Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 29TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.I.ARUN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI
WRIT APPEAL NO. 100002 OF 2026 (GM-RES)
BETWEEN:
VISHAL NINGAPPA
PATTIHAL
Location: High
Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench,
Dharwad
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORPORATION
LIMITED, HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE
AT, PETROLEUM CORPORATION LTD.,
HINDUSTAN BHAVAN
SU MANG FORT, MUMBAI – 400 001,
MAHARASHTRA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS
SENIOR REGIONAL MANAGER,
VINAY KANTH ABBIGARI,
S/O. RAJENDRA PRASAD.
… APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ANGADI CHANNAPPA VIRUPAXAPPA, ADV.)
AND:
1.
THE UNION OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF PETROLEUM AND
NATURAL GAS,
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
KARTAVYA BHAVAN – 03, JANPATH,
NEW DELHI – 110 001,
REPRESENTED BY ITS JOINT SECRETARY.
2.
M/S VINP DISTILLERIES AND SUGARS
PVT LTD., A COMPANY DULY
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
INCORPORATED UNDER THE PROVISIONS
OF THE COMPANIES ACT, 2013,
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT
SY. NO. 42 43 AND 53,
JAKKANAKATTI ROAD, KONANAKERI VILLAGE,
SHIGGAON TQ,
HAVERI DISTRICT – 581 193,
REPRESENTED BY ITS VICE PRESIDENT,
SRI. MANJUNATHA C. B.,
3.
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
BHARAT PETROLEUM CORPORATION LTD.,
BHARAT BHAVAN, PETROLEUM
CORPORATION LTD., 12TH FLOOR,
E AND F MAKAR TOWN CUFFE PARADE,
MUMBAI – 400 005, MAHARASTRA.
4.
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
INDIAN OIL CORPORATION LIMITED,
INDIAN OIL BHAVAN, G-9, ALI YAVAR
JUNG MARG, BANDRA EAST, MUMBAI,
MAHARASHTRA – 400 051.
… RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. KAMAT, ADDITIONAL SOLICITOR GENERAL FOR
SRI. M.B, KANAVI, CGSC FOR R1;
SRI. PRABHULING K. NAVDAGI, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI. AJAY KADKOL, SRI. SANAT KUMAR H. &
SMT. PRIYANAKA J. SREEDHARA, ADV. FOR R2)
(NOTICE TO R3 & R4 IS DISPENSED WITH)
THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO ALLOW THIS
WRIT APPEAL AND SET ASIDE THE INTERIM ORDER DATED
15-12-2025 PASSED IN W.P.NO.109133/2025 (GM-RES), IN THE
ENDS OF EQUITY AND JUSTICE. TO PASS SUCH OTHER ORDER/S
AS DEEMED FIT BY THIS HON’BLE COURT, IN THE FACTS AND
CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE, IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE.
THIS WRIT APPEAL, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HEARING THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS
UNDER:
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.I.ARUN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.I.ARUN)
Aggrieved by the interim order dated 15.12.2025 passed in
Writ Petition No.109133/2025, the present writ appeal is
preferred by respondent No.3 therein.
2. For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to
as per their status in the writ petition.
3. Respondent No.1-Union of India came up with a policy
to encourage production of ethanol, so that dependence on crude
oil by the nation could be reduced. In the process, a policy was
framed
wherein
private
participants
were
encouraged
to
establish dedicated ethanol plants, wherein no other produce
could be manufactured and they were also allocated specific
areas where sugar cane or maize is grown which requires the
dedicated ethanol plants to compulsorily purchase the produce
from the farmers of the area and utilise the same for production
of ethanol. Ethanol so produced can be sold only to oil marketing
companies, who will mix the same in the petrol to be sold by
them.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
4. The petitioner is one such dedicated ethanol plant,
which is established for production of ethanol. A long term
offtake agreement was entered into between the petitioner and
respondents No.2, 3 and 4, who are Oil Marketing Companies
owned by respondent No.1-Union of India. Clause 1.1.1 of the
said agreement reads as under:
“1.1.1. Dedicated Ethanol Plant (DEP): These ethanol plants
will only produce ethanol (as per prevalent BIS
specifications) and all of the quantity produced in
this unit would be supplied to Buyer/OMCs only. In
case a new dedicated ethanol plant is setup in the
same premises where the existing distillery is
operating (or is set up as a new distillery), the
ethanol plant should be clearly identifiable as a
separate unit. Processing units and storage area of
ethanol have to be separate for the dedicated
ethanol
plant.
