Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:31688
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
F.A. No. 322 of 2023
Anil Kumar Upadhyay, aged about 61 Years, son of Late Ambika
Upadhyay, Resident of Qtr. No.349, Sector-III/A, P.O. & P.S.Bokaro Steel City, District- Bokaro, Jharkhand
…
…
Defendant No.1/Appellant
-Versus1. Arun Kumar Srivasatava, son of Late Harish Chandra Lal
Srivastava, Resident of Plot No.07, Co-operative Colony, P.O. &
P.S.- Bokaro Steel City, District- Bokaro, Jharkhand - an agent and
authorized representative of Biramdeo Roy Choudhary, son of Late
Sheo Prasad Roy Choudhary, Resident of Plot No.07, Co-operative
Colony, P.O. & P.S.- Bokaro Steel City, District- Bokaro,
Jharkhand
…
…
Plaintiff/Respondent
2. The Deputy Commissioner, Bokaro, P.O. & P.S. -Bokaro, DistrictBokaro
3. The S.D.O., Chas, P.O. & P.S.- Chas, District- Bokaro
4. The Officer-in-charge, Sector-XII P.S., P.O. & P.S.- Sector-XII,
District- Bokaro … …
Defendants/Proforma Respondents
--CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Appellant
: Mr. Pawan Kumar Choudhary, Advocate
For the plaintiff
: Mr. Harsh Vardhan, Advocate
For the State
: Mr. Shashank Kumar, Advocate
--C.A.V. on 15.06.2026
Pronounced on 26.10.2026
This appeal has been filed against the judgment and decree dated
12.10.2023 (decree sealed and signed on 18.10.2023) passed by the
learned Sub-Judge-IV, Bokaro in Original Suit No. 96/2016, whereby the
suit seeking specific performance of contract has been decreed. The
appellant was the defendant no.1 in the suit.
2.
The plaint was filed by Arun Kumar Srivasatava, who claimed to be
an agent and authorized representative of Biramdeo Roy Choudhary.
Defendant no. 1, Anil Kumar Upadhyay, was the contesting defendant.
So far as defendant nos. 2 to 4 are concerned, they were Deputy
Commissioner, Bokaro, Sub-Divisional Officer, Chas, Bokaro and the
Officer-in-charge, Sector-XII P.S., Bokaro respectively.
3.
The plaintiff had prayed for the following reliefs: 1
2026:JHHC:31688
(i)
For specific performance of contract directing the
defendant who took back the deed from the office of the district
Sub-Registrar, Bokaro at Chas to refile or to represent the said
deed of transfer of sub-lease hold interest which was signed by
the defendant and plaintiff and counter signed by the Secretary
of Udaymi Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal Complex Samity
Limited before the District Sub-Registrar, Bokaro (Chas) for
registration and execute the same, failing which the plaintiff be
given liberty to get the deed of transfer of sub-lease hold
interest executed and registered in his favour in respect of cooperative plot no. 83 described in schedule below through the
process of court, the cost of which will be borne by the
defendant.
(ii) For confirmation of possession of the property described
in schedule below with direction to the officer in-charge of
Sector-XII PS to open the lock or hand over the key of the lock
of the entrance gate of the concerned building over the said
property to the plaintiff and if it is found that during pendency
of the present suit, Defendant No.1 has come in possession of
the suit premises (described in schedule of the plaint) at the
facit support of Defendant No.2, 3 and 4, the officers of local
administration, restore possession of the suit premises to
plaintiff.
(iii) In alternatively of the relief (i) & (ii), a direction may
kindly be issued to the defendant to pay the current market
value of the concerned building prevailing at the time of
passing the decree on assessment of the same made by the
property valuer appointed by the court.
(iv) For interest on the said amount from the date of decree
till payment.
(v)
For any other relief or reliefs which plaintiff may be
found entitled to.
4.
The suit property as mentioned in Schedule of the plaint is a
plot of land being Plot No.83 of Udaymi Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal
Complex Samity Limited situated at Lohanchal Colony, Bokaro Steel
City, Circle- Chas, P.S.- Sector-XII, District- Bokaro, bounded as
North: Co-operative Plot No.82, South: Co-operative Plot No.84,
East: Road, thereafter Shiv Durga Mandir and West: Vacant.
2026:JHHC:31688
5.
The suit was decreed and relief was granted in the following
terms: “Relief:
Plaintiff successfully proved its case. Since contract
was valid & evasive denial by defendant successfully proved.
Defendant no.1 is hereby given 3 months to perform his
part of contract and get the deed of transfer of sub-lease hold
interest executed and register in favour of plaintiff in respect
of plot no.83 of co-operative society & in case of failure
plaintiff will be at liberty to get the register deed executed
through agency of court as per law.
This court further observes that – The contract was
mutual and hence plaintiff should get the plot no. 186 of cooperative society register in the name of defendant no. 01
within reasonable time or else it will lead to miscarriage of
justice.”
6.
Thus, the learned court has directed the Defendant no.1 to
perform his part of contract and get the deed of transfer of sub-lease
hold interest executed and register in favour of plaintiff in respect of
plot no.83 of co-operative society and also directed that the plaintiff
should get the plot no. 186 of co-operative society registered in the
name of defendant no. 1 within reasonable time or else it will lead to
miscarriage of justice.
7.
Case of the Plaintiff/Respondent No.1 as per the plaint
(a) The plaintiff, Arun Kumar Srivasatava is an authorized
agent of Biramdeo Roy Choudhary, who by issuing letter of
authorization on 04.01.2000 and executing a power of
attorney on 05.12.2016 authorized him to look after day-today work, to make correspondence and represent him as his
authorized representative in relation to his firm M/s.
Choudhary Engineering Syndicate, Plot No.200(P), 201(P),
202(P), 243(P) & 248(P), Bokaro Industrial Area, Balidih,
Bokaro and also for all affairs relating to construction and
other incidental acts with regard to Plot No.83, Udaymi
Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal Complex Samity Limited,
2026:JHHC:31688
Bokaro
Steel City. In
the capacity of authorised
representative, plaintiff has filed the suit related to Plot
No.83, Udaymi Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal Complex
Samity Limited, Bokaro Steel City on behalf of Biramdeo
Roy Choudhary.
(b) Biramdeo Roy Choudhary (plaintiff) and Anil Kumar
Upadhyay (Defendant No.1) were doing business on
partnership in the names of two firms namely, M/s. Anil
Udyog and M/s. Choudhary Engineering Syndicate. The
Bokaro Industrial Area Development Authority allotted and
leased lands to a registered Co-operative Society namely,
Udaymi Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal Complex Samity
Limited (hereinafter referred to as Co-operative Society)
for development of Housing standard size of plots for the
members
for construction
of
residential
house
for
themselves.
(c) The defendant and plaintiff both were allotted Housing plots
by the said Co-operative Society. Co-operative Plot No.83
was allotted to Anil Kumar Upadhyay (Defendant No.1)
vide Allotment Letter dated 04.10.1992 and Co-operative
Plot No.186 was allotted to Biramdeo Roy Choudhary
(Plaintiff) vide Allotment letter dated 25.08.1993. The lease
deed of the plot of the Defendant No.1 was registered by the
Co-operative Society on 04.08.1995, but the registration of
lease deed of the plot of the plaintiff remained under process
and remained awaited.
(d) After registration of the lease deed, it became incumbent
duty of the Defendant No.1 to start and complete
construction of the building on his plot, but he found
himself financially unable to start construction of the
building. It was agreed between the plaintiff and the
defendant no. 1 that they should exchange the plots by
mutual agreement and accordingly, both agreed that Plot
2026:JHHC:31688
No.83 of the Defendant No.1 would be transferred to the
plaintiff and Plot No.186 of the plaintiff would be
transferred to the Defendant No.1 and they executed a
memorandum of agreement on 19.03.1997 and exchanged
their plots and both took possession over their respective
exchanged plots. Accordingly, Plot No.186 came under
possession of the Defendant No.1 and Plot No.83 came
under possession of the plaintiff.
(e) It was further agreed in the memorandum of agreement that
they would request the cooperative society to allow them to
exchange their plots and they would apply jointly.
Accordingly, both submitted a joint application to the Cooperative Society on 20.03.1997 requesting to allow them to
mutually exchange their plots. Thereafter, as per the
direction of the Secretary of the Co-operative Society, both
submitted their affidavits sworn on 02.06.2003 alongwith a
joint application dated 10.06.2003 requesting to allow the
mutual exchange of their plots. The Defendant No.1 in his
affidavit affirmed that on the basis of the agreement dated
19.03.1997, the plaintiff had started construction on Plot
No.83 and had made all expenditures by himself and the
Defendant No.1 has not invested a single pie in the
construction of the building over Plot No.83. When both
submitted another request letter on 25.07.2014, they were
directed to pay the transfer fee of Rs.11,000/- and
accordingly, both paid the transfer fee of Rs.11,000/through separate cheques to the Co-operative Society
alongwith their Letter dated 28.05.2015. Accordingly, both
fulfil all the requirements made by the Co-operative Society
and the Co-operative Society issued letter of permission
vide Letter dated 10.06.2015 for mutual transfer of Plot
Nos.186 to the plaintiff and also issued another letter to the
Defendant No.1 for mutual transfer of Plot No.83. The Co5
2026:JHHC:31688
operative Society also issued Letter No. dated 11.06.2015 to
the District Sub-Registrar, Bokaro (addressed as the
Registrar, Chas, Bokaro) requesting the said authority to
transfer Sub-Lease No.3569 of Plot No.83 in favour of the
plaintiff.
(f) After grant of permission, both parties prepared a deed of
transfer of lease hold interest duly signed by both the parties
and countersigned by the Secretary of the Co-operative
Society and presented the same before the District SubRegistrar, Bokaro, Chas on 03.08.2015 for registration and
they also presented themselves before the Registrar and all
the formalities for execution of deed, photography of finger
print, scanning, etc. were completed. On 04.08.2015, the
Registry Office informed the plaintiff that due to failure of
the departmental server, the registration process of transfer
of sub-lease deed could not completed and they were
directed to visit on any other date. The plaintiff further
stated that while the matter of registration of deed of
transfer was pending, it was decided that the electric
connection in the house standing in the name of the
Defendant No.1 would be changed in the name of the
plaintiff and accordingly, the plaintiff submitted application
on 11.08.2015 alongwith two affidavits executed by the
plaintiff and Defendant No.1 to the Assistant Electrical
Engineer,
Electric
Supply
Sub-Division,
Chas.
The
Defendant No.1 in his affidavit admitted and acknowledged
the mutual exchange of Plot No.83 standing in his name
with Plot No.186 standing in the name of the plaintiff and
he also accepted the transfer of ownership of Plot No.83 by
the Co-operative Society in the name of the plaintiff and
handing over of physical possession of Plot No.83 to the
plaintiff and he has no concern with Plot No.83.
Accordingly, the electric connection of the house was
2026:JHHC:31688
changed in the name of the plaintiff by the Jharkhand State
Electricity Board.
(g) The plaintiff further stated that in the meantime, the
Defendant No.1 changed his mind and evaded to get the
transfer deed registered. On 09.08.2016, the Defendant No.1
alongwith some anti-social elements broke open the lock of
the house and tried to take possession of the house. When
the plaintiff reported the matter to the police, the police
intervened and locked the entrance door of the house and
kept the key in its possession and submitted a report to the
S.D.M., Chas. On the report of the police, the S.D.M., Chas
initiated a proceeding under Section 144 of Cr.P.C. vide
Case
No.430/2016.
Subsequently,
the
plaintiff
got
information vide Letter No.1117 dated 17.10.2016 that the
Defendant No.1 has unilaterally withdrawn the deed of
transfer of sub-lease hold interest presented for registration
on 03.08.2015 from the office of the District Sub-Registrar,
Bokaro at Chas by submitting an application for withdrawal
of the deed on 31.08.2015. Thereafter, the S.D.M., Chas
vide order dated 06.10.2016, dropped the proceeding under
Section 144 of Cr.P.C. with observation that the parties
should take shelter of the competent court for specific relief,
as because to give decision in the matter related to right and
title is beyond the jurisdiction of the court.
