Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:28555
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. NITIN JAMDAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.MANU
TUESDAY, THE 1ST DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 11TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 2105 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 29.11.2024 IN WP(C)
NO.30694 OF 2024 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
THE MUPPATHADAM SERVICE CO-OPERATIVE BANK
LTD.NO.E-216, MUPPATHADAM.P.O., ALUVA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, PIN – 683 110
BY ADVS.
APARNA RAJAN
P.RAVINDRAN (SR.)
LAKSHMI RAMADAS
M.R.SABU
P.DEEPAK (SR.)
SREEDHAR RAVINDRAN
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
THE STATE CHIEF INFORMATION COMMISSIONER,
TC-14, 2071, PUNNEN ROAD,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695 001
THE JOINT REGISTRAR (GENERAL),
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES & FIRST APPEAL AUTHORITY,
5TH FLOOR, CIVIL STATION, KAKKANAD,
ERNAKULAM, PIN – 682 030
2025:KER:28555
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
THE STATE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER & DEPUTY
REGISTRAR (ADMINISTRATION) CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES,
5TH FLOOR, CIVIL STATION, KAKKANAD,
ERNAKULAM, PIN – 682 030
P.R.RAMACHANDRAN,
AGED 64 YEARS, S/O.P.K.RAMAN NAIR,729/20,
PUKKATTU HOUSE, MUPPATHADAM.P.O., ALUVA, PIN – 683
BY ADV P.R.RAMACHANDRAN,(Party-In-Person)
SRI.M. AJAY, SC
SRI.V. TEKCHAND, SR. G.P.
THIS
WRIT
APPEAL
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD
ON
19.2.2025, THE COURT ON 01.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28555
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
“C.R.”
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 1st day of April 2025
Nitin Jamdar, C.J.
The application made by a member of the Appellant Cooperative
Society under the Right to Information Act, 2005, for supplying a copy
of a resolution of the Society and details of a construction contract, the
State Chief Information Commissioner directed the Appellant Society to
furnish the information. The learned Single Judge dismissed the writ
petition filed by the Appellant Society challenging this direction. The
Appellant Society has now filed this appeal under Section 5 of the Kerala
High Court Act, 1958.
2.
The Appellant is a Cooperative Society registered under the Kerala
Cooperative Societies Act, 1969 (Act of 1969). Respondent No.4 is a
member of the Appellant Society. The Appellant Society had given a
contract for the construction of a building. Respondent No.4 approached
the Appellant Society seeking information in respect of an agreement
entered into by the Appellant Society and a Labour Contract Society and
also asking for copies of the minutes of the last general body meeting.
Since this was not given, Respondent No.4 filed an application on 14
January 2023 before Respondent No.3 / State Public Information
Officer, under Section 6 of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (RTI
Act). The Public Information Officer, by order dated 15 February 2023,
informed Respondent No.4 that the documents cannot be given.
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
Respondent No. 4 thereafter approached the Appellate Authority under
the RTI Act. The Appellate Authority disposed of the appeal on 8 May
2023. Respondent No.4 thereafter filed a second appeal before the State
Chief Information Commissioner, which was rejected by order dated 14
September 2023. Respondent No.4 challenged the order of the State
Chief Information Commissioner by filing W.P.(C)No.37938 of 2023.
The learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition by order dated 8
April 2024. Respondent No. 4 thereafter filed an appeal before the
Division Bench bearing No.729 of 2024. The Division Bench, after
considering the statutory provisions, observed that the State Chief
Information
Commissioner,
before
rejecting
the
application
of
Respondent No. 4, ought to have examined whether the information
sought by Respondent No. 4 will come within the scope of information
which the Registrar can access in the exercise of his powers under the Act
of 1969 and the Rules framed thereunder. Since this aspect was not
considered, the Division Bench set aside the orders passed by the learned
Single Judge and the order passed by the State Chief Information
Commissioner, and the appeal was directed to be reheard.
3.
The Chief Information Commissioner, on remand, considered the
appeal and concluded that the Registrar has supervisory and
administrative control over the Appellant Society. Therefore, the State
Public Information Officer can ask the Deputy Registrar of Cooperative
Societies/Respondent No.1 (Registrar) to call for the information from
the Appellant Society and furnish the same to Respondent No. 4. The
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
appeal was accordingly allowed by the Chief Information Commissioner
by order dated 17 August 2024.
4.
The Appellant Society filed W.P.(C)No. 30694 of 2024,
challenging the order dated 17 August 2024. The learned Single Judge
observed that if the Registrar of Cooperative Societies can access the
information sought by him from the Appellant Society, then the
information has to be given to Respondent No. 4 under the RTI Act.
