The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. At this stage, it is to be noted that at the time of accident i.e., in the year 2011, the income of claimant ought to have been taken at ₹.8,000 per month as per the Gazette Notification No.S.O.1258/(E), dated 31.05.201, but the Commissioner has taken it at ₹.4,500/- which is erroneous. Hence, the compensation awarded by Commissioner is to be modified as follows: ₹.8,000/- x 60% x 184.17 x 8% = ₹.70,721/24. For the above reasons, I pass the following: (i) The appeal is allowed in part. (ii) The judgment and award passed by the Labour Officer and Commissioner for Workmen’s Compensation, Sub-Division-I, the - 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:214 MFA No. 22200 of 2013 HC-KAR Belagavi in Case No.KAPAKA/SR-16/2012 dated 20.02.2013 is modified. The claimant is entitled to a total compensation of ₹.70,721/- as against ₹.1,24,314/- awarded by the Commissioner with interest at the rate of 12% p.a. after 30 days from the date of accident till realization. (iii) Respondent No.2-Insurance Company shall deposit the compensation amount with accrued interest before the Commissioner, within eight weeks from the date of receipt of certified copy of this judgment. (iv) Registry is directed to transfer the amount in deposit, if any, to the Commissioner. The Commissioner is directed to refund the excess amount, if any, appellant/Insurance Company. to the - 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:214 MFA No. 22200 of 2013 HC-KAR (v) S…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 9TH DAY OF JANUARY 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 22200 OF 2013 (WC)
BETWEEN:
THE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED,
RAMADEV GALLI, BELGAUM,
R/BY DEPUTY MANAGER,
THE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED,
REGIONAL OFFICE, KUSUGAL ROAD, HUBLI.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. S.V. YAJI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN
KATTIMANI
CHANDRASHEKAR
LAXMAN KATTIMANI
Location: HIGHCOURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
1.
YALLAPPA TOLE S/O. SHIVAPPA,
AGE: 39 YEARS, OCC: COOLIE,
R/O. KANCHAKAR WADI,
TQ: RAIBAG, DIST: BELGAUM.
2.
RAVI BHIMAPPA METHRI,
S/O. C. BHIMAPPA,
AGE: 33 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS,
R/O. VIDYANAGAR, RAIBAG,
TQ: RAIBAG & DIST: BELGAUM.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. K. ANANDKUMAR, ADVOCATE FOR C/R1;
NOTICE TO R2 IS SERVED)
THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 30(1) OF WORKMEN
COMPENSATION ACT PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE RECORDS IN
NO.WCA/SR-16/2012 ON THE FILE OF THE LABOUR OFFICER
AND COMMISSIONER FOR WORKMEN COMPENSATION, SUBDIVISION-I, BELGAUM DISTRICT. BELAGAUM; PRAYING TO SET
ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND ORDER DATED 20.02.2013 PASSED
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
BY THE LABOUR OFFICER AND COMMISSIONER FOR WORKMEN
COMPENSATION,
SUB-DIVISION-I,
BELGAUM
DISTRICT
BELGAUM IN NO.WCA/SR-16/2012 SADDLING THE LIABILITY
AGAINST THIS APPELLANT AND ETC.,
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
This is the appeal filed by the Insurer under Section
30(1) of Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 challenging
the judgment and award passed by the Labour Officer and
Commissioner for Workmen’s Compensation, Sub-DivisionI,
Belagavi
(for
short,
‘Commissioner’)
in
Case
No.KAPAKA/SR-16/2012 dated 20.02.2013.
2.
Parties would be referred with their ranks, as
they were before Commissioner for the sake of convenience
and clarity.
3.
The claimant has filed the claim petition before
the Commissioner contending that he sustained accident
while discharging his duty as employee under respondent
No.1 on 24.02.2011 at about 02.30 p.m. while he was
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
leveling the sugarcane in the trailer attached to the tractor
bearing No.KA-23/TA/6493 and No.KA-23/TA/6494. His
contention is that before the accident he was working as
coolie under first respondent, thus there was employer and
employee relationship between first respondent and the
claimant; claimant was getting income of ₹.8,000/- per
month and he was aged about 30 years at the time of
accident. Due to the accident, the claimant sustained
fracture of left calcaneum with tendo Achilles rupture and
thus sustained disability and unable to work as he was
working earlier and thus prayed for compensation of
₹.10,00,000/- with 12% interest.
4.
After receipt of notice of the claim petition, first
respondent appeared through his counsel and filed his
objection statement, wherein he admitted the relationship
of employer and employee between him and the claimant
and also admitted about the accident, but denied about the
nature of injuries sustained by the claimant. Further he
contended that his tractor-trailers are duly insured with
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
respondent No.2 and thus respondent No.2 is liable to pay
compensation.
5.
