Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE C.PRATHEEP KUMAR
TUESDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 18TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MACA NO. 2076 OF 2012
OPMV NO.1870 OF 2006 OF MOTOR ACCIDENTS CLAIMS
TRIBUNAL,THALASSERY
APPELLANT/2ND RESPONDENT
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO.LTD.
KANNUR, REPRESENTED BY ITS ASSISTANT MANAGER,
REGIONAL OFFICE, ERNAKULAM NORTH, KOCHI-18.
BY ADVS.
SRI.GEORGE CHERIAN (THIRUVALLA)(Sr.)
GEORGE A.CHERIAN
RESPONDENTS/CLAIMANTS/1ST RESPONDENT
C.HAMZA
S/O. MAMMU, CHAPPARAPADAVU, NOW RESIDING AT
CHAVANAPUZHA, P.O.POOMANGALAM, KARIMBAM VIA, PIN670 001.
THANIYANTAKEEZHIL SARA
W/O. HAMSA, CHAVANAPUZHA, P.O.POOMANGALAM,
KARIMBAM VIA, THALIPARAMBA TALUK, PIN-670 001.
THANIYANTAKEEZHIL IBRAHIM KUTTY
MOIDEENKUTTY, CHAVANAPUZHA, P.O., POOMANGALAM,
KARIMBAM VIA, TALIPARAMBA TALUK, PIN-670 001.
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN
FINALLY HEARD ON 28.2.2025, THE COURT ON 08.04.2025,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
C.R.
JUDGMENT
Dated : 8th April, 2025
The 2nd respondent in OP(MV).1870/2006 on the file of the Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thalassery is the appellant. ( For the purpose of
convenience the parties are hereafter referred to as per their rank before the
Tribunal).
2.
The petitioners are the parents of a 13 year old boy, who died in a
motor vehicle accident that occurred on 19.4.2000. According to the
petitioners, on 19.4.2000 at about 1.30 p.m while the boy was travelling along
with the 1st respondent, in a tempo van bearing registration No.KL13D/5954
owned and driven by the 1st respondent in a rash and negligent manner, the
vehicle met with an accident, the child sustained serious injuries and he
succumbed to the injuries on the same day. The 2nd respondent is the insurer
of the tempo van.
3.
The evidence consists of the oral testimony of PW1 and Exts.A1,
A2 and Ext.B1. After evaluating the evidence on record, the Tribunal found
that the accident occurred due to the negligence of the 1 st respondent and also
found that the boy was engaged by the 1st respondent for supplying water to
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
hotels and houses at Thaliparamba and awarded a compensation of
Rs.2,44,500/- and directed the insurer to pay the same.
4.
Now the point that arises for consideration is the following:
1) Whether the deceased boy was a gratuitous passenger or a
person engaged by the owner?
2) Whether absence of pleading is fatal in a proceeding under
S.166 of M.V.Act?
3) Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal
5.
is just and reasonable?
Heard Sri.George Cherian, the learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the appellant.
6.
The Point: In this case the accident as well as valid policy of the
offending vehicle are admitted. One of the arguments raised by the learned
Senior counsel for the Insurance Company is that the boy was a gratuitous
passenger in the tempo van and as such, the insurer has no liability to
indemnify the insured. He has also relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in New India Assurance Co.Ltd v. Asha Rani and Others,
(2003) 2 SCC 223, Manager, National Insurance Company Limited v.
Saju P.Paul and Another, (2013) 2 SCC 41 and a Division Bench of this
Court in New India Assurance Co.Ltd. v. Alekutty Antony, 2009 (4) KLT
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
130, in support of his argument.
7.
In the decision in Asha Rani (supra) the question that arose for
consideration was whether the insurer is liable to pay compensation to the
dependents of the deceased passenger while the deceased passenger was
travelling in a goods vehicle and that the vehicle met with an accident, prior
to the amendment of 1994. The above question was answered by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the negative. In the instant case, the accident occurred on
19.4.2000, after the commencement of the amendment of 1994 and as such,
the decision in Asha Rani (supra) will not apply to the facts of this case.
8.
In the decision in Saju P.Paul (supra), the question of law that
arose was whether the insurer is liable to pay compensation for the bodily
injury caused to the claimant who was travelling in a goods vehicle as a spare
driver, though he was employed as a driver in another vehicle owned by the
owner of the vehicle under the policy of insurance. The Hon'ble Apex Court
found that the deceased in that case was not in any manner engaged in the
vehicle that met with the accident but he was employed as a driver in another
vehicle owned by the owner of the vehicle. It was also found that the insurer
had paid a premium for one driver and one cleaner alone and therefore, a
second driver or for that purpose, spare driver was not covered under the
policy. The Court also found that merely because he was travelling in the
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
cabin could not make his case different from any other gratuitous passenger.
9.
