्परा िे अनस
ु ार
सभी तरह िे धालमषि अनष्ु ठान, वववाह, मण्
ु डन, दाह संस्िार, नामिरण आदद
सभी िा तनवषहन सरना रीतत ररवाज िे अनुसार िरते हैं।
23. आपवर्त्िताष िे ववद्वान अधधवक्ता द्वारा साक्षी िो एि फोटो ददखाया
गया जजसे दे खिर वह िहता है कि यह मेरे घर िा फोटो है । परन्तु उसमें
िगा झण्डा मेरे घर में िगे झण्डे से अिग है । साक्षी फोटो में िगे झण्डा
िो दे खिर िहता है कि यह रामनवमी िा झण्डा है । मेरे घर में सरना िा
झण्डा िगता है । राम नवमी िा झण्डा मेरे घर में नहीं िगता है ।
I. Learned counsel for the respondent no.1 has also submitted that the
pleadings filed by both the parties appear to be independent of each
other, inasmuch as, none of them have filed para-wise comments to show
that one or the other pleading of the party concerned stood admitted by
the other party. He submits that this is also apparent from the fact that at
the very first page of the respective pleadings, both the parties have
claimed themselves to be “petitioners/claimants” and the pleading has
not been filed in terms of the plaint/written statement, rather each of
them filed their respective petition. The learned counsel has submitted
that under such circumstances, it cannot be said that it stood admitted on
the part of the respondents that there is a custom which is consistently
followed to exclude the female from inheritance.
J. The aforesaid judgment reported in (2000) 8 SCC 587(supra), has also
been relied upon by the learned counsel for the respondent no.1,
paragraphs 5 and 6.
K. Learned counsel for the respondent no.1 has relied upon the following
judgments: (i)
F.A. No. 124 of 2018 (Baga Tirkey vs. Pinki Linda)
decided on 08.04.2021, paragraph 23 to 26.
(ii)
1955 SCC OnLine Pat. 67 (Budhu Majhi vs. Dukhan
Majhi), paragraph 38.
(iii)
2017 11 SCR 28 (Ratanlal @ Babulal Chunilal
Samsuka v. Sundarabai Govardhandas Samsuka (D)
Thr. LRs & Ors.), paragraph 12 and 13.
Rejoinder
10.
Learned counsel for the appellants, in response, has submitted that
the specific case of the respondent no.1 was that they are sufficiently
2026:JHHC:29793
Hinduized in order to claim that they are governed by Hindu Succession
Act. Even during the evidences which were produced on behalf of the
appellants, there is no cross-examination on this aspect of the matter.
11.
During the course of arguments, the judgment passed by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in (2013) 4 SCC 97 [Laxmibai (dead)
through LRs. and Another Vs. Bhagwanthbuva (dead) through LRs
and others] has also been referred by the Court.
Findings of this court.
12.
Background of the case.
The case was referred to the learned court under the relevant provisions of
Act of 2013 for deciding the right, title, interest and claim of the parties
with respect to the lands of revisional survey khata no. 447 including plot
no. 237 area 0.37 acres, plot no. 238 area 0.04 acres, plot no. 239 area
0.01 acres, plot no. 247 area 0.06 acres, plot no. 248 area 0.03 acres, plot
no. 249 area 0.36 acres and plot no. 256 area 0.28 acres and the lands of
khata no. 448 plot no. 246 area 0.04 acres, plot no. 250 area 0.04 acres,
plot no. 252 area 0.18 acres and plot no. 255 area 0.03 acres and the lands
of R.S. khata no. 519 including plot no. 190 area 0.01 acres, plot no. 194
area 0.28 acres, plot no. 195 area 0.28 acres, plot no. 196 area 0.6 acres
situated at village Sukurhutu, Police Station Ranchi (now P.S. Sukurhutu),
Thana no. 154, District Ranchi along with other lands which were sought
to be acquired for construction of Transport Nagar vide Land Acquisition
Case No. 132 of 2017-18.
The property in dispute are as follows:
Khata No. Plot No.
Area
01 decimal
28 decimal
28 decimal
06 decimal
Total Area
63 decimal
2026:JHHC:29793
Khata No. Plot No.
Area
37 decimal
04 decimal
01 decimal
06 decimal
03 decimal
36 decimal
28 decimal
Total Area
115 decimal
Khata No. Plot No.
Area
04 decimal
04 decimal
18 decimal
03 decimal
Total Area
29 decimal
Award no. 4 for Rs. 3,89,70,089.00 with respect to acquisition of lands of
R.S. khata no. 519 including plot no. 190 area 0.01 acres, plot no. 194
area 0.28 acres, plot no. 195 area 0.28 acres, plot no. 196 area 0.6 acres,
award no. 08 for Rs. 18,55,718.00 with respect to acquisition of land of
R.S. khata no. 448 plot no. 255 area 0.03 acres and award no. 9 for Rs.
1,73,20,035.00 with respect to acquisition of land of R.S. khata no. 447
plot no. 256 area 0.28 acres, award no. 26 for Rs. 5,38,15,823.00 with
respect to acquisition of land of R.S. khata no. 447 plot no. 237 area 0.37
acres, plot no. 238 area 0.04 acres, plot no. 239 area 0.01 acres, plot no.
247 area 0.06 acres, plot no. 248 area 0.03 acres and plot no. 249 area
0.36 acres and award no. 27 for Rs. 1,60,82,890.00 with respect to
acquisition of land of R.S. khata no. 448 plot no. 246 area 0.04 acres, plot
no. 250 area 0.04 acres, plot no. 252 area 0.18 acres, situated at village
Sukurhutu, Police Station Ranchi (now P.S. Sukurhutu), Thana no. 154,
District Ranchi has been published in the name of Sauna Munda and
others for which there is dispute between the parties regarding payment of
compensation of the said acquired lands.
2026:JHHC:29793
13.
The award
The award was with respect to the properties of common ancestor of the
parties, late Soma Munda, but the award was prepared in the name of his
three sons, who were termed as the awardees. Further details are as
followsa. Bhadwa Munda (one of the three awardees) died issueless.
b. The grand daughter in the branch of Induwa Munda (one of
the three awardees), namely, Daho Devi, was allocated the
share of property/compensation.
c. Sauna Munda (one of the three awardees) had two sons but
one son had only one daughter and Mohan Munda was the son
of the granddaughter of Sauna Munda. Mohan Munda was
also allocated share/compensation.
d. The male descendants of Sauna Munda in male lineage
through one of his sons objected to allocation of compensation
to Daho Devi and Mohan Munda and claimed that the entire
compensation ought to have been awarded to them being the
male agnates in the family.
e. The male descendants of Sauna Munda claimed the entire
compensation amount in the capacity of the nearest male
agnates in the family by referring to customary law governing
the parties and claimed that under the customary law females
are completely excluded from inheritance and are entitled only
to maintenance under certain circumstances.
14.
Reference to the learned court.
Thus, Daho Devi and Mohan Munda were found entitled to the share of
their respective ancestor being female descendant/ through female
descendant of their respective branch. However, the appellants herein
objected and asserted that they are governed by tribal laws with respect to
inheritance and females in the family are not entitled to inherit and in
absence of male heirs the property devolves upon male agnates in the
family. Daho Devi and Mohan Munda claimed that they are sufficiently
hinduised and are governed by Hindu Succession Act, 1956 in the matter
of succession and inheritance. Upon such dispute, the matter was referred
to the court under section 64 of the aforesaid Act of 2013 for deciding the
dispute. Mohan Munda expired during the pendency of the case before the
learned trial court and his name was deleted. It is important to note that
2026:JHHC:29793
the appellants jointly contested against the allocation of any share to Daho
Devi and Mohan Munda with respect to the compensation of the acquired
land which was admittedly belonging to the common ancestor namely,
Soma Munda.
15.
The learned court held that Daho Devi as well as Mohan Munda
(deceased and deleted during the pendency of the case) were entitled to
their share in the compensation and dismissed the claim of the
claimants/appellants that Daho Devi as well as Mohan Munda (deceased
and deleted during the pendency of the case) are not entitled to any share
of compensation.
16.
Before proceeding further, it would be relevant to deal with the
law regarding claim based on custom which has now been settled by
various judicial pronouncements. The discussions are as follows: A. In the judgment passed by Hon’ble Patna High Court reported in
AIR 1956 Pat. 123 (Budhu Majhi & Anr. Vs. Dukhan Majhi &
others), the case was 2nd appeal with respect to parties who were
Santhal (Scheduled Tribe). One of the parties denied to be governed
by tribal laws on the ground that they have been sufficiently
Hinduized and had adopted the Hindu law in the matter of
inheritance and succession. The trial court accepted the contention
of the defendants and held that the parties were Hinduized and had
adopted the Hindu law for the purpose of succession. The 1 st
appellate court reversed the finding by holding that the parties were
governed by Tribal laws and females were excluded from
inheritance. The question whether the parties, who are of nonHindu origin, have been sufficiently Hinduised so as to attract the
provisions of Hindu law in the matter of inheritance and succession,
was earlier held to be a mixed question of fact and law in the
judgment reported in AIR 1946 Pat 218(A), therefore, the Hon'ble
Patna High Court in the case of Budhu Majhi (Supra) examined
the evidence to find out whether the parties were sufficiently
hinduised.