Accordingly, the learned Single Judge found no reason to interfere with
the order passed by the State Chief Information Commissioner and
dismissed the writ petition by the impugned judgment dated 29
November 2024. Challenging this order, the present appeal has been
filed.
5.
We have heard Mr P. Ravindran, learned Senior Advocate for the
Appellant, Mr M. Ajay, learned Standing Counsel for the State
Information Commission, Mr V. Tekchand, learned Senior Government
Pleader for the State and Mr P.R. Ramachandran, party in person.
6.
The learned Senior Advocate for the Appellant Society in short
submitted as follows. A combined reading of Section 2(f) and Section 2(j)
would show that only that information which relates to a private body
which can be accessed by a public authority under any other law for the
time being in force can be treated as information and supply. The
Registrar under the Act of 1969 is a statutory authority, and he can access
only those documents that are enumerated under Section 66C of the Act
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
of 1969. Only those documents which are accessible to the Registrar
under Section 66 C of the Act of 1969 are held by him for the purpose of
the RTI Act. Rule 24 of the Kerala Cooperative Societies Rules, 1969,
pertains to the document and information in the access and control of the
Registrar. Section 66C of the Act of 1969 mandates a cooperative society
to file returns within six months of the closure of every financial year
before the Registrar containing the particulars mentioned in the subsections and provide any information the Registrar may require and
therefore, only these documents, i.e., under Sections 19B and 66C of the
Act of 1969 and Rule 24, would be the documents that can be considered
under the RTI Act. The right of a member of a cooperative society to get
information in respect of the functioning of the society is provided under
Section 19B of the Act of 1969, which only includes up-to-date copies of
the bye-laws, register of members, the latest audited balance sheet of the
society and the accounts of the society in so far as they relate to the
members' transactions. As per Section 4 of the RTI Act, only those
documents which are maintained, duly catalogued and indexed can be
considered as information under the RTI Act and, therefore, since there
are no documents which are with the Registrar of Cooperative Societies in
respect of the Appellant Society duly catalogued and indexed, they could
not be ordered to be furnished to Respondent No. 4. As regards the other
provisions, such as Sections 65 and 66 of the Act of 1969, they are only
meant for supervision and inspection of the affairs of the Society. These
powers are circumscribed by the condition laid down therein for invoking
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
the power. There is no enquiry under Section 65(6) of the Act of 1969
against the Appellant Society, and therefore, there is no question of
accessing any documents of the Appellant Society by the Registrar or the
Joint Registrar. The observations of the Division Bench in W.A.No.729
of 2024, dated 2 July 2024, have been completely misconstrued by
Respondent No.1 – Commissioner as a mandate to issue the information
when the observations made in the said decision support the contention
of the Appellant Society. Under the RTI Act, a direction can be issued to
an authority to furnish the documents, but there cannot be any direction
from another body to a statutory authority to access the documents that it
does not possess and hand them over to the Applicant. The learned
Senior Advocate for the Appellant placed reliance on the decisions of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Central Board of Secondary
Education and Another v. Aditya Bandopadhyay and Others 1,
Thalappalam Service Cooperative Bank Limited and Others v. State of
Kerala and Others2 and Central Public Information Officer, Supreme
Court of India v. Subhash Chandra Agarwal3.
7.
The learned counsel for Respondent No. 1 – Commissioner
submitted that the view taken by the learned Single Judge in upholding
the direction issued by the Commissioner to supply the information to
Respondent No.4 is correct, and since the Registrar can call for
information, it can be directed to be supplied.
(2011) 8 SCC 497
(2013) 16 SCC 82
(2020) 5 SCC 481
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
8.
2025:KER:28555
Respondent No.4, who appeared in person, submitted that the
information can be accessed by a public body as can be seen from the
definition of information under the RTI Act and that under the Act of
1969 and the Kerala Cooperative Societies Rules, 1969, ample power
exists with the Registrar to call for information from the society. The
Registrar of the Cooperative Societies has access to information on the
cooperative society within the parameters of the RTI Act. Such
documents can be accessed, copied, and supplied to the Applicants. The
documents need not be in the custody of the Registrar as that is not the
mandate of the RTI Act. The orders passed by Respondent No. 1 –
Commissioner and the learned Single Judge are correct and need not be
interfered with.
9.
We have considered the rival contentions.
10.