Respondent No.2 appeared through its counsel
and filed its objection statement, wherein it denied all the
averments made in the petition including the employer and
employee relationship. Further, it contented that the tractor
was duly insured with respondent No.2 as on the date of
accident, but trailer was not insured and thus it is not liable
to pay the compensation.
6.
On behalf of claimant, claimant was examined as
P.W.1 apart from examining the doctor, who treated him as
P.W.2, got marked Exs.P.1 to P.6 and closed his side before
the Commissioner. On behalf of respondents, respondent
No.1 was examined as R.W.2 and on behalf of respondent
No.2, the officer of respondent No.2 is examined as R.W.1
and got marked Exs.R.1 and R.2 and closed their side.
7.
After recording evidence of sides and hearing
arguments of both sides, the Commissioner has allowed the
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
claim
petition
employee
holding
relationship
that
there
between
was
employer
respondent
No.1
and
and
claimant and claimant has suffered injury at the time of
discharging
his
duty
as
employee/workman
under
respondent No.1 and he has suffered 25% disability and
thus awarded compensation of ₹.1,24,314/- with interest at
12% per annum.
8.
Aggrieved
by
the
said
judgment,
the
appellant/insurer has filed this appeal.
9.
Heard arguments of both sides.
10.
Learned counsel for appellant, Sri S.V.Yaji would
submit that the injured/claimant was not employee under
respondent No.1 in respect of insured vehicle; the trailer in
question was not insured with respondent No.2 and thus
respondent
No.2
is
not
liable
to
make
payment
of
compensation; the disability assessed by the doctor is at
25% to the left lower limb and thus the Commissioner
ought to have taken the disability to whole body at 8%, but
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
25% taken by him is excess and thus it needs interference.
Hence, prayed for allowing the appeal.
11.
Learned
counsel
for
respondent
No.1,
Sri
K.Anandkumar would submit that there is clear employer
and employee relationship between respondent No.1 and
the claimant and it is in categorical terms admitted by
respondent No.1 in his objection statement as well as in his
oral evidence. Hence, the relationship between claimant and
respondent No.1 is established. He would further submit
that the trailer in question was also insured with respondent
No.2 as per the insurance policy produced by respondent
No.2.
12.
Learned
counsel for respondent No.1
would
further submit that question of determination of disability is
a question of fact and that cannot be entertained in the
appeal. In this regard, he relied on the judgment of Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of Golla Rajanna vs. The
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
Divisional Manager and Another reported in 2017 (1)
G.L.H. 150.
13.
Having heard the arguments of both sides and
upon verifying the appeal papers along with Trial Court
records, the following substantial questions of law would
arise for consideration:
1.
Whether the appellant/insurer would establish
that there is no employer and employee relationship
between respondent No.1 and claimant?
2.
Whether the trailer in question was not
insured with respondent No.2?
3.
Whether the assessment of disability to the
whole body based on disability certificate issued by
the doctor by the Commissioner is erroneous?
14.
Answer to substantial questions of law No.1 and
2 is in the negative and substantial question of law No.3 is
in the affirmative for the following:
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
REASONS
15.
The contention of claimant is that he along with
10-12 employees had been to the lands of Vijaya Maruthi
Poojery on 24.02.2011 and then they have harvested the
sugarcane and at about 04.00 p.m., they have loaded the
harvested sugarcane to trailers bearing No.KA-23/TA-6494,
KA-23/TA-6495to attached to the tractor bearing No.KA23/TA-6493 and they belonged to respondent No.1-Ravi
Bhimappa Metri and then he was leveling the sugarcane in
the trailer; at that time the sickle in his hand slipped from
his hand and fell on his left ankle and caused bleeding
injury to him and then he was got admitted to the hospital
by respondent No.1 and then he has taken treatment as
inpatient from 24.02.2011 to 10.03.2011 and he sustained
compound fracture of left Calcaneum with tendo Achilles
rupture and the doctor has issued disability certificate that
he sustained disability of 25% to left lower limb.
16.
It is the contention of the respondent No.2 that
the claimant had been to the lands of Vijaya Maruthi
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
Poojery for harvesting the sugarcane and thus he was
employed by Vijaya Maruthi Poojery and not by respondent
No.1. However, it is admitted by respondent No.1 that he
has hired the claimant for harvesting the sugarcane in the
lands of Vijaya Maruthi Poojery because he was running
Jaggery manufacturing unit and he required the sugarcane
for said unit. When there is such a categorical admission
from the side of respondent No.1 that he has engaged the
claimant as his employee on said date for the purpose of
loading and unloading and leveling the sugarcane in the
trailer, insurer is debarred from contending that the
claimant is employee under respondent No.1 unless he
establishes fraud, misrepresentation or collusion between
claimant and respondent No.1, which is not the contention
of respondent No.2. Hence, rightly the Commissioner has
come to the conclusion that respondent No.1 is employer
and claimant is employee under respondent No.1 at the
time of accident.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
17.