2026:JHHC:29793
In the aforesaid background, the Hon’ble Patna High Court referred
to the judgment reported in AIR 1929 Cal 577(B), which was
quoted with approval in the judgment reported in AIR 1946 Pat
218(A) wherein it has been held that adoption of Hindu names,
employment of priests, performance of Pujas such as Durga Puja,
Mansa Puja, Kali Puja, etc. offering of pindas, observance of
mourning, performance of funeral ceremonies were sufficient proof
of a family, aboriginal in origin, having adopted Hinduism in its
entirety.
B. The paragraph 8 of the judgment is quoted as under:
“8. The tests to be applied for the determination of the question
whether a non-Hindu tribe has been so Hinduised have been
pointed out in the case of — ‘Narendra Narain v. Nagendra
Narain’, AIR 1929 Cal 577 (B), and they have been quoted with
approval by a Bench of this Court in the aforesaid case in. AIR
1946 Pat 218 (A). It has been held that adoption of Hindu
names, employment of priests, performance of pujas, such as
Durga Puja, Mansa Puja, Kaii Paja, etc. offering of pindas,
observing of mourning, performance of funeral ceremonies were
sufficient proof of a family, aboriginal in origin, having adopted
Hinduism in its entirety.”
The Hon’ble Patna High Court also referred to a judgment reported
in AIR 1937 Mad 172(C) wherein it was held that a formal
conversion is not a pre-requisite to a person becoming Hindu.
The Hon’ble Patna High Court observed in paragraph 13 of the
judgment that one of the tests is the adoption of Hindu names and in
the said case, the parties, witnesses and their relations mostly had
Hindu names.
The Hon’ble Patna High Court referred to the finding of the learned
sub-ordinate Judge that if the Hindu names have to be adopted,
each and every Santhal must be so named and observed that the
same was not correct position.
The Court further observed that the Santhals must have Santhal
name as a matter of course, but when it is found that they are
subsequently attempting to adopt Hindu names, the intention on
2026:JHHC:29793
their part may be safely inferred that they want to acknowledge
themselves to be Hindus, or at least, they are attempting to do so.
The Hon’ble Patna High Court dealt with another test and observed
that another test is the performance of Hindu Pujas and observance
of Hindu ceremonies. The Court also considered that the evidence
of the witnesses in their cross-examination, which showed that they
were still retaining some of their old relics, such as, Sarhul Puja,
Jahira Puja, worship of ghosts and use of Handia at the Sradh
ceremony, does not mitigate against their adoption of Hinduism.
The Hon’ble Court examined the evidence of the witnesses from
the side of the plaintiffs also and observed that even from the
plaintiffs’ own witnesses, it appeared that females were not
excluded from inheritance. The Court ultimately held in paragraph
38 as follows:
“38. All these grounds are no longer good for holding against the
parties being governed by the Hindu Law in matters of
inheritance and succession. It is not necessary that they must be
completely Hinduised. Even if they had been sufficiently
Hinduised so as to be governed by the Hindu Law of succession,
it is enough.”
C. In the judgment passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in
(1996) 5 SCC 125 (Madhu Kishwar and Ors. Vs. State of Bihar
and Ors.), writ petitions were filed before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court challenging the provision of Chhota Nagpur Tenancy Act,
1908, which provides succession of property only in the male line.
The judgment rendered by Hon’ble Mr. Justice K. Ramaswamy
commenced from paragraph 15 of the reports who held in
paragraph 46 that customs among the Scheduled Tribes, vary from
tribe to tribe and region to region, based upon the established
practice prevailing in the respective regions and among particular
tribes. It has been held that it would be difficult to decide, without
acceptable material among each tribe, whether customary
succession is valid, certain, ancient and consistent and whether it
has acquired the status of law. The Hon’ble Judge held that customs
2026:JHHC:29793
became a part of the tribal laws as a guide to their attitude and
practice in their social life and not a final definition of law. They
are accepted as set of principles and are being applied when
succession is open. They have accordingly nearly acquired the
status of law. The Hon’ble Judge held that under aforesaid
circumstances, it was not desirable to grant general declaration that
the custom of inheritance offends Articles 14, 15 and 21 of the
Constitution and each case must be examined and decided as and
when full facts are placed before the Court. Paragraph 46 of the
aforesaid judgment is quoted as under:“46. It would thus be seen that the customs among the
Scheduled Tribes, vary from tribe to tribe and region to
region, based upon the established practice prevailing in
the respective regions and among particular tribes.
Therefore, it would be difficult to decide, without acceptable
material among each tribe, whether customary succession is
valid, certain, ancient and consistent and whether it has
acquired the status of law. However, as noticed above,
customs are prevalent and are being followed among the
tribes in matters of succession and inheritance apart from
other customs like marriage, divorce etc. Customs became
part of the tribal laws as a guide to their attitude and
practice in their social life and not a final definition of law.
They are accepted as a set of principles and are being
applied when succession is open. They have accordingly
nearly acquired the status of law. Except in Meghalaya,
throughout the country patrilineal succession is being
followed according to the unwritten code of customs. Like in
Hindu law, they prefer son to the daughter and in his
absence daughter succeeds to the estate as a limited owner.
Widows also get only limited estate. More than 80 per cent
of the population is still below poverty line and they did not
come on a par with civilized sections of the non-tribals.
Under these circumstances, it is not desirable to grant
general declaration that the custom of inheritance offends
Articles 14, 15 and 21 of the Constitution. Each case must
be examined and decided as and when full facts are placed
before the court.”
The majority view has been recorded in paragraph 1 to 14 of the
aforesaid judgment and it has been observed by majority judgment
2026:JHHC:29793
in paragraph 5 that they agreed with Hon’ble Justice K.
Ramaswamy as mentioned in paragraph 46 of his judgment.
D. This Court finds that the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Madhu Kishwar (supra) has clearly taken note of the
fact that the customary law varies from tribe to tribe and from
region to region and each case is required to be examined when full
facts are placed before the Court.
E. In the judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in
(2000) 8 SCC 587 (Labishwar Manjhi vs. Pran Manjhi & Others),
the case was with respect to Santhal tribe. There was a concurrent
finding by the learned trial court as well as the learned 1 st appellate
court that the parties were sufficiently Hinduised and the Hindu law
of succession would be applicable. The 2nd appeal was allowed and
the concurrent finding of both the courts was set-aside. Before the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, it was argued that even if the parties were
Hinduised, the parties being of Santhal tribe, they are following
their customary law of Santhal, hence Hindu Succession Act would
not be applied. The question which arose before the Hon'ble
Supreme Court was, whether the parties who admittedly belonged
to Santhal tribe, are still continuing with their customary tradition
or have they, after being Hinduised, changed their customs to that
which is followed by the Hindus. The Hon'ble Supreme Court took
note of the fact that the trial court recorded that most of the names
of the families of the parties were Hindu names. PW- 1 admitted
that they perform Pindas at the time of death of anybody, females
do not use vermillion on the forehead after the death of their
husband, widows do not wear ornaments and P.W. 2 admitted that
they perform Shradh ceremony for 10 days after the death and
recorded that the parties were following the customs of Hindus and
not the Santhal customs. Ultimately, the Hon’ble Court held that the
parties originally belonged to Santhal (Scheduled Tribe) and they
were Hinduised and they were following the Hindu tradition and
2026:JHHC:29793
consequently, they would be governed by Hindu Succession Act.
Paragraph 6 of the aforesaid judgment is quoted as under:
“6. The question which arises in the present case is, whether
the parties who admittedly belong to the Santhal Tribe are still
continuing with their customary tradition or have they after
being Hinduised changed their customs to that which is
followed by the Hindus. It is in this context when the matter
came first before the High Court, the High Court remanded the
case for decision in this regard. After remand the first
appellate court recorded the finding that most of the names of
the families of the parties are Hindu names. Even PW 1 admits
in the cross-examination that they perform the pindas at the
time of death of any body. Females do not use vermilion on the
forehead after the death of their husbands, widows do not wear
ornaments. Even PW 2 admits that they perform shradh
ceremonies for 10 days after the death and after marriage
females used vermilion on their foreheads. The finding of the
words is that they are following the customs of the Hindus and
not the Santhal customs. In view of such a clear finding it is not
possible to hold that sub-section (2) of Section 2 of the Hindu
Succession Act excludes the present parties from the
application of the said Act. Sub-section (2) only excludes
members of any Scheduled Tribe admittedly as per finding
recorded in the present case though the parties originally
belong to the Santhal Scheduled Tribes they are Hinduised and
they are following the Hindu traditions. Hence we have no
hesitation to hold that sub-section (2) will not apply to exclude
the parties from application of the Hindu Succession Act. The
High Court fell into error in recording a finding to the
contrary. In view of this, the widow of Lakhiram would become
the absolute owner by virtue of Section 14 of the said Act,
consequently the gift given by her to Appellants 2 and 3 was a
valid gift, hence the suit of Respondent 1 for setting aside the
gift deed and inheritance stands dismissed.”
