Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE MARY JOSEPH
THURSDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2024 / 19TH MAGHA, 1945
MACA NO. 619 OF 2014
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 23.10.2013 IN OP(MV) NO.323 OF 2009 OF MOTOR ACCIDENTS CLAIMS
TRIBUNAL, WAYANAD, kALPETTA
APPELLANT/13th RESPONDENT:
THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED,
KOZHIKODE,NOW REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER,
REGIONAL OFFICE,M.G.ROAD,KOCHI-11.
BY ADVS.SRI.MATHEWS JACOB (SR.)
SRI.P.JACOB MATHEW
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS AND RESPONDENTS 1 TO 6.
*8
KUNJIMUHAMMED,S/O.KUNHALANKUTTY,KOLAMBIL HOUSE,VELLAMUNDA
VILLAGE,MANANTHAVADI.P.O,WAYANAD DISTRICT,PIN-670320.
ASYA,W/O.KUNJIMUHAMMED,KOLAMBIL HOUSE,VELLAMUNDA VILLAGE,
MANANTHAVADI.P.O,WAYANAD DISTRICT,PIN-670320.
MASIDA,D/O.KUNJIMUHAMMED,KOLAMBIL HOUSE,VELLAMUNDA VILLAGE,
MANANTHAVADI.P.O,WAYANAD DISTRICT,PIN-670320.
RAFEEDA,W/O.KUNJIMUHAMMED,KOLAMBIL HOUSE,VELLAMUNDA VILLAGE,
MANANTHAVADI.P.O,WAYANAD DISTRICT,PIN-670320.
RAJU @ RAPHEL,S/O.PAILY,PALLIKKAL HOUSE,THONICHAL,MANANTHAVADI.P.O,WAYANAD
DISTRICT,PIN-670320.
DEVASSYKUTTY,S/O.VARGHESE,5/873,PALLIYAN HOUSE,MANANTHAVADI.P.O,WAYANAD
DISTRICT,PIN-670320.
THE MANAGER,UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED,VETTUKATTIL
BUILDINGS,M.G.ROAD,KOCHI-682016.
ASGAR ALI,MANNAMKANDY HOUSE,HALBAR ROAD,VEERAJPET.P.O,PIN-670320.(DELETED)
RESPONDENT NO. 8 IS DELETED FROM THE PARTY ARRAY AT THE RISK OF APPELLANT
VIDE ORDER DATED 18/2/15 IN IA NO 553/15IN MACA 619/2104
NAVAS,THALATHIL HOUSE,P.C.ROAD,MUKKAM.P.O,KOZHIKODE,PIN-673318.
NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
KOZHIKODE,PIN-673318.
R1 TO R4 BY ADVS.SRI.GEORGE THOMAS MEVADA (SR.)
SRI.MANU GEORGE KURUVILLA
SRI.AMAL GEORGE
R10 BY SRI.A.R.GEORGE
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 08.02.2024, ALONG WITH MACA.681/2014,
682/2014 AND MACA NO.3852/2017 THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:2:IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE MARY JOSEPH
THURSDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2024 / 19TH MAGHA, 1945
MACA NO. 681 OF 2014
AGAINST
THE
AWARD
DATED
23.10.2013
IN
OP(MV)
NO.323
OF
OF
MOTOR
ACCIDENTS CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, WAYANAD, KALPETTA
APPELLANT/6TH RESPONDENT IN THE OP:
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.
KOZHIKODE, REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER, NATIONAL INSURANCE
CO.LTD.,KOCHI, REGIONAL OFFICE, OMANA BUILDINGS, PADMA JUNCTION,
KOCHI -35.
BY ADV SRI.A.R.GEORGE
RESPONDENTS/CLAIMANTS IN THE OP:
KUNJIMUHAMMED,
S/O.KUNJALIKKUTTY, KOLAMBIL HOUSE,VELLAMUNDA VILLAGE,
MANANTHAVADI, WAYANAD DISTRICT, PIN-670 731.
ASYA
W/O.KUNJIMUHAMMED, KOLAMBIL HOUSE,VELLAMUNDA VILLAGE,
MANANTHAVADI, WAYANAD DISTRICT, PIN- 670 731.