(h) The plaintiff claimed that he has performed his part of
contract by handing over possession of Co-operative Plot
No.186 to the Defendant No.1 and was ready to attend the
office of the District Sub-Registrar at Chas to execute the
deed of transfer and he has already paid the required stamp
duty of around Rs.11,000/- alongwith the stamp papers
purchased in the name of the Defendant No.1 and he is
ready to bear the ancillary cost. He further claimed that the
Defendant No.1 had willingly handed over his Plot No.83 to
2026:JHHC:31688
the plaintiff in performance of contract and had allowed the
plaintiff to carry out construction of the building and the
plaintiff invested Rs.35,00,000/- or above for construction
of the building and therefore, the Defendant No.1 cannot be
allowed to withdraw from his contractual obligation to
execute the deed of transfer of lease hold interest, which he
unilaterally took back from the office of the District SubRegistrar, Bokaro at Chas.
(i) The plaintiff stated that the cause of action for the suit arose
on 19.03.1997 when the parties entered into agreement; on
03.08.2015 when deed of transfer was presented before the
District Sub-Registrar, Bokaro; on 31.08.2015 when it was
taken back by the Defendant No.1; on 09.08.2016 when the
Defendant No.1 tried to enter in the house on Plot No.83
and on other several dates within the jurisdiction of the
learned court at Bokaro Steel City.
(j) The plaintiff valued the suit at Rs.50,00,000/- for the
purpose of court fees and jurisdiction and paid the advalorem court fees.
(k) During pendency of the suit, amendment of the plaint was
allowed vide order dated 12.02.2019 and vide Para-19A, the
plaintiff further stated that during pendency of the suit under
illegal and extra-jurisdictional order or direction of the
Deputy Commissioner, Bokaro and S.D.O., Chas, the local
police handed over the key of the house to Defendant No.1
and the defendant no.1 had come in possession of the suit
property.
8.
Case of the Defendant No.1 (Appellant) as per the written
statement
(i)
On receiving summons, the Defendant No.1 appeared in the
suit on 24.03.2017 and filed his written statement stating
that the suit is not maintainable, barred by the principle of
estoppel, waiver and acquiescence, barred under Section 34
2026:JHHC:31688
of the Specific Relief Act, the plaintiff is not in possession
of the suit property and the plaintiff has not paid the advalorem court fees over the actual valuation of the suit
property and the structures standing thereon. He further
stated that no cause of action arose to the plaintiff for
instituting the suit and the suit is liable to be dismissed. He
further stated that the valuation of the suit property given in
Para-25 of the plaint is very low and in fact, actual valuation
of the suit property is Rs.1,00,00,000/-.
(ii) While giving para-wise reply to the plaint, the Defendant
No.1 stated that it is upon the plaintiff to prove the facts and
allegations mentioned in Para-1. He stated that the statement
made in Para-2 of the plaint is incorrect and the plaintiff has
no locus standi to file any suit with respect to Plot No.83 of
the Co-operative Society. He admitted the statements made
in Para-3, 4, 5 and 6 of the plaint as a matter of record. He
denied the statements regarding agreement of the year 1997
to exchange the plots and the entire story put by the plaintiff
regarding exchange of plots and alleged that the case of the
plaintiff was based on forged and fabricated documents. It
was alleged that the case of the plaintiff was based on
incorrect, baseless, unfounded and imaginary facts.
(iii) The Defendant No.1 stated that when he came to know
about the forgery committed by the plaintiff after taking his
signatures on several papers as a witness and creating
several
concocted
documents,
the
defendant
no.1
immediately withdrew the documents from the SubRegistrar, Chas. Defendant No.1 stated that he is in
possession over Plot No. 83; the police had locked the house
over Plot No.83 at the instance of the plaintiff and handing
over its possession to the plaintiff. The Defendant No.1
further stated that the suit property over Plot No.83 is his
2026:JHHC:31688
exclusive property and he had never exchanged the suit
property in favour of the plaintiff.
(iv) The Defendant Nos.2 and 3 appeared in the suit on
16.08.2019, but did not file any written statement, whereas
the Defendant No.4 did not appear in the suit and vide order
dated 04.03.2022, the case proceeded ex-parte against
Defendant No.4.
9.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial
court framed the following issues for consideration: (1)
Whether the suit as framed is maintainable?
(2)
Whether the plaintiff has got valid cause of action for the
suit?
(3)
Whether the suit is barred by law of limitation?
(4)
Whether the suit is barred u/s 34 of Specific Relief Act?
(5)
Whether the suit is barred by principles of estoppel,
waiver and acquiescence?
(6)
Whether the suit has been properly valued?
(7)
Whether the plaintiff and the defendant had mutually
entered into an agreement on 19.03.1997 to exchange
their plots?
(8)
Whether there exists any valid contract between the
parties?
(9)
Whether the plaintiff had performed his part of the
contract?
(10) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the reliefs?
Findings of the learned trial court
10.
The learned trial court first took up Issue Nos. (1), (2) and (3)
together and decided these issues in favour of the plaintiff.
11.
The learned trial court took up Issue Nos. (4), (5) and (6)
together and recorded its findings in Paragraph-12, which are as
under:
2026:JHHC:31688
“12. Issue no.4 and 5 are related to each other and are taking
together.
Issue no.4 “Whether the suit is barred u/s 34 of the specific
Relief Act”
Issue no.5 “Whether the suit is barred by principles of
estoppel, waiver and acquiescence”
So far as section 34 of Specific Relief Act is concerned it
is read “as any person entitled to any legal character or to any
right as to any property may institute a suit against any person
denying or interested to deny his title to such character or right
and the court may in its discretion make their in a declaration
that he is so entitled and the plaintiff need not in such suit”
Here in this case as admitted by the defendant he has put
his signature in the agreement dated 19.03.97 which has
subsequently been denied by the defendant and submitted that
signature was obtained on blank paper. Therefore, the plaintiff
is entitled to his legal right as to the property.
So far as principal of estoppel, waiver and acquiescence
are concerned the onus to prove it lies on the defendant but
nothing on record has come to suggest that the suit is barred u/s
34 of SR Act or by principal of estoppel, waiver and
acquiescence. Accordingly, these two issues are decided in
favour of the plaintiff.”
Issue No.6 relating to court fees was decided in favour of the
plaintiff.
12.
The learned trial court took up Issue Nos. (7), (8), (9) and (10)
together and recorded its findings in Paragraph No.13, which are as
under:
“13. Issue No 7, 8, 9 are the core issues and are co-related
and therefore they are taken together for discussion,
examination and finding.
…………………………..
Ld. Counsel on behalf of plaintiff has submitted that
EXT-4 is Memorandum of Agreement dated 19.03.1997. Both
2026:JHHC:31688
parties have admitted that Anil Kumar Upadhyay (defendant
no.1) and Biramdeo Roy Choudhary (Plaintiff) have signed on
each page of it. Both of them clearly admit therein that for
their mutual convenience they have decided or agreed to
exchange their plots i.e. plot no. 83 in the name of Sri
Biramdeo Roy Choudhary and Plot no. 186 in the name of Sri
Anil Kumar Upadhyay, that both of them have accordingly
decided to request the society to exchange their plots for
which they applied jointly an application mentioning that as
per the agreement they have exchanged own plots and have
taken possession accordingly from each other.
Ld. Counsel on behalf of the defendant has submitted
that the Ext.4 is forged and it has been prepared under
complete deception. He has further stated that the stamp
paper valued 50 rupees have been purchased in the name of
defendant but on 19.03.97 and the stamp paper itself is
forged.
Ld. Counsel on behalf of the defendant has further
submitted that the sign of the defendant no.1 has been
obtained on blank page and subsequently it was typed and
which has been misused.
EXT-5 – Joint application dated 20.03.1997 addressed
to Secretary. From this document it transpires that enclosing
a photostat copy of agreement dt. 19.03.1997, both of the
parties sent a letter to the Secretary of the Co-operative
Society to allow mutual exchange of plots. Ld. Counsel on
behalf of the defendant has simply denied it.
EXT-6 and EXT-6/1 are affidavits of both the parties
admitting the Agreement for mutual exchange of plots and
applying for permission for exchange of plots to the secretary.
Ld. Counsel on behalf of the defendant has submitted
that the content of the Ext.6 and 6/1 is completely baseless
and the signature of the Biramdeo Roy Choudhary and
defendant no. 1 has been completely forged since it does not
contain the date when it has been prepared in front of
Damodar Prasad and his testimony has also not been
adduced before the court.
EXT-7 is the letter addressed to the Secretary of the
Co-operative Society by both the parties for permission for
mutual change of plots.
Ld. Counsel on behalf of the defendant has stated that
the signature of defendant no.1 and Biramdeo Roy Choudhary
has been obtained on blank paper and the letter was
prepared. He further stated that the signature of defendant
2026:JHHC:31688
no.1 has been done differently and the clerk has not been
examined.
EXT-8 is the letter addressed to the President of the
said Co-operative Society for the same purpose of allowing
mutual change of plots. EXT - Y, Y/1, Z & Z/1 – Both the
parties as per Direction of the society paid transfer fee of
Rs.11,000/- each. Plaintiff has filed the copy of letters and
banker’s cheque for Rs.11,000/- which for purpose of
identification have been marked as Y, Y/1 and Z, Z/1.
EXT-9, is the letter from the Secretary of the society
informing to the Plaintiff about permission for mutual transfer
of plots no. 186 to plot no. 83 by the co-operative society.
Ld. Counsel on behalf of the defendant has submitted
that on the Ext.9 only contained the signature of the Secretary
Pradeep Kr. Singh and it does not contain the signature of
President and Cashier of the Lohanchal Society.
EXT-12, 12/1 and 12/2 , are the documents received
from District Sub Registrar cum Public Information Officer,
where under it is disclosed that deed of Transfer of sub-lease
hold interest filed for registration by Anil Kumar Upadhyay
and Biramdeo Roy Choudhary was taken back by Anil Kumar
Upadhyay and from Ext-P.W.-2, has also in his deposition
fully supported the case of plaintiff and the testimony of it
remained intact in cross examination and nothing has come
out to demolish his statement made in examination in chief in
the affidavit filed by him.
Ld. Counsel on behalf of the defendant has submitted
that the defendant no.1 has already been stated in his
examination-in chief that he was deceived and taken to the
Registrar Office and there he got to know that the registry
was in connection with his plot and hence, he has taken all the
paper.
EXT-Z/3 – From documents marked for identification
as Z/3, Z/4 and Z/5 support the case of plaintiff that both the
parties had agreed to get the Electric connection of the house
transferred in the name of Biramdeo Roy Choudhary
(Plaintiff), in view of mutual transfer of the house to him.
Before coming to the conclusion on Issue No. 7, 8 and
9 it is important to be re-produced section 91 and 92 of Indian
Evidence Act and the finding of Apex Court on maxim nonestfactum for ready reference.
Section 91- Evidence of terms of contracts, grants and other
dispositions of property reduced to form of document …………………………
2026:JHHC:31688
Section-92. Exclusion of evidence of oral agreement –
………………..
Here in this case, it has been admitted that Biramdeo
Roy Choudhary (Plaintiff) and Anil Kumar Upadhyay
(Defendant No.1) were doing business in the names of two
firms namely, M/s. Anil Udyog and M/s. Choudhary
Engineering Syndicate at Bokaro Industrial Area. Being
Industrialists, both were entitled to get plot in Udaymi Awasia
Sahkari Lohanchal Complex Samity Limited (to be called
hereafter in short as Co-operative Society) and accordingly
they were allotted Housing plots. One Co-operative Plot No.
83 was allotted to Anil Kumar Upadhyay and one Cooperative Plot no. 186 was allotted to Biramdeo Roy
Choudhary. It was agreed between the two business partners
that they should exchange the plots by mutual agreement and
accordingly a memorandum of agreement was made and
executed by both of them on 19.03.1997 and as per agreement
they exchanged their plots and then as per the terms of
agreement they submitted a joint application to the Lohanchal
Co-operative society on 20.03.1997 enclosing therewith a
copy of agreement requesting therein to allow them to
mutually exchange their plots. Then being asked by the
Secretary of the said Co-operative society they also submitted
affidavits which were sworn by them on 02.06.2003. In the
said affidavit they admitted that as agreed under agreement
dated 19.03.1997 Sri Biramdeo Roy Choudhary had started
construction on plot no. 83 meeting entire expenses incurred
therein. Both the affidavits along with another joint
application dated 10.06.2003 requesting for mutual change of
plots submitted to the Secretary Co-operative society.