F. In the judgment passed by this Court reported in AIR 2004 Jhar.
121 (Lakshmi Narayan Tudu alias Lakshmi Narayan Manjhi and
another Vs. Smt. Basi Majhian and others), the party claimed that
they are governed by customary law applicable to Santhal tribe and
one of the issues before the learned trial court was as follows:
“Have both the parties been sufficiently Hinduised and or
they governed by Hindu Law in the matters of succession
and inheritance?”
2026:JHHC:29793
The appeal was admitted on the following substantial question of
law:
“Whether Hindu Succession Act or Hindu law is
applicable in the matter of inheritance among the members
of Scheduled Tribes, if they are sufficiently Hinduised and
if so, where a daughter has any share in the property?”
This Court, inter alia, referred to the judgment passed in the case of
Labishwar Manjhi v. Pran Manjhi (Supra) and held that there was
concurrent finding of both the courts that the parties to the suit were
sufficiently hinduised and in this view of the matter, it could not be
said that section 2(2) of Hindu Succession Act excludes the parties
from application of the said act. It has also been held that section
2(2) of the Hindu Succession Act only excludes members of
Schedule Tribe, but as per concurrent finding, the parties though
originally belonged to Santhal Scheduled Tribes, but they were
Hinduised and followed Hindu tradition and therefore, they will be
governed by Hindu Succession Act.
G. In the judgment passed by this Court reported in 2004 SCC OnLine
Jhar 696 (Ram Nath Munda & Anr. Vs. Khaintu Munda and
Anr.), there was concurrent findings that the plaintiff and her father
were sufficiently Hinduised and the court was of the view that
consistent findings of fact based on appreciation of evidence do not
warrant any re-appreciation in 2nd appeal. However, in paragraph 10
of the judgment, the court observed that the only thing remained to
be examined was whether Munda (undisputedly a S.T.)
being
sufficiently Hinduised will be governed by Hindu Succession Act,
1956 and the plaintiff-respondent will become class 1 heir of her
father under the aforesaid Act? The High Court ultimately held that
once they are sufficiently Hinduised, they will be governed by
Hindu Succession Act.
H. ‘Custom’ has not been defined under the provisions of Hindu
Succession Act, 1956, but the same has been defined under the
provision of section 3(a) of Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act,
2026:JHHC:29793
1956. In the judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
reported in (2005) 9 SCC 407 (Subramani Vs. Chandralekha), it
has been held in paragraph 10 as follows:
“it is well established by long chain of authorities that
prevalence of customary divorce in the community to which
parties belong, contrary to general law of divorce must be
specifically pleaded and established by the person
propounding such custom…”
I. In the judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case
reported in 2017 11 SCR 28 [Ratanlal @ Babulal Chunilal
Samsuka v. Sundarabai Govardhandas Samsuka (D) Thr. LRs &
Ors.], the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that custom, at variance
with general law, should be strictly proved and the burden of
proving such custom is heavy on the person who relies upon such
custom. The Hon'ble Supreme Court interpreted the provision of
section 3(a) of the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act, 1956 and
held that the following ingredients are necessary for establishing a
valid customa. Continuity,
b. Certainty,
c. Long usage and
d. Reasonability.
It has also been held that generally there is a presumption that the
law prevails and whosoever claims custom against such law, has to
discharge the onus of proving it with all requisites to the
satisfaction of the court in the most clear and unambiguous manner.
There may be many types of customs – general custom, local
custom, tribal custom, etc. and the burden of proof for establishing
a type of custom depends on the type and the extent of usage. It
must be shown that the alleged custom has the characteristics of
genuine custom i.e., it is accepted willfully and having force of law
and is not a mere practice more or less common. The acts required
for establishment of customary law ought to be plural, uniform and
2026:JHHC:29793
constant. The findings and observation of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court with respect to aforesaid provision is quoted as under which
is in paragraph 12 to 17 of the judgment:
12. India has a strong tradition of respect for difference and
diversity which is reflected under the Hindu Family Laws as it
is applicable to diverse communities living from the southern
tip to northern mountains, from western plains to eastern hills.
Diversity in our country brings along various customs which
defines what India is. Law is not oblivious of this fact and
sometimes allows society to be governed by customs within the
foundation of law. It is well known that a custom commands
legitimacy not by an authority of law formed by the State
rather from the public acceptance and acknowledgment. This
Court in Thakur Gokal Chand v. Parvin Kumari, AIR 1952 SC
231, has explained the ingredients of a valid custom in the
following manner:
“A custom, in order to be binding, must derive its force from
the fact that by long usage it has obtained the force of law, but
the English rule that “a custom, in order that it may be legal
and binding, must have been used so long that the memory of
man runneth not to the contrary” should not be strictly
applied to Indian conditions. All that is necessary to prove is
that the usage has been acted upon in practice for such a long
period and with such invariability as to show that it has, by
common consent, been submitted to as the established
governing rule of a particular locality.”
Black's Law Dictionary defines customary law as: “customs
that are accepted as legal requirements or obligatory rules of
conduct, practices and beliefs that are so vital and intrinsic a
part of a social and economic system that they are treated as
if they are laws”.
Privy Council in The Collector of Madura v. Moottoo
Ramalinga Sathupathy, 12 MIA 397 (1868), has observed
that:
“under the Hindu system of law, clear proof of usage will
outweigh the written text of law”.
13. As per the settled law under Section 3(a) of the Act, the
following ingredients are necessary for establishing a valid
custom:
(a) Continuity
(b) Certainty
2026:JHHC:29793
(c) Long usage
(d) Reasonability
As customs, when pleaded are mostly at variance with the
general law, they should be strictly proved. Generally, there is
a presumption that law prevails and when the claim of custom
is against such general presumption, then, whoever sets up the
plea of existence of any custom has to discharge the onus of
proving it, with all its requisites to the satisfaction of the court
in a most clear and unambiguous manner. It should be noted
that, there are many types of customs to name a few—general
customs, local customs and tribal customs, etc. and the burden
of proof for establishing a type of custom depends on the type
and the extent of usage. It must be shown that the alleged
custom has the characteristics of a genuine custom viz. that it
is accepted wilfully as having force of law, and is not a mere
practice more or less common. The acts required for the
establishment of customary law ought to be plural, uniform
and constant.
14. Custom evolves by conduct, and it is therefore a mistake to
measure its validity solely by the element of express sanction
accorded by courts of law. The characteristic of the great
majority of customs is that they are essentially non-litigious in
origin. They arise not from any conflict of rights adjusted, but
from practices prompted by the convenience of society. A
judicial decision recognising a custom may be relevant, but
these are not indispensable for its establishment. When a
custom is to be proved by judicial notice, the relevant test
would be to see if the custom has been acted upon by a court
of superior or coordinate jurisdiction in the same jurisdiction
to the extent that justifies the court, which is asked to apply it,
in assuming that the persons or the class of persons concerned
in that area look upon the same as binding in relation to
circumstances similar to those under consideration. In this
case at hand there was no pleading or proof which could
justify that the above standards were met.
15. It would not be out of context to observe certain judicial
decisions which throw some light on the issue raised in this
case instant. In Rup Chand v. Jambu Parshad, (1910) ILR 32
247, Privy Council held that:
“The custom alleged in the pleading was this: “Among the
Jains adoption is no religious ceremony, and under the law or
custom there is no restriction of age or marriage among
them.” And that appears to be the custom found by the High
2026:JHHC:29793
Court to exist. But upon the argument before their Lordships it
was strenuously contended that the evidence in the present
case, limited as it is to a comparatively small number of
centres of Jain population, was insufficient to establish a
custom so wide as this, and that no narrower custom was
either alleged or proved.
In their Lordships' opinion there is great weight in these
criticisms, enough to make the present case an unsatisfactory
precedent if in any future instance fuller evidence regarding
the alleged custom should be forthcoming.”
16. In Sheokuarbai v. Jeoraj, AIR 1921 PC 77, the Privy
Council observed that, among the Sitambari Jains the widow
of a sonless Jain can legally adopt to him a son without any
express or implied authority from her deceased husband to
make an adoption, and the adopted son may at the time of his
adoption be a grown- up and married man. The only
ceremony to the validity of such an adoption is the giving and
taking of the adopted son.
