Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SYAM KUMAR V.M.
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RSA NO. 1060 OF 2010
ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED
15.02.2010 IN AS NO.122 OF 2008 OF I ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
JUDGE-I, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
ARISING OUT OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 26.10.2007 IN OS
NO.312 OF 2001 OF II ADDITIONAL SUB
COURT,THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
APPELLANT/APPELLANT/DEFENDANT:
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
KERALA STATE FILM DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LTD.,
CHALACHITRA BHAVAN, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
BY ADVS.
SRI.A.SUDHI VASUDEVAN
SRI.JOSE JONES JOSEPH, SC,
KERALA STATE FILM DEVELOPMENT CORPN. LTD.
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF:
KUMARI DEVI
D/O.G.SURESH, DEVI PRIYA, T.C.NO.73/905
(OLD T.C.NO.36/403), PALKULANGARA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,, PIN-695 002.
BY ADVS.
SRI.R.T.PRADEEP
SRI.V.VIJULAL
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 25.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 25th day of March, 2025
This appeal is filed challenging the judgment and decree
dated 15.02.2010 in A.S.No.122 of 2008 of the Additional District
Judge-I, Thiruvanathapuram and judgment and decree dated
26.10.2007 in O.S.No.312 of 2001 the II Additional Sub Court,
Thiruvananthapuram. Appellant was the defendant in the suit and
appellant before the First Appellate Court. Respondent was the
plaintiff in the suit and respondent before the First Appellate Court.
Parties are hereinafter referred to as per their status in the suit
2. On 31.12.1999, at around 2.00 P.M, the plaintiff who was a
minor, aged 12 years, went with her mother to watch a movie at the
Chalachitra Kalabhavan Theatre, Thiruvananthapuram. While they
were standing in the theatre premises, the iron gate of the theatre
collapsed and fell on the plaintiff. She sustained a hip bone fracture
(trochanteric fracture) and had to undergo inpatient treatment for a
period of 28 days. Alleging that the accident happened due to the
negligence of
the defendant,
a suit
seeking damages of
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
Rs.1,50,000/- with interest and cost was filed by the plaintiff. The
defendant filed a written statement inter alia contending that the suit
is not maintainable and that the claim is barred by limitation. The
incident happened due to reasons beyond the control of the
defendant and there was no negligence or breach of duty on the
part of the defendant or its employees. The trial court framed four
issues for consideration and the matter proceeded to trial. Exts.A1
to A7 were marked from the side of the plaintiff and PW1 and PW2
were examined. No evidence, neither documentary nor oral was
tendered from the side of the defendant. After the trial and hearing,
Sub Court decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff permitting her to
realise from the defendant a sum of Rs.1,50,000/- with interest. The
defendant filed A.S.No.122 of 2008 before the Additional District
Court-I, Thiruvananthapuram, challenging the judgment and decree
of the Sub Court. The First Appellate Court allowed the appeal in
part and modified the judgment and decree of the trial court by
passing a decree for realisation of Rs.77,800/- with interest at 6%
per annum from the date of suit till the date of recovery from the
defendant. Challenging the same, the defendant had filed this
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
R.S.A.
3. This Court admitted the second appeal on the following
substantial questions of law:
“1. Have the courts below erred in considering
the disputed facts involved in the case ignoring the
material evidence tendered and also settled
principles of law?
2. Whether Ext.A2 certificate assessing the
disability suffered by the plaintiff could have been
acted and relied upon by the court without other
material pieces of medical evidence showing the
injury suffered by the plaintiff ?”
4. Heard Sri.Jose Jones Joseph, Advocate for the
appellant/ defendant and Sri.R.T.Pradeep, Advocate for the
respondent/plaintiff.
5. Contentions of the appellant/ defendant in brief :
• The plaintiff had not been examined before the trial court. She
was aged 18 years at the time of trial and could have been
examined. Thus the best possible evidence that could have
been tendered had not been tendered.
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
• Examination of the plaintiff's father is improper and insufficient
evidence to decree the suit. The father had admittedly not
gone to the theatre and was not competent to depose on the
incident. He had only hearsay information.
• The plaintiff was an engineering student at the time of trial.
This fact alone reveals that the accident did not affect her
studies or educational faculties. Thus, claims made under the
said headings stand refuted.
• The doctor, who issued Ext.A2 disability certificate, had not
treated the plaintiff. He had only issued the disability
certificate which is dated 27.10.2000.
• The examination for the issuance of a disability certificate was
done after the plaintiff had attained 18 years, not earlier.
• The doctor had not even seen the medical records before
issuing the disability certificate.