The
nonproduction
facilities,
however, can be shared. Necessary certification of
such plants by appropriate authorities is required.”
5.
Clause 2.1 of the agreement reads as under:
“2.1. The
Seller/Supplier
agrees
to
supply
and
the
Buyer/OMCs agree to purchase Ethanol under the
terms of this Agreement in the quantities, and at
Supply Price determined in accordance with, and
subject
to,
Agreement.”
the
terms
and
conditions
of
this
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
6.
Clause 6 of the agreement reads as under:
“6.
6.1.
Quantities and Allocations:
Seller/Supplier
OMCs/BPCL
process
will
register
through
and
procurement
a
himself
vendor
participate
process
with
registration
in
ethanol
mandatorily.
After
successful registration, the Seller/Supplier will
participate in ethanol procurement process
followed
by
OMCs
for
their
location-wise
requirement of ethanol.
6.2. Buyer/OMCs offer jointly an annual offtake
quantity of 1.44 Cr lit of Ethanol and the
Seller/Supplier commits to supply the same by
participating in the vendor registration process
and ethanol procurement process. Interstate
movements, if required, by Buyer/OMCs should
be honoured by the Seller/Supplier. The annual
offtake quantity offered is on best endeavor
basis
to
the
considering
extent
of
prevalent
ethanol
required,
ethanol
blending
percentage and MS sale of Buyer/OMCS, and
any
other
factor
impacting
ethanol
requirement, including, but not limited to,
demand issues arising out of the new economic
imperatives/ regulations, vehicle short supply
and such similar circumstances beyond the
control
of
Buyer/OMCs.
In
case,
the
Seller/Supplier intends to supply during the
ongoing ESY, offtake quantity will be limited to
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
the requirement of Buyer/OMCs for the balance
period of that ESY.
6.3. Offtake quantity offered jointly by Buyer/OMCs is
subject to the Seller/Supplier complying with
the condition under clause 6.1.
6.4. The annual off take quantity offered as above for
supply of denatured anhydrous ethanol to
OMCs may be less than the annual design
capacity offered by the shortlisted bidder in his
application.
6.5
The shortlisted bidder is free to set up plant
upto the annual design capacity offered in his
application. This additional capacity, over and
above the annual offtake quantity offered in
6.2 above, also needs to remain dedicated
ethanol plant only.
6.6.
Ethanol so produced from additional capacity
stated in 6.5 above, may be procured through
the prevailing Ethanol procurement process
followed by OMCs and/or Pvt. OMCs on need
basis.
6.7.
The annual offtake quantity offered as per 6.2
above, may be considered for amendment in
future, to include the additional capacity as
stated in 6.5 above, as per the need of OMCs
at that point of time and rules and guidelines
in force.
6.8.
In the above EOI floated for setting up of
dedicated ethanol units, in case a bidder is
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
being issued LOI for a quantity lesser than the
quantity for which they have bid it is clarified
that in case they set up plants as per their
bids, Buyer/OMCs may offer additional annual
offtake quantity, beyond that offered under 6.2
above, with overall annual offtake quantity
limited to the design capacity of the plant
offered by the bidder under the EOI. This
additional offtake quantity by Buyer/OMCs will
be given through preferential allocation in the
ethanol
procurement
process
followed
by
Buyer/OMCs on best endeavor basis.
6.9. "EOI for Quantity Bids" for the full requirement
of the ESY shall be floated prior to the start of
ESY to the registered vendors only. There after
EOI for quantity bids shall be floated for the
shortfall
quantity/additional
requirement,
if
any, purely based on requirements of Buyer/
OMCs.
a.
Location-wise,
individual
OMC-wise
quantity to be supplied in each ESY quarter
shall be allocated to the Seller/Supplier as
per prevalent allocation criteria.
b.
All allocations including any subsequent reallocation will be at the sole discretion of
the Buyer/OMCs.
C.
LOI will be issued by individual OMCs for
the
allocated
Seller/Supplier.
quantity
to
the
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
d.