17. It is very much evident that the appellant in this case has
failed to produce any evidence to prove that such practice has
attained the status of general custom prevalent among the
community concerned. Custom, on which the appellant is
relying, is a matter of proof and cannot be based on a priori
reasoning or logical and analogical deductions, as sought to
be canvassed by the appellant herein. Hence the issue is
answered against the appellant.”
J. In the judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case
reported in (2013) 4 SCC 97 [Laxmibai (dead) through LRs. and
Another Vs. Bhagwanthbuva (dead) through LRs and others], it
has been held in paragraph 68 that in order to declare a custom
applicable in a particular case, which is at variance with general
law, the onus of its applicability is on the person who alleges a
custom to be a valid custom and in order to prove a custom to be
binding custom enforceable under law, it must be ancient, uniform,
certain, continuous and compulsory.
K. In the judgment passed in F.A. No. 124 of 2018 (Baga Tirkey vs.
Pinki Linda & Others) decided on 08.04.2021, (paragraph 22 to
26), reference has been made to the earlier judgement of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court wherein it has been held that for custom to
2026:JHHC:29793
have the colour of a rule or law, it is necessary for the party
claiming it to plead and thereafter prove that such custom is
ancient, certain and reasonable. Custom being in derogation of the
general rule is required to be construed strictly. The party relying
upon a custom is obliged to establish it by clear and unambiguous
evidence. Vide paragraph 22 to 26 it has been held as under:“22… In such a case, where parties claimed to be governed by
Customary Law, the learned Family Court ought to have
framed an issue to that effect. Once it is found that the parties
are governed by the Customary Law, the parties are required
to plead and prove the customs, by which, they are governed
in matters concerning, marriage and divorce. The judgment of
the Apex Court in the case of Yamanaji H. Jadhav Versus
Nirmala, reported in (2002) 2 SCC 637, para-7 enunciates the
course to be followed by the Family Court in a matter of
divorce involving customary law. It has been held as under:“…. As per the Hindu Law administered by courts in India
divorce was not recognised as a means to put an end to
marriage, which was always considered to be a sacrament,
with only exception where it is recognised by custom.
Public policy, good morals and the interests of society
were considered to require and ensure that, if at all,
severance should be allowed only in the manner and for
the reason or cause specified in law. Thus such a custom
being an exception to the general law of divorce ought to
have been specially pleaded and established by the party
propounding such custom since said custom of divorce is
contrary to the law of the land and which, if not proved,
will be a practice opposed to public policy. Therefore,
there was an obligation on the trial court to have framed
an issue whether there was proper pleadings by the party
contending the existence of a customary divorce in the
community to which the parties belonged and whether such
customary divorce and compliance with the manner or
formalities attendant thereto was in fact established in the
case on hand to the satisfaction of the court….”
23. It was further observed in case of Subramani Versus M.
Chadralekha, reported in (2005) 9 SCC 407 in para-10:“it is well established by long chain of authorities that
prevalence of customary divorce in the community to which
parties belong, contrary to general law of divorce must be
specifically pleaded and established by the person
propounding such custom….”
24. It was thus necessary for the Family Court to call upon the
party, seeking divorce under the customary law to plead and
establish such custom by leading evidence. In any event,
2026:JHHC:29793
learned Family Court would not have dismissed the suit as not
maintainable, since the parties belonged to Tribal Community
and are governed by Customary Law, which is not a codified
substantive law, like the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, Special
Marriage Act, 1954 and Divorce Act, 1869.
25. As observed at the outset, we have consciously refrained
from referring to one or the other custom, said to be operating
in the Oraon Community regarding divorce, since it is for the
party to plead and prove such customs for seeking relief
before the Family Court. The illuminating opinion of the Apex
Court rendered in the case of Salekh Chand Versus Satya
Gupta & ors., reported in (2008) 13 SCC 119, followed in the
recent decision in the case 2021:JHHC:13641-DB of
Rathnamma Versus Sujathamma, reported in (2019) 19 SCC
714, para-16 is quoted hereunder:16. This Court in a judgment reported as Salekh Chand
(Dead) by LRs v. Satya Gupta & Ors.4 while dealing with
the claim of adoption under the Hindu Adoption and
Maintenance Act, 1966, held as under:
“21. In Mookka Kone v. Ammakutti Ammal [AIR 1928 Mad
299] it was held that where custom is set up to prove that it
is at variance with the ordinary law, it has to be proved
that it is not opposed to public policy and that it is ancient,
invariable, continuous, notorious, not expressly forbidden
by the legislature and not opposed to morality or public
policy. It is not disputed that even under the old Hindu
Law, 4 (2008) 13 SCC 119 adoption during the lifetime of
a male issue was specifically prohibited. In addition, I have
observed that such an adoption even if made would be
contrary to the concept of adoption and the purpose
thereof, and unreasonable. Without entering into the arena
of controversy whether there was such a custom, it can be
said that even if there was such a custom, the same was not
a valid custom.”
26. In the case of Dr. Surajmani Stella Kujur Versus Durga
Charan Hansdah, reported in (2001) 3 SCC 13, para-10 also,
it has been held as under:“For custom to have the colour of a rule or law, it is
necessary for the party claiming it to plead and thereafter
prove that such custom is ancient, certain and reasonable.
Custom being in derogation of the general rule is required
to be construed strictly. The party relying upon a custom is
obliged to establish it by clear and unambiguous
evidence.”
2026:JHHC:29793
L. This Court has referred to the judgment in the case of Laxmibai
(Supra) passed in S.A. No. 309 of 2016 and has held that each of
the aforesaid elements i.e., ancient, uniform, certain, continuous
and compulsory have distinct meaning and is required to be proved
by a person who relies upon a particular practice and terms it as a
binding custom in law. Paragraphs 66 to 68 of the aforesaid
judgment passed in S.A. No. 309 of 2016 are quoted as under:
“66. This Court is of the considered view that the exclusion of
applicability of general law, on the ground of applicability of
customary law, is an exception to the general law, and the
exclusion is to be strictly construed. This Court is of the
considered view that unless the party (here plaintiffs) who
relies upon a custom so as to exclude applicability of general
law, proves that the custom so relied upon is not only ancient
but is also uniform, certain, continuous and compulsory
amongst the people of the community in the area/region to
which the custom is sought to be applied, the ancient custom
does not translate into a customary law so as to exclude
applicability of general law.
67. This Court is of the considered view that unless every
element of a binding customary law as pointed out by the
Hon’ble Supreme court in the case of Laxmibai (supra) i.e.
custom asserted by the plaintiffs was being followed with
certainty, uniformity, continuously and compulsorily, the
alleged custom as asserted by the plaintiffs cannot be said to be
a binding customary law governing the parties.
68. In Laxmibai case (supra), it has been held that a custom is
an established practice at variance with the general law which
is a rule in a particular family, a particular class, community
or in a particular district owning to prolonged use and has
obtained the force of law. Custom has the effect of modifying
general personal law, but it does not override statutory law,
unless the custom is expressly saved by it. It has been held that
such a custom must be ancient, uniform, certain, continuous
and compulsory and no custom is valid if it is illegal, immoral,
unreasonable or opposed to public policy. It has also been held
that the party who relies upon custom varying the general law,
must plead and prove it and the custom must be established by
clear and unambiguous evidence. It has also been clearly held
that a custom must be proved to be ancient, certain and
reasonable. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has further held in the
aforesaid judgment that the evidence adduced on behalf of the
2026:JHHC:29793
party concerned must prove the alleged custom and the proof
must not be unsatisfactory and conflicting and that a custom
cannot be extended by analogy or logical process and it cannot
be established by a priori method. Thus, the aforesaid judgment
clearly holds that in order to declare a custom applicable in a
particular case which is at variance with the general law, the
onus of its applicability is on the person who alleges the custom
to be a valid custom and in order to prove a custom to be
binding custom enforceable under law, it must be ancient,
uniform, certain, continuous and compulsory. This Court is of
the considered view that each of the aforesaid elements i.e.,
ancient, uniform, certain, continuous and compulsory have
distinct meaning and is required to be proved by the person
who relies upon a particular practice and terms it as a binding
custom in law.”
In the said 2nd appeal, this Court recorded a finding that the
plaintiffs of the said case had failed to prove that the ancient custom
of debarring daughter from inheriting the property of her father in
the absence of son, was followed uniformly with certainty,
continuously and compulsorily with respect to the area involved in
the case. In the aforesaid 2nd appeal being S.A. No. 309 of 2016,
the matter was relating to inheritance of property by daughters
belonging to Santhal tribe and this Court answered the question
formulated as under:
“Whether alleged custom amongst Santhals debarring females
from their right of inheritance over the land left by the
ancestors satisfies the test of binding custom as has been laid
down in the case of Laxmibai (dead) through LRs. Vs.