MASIDA
D/O.KUNJIMUHAMMED, KOLAMBIL HOUSE,VELLAMUNDA VILLAGE,
MANANTHAVADI, WAYANAD DISTRICT, PIN- 670 731.
RAFEEDA,
D/O.KUNJIMUHAMMED, KOLAMBIL HOUSE,VELLAMUNDA VILLAGE,
MANANTHAVADI, WAYANAD DISTRICT, PIN -670 731.
R1 TO R4 BY ADVS.SRI.AMAL GEORGE
SRI.GEORGE THOMAS MEVADA (SR.)
SRI.MANU GEORGE KURUVILLA
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 08.02.2024,
ALONG WITH MACA.619/2014, MACA 682/2014, AND MACA 3852/2017, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:3:-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE MARY JOSEPH
THURSDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2024 / 19TH MAGHA, 1945
MACA NO. 682 OF 2014
AGAINST
THE
AWARD
DATED
23.10.2013
IN
OP(MV)
NO.172
OF
OF
MOTOR
ACCIDENTS CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, WAYANAD,KALPETTA
APPELLANT/6th RESPONDENT IN THE OP
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.
KOZHIKKODE, REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER, NATIONAL INSURANCE CO.
LTD., KOCHI REGIONAL OFFICE, OMANA BUILDINGS, PADMA JUNCTION,
KOCHI-35.
BY ADV SRI.A.R.GEORGE
RESPONDENTS/CLAIMANTS IN THE OP
S.ABDULLA,
S/O.KUNHAMMED HAJI, SAID HOUSE, KATTAYAD POST, VELLAMUNDA,
MANANTHAVADY TALUK, WAYANAD DISTRICT -670 731.
SUBAIDA
W/O.ABDULLA, -DO- -DONUBAISATH,
D/O.ABDULLA, -DO- -DOJUNAISATH,
D/O.ABDULLA, -DO- -DOBY ADV SMT.CELINE JOSEPH
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 08.02.2024,
ALONG WITH MACA.619/2014, MACA NO.681/2014 AND MACA 3852/2017, THE COURT ON
THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:4:IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE MARY JOSEPH
THURSDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2024 / 19TH MAGHA, 1945
MACA NO. 3852 OF 2017
AGAINST
THE
AWARD
DATED
23.10.2013
IN
OP(MV)
NO.172
OF
OF
MOTOR
ACCIDENTS CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, WAYANAD, KALPETTA
APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS:
S.ABDULLA
AGED 57 YEARS
S/O KUNHAMMED HAJI,(FATHER OF LATE MUHAMMED AFSAL)
SUBAIDA,
AGED 47 YEARS, W/O ABDULLA, (MOTHER OF LATE MUHAMMED AFSAL)
NUBAISATH,
AGED 29 YEARS, D/O ABDULLA, (SISTER OF LATE MUHAMMED AFSAL)
JUNAISATH,
AGED 25 YEARS, D/O ABDULLA, (SISTER OF LATE MUHAMMED AFSAL)
ALL ARE RESIDING AT SAID HOUSE, KATTAYAD POST,VELLMUNDA,
MANANTHAVADY TALUK, WAYANAD DISTRICT
BY ADV. SMT.CELINE JOSEPH
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
RAJU @ RAPHEL,AGED 48 YEARS, S/O PAILY, PALLIYAN
HOUSE,THONICHAL, NALLOORNAD VILLAGE- 670645
DEVASSYKUTTY, S/O VARGHESE, PALLIYAN HOUSE, CHOOTAKADAVU
ROAD,MANANTHAVADY POST, WAYANAD- 670645
THE BRANCH MANAGER, UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COM.LTD, VETTUKATTIL
BUILDINGS,M.G ROAD, ERNAKULAM, KOCHI-682016
ASGAR ALI,AGED 29 YEARS, S/O MOIDEEN, MANDANKANDIL HOUSE,5TH
MILE, KALLOOR, ANCHUKUNNU VILLAGE, PIN-670645
NAVAS,THALATHIL HOUSE, P.C ROAD, MUKKAM PO, CALICUT-673601
THE BRANCH MANAGER, NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD, KALPANA
SHOPPING COMPLEX, MAIN ROAD, KALPETTA -673121
R1 AND R2 BY ADVS.SRI.D.G.VIPIN
SRI.KAROL MATHEWS SEBASTIAN ALENCHERRY
SRI.DANIEL A.J.
