Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:30937
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
MONDAY, THE 7TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 17TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MACA NO. 2190 OF 2021
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 05.03.2021 IN OPMV NO.376 OF
2014 OF MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, ALAPPUZHA
APPELLANT/3RD RESPONDENT:
THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
KOLLAM, REPRESENTED BY ITS ADMINISTRATIVE
OFFICER, REGIONAL OFFICE, M.G. ROAD,
ERNAKULAM, PIN - 682011.
BY ADVS.
LAL K.JOSEPH
SURESH SUKUMAR
CHACKO MATHEWS K.
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS:
LATHA
VELUTHEDATHU PARAMBU, PUNNAPARA P.O, PUNNAPARA,
ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT - 688004.
ARJUN
VELUTHEDATHU PARAMBU, PUNNAPARA P.O, PUNNAPARA,
ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT - 688004.
ARAVIND
VELUTHEDATHU PARAMBU, PUNNAPARA P.O, PUNNAPARA,
ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT - 688004.
BY ADVS.
GEORGE VARGHESE(PERUMPALLIKUTTIYIL)
A.R.DILEEP
P.J.JOE PAUL
MANU SRINATH
THIS
MOTOR
ADMISSION
ACCIDENT
ON
CLAIMS
07.04.2025,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
APPEAL
THE
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
SAME
DAY
MACA No.2190/2021
2025:KER:30937
EASWARAN S., J
.....................................
MACA No.2190 of 2021
...................................…
Dated this the 7th day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
This appeal is preferred by the Insurance Company against
the award passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal,
Alappuzha, in O.P.(MV)No.376/2014.
2.
The brief facts necessary for the disposal of the
appeal are as follows:
The claimants are the legal representatives of deceased
Biju, who succumbed to the injuries in a motor vehicle accident
on 12.02.2014 at about 7.30 pm, while the deceased was riding
a motorcycle bearing Reg.No.KL-04/X-1139 from east to west
along the Alappuzha-Changanacherry public road and when the
motor bike reached near Pallathuruthy Bridge, it hit against a
mini
lorry
bearing
Reg.No.KL-05/Z-466
respondent in the claim petition.
driven
by
the
1 st
The allegation in the claim
petition was that the lorry was parked towards west at the
MACA No.2190/2021
2025:KER:30937
southern side of the road dangerously without glowing the
parking light or any signal. The collision took place due to the
darkness in the area and in the absence of an indication or signal
near the rear portion of the vehicle.
3.
The claimants contended that the driver of the mini
lorry is solely negligent for the accident.
The
appellant -
Insurance Company appeared and contested the case and raised
a specific objection regarding the finding of negligence on the
part of the driver of the vehicle in the final report.
It was
contended that deceased Biju ought to have maintained a safe
distance while driving the motorcycle and it was contended that
even if the negligence on the part of the driver was found, the
rider of the motorcycle equally contributed towards the accident
and thus the contributory negligence on the part of the deceased
Biju should also be fastened.
4.
The Tribunal, on consideration of the materials on
record, found that the lorry was unauthorizedly parked on the
road in contravention of Regulation 5 and 22 of the Motor
Vehicles (Driving) Regulations, 2017 and proceeded to allow the
claim petition by granting the following compensation:
MACA No.2190/2021
2025:KER:30937
Sl. Head of Claim
No
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
g)
h)
PART - I
Transport to hospital including ambulance
charges
Damage to clothing and articles
Funeral expenses & miscellaneous
PART -II
Compensation for pain and sufferings
Compensation for loss of love and affection
Compensation for loss of consortium
Compensation for loss of dependency
Compensation for loss of estate
Total
5.
Amount
Claimed
Amount
Awarded
7,000/-
Not allowed
1,000/35,000/-
Not allowed
16,500/-
30,000/20,000/1,00,000/52,00,000/20,000/54,13,000/(claim is
limited to
Rs.50,00,000/-)
25,000/Not allowed
1,32,000/42,45,766/16,500/44,35,766/-
Aggrieved by the fastening of the liability on the
appellant - Insurance Company, the present appeal is preferred.
6.
Heard, Sri.Lal.K.Joseph – learned counsel appearing
for the appellant - Insurance Company and Sri.P.J.Joe Paul –
learned counsel appearing for the claimants.
7.
On a consideration of the rival submissions raised
across the Bar, this Court is of the considered view that the
appellant has not made out a case for interference in the present
appeal.
8.
The finding rendered by the Tribunal in paragraph 8 of
the impugned award is extracted as follows:
MACA No.2190/2021
2025:KER:30937
“These issues are considered jointly for convenience. The
learned counsel appearing for the insurer submitted that
the motorcyclist was rash and negligent in riding the
motor-cycle. Admittedly, the motor-cycle hit at the back of
a stationary lorry parked on the road. It is the case of the
petitioners that the 1st respondent who was the driver of
the lorry had unauthorizedly parked the vehicle on the
road in Contravention of Regulations 5 and 22 of Motor
Vehicles (Driving) Regulations, 2017. The investigating
officer, after the collection of evidence, laid charge sheet
before
the
Judicial
Magistrate
of
the
First
Class,
Ramankary stating the offences committed by the 1 st
respondent
u/s.283
and
304A
IPC.
The
contesting
respondent did not adduce any evidence to prove contrary
to charge sheet prepared by the police. There is primafacie
evidence of the obstruction of lorry by the 1 st respondent
in the public way. In Philip.P.Mathew and Another v.