Bhagwantbuwa (dead) through LRs. Reported in (2013) 4
SCC 97.”
The aforesaid substantial question of law was answered in favour of
the appellants of the said case and the 2nd appeal was allowed
wherein it was held in paragraph 72 of the aforesaid judgement as
follows: “72. In view of the aforesaid findings in the light of the facts
and circumstances of this case, this court is of the considered
view that the alleged custom amongst Santhals debarring
females from their right of inheritance over the land left by
the ancestors does not satisfies the test of binding custom as
2026:JHHC:29793
has been laid down in the case of Laxmibai (dead) through
LRs. Vs. Bhagwantbuwa (dead) through LRs. Reported in
(2013) 4 SCC 97, inasmuch as, the plaintiffs have failed to
prove that the ancient custom of debarring daughter from
inheriting the property of her father in the absence of son,
was followed uniformly with certainty, continuously and
compulsorily with respect to the area involved in this case.”
The SLP filed against the judgment passed in S.A. No. 309 of 2016
has been dismissed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court vide order dated
08.12.2025 in SLP (Civil) No. 30712 of 2025.
M. In the judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Ram Charan & Ors. Vs. Sukhram & Ors. (Supra), the appellants
were the legal heirs of one Dhaiya, a woman belonging to
Scheduled Tribe and they sought partition of the property belonging
to their maternal grandfather. The suit was dismissed. The 1 st
appellate court concurred with the findings of the trial court. The
2nd appeal was heard on the substantial question of law, as to
whether both the Courts were justified in dismissing the suit of the
plaintiffs by recording a finding which is perverse and contrary to
the record. The High Court in the said case, while answering the
substantial question of law, held that the plaintiffs seeking partition
of property failed to establish their right over such property by way
of custom, showing that a female heir is also entitled thereto. It was
also argued by the plaintiffs of the said case that in absence of
custom, justice, equity and good conscience must prevail. The
substantial question of law was answered against the plaintiffs of
the said case and consequently, the plaintiffs were before the
Hon'ble Supreme Court challenging the judgment of all the three
courts.
With the aforesaid background, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
clarified that the question of the parties having adopted Hindu
customs and way of life was no longer in play, inasmuch as, there
was no such evidence brought on record.
2026:JHHC:29793
The Hon'ble Supreme Court recorded that since the Hindu law had
no application, the next possibility to be considered was that of
application of custom.
In paragraph 13 of the judgment, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
observed that for the application of a custom to be shown, it has to
be proved, but it was not so in the case before the Hon'ble Supreme
Court. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in paragraph 15 of the said
judgment, recorded that neither any particular law of a community
nor custom can be brought into application by either side and then
examined the case in the light of the principle of justice, equity and
good conscience. The Court also recorded that such principle could
be applied only when there is a void or, in other words, in absence
of any law governing the particular aspect.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court also took note of the fact that though
no such custom of female succession could be established by the
plaintiffs of the said case, but it was equally true that a custom to
the contrary also could not be shown in the slightest, much less
proved. Paragraphs 27, 28 and 29 of the aforesaid judgment are
quoted as under:
“27. Similarly, we are of the view that, unless otherwise
prescribed in law, denying the female heir a right in the
property only exacerbates gender division and
discrimination, which the law should ensure to weed out.
28. Granted that no such custom of female succession
could be established by the appellant-plaintiffs, but
nonetheless it is also equally true that a custom to the
contrary also could not be shown in the slightest, much
less proved. That being the case, denying Dhaiya her
share in her father's property, when the custom is silent,
would violate her right to equality vis-à-vis her brothers
or those of her legal heirs vis-à-vis their cousin.
29. In view of the above discussion, we are of the firm
view that in keeping with the principles of justice, equity
and good conscience, read along with the overarching
effect of Article 14 of the Constitution, the appellantplaintiffs, being Dhaiya's legal heirs, are entitled to their
equal share in the property. The judgments of the Courts
2026:JHHC:29793
below are accordingly set aside to that extent. The civil
appeal is allowed accordingly.”
The aforesaid judgment in the case of Ram Charan & Ors. Vs.
Sukhram & Ors. (Supra) clearly reveals that in a case where party
insists that females are excluded from succession under customary
law, they have to not only plead, but also prove the same. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court, in paragraph 15 of the said judgment,
recorded that neither any particular law of a community nor custom
could be brought into application by either side and then examined
the case in the light of the principle of justice, equity and good
conscience. The Court also recorded that such principle could be
applied only when there is a void or, in other words, in absence of
any law governing the particular aspect.
N. In the judgment reported in 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1302 (Bejla
Oraon Vs. Kali Das Oraon and others) (paragraph 6), it has been
held as under:
“6. We must at this stage look to how a custom is to be proved
before a court. A perusal of previous decisions of this court
reveals the following aspects:
6.1 He who alleges the custom must prove it. He must also
prove that he is in fact governed by said custom;
6.2 In order for a custom to be binding, long usage thereof has
to be established or in other words its practice and
prevalence has to be shown;
6.3 It is proved by general evidence by the members of the
tribe or family. If such a custom is supported by public
record, then it can be safely acted upon;
6.4 Custom must be certain and reasonable; not immoral or
optional or opposed to public policy;
6.5 Once judicial notice had been taken of a particular
custom, the same need not be proved independently in every
proceeding;
6.6 Another form of a custom acquiring the force of law is that
the same be legally confirmed; or still further a statute may
be passed on the basis of or in regulation of that custom
transforming it into a statutory right;
6.7 A custom once disallowed cannot, once again be revived.
2026:JHHC:29793
6.8 Section 48 of the Evidence Act, 1872 provides that the
opinion of those persons who are likely to know of the
existence of the custom are to be taken into account by the
court.”
O. At this stage it is reiterated that in the judgment of Madhu Kishwar
(supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has clearly taken note of the
fact that the customary law varies from tribe to tribe and from
region to region and each case is required to be examined when full
facts are placed before the Court. Further, while answering the
substantial question of law in second appeal being S.A. No. 309 of
2016, this Court has referred to the judgment in the case of
Laxmibai (Supra) and has held that each of the aforesaid elements
i.e., ancient, uniform, certain, continuous and compulsory have
distinct meaning and is required to be proved by a person who
relies upon a particular practice and terms it as a binding custom in
law. The S.L.P. against the judgement passed in the S.A. No. 309 of
2016 has already been dismissed.
17.
This court finds that it has been rightly pointed out by the learned
counsel for the respondent no.1 that the pleadings filed by both the parties
appear to be independent of each other, inasmuch as, none of them have
filed para-wise comments to show that one or the other pleading of the
party concerned stood admitted by the other party. This is also apparent
from the fact that at the very first page of the respective pleadings, both
the parties have claimed themselves to be “petitioners/claimants” and the
pleadings have not been filed in terms of the plaint/written statement,
rather each side filed their respective petition. It has been rightly
submitted by the learned counsel for the respondent no.1 that under
aforesaid circumstances it cannot be said that it stood admitted on the part
of the respondents that there is a custom which is consistently followed to
exclude the female from inheritance. Otherwise also it is well settled that
the party who alleges existence of a custom which is at variance with the
general law, has to specifically plead and prove such custom and it has to
be proved that such custom is ancient, uniform, certain, continuous and
2026:JHHC:29793
compulsory and is also not opposed to public policy. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court has held that custom, at variance with general law, should
be strictly proved and the burden of proving such custom is heavy on the
person who relies upon such custom. It has also been held that generally
there is a presumption that the law prevails and whosoever claims custom
against such law, has to discharge the onus of proving it with all requisites
to the satisfaction of the court in the most clear and unambiguous manner.
There may be many types of customs – general custom, local custom,
tribal custom, etc. and the burden of proof for establishing a type of
custom depends on the type and the extent of usage. It must be shown that
the alleged custom has the characteristics of genuine custom i.e., it is
accepted wilfully and having force of law and is not a mere practice more
or less common. The acts required for establishment of customary law
ought to be plural, uniform and constant.
18.
During the course of hearing, it transpired that the genealogy, as
projected in the impugned judgment at paragraph 8, is not in dispute. The
genealogy is embossed as under:
2026:JHHC:29793
19.
It is not in dispute during the course of hearing that the common
ancestor, Soma Munda, had three sonsa) Bhadwa Munda [son of Late Soma Munda] died issueless.
b) Induwa Munda was left with only one descendant, that is, granddaughter namely, Daho Devi [ opposite party no. 1 before the
learned court] ;
c) Sauna Munda had two sons, Bandhan Munda and Langda Munda.
Langda Munda had only one daughter, Sukro Devi and
Mohan Munda was the son of Sukro Devi [opposite
party no. 2 before the learned court]
Bandhan Munda’s descendants and family members
including widow and daughter were objecting to award
of any portion of compensation to daughter/daughter’s
son stating that females are excluded from
succession/inheritance as per tribal customary law
governing the parties.