R3 BY ADV.SRI.P.JACOB MATHEW
R6 BY ADV.SRI.A.R.GEORGE
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING CBEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 08.02.2024,
ALONG WITH MACA.619/2014, 681/2014 AND MACA 682/2014, THE COURT ON THE SAME
DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:5:-
MARY JOSEPH, J.
-------------------------M.A.C.A. Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and
M.A.C.A. No. 3852 of 2017
-------------------------Dated this the 8th day of February, 2024
JUDGMENT
The above four appeals have been originated from a
common award passed by Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Kalpetta (for short ‘the Tribunal’) on 23.10.2013 in OP(MV)
Nos.323 of 2009 and 172 of 2010.
2. MACA No.619/2014 was filed by supplemental 13 th
respondent in OP(MV) No.323/2009, the insurer of the
motorcycle bearing Registration No.KL-11/Z 9402 in which
Mr.Fahad,
the victim who died in the motor accident was
pillion riding on the fateful day, challenging the award passed
by the Tribunal on 23.10.2013 in O.P.(MV) No.323/2009 to the
extent the Tribunal finds contributory negligence on the rider
of the motorcycle, fixes 50% liability on him for causing the
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:6:-
motor accident and the insurer to pay 50% of `17,51,000/-,
the compensation arrived at.
3.
MACA Nos.681/2014 and 682/2014 were filed by
the supplemental 6th respondent, the insurer of the car bearing
Registration No.KL-57-1034 in OP (MV) Nos.323/2009 and
172/2009, challenging only the quantum of compensation
stood awarded by the Tribunal in favour of the petitioners
who
are
the
legal
representatives
of
Mr.Fahad
and
Mr.Mohammed Afsal respectively who died as a result of the
injuries sustained by them in the motor accident occurred at
about 3 p.m. on 10.03.2009 at Kommayad. No challenge was
raised in the above appeals against the motor accident and the
liability fixed by the Tribunal on them.
4.
MACA
No.3852/2017
was
filed
by
the
legal
representatives of Mr.Mohammed Afsal who died on account of
the injuries sustained in the motor accident challenging the
mode of calculation adopted by the Tribunal and the quantum
of
compensation
stood
awarded
by
it
in
O.P.
(MV)No.172/2010 in their favour and finding of negligence on
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:7:-
the deceased
and fixation of 50% as his contribution to the
motor accident.
5.
Since MACA Nos.682/2014 and 3852/2017
were
filed by the insurer of the car (6th respondent) and the
petitioners respectively in O.P.(MV)No.172/2010 challenging
the award, those are considered together first.
6.
The motor accident in question which caused the
cause of action for preferring the claims for compensation was
occurred on 10.03.2009 at about 3:00 p.m. at Kommayad.
The driver of the car bearing Registration No.KL-57/1034
proceeding towards Panamaram side applied break all on
a
sudden
without
signal
proceeding
behind
it
and
thereby
the
motorcycle
hit on it’s rear side and thereby the
rider and the pillion rider of the motorcycle fell on the
road.
A tipper lorry bearing Registration No.KL-12C/7902
proceeding against,
ran over the rider as well as the pillion
rider and thereby they sustained fatal injuries.
Both the
injured died at the spot of accident itself. The motor accident
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:8:-
was alleged as occurred due to the rash and negligent driving
by the drivers of the tipper lorry bearing Registration No.KL12C-7902 and the car bearing Registration No.KL-57/1034
respectively.
7.