In Alekutty Antony (supra), four persons namely a mason and
two headload workers were travelling in a goods vehicle. While the Mason
was sitting inside the cabin and others were in platform, the vehicle met with
an accident. The question that arose for consideration was whether the
persons who were on the platform in the goods vehicle are to be indemnified
by the insurer. The Division Bench answered the above question in the
negative. However, since the mason engaged by the owner was sitting in the
cabin of the vehicle as representative of the owner of the goods, it was held
that the insurer is liable to indemnify the owner of the vehicle for the
compensation payable to the legal heirs of the deceased mason.
10.
In the instant case, the boy was sitting inside the cabin. Now the
question remains to be answered is whether he was a gratuitous passenger or
was a person engaged by the owner?
11.
When the mother of the deceased was examined as PW1 she
categorically deposed that the 1st respondent was engaged in supplying
drinking water in large plastic tanks for consideration and during holidays her
son used to go along with the 1st respondent in his vehicle for helping him in
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
supplying drinking water to his customers. According to her, during such days
the 1st respondent used to pay daily wages of Rs.100/- to the deceased. On the
date of the accident also the deceased accompanied the 1st respondent in his
vehicle for the aforesaid job and it was at that time the accident occurred. At
the time of the accident, he had completed the 8th standard and was awaiting
admission to the 9th standard. According to her, the deceased was a bright
student and he was also engaged in extra curricular activities. He used to give
the wages received from the above job to her. Though during the crossexamination a suggestion was put to to the effect that the boy travelled in the
offending vehicle as a gratuitous passenger, she denied the said suggestion.
Therefore, from the evidence of PW1 it is crystal clear that the deceased
travelled in the offending vehicle as engaged by the 1 st respondent to help him
in supplying drinking water to his customers.
12.
The learned Senior counsel for the insurer invited my attention to
the effect that in the claim petition there is no specific pleading to the effect
that the deceased travelled in the vehicle as an employee of the 1 st respondent
and argued that, in the absence of any such pleading, it is to be treated that the
deceased was a gratuitous passenger.
13.
The law is well settled that in a proceeding under Section 166 of
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
the M.V.Act the Tribunal has a duty to award just and reasonable
compensation to the victims of road traffic accidents. Further, sub-section (6)
of Section 158 of the M.V.Act states that :
“As soon as any information regarding any accident involving
death or bodily injury to any person is recorded or report under this
section is completed by a police officer, the officer-in-charge of the police
station shall forward a copy of the same within thirty days from the date of
recording of information or as the case may be, on completion of such
report to the Claims Tribunal having jurisdiction and a copy thereof to the
concerned insurer, and where a copy is made available to the owner, he
shall also within thirty days of receipt of such report, forward the same to
such Claims Tribunal and Insurer.”
14.
As per sub-section (4) of Section 166, the Claims Tribunal shall
treat any report of accidents forwarded to it under sub-section (6) of Section
158 as an application for compensation under this Act.
15.
In the decision in Raj Rani and Ors. v. Oriental Insurance
Co.Ltd and Ors. (2009) 13 SCC 654 in paragraph 13, the Apex Court held
that :-
“13. It is not necessary in a proceeding under the Motor Vehicles Act to
go by any rules of pleadings or evidence. Section 166 of the Act speaks
about grant of just compensation. The court's duty being to award just
compensation, it will try to arrive at the said finding irrespective of the
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
fact as to whether any plea in that behalf was raised by the claimant or
not. “
16.
In the decision in Ningamma and Ors v. United India
Insurance Co.Ltd., AIR 2009 SC 3056 in paragraph 25 the Apex Court held
that :
“25.Undoubtedly, Section 166 of the MVA deals with "Just
Compensation" and even if in the pleadings no specific claim was made
under Section 166 of the MVA, in our considered opinion a party should
not be deprived from getting "Just Compensation" in case the claimant is
able to make out a case under any provision of law. Needless to say, the
MVA is beneficial and welfare legislation. In fact, the court is duty bound
and entitled to award "Just Compensation" irrespective of the fact
whether any plea in that behalf was raised by the claimant or not.”
17.
In the decision in United India Insurance Company Ltd. v.
Shila Datta and Ors, AIR 2012 SC 86, [SC] a three Judge Bench of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court held that rule of
pleadings does not apply to
proceedings prescribed under the M.V Act. In paragraph 5 the Apex Court
held that :
“A claim petition for compensation in regard to a motor accident (filed
by the injured or in case of death, by the dependent family members)
before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal constituted under section 165
of the Act is neither a suit nor an adversarial lis in the traditional sense.
It is a proceedings in terms of and regulated by the provisions of Chapter
XII of the Act which is a complete Code in itself. We may in this context
refer to the following significant aspects in regard to the Tribunals and
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
determination of compensation by Tribunals:
(i) A proceedings for award of compensation in regard to a motor
accident before the Tribunal can be initiated either on an application for
compensation made by the persons aggrieved (claimants) under section
166(1)or section 163A of the Act or suo moto by the Tribunal, by
treating any report of accident (forwarded to the tribunal under section
158 (6) of the Act as an application for compensation under Section
166(4) of the Act.