20.
It is important to note that Mohan Munda expired during the
pendency of the case before the learned court and his name was deleted
and thus only Daho Devi is left as the sole contesting respondent in this
case.
The case of claimants /appellants before the learned court
21.
The claimants /appellants filed their response to the reference by
terming themselves as petitioners and gave details of the property
involved in the land acquisition, details of the various awards prepared by
the authority and details of the genealogy with respect to which there are
no disputes. After having given the aforesaid facts about description of the
acquired lands and preparation of awards, the claimants /appellants
described the entire genealogy as mentioned above which during the
course of arguments is not in dispute. Thereafter, the claimants /appellants
stated the ground of their objection to the award of portion of
compensation to the female/descendant of female in the family as under: a) That the claimants and opposite parties are by caste Munda being
members of Scheduled Tribe and are governed by their customary
law in the matter of succession and inheritance.
b) That according to the customary law prevalent amongst Munda
community, if a male Munda dies leaving behind no male issue, his
2026:JHHC:29793
widow and unmarried daughters are entitled to be maintained out of
the usufructs of the immoveable properties left by the last sonless
male munda and upon their death the property of the last male
sonless munda devolve upon his nearest male agnates.
c) That lands involved in this case were recorded in the revisional
survey record of right finally published in the year 1935 in the
name of Sauna Munda, Bhadwa Munda and Induwa Munda sons
of Soma Munda.
d) The recorded raiyat Induwa Munda died leaving behind his only
son Budhuwa Munda who inherited the interest of his deceased
father in the aforementioned land and came into possession.
Budhuwa Munda died leaving behind no male issue and as such
according to the customary law prevalent amongst Munda
community, his interest in the lands devolved upon his nearest male
agnates i.e. upon the surviving legal heirs of Late Sauna Munda
including the claimants /appellants and they are coming in peaceful
possession.
e) That Daho Devi, daughter of Late Budhuwa Munda was married
with Shiv Dayal Munda, since deceased and is residing in her inlaw's house since the time of her marriage and according to the
customary law prevalent amongst Munda community, a married
daughter does not inherit the property left by her deceased sonless
father and as such after the death of Budhuwa Munda, Daho Devi
is not entitled to receive any share of compensation with respect to
the acquired land.
f) That so far as the claim of Mohan Munda is concerned, he is son
of the granddaughter of Sauna Munda. Mohan Munda’s maternal
grandfather was late Langda Munda. It was the case of the
claimants /appellants that Sukro Devi did not inherit the interest in
her deceased father’s property and according to the customary law
prevalent amongst Munda community, after the death of sonless
male munda his property devolves upon his nearest male agnates.
g) That the parties are following Sarna religion and are following their
customary law till today. The claimants /appellants asserted that
2026:JHHC:29793
they are entitled to the entire compensation amount and Daho Devi
and Mohan Munda are not entitled to any share.
22.
Thus, it was the specific case of the claimants /appellants that the
parties are Munda by caste, they follow Sarna Religion and are governed
by customary law in the matter of succession and inheritance; according
to customary law prevalent amongst Munda community, if a male Munda
dies leaving behind no male issue, his widow and unmarried daughter are
entitled to be maintained out of the usufructs of the immovable property
left by the sonless Munda so long as the widow does not marry and so
long as the daughters remain unmarried. It was also their case that in case
the widow remarriages and the daughters are married or if they die
unmarried, the property then devolves upon the nearest male agnates. It
was their specific case that the entire acquired property involved in this
case was recorded in the revisional survey record-of-right in the name of
Sauna Munda, Bhadwa Munda and Induwa Munda, all sons of Soma
Munda;
Bhadwa Munda died issueless and therefore, his interest in land devolved
upon his full brothers Sauna Munda and Induwa Munda;
Sauna Munda died leaving behind his two sons namely, Bandhan Munda
and Langda Munda out of which Langda Munda died leaving behind no
male issue and therefore, his interest devolved upon his full brother
namely, Bandhan Munda; Bandhan Munda died leaving behind his three
sons namely, Chaman Munda, Kaila Munda and Sanicharwa Munda who
inherited the property of their deceased father; Chaman Munda died
leaving behind his only son Gahnu Munda who inherited the property of
his deceased father; Gahnu Munda died during the pendency of the case
leaving behind his widow Budhan Devi (claimant no.1), his son Radha
Munda [claimant no. 1(a)], unmarried daughter Savitri Kumari [claimant
no. 1(b)] and minor son Sunni Munda [claimant no. 1(c)] represented
through his mother who inherited the interest of the deceased Gahnu
Munda and remained in possession; Kaila Munda died leaving behind his
only son Chotan Munda who also died leaving behind his widow Munni
Devi (claimant no. 2); Sanicharwa Munda died leaving behind his two
2026:JHHC:29793
sons namely, Sitaram Munda and Etwa Munda (claimant nos. 3 and 4
respectively) who inherited the interest of their deceased father.
Induwa Munda died leaving behind his only son Budhuwa Munda who
also died leaving behind no male issue (except his daughter Daho Devi,
opposite party no.1).
23.
The claimants /appellants claimed that Daho Devi was not entitled
to any share in the compensation and she was married but became widow
and was residing in her in-laws’ house and as such, Daho Devi is not
entitled to receive any compensation. It was their case that the parties are
following Sarna religion and they are following customary law till today.
It was their case that the claimants have absolute right, title, interest and
possession with respect to Khata Nos. 447, 448 and 519 which are the
acquired lands involved in this case. It was also their case that the parties
are not governed by Hindu Succession Act.
The case of the opposite parties (private respondents) before the learned
court
24.
Mohan Munda and Daho Devi also filed their petition before the
learned court and genealogy was not in dispute. It was their specific case
that the Mukhia of the village had mentioned in the genealogical table that
Langda Munda died leaving behind only one daughter namely, Sukro
Devi and Budhuwa Munda died leaving behind only daughter, namely
Daho Devi as legal heirs and they have inherited the property involved in
this case and 103 decimals of land came in the share of Daho Devi out of
207 decimals. It was their case that they were entitled to inherit the
property. Reference was made to certain judgments passed by other High
Courts namely, Bombay High Court and Himachal Pradesh High Court
and also the judgments passed by this Court. It was their specific case that
they were performing Hindu religion in all kinds of festivals i.e.,
Deepawali, Holi festivals just like Hindu woman of Hindu religion. They
took a specific plea that if the parties to the suit are sufficiently Hinduized,
they are governed by Hindu law in the matter of inheritance and
succession and they asserted that they have been sufficiently Hinduized.
They have also claimed that they are performing Hindu religion and also
2026:JHHC:29793
submitted that Mukhia of the village had given in writing in this regard
which was signed by villagers. They asserted that a tribal woman has got
right and inherits the parental and ancestral property just like Hindu
women. Daho Devi also submitted an affidavit that she was performing
Hindu religion in all kinds of festivals just like Hindu woman. The
affidavit of Daho Devi was filed as Annexure-4 and the letter of the
Mukhia with the signature of the villagers was filed as Annexure- 5 to the
said petition.
25.
So far as opposite party no. 1 namely, Daho Devi is concerned, she
also filed response to the reference by way of a petition terming herself as
the claimant stating that Induwa Munda – one of the recorded tenants died
leaving behind only one son namely, Budhuwa Munda and upon his
death, Daho Devi was the person who inherited his entire share. It was
also asserted that there was one opposite party no. 2 namely, Mohan
Munda, son of Sukro Devi, daughter of late Langda Munda, who had
inherited the land after death of his mother Sukro Devi and she was the
only daughter of late Langda Munda and consequently, Mohan Munda
was also entitled to 1/2 share amongst the heirs of late Bandhan Munda.
The trial court’s judgement /findings.
26.
On the basis of the case of the respective parties, the learned court
was of the view that the point for determination was, “as to whether the
tribal woman/daughter or their legal heirs (the petitioners/claimants as
well
as
opposite
parties
herein)
are
entitled
for
equal
inheritance/succession right in the ancestral property of their
father/maternal grandfather or not?”
27.
Both the parties led oral evidences. Six witnesses were produced
from the side of the Claimants/appellants. Petitioner no. 2 Munni Devi
was examined as C.W. 5, Petitioner no. 3 Sita Ram Munda was examined
as C.W. 4 and petitioner no. 4 Etwa Munda was examined as C.W. 3. The
khatiyans of khata nos. 447, 448 and 519 were exhibited as exhibits – 1,
1/1 and ½ respectively and exhibit 2 to 2/3 were the rent receipts.
2026:JHHC:29793
28.
So far as Daho Devi-opposite party no.1 is concerned, she
examined altogether six witnesses, but no documentary evidences were
produced. She herself was examined as O.P.W- 2.