Subsequently also another request letter was submitted to the
secretary on 25.07. 2014. Thus, as per direction they also
paid transfer fee of Rs.11000/-( Rupees Eleven thousand) each
by two separate Banker’s cheque with letter dated
28.05.2015. The co- operative society approving the mutual
transfer of plots issued letter of permission for mutual transfer
of plot no. 186 to 83 and 83 to 186.The society also issued a
letter to the District Sub-Registrar requesting him to transfer
sub-lease no.3569 of plot no. 83 in favour of Biramdeo Roy
Choudhary. There after a deed of transfer of lease hold
interest of plot no. 83 was prepared in favour of plaintiff by
defendant no. 1 and after signing and getting it countersigned
by the Secretary of Co-operative society parties presented the
same for registration in the office of the District Sub14
2026:JHHC:31688
Registrar, Bokaro at Chas on 03.08.2015 and thereafter all
other formalities including photography, finger print,
scanning etc were completed. The defendant disclosed that he
had taken back the transfer deed from the office of District
Sub-Registrar, Bokaro at Chas, this was confirmed by the
District Sub-Registrar by his letter dated 17.10.2016 sent in
reply to the application for information under the provisions
of RTI Act,2005 to the plaintiff. It was also disclosed to
plaintiff that Anil Kumar Upadhyay- (the defendant no.1) had
submitted the application for withdrawal of the transfer deed
on 31.10.2015 to the Sub-Registrar, Bokaro at Chas.
The case of defendant no.1 is in denial to the case of
plaintiff, According to him it is not correct that he was not
financially sound to start construction of building, he never
agreed to exchange his plot no. 83 with plot no. 186 of
plaintiff, no memorandum of agreement to that effect was
made on 19/3/1997, he denies the statement made in para 8 of
the plaint that according to terms of agreement a joint
application for allowing them to exchange plots was
submitted to the co-operative society. He denies the meeting
with the secretary, execution of the affidavit by him and all
other statements in para 8 to 15 of the plaint but he does not
deny them specifically. There is an evasive and general denial
that statements made in those paras are incorrect, baseless
and imaginary.
In para 21 of W.S. defendant no.1 admits that he
withdrew the documents from Sub-Registrar, Bokaro, Chas,
meaning thereby that he the knowledge that he had presented
the documents for registration. He has made a general
allegation that plaintiff on several papers has taken his
signature, so he admits his signature on all those papers. He
admits that the police has locked the house over plot no. 83.
He does not deny that plaintiff applied to SDM, Chas for
direction to the police to remove the lock. He does not assert
that he opposed the locking of House by the police, he does
not also claim that he applied to SDM, Chas for removal of
lock by police and handing over possession of the house to
him. He on the other hands states that learned SDM, Chas
validly passed the order. The defendant no. 2 to 4 have been
impleaded as parties in this suit by order dated 12.02.2019.
These defendant no.2 & 3 appeared in the suit, but did not file
any written statement. The proceeding against defendant no.4
went Ex party as it not appeared in the suit. These defendants
did not adduce in any oral or documentary evidences in the
2026:JHHC:31688
suit. This court further finds those issues related to agreement
for mutual transfer of plots between the parties thereby
constituting a contract and the performance of the said
contract. While discussing the pleading and evidences as
above this court finds that plaintiff and defendant no.1 in
performing their part of contract did many acts and deeds,
as required to be done under the said contract. They
executed the deed of Memo of Agreement on 19.03.1997 and
as final act they executed a Deed of Transfer of Sub- lease
hold interest which was signed by defendant no.1 as
Transferor & by plaintiff as Transferee and approving it,
signed by the secretary of the co-operative on 03.08.2015 &
then said deed of transfer of sub-lease was taken back
unilaterally by the Defendant no.1 on 31.08.2015 ( vide Ext12 and 12/1) Defendant no.1 has fled the said deed in the
court on 28.02.2023 which is present on record of the suit.
Now under the above back drops when this court examines
the evidences brought on record by defendant then it is
found that they do not throw any light on those issues. They
do not disprove the contract and do not present anything to
show that plaintiff is not ready to perform his part of
contract. So, this court concludes that plaintiff and
defendant no.1 had Mutually entered into an agreement on
19.03.1997 to exchange their plots. The said agreement was
made by the free consent of both the parties, who as per
section 14 of the contract Act 1872 were competent to
contract, the said agreement is for exchange of their plots
allotted to them by the society, with permission of the said
society and so it was for a lawful consideration and with a
lawful object and there is nothing to suggest that the said
agreement is void and so it is a valid contract.
Here it is worth quoting the finding of Hon’ble Apex
Court in doctrine non-est-factum.
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Madhvakrishnan V.
Sami, a reference has been made to the doctrine of non-estfactum also. But this has been explained after a statement of
the general rule of law that a party of full age and
understanding is normally bound by his signature to a
document whether he reads it or understand it or not. Because
equity does not save people from consequences of their own
folly but will save them from being victimized by other people.
The learned Judge who has delivered the judgement in the
court has stated.
2026:JHHC:31688
Therefore, keeping in mind, the provision as laid down
u/s 91 and 92 of Evidence Act it is crystal clear that when the
terms of the contract have been reduced to form a document.
No evidence shall be given in proof of the terms of such
contract except the document itself and no oral evidence for
contradicting the written agreement shall be admitted in
evidence. Here in this case, it is evident that the defendant
no.1 has admitted his signature on memorandum of
agreement dated 19.03.97 but during his testimony he has
stated that the signature was opened on blank paper.
Further the defendant no.1 has evasively denied the
submission on joint application for permission to transfer
exchange the suit property. Further from the submission of
plaintiff it is clear that the plaintiff has been performing his
part of contract.
Further it is also clear that the defendant has also
performed part of his contract by submitting letter before
President of Co-operative Society by submitting letter for
permission for mutual exchange of plot before President of
Co-operative Society (Ext.8). Further after getting permission
from the society transfer fees has also been paid (Ext Y, Y/1, Z
and Z/1).
The defendant raised only defence that he was deceived
while signing memorandum of agreement (Ext.4) but simply
denied his signature on joint application dated 20.03.1997
(addressed to Secretary Co-operative Society) for allowing
mutual exchange of plot (Ext.5). Defendant no.1 has also
denied content of affidavit by both the parties which has been
marked as Ext.6 and 6/1.
So far as evidence adduced on behalf of the defendant
no.1 is concerned it has already been admitted by both the
parties that a proceeding u/s 144 was initiated and
subsequently the court of SDO has directed both the parties to
approach the court and in the meantime the possession of the
building was handed over to the defendant no.1 but it has also
been admitted that previously the building was in possession
of plaintiff and the connection of the electricity have been
taken with the consent of the defendant no.1(Ext.-Z/3).
Therefore, the averment in the plaint and the evidence
clearly indicate readiness and willingness of the plaintiff to
fulfil his part of contract. Here in this case readiness and
willingness of both the parties cannot be established by
applying any straight jacket formula rather it has to be
determined from the entirety of facts and circumstances
2026:JHHC:31688
relevant to the intention and conduct of the party concern.
Here in this case, it cannot be said that the plaintiff at any
stage was not ready and willing to perform his part of
contract. Rather the conduct of defendant also established this
fact that till the time the defendant withdrew his paper from
the Registry Office, Chas, the defendant no.1 was not only
willing rather he has also performed his part of contract.
Therefore, merely the defence of non-est-factum cannot save
the defendant from his legal liability. In the facts and
circumstances mentioned above plaintiff has successfully
proved that
- The plaintiff and the defendant had mutually entered into an
agreement on 19.03.1997 to exchange their plots.
- There exists valid contract between the parties.
- The plaintiff had performed his part of the contract and
willing to perform the remaining part.
Under the above facts and law, plaintiff is entitled to
get the relief of possession over plot no.83 described on
schedule of the plaint. Thus, it may be concluded that in view
of finding of the court that may be made on issue no. 7,8 and 9
in his favour, the plaintiff is entitled to get all the reliefs
claimed in the present suit. And, accordingly these issues are
decided in favour of the plaintiff.”
Issue no. 10: Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the reliefs?
13.
In the light of finding on core issue i.e. issue no. 07, 08
& 09, this court comes to the conclusion that plaintiff is
entitled for relief.”
Accordingly, the learned trial court decided all the issues in
favour of the plaintiff and decreed the suit on contest without cost and
issued directions to the Defendant No.1 observing as under:
“Relief:
Plaintiff successfully proved its case. Since contract
was valid & evasive denial by defendant successfully proved.
Defendant no.1 is hereby given 3 months to perform his
part of contract and get the deed of transfer of sub-lease hold
interest executed and register in favour of plaintiff in respect
of plot no.83 of co-operative society & in case of failure
plaintiff will be at liberty to get the register deed executed
through agency of court as per law.
This court further observes that – The contract was
mutual and hence plaintiff should get the plot no. 186 of cooperative society register in the name of defendant no. 01
2026:JHHC:31688
14.
within reasonable time or else it will lead to miscarriage of
justice.”
Arguments of the appellant-defendant no. 1
A. The learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the
Deputy Commissioner, Bokaro and Sub-Divisional Officer,
Chas, Bokaro had not contested the suit and so far as Officerin-charge, Sector-XII P.S., Bokaro is concerned, the proceeding
was ex-parte against him vide order dated 04.03.2022.
B. The learned counsel submits that as per the case of the plaintiff,
an agreement was entered into between the plaintiff and the
defendant no. 1 with respect to exchange of plots as both of
them were allocated plot in the Co-operative Society, namely,
Udaymi Awasiya Sahakari Lohanchal Complex Samittee
Limited. The plaintiff was allotted plot no. 186 and the
defendant no. 1 was allotted plot no. 83. He further submits that
the land was lease hold property given to Udaymi Awasiya
Sahakari Lohanchal Complex Samittee Limited and the
property allotted was to be transferred to the concerned person
by way of sub-lease.
C. The learned counsel has submitted that the Co-operative
Society was not a party to the proceeding.
D. The learned counsel submits that pursuant to the allotment of
the plot to the defendant no. 1, which is plot no. 83, a registered
deed was duly executed by the Co-operative Society, but so far
as the allotment of plot no. 186 to the plaintiff is concerned, no
such registered deed was executed and therefore the plaintiff
did not acquire any title as per law. He submits that the sublease was required to be compulsorily registered in favor of the
plaintiff.
E. The learned counsel submits that the specific case of the
plaintiff was that the plaintiff was to get the property of the
defendant no. 1 i.e. plot no. 83 and he was to give his plot no.
186 to the defendant no. 1 and for that purpose, an exchange
2026:JHHC:31688
deed of agreement was duly executed. The learned counsel
submits that the deed could not be registered as the defendant
no. 1 ultimately did not participate in the registration of the
deed and took back the deed from the registry office which
gave rise to the cause of action for the plaintiff to file the suit
seeking specific performance of contract. The learned counsel
has further submitted that the suit property was only in relation
to plot no. 83 as per the schedule to the plaint.
F. The learned counsel submits that the learned court decreed the
suit by directing the defendant no. 1 to execute the deed in
favor of the plaintiff and also directed the plaintiff to execute
the deed in favor of the defendant no. 1 with respect to plot no.
186. However, the learned court erred in doing so, inasmuch as,
the learned court did not examine as to whether the plaintiff has
any valid title with respect to the plot no. 186 which could be
transferred in favor of defendant no. 1. The learned counsel
submits that in absence of registration of deed with respect to
plot no. 186 in favor of the plaintiff, the plaintiff had no title to
transfer in favor of defendant no. 1 and consequently, the
decree with respect to direction issued to the plaintiff to transfer
the plot no. 186 to the defendant no. 1 is of no consequence. He
submits that the other part of the decree directing the defendant
no. 1 to transfer the property in favor of the plaintiff with
respect to plot no. 83 is only half portion of the decree and
since the plots cannot be exchanged, therefore, the impugned
judgment cannot be sustained in the eyes of law.
G. The learned counsel has referred to his written submissions
filed before this Court, wherein it has been stated that the
allotment made in favor of the plaintiff was cancelled with
respect to plot no. 186 on 18.12.2024 and it has been allotted to
another person through registered lease deed. However, it is not
in dispute that this fact has not been brought on record in the
First Appeal by way of any additional evidence.