The RTI Act was enacted to provide for setting out the practical
regime of the right to information for citizens to secure access to
information under the control of public authorities to promote
transparency and accountability. The RTI Act confers a right to
information under Section 3. It places obligations and regulates the
public authorities' supply of information under the Act. Section 2(f) of
the RTI Act defines 'information' as follows:
“(f) “information” means any material in any form, including
records, documents, memos, e-mails, opinions, advices, press
releases, circulars, orders, logbooks, contracts, reports, papers,
samples, models, data material held in any electronic form and
information relating to any private body which can be accessed
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
by a public authority under any other law for the time being in
force.”
(emphasis supplied)
Section 2(j) defines ‘right to information’ as follows:
“(j) “right to information” means the right to information
accessible under this Act which is held by or under the control
of any public authority and includes the right to(i) inspection of work, documents, records;
(ii) taking notes, extracts or certified copies of documents or
records;
(iii) taking certified samples of material;
(iv) obtaining information in the form of diskettes, floppies,
tapes, video cassettes or in any other electronic mode or
through printouts where such information is stored in a
computer or in any other device.”
Section 2(h) defines ‘public authority’ as follows:
“(h) “public authority” means any authority or body or
institution of self-Government established or constituted-(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
by or under the Constitution;
by any other law made by Parliament;
by any other law made by State Legislature;
by notification issued or order made by the appropriate
Government, and includes any-(i) body owned, controlled or substantially financed;
(ii) non-Government organisation substantially financed,
directly or indirectly by funds provided by the
appropriate Government.”
As far as the cooperative society is concerned, the same is held to be not a
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
"public authority" as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Thalappalam Service Cooperative Bank Limited. The Appellant would be
covered by the second part of the definition of "Information". Under
Section 3, as per the second part of the definition of 'Information',
information relating to any private body can be accessed by a public
authority under any other law for the time being in force and can be
supplied. There is no debate before us that this is the route through which
Respondent No.4 can seek information under the RTI Act. Disputes
centre around the meaning of the phrase "can be accessed by the public
authority".
11. The first contention of the Appellant is that the information
contemplated under the second part of Section 2(f) will have to be
accessed by public authority within the parameters of the statute which
confers such power, and secondly, it has to be stored and available as per
Section 4(1)(a). Section 4(1)(a) of the RTI Act reads thus:
“4. Obligations of public authorities.- (1) Every public authority
shall-(a)
maintain all its records duly catalogued and
indexed in a manner and the form which facilitates the
right to information under this Act and ensure that all
records that are appropriate to be computerised are,
within a reasonable time and subject to availability of
resources, computerised and connected through a
network all over the country on different systems so that
access to such records is facilitated.”
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
According to Respondent No. 1- Commissioner and Respondent No. 4, a
plain reading of the second part of Section 2(f) will show that it is
sufficient if the information is accessible. The foundation of Respondent
No.4 is that he can invoke the powers of the Registrar, who can always
access the documents which Respondent No.4 has asked for.
12.
The Supreme Court in Thalappalam Service Co-op. Bank Ltd. had
considered the provisions of the Kerala Cooperative Societies Act, 1969
and the RTI Act in the context of the status of the cooperative society. In
that case, an application was filed under the RTI Act seeking particulars
relating to the bank accounts of certain members of the Society, which the
Society did not provide. The learned Single Judge held that all
cooperative societies registered under the Act of 1969 are public
authorities for the purpose of the RTI Act and amenable to the
jurisdiction of the State Information Commission. The cooperative
society then preferred a writ appeal. The question as to whether
cooperative societies registered under the Act of 1969 are generally
covered under the definition of Section 2(h) of the RTI Act was referred
to the Full Bench of this Court. The Full Bench answered the question in
the affirmative, giving a liberal construction of the definition of public
authority. The decision of the Full Bench was examined by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court and observed thus:
“Registrar of Co-operative Societies
67. The Registrar of Cooperative Societies functioning under
the Cooperative Societies Act is a “public authority” within the
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
meaning of Section 2(h) of the Act. As a public authority, the
Registrar of Cooperative Societies has been conferred with lot of
statutory powers under the respective Act under which he is
functioning. He is also duty-bound to comply with the
obligations under the RTI Act and furnish information to a
citizen under the RTI Act. The information which he is
expected to provide is the information enumerated in Section
2(f) of the RTI Act subject to the limitations provided under
Section 8 of the Act. The Registrar can also, to the extent law
permits, gather information from a society, on which he has
supervisory or administrative control under the Cooperative
Societies Act. Consequently, apart from the information as is
available to him, under Section 2(f), he can also gather those
information from the society, to the extent permitted by law.