For the allocated quantity, Seller/Supplier
will sign Purchase Agreement with each
OMC after submitting Security Deposit as
per the terms and conditions of the LOI. All
terms and conditions of the Purchase
Agreement
will
be
binding
on
the
execution
of
Seller/Supplier.
6.10.
The
responsibility
of
allocations/re-allocations made in relation to
procurement of ethanol and related activities
will lie with the respective OMCs to whom
allocation has been made as per procurement
process and the parties will keep each other
indemnified in respect of any dispute arising
between them or with any third party after
such
allocations/re-allocations
has
been
done.”
7. Thus, as per the terms of the agreement, petitioner has
established a dedicated ethanol plant and the respondents have
agreed to purchase a minimum of 1.44 crore litres of ethanol
from the petitioner annually.
8. The petitioner is also permitted to increase its capacity
to produce more than 1.44 crore litres annually by taking
previous permission of the State. Presently, it is submitted that
the petitioner has established a dedicated ethanol plant with a
design capacity of producing 9.9 crores litres of ethanol annually.
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
As per terms of the agreement, the petitioner is required to sell
such
quantity
of
ethanol
produced
by
him
in
favour
of
respondents No.2 to 4 and only if the policy of the Government
from time to time permits the sale to other Oil Marketing
Companies, it can be sold to a private Oil Marketing Company.
Presently, no such policy is existing permitting the petitioner
herein to sell his produce to a private Oil Manufacturing
Company.
9. Respondents No.2 to 4 are obliged to procure 1.44 crore
litres of ethanol from the petitioner annually. With regard to any
excess quantity of ethanol produced by the petitioner over and
above the 1.44 crore litres, respondents are required to procure
same from the petitioner on a preferential basis as per the terms
mentioned in Clause 6.8 of the contract above.
10. The procurement policy of ethanol is revised annually
by the respondents depending upon their needs. In this regard,
respondents No.2 to 4 have invited bids for supply of ethanol for
the Ethanol Supply Year 2025-26, (Annexure-F to the writ
petition), wherein tender is invited for procuring 1050 crore litres
of ethanol. The said requirement requires respondents No.2 to 4
to procure much more than the quantity compulsorily agreed to
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
be procured from the dedicated ethanol plants, similarly situated
as that of the petitioner. That is to say respondents No.2 to 4 are
in requirement of procuring a quantity of ethanol much more
than the promised minimum quantity of 1.44 crore litres from
the petitioner. Under the circumstances, respondents No.2 to 4
are required to procure ethanol from the petitioner as per the
terms mentioned in Clause 6.8 of the Long Term Offtake
Agreement, wherein, they have to do so, on a preferential basis.
11. However, the tender document for the Ethanol Supply
Year 2025-26, flouted the said condition mentioned in the Long
Term Offtake Agreement. The bid document incorporates the
following condition instead:
“PREFERENTIAL ALLOCATION TO COOPERATIVE
SUGAR MILLS (CSMs) & DEDICATED ETHANOL
PLANTS (DEPs) HAVING LTOA
For
all
DEPs
under
EOI-1
(CRFQ
No.1000374174, System ID 86996 dtd. 28-092021) and EOI-2 (CRFQ No.1000403925, System
ID 11837 dtd. 15-05-2023), Additional Quantity
offered, if any, beyond long term offtake quantity
(pro-rated and calculated on a quarterly basis) shall
not
be
considered
for
preferential
allocation.
Allocation of this additional quantity offered shall be
done as per allocation criteria applicable for nonDEPs.”
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
12.
The
grievance
of
the
petitioner
is
that
the
aforementioned condition in the tender document is in violation
of Clause 6.8 of the Long Term Offtake Agreement. Hence, they
gave a representation to the authorities concerned to revise the
tender conditions. As the same has not been done, Writ Petition
No.109133/2025 has been filed with the following prayers:
“Wherefore, the petitioner herein above named,
humbly prays that this Hon'ble Court be pleased to:
a.
Pass an appropriate writ, direction or order
directing the Respondents No.2 to 4 to take
necessary steps in accordance with law, in relation
to the Representation dated 27.10.2025 filed by the
Petitioner,
seeking
an
enhancement
of
the
allocation in supply of ethanol to the Respondents
No.2 to 4 herein under Tender No.22376 dated
23.09.2025 for the Ethanol Supply Year 2025-26
which is produced as Annexure - "A".