2026:JHHC:31688
H. It is evident from the evidence that co-operative plot no. 186
was allotted to the plaintiff/respondent but it was not duly
registered through registered lease deed in favour of the
plaintiff/respondent and therefore plaintiff/respondent cannot be
said to be the owner of the property and therefore a person
having no title cannot transfer his immoveable property to
another person and therefore the agreement dated 19.03.1997
(exhibit- 4) is illegal and unlawful and void in the eyes of law.
I. The trial court failed to discuss about the registration of plot no.
186 in favour of the plaintiff/respondent and without deciding
about the entitlement of respondent over plot no.186 decreed
the suit for mutual transfer of the property between the parties.
J. As per the plaintiff, plot no. 186 was allotted to him by the cooperative society, but admittedly the same was not registered by
the cooperative society in favour of the plaintiff. It was the case
of the plaintiff that there was an agreement of exchange
between plaintiff and the contesting defendant with respect to
plot no. 186 of the plaintiff and plot no. 83 of the contesting
defendant. The plot no. 83 was duly registered in the name of
the contesting defendant, but there was no registry with respect
to plot no. 186 in the name of the plaintiff and therefore, there
cannot be any exchange between two immovable properties –
one registered in favour of the contesting defendant and other
not registered in favour of the plaintiff. Even the possession
with respect to plot no. 186 was never handed over by the
cooperative society to the plaintiff.
K. The learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that
altogether 10 issues were framed by the learned court and out of
them, issue nos. 7, 8 and 9 are the core issues which will also
form the point for determination in the present case.
15.
Arguments of the Respondent No. 1-plaintiff
2026:JHHC:31688
I.
Learned counsel for the plaintiff has submitted that both the
plaintiff and the defendant no. 1 had approached the Cooperative Society for the purpose of mutual transfer and the
transfer fee was also submitted which was to the extent of Rs.
11,000/- by both the parties with respect to their respective
plots and both of them had applied for permission for mutual
transfer which was granted by the Co-operative Society, which
is apparent from the letter dated 10.06.2015 (Exhibit-9 -marked
with objection) and addressed to the plaintiff which indicates
that the permission for mutual transfer was granted with respect
to both the plots. He submits that since the permission for
transfer was granted with respect to both the plots, the parties
entered into deed for mutual transfer, presented it before the
Sub-Registrar for registry, necessary formalities were also
done, but on account of technical fault, the registration could
not be completed. The specific case of the plaintiff was that the
parties were required to come on another date, but defendant
no. 1 did not come and ultimately, the defendant no.1 took
away the deed presented before the Sub-Registrar without
finalization of the registry and therefore the suit for specific
performance of contract was filed.
II.
During the course of arguments, a letter dated 11.06.2015
marked as Exhibit-Z/2 was placed which is a letter issued to
the Registrar, Chas, Bokaro by the Co-operative Society,
wherein the Registrar, Chas, Bokaro was informed that a
request was made to transfer of plot no. 83 to the plaintiff,
namely, Biramdeo Roy Choudhary and all dues of the society
was received and a request was made to transfer the sub-lease
in favor of Sri Biramdeo Roy Choudhary.
III.
However, during the course of arguments, the learned
counsel for the plaintiff could not point out any such letter
issued by the Co-operative Society to the Registrar, Chas,
Bokaro with respect to plot no. 186.
2026:JHHC:31688
During the course of arguments, it is not in dispute that the
sub-lease in favor of the plaintiff with respect to plot no. 186
was never registered. The plaintiff only had a letter of
allotment, with respect to plot no. 186.
IV.
To this, the learned counsel for the respondent-plaintiff has
referred to the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reported in (2010) 5 SCC 401 (S. Kaladevi vs. V.r.
Somasundaram & others) paragraph 11 and 12 to submit that
the law has been laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that
there is no need to get agreement of sale registered with respect
to specific performance of contract. He submits that in such
circumstances, merely because sub-lease was not registered in
favor of the plaintiff with respect to plot no. 186, the same has
no consequence in this case and the judgment passed by the
learned court asking the parties to execute their respective
deeds in favor of each other with respect to their respective
plots is in terms of the agreement and therefore the same does
not call for any interference.
16.
Rejoinder argument of the appellant-defendant no. 1
Learned counsel for the appellant, in response, has submitted that the
agreement of transfer need not be registered, but a person cannot be
directed to pass title which he does not possess. He submits that the
plaintiff never had any title with respect to plot no. 186 as the lease
deed was never executed by the Co-operative Society in favor of the
plaintiff. Therefore, the plaintiff had no title to transfer the property to
the defendant no. 1 with respect to plot no. 186. In such
circumstances, the direction upon the defendant no. 1 to transfer his
property i.e. plot no. 83 to the plaintiff cannot be sustained in the eyes
of law as there can be no possible exchange between the plaintiff and
the defendant no. 1 with respect to their respective plots, the plaintiff
having no title with respect to plot no. 186.
17.
Points for determination.
2026:JHHC:31688
Considering the disputes involved in the case, following points of
determination arise in the present first appeal:
(i)
Whether the plaintiff and the defendant no. 1 had
mutually entered into an agreement on 19.03.1997 to
exchange their plots?
(ii)
Whether there exists any valid contract between the
parties?
(iii)
Whether the plaintiff had performed/ready to perform his
part of the contract?
(iv)
Whether, in the event of allowing the present first appeal,
the Respondent No.1 (Plaintiff) is entitled for any relief
against the appellant (Defendant No.1) in terms of Relief
No. (iii) and (iv) as prayed for in the plaint?
Findings of this Court
In course of trial, the plaintiff examined 03 witnesses as oral
evidence in support of his case, who are as under: PW-1
Arun Kumar Srivastava
PW-2
Anup Kumar Srivastava
PW-3
Pradeep Kumar Singh
The plaintiff exhibited the following documents as documentary
evidences: Exhibit-1
Exhibit- 1/1
Exhibit-2
Exhibit-2/1
Exhibit-3
Exhibit-4
Exhibit-5
Exhibit-6
Authorisation letter dated
04.01.2000
General Power of attorney
dated 05.12.2016
Allotment
letter
dated
25.06.93 of Plot No.186
Map of Plot No.186
Agreement of Sub-lease
dated 04.08.1995 of Plot
No.83
Memorandum of agreement
dated 19.03.1997
Joint Application dated
20.03.1997
Affidavit of plaintiff dated
With Objection
With Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
With Objection
With Objection
With Objection
2026:JHHC:31688
Exhibit-6/1
Exhibit-7
Exhibit-8
Exhibit-9
Exhibit-10
Exhibit-10/1
Exhibit-11
Exhibit-11/1
02.06.2003
Affidavit of Defendant No.1
dated 02.06.2003
Application for mutual
change of plots dated
10.06.2003
Joint request application
dated 25.07.2014 submitted
for mutual change of plots
Permission letter dated
10.06.2015
C.C. of notice issued in
M.P. Case No.430/2016
C.C. of police report in
M.P. Case No.430/2016
Application
dated
27.09.2016 filed under
R.T.I. Act
Counterfoil of Postal Order
Exhibit-12
Information vide Letter
No.1117 dated 17.10.2016
Exhibit-12/1 Photocopy of application
dated 31.08.2015
Exhibit-12/2 Photocopy of Letter vide
Registration
No.
UASLCSL/ 2014-15/14
Exhibit-13
C.C. of order dated
06.10.2016 passed in M.P.
Case No.430/2016
Exhibit-14 to Three (03) postal receipts
14/2
Exhibit-Z
Xerox copy of application
dated 28.05.2015
Exhibit-Z/1 Xerox copy of Cheque
dated 27.05.2015
Exhibit-Z/2 Xerox copy of application
dated 11.06.2015
Exhibit-Z/3 Xerox copy of application
to
Jharkhand
State
Electricity Board
Exhibit-Z/4 Xerox copy of affidavit
dated
11.08.2015
of
plaintiff
Exhibit-Z/5 Xerox copy of affidavit
dated
11.08.2015
of
Defendant No.1
Exhibit-Z/6 Xerox copy of application
With Objection
With Objection
With Objection
With Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
With Objection
With Objection
Without
Objection
With Objection
With Objection
With Objection
Without
2026:JHHC:31688
submitted to O/c Sector-12
PS
Mark-X for Xerox copy of allotment
identification letter dated 04.10.1992
Mark-Y for Xerox copy of application
identification dated 28.05.2015
Mark-Y/1
Xerox copy of cheque dated
for
27.05.2015
identification
Mark-Y/2
Notice under Section 80 of
for
CPC
identification
Objection
Without
Objection
With Objection
With Objection
Without
Objection
The Defendant No.1 examined 03 witnesses, who are as under:
DW-1
Shailendra Kumar Roy
DW-2
Sanjay Roy
DW-3
Anil Kumar Upadhyay
The Defendant No.1 exhibited the following documents in support of
his case: Exhibit- A
Exhibit-A/1
Exhibit-B
Exhibit-B/1
Exhibit- C
Exhibit- D
Exhibit-E
Exhibit-F
Original Receipt No.1835
dated 02.09.2022
Original Receipt No.362
dated 02.09.2022
Original Electricity Bill
No.147893
dated
22.06.2016
Original Receipt No. NS
28/14251 dated 14.09.2016
of Electricity Department
Original Receipt No.1091
dated 22.06.2016 in the
name of Defendant No.1
related to change of name
Original
Letter
No.
UASLCSLtd/17-18/58
dated 08.11.2017 issued by
Udaymi Awasiya Sahkari
Lohanchal
Complex
Samity Limited
Original reply letter dated
13.08.2016
issued
by
Secretary
Original Receipt No.556
dated 08.08.15 issued by
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
Without
Objection
2026:JHHC:31688
Jharkhand Police
Mark-X for Computer generated Bill
Without
identification dated 30.09.2022
Objection
Mark-X/1
Letter dated 15.01.2017 of Without
for
Defendant No.1 demanding Objection
identification key of the house
18.
PW-1 (Arun Kumar Srivastava), an agent and authorized
representative of Biramdeo Roy Choudhary filed his examination-inchief on affidavit and supported his case as pleaded in the plaint. He
specifically stated thata. The Co-operative Society had allotted Plot No.186 to the
plaintiff vide Allotment letter dated 25.08.1993 and Plot No.83
to the Defendant No.1 vide Allotment Letter dated 04.10.1992.
b. The Co-operative Society registered the allotted Plot No.83 in
the name of the Defendant No.1 on 04.08.1995, but the plot
allotted to the plaintiff could not be registered and had remained
under process.
c. It was agreed between the plaintiff and the defendant no.1 that
both would mutually exchange their allotted plots. Accordingly,
the plaintiff will give his allotted Plot No.186 to the Defendant
No.1 and the Plot No.83 allotted to the Defendant No.1 will be
given to the plaintiff and both parties will get the exchanged
plots transferred in their respective names. In this regard, a
Memorandum of Agreement was executed between both the
parties on 19.03.1997 and as per the terms of the agreement,
both parties exchanged their allotted plots and took possession
of the exchanged plots.
d. Thereafter, both parties submitted a joint application dated
20.03.1997 alongwith a copy of the Memorandum of
Agreement in the office of the Co-operative Society for
obtaining permission to exchange their plots and as per the
direction of the Secretary of the Co-operative Society, both
submitted their affidavits dated 02.06.2003 in the office of the
2026:JHHC:31688
Society alongwith a joint application dated 10.06.2003
requesting him to allow the mutual exchange of their plots. The
Defendant No.1 in his affidavit had clearly stated that as per the
agreement dated 19.03.1997, the plaintiff had commenced
construction of the house on Plot No.83 at his own expenses
and the Defendant No.1 had not invested a single penny in the
construction of the house on Plot No.83.
e. Both parties also submitted a joint request application dated
25.07.2014 to the Secretary of the Society, on which both
parties were directed to deposit the transfer fee of Rs.11,000/for mutual exchange of their plots. Accordingly, both parties
deposited their respective transfer fee of Rs.11,000/- on
29.05.2015 through separate cheques.
f. Thereafter, the Co-operative Society issued Letter No. dated
10.06.2015 regarding mutual exchange of plots and allotting
Plot No.83 to the plaintiff and allotting Plot No.186 to
Defendant No.1.
g. Thereafter, the Co-operative Society vide Letter dated
11.06.2015 requested the District Sub-Registrar, Chas to
transfer Sub-Lease No.3569 related to Plot No.83 in the name
of the plaintiff.
h. After grant of permission, both parties prepared a deed of
transfer of lease duly signed by both the parties and
countersigned by the Secretary of the Co-operative Society and
presented the same before the District Sub-Registrar, Chas on
03.08.2015 for registration and both parties also presented
themselves physically in the office of the District SubRegistrar, Chas, where procedures of taking of photographs,
fingerprints, scanning, etc. of both parties were completed.
i. On 04.08.2015, the Registry Office informed the plaintiff that
due to a technical problem in the departmental server, the
registration process could not be completed and directed both
parties to come on any other date.