(ii) The rules of pleadings do not strictly apply as the claimant is
required to make an application in a form prescribed under the Act. In
fact, there is no pleading where the proceedings are suo moto initiated by
the Tribunal.”
18.
In the decision in The New India Assurance Co.Ltd v. Safder
Ali and Ors. MANU/JK/1254/2023, the Jammu and Kashmir High Court
also held that in a proceeding under the Motor Vehicles Act, strict rules of
proceedings are not applicable. In paragraph 8, the Court held that :
“It is profitable to note that, in law, pleadings and proof are distinct and
different from each other and in a claim petition filed under the
provisions of Motor Vehicles Act, the strict rules of pleadings are not
applicable suggesting that it is not imperative and necessary for a
claimant to plead specifically all the facts in the claim petition. “
19.
Therefore, it can be seen that strict rules of pleadings are not
applicable in a proceeding under Section 166 of the M.V.Act. Further, it is to
be noted that at the time of the accident, the deceased was a 13 year old boy
engaged in daily wage work, to help his mother, being her elder son. In the
above circumstances, for the sole reason that there is no specific pleading in
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
the claim petition to the effect that he was engaged as an employee of the 1 st
respondent in his vehicle, his dependents cannot be denied the legitimate
compensation due to them.
20.
In this context it is also to be noted that at the time of the
accident, drinking water in plastic tanks were transported in the offending
lorry and there was nobody else in the said vehicle as employee of the 1 st
respondent to help him supplying drinking water from the lorry to his
customers. The above circumstance also probabilises the evidence of PW1
that at the time of the accident, the deceased was travelling along with the 1 st
respondent not as a gratuitous passenger, but as an employee of the 1 st
respondent. The respondents also have not adduced any evidence to
controvert the above evidence of PW1 and as such, it is to be held that at the
time of the accident the deceased was travelling in the cabin of the offending
vehicle along with the 1st respondent as his employee and as such, the 2 nd
respondent/insurer cannot take a contention that they are not liable to
indemnify the insured, the compensation legitimately due to the dependents
of the deceased.
21.
With regard to the notional income to be taken for quantifying
the compensation to be awarded to the dependents of a child between the age
group 6 to 15, in the decision in National Insurance Company Ltd. and
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
Ors. v. K.K.Assaignar and Others, 2019 (4) KLT 39,
a learned Single
Judge of this Court after relying upon various decisions, formulated a
schedule, taking into account the fact of inflation on the real money value. As
per the above decision, during the year 2000-2001, the annual notional
income will come to Rs.35,000/-. Further, as per the above decision the
multiplier to be applied is 15, and one-third of the income is to be deducted
towards personal and living expense. Accordingly, the compensation due to
the petitioners on loss of dependency, as per the above decision will come to
only Rs.3,50,000/-.
22.
In the decision in Kishan Gopal and Another v. Lala and
Others, (2014) 1 SCC 244, in the case of a ten year old child who died in a
motor vehicle accident that occurred in the year 1992, the Hon'ble Apex Court
has fixed his notional income at Rs.30,000/- and the multiplier of 15 was
applied. However, in the decision in Kusmi Devi v. Md.Kasim, 2023 ACJ
1658, in the case of a three year old child who died in a motor vehicle
accident in the year 1994, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has awarded a total
compensation of Rs.6,00,000/- which includes Rs.5,00,000/- awarded by the
High Court and an additional sum of Rs.1,00,000/- awarded by the Apex
Court on the head 'global enhancement'.
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
23.
Therefore, considering the entire facts, I hold that in this case
also by applying the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kusmi Devi
(supra) a sum of Rs.6,00,000/- can be awarded to the dependents of the
deceased child, on all non-pecuniary heads taken together. In addition to the
same, a sum of Rs.2000/- is awarded towards transportation expenses and
Rs.500/- towards damage to clothing. Therefore, the total compensation due
to the petitioners will come to Rs.6,02,500 [6,00,000 + 2000 + 500].
24.
I am aware that this is an appeal filed by the insurer and that the
claimants have not filed any appeal or cross-objection. Even in such cases,
this court has a duty to ensure that just compensation is awarded to the
affected person or the claimants (Surekha and Others v. Santhosh and
Others, 2020 ACJ 2156).
25.
In the result, this Appeal is dismissed. At the same time, the
quantum of compensation due to the petitioners is enhanced to Rs.6,02,500/-.
The 2nd respondent is directed to deposit a total sum of Rs.6,02,500/- (Rupees
six lakh two thousand five hundred Only), less the amount already deposited,
if any, along with interest @ 8% from the date of the petition till
realisation/deposit, excluding interest for a period of 155 days, the period of
delay in filing the appeal, within a period of two months from today.
MACA 2076/2012
2025:KER:30132
On depositing the aforesaid amount, the Tribunal shall disburse the
entire amount to the petitioners, in the ratio fixed by the Tribunal, excluding
excess court fee payable, if any, without delay, as per rules.
Sd/C.Pratheep Kumar, Judge
Mrcs/10.3.25
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review