29.
The learned court recorded that the only legal question was,
whether the opposite party no.-1 Daho Devi who is grand-daughter of
one awardee Late Induwa Munda and opposite party Mohan Munda
(now dead) who was the son of Sukro Devi (grand-daughter of another
awardee Late Sauna Munda) are entitled for their right of
inheritance/succession in the ancestral property of the grandfather of
their mother (maternal grandfather)?
30.
The learned trial court, in paragraph 10, referred to certain
judgments and straightaway came to the finding in paragraph 11 which is
quoted as under:
“11. So, on considering as a whole of the above discussion and as
per settled law in spite of absence of proof of any custom in the
tribal, the tribal woman or her legal heirs has equal right of
inheritance in her ancestral property (Maternal grandfather) and
in the present case it is admitted fact by the parties that both are
Tribals and the land acquired in question belongs to their
predecessor in interest (awardee) namely Late Sauna Munda, Late
Bhadwa Munda and Late Induwa Munda (grandfather of O.P. No1 and maternal grandfather of O.P. Mohan Munda, now dead) in
whose name the lands in question are recorded in the record of
rights and all the above awardee are related to common ancestor
Soma Munda, the question as above is answered in the favour of
opposite parties No-1 Daho Devi and Mohan Munda (now dead)
who are the successors in interest of the awardees as above being a
granddaughter and grandson (daughter’s son) respectively and
they are entitled for equal share in the land acquired. Hence, claim
of petitioners/claimants is hereby rejected.”
31.
The learned trial court has referred to the following judgments:
(i) 2001(1) BLJR 30 (Labishwar Manjhi Vs. Pran
Manjhi and others)
(ii) AIR 2004 Jhar 121 (Lakshmi Narayan Tudu @
Lakshmi Vs. Smt. Basi Majhian & others)
(iii) 2004 (3) JCR 561 Jhr. (Ram Nath Munda & Anr.
Vs. Khaintu Munda and Anr.)
2026:JHHC:29793
(iv) AIR 1956 Pat. 123 (Budhu Majhi & Anr. Vs.
Dukhan Majhi & others)
(v) Judgment in Second Appeal No. 388 of 2016
(Babulal & Anr. Vs. Sau Resmabai Narayanrao Kaurati &
Anr.)
(vi) Judgment in RSA No. 8 of 2003 (Bahadur Vs.
Bratiya & Others).
32.
However, the aforesaid judgements have not been discussed by
the learned trial court.
The learned trial court has given the gist of testimony /evidence and
summarized as under: “5. In order to support their case, some of the petitioners/claimants
have examined themselves and further produced certain documentary
evidence for consideration of the Court. In order to ensure clarity in
presentation, the gist of the testimony, both oral and documentary may
conveniently be summarized as under: CW-1
CW-2
CW-3
CW-4
CW-5
CW-6
Aghnu Munda
Ramkishun
Munda
Etwa Munda
Sita Ram Munda
Munni Devi
Radha Munda
The gist of the all oral evidences of
petitioners/claimants’ witnesses that
they have only supported the claim of
petitioners/claimants and denied the
claim of opposite parties and stated
that both the parties belongs to Munda
Community and are Schedule Tribe and
they are guided by Sarna Religion and
as per custom of Munda Community
they follow the rituals of the said
community and as per the custom the
widow woman and daughters have no
right of inheritance except for their
maintenance
till
lifetime/remarry/marry, as the case
may be, and stated it is not true that
they follow rituals of Hindu Religion.
Exhibit- 1
C.C. of Khatiyan of Khata No- 447
Exhibit- 1/1
C.C. of Khatiyan of Khata No- 448
Exhibit- 1/2
C.C. of Khatiyan of Khata No- 519
Exhibit- 2 to
2/3
Rent Receipts
2026:JHHC:29793
6. On the other hand, opposite parties have also examined altogether
06 witnesses but have not produced any documentary evidence. The
oral witnesses are mentioned below:OPW-1
OPW-2
OPW-3
OPW-4
OPW-5
OPW-6
33.
Manoj Munda
Daho Devi
Mohan Munda
Babu Lal Munda
Mahabir Munda
Nakul Munda
The gist of the all oral evidences of
opposite parties witnesses that they
have only supported the claim of
opposite parties and denied the claim of
petitioners/claimants and admitted that
both the parties belongs to Munda
Community and are Schedule Tribe and
also related to common ancestors as
per genealogy and stated that they
follow all rituals of Hindu Religion in
their festivals like Deepawali, Durga
Pooja, Ram Navmi, Saraswati Mata
and Laxmi Pooja, Shiv and Kali Pooja
and in their marriage, adoption,
funerals, nomination etc and they
completely become Hinduised and thus
the Hindu Succession Act is applicable
in the matter of succession and
inheritance and in support of that
contention they have filed one notarized
affidavit showing the genealogy
between the parties along with
certificate given by Mukhiya of village
Sukurhuttu signed by the villagers of
the same village.
The learned trial court further discussed the evidence in paragraph 9
of the impugned judgement as under: “9. In support of their claim both the parties have adduced oral as well
as documentary evidence which are described earlier in para- 5 & 6.
So, only the legal question is that whether the opposite party No-1
Daho Devi who is grand daughter of one awardee Late Induwa Munda
and opposite party Mohan Munda (now dead) who was the son of Sukro
Devi (grand daughter of another awardee Late Sauna Munda) are
entitled for their right of inheritance/ succession in the ancestral
property of the grandfather of their mother (maternal grandfather) and
in this regard the opposite parties are claiming their rights by oral
evidence that they follow the rituals of Hindu religion in their festivals
like Durga Pooja, Deepawali, marriage, adoption, death, nomination
etc which is denied by the petitioners/claimants on the basis of their
2026:JHHC:29793
oral evidence that in absence of any custom of Munda Community, the
woman/daughter or their legal heirs have no right of
inheritance/succession in the ancestral property.”
34.
The learned trial court thereafter referred to the judgment passed by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 9537 of 2025 (Ram
Charan & Ors. Vs. Sukhram & Ors.) reported in 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 717
and applied the principle of justice, equity and good conscience and held
that in the present case also same question arises for consideration.
35.
In the judgement passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court it has been
held that where no such custom as claimed by the plaintiffs with respect to
female succession could be established by the plaintiffs and a custom to
the contrary also could not be shown in the slightest, much less proved,
the principles of justice, equity and good conscience, read along with the
overarching effect of Article 14 of the Constitution could be applied and
the plaintiffs of the said case were found entitled to their equal share in the
father’s property. The learned trial court, while dismissing the case of the
claimants/appellants, followed the judgement passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court and held in paragraph 11 of the judgement as under:
“11.
So, on considering as a whole of the above
discussion and as per settled law in spite of absence of proof
of any custom in the tribal, the tribal woman or her legal
heirs has equal right of inheritance in her ancestral property
(Maternal grandfather) and in the present case it is admitted
fact by the parties that both are Tribals and the land
acquired in question belongs to their predecessor in interest
(awardee) namely Late Sauna Munda, Late Bhadwa Munda
and Late Induwa Munda (grandfather of O.P. No-1 and
maternal grandfather of O.P. Mohan Munda, now dead) in
whose name the lands in question are recorded in the record
of rights and all the above awardee are related to common
ancestor Soma Munda, the question as above is answered in
the favour of opposite parties No-1 Daho Devi and Mohan
Munda (now dead) who are the successors in interest of the
awardees as above being a granddaughter and grandson
(daughter’s son) respectively and they are entitled for equal
share in the land acquired. Hence, claim of
petitioners/claimants is hereby rejected.”
2026:JHHC:29793
The point for determination
The point for determination in this appeal would be the same legal
question as has been considered by the learned trial court and it is framed
as under: Whether the respondent no.1 [Daho Devi] who is
grand-daughter of one awardee Late Induwa Munda
and Mohan Munda (now dead) who was the son of
Sukro Devi (grand-daughter of another awardee Late
Sauna Munda) are entitled for their right of
inheritance/succession in the ancestral property of
the common ancestor?
36.
Upon scrutiny of the evidence of all the witnesses from the side of
the appellants i.e., CW-1 to CW-6, it appears that they have deposed on
similar lines and fully supported their case that the parties belong to
Munda community which is a Scheduled Tribe. They have consistently
stated that parties are following Sarna religion and have stated that they
are not following Hindu religion. They have stated that they perform
religious ceremonies, marriage, tonsure (mundane), last rites, baby
naming ceremony etc. as per Sarna Customs applicable to Munda
community. They have also deposed that as per their custom, the widow
women and daughters have no right of inheritance except for their
maintenance till lifetime/re-marriage/marriage. They have denied the
suggestion that they follow Hindu religion.
37.