2026:JHHC:31688
j. He further stated that during pendency of the registration
process, both parties decided that the electricity connection
standing in the name of the Defendant No.1 for Plot No.83
would be transferred in the name of the plaintiff. Thereafter, the
plaintiff submitted an application dated 11.08.2015 alongwith
two affidavits dated 11.08.2015 of both parties to the Assistant
Electrical Engineer, Electric Supply Sub-Division, Chas. The
Defendant No.1 clearly stated in his affidavit that he has
mutually exchanged his Plot No.83 with Plot No.186 of the
plaintiff and the Co-operative Society has transferred the
ownership of Plot No.83 to the plaintiff and he has also given
physical possession of Plot No.83 to the plaintiff. On the basis
of the aforesaid application, Jharkhand State Electricity Board
transferred the electricity connection of Plot No.83 from the
Defendant No.1 to the plaintiff.
k. In the meantime, the Defendant No.1 changed his mind and
started evading to go to the office of the District Sub Registrar,
Chas for execution of the Deed of Transfer. On 09.08.2016, the
Defendant No.1 alongwith some anti-social elements broke the
lock of the plaintiff at Plot No.83 and forcibly tried to take
possession of the house. On reporting the matter to the police,
the police locked the entrance door of the house and kept the
key with its possession and on the report sent by the police, the
learned S.D.M., Chas initiated Misc. Case No.430/2016 under
Section 144 of Cr.P.C.
l. In course of verification by the police, it transpired that the
Defendant No.1 has withdrawn the Deed of Transfer from the
office of the District Sub-Registrar, Chas. The plaintiff sought
information under the Right to Information Act in this regard
from the District Sub-Registrar, Chas-cum-Public Information
Officer, Chas, Bokaro, who vide Letter No.1117 dated
17.10.2016 provided information to the plaintiff that the
Defendant No.1 has withdrawn the Deed of Transfer presented
2026:JHHC:31688
by both the parties for registration. The Sub-Registrar also
provided a copy of the application dated 31.08.2015 to the
plaintiff in which the Defendant No.1 had stated that now he
does not want to register the Deed of Transfer of Sub-Lease
Hold Interest related to Plot No.83 and the same be returned to
him.
m. Thereafter, the S.D.M., Chas, vide order dated 06.10.2016,
dropped the proceeding under Section 144 of Cr. P.C. with the
observation that the parties should approach the competent
court for specific relief, as the subject matter of the case is
related to right and title of the parties, which is beyond the
jurisdiction of the court.
n. He further stated that during pendency of the suit, the Deputy
Commissioner, Bokaro (Defendant No.2), the Sub-Divisional
Officer, Chas (Defendant No.3) and Sector-12 P.S. (Defendant
No.4) illegally handed over the key and possession of the house
at Plot No.83 to the Defendant No.1.
o. He further stated that as per the terms and conditions of
Memorandum of Agreement dated 19.03.1997 executed
between both the parties, the plaintiff had given possession of
his Plot No.186 to the Defendant No.1 and the plaintiff is ready
to appear in the office of the District Sub-Registrar, Chas for
execution of the deed of transfer and he has already purchased
the stamp duty of Rs.11,000/- approximately alongwith the
stamp papers in the name of the Defendant No.1 and he is also
ready to bear the other expenses.
p. He further stated that the Defendant No.1 had voluntarily
agreed to transfer Plot No.83 to the plaintiff and after
willingness of both parties, the plaintiff has invested
Rs.35,00,000/- towards the construction of the house.
Therefore, now the Defendant No.1 has no basis to resile from
the terms and conditions of the Memorandum of Agreement
and he is bound to execute the Deed of Transfer of Plot No.83,
2026:JHHC:31688
which he had unilaterally withdrawn from the office of the
District Sub-Registrar, Chas, Bokaro. He exhibited the
aforesaid documents mentioned above as exhibit 1 to 13.
During cross-examination on behalf of the Defendant No.1, he
admitted at Para-81 that Exhibit-3 (Agreement of Sub-Lease) is
registered in the name of the Defendant No.1 and the Defendant No.1
has given the original Agreement of Lease to the plaintiff, which is in
the name of Defendant No.1. He has not filed the document of Plot
No.186 related to the plaintiff, as the said document has not been
registered till date. He also admitted at Para-95 that Sub-Lease of Plot
No.186 has not been registered by the Registrar till date. He stated at
Para-99 that after execution of agreement-cum-lease dated 04.08.1995
of plot no. 83 (Exhibit-3), the Defendant No.1 has given the Exhibit-3
to the plaintiff in the year 1997. Exhibit-4 does not bear the date with
the signature of the witnesses and Exhibit-4 has not been verified by
any attesting authority or Registrar / Registration Officer. He stated
that Exhibit-4, which is a memorandum of agreement, was prepared
on 19.03.1997. He also admitted at Para-165 to 167 that the Society
had sub-leased Plot No.83 in the year 1997, but the sub-lease of Plot
No.186 has not been registered till date and Plot No.186 is in
possession of the Society till date. He also admitted at Para-168 & 169
that house is lying constructed over Plot No.83 which was constructed
about 10-12 years ago and the electricity connection is in the name of
the Defendant No.1 at present. He further admitted at Para-171 and
172 that Biramdeo Roy Choudhary has submitted application against
the Defendant No.1 for vacating Plot No.83 before the Hon’ble High
Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi, Deputy Commissioner, Bokaro and
others. The plaintiff has filed Writ Petition No.6636/2017 before the
Hon’ble High Court, Ranchi. He admitted at Para-173 to 175 that he
had submitted an application on 09.08.2016 to the Officer-in-charge,
Sector-12 P.S. against the Defendant No.1 and on the basis of the said
application, the proceeding under Section 144 of CrPC was initiated
by the Sub-Divisional Officer, Chas. On the order of the Sub31
2026:JHHC:31688
Divisional Officer, the police officer had inspected and locked the
house, but both the parties were directed to approach the Civil Court
for specific relief.
19.
PW-2 (Anup Kumar Srivastava) filed his examination-in-chief
on affidavit stating that he knows both parties of the suit and the facts
related to the suit. He has also stated that the Cooperative society,
namely, Udaymi Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal Complex Samity
Limited had allotted Plot No.186 to the plaintiff and Plot No.83 to the
Defendant No.1; the Co-operative Society registered the allotted Plot
No.83 in the name of the Defendant No.1, but the plot allotted to the
plaintiff could not be registered and had remained under process. A
Memorandum of Agreement was executed between them and
subsequently, both exchanged their allotted plots and took possession
of the exchanged plots. Both the parties submitted a joint application
in the office of the Society and paid the transfer fee for permission to
exchange their respective plots and thereafter, the Co-operative
Society issued an order regarding the exchange. Thereafter, The Cooperative Society requested the District Sub-Registrar, Chas to
transfer the Sub-Lease related to Plot No.83 in the name of the
plaintiff. After getting permission from the Society, both parties
prepared a Deed of Transfer for the transfer of Plot No. 83 in the
name of the plaintiff, which was signed by both the parties and
countersigned by the Secretary of the Co-operative Society, and
presented the same before the District Sub-Registrar, Chas for
registration. However, due to technical problem with the departmental
server, the registration process of transfer of sub-lease deed could not
completed and they were asked to come again. He further stated that
after mutual consent, the electricity connection taken in Plot No.83 in
the name of the Defendant No.1 was transferred in the name of the
plaintiff. Thereafter, the Defendant No.1 started evading to go to the
office of the District Sub Registrar, Chas for execution of the Deed of
Transfer. On 09.08.2016, the Defendant No.1 alongwith some antisocial elements broke open the lock of the plaintiff over Plot No.83
2026:JHHC:31688
and tried to take possession of the house. When the matter was
reported at the police station, the police locked the entrance door of
Plot No.83 and kept the key in its possession and submitted a report to
the court of the learned Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Chas. On the
report sent by the police, the learned court initiated Misc. Case
No.430/2016 under Section 144 of Cr.P.C. in which he is also a party.
The plaintiff had filed an application in the court of the learned SubDivisional Magistrate, Chas, requesting to direct the local police to
open the lock and to give possession of Plot No.83 to the plaintiff
because the plaintiff had constructed a house on Plot No.83 at his own
expense and it was in his possession. The learned court passed an
order that the parties should approach the competent court for specific
relief, as the subject matter of the suit is related to the right and title of
the parties, which is outside the jurisdiction of the court. He further
stated that during pendency of the suit, the Defendant No.2 (Deputy
Commissioner, Bokaro), Defendant No.3 (Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Chas) and Defendant No.4 (Sector-12 Police Station) illegally handed
over the key and possession of the house at Plot No.83 to the
Defendant No.1. The Defendant No.1 had voluntarily agreed to
transfer his Plot No.83 to the plaintiff and with the consent and wish
of both parties, the plaintiff had made the investment for construction
of the house. He stated that the claim of the plaintiff is correct.
During cross-examination on behalf of the Defendant No.1, P.W-2
admitted that Plot No.186 was allotted to the plaintiff and Plot No.83
was allotted to the Defendant No.1. He admitted that Plot No.83 has
been registered by the Society, whereas Plot No.186 has not been
registered by the Society and that he had no knowledge as to who has
rights over Plot No.186. During cross-examination on behalf of the
Defendant Nos.2 and 3, he admitted at Para-70 and 71 that he has no
knowledge as to on whose application and order, the police had
locked Plot No.83 and had opened the lock. He also admitted at Para72 that on the application of the plaintiff, Defendant Nos.2 and 3 were
implead parties in the suit.
2026:JHHC:31688
20.
PW-3 (Pradeep Kumar Singh) was the Secretary of Udaymi
Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal Complex Samity Limited during the
relevant period of the case. He filed his examination-in-chief on
affidavit stating that he came to know about the suit from the records
available in the office of the Society. He further stated that Plot
No.186 was allotted to the plaintiff and Plot No.83 was allotted to the
Defendant No.1 by Udaymi Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal Complex
Samity Limited. Plot No.83 allotted to Defendant No.1 was registered
in his name by the Co-operative Society, but the plot allotted to the
plaintiff could not be registered and was pending in the process. Both
parties had submitted a joint application dated 20.03.1997 alongwith a
photocopy of the Memorandum of Agreement dated 19.03.1997 in the
office of the Society for permission to exchange their respective plots.
The joint application dated 20.03.1997 has already been exhibited as
Exhibit-5. Both the parties had also submitted joint applications dated
10.06.2003 and 25.07.2014 to the Society for transfer of the plots
alongwith application dated 20.03.1997, Memorandum of Agreement
dated 19.03.1997 and Affidavit dated 02.06.2003. The joint
application dated 10.06.2003 has already been exhibited as Exhibit-7
and the joint application dated 25.07.2014 has already been exhibited
as Exhibit-8. On 28.05.2015, both parties had submitted separate
applications alongwith banker's cheques of Rs.11,000 each against
transfer fees. Both the applications and the banker's cheques have
already been exhibited as Exhibits- Y, Y/1 Z and Z/1. Thereafter, on
10.06.2015, the Cooperative Society had issued an order related to the
exchange, which bears his signature as Secretary of the Society. The
permission letter dated 10.06.2015 has already been exhibited as
Exhibit-9. Thereafter, the Co-operative Society vide Letter dated
11.06.2015 had requested the District Sub-Registrar, Chas to transfer
Sub-Lease No.3569 related to Plot No.83 in the name of the plaintiff,
which bears his signature. Letter dated 11.06.2015 has already been
exhibited as Exhibit-Z/2. After getting permission from the society,
both parties prepared a Deed of Transfer for transfer of Plot No.83 in
2026:JHHC:31688
the name of the plaintiff and both parties signed and got countersigned
by the Secretary of the Society and presented it in the office of the
District Sub Registrar, Chas for its registration. He stated that the
Defendant No.1 had voluntarily agreed to transfer his Plot No.83 to
the plaintiff and the plaintiff made investment for construction of the
house with consent of both parties. The claim of the plaintiff is
correct.