The
second
contention
raised
by
the
appellant/insurer is that the tractor in question was insured
with the respondent No.2 and trailer in question is not
insured with him. In this regard, he has produced the
insurance policy as per Ex.R.4.
18.
On perusal of Ex.R.4, as on the date of accident
there was valid insurance policy. According to it, the tractor
bearing No.KA-23/TA-6493 was insured with respondent No
2, in that first page, the value of vehicle is shown as
₹.5,15,302/- and value of trailer is shown as ₹.4,56,000/and the total value of the insured vehicle is shown as
₹.9,71,302/- and in the second page, the trailer number is
shown as KA-23/TA-6494, which is involved in the present
case and it is for non-agricultural purpose and thus Ex.R.4
clearly and categorically establishes that both tractor and
trailer involved in this case are insured with respondent
No.2 and there was valid insurance for both tractor and
trailer; including both the value of tractor and trailer the
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
premium was collected. Hence, this contention of insurer is
also not tenable.
19.
The
third
contention
taken
by
the
appellant/insurer is that as per the disability certificate
issued by the doctor, the disability is 25% to the left lower
limb and thus the Commissioner ought to have taken 1/3rd
of said disability to the whole body i.e., 8% at the time of
assessing the compensation.
20.
Learned counsel for respondent No.1 vehemently
submitted his arguments that the determination of disability
is a question of fact and it cannot be gone into in the
appeal. In this regard, he relied on Golla Rajanna’s case
(supra), wherein it is held as under:
“10. The Workmen’s Compensation Commissioner,
having regard to the evidence, had returned a finding on
the nature of injury and the percentage of disability. It is
purely a question of fact. There is no case for the
insurance company that the finding is based on no
evidence at all or that it is perverse. Under Section
4(1)(c)(ii) of the Act, the percentage of permanent
disability needs to be assessed only by a qualified medical
practitioner. There is no case for the respondents that the
doctor who issued the disability certificate is not a qualified
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
medical practitioner, as defined under the Act. Thus, the
Workmen’s Compensation Commissioner has passed the
order based on the certificate of disability issued by the
doctor and which has been duly proved before the
Workmen’s Compensation Commissioner.
11. Under the scheme of the Act, the Workmen’s
Compensation Commissioner is the last authority on facts.
The Parliament has thought it fit to restrict the scope of
the appeal only to substantial questions of law, being a
welfare legislation. Unfortunately, the High Court has
missed this crucial question of limited jurisdiction and has
ventured to re-appreciate the evidence and recorded its
own findings on percentage of disability for which also
there is no basis. The whole exercise made by the High
Court is not within the competence of the High Court under
Section 30 of the Act.”
21.
On careful perusal of the principles laid down by
the Hon'ble Apex Court in the aforesaid judgment, it is clear
that the determination of disability is a question of fact and
cannot be gone into in the appeal.
22.
In the instant case, the question of disability is
not questioned by the appellant, but he is questioning only
the way of considering said disability. Always, 1/3rd of
disability assessed by the doctor to particular limb is to be
taken to the whole body. This is a point of law and not the
question of fact. But, in the instant case the Commissioner
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
has taken the disability of particular limb as disability to the
whole
body,
which
is
incorrect.
Hence,
it
requires
interference.
23.
At this stage, it is to be noted that at the time of
accident i.e., in the year 2011, the income of claimant
ought to have been taken at ₹.8,000 per month as per the
Gazette Notification No.S.O.1258/(E), dated 31.05.201, but
the Commissioner has taken it at ₹.4,500/- which is
erroneous. Hence, the
compensation
awarded by
Commissioner is to be modified as follows:
₹.8,000/- x 60% x 184.17 x 8% = ₹.70,721/24.
For the above reasons, I pass the following:
ORDER
(i)
The appeal is allowed in part.
(ii)
The judgment and award passed by the
Labour
Officer
and
Commissioner
for
Workmen’s Compensation, Sub-Division-I,
the
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
Belagavi in Case No.KAPAKA/SR-16/2012
dated 20.02.2013 is modified. The claimant
is entitled to a total compensation of
₹.70,721/-
as
against
₹.1,24,314/-
awarded by the Commissioner with interest
at the rate of 12% p.a. after 30 days from
the date of accident till realization.
(iii) Respondent No.2-Insurance Company shall
deposit
the
compensation
amount
with
accrued interest before the Commissioner,
within eight weeks from the date of receipt
of certified copy of this judgment.
(iv) Registry is directed to transfer the amount
in deposit, if any, to the Commissioner. The
Commissioner is directed to refund the
excess
amount,
if
any,
appellant/Insurance Company.
to
the
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:214
MFA No. 22200 of 2013
HC-KAR
(v)
Send back the records along with a copy of
this judgment and award to the Labour
Officer and Commissioner for Workmen’s
Compensation, Sub-Division-I, Belagavi.
(vi) No order as to costs.
(vii) Draw modified award accordingly.
Sd/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
SH
CT-MCK
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 4
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review