The
Tribunal
has
fixed
50%
contribution
of
negligence for the rider of the motorcycle towards the motor
accident. The fixation of 50% negligence on him was based
on the
oral
evidence
ocular witness.
let
in
by
PW2
claiming to be an
He had also stated during examination that
the car overtook the motorcycle and stopped in front of it
to avoid a ditch that exists on the road. The Tribunal found
that
the
petitioners
in O.P.(MV) No.172/2010
raised such a claim and
have
not
therefore the version of PW2, as
against their claim. The Tribunal having read the narration in
the scene mahazar
Ext.A2,
marked
in evidence in the case as
found the presence of a ditch on the road,
meters away from the accident spot on the eastern
but 4
side
of
the road. The measurement of the ditch was also described
in
Ext.A2
as
1.3 metres
long,
80 cm wide
and
20 cm
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:9:-
deep. From the description, it could also be seen that both
the car and the
motorcycle
were
proceeding
though
the
eastern side of the road at the relevant time.
8.
The chargesheet was marked in the case as Ext.A4
without contest. It is found that contra evidence was not
adduced by the insurer against Ext.A4, by which the driver of
the tipper lorry bearing Registration No.Kl 12C/7902 as well as
the driver of the car stood chargesheeted for rash and
negligent driving. The investigating officer was not examined
to establish any collusion behind chargesheeting the driver of
the tipper lorry and the car for rash and negligent driving.
Though it was contended by the insurer of the tipper lorry in
the written statement filed that the driver of the tipper lorry
was not negligent in driving it at the relevant time, failed to
establish that.
Even on a consideration of the evidence on
record, this Court finds that the driver of the tipper lorry if had
exercised reasonable care could have avoided the running of
the same over the victims of the motor accident. It is stated in
the final report filed and marked in evidence as Ext.A4 (copy of
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:10:-
which is Ext.B1)
that prior to stopping the car, the driver
failed to show signal. Accordingly the Tribunal found that the
driver who stopped the car (R4) without signal, responsible for
causing the motor accident. The Tribunal observed that if the
4th respondent had exercised vigilance and reasonable care
expected from a driver at the relevant time, the accident could
have been averted by him. This Court is hesitant to take a
view contrary to that taken by the Tribunal. The view of the
Tribunal undoubtedly is justified for the reason that the police
after investigation has also laid a final report chargesheeting
the driver of the car for rash and negligent driving and it
formed part of the evidence as a document uncontested by the
insurer while marking.
uncontested final
report
It is an indisputable factum that an
will form prima facie evidence of
negligence in claims relating to motor accident. Therefore, it
cannot be overlooked by the Tribunal. The Tribunal found 50%
contribution
of
negligence
from
the
driver of the car
towards the motor accident. On the strength of the evidence
available, this Court finds every reason to maintain that. The
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:11:-
challenge raised by the 6th respondent in MACA No.682/2014
against fixation of 50% liability on them is repelled for the
reasons.
9.
The rider of the motorcycle was found fastened with
negligence without basis.
Abated chargesheet was also not
laid against him. Even going by the oral evidence of PW2 also
it
is
noticed
that the alleged ditch
exists on the road 4
meters ahead the place of the motor accident. Therefore, it is
difficult to believe that the driver stopped the car all on a
sudden to avoid the ditch on the road.
The Tribunal
undoubtedly unjustified in fixing liability on the rider of the
motorcycle from whose death in the motor accident, the claim
for compensation in OP(MV) No.172/2010 was originated. The
finding of 50% negligence on the rider of the motor cycle,
fixing of entitlement of the petitioners in OP(MV) No.172 of
2010 to receive only 50% of the total compensation arrived at
as payable and fastening of liability on the insurer of the
motorcycle to pay 50% contribution to the petitioners in
OP(MV) No.323 of 2009 are only to be set aside and this Court
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:12:-
do so.
10.
Then the next question to be dealt with is the
reasonableness of the quantum stood awarded by the Tribunal
as compensation
in O.P.(MV) No.172/2010
in favour of the
legal representatives of Mr.Mohammed Afsal who died in the
motor accident.
11.
Petitioners in O.P.(MV) No.172/2010 are the parents
and siblings of Mr.Mohammed Afsal who died in the motor
accident. Dispute is not found raised by the respondents in the
Original Petition against the claim of the petitioners that
Mr.Mohammed Afsal died in the motor accident occurred on
10.03.2009. The factum is also established from Exts.A1, A4
and A5.