During cross-examination on behalf of the Defendant No.1, he
admitted at Para-17 that he had worked on the post of Secretary from
2014 to 2019. He also admitted at Para-24 & 26 that Plot No.186 has
not been registered by the Society, whereas Plot No.83 has been
registered by the Society in the name of the Defendant No.1. He also
stated at Para-29 that an unregistered plot can be exchanged with
consent of both parties. He further admitted at Para-30 that he had
given information to the Sub-Registrar, Chas in the year 2015. He had
received letter in the name of Secretary in the year 2015. He admitted
at Para-31 that the receiving on the Letter dated 20.03.1997 is not his
signature and he cannot say as to whose signature is it. He further
admitted at Para-37 that Plot No.83 is allotted in the name of the
Defendant No.1 and he is residing there and the society fee is being
deposited in his name. He also admitted at Para-39 that he had not
gone to the office of the Sub-Registrar. He further admitted at Para-43
that all the plots in Lohanchal Society are in the names of plot holders.
He denied the suggestion at Para-44 that Plot No.186 is not registered
in the name of any person and Plot No.83 is registered in the name of
the Defendant No.1 and therefore, Plot No.186 and Plot No.83 cannot
be exchanged. During cross-examination on behalf of the Defendant
Nos.2 and 3, he admitted at Para-48 that he does not have knowledge
as to in which clause of the Bye-laws of the Society, it is mentioned
that unregistered plots can be exchanged between two persons.
21.
DW-1 (Shailendra Kumar Roy) filed his examination-in-chief
on affidavit stating that he knows and identifies both parties of the
suit. He further stated that Arun Kumar Srivastava and his two
2026:JHHC:31688
brothers have house adjacent to the house of the Defendant No.1 at
Plot No.83, Lohanchal Awasiya Colony, BIADA. About 23 years ago,
he had seen the Defendant No.1 constructing house on the land over
Plot No.83, Lohanchal Colony, BIADA allotted to him as an
industrialist of BIADA Industrial Area, Balidih, Bokaro. The
Defendant No.1 has right and possession over Plot No. 83, Lohanchal
Awasiya Colony and he complies with the rules and conditions of the
Society in letter and spirit and he has not exchanged his plot with any
person. Arun Kumar Srivastava and his family members are harassing
the Defendant No.1 for past few years. Arun Kumar Srivastava and
Defendant No.1 had good relationship between them from the time of
allotment of the plot till the construction of the house and due to the
cordial relationship between them, the house was constructed on the
same plan and structure. The Defendant No.1 always used to live with
the father of Arun Kumar Srivastava and he used to support him fully
in the works and he used to take meal, interact and conduct business
with him day and night. After death of Harishchandra Lal Srivastava,
the father of Arun Kumar Srivastava, Arun Kumar Srivastava started
harassing the Defendant No.1 by making various fake documents and
in connivance with the Secretary, BIADA Housing Colony and police
of Sector-12 P.S. and without any order of Senior Officer threw all the
articles from the house of Plot No.83 and locked and sealed the gate
and gave the key of the gate to the Secretary and submitted an
application to the Sub-Divisional Officer, Chas. When the Defendant
No.1 reported the incident to the Senior Officer, after hearing both the
parties, an order was passed and the key was handed over to the
Defendant No.1. He further stated that the Defendant No.1 has not
exchanged or transferred his plot with any person and since the time
of allotment of the plot, the Defendant No.1 has been living
peacefully by constructing a house. The suit is baseless and false. The
plaintiff has prepared all the documents by deceiving the Defendant
No.1 and as soon as the Defendant No.1 came to know the truth, he
made complaint before the Senior Police Officer. The claim of
2026:JHHC:31688
ownership of the plaintiff over the aforesaid plot is completely false
and baseless and his claim is erroneous and unjust.
During cross-examination, he admitted at Para-15 that he knows the
Defendant No.1 for the last 25 years. He further admitted at Para-23
that he cannot say as to which forged documents were prepared.
During cross-examination on behalf of the Defendant Nos.2 and 3,
he admitted at Para-31 that on the order of the Senior Police Officer,
the lock of the gate of Plot No.83, Lohanchal Awasiya Colony was
opened and its key was handed over to the Defendant No.1. He said
that the claim of the plaintiff over the land and house over Plot No.83,
Lohanchal Awasiya Colony, BIADA is false.
22.
DW-2 (Sanjay Roy) filed his examination-in-chief on affidavit
stating that Plot No.83, Lohanchal Awasiya Colony, BIADA is
allotted land of the Defendant No.1. The house of plaintiff and his
brothers is situated at Plot No.82, 81 and 80 adjacent to the house of
the Defendant No.1. He further stated that the suit is legally not
maintainable and is baseless and false. He has not seen Biramdeo Roy
Choduhary and Arun Kumar Srivastava while constructing house over
the allotted Plot No.83, nor they have right and possession over the
same. He had seen the Defendant No.1 constructing house over plot
No.83 and he had seen the Defendant No.1 while construction of the
house over Plot No.82, 81 and 80 and completion of the work.
Defendant No.1 looked after all the works of the house of the father of
the plaintiff related to Lohanchal Awasiya Colony, BIADA till his
lifetime and continued to do his work as an assistant. He further stated
that the Defendant No.1 has not executed any agreement of transfer of
his plot with Biramdeo Roy Choudhary, the plaintiff. It is true that
Biramdeo Roy Choudhary and Defendant No.1 had a partnership in
industry in the BIADA Industrial Area, which the plaintiff has also
presented in court in his evidence. The house constructed over Plot
No.83 is in title and possession of the Defendant No.1 and is also
recorded in the society register and Plot No.83 is registered in the
name of Defendant No.1. The suit filed by the plaintiff is baseless,
2026:JHHC:31688
false and unjustified. All the documents produced by the plaintiff in
court to grab the house of Defendant No.1 constructed over plot
No.83 are forged.
During cross-examination on behalf of the plaintiff, he admitted at
Para-16 that the Defendant No.1 has one more industry in partnership
named Choudhary Syndicate. He further admitted at Para-19 that Plot
No.83, Lohanchal Colony was allotted to the Defendant No.1 in the
year 1988 and construction works in it started in the year 2000.
During cross-examination on behalf of the Defendant Nos.2 and 3,
he admitted at Para-31 that Plot No.83, Lohanchal Colony was locked
on the application of Arun Kumar Srivastava.
23.
DW-3 (Anil Kumar Upadhyay) filed his examination-in-chief
on affidavit stating that he is the Defendant No.1 in the suit. The suit
is baseless, false and unjustified. The rights and duties of the plaintiff
mentioned in the plaint are completely false and shows conspiracy.
The statement of the plaintiff that document for exchange of plots
between Biramdeo Roy Choudhary and him was prepared is
completely false, rather he and Biramdeo Roy Choudhary had good
relationship with the father of the plaintiff and he had obtained his
signature on blank paper for his personal work and the same was
illegally used by the plaintiff. He further stated that Biramdeo Roy
Choudhary has not given him anything in writing or information that
he has given the right and responsibility to Arun Kumar Srivastava to
look after and manage his property and to look after and run the
factory in partnership. Plot No.83 situated in Lohanchal Awasiya
Colony has been allotted in his name by BIADA, which is registered
in his name and is in his right and possession. He has constructed the
house over Plot No.83 situated in Lohanchal Awasiya Colony and he
is residing in the house and complying with all society rules and
conditions. He is paying the electricity bill and society maintenance
fees. The plaintiff has stated in the plaint and his evidence that
BIADA has allotted Plot No.186, Lohanchal Awasiya Colony in the
name of Biramdeo Roy Choudhary, whereas the Plot No.186 is not
2026:JHHC:31688
registered in the name of Lohanchal Housing Society. Therefore, there
is no basis for exchange or transfer and he has not carried out any
transfer. No plot has been registered in the name of Biramdeo Roy
Choudhary, nor it would be registered in future, since Plot No.186 is a
tribal land inhabited by tribal persons and it is in their rights and
possession. It has only been marked on a map and it has not been
registered in the name of the Lohanchal Colony Society. The plaintiff
has stated that an industry is established in partnership in his name
and Biramdeo Choudhary in Bokaro Industrial Area, BIADA. It is
true that on the basis of the industry, plot has been allotted in Udaymi
Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal Complex Samity Limited and the
Secretary, Udaymi Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal Complex Samity
Limited, B.S. City has issued a certificate. 10 decimals land has been
allotted to him, but it is not mentioned as to how much land has been
allotted to Biramdeo Roy Choudhary. A separate factory, Anil Udyog,
is allotted in his name in which Biramdeo Roy Chodudhary has no
share, rather he has 49% share in Choudhary Engineering Syndicate.
He further stated that the father of the plaintiff deceived him and took
him as a witness to the registration office in Chas, Bokaro, where he
came to know about all the facts related to the plot and thereafter, he
returned home with all the documents. The plaintiff, in connivance
with Officer-in-charge, Sector-12 P.S., evicted him from his house at
Plot No.83, locked the gate and initiated a proceeding under Section
144 of CrPC in the court of the learned Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Chas, but after perusal of the documents and hearing both the parties,
the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Chas, Bokaro passed an order in his
favour. Thereafter, pursuant to the order of the Sub-Divisional
Magistrate, Chas Bokaro, he submitted a complaint before the senior
police officer against the illegal act of the Officer-in-charge, Sector12, B.S. City P.S. and the senior police officer verified at his level and
unlocked the sealed gate and allowed him to enter into the house and
he is residing in the allotted house. He further stated that the suit filed
by the plaintiff is totally baseless and is liable to be dismissed. He also
2026:JHHC:31688
stated that on 08.08.2015, he has informed B.S. City P.S., Bokaro
regarding missing of the original allotment document of Plot No.83,
Lohanchal Awasiya Colony allotted in his name and Receipt No.556
is the receipt for the information. The plaintiff has filed the original
allotment document of his Plot No.83, Lohanchal Awasiya Colony in
court and has exhibited as Exhibit-3. On 08.11.2017, on the order of
the Deputy Commissioner Bokaro, Pradeep Kumar Singh, the
Secretary handed over the key of the lock of the main gate of his Plot
No.83, Lohanchal Awasiya Colony to him and its receiving is
U.A.S.L.C.S.Ltd./17-18/58.
During cross-examination on behalf of the plaintiff, he admitted at
Para-32 that he had business relationship with Biramdeo Roy
Choudhary. He further admitted at Para-37 that he cannot say as to
whether the statements stated in Para-5, 9, 10, 13, 14, 15, 16,18,19, 21
and 23 was stated in the written statement or not. He also admitted at
Para-38 & 40 that he cannot say as to on which date and month his
signatures were taken on blank papers. He further admitted at Para-39
that he has never filed any complaint before the police or
administration with regard to misusing his signatures made on blank
papers by the plaintiff, as he came to know about the same after filing
the suit, but he has also not filed any case even after coming to know
about the same. He further admitted at Para-42 that he has not filed
any document which suggests that Plot No.186 is not registered with
Udaymi Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal Complex Samity Limited and he
has said the same on the basis of the documents produced by the
plaintiff. He further admitted at Para-43 that he has not filed any
document to establish that Plot No.186 is a tribal land, but he came to
know from the Society that the same is a tribal land and the land has
not been registered till date and BIADA has cancelled the same. He
admitted at Para-44 that he does not know as to whether Plot No.186
is registered or not. He admitted at Para-48 that he has returned the
industry to BIADA and he is the owner of Choudhary Engineering
Associate and Biramdeo Roy Choudhary is also a partner. He also
2026:JHHC:31688
admitted at Para-59 that he had not filed any complaint to SDO, Chas,
DIG with regard to the forgery committed with him and he has not
filed any document related to the complaint. He admitted at Para-66
that he had withdrawn the original deed from the Registrar Office. He
denied the suggestion at Para-68 that the plaintiff has made all the
expenses of construction over Plot No.83 and he has not made any
investment. He also denied the suggestion at Para-69 that before
handing over Plot No.83 to him by the administration, the plaintiff
had possession over the plot and the construction works. He denied
the suggestion that he has not claimed over Plot No.83. He was not
cross-examined on behalf of the Defendant Nos.02 and 03.