Regional Transport Authority and Others (2019(4)
КНС 490), the Hon'ble High Court of Kerala held that the
driver of a motor vehicle has to ensure that his vehicle,
when stationary, does not cause any hindrance or undue
inconvenience to other road users or occupants of any
properties; and no vehicle shall be parked in front of the
entrance or exit of a property. The facts and circumstance
of the case clearly indicate rashness and negligence on the
part of the 1st respondent while driving the lorry bearing
registration No. KL-05/Z-466 on the public road.”
MACA No.2190/2021
2025:KER:30937
9.
Tribunal
On a perusal of the above findings, it is clear that the
has
entered
a
factual
finding
regarding
the
contravention of Regulations 5 and 22 of the Motor Vehicles
(Driving)Regulations, 2017, inasmuch as there was no evidence
before the Tribunal to the effect that the driver of the vehicle
had parked the lorry with the parking lights on, this Court cannot
overturn the findings based on the final report Ext.A6. It is now
settled law that the final report is a prima facie evidence
regarding the negligence, while considering the claim under
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
Of course, the
presumption is rebuttable. In the facts of the present case, this
Court hastens to add that the Insurance Company did not take
any steps to discharge the burden.
Having not done so, the
appellant cannot be heard to contend that the Tribunal ought to
have fastened contributory negligence on the side of deceased
Biju. Therefore, the inevitable consequences is that the appeal
preferred by the Insurance Company has to fail. Accordingly, the
same is dismissed.
10.
However, having said so, when the impugned award
is carefully scrutinized, it becomes evident that procedure
adopted by the Tribunal for fixation of the income is completely
MACA No.2190/2021
2025:KER:30937
erroneous inasmuch as the Tribunal failed to consider the
relevant
precedents on the point. It is indisputable that
deceased Biju was a Police Constable attached to Nedumudy
Police Station. Ext.A8 was produced to prove the salary of the
deceased and the deceased was drawing a sum of Rs.30,162/per month.
The Tribunal, after noticing the said fact, had
deducted the amount paid by the deceased towards the GPF,
LIC, SLI, GIS and FBS.
The Tribunal also made a further
deduction of 10% towards the probable income tax that is
required to be paid by the deceased. The deductions made by
the Tribunal are as follows:
DEDUCTION
GPF
LIC
SLI
GIS
FBS
TAX
2,00,000/3,16,688 – 2,00,000
1,16,688X10%
11,668X3% (Cess)
Total
11.
2000X12
1203X12
150X12
200X12
10X12
TOTAL
=24,000/=14,436/=1,800/=2,400/=120/42,756/-
= NIL
= 1,16,688/= 11,668/= 350/=12,018/-
The question as to whether the aforesaid deductions
could stand scrutiny of law has been considered by this Court in
MACA No.2190/2021
2025:KER:30937
Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd. v. Bindu [2025
KHC 228], wherein after scanning the entire case law on the
point, this Court held that the tax that is payable by the claimant
or the victim, cannot be deducted by the Tribunal while
computing the income. Similarly, the deductions in the form of
payment towards GPF, LIC and other deductions being personal
in nature, are also not liable to be deducted from the income.
This leads to the inevitable conclusion that the income fixed by
the Tribunal is incorrect which calls for interference.
12.
However,
when
the
appeal
was
taken
up
for
consideration earlier it was noticed that the claimants had not
preferred any cross objections. However, today when the matter
is being considered, learned counsel for the claimants pointed
out that a cross objection is preferred, though belatedly. Though
the learned counsel for the Insurance Company opposed the plea
of the cross objection being considered, in the light of the settled
position
in
Reliance
General
Insurance
Company
Ltd.
(supra), wherein this Court in similar case had invoked the
provisions of Order XLl Rule 33 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 and enhanced the compensation, the absence of the cross
objection on the side of the claimants is not much of a
MACA No.2190/2021
2025:KER:30937
consequence.
Accordingly, this Court finds that the objection
raised on behalf of the Insurance Company that without the
cross objection, this Court cannot enhance the quantum of
compensation in the appeal preferred by the Insurance Company
is hereby rejected. Accordingly, while dismissing the appeal, this
Court is of the view that compensation that was structured by
the Tribunal requires to be modified as follows:
Heads
Amount awarded
by the Tribunal
Total
compensation
awarded in
appeal
Enhanced amount
of compensation
Income of deceased Biju is taken as 30,162/- per month.
After deducting the
provisional tax liable to be paid by the deceased at Rs.2,500/- per year, the
monthly income of the deceased is fixed at Rs.29,954/-.
The claimants are also
entitled for 30% future prospects. Thus, the income would come to Rs.38,940/-.
Compensation for
loss of dependency
42,45,766/-
43,61,280/1,15,514/[38940x12x14x2/3] [43612804245766]
Total enhanced amount of compensation
Accordingly,
the
claimant
1,15,514/-
is
awarded
an
additional
compensation of Rs.1,15,514/- (Rupees One lakh fifteen thousand
five hundred and fourteen only) over and above the compensation
awarded by the Tribunal with interest 6% per annum from the date
of the application till realization together with proportionate costs.
The interest in the above rate is awarded since the enhancement is
MACA No.2190/2021
2025:KER:30937
being granted by exercising the power under Order XVl Rule 33.
The Insurance Company is directed to deposit the aforesaid amount
within a period of 2 months from the date of receipt of a copy of
this judgment.
The appeal is accordingly dismissed.
Sd/-
EASWARAN S.
JUDGE
ACR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review