Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 5TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 16TH MAGHA, 1946
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 13.02.2020 IN WP(C) NO.27732 OF
2015 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANTS/2ND & 3RD RESPONDENTS IN W.P.:
CHAIRMAN RUBBER BOARD, P.B NO.1122
RUBBER BOARD, P.B NO. 1122, JAIL ROAD, KOTTAYAM 686 002
THE SECRETARY-CUM-DIRECTOR (FINANCE)
RUBBER BOARD, P.B NO. 1122, SUB JAIL ROAD,
KOTTAYAM 686 002
BY ADVS.
V.ABRAHAM MARKOS
ABRAHAM JOSEPH MARKOS
ISAAC THOMAS
P.G.CHANDAPILLAI ABRAHAM
ALEXANDER JOSEPH MARKOS
SHARAD JOSEPH KODANTHARA
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER & 1ST RESPONDENT IN W.P.:
SUMA GEORGE
AGED 57 YEARS
W/O. GEORGE THOMAS, ASSISTANT SUSTEM OFFICER,
COMPUTER DIVISION, RUBBER BOARD,
KOTTAYAM RESIDING AT CHELAMATTOM HOUSE, THOTTACKAD P.O,
KOTTAYAM 686 539
UNION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY,
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, UDYOG BHAVAN, NEW DELHI 110 011
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-2-
2025:KER:13367
BY ADV.
SRI.HARIDAS P.NAIR, CGC
SRI.T.C.KRISHNA (DSGI IN CHARGE)
THIS
WRIT
APPEAL
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD
ON
05.02.2025, ALONG WITH WA.896/2020, 1052/2020, THE COURT
ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-3-
2025:KER:13367
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 5TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 16TH MAGHA,
WA NO. 896 OF 2020
AGAINST
THE
JUDGMENT
DATED
13.02.2020
IN
WP(C)
NO.11529 OF 2015 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO.1:
THE RUBBER BOARD,
COLLECTORATE PO, KEEZHUKUNNU, KOTTAYAM 686002
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY.
BY ADVS.
ABRAHAM JOSEPH MARKOS
SRI.V.ABRAHAM MARKOS
SRI.ISAAC THOMAS
SRI.P.G.CHANDAPILLAI ABRAHAM
SHRI.VIPIN ANTO H.M.
SHRI.ALEXANDER JOSEPH MARKOS
SHRI.SHARAD JOSEPH KODANTHARA
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER IN WP/RESPONDENTS:
BABY MATHEW
W/O.THANKACHAN ZACHARIAS, SYSTEMS OFFICER,
EDP DIVISION, RUBBER BOARD, COLLECTORATE PO,
KOTTAYAM 686002(RESIDING AT KANNADY THUNDIYIL,
NORTH OF BISHOP'S HOUSE,
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-4-
2025:KER:13367
CHENGANACHERRY 686101).
THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR OF COMMERCIAL AUDIT
AND EX OFFICIO MEMBER OF THE AUDIT BOARD OFFICE
OF THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR OF COMMERCIAL AUDIT
AND OFFICIO MEMBER AUDIT BOARD 4 CH OFFICE,
GREAMS ROAD, THOUSAND LIGHTS, CHENNAI,
TAMIL NADU 600006
UNION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL TRAINING,
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, BLOCK 04,3RD FLOOR,
OLD JNU CAMPUS, NEW MEHRAULI ROAD,
NEW DELHI-110 067
BY ADVS.
SRI.T.C.KRISHNA (DSGI IN CHARGE)
SRI.ASOK M.CHERIAN
SRI.P.VIJAYAKUMAR
SRI.SATHEESH N
THIS
WRIT
APPEAL
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD
ON
05.02.2025, ALONG WITH WA.1047/2020 AND CONNECTED CASES,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-5-
2025:KER:13367
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 5TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 16TH MAGHA,
WA NO. 1052 OF 2020
AGAINST
THE
JUDGMENT
DATED
13.02.2020
IN
WP(C)
NO.11531 OF 2015 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT/1ST RESPONDENT:
THE RUBBER BOARD
COLLECTORATE P.O., KEEZHUKUNNU,
REPRESENTED B ITS SECRETARY, P.B.NO.1122,
SUB-JAIL ROAD, KOTTAYAM-686 002
BY ADVS.