The relationship of petitioners with the deceased is
also established from Ext.A6. Evidence is also let into establish
that petitioners 3 and 4, who are sisters of the deceased are
married and staying
away with their husbands.
Therefore,
petitioners 1 and 2 alone are the legal heirs of the deceased,
entitled to get compensation.
The factum also remains that
Mr.Mohammed Afsal was a bachelor at the relevant time of his
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:13:-
death. The notional income of the deceased was fixed by the
Tribunal as `3,000/-.
As per the claim of petitioners in the
Original Petition the deceased was a student cum tutor at the
relevant time of the motor accident. He was aged 19 years at
that point of time. Though the deceased was pleaded by the
petitioners in the Original Petition as a tutor, no evidence was
adduced by them to establish so and the monthly income
earned by him. However, since the deceased at the relevant
time of his death was aged 19 years, there is every possibility
for him to obtain a job within 2-3 years. When viewed in that
angle, the fixation of `3,000/- notionally as monthly income is
on the lowerside. This Court finds it appropriate to refix it as
`7,000/-. Deceased being a bachelor at the relevant time of
his death, half of the monthly income is liable to be deducted
having due regard to the expenditure, he would have spent to
meet his personal needs had he been alive. The Tribunal has
applied it correctly.
Multiplier of 18 was also adopted by it.
The Tribunal had also considered 40% addition to the monthly
income towards loss of future prosepcts having due regard to
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:14:-
the age of the deceased and his untimely death in the motor
accident.
That being
correctly considered is maintained.
Compensation for loss of dependency is re-calculated on the
basis of the modified monthly income and thus, `10,58,400/is arrived at.
12.
It is found that `25,000/- and `5,000/- respectively
were awarded
by the Tribunal as compensation towards
funeral expenses and loss of estate against the direction of the
Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in National Insurance
Co.Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi and others [2017 (4) KLT 662(SC)]
to pay `15,000/- each. Therefore, `15,000/- each is awarded
under the above heads.
13.
`1,00,000/-
was also awarded by the Tribunal
towards loss of love and affection, for which the petitioners are
not entitled to.
On the contrary petitioners 1 and 2 are
entitled to get `40,000/- each as compensation towards loss of
consortium and thus `80,000/- is arrived at.
`1,000/- was
awarded by the Tribunal towards transportation expenses and
it being reasonable is maintained.
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:15:-
14.
In the fresh calculation as above, petitioners are
entitled to get `11,69,400/- as total compensation in the place
of `6,17,000/- stood awarded by the Tribunal.
7.5% was
found fixed by the Tribunal as interest and it being reasonable
is maintained.
Thus
M.A.C.A. No.3852/2017 and M.A.C.A.
No.682/2014 are allowed in part.
15. MACA Nos .619/2014 and 681/2014 are originated
from the award pased by the Tribunal in OP(MV) No.323/09
and the challenge against is respectively to the extent of
fixation of 50% negligence each on the rider of the motorcycle
and the driver of the car and 50% liability on the insurers of
those.
Challenge was also raised against the quantum of
compensation in both appeals.
16. OP(MV) No.323/2009 was a claim petition preferred
before
the
Tribunal
by
the
petitioners
who
are
legal
representatives of Mr. Fahad who was on the pillion seat of the
Motorcycle bearing Registration No.KL-11/Z-9402 and died
due to the injuries sustained in the motor accident occurred on
10.03.2009.
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:16:-
17.
As per the claims of the petitioners in OP(MV)
No.323/2009, Mr.Fahad was aged 23 years and employed as
salesman in a supermarket at Sharjah. The salary certificate
was marked in evidence as Ext.A12. Ext.A12 was found issued
by one Mr.Abdulla in his capacity as Manager of a company
named 'Hital Al Madina Supermarket, L.L.C, Sharjah, UAE. The
so called manager was not examined and therefore, Ext.A12
was marked subject to proof. The passport of the deceased is
marked in evidence as Ext.A13 and it shows that the petitioner
was at Sharjah at the relevant time of the motor accident. The
1st petitioner, who is none other than the father of Mr.Fahad
also deposed accordingly as PW1. Therefore, the claim of the
petitioners that the deceased was employed at Sharjah is only
to be accepted.