Point of determination no. 1 and 2
Whether the plaintiff and the defendant had mutually entered
into an agreement on 19.03.1997 to exchange their plots?
AND
Whether there exists any valid contract between the parties?
24.
It was the specific case of the plaintiff that vide exhibit-4, the
plaintiff (plot no. 186) and the defendant no.1(plot no. 83) entered into
memorandum of agreement dated 19.03.1997 for mutual transfer of
plots. Both parties signed on each page of it. Both of them accordingly
decided to request the society to exchange their plots for which they
applied jointly an application mentioning that as per the agreement
they have exchanged own plots and have taken possession
accordingly from each other. It was the case of the plaintiff that
pursuant to the agreement, the plaintiff had handed over the
possession of plot no. 186 to the defendant no.1 and was ready to
transfer the same to the defendant no.1 for which he had purchased
some stamp paper in the name of defendant no.1. It was further case
of the plaintiff that pursuant to the permission granted by the cooperative society, the defendant no.1 also acted and ultimately deed of
transfer was prepared and presented for registry but later on the
defendant no.1 unilaterally took back the document from the registry
2026:JHHC:31688
and refused to register the deed of transfer of plot no. 83 to the
plaintiff and hence the suit was filed for specific performance by the
defendant no.1. On the other hand, the defendant no.1 asserted that
the agreement- Ext.4 is forged and it has been prepared under
complete deception. It was also asserted that the sign of the defendant
no.1 has been obtained on blank page and subsequently it was typed,
which has been misused and under such circumstances, the defendant
no.1 had taken back the document presented for registration from the
registry office.
25.
While assailing the impugned judgement decreeing the suit
directing the defendant no.1 to transfer the plot no. 83 in favour of the
plaintiff and also directing the plaintiff to get the deed in connection
with plot no. 186 transferred in favour of the defendant no.1, it is the
specific case of the defendant no.1 that since the plot no. 186 was
never registered in favour of the plaintiff, the plaintiff was not capable
to transfer the same in favour of the defendant no.1 and was not ready
and willing to perform his part of the agreement of the year 1997 and
therefore no decree could have been passed upon the defendant no.1
to transfer the plot no. 83 in favour of the plaintiff pursuant to the so
called agreement of the year 1997 for mutual transfer of plots. On the
other hand, the plaintiff-respondent no.1 has argued that the
impugned judgement and decree do not call for any interference. The
arguments advanced by the parties have already been recorded above.
26.
The evidence of P.W.-1, Arun Kumar Srivastava, who claims to
be the agent and authorized representative of Biramdeo Roy
Choudhary, reveals that it is not in dispute that the Co-operative
Society had allotted plot no. 186 to the plaintiff vide allotment letter
dated 25.08.1993 and plot no. 83 to the defendant no. 1 vide allotment
letter dated 04.10.1992 and further the Co-operative Society registered
the sub-lease relating to allotted plot no. 83 in the name of defendant
no. 1 on 04.08.1995, but the plot allotted to the plaintiff, that is, plot
no. 186, was not registered in the name of the plaintiff , which
according to P.W.-1 remained under process. The plaintiff and the
2026:JHHC:31688
defendant no. 1 entered into an agreement to exchange their respective
plots and the memorandum of agreement executed between both the
parties is dated 19.03.1997. The required affidavit regarding exchange
of plot was also submitted before the Secretary, Cooperative Society
in the month of June 2003.
It was the deposition of P.W.1 that as per the agreement dated
19.03.1997, the plaintiff had commenced construction of the house
over plot no. 83 at his own expenses and subsequently on 25.07.2014,
a joint request application was made to the Secretary of the Society
and the parties deposited transfer fee of Rs. 11,000/- on 28.05.2015
through separate cheques. This was followed by the letter dated
10.06.2015 issued by the Cooperative Society regarding mutual
exchange of plot allotting plot no. 83 to the plaintiff and allotting plot
no. 186 to the defendant no. 1. Further, the Cooperative Society vide
letter dated 11.06.2015 requested the District Sub-Registrar, Chas to
transfer sub-lease relating to plot no. 83 in the name of the plaintiff.
However, pursuant to the letter dated 11.06.2016 issued by the Cooperative Society to the District Sub-Registrar, Chas in relating to plot
no. 83 permitting its transfer in the name of the plaintiff, a deed was
prepared for such transfer in connection with plot no. 83, but it did not
materialize and ultimately, it was the defendant no. 1 who had taken
away the deed so presented for registration from the office of District
Sub-Registrar, Chas.
P.W.-1 during his cross-examination has stated that he has not filed
any document in connection with plot no. 186 relating to the plaintiff
as the said document has not been registered till date. He also
admitted that plot no. 186 was in possession of the Society till date.
He further admitted that the house is lying constructed over plot no.
83 which was constructed about 10 to 12 years ago and the electricity
connection was continuing in the name of defendant no. 1. He stated
that on the basis of his application, the proceeding under Section 144
of Cr. P.C. was initiated by the Sub-Divisional Officer, Chas and on
the order of the Sub-Divisional Officer, the Police Officer had
2026:JHHC:31688
inspected and locked the house and both the parties were directed to
approach the civil court for specific relief.
It is the admitted position that though sub-lease in connection with
plot no. 186 was allotted in the name of the plaintiff, but the same was
not registered in favour of the plaintiff. Further P.W.-1 during his
cross-examination has stated that plot no. 186 was still in possession
of the Co-operative society.
It stands admitted from the evidence of the P.W-1 that neither the sublease in connection with plot no. 186 was registered nor any such
letter was issued by the Cooperative Society so as to request the
District Sub-Registrar, Chas to transfer the plot no. 186 in favour of
defendant no. 1. P.W.-1 during his cross-examination has clearly
admitted that no document was filed in connection with plot no. 186
which was allotted to the plaintiff as the registration was not done and
also stated that so far as the house constructed over plot no. 83 is
concerned, it was constructed about 10 to 12 years ago and the
electricity connection was continuing in the name of defendant no. 1.
PW-2 (Anup Kumar Srivastava) also supported the case of the
plaintiff and has deposed on similar lines as that of P.W-1, the
plaintiff.
PW-3 (Pradeep Kumar Singh) was the Secretary of Udaymi Awasiya
Sahkari Lohanchal Complex Samity Limited during the relevant
period of the case. He stated that Plot No.186 was allotted to the
plaintiff and Plot No.83 was allotted to the Defendant No.1 by
Udaymi Awasiya Sahkari Lohanchal Complex Samity Limited. Plot
No.83 allotted to Defendant No.1 was registered in his name by the
Co-operative Society, but the plot allotted to the plaintiff could not be
registered and was pending in the process. Both parties had submitted
a joint application dated 20.03.1997 alongwith a photocopy of the
Memorandum of Agreement dated 19.03.1997 in the office of the
Society for permission to exchange their respective plots. The joint
application dated 20.03.1997 has already been exhibited as Exhibit-5.
Both the parties had also submitted joint applications dated
2026:JHHC:31688
10.06.2003 and 25.07.2014 to the Society for transfer of the plots
alongwith application dated 20.03.1997, Memorandum of Agreement
dated 19.03.1997 and Affidavit dated 02.03.2006. The joint
application dated 10.06.2003 has already been exhibited as Exhibit-7
and the joint application dated 25.07.2014 has already been exhibited
as Exhibit-8. On 28.05.2015, both parties had submitted separate
applications alongwith banker's cheques of Rs.11,000 each against
transfer fees. Both the applications and the banker's cheques have
already been exhibited as Exhibits- Y, Y/1 Z and Z/1. Thereafter, on
10.06.2015, the Cooperative Society had issued an order related to the
exchange, which bears his signature as Secretary of the Society. The
permission letter dated 10.06.2015 has already been exhibited as
Exhibit-9. Thereafter, the Co-operative Society vide Letter dated
11.06.2015 had requested the District Sub-Registrar, Chas to transfer
Sub-Lease No.3569 related to Plot No.83 in the name of the plaintiff,
which bears his signature. Letter dated 11.06.2015 has already been
exhibited as Exhibit-Z/2. After getting permission from the society,
both parties prepared a Deed of Transfer for transfer of Plot No.83 in
the name of the plaintiff and both parties signed and got countersigned
by the Secretary of the Society and presented it in the office of the
District Sub Registrar, Chas for its registration. He stated that the
Defendant No.1 had voluntarily agreed to transfer his Plot No.83 to
the plaintiff and the plaintiff made investment for construction of the
house with consent of both parties. The claim of the plaintiff is
correct. During cross-examination on behalf of the Defendant No.1,
he admitted that Plot No.186 has not been registered by the Society,
whereas Plot No.83 has been registered by the Society in the name of
the Defendant No.1. He also stated that an unregistered plot can be
exchanged with consent of both parties. He further admitted that Plot
No.83 is allotted in the name of the Defendant No.1 and he is residing
there and the society fee is being deposited in his name. He admitted
that all the plots in Lohanchal Society are in the names of plot holders.
He denied the suggestion that Plot No.186 is not registered in the
2026:JHHC:31688
name of any person and Plot No.83 is registered in the name of the
Defendant No.1 and therefore, Plot No.186 and Plot No.83 cannot be
exchanged. During cross-examination on behalf of the Defendant
Nos.2 and 3, he admitted that he does not have knowledge as to in
which clause of the Bye-laws of the Society, it is mentioned that
unregistered plots can be exchanged between two persons.
27.
Thus, there is consistent evidence on record that registered sub-
lease of plot no. 83 was duly executed by the cooperative society in
favour of the defendant no.1 and the registry of sub-lease of plot no.
186 by the co-operative society in favour of the plaintiff was still
under process. As per the agreement of exchange of plot dated
19.03.1997 also, the registry of sub-lease of plot no. 186 by the cooperative society in favour of the plaintiff was under process.
28.
The plaintiff has placed on record enough materials to
demonstrate that the agreement dated 19.03.1997 (Exhibit-4) was
entered into between the parties and was also acted upon by way of
various documents and also money deposited before the co-operative
society for exchange of plot and even the plaintiff and the defendant
no.1 executed a deed for registration of transfer of plot no. 83 to the
plaintiff which was not registered as the same was taken back by the
defendant no.1 from the registry office. On the other hand, the
defendant no.1 has failed to prove his case that the documents
including the agreement dated 19.03.1997 (Exhibit-4) and other
documents have been prepared by the plaintiff by taking signatures on
blank pages. The defendant no. 1 has been examined before the
learned court at D.W-3. During cross-examination on behalf of the
plaintiff, he stated that he cannot say as to on which date and month
his signatures were taken on blank papers and that he has never filed
any complaint before the police or administration with regard to
misusing his signatures made on blank papers by the plaintiff and
stated that he came to know about the same after filing the suit, but he
has also not filed any case even after coming to know about the same.
He admitted that he had withdrawn the original deed from the
2026:JHHC:31688
Registrar office. He denied the suggestion at Para-68 that the plaintiff
has made all the expenses of construction over Plot No.83 and he has
not made any investment. He also denied the suggestion at Para-69
that before handing over Plot No.83 to him by the administration, the
plaintiff had possession over the plot and the construction works. He
denied the suggestion that he has no claim over Plot No.83.
29.
In view of the aforesaid discussions of the materials on record,
this court is of the considered view that the plaintiff has proved that
agreement dated 19.03.1997 (Exhibit-4) was duly entered into
between the plaintiff and the defendant no.1 and both the parties have
acted upon pursuant thereto to a great extent and even the cooperative society had issued specific letter to the registrar to register
the plot no. 83 in favour of the plaintiff by the defendant no.1 and
deed was also prepared for registry and presented for registry but the
same was not registered and the defendant no.1 took the deed back
from the registry office.
30.