V.ABRAHAM MARKOS
SRI.P.G.CHANDAPILLAI ABRAHAM
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER IN W.P. & 2ND RESPONDENT:
CHANDRIKA DEVI.M
AGED 58 YEARS
W/O.K.V JAYAKUMAR, ASST. SYSTEMS OFFICER, EDP
DIVISION, RUBBER BOARD, COLLECTORATE P.O.,
KOTTAYAM-686 002, (RESIDING AT NANDANAM,
ARPOOKARA EAST P.O., KOTTAYAM-686 008)
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-6-
2025:KER:13367
THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR OF COMMERCIAL AUDIT AND
EX OFFICIO MEMBER OF THE AUDIT BOARD,
OFFICE OF THE PRINCIPAL DIRECTOR OF COMMERCIAL
AUDIT AND EX OFFICIO MEMBER OF THE AUDIT BOARD,
4-CH OFFICE, GREAMS ROAD, THOUSAND LIGHTS,
CHENNAI,TAMIL NADU-600 006
BY ADVS.
SRI.T.C.KRISHNA (DSGI IN CHARGE)
SRI.ASOK M.CHERIAN
SRI.P.VIJAYAKUMAR
THIS
WRIT
APPEAL
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD
ON
05.02.2025, ALONG WITH WA.1047/2020 AND CONNECTED CASES,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-7-
2025:KER:13367
JUDGMENT
[WA Nos.1047/2020, 896/2020, 1052/2020]
AMIT RAWAL, J.
This order shall dispose of three writ appeals
preferred by the Rubber Board against the common
judgment
of
the
Single
Bench
dated
13.02.2020,
whereby the writ petitions, challenging the action of the
Rubber Board in recovering the amount allegedly and
erroneously paid under the Modified Assured Career
Progression (MACP) by granting the third up-gradation,
have been allowed and the impugned order has been
quashed.
2.
All
respondents/writ
petitioners
were
appointed as Lower Divisional Clerks and Statistical
Assistants having a pay scale of Rs.1400-2300 as per the
4th Central Pay Commission. Recruitment Rules for the
post of Computer Programmer, Exhibit R1(b), envisaged
that the selection is on the basis of test and training and
the
method
of
recruitment
was
promotion.
The
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-8-
2025:KER:13367
categories of posts from which promotion can be made
was on the basis of a departmental test to determine
aptitude followed by training on computer application
and evaluation of performance with a condition that the
employees eligible must possess a minimum educational
qualification of pass in S.S.L.C. or equivalent course.
The whole controversy revolves around the recruitment
rules
where
against
column
No.5
of
‘method
of
recruitment’, expression ‘promotion’ has been referred
to. If at all it had been a promotion, there would have
been a seniority list of the Statistical Assistants or Lower
Divisional Clerks but, in fact the said rule meant only for
the employees of the Rubber Board to avail the chance
of selection on the basis of the test and training.
3.
aforementioned
All the employees, on the basis of the
rule,
were
appointed
as
Computer
Programmer and Data Entry Machine Operators, having
different pay scale. Thereafter, all the aforementioned
posts merged together with effect from 01.04.1991
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-9-
2025:KER:13367
as ‘Programmer cum
scale
of
Processing Assistant’ in the pay
Rs.2000-3200
as
per
4th
Central
Pay
Commission, which were later revised from time to time.
The department granted them the 3 rd MACP with effect
from on 15.02.2002 as they had put in ten(10) years of
stagnated service.
The question which arose for
withdrawing the aforementioned benefit was on the
basis
of
an
audit
objection,
that
recruitment
as
Computer Programmer or Data Entry Operator was the
first upgradation and not an appointment by selection
and re-designation as Programmer cum Processing
Assistant was second upgradation. With effect from
February 2002, on recommendation of 5th Central Pay
Commission, were placed in the pay scale of Rs.800013500 under the cadre review scheme, which was to be
considered
as
third
upgradation.