The Registrar is also not obliged to disclose those information if
those information fall under Section 8(1)(j) of the Act. No
provision has been brought to our knowledge indicating that,
under the Cooperative Societies Act, a Registrar can call for the
details of the bank accounts maintained by the citizens or
members in a cooperative bank. Only those information which a
Registrar of Cooperative Societies can have access under the
Cooperative Societies Act from a society could be said to be the
information which is “held” or “under the control of public
authority”. Even those information, the Registrar, as already
indicated, is not legally obliged to provide if those information
falls under the exempted category mentioned in Section 8(j) of
the Act. Apart from the Registrar of Co-operative Societies,
there may be other public authorities who can access
information from a cooperative bank of a private account
maintained by a member of a society under law, in the event of
which, in a given situation, the society will have to part with that
information. But the demand should have statutory backing.
(emphasis supplied)
Thus, the information held by the Registrar is the one he can access.
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
13.
2025:KER:28555
Further, Respondent No. 4 has pointed out from paragraph 20 of
the decision in Subhash Chandra Agarwal that there is a distinction
between the information to be held by the public authority and the
private body. Paragraph 20 reads thus:
“20. ‘Information’ as per the definition clause is broad and wide,
as it is defined to mean "material in any form" with amplifying
words including records (a term again defined in widest terms
vide clause (i) to S.2 of the RTI Act), documents, emails, memos,
advices, logbooks, contracts, reports, papers, samples, models,
data material held in electronic form, etc. The last portion of the
definition clause which states that the term 'information' would
include 'information relating to any private body which can be
accessed by a public authority under any other law for the time
being in force' has to be read as reference to 'information' not
presently available or held by the public authority but which can
be accessed by the public authority from a private body under
any other law for the time being in force. The term - 'private
body' in the clause has been used to distinguish and is in
contradistinction to the term - 'public authority' as defined in
S.2(h) of the RTI Act. It follows that any requirement in the
nature of precondition and restrictions prescribed by any other
law would continue to apply and are to be satisfied before
information can be accessed and asked to be furnished by a
private body.”
(emphasis supplied)
Therefore, the Supreme Court has made a clear distinction between the
holding of information by a private body and the public authority. In the
context of a private body, Information is the one not presently available
or held by a public authority but can be accessed by a public authority.
Therefore, the contention of the Appellant that only the information
which the Registrar holds and actually possesses in respect of a private
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
body under Rule 66 and Rule 24 cannot be accepted.
14.
Therefore, the question that arises for consideration is whether the
information sought by Respondent No.4 can be 'accessed' by the
Registrar and whether the learned Single Judge and the Information
Commissioner were right in holding so.
15.
Respondent No.4 had sought information as to the agreement
entered into by the Appellant Society and a Labour Contract Society
regarding construction and copies of the minutes of the last general body
meeting. In different fact situations, various other legal issues may arise.
The discussion in the judgment is only in the context of the correctness of
the view taken by the Information Commissioner and the learned Single
Judge in respect of the information sought by Respondent No.4 from the
Appellant Society.
16.
Section 2(f) of the Act of 1969 defines a cooperative society as a
cooperative society registered or deemed to be registered under the said
Act. Registration is provided under Section 9 of the Act of 1969, and
upon registration, it becomes a corporate body. The Government and the
Registrar shall have the power to regulate the workings of society for the
economic and social betterment of its members and the general public.
The Appellant Society has pointed out that the words ‘and control’ have
been omitted by way of the Act of 2013. However, the Government and
the Registrar shall have the power to regulate the workings of a society for
the economic and social betterment of its members and the general
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
public.
17.
The Registrar is defined under Section 2(p) of the Act of 1969 to
mean the Registrar of Cooperative Societies appointed under Section 3(1)
of the Act. Section 3 of the Act of 1969 empowers the Government to
appoint a person as the Registrar of Cooperative Societies. Under Section
32 of the Act of 1969, if the Registrar is satisfied that a committee of any
society makes persistent default or is negligent, he may, by order in
writing, remove the committee and appoint an Administrator. Under
Section 33(1) of the Act of 1969, when contingencies specified therein
exist, the Registrar, either suo motu or on the application, can appoint an
Administrator. As per Section 33(1A), the Government may permit the
Registrar to extend the term of the Administrator. Under sub-section (2),
the Administrator appointed under sub-section (1) and (1A), subject to
the control of the Registrar, has the power to exercise all or any of the
powers and functions of the committee and take all such action as may be
required in the interest of the society. As per Section 34(1) of the Act of
1969, if the outgoing members of the committee refuse to hand over
charge of the records and property of the society to the Administrator, the
Administrator can, with the previous sanction of the Registrar, apply to
the Magistrate within whose jurisdiction the Cooperative Society
functions, for securing the records and properties of the Society.
18.