Even the learned trial court has considered the evidence thread
bare to come to findings in favour of the plaintiff while holding that
the plaintiff and the defendant had mutually entered into an agreement
on 19.03.1997 to exchange their plots and that there exists a valid
contract between the parties. There is no reason to differ with the
aforesaid findings of the learned trial court with respect to issue no. 7
and 8 [corresponding to point of determination no. 1 and 2
respectively]. Accordingly, the point of determination no. 1 and 2 is
decided in favour of the plaintiff-respondent no.1 and against the
appellant-defendant no.1.
Point of determination no.3
Whether the plaintiff had performed/ready to perform his part of the
contract?
31.
As per the agreement dated 19.03.1997 (Exhibit-4), M/s Bokaro
Industrial Area Development Authority had allotted land to the
aforesaid Co-operative Society and the aforesaid Co-operative society
had in turn allotted plot bearing No. 83 measuring 0.10 acres to the
2026:JHHC:31688
defendant no. 1 vide allotment letter dated 04.10.1992 and plot No.
186 measuring 0.10 acres in the name of the plaintiff vide allotment
letter dated 25.06.1993. It has also been clearly mentioned in the
agreement that the said Co-operative society had already registered
the plot no. 83 in favor of defendant no. 1 on 04.08.1995 and the
registration process of plot no. 186 in the name of the plaintiff was
under process. It was specifically stipulated in the agreement that for
the mutual convenience of the plaintiff and the defendant no. 1, they
decided/agreed to exchange their plots. Both the parties decided to
request the said Co-operative society to exchange their plots.
32.
The records further reveal that joint applications were made by
both the parties to the said Co-operative society for mutual exchange
of plot which resulted in issuance of letter dated 10.06.2015 (Exhibit9) marked with objection whereby the Society granted permission for
mutual transfer of plots as requested. The said letter dated 10.06.2015
(Exhibit-9) is addressed to the plaintiff whereby the plaintiff was also
directed to take necessary steps to do the sub-lease of the plots. The
sub-lease of plot no. 186 continued to be under process and had not
materialized in favor of the plaintiff so as to enable the plaintiff to
transfer the same in favor of defendant no. 1. Thus, therefore there
was no readiness on the part of the plaintiff to perform his part of the
contract of transferring plot no. 186 in favor of defendant no. 1.
33.
This is coupled with the fact that the plaintiff asserted in his
plaint that he had already performed his part of the agreement as the
plot no. 186 was already handed over to the defendant no.1 though
admittedly, the plot no. 186 was not registered in favour of the
plaintiff by the co-operative society.
34.
It further transpires from the record that the Co-operative
Society issued a letter to the Registrar (Exhibit-Z/2) dated 11.06.2015
stating that plot no. 83 was of the defendant no. 1 and he had
requested to transfer the same to the plaintiff and all the dues of the
society was already paid and the request was made to the Registrar,
Chas, to transfer the sub-lease with respect to plot no. 83 in favor of
2026:JHHC:31688
the plaintiff. Admittedly, no such corresponding letter has been
referred to by the plaintiff with respect to plot no. 186 requesting the
Registrar, Chas, Bokaro to transfer the plot no. 186 in favor of
defendant no. 1 and apparently this is due to the reason that the sublease was never registered by the Co-operative Society in favor of the
plaintiff with respect to plot no. 186 and therefore there was complete
absence of readiness on the part of the plaintiff to perform his part of
the contract of mutual transfer of plot in connection, as admittedly, the
sub-lease with respect to plot no. 186 was never registered/executed
by the said Co-operative society in favour of the plaintiff. The
plaintiff made a statement in paragraph 21 of the plaint that the
plaintiff had already performed his part of the contract by handing
over possession of co-operative plot no. 186 to the defendant and is
ready to attend the office of District Sub-Registrar at Chas to execute
the deed of transfer and that he has already paid the stamp duty
around Rs. 11,010/- (Rupees Eleven Thousand ten only) required for
the purpose along with the stamp papers purchased in the name of
defendant and he is ready to bear any ancillary cost which the
defendant is well aware. However, in the absence of registry of sublease with respect to plot no. 186 by the cooperative society in favour
of the plaintiff, there was no scope of the plaintiff to be able to
transfer the plot no. 186 to the defendant no.1.
35.
On the face of aforesaid aspect of the matter, there can be no
doubt that there was no readiness on the part of the plaintiff to
perform his part of the agreement of the year 1997 (exhibit-4) so as to
enable him to transfer the sub-lease in favour of the defendant no.1
and certainly it cannot be said that the plaintiff had performed his part
of the contract of the year 1997 by stating that he had handed over the
plot no. 186 to the defendant no.1 and his statement that he was ready
to go to registry office to execute the deed of transfer of plot no. 186
in favour of the defendant no. 1 is of no consequences as the plaintiff
did not acquire title over plot no. 186 in absence of registry in his
name.
2026:JHHC:31688
36.
Considering the fact that the agreement is of the year 1997 and
also the fact that the agreement is not a transfer of title and in view of
the judgements placed by the learned counsel for the respondent –
plaintiff, there is no doubt that the agreement of exchange of plots was
not compulsorily registrable. However, at the same time, in order to
enable the plaintiff to transfer the plot no. 186 to the defendant no. 1
in exchange of plot no. 83, which was to be transferred by the
defendant no. 1 in favour of the plaintiff, it was compulsory for the
plaintiff to acquire title with respect to plot no. 186 and for that
purpose the sub-lease with respect to plot no. 186 was required to be
registered in favour of the plaintiff by the Co-operative society which
was admittedly never done and was still under process since prior to
1997. In the absence of such registry with respect to plot no. 186 in
favour of the plaintiff, the plaintiff was not capable of performing his
part of obligation with respect to the contract of the year 1997
regarding mutual exchange of plot. Therefore, there can be no doubt
that there was no readiness on the part of the plaintiff to perform his
part of the contract of the year 1997 so as to be entitled to a decree
seeking performance of the corresponding obligation of the defendant
no.1.
37.
In view of the admitted position that plot no. 186 was not
registered in the name of the plaintiff, though it was allotted way back
in the year 1995, it cannot be said that the plaintiff was ready to
perform his part of the contract/agreement of the year 1997. This is in
view of the fact that even as per the contract/agreement of the year
1997 the process of registry in favour of the plaintiff with respect to
plot no. 186 was under process and the registry with respect of plot
no. 83 in favour of the defendant no. 1 was done. Unless the sub-lease
in connection with plot no. 186 was registered in the name of the
plaintiff, the same was not capable of being transferred by the plaintiff
to the defendant no. 1 in spite of the agreement of exchange of plots
executed way back in the year 1997.
2026:JHHC:31688
38.
In view of the aforesaid circumstances, the plaintiff was
incapable of performing his part of the contract of transfer of sublease in connection with plot no. 186 in favour of the defendant no. 1
in terms of the agreement of the year 1997 (exhibit-4) so as to seek
relief of corresponding obligation upon the defendant no. 1 to transfer
the sub-lease in connection with plot no. 83 in favour of the plaintiff.
39.
The plaintiff has miserably failed to demonstrate his readiness
to perform his part of the contract, that is, transfer of sub-lease in
connection with plot no. 186 to the defendant no. 1 and under such
circumstances, there was no scope for the learned court to decree the
suit and directing the defendant no. 1 to transfer the sub-lease in
connection with plot no. 83 in favour of the plaintiff.
40.
This court finds that the learned trial court has completely failed
to consider that the agreement of mutual transfer of plot between the
plaintiff and the defendant no.1 was not capable of giving effect to, as
the co-operative society had not transferred the plot no. 186 to the
plaintiff by way of a registered deed although the plot no. 83 was
transferred to the defendant no.1 by registered sub-lease. Even if the
plaintiff was willing to perform his part of contract but was not ready/
capable to transfer the plot no. 186 to the defendant no.1 in absence of
registration of sub-lease in his favour. The findings of the learned
trial court in favour of the plaintiff with respect to issue no. 9 is setaside.
41.
In view of the aforesaid discussions, the plaintiff had neither
performed nor was in a state of readiness to perform his part of the
contract of transfer of plot no. 186 to the defendant no.1 as the
property was not yet transferred in favour of the plaintiff by the
aforesaid cooperative society through a registered sub-lease. The
point of determination no.3 is accordingly answered in favour of the
appellant-defendant no.1 and against the plaintiff-respondent no.1.
42.
As a cumulative effect of the aforesaid findings with respect to
point of determination no. 3, the learned trial court was not justified
in directing the defendant no.1 to execute deed of transfer of sub51
2026:JHHC:31688
lease in favour of plaintiff when the plaintiff had neither performed
nor was in a state of readiness to perform his part of the contract of
transfer of plot no. 186 to the defendant no.1. Further, the learned
court also erred in directing the plaintiff to get the plot no. 186 of
co-operative society register in the name of defendant no. 01 within
reasonable time when admittedly the plaintiff had no title with
respect to plot no. 186 as the sub-lease in connection with plot no.
186 was not registered in the name of the plaintiff by the aforesaid
co-operative society. It is also important to note that the aforesaid
co-operative society is not even a party to the suit.
Point of determination no.4
Whether, in the event of allowing the present first appeal, the
Respondent No.1 (Plaintiff) is entitled for any relief against the
appellant (Defendant No.1) in terms of Relief No. (iii) and (iv) as
prayed for in the plaint?
The relief no. (iii) and (iv) as prayed in the suit were –
43.
In alternatively of the relief (i) & (ii), a direction may kindly be
issued to the defendant to pay the current market value of the
concerned building prevailing at the time of passing the decree on
assessment of the same made by the property valuer appointed by
the court.
And
For interest on the said amount from the date of decree till
payment.
Admittedly, the plaintiff-respondent no.1 has not filed any cross
objection/cross appeal in connection with the alternative relief prayed
for by the plaintiff in the suit. The learned trial court had also not
framed any issue on the alternative relief as prayed for by the plaintiff.
44.
So far as the point of determination no. 4 is concerned, which
is by way of alternative relief as prayed for by the plaintiff, this Court
finds that though the plaintiff has stated that it was the plaintiff who
had constructed the building over plot no. 83 and spent Rs.
35,00,000/- on the building, but the plaintiff miserably failed to prove
this fact, inasmuch as, no documentary evidence in connection with
spending of money with respect to construction of building over plot
2026:JHHC:31688
no. 83 has been produced by the plaintiff; there is no evidence or
details as to when the amount was spent for construction of the house.
Further, even as per the documents produced by the plaintiff, at the
time of payment of transfer fee of Rs. 11,000/- to the Co-operative
Society on 28.05.2015, the lease rent with respect to the property
belonging to the plaintiff was paid by the plaintiff and the lease rent
with respect to the property belonging to the defendant no. 1 was paid
by the defendant no. 1 [exhibit-Y, Y/1, Z, Z/1]. The agreement for
exchange of plot is of the year 1997 [exhibit-4]. P.W-3, the secretary
of the cooperative society has admitted that Plot No.83 is allotted in
the name of the Defendant No.1 and he is residing there and the
society fee is being deposited in his name. Further, P.W.-1 during his
cross-examination has clearly stated that the electricity connection
was still standing in the name of defendant no. 1.
45.
In the aforesaid circumstances, the plaintiff having failed to
make out a case for any relief as prayed for in relief nos. (iii) and (iv)
in the plaint, no relief can be granted to the plaintiff in this regard.
Accordingly, point of determination no. 4 is decided in favor of the
appellant (defendant no. 1) and against the respondent no. 1
(plaintiff).
46.
Summary: a. There is no reason to differ with the findings of the
learned trial court with respect to issue no. 7 and 8
[corresponding to point of determination no. 1 and 2
respectively]. Accordingly, the point of determination
no. 1 and 2 is decided in favour of the plaintiffrespondent no.1 and against the appellant-defendant
no.1.
b. The findings of the learned trial court in favour of the
plaintiff with respect to issue no. 9 is set-aside and point
of determination no.3 is accordingly answered in favour
of the appellant-defendant no.1 and against the
plaintiff-respondent no.1.
2026:JHHC:31688
c. Point of determination no. 4 is decided in favor of the
appellant (defendant no. 1) and against the respondent
no. 1 (plaintiff).
47.
As a cumulative effect of the aforesaid findings, this appeal is
hereby allowed. Consequently, the impugned judgment and decree is
set-aside.
48.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, is dismissed as not
pressed.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Date of Order:26.10.2026
Mukul/Date of Uploading:29.10.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review