AND/OR
b. Pass such other Order/s as this Hon'ble Court may
deem fit and proper in the ends of justice.
INTERIM PRAYER
Pending disposal of the above Writ Petition, the
Petitioner above named humbly prays that this Hon'ble
Court be pleased to:
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
a. Issue a direction to the Respondents No.2 to 4 to
revise the allotment made under Tender bearing
No.22376 dated 23.09.2025, in line with the terms
and conditions of the Long Term Offtake Agreement
(LTOA) entered into between the Petitioner and the
said Respondents No.2 to 4 herein.
AND/OR
b. Pass such other Order/s as this Hon'ble Court may
deem fit and proper in the ends of justice.”
13. The learned Single Judge on the ground that the
decision in the tender document regarding preferential allocation
to
dedicated
ethanol
plants
having
Long
Term
Offtake
Agreement is in violation of Clause 6.8 of the Long Term Offtake
Agreement, has granted the interim order as prayed for and has
passed the impugned order. Aggrieved by the same, the present
writ appeal is filed.
14. The case of the appellant/respondent in the writ
petition is that Clause 6.8 of the Long Term Offtake Agreement
is not violated by the condition mentioned in the tender
document. It is submitted that Clause 6.8 of the Long Term
Offtake Agreement must be incorporated as it is being subjected
to
the
ethanol
procurement
process
announced
by
the
respondents from time to time and subject to the said
procurement process, respondents will make their best endeavor
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
to purchase the ethanol from dedicated ethanol plants on
preferential basis. It is submitted that for the Ethanol Year 202526, the policy announced by the respondents requires to treat
the dedicated ethanol plants on equal footing as that of plants
which are not dedicated to produce only ethanol. It is submitted
that presently a quantity of 3.92 crore litres is being purchased
from the petitioner, which is over and above the promised 1.44
crore litres and hence, the petitioner cannot have any grievance.
For the said reason, it is prayed that the order passed by the
learned Single Judge be set aside.
15. The question that arises for consideration in the
present appeal is how Clause 6.8 of the agreement has to be
interpreted and whether it is advisable for the writ Court to
interfere in contractual matters entered into between the State
and private players.
16. Normally, Court should not interfere in contractual
matters, and the remedy for a person like the petitioner would
be to approach arbitration as per the Long Term Offtake
Agreement contains an arbitration clause. However, when facts
are not in dispute and it requires only an interpretation of the
contract and the action of the State is found to be arbitrary and
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
unreasonable on the face of it, the Court does interfere under
these circumstances.
17. Admittedly, there is a promise made out by the Union
of India urging private players to establish dedicated ethanol
plants, which led to
the
petitioner
herein establishing
a
dedicated ethanol plant and the Long Term Offtake Agreement
being entered into with the respondents.
18. The respondents are bound by Clause 6 of the Long
Term Offtake Agreement and Clause 6.8 pertains as to how
respondents have to procure the additional ethanol produced by
the petitioner over and above 1.44 crore litres per annum. They
have to give preferential allocation in ethanol procurement
process as per the agreed terms. It means that the tender
conditions floated every year by the respondents (in this case
the tender document for the year Ethanol Procurement Year
2025-26), cannot be contrary to the condition mentioned in
Clause 6.8 of the Long Term Offtake Agreement.
19. The decision of the respondents to treat the dedicated
ethanol plants on par with other ethanol producing units is in
violation of Clause 6.8. Other ethanol producing units, which are
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1172-DB
WA No. 100002 of 2026
HC-KAR
not dedicated for manufacturing of only ethanol, are having the
liberty to produce other products like sugar cane, alcohol,
denatured spirit and the like and market it elsewhere. Whereas,
dedicated ethanol plants have been established at the behest of
the Union of India by private players by taking huge financial
risk and not giving them the preferential treatment as agreed
upon, may have consequences disastrous to the very survival of
the said establishments.
20. Under the said circumstances, we do not see any error
in the interim order passed by the learned Single Judge and the
writ appeal is hereby dismissed.
In view of dismissal of the appeal, pending I.As., if any,
stand disposed of as not surviving for consideration.
Sd/(M.I.ARUN)
JUDGE
Sd/(B. MURALIDHARA PAI)
JUDGE
KMS, CKK
CT: ASC
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 0
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review