Under Sections 65 and 66 of the Act of 1969, the Registrar may
hold an enquiry, and the parameters of the same are specified therein.
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
Under Section 65, apart from other modes, the Registrar may, on his own
motion, call for documents for the purpose of an enquiry as stated in
Section 65(2). Section 65(2) reads thus:
“(2) The Registrar or the person authorised by him under subsection (1) shall, for the purpose of an inquiry under this section
have the following powers, namely:-(a) he shall, at all reasonable times, have free access to the
books, accounts, documents, securities, cash and other
properties belonging to, or in the custody of, the society
and may summon any person in possession of or
responsible for the custody of any such books, accounts,
documents, securities, cash or other properties, to produce
the same at any place at the headquarters of the society or
at any branch thereof or where there is no working office
for the society, at the office of the Registrar or at the office
of any of his subordinate officers;
(b) he may summon any person who, he has reason to
believe, has knowledge of any of the affairs of the society
to appear before him at any place at the headquarters of
the society or any branch thereof and may examine such
person on oath; and
(c)(i) he may, notwithstanding any rule or bye-law
specifying the period of notice for a general body meeting
of the society himself call a general body meeting or
require the president or secretary of the society to call a
general body meeting at such time and place at the
headquarters of the society or any branch thereof, to
determine such matters as may be directed by him;
(ii) any meeting called under sub-clause (i) shall have all
the powers of a general body meeting called under the bye-
2025:KER:28555
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
laws of the society.
(d) The person/persons related to or involved in the
inquiry shall be issued a notice, indicating the matter of
inquiry and he/they shall be provided an opportunity of
being heard, with proper notice by registered post or in
person.
(2A)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
xxxxx
*****
Under Section 66, Supervision and inspection of the Registrar is
provided. Under Section 66(1), the Registrar shall supervise or cause to
be supervised the working of every society as frequently as he may
consider necessary. The supervision includes an inspection of the books
of the society. Under Section 66(2), the Registrar can, on his own motion
and other modes, inspect the books of the society issued. Section 66 then
provides for the methodology as follows:
“(2A) The Registrar may authorize special team of officers under
his control for the inspection of apex, central and federal cooperative societies and all other primary co-operative societies.
(2B) The report of such inspections shall be communicated in
writing to the apex, central and federal societies and all primary
co-operative societies concerned, within a period of thirty days
and the Committee and the chief executive of the society
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
concerned shall be under an obligation to file a para-wise
satisfactory compliance report before the Registrar within a
period of forty five days from the date of such communication.
(3) Where the inspection under sub-section (2) is made on the
application of the creditor, the Registrar shall communicate the
result of such inspection to such creditor.
(4) The Registrar or any person authorised by him under subsection (l) or sub-section (2) shall at all reasonable time have free
access to and have power to inspect the books, records, accounts,
documents, securities, cash balance and other properties
belonging to the society and may summon any person in
possession of or responsible for the custody of such books,
records, accounts, documents, securities, cash balance and other
properties, to produce the same for inspection at any place at the
Headquarters of the society or any branch thereof or where there
is no working office for the society, at the office of the Registrar
or at the office of any of his .subordinate officers.
(4A) It shall be the duty of every officer and employee of the
society to co-operate with and assist in such supervision or
inspection, to furnish any information that may be required for
the purpose and to produce the books, records, cash balance etc.
referred to in sub-section (4), on demand by such officer, failing
which it shall be treated as an offence under sub-section (4) of
section 94.
(5) within the time that may be mentioned in such order.
[x x x x]
(7)
xxxx
(8)
xxxx
(9)
xxxx
(10) x x x x
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
(11) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-sections (1) and
(2) above, the Registrar or his subordinate officers authorized by
him under sub-section (1), shall have power to hold an enquiry
with necessary records of a society, on any petition received, and
to inspect the affairs of a society periodically, in such cases, the
inspecting officers shall have the same powers as specified in subsection (4).
Explanation 1:--The "affairs of a society" for the purpose of this
subsection includes, among other things, matters relating to
administration, management and the business of a society.
Explanation 2:--The duty of the officers and chief executive of a
society and the nature of offences and penalties mentioned in
sub-section (4A) shall be applicable to this sub-section also.”
19.
The procedure for conducting enquiry and inspection by the
Registrar under Section 65 is provided under Rule 66 of the Kerala
Cooperative Societies Rules, 1969, which reads thus:
“66. Procedure for the conduct of inquiry and inspection:- (1) (i)
An order, authorising inquiry under Section 65 or inspection
under Section 66 shall among other things, contain the
following:
(a) the name of the society whose affairs are to be inquired
into or whose books of accounts which are kept either in
digital or in physical form are to be inspected:
(b) the name of the person/persons authorised to conduct the
inquiry or inspection;
(c) in specific point or points on which the inquiry or
inspection is to be made, the period within which the
inquiry or inspection is to be completed and report
submitted to the Registrar;
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
(d) costs of inquiry or inspection;
(e) any other matter relating or pertaining to the inquiry or
inspection.
(2) A copy of every order authorising inquiry under Section 65
or inspection under Section 66 shall be issued to the President or
the Secretary of the Society concerned by registered post with
acknowledgment due. A copy of the order shall also be made
available to the Central Society or societies, to which the society
in respect of which the order is issued, is affiliated;
(3) If the inquiry or inspection cannot be completed within the
time specified in the order referred to in sub-rule (1)(c), the
person conducting the inquiry or inspection shall submit an
interim report stating the reasons for failure to complete the
inquiry or inspection, and the Registrar, it he is satisfied, may
grant such extension of time as he may deem necessary or he may
withdraw the inquiry or Inspection from the officer to whom it is
entrusted and hold the inquiry or inspection himself or entrust
to such other person as he deems fit.
(4) On receipt of the orders referred to in sub-rule (1) the person
/persons authorised to conduct the inquiry or inspection shall
proceed to examine the relevant books of accounts [which are
kept either in digital or in physical form] and other documents in
the possession of the society or any of its officers, members,
agents or servants and obtain such information or explanation
from any such officer, members, agents or servants of the society
in regard to the transaction and working of the society as he
deems necessary for the conduct of such inquiry or inspection.
(5) The person authorised to conduct the inquiry or inspection
shall submit his report to the Registrar on all points mentioned
in the order referred to in clause (c) to sub-rule (1). The report
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
shall invariably contain a latest balance sheet of the society and
the last known addresses of the members of the Committee and
of the Secretary. The report shall also contain his findings and
the reason therefore; supported by such documentary or other
evidence as recorded by him during the course of the inquiry or
inspection. He shall also specify in his report the costs of the
inquiry or inspection together with reasons and recommend to
the Registrar the manner in which the entire cost or a part
thereof may be apportioned amongst the parties specified in
Section 32. The Registrar shall pass such orders thereon as may
be considered just after giving a reasonable opportunity of being
heard to the society, person or persons concerned.
(6) The Registrar, if he is satisfied that action under section 66B
of the Act is warranted, shall issue a direction to the committee
of a society to suspend the officer or officers responsible for the
offence. The reason for the proposed suspension shall be
specified in the direction. The direction shall be sent by
registered post with acknowledgement due.
(7)(i) The order in writing for an inquiry under sub-section (1)
of Section 68 of the Act shall among other things contain the
following:
(a) name of the society whose affairs are to be inquired
into or whose books of accounts are to be inspected;
(b) name of the person authorised to conduct the
inquiry;
(c) the specific point or points on which the inquiry is to
be made;
(d) the period of three months from the date of order]
within which the inquiry is to be completed and report
submitted to the Registrar;
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
(e) costs of inquiry or inspection;
(f) any other matter relating or pertaining to the inquiry.
(ii) Within one month from the date of receipt of inquiry report,
the Registrar shall give the person or persons concerned an
opportunity of being heard before issuing an order for surcharge.
The order for surcharge shall be in writing and shall be sent
under registered post with acknowledgement due. The order
shall among other things contain the following:(a) name of society;
(b) name/names of person/persons responsible or repay
or restore the money or any property or any part thereof, by
mentioning clearly the total amount, involved due from each;
(c) the rate of interest if any, to be clearly specified;
(d) the amount of cost or compensation to be specified;
(e) the period within which the amount is to be realised;
(f) in case the person responsible is not remitting the
amount within the time-limit so fixed, the society shall report the
matter to the Registrar forthwith and the Registrar shall realise
the amount as per the Revenue Recovery Act.
(8) While conducting an inquiry under section 65 or an
inspection under section 66, the inquiry/inspection officer be
transferred or promoted to another post, the officer conducting
inquiry/inspection shall hand over a report of all the work done
till the period of transfer/promotion with supporting documents
to the new inquiry/inspection officer as appointed. The former
inquiry/inspection officer be held answerable for the work done
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
with regard to the inquiry/inspection till his period. The newly
appointed inquiry/inspection officer should start the work in
continuation of the report handed over by the former
inquiry/inspection officer and should submit the final
inquiry/inspection report in time.”
20.
Under Rule 176, the Registrar has the power to rescind the
resolution. Rule 176 reads as follows:
“176.