Realizing
the
aforementioned factum, notice was issued for recovery
of the excess amount, which was challenged before the
single bench. Learned Single bench, on analysis of the
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-10-
2025:KER:13367
evidence, allowed the writ petition.
4.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the petitioner submitted that the recruitment rules is the
barometer for the purpose of the eligibility or noneligibility of the third up-gradation under the MACP
after having rendered ten(10) years of stagnated service,
as, the first up-gradation was strictly as per the
recruitment
rules
which
did
not
envisage
any
appointment, but only promotion. He further submitted
that
the
considered
learned
common
Single
Bench
seniority
list
had
erroneously
of
Data
Entry
Operator, which was not the issue raised even by the
respondents/writ
petitioners.
The
Modified
Career
Progression Scheme, when promulgated, had different
doubts and clarifications was sought that regular service
for the purposes of MACP is from the date of joining the
post and direct entry cadre, whereas the respondents –
writ petitioners, after having undergone the aptitude
and
other test,
were promoted
and
it would
be
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-11-
2025:KER:13367
considered as first financial up-gradation, therefore the
benefit of first MACP, after having rendered ten(10)
years of stagnated service, was not liable to be accorded
or sanctioned.
The action for recovery of the amount
was justified.
5.
On the other hand learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the respondents countered the
aforementioned arguments and submitted that the terms
and conditions of the appointment letter do not leave
any matter of doubt that it was an appointment and not
a promotion. The expression ‘promotion’ in the rule is
only for the purpose that the employees of the Rubber
Board were only eligible to undergo the tests and further
submitted that the findings of the facts and law arrived
at by the learned Single Bench do not require any
different interpretation.
6.
We have heard learned counsel for the
parties and appraised the paper books.
7.
Recruitment
rules
for
the
post
of
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-12-
2025:KER:13367
Computer Programmer reads as under:
“RECRUITMENT RULE FOR THE POST OF Computer
Programmer”
1. Name of the Post
: Computer Programmer
2. Classification
: Group ‘C’
3. Scale of Pay
: Rs.425-800
4. Whether selection or
non-selection
: Selection on the basis of test and
training
5. Method of recruitment
: Promotion
6. Categories of posts from : Selection on the basis of a departmental
which promotion can be
test to determine aptitude, followed by
made
training on computer application and
evaluation of performance. Employees
of the Board possessing a minimum
educational qualification of a pass in
SSLC or equivalent shall be eligible to
appear for the test.
8.
All the respondents/writ petitioners had
rendered two(2) years of service when the process of
selection to the post of Computer Programmer or Data
Entry
Operator
was
initiated.
Even
in
the
communication dated 03.09.1991 of the Government of
India, Ministry of Commerce, it was clarified that the
post of Computer Programmer was not a promotion, but an
appointment. The contents of the letter reads as under:
“orders of the Chairman fixing interse seniority
of
the
personnel
drafted
to
the
post
of
Programmer-cum-processing Assistant on the
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-13-
2025:KER:13367
basis of their grace and length of service in the
Rubber
Board
was
issued
vide
OM
No.
23/1(2)/91/EST dated 1st April, 1991. Now on
re-examination of the matter considering the
representation in this regard it has been
decided that seniority of the personnel holding
the
post
of
Programmer-cum-Processing
Assistant may be fixed based on the original
ranking
recommended
by
the
Computer
Consultants who conducted the evaluation and
assessment tests for the trainees sponsored by
us in computer programming. The posting as
Computer Programmer was not a promotion,
but an appointment and the length of service in
the previous post is not relevant in fixing the
seniority in the new cadre of Programmers
selected.
The
fact
that
programmer-cum-
Processing Assistant is only a redesignation of
the post of Computer Programmer has also
been taken into account in arriving at this
decision. The seniority of the four personnel
holding
the
post
of
programmer-cum-
Processing Assistant is therefore, refixed as
follows:1
Shri S Naveena Kumar
Smt. Baby Mathew
Shri N Peethambaran
Shri U Suryanarayana Bhatt.