This Court finds that although the learned trial court has not
separately discussed the evidence of each of the witnesses i.e., CW-1 to
CW-6, but the gist of the oral evidences appears to have been rightly
recorded. The recording of the learned trial court in paragraph 5 of the
impugned judgment is already quoted above.
38.
Altogether 6 witnesses were examined on behalf of the opposite
parties (respondent herein) including Daho Devi (respondent no. 1), who
herself was examined as OPW-2. Mohan Munda who had joined with
Daho Devi was examined as O.P.W. - 3, but he has died during the
pendency of the case before the learned court and his name has been
2026:JHHC:29793
deleted from the cause title by the learned trial court. The learned trial
court recorded the gist of oral evidence on behalf of the opposite party.
39.
However, after recording the gist of evidence of both the sides, the
learned trial court has not recorded any finding as to whether the parties
are governed by their customary law in the matter of succession and
inheritance and whether the alleged custom of exclusion of daughters and
widows from inheritance and succession, which is sought to be relied
upon by the present appellants, has been proved as required by law, so as
to bind the parties. The learned court has also not recorded any finding as
to whether the initial onus to prove the custom as asserted has been
discharged by the appellants. The learned court has also not recorded any
findings as to whether the parties are sufficiently hinduised so as to be
governed by Hindu Succession Act as claimed by the opposite parties.
40.
The various witnesses of private opposite parties i.e., OPW-1 to
OPW-6 have admitted that the parties belong to Munda community and
relate to common ancestor as per genealogy. They have stated that the
parties follow Hindu religion and celebrate festivals like Deepawali,
Durga Puja, Ramnavami, Saraswati Mata Puja, Laxmi Puja, Shiv and Kali
Puja. The witnesses have deposed that widow in their society do not wear
vermillion and in case of alive husband only, the women wear vermillion.
They have also stated that the family members of the parties are keeping
Hindu names such as Shiv Dayal Munda, Mohan Munda, Sita Ram
Munda etc. They claimed that they are completely Hinduised and also
claimed that they are governed by Hindu Succession Act. However,
during the cross-examination, it has come that the last rites are performed
by burying the dead in Masna belonging to Munda Community and that
they are following Sarna Religion. The statement of Daho Devi with
respect to last rites are self-contradictory during cross -examination.
41.
There is no doubt that many of the family members and close
relatives of the appellants have Hindu names for example - Radha Munda,
Savitri Kumari, Sita Ram Munda, Ram Kishun Munda, Sita Kumari and
Mohan Munda. However, at the same time the last rites are certainly not
done as per Hindu Religion and during cross examination Daho Devi has
2026:JHHC:29793
admitted that the parties follow Sarna Religion. Considering the totality of
the evidences placed on record, this Court is of the considered view that
the witnesses from both the sides have supported their respective cases.
However, the opposite parties have not been able to prove that the parties
are sufficiently hinduised so as to be governed by Hindu Succession Act.
42.
So far as the claimants /appellants are concerned, except the
statement from the side of the witnesses of the present appellants that the
widow and daughters in the family have no right of inheritance, no
example denying inheritance to widow and daughter has been cited either
by way of documentary evidence or oral evidence. The law is well settled
as discussed above by referring to the various judicial pronouncements
that in order to rely upon custom, which is contrary to the general law,
such custom must be proved to be ancient, uniform, certain, continuous
and compulsory and one who relied upon custom, must plead and prove
it. Custom must be established by clear and unambiguous evidence. It has
also been settled that the custom being in derogation of a general rule is
required to be construed strictly and a party relying upon a custom is
obliged to establish it by a clear and unambiguous evidence.
43.
This court is of the considered view that the appellants have not
been able to prove the alleged custom of complete exclusion of daughters
and widows from inheritance and succession and that they are only
entitled to maintenance as per alleged customary law governing the
parties. The requirement of law to prove the alleged custom as claimed by
the claimants /appellants has not been satisfied in the present case.
44.
Thus, this court is of the considered view that neither the appellants
have been able to prove the custom of complete exclusion of daughters
and widows from inheritance and succession and that they are only
entitled to maintenance as required by law nor the opposite party/
respondent has been able to prove that the parties were sufficiently
hinduised so as to be governed by Hindu Succession Act in the matter of
inheritance and succession. There is a complete void as to under what
provision of law the compensation has to be allotted to the parties.
2026:JHHC:29793
However, the fact remains undisputed that both the parties belong to
Munda community belonging to Scheduled Tribe.
45.
It is also important to note that amongst the appellants, the
daughters and the widows falling in the lineage of Late Bandhan Munda,
son of Late Sawna Munda and grandson of Late Soma Munda, have all
joined to claim the compensation of the acquired land. One of the
claimants Munni Devi is a widow in the family and she has also stated
that she is one of the claimants and in her cross-examination also, she has
reiterated that she is claiming the compensation of the acquired land.
46.
Further, C.W. 6, who is one of the appellants (claimants) has stated
in his evidence that all the appellants have right, title and possession over
the acquired land and all of them are entitled to claim compensation of the
acquired land. Thus, when it comes to the appellants (claimant) consisting
of widows and daughters of the family also falling in the lineage of Late
Budhan Munda, S/o Late Sawna Munda grandson of late Soma Munda,
they jointly claim right, title and possession of the acquired land and also
compensation of the acquired land. But when it comes to opposite parties
falling in the lineage of other branch, their case is that as per Munda
community, daughters/widows are not entitled to inherit any property of
their father/husband.
47.
It is also important to note that the claimants/appellants include
widow and daughter in the family under the lineage of Bandhan Munda
son of Sauna Munda and each have been allocated share in the
compensation amount but the claimants /appellants have no grievance
with respect to such allocation of share and when it comes to share of
opposite party, the claimants /appellants have raised an objection that the
daughter in the family has no right to inheritance or succession.
48.
This court is of the considered view that under the aforesaid
circumstances and in view of the discussions of the materials on record,
the judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.
9537 of 2025 (Ram Charan & Ors. Vs. Sukhram & Ors.) reported in
2025 LiveLaw (SC) 717 is fully applicable and the principle of justice,
equity and good conscience is required to be applied. This court is of the
2026:JHHC:29793
considered view that the learned trial court has rightly relied upon the
judgment passed in Civil Appeal No. 9537 of 2025 (Ram Charan & Ors.
Vs. Sukhram & Ors.) reported in 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 717 (supra) to
allocate share of the awarded compensation amount to Daho Devi and
also to Mohan Munda, but failed to consider that Mohan Munda having
died issueless without leaving behind any heir or successor and his name
was deleted from the cause title by the learned court, could not have been
allocated any share as his share would go to the nearest family members
who happen to be the descendants/ family members in the line of Bandhan
Munda son of Sauna Munda , that is, the claimants /appellants in the
present case. Daho Devi, daughter of Budhuwa Munda [son of Induwa
Munda] would be entitled to ½ share of the compensation as out of three
sons of the common ancestor, one son, namely, Bhadwa Munda, died
issueless.
49.
The point for determination is answered by holding that the
respondent no.1 [Daho Devi] who is grand-daughter of one awardee Late
Induwa Munda and Mohan Munda (now dead) who was the son of Sukro
Devi (grand-daughter of another awardee Late Sauna Munda) are entitled
for their right of inheritance/succession in the ancestral property of the
common ancestor. It is further held that Daho Devi has been rightly
allocated half share of the compensation amount. It is also held that
Mohan Munda (now dead) has also been rightly allocated ½ share of ½
share (that is 1/4th share) of the compensation amount as Sauna Munda
had two sons and Mohan Munda was the descendant of one of his sons.
50.
This court has also gone through the allocation of share as
prepared by the learned trial court on the basis of the impugned judgement
vide order dated 03.01.2026 and finds that Daho Devi has been allocated
½ share of the entire compensation amount relating to each award (award
nos. 8, 27, 26, 9 and 4) involved in this case and is of the considered view
that the allocation of share to Daho Devi has been rightly made by the
learned Court. The allocation of ½ share of the entire compensation
amount to Daho Devi does not call for any interference.
2026:JHHC:29793
51.
So far as allocation of share to Mohan Munda (deceased and
deleted) to the extent of 1/4th share vide order dated 03.01.2026 passed
by the learned court while allocating the share of the compensation
amount is concerned, the same can be disbursed to his legal heirs and
successors as may be claimed
as per law. Admittedly, the
claimants/appellants are in the lineage of Bandhan Munda 1 st son of
Sauna Munda and Mohan Munda falls in the lineage of Langda Munda
2nd son of Sauna Munda.
52.
This appeal is accordingly dismissed.
53.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, is closed.
54.
Office to prepare decree.
55.
Let this judgement be communicated to the learned court concerned
through FAX/e-mail.
56.
Let the records received from the learned court concerned be sent
back forthwith.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Date of Pronouncement:05.10.2026
Pankaj/AFR
Date of Uploading:07.10.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review