Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON
PRONOUNCED ON
: 23.01.2026
: 09.06.2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE A.D. MARIA CLETE
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
and
C.M.P. No. 27902 of 2019
The Special Tahsildar,
Land Acquisition,
Adi Dravidar Welfare,
Vellore.
...Appellant/Respondent
Versus
1.Muniyammal (Died),
W/o.Late Shanmugam,
Krishnapuram Village,
Arcot Taluk.
2.Bhavani W/o.Gunasekaran,
Quarters Street, Tajpura Madura
Krishnavaram Village, Arcot Taluk,
Ranipet District.
(Sole respondent (Muniyammal) died. R2 is brought
on record as L.R.s of the deceased sold respondent
vide court order dated 09.01.2026 made in C.M.P.
Nos.30084, 30085, 30086 of 2025 in A.S.No.1070
of 2019 (ADMCJ))
...Respondents/Claimants
PRAYER in A.S.:
Appeal Suit filed under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act
praying to set aside the decree passed in L.A.O.P.No.157 of 2002 dated
1/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
30.09.2003 on the file of the Additional District and Sessions Court (FTC
No.II) Ranipet and pass such further or other orders as this Court may
deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case and thus render
justice.
PRAYER in C.M.P.:
Civil Miscellaneous Petition filed under Order 41 Rule 5 of the
Civil Procedure Code to stay the execution of the decree passed in
L.A.O.P.No.157 of 2002, Additional District & Sessions Court (FTC.2)
Ranipet on 30.09.2003 pending disposal of the above appeal and thus
render justice.
For Appellant
: Mr.M.Murali, Government Advocate.
For Respondents
: Mr.B.Manohar, Advocate.
JUDGMENT
This Appeal Suit has been filed by the Special Tahsildar, Land
Acquisition, Adi Dravidar Welfare, Vellore, challenging the judgment
and decree dated 30.09.2003 passed in L.A.O.P.No.157 of 2002 by the
learned Additional District and Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court No.II,
Ranipet.
2. The appellant herein was the respondent before the Reference Court.
The first respondent herein was the claimant before the Reference Court.
2/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
Pending appeal, the sole respondent / claimant died and the second
respondent has been brought on record as her legal representative. For
convenience, the parties are referred to as referred in the trial court.
3.
The lands in S.Nos.30/1 and 30/5 at Thazhanoor Village, Walajapet
Taluk, measuring 0.35.0 hectares and 0.33.0 hectares respectively, in all
0.68.0 hectares or 1 acre 68 cents, belonged to the claimant. They were
acquired for providing house sites to Adi Dravidars. The notification
under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, was issued on
17.10.1994. Possession was taken on 24.03.1995. The Land Acquisition
Officer passed Award No.4 of 1994-1995 dated 24.03.1995, fixing the
market value at Rs.214.28 per cent and awarding compensation with 30%
solatium and 12% additional amount. The total amount ordered to be paid
was Rs.53,014/-.
4.
The claimant contended that the market value fixed by the Land
Acquisition Officer was very low. According to her, the acquired lands
had house-site potential, were situated near Arcot town, T.V. Station,
Gold Winner Oil Company, Pallavan I.T.I., Ganapathy Nagar, Sathya
Nagar and Kamarajar Nagar, and had access to Arcot-Arni Road. It was
also pleaded that the locality had factories, hospital and municipal
3/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
amenities. On that basis, the claimant sought compensation at Rs.7,000/per cent.
5.
The Land Acquisition Officer resisted the claim contending that
relevant pre-notification data sale deeds had been considered and that the
value was properly fixed at Rs.214.28 per cent on the basis of the sale
relating to S.Nos.25/3A and 25/3B. According to the Land Acquisition
Officer, the claimant had not produced any proper comparable sale deed
to justify enhancement.
6.
On the side of the claimant, C.W.1 Gnanasekaran was examined and
Exs.C1 and C2 were marked. Ex.C1 is the registered sale deed dated
17.09.1992 relating to S.No.119/2, under which 10¾ cents of land were
sold for Rs.47,350/-. Ex.C2 is the Arcot Town Map.
7.
On the side of the Land Acquisition Officer, R.W.1 M.Venkatesan
was examined and Exs.R1 to R4 were marked. Ex.R1 is the data land
sales and statistical particulars. Ex.R2 is the registered sale deed relating
to the data lands in S.Nos.25/3A and 25/3B. Ex.R3 is the A-Register
extract for the acquired land. Ex.R4 is the rough sketch.
4/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
8.