These orders are issued in partial
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-14-
2025:KER:13367
modification
of
the
OM
No.23/1(2)/91/EST
dated 1st April, 1991.”
9.
The appointment letter issued to one of
the Computer Programmers is worth extraction.
same reads as under:
“The following Statistical Assistants
and LD Clerks, who have undergone the course
on “Computer Programming” in April, 1986 run
by M/s. Pallavan Transport Consultancy Service
Ltd.,
Madras,
Computer
-
are
appointed
Computer
as
“Trainee
Programmers”
on
Rs.425/- p.m. in the scale of pay of Rs. 425 800. On relief they should report before the
Financial Adviser.
1.
Sri S Naveena Kumar, Statistical
Assistant, S & P Dn.
2.
Smt Baby Mathew, Statistical
Assistant, Research Dept.
3.
Sri N Peethambaran, LD Clerk,
Regional Office, Palghat.
4.
Sri U Surya Narayana Bhat, LD
Clerk, RO, Mangalore.
On satisfactory completion of training,
they
will
be
posted
as
“Computer
Programmers” in the scale of pay of Rs.425 800.”
The
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-15-
2025:KER:13367
9.
If at all it was a case of promotion, the
expression ‘promotion’ would have been used and not
appointment, or it would have been an appointment on
promotion.
Therefore, said appointment cannot be
considered to be the first upgradation and denied the
benefit of the first part of the MACP Scheme, financial
upgradation after having rendered ten(10) years of
stagnated service.
Though after having appointed as
Data Entry Operator or Computer Programmer, the post
was re-designated and named as ‘Programmer cum
Processing Assistant’, which was upgraded in 2002 and
that would have been a second upgradation and not the
third upgradation.
10.
The finding rendered by the learned
single bench reads as under:
“21. Therefore, I am of the view that the
upgradations given to the petitioners after their
appointment in the EDP Division alone shall be
taken into account for the purpose of financial
upgradation
under
MACP
Scheme.
Even
assuming that the method of appointment to
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-16-
2025:KER:13367
the posts in EDP is by way of promotion, even
when it is in a different hierarchy of posts, they
would be entitled to be considered for the
benefit of MACP with reference to the date on
which they were appointed as Data Entry
Machine Operators/Computer Programmers in
the EDP unit. Even if the argument of the
learned Standing Counsel that the Chairman
was competent to take a decision with respect
to recruitment to new posts under Section 27(7)
of Chapter 5 of the Rubber Board Act and as
per
the
Recruitment
Rules
which
got
ratification subsequently, which provides for
promotion as the method of appointment is
accepted, I am of the view that the petitioners,
who are governed by separate seniority list in
the Electronic Data Processing Division which
is a separate cadre, having regard to the entire
process of selection for appointment to the post
in a separate Department which is functioning
separately, without any consideration for their
length of service in the Rubber Board, based on
their initial appointments as LDC/Statistical
Assistants, are liable to be considered as having
been absorbed or recruited to the new cadre.
22. In the above circumstances of the case, I
am of the considered view that the audit
objections raised in the case of the petitioners
in all these Writ Petitions and the consequential
action of the Rubber Board in withdrawing the
WA NO. 1047 OF 2020
-17-
2025:KER:13367
benefit of MACPS and in re-fixing their pay are
unsustainable and accordingly the impugned
orders in all these Writ Petitions i.e Exts.P6 and
P7 in W.P.(C).No. 27732/2015, Exts.P9 and P11
orders
in
W.P.(C).Nos
11529/2015
and
11531/2015 to the extent those relate to the
petitioners shall stand set aside. The benefits
given to them prior to the orders which are set
aside shall stand restored and they shall be
granted consequential benefits.”
11. As an upshot of our findings as well as the
view noticed by the learned Single Bench, we are of the
view that nothing survives in the appeal as the order
under challenge is perfectly legal and justified and do
not call for any interference.
Writ appeals stand dismissed.
Sd/AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
vv
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review