Registrar’s power to rescind resolution:Notwithstanding anything contained in the bye-laws of a
registered society, it shall be competent for the Registrar to
rescind any resolution of any meeting of any society or the
committee of any society, if it appears to him that such
resolution is ultra vires of the objects of the society, or is
against the provisions of the Act, Rules, Bye-laws or of any
direction or instructions issued by the Department, or
calculated to disturb the peaceful and orderly working of the
society or is contrary to the better interest of the society.”
21.
The Scheme of the Act of 1969 from these provisions would thus
show that the Registrar may conduct an inquiry into the conduct,
functioning, and financial condition of a cooperative society if he deems
it necessary. The Registrar can supervise the functioning of cooperative
societies as he deems necessary. It includes an inspection of books and
records. He may conduct such an inspection on his own motion. The
Registrar or any person authorised by him shall have the power to access
and inspect all relevant records of the society. The Registrar may summon
any person responsible for their custody and require them to produce
these records for inspection. Failure to produce information shall be
treated as an offence under Section 94(4) of the Act of 1969. The
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
Registrar also has the authority to rescind any resolution passed by any
meeting of the society or its committee if he determines that such
resolution is ultra vires to the objects of the society, violates provisions of
the Act, Rules, Bye-laws, or any direction or instructions issued by the
Department, disrupts the peaceful and orderly functioning of the society,
or is contrary to the best interests of the society. Therefore, it is amply
clear that under the above provisions, the Registrar of the Cooperative
Societies has access to the documents of a cooperative society.
22.
The Appellant Society relied on the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Aditya Bandopadhyay, more particularly, on
the observations of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in paragraphs 63 and 65.
In this case, the Respondent student had applied for inspection and
revaluation of his answer book. The Central Board of Secondary
Education rejected the application. The High Court allowed the writ and
held that the examinees have a right under the RTI Act to examine their
answer books. The Supreme Court upheld the said right and, in that
context, made the observations in paragraphs 63 and 65, which the
Appellant seeks to rely upon. However, these observations are in the
context of information in the first part of the definition of Section 2(f),
i.e., the information available with a public body as defined under Section
2(h). In the case of Aditya Bandopadhyay, the Supreme Court was
considering the information as available with the public authority and,
therefore, was concerned with the definition of information in the first
part of Section 2(f) and therefore the Supreme Court made an
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
observation that it is only available and existing information that is to be
supplied and the public authority is not required to take steps to secure
compliance of the provisions of the Act or issue directions beyond the
Act. This decision, therefore, is of no relevance to the facts of the present
case.
23.
Similarly, the reliance of the Appellant on paragraph 21 of the
decision of the Constitution Bench in Subhash Chandra Agarwal will not
assist the Appellant. In this case, an application was made under the RTI
Act relating to the appointment of Judges of the Supreme Court and
High Courts. Various facets of the RTI Act were discussed and settled in
the said decision. As regards the case at hand, the Appellant relies on
paragraph 21, in which it was observed that though information relating
to the private body can be accessed by public authority, it is subject to
pre-imposed conditions and restrictions as applicable to access the
information and when access to information by public authority itself is
prohibited or is accessible subject to certain conditions, then the
prohibition is not obliterated, and the preconditions are not erased. The
Appellant submits that Section 2(f) cannot be used to eradicate
prohibition and limitation on the rights of the public authority to access
the information. Based on this observation, the Appellant contends that
unless the power to access the records is formally invoked, the Registrar
does not obtain possession of the society’s documents, and consequently,
such documents cannot be disclosed under the RTI Act unless they are in
the Registrar’s possession as contemplated under Section 4 of the Act.
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
The Appellant further contends that, in the present case, the Registrar has
not exercised this power by instituting an inquiry into the affairs of the
Appellant Society. However, the reliance on this observation is misplaced
for the present case. The aforementioned provisions of the Act of 1969
will show that there is no prohibition on the access of the documents by
the Registrar, which Respondent No. 4 seeks from the Appellant Society.
24.
Under section 65(1), the Registrar can, on his own motion, hold an
enquiry by himself or by a person or persons authorised by order in
writing into the constitution, working and financial condition of the
society if he is satisfied that it is necessary so to do. Under Section 66, the
Registrar may, on his own motion, inspect the books of the society. Once
the documents that Respondent No. 4 seeks can be accessed by the
Registrar under Section 65 read with Rule 66, then it becomes
information for the purpose of the RTI Act. Further, there is a difference
between the existence of the power of the Registrar to access the
document and the actual use of that power by the Registrar. As far as the
RTI Act is concerned, the second part of the definition of ‘Information’
would show that it postulates the ‘existence’ of power to access the
documents and not ‘its actual’ exercise by the Registrar. Correctness and
validity of the actual exercise of power by the Registrar to access the
document would be a different subject matter. The information sought by
the Respondent - Member under Section 2(f), read with Section 3, is
accessible by the Registrar within the ambit of the RTI Act.