18.
In the absence of any evidence regarding the nature
of the job and the monthly income received by the deceased at
the
relevant
time,
the
Tribunal opted to
notionally as his monthly income.
fix
`10,000/-
The insurer has raised a
challenge against addition of 50% to the monthly income by
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:17:-
the Tribunal towards loss of future prospects for the reason
that petitioner was not proved as a person employed with fixed
salary.
It stands established from Ext.A13 that Mr.Fahad had
been working abroad since long. Therefore, he can be considered
as a permanent employee. He was aged below 40 years also.
Therefore, there is nothing wrong in the Tribunal fixing 50%
addition to the monthly income fixed in consideration of loss of
future prospects and that is maintained. Multiplier of 18 adopted
by the Tribunal is also maintained being correct. Therefore, this
Court finds that compensation for loss of dependency wa s
calculated
correctly
and
`16,20,000/-
arrived
at
as
`25,000/-
and
compensation is a reasonable sum.
19.
It
is
noticed
that
`1,00,000/-,
`5,000/- were awarded by the Tribunal respectively as
compensation towards loss of love and affection, funeral
expenses and loss of estate . Compensation was not awarded
by the Tribunal towards loss of consortium though the
deceased was survived by his father and mother. Sisters are
not entitled to get compensation towards los s of consortium or
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:18:-
loss of love and affection.
Father and mother are also not
entitled to get compensation towards loss of love and affection.
Therefore,
`1,00,000/- stood awarded towards loss of love
and affection is deducted.
20.
As per Pranay Sethi supra, petitioners are entitled
to get `15,000/- each as compensation towards funeral
expenses and loss of estate and `40,000/- each, towards loss
of
consortium.
Therefore,
compensation
accordingly under the above heads.
is
awarded
`1,000/- stood awarded
by the Tribunal towards transportation expenses is maintained.
Thus
the
petitioners
(`16,20,000/-
+
are
`1,000/-
entitled
+
to
`15,000/-
get
`17,31,000/-
+
`15,000/-
+
`80,000/-) as the modified compensation and the same is
payable to the petitioners in OP(MV) No.323/2009, in the place
of `17,51,000/- stood awarded by the Tribunal. Interest rate
fixed
by
the
Tribunal as 7.5% being reasonable is
maintained.
21.
The Tribunal has fixed 50% as the contribution of
the rider of the motorcycle bearing registration No. KL-11/Z-
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:19:-
9402 involved in the motor accident and thus found the
petitioners in OP(MV) No.323/2009, entitled to get only 50%
of the amount arrived at as compensation from the insurer of
the car, the 6th respondent.
22. In view of the reversal of liability of the rider of the
motorcycle and fixation of liability on the driver of the
tipper lorry, petitioners in OP(MV) No.323/2009 are entitled
to get the full amount now arrived at as compensation with
interest and costs.
172/2010 are
Similarly, the petitioners in OP(MV) No.
entitled
to
get compensation in the ratio
50:50 from the insurers of the car and the tipper lorry. The
appellants
in
MACA
Nos.682/2014
and
681/2014
(supplemental 6th respondent in OP(MV) No.323/2009) and the
3rd respondent in MACA No.3852/2017 (3rd respondent in
OP(MV) No.172/2010) shall deposit the compensation with
interest and costs in the ratio 50:50 in favour of petitioners
in OP(MV) No.172/2010, within a period of two months from
the date of receipt of a certified copy of this common
judgment. MACA No.3852/2017 being filed with a delay of
MACA Nos. 619, 681, 682 of 2014
and MACA No.3852 of 2017
-:20:-
1400 days,
the respondents are exonerated from paying
interest for that period. Compensation if any is already paid,
the Tribunal shall adjust the same in the sum payable.
In the result, all appeals are allowed in part.
Sd/MARY JOSEPH
JUDGE
ttb
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review