The Reference Court noticed that the Land Acquisition Officer had
relied upon the data lands in S.Nos.25/3A and 25/3B and fixed the market
value at Rs.214.28 per cent. It also noticed that Ex.C1 related to
S.No.119/2 and that, as per Ex.R4 rough sketch, S.No.119/2 was far away
from the acquired lands. On that reasoning, the Reference Court observed
that Ex.C1 could not be taken as the basis for fixing compensation.
9.
However, taking note of the fact that Arcot was an important and
well-developed place, the Reference Court enhanced the market value
from Rs.214.28 per cent to Rs.1,700/- per cent. It also granted 30%
solatium, 12% additional amount from the date of Section 4(1)
notification till the date of taking possession, interest at 9% for the first
year and 15% thereafter till deposit, with a direction to deduct
Rs.53,014/-, if already received by the claimant.
10.
The Land Acquisition Officer has challenged the judgment mainly
on the ground that the Reference Court enhanced the market value
without sufficient evidence. It is contended that the claimant did not
produce proper documents to substantiate the enhanced claim; that the
Land Acquisition Officer had relied upon a relevant sale deed prior to the
Section 4(1) notification; that Ex.C1 related only to a small extent in a
5/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
different survey number; that the Reference Court itself rejected Ex.C1
but still enhanced the value without reasons; and that no deductions were
applied towards smallness of extent and development charges. The
appellant therefore contends that the enhancement is excessive, arbitrary
and liable to be set aside.
11. The learned counsel for the appellant/Land Acquisition Officer
submitted that the Court below erred in fixing the compensation without
making proper deductions. It is contended that the acquired land is a large
extent of acreage, whereas the sale deeds relied upon by the Court below
relate only to small extents of land. Therefore, suitable deduction ought to
have been made while adopting the value reflected in such small extent
sale transactions. It is further submitted that the Court below also failed to
make appropriate deduction towards development charges, particularly
when the acquisition was for a housing scheme. According to the
appellant, deductions under the heads of small extent comparison and
development charges could go up to 65%, as held in several decisions of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court and this Court. Hence, the compensation
fixed by the Court below is excessive and requires interference.
6/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
12. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent/claimant submitted
that even if deduction is made towards small extent comparison and
development charges, the compensation fixed by the Court below does
not call for substantial interference. It is submitted that, after making a
reasonable deduction, the market value may be rounded off and fixed at
Rs.1,00,000/- per acre, which would be just and reasonable compensation
for the acquired land.
13. The following points arise for consideration in this appeal:
i. Whether the Reference Court was right in enhancing the market value
from Rs.214.28 per cent to Rs.1,700/- per cent?
ii. Whether Ex.C1 sale deed dated 17.09.1992 relating to S.No.119/2 can
be relied upon for fixing the market value of the acquired lands in
S.Nos.30/1 and 30/5?
iii. Whether Ex.R2, the data sale relied upon by the Land Acquisition
Officer relating to S.Nos.25/3A and 25/3B, correctly reflects the market
value of the acquired lands?
iv. Whether the Reference Court failed to apply proper deductions for
smallness of extent and development charges?
7/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
v. Whether the judgment and decree of the Reference Court require
interference in this appeal?
Point Nos.1 to 4
14.
The acquired lands are in S.Nos.30/1 and 30/5 at Thazhanoor
Village, Walajapet Taluk. The total extent is 1 acre 68 cents. The
acquisition was for providing house sites to Adi Dravidars. The relevant
date for fixing market value is 17.10.1994, the date of the Section 4(1)
notification.
15. The Land Acquisition Officer fixed the value at Rs.214.28 per cent
on the basis of Ex.R2, the data sale relating to S.Nos.25/3A and 25/3B.
The claimant relied upon Ex.C1, a sale deed dated 17.09.1992 relating to
S.No.119/2, under which 10¾ cents were sold for Rs.47,350/-. The
claimant also relied upon Ex.C2 Arcot Town Map to show the locational
advantages and developmental potential of the acquired lands.
16.
Both Ex.C1 and Ex.R2 are prior to the Section 4(1) notification.
Therefore, neither document can be rejected on the ground that it is postnotification. The real question is which of them is more comparable and
what evidentiary weight should be given to each.
8/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
17. Ex.R2 is relevant because it was the data sale adopted by the Land
Acquisition Officer. However, the record does not show any measured
distance between S.Nos.25/3A and 25/3B and the acquired lands in
S.Nos.30/1 and 30/5. Nor is there any detailed comparison as to road
access, development, locality advantage or house-site potential. Ex.R2,
therefore, may provide a conservative base value, but it cannot be treated
as conclusive of the true market value.
18. Ex.C1 is also relevant as a pre-notification sale. It shows that lands
in the wider Arcot area had higher market potential. At the same time,
Ex.C1 cannot be adopted directly. It relates only to 10¾ cents in
S.No.119/2, whereas the acquired extent is 1 acre 68 cents. Further, the
Reference Court has recorded, on the basis of Ex.R4 rough sketch, that
S.No.119/2 is far away from the acquired lands. Thus, Ex.C1 cannot be
treated as a direct comparable sale, but it can be used as a broad indicator
of market potential, subject to substantial deductions.
19. The objection of the appellant that Ex.C1 relates to a small extent is
correct. But that does not make Ex.C1 wholly irrelevant. A sale deed
relating to a small extent can be considered, if otherwise relevant, while
9/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
valuing a larger extent; but deductions must be made for smallness of
plot, development, roads, open spaces and other amenities.
20.
The rate under Ex.C1 works out to approximately Rs.4,405/- per
cent. However, the said rate cannot be adopted as such, since Ex.C1
relates to a smaller extent, whereas the acquired land is a larger extent
and the acquisition is for a housing scheme. Therefore, appropriate
deductions are required towards smallness of extent, locational factors,
distance and development charges. If deduction in the range of 60% to
65% is applied, the market value would work out approximately between
Rs.1,540/- and Rs.1,760/- per cent. In that view of the matter, the value of
Rs.1,700/- per cent fixed by the Reference Court cannot be said to be
excessive or unreasonable. The deduction effectively adopted by the
Reference Court is about 61.41%, which falls within the permissible and
reasonable range.
21.
The value fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer at Rs.214.28 per
cent appears to be on the lower side. The acquired lands were not
acquired as remote agricultural lands, but for house sites. The claimant’s
evidence, supported by Ex.C2, shows that the lands were in a locality
influenced by Arcot town and nearby developments, including roads,
10/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
residential areas, factories, hospital and other amenities. These
circumstances support the claimant’s case that the acquired lands had
house-site potential.
22. The reasoning of the Reference Court, however, is incomplete. After
observing that Ex.C1 could not be taken as the basis for fixing
compensation, it did not explain how it arrived at Rs.1,700/- per cent. It
did not state whether it was applying any deduction from Ex.C1; it did
not make a detailed comparison between Ex.C1 and Ex.R2; it did not
specify the relative distance of the acquired lands from the lands covered
under Ex.C1 or Ex.R2; and it did not expressly apply any deduction
towards development charges or difference in extent.
23. Nevertheless, the appellate Court is not required to interfere merely
because the Reference Court has not expressed its reasons adequately, if
the final value can be sustained on an independent appraisal of the
evidence. In the present case, Ex.R2 gives only a conservative base value,
while Ex.C1 indicates higher potentiality but requires substantial
deduction. Weighing both documents together, and taking note of the
house-site potential of the acquired lands, the value of Rs.1,700/- per cent
cannot be said to be excessive.
11/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
24.
Accordingly, Point Nos.1 to 4 are answered by holding that the
market value of Rs.1,700/- per cent fixed by it does not warrant
interference.
Point No.5
25. The appellant is right in contending that the Reference Court did not
give adequate reasons and did not expressly apply deductions. However,
on independent consideration of the evidence, the final valuation is
sustainable. Ex.C1 cannot be adopted directly, but, after substantial
allowance for smallness of extent, distance and development, it supports a
valuation in the range adopted by the Reference Court. Ex.R2, on the
other hand, does not sufficiently reflect the locational advantage and
house-site potential of the acquired lands.
26. Therefore, there is no ground to interfere with the final market value
fixed by the Reference Court. It is clarified that the confirmation of
Rs.1,700/- per cent is not on the exact reasoning given by the Reference
Court, but on the independent assessment made by this Court.
27. In the result, the Appeal Suit is dismissed. The judgment and decree
dated 30.09.2003 passed in L.A.O.P.No.157 of 2002 by the learned
12/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
Additional District and Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court No.II, Ranipet,
fixing the market value at Rs.1,700/- per cent, are confirmed.
28. The claimant / legal representative shall be entitled to compensation
at Rs.1,700/- per cent with statutory benefits under the Land Acquisition
Act, 1894, after giving credit to the amount already received or deposited.
There shall be no order as to costs. Consequently, connected
miscellaneous petitions if any, stand closed.
09.06.2026
ay
Index:Yes/No
Speaking Order /Non-speaking order
To
1.The Additional District and Sessions Court,
(FTC No.II), Ranipet.
2. The Section Officer,
V.R.Records,
Madras High Court.
13/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
DR. A.D. MARIA CLETE, J
ay
PRE DELIVERY JUDGMENT
A.S. No. 1070 of 2019
09.06.2026
14/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review