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
25.
2025:KER:28555
The Appellant argues that under Section 66 of the Act of 1969,
Cooperative Societies are required to submit certain documents to the
Registrar, and only these specific documents, which are in the custody of
the Registrar, can be accessed under the RTI Act. While these documents
are indeed available with the Registrar and can be disclosed under the
RTI Act, this does not mean they are the only documents that can be
accessed. Section 2(f) of the RTI Act defines "information" not as any
material held by or under the control of a public authority but which can
be accessed. The arguments of the Appellant are against the plain reading
of Section 2(c), which declares a position that information with a
Cooperative Society which "can" be accessed by a public authority under
the law is information for the purpose of Section 3. It is a well-settled
principle of statutory interpretation that the first attempt must be to read
the statute as it is unless it leads to an absurdity. Reading of Section 2(f) of
the RTI Act makes it clear that Parliament has deliberately employed the
phrase "can access" to emphasise the legal entitlement of a Registrar to
obtain certain documents. Had Parliament intended to restrict the scope
of access solely to documents that had already been physically obtained
by the Registrar, it would have employed different language, such as "has
accessed" or "is in possession of." The deliberate choice of "can access"
signifies that the right to seek information extends beyond mere physical
custody of the documents with the Registrar and includes those
documents that a Registrar has the statutory power to access. This phrase
does not imply that the Registrar can only ask for documents when an
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
inquiry is already in progress. Without these documents, the Registrar
may be unable to determine whether an inquiry is necessary in the first
place. Therefore, imposing a requirement that an inquiry must already be
underway before documents can be accessed would be contrary to the
intent and purpose of the statute. Thus, the phrase "subject to the
limitations of the statute" should be understood as a guiding principle
that ensures the Registrar's powers are exercised within legal bounds
rather than as a restriction that would prevent access to documents unless
an inquiry has already been initiated. This interpretation is in consonance
with the broader objective of the RTI Act, which is to ensure transparency
and accountability in the governance of the cooperative society as well.
26.
Respondent No. 1 – the Commissioner has held that the Registrar
is empowered to gather information from the society or over which he has
supervisory control under the Act of 1969, and the Registrar has
supervisory and administrative control to access the information. This
view taken by Respondent No. 1 – the Commissioner is in consonance
with the scheme of the Act which we have discussed above.
27.
Even otherwise all documents could not be furnished to
Respondent No.4 under the RTI Act. Certain documents are exempted
from the purview of the RTI Act under Section 8 of the RTI Act. There is
no obligation to give information which has been expressly forbidden to
be published by any court of law or tribunal or the disclosure of which
may constitute contempt of court. Secondly, information including
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
commercial confidence, trade secrets or intellectual property, the
disclosure of which would harm the competitive position of a third party
unless the competent authority is satisfied that larger public interest
warrants the disclosure of such information. Also, the information
available to a person in his fiduciary relationship cannot be given unless
the competent authority is satisfied that the larger public interest warrants
the disclosure of such information. The information, the disclosure of
which would endanger the life or physical safety of any person or identify
the source of information or assistance given in confidence for law
enforcement or security purposes, also cannot be given. The information
that would impede the investigation, apprehension or prosecution of
offenders can be withheld. Information which relates to personal
information, the disclosure of which has no relationship to any public
activity or interest or which would cause an unwarranted invasion of the
privacy of the individual, can be refused unless the authority under the
RTI Act can supply the same. In the case at hand, Respondent No.4 has
asked for a construction agreement and copies of the last General Body
meeting. Both these documents do not fall within the exemption of
Section 8 of the RTI Act. There may be cases where a cooperative society
may argue that a member is not entitled to any relief as proceedings are
initiated to remove him as a member of the society, etc. However, no such
case is made out in the present case.
28.
The learned Single Judge has considered the challenge of the
Appellant to the order passed by Respondent No. 1 – the Commissioner
W.A.No. 2105 of 2024
2025:KER:28555
in detail, has analysed the relevant provisions and decisions of this Court
and the Supreme Court, and has concluded that the information sought
by the Applicant is accessible by the Registrar and has rightly dismissed
the Writ Petition. No case is made out to interfere with the impugned
order in appeal.
29.
The Appeal is dismissed.
Sd/Nitin Jamdar
Chief Justice
Sd/S. Manu
Judge
vpv
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review