• The permanent disability certificate does not disclose the
occupational disability of any. No data was available before
the doctor to satisfy himself regarding the plaintiff's disability.
The certificate produced is unreliable and issued without any
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
basis. No details regarding the X-ray are forthcoming, though
a fracture is stated to have occurred on the left side of the
pelvis. The testimony of PW2 thus cannot be relied upon.
• Res ipsa loqitur principle, which had been relied upon by the
defendant, ought to be specifically pleaded and proved. As
long as the same had not been undertaken by the plaintiff,
reliance on the said legal principle is misplaced and not
acceptable in law.
• The court did not have sufficient evidence to find that the
relevant gate was precariously positioned to cause danger or
injury. The plaintiff did not put forth any plea or evidence in
this respect. Reliance is placed on the dictum laid down in
H.M.T. Ltd. v. T.K.Simon [2009 (2) KHC 982] to contend that
unless there were specific allegations in this respect
substantiated with legally reliable evidence, no finding could
have been arrived at by the courts decreeing the suit.
• Reliance is placed on the dictum laid down in Hero Vinoth
(Minor) v. Sheshammal [2006 KHC 831] to support the
substantial question of law raised in this appeal and to
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
buttress its maintainability and relevance.
• No reason had been stated for not examining the plaintiff.
6. Contentions of the respondent/plaintiff :
• The findings of the trial court and the District Court are valid
and proper. They do not call for any interference. No
substantial question of law arises for consideration in the
matter.
• The defendant had a duty of care to ensure that the premises,
including the gate, did not injure or damage the public who
visited the theatre.
• The incident that occurred as well as what followed including
injury, its nature and hospitalisation are admitted by the
defendant.
• The trite principle of res ipsa loquitur squarely applies to the
case at hand and the incident and its very nature supports
and substantiates the claim put forth by the plaintiff.
• Reliance is placed on the dictum laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Kajal v. Jagdish Chand and others
[(2020) 4 SCC 413]
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
• Reliance is also placed on the dictum laid down by this Court
in National Insurance Co. Ltd. and others v. K.K.Assainar
and others [2019 KHC 685].
• What essentially matters is the functional disability that had
been caused to the plaintiff. Ext.A2 is in effect the assessment
of disability as per the McBride scale. It had been validly
assessed at 8%. The same has not been contested.
Discussion and Analysis :
7. The principal contention put forth by the defendant is
that the courts below erred in considering the disputed facts
involved in the matter and in properly appreciating the material
evidence tendered. It would hence be pertinent to begin by
examining the sustainability of the said contention put forth by the
appellant. The derailing of the iron gate within the premises of the
defendant on 31.12.1999 and the consequent injuries sustained by
the plaintiff have been unequivocally admitted by the defendant.
Ext.A7 reply notice issued at the instance of the defendant reads as
follows:
“It is admitted there occurred an accident in the
Kalabhavan theatre premises on 31.12.1999 by the
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
derailment of the gate and that the daughter of your
client sustained injury.”
It is in light of the above admission, that the defendant's contention
that there is absolutely nothing on record to show that the gate fell
on the respondent due to any defect in the gate or poor
maintenance of the gate has to be examined. The trial court had
specifically framed an issue on the said aspect and had elaborately
considered the evidence available on the point. It had been
concluded by the trial court, based on materials on record, that there
is an element of negligence or breach of duty on the part of the
defendant which led to the accident in which the plaintiff suffered
fracture injuries. The said finding has been affirmed by the First
Appellate Court, inter alia holding that once the defendants admitted
that the iron gate derailed, it will ipso facto reveal the negligence on
the part of the person who was bound to keep the gate in good
condition. It had also been validly concluded by the First Appellate
Court that if it was an act of god, for instance, due to any natural
calamity, the matter would have stood on a different footing.
However, derailing an iron gate within the premises maintained as
the entrance to the theatre would definitely reveal negligence on the
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
part of the authority or person who was bound to maintain the gate
and keep the theatre and its premises danger-free and in a safe
condition. The First Appellate Court had correctly concluded that the
very admission of the incident and the manner in which it occurred,
leading to the injuries to the plaintiff, effectively substantiated the
case put forth by the plaintiff for damages. The finding in this
respect arrived in the judgments under challenge, requiring no
interference.
8. Further, the law regarding res ipsa loquitur which is a
rule of evidence that essentially belongs to the law of torts is trite.
Inference
as
to
negligence
may
be
drawn
from
proved
circumstances by applying the said rule if no reasonable explanation
as to the cause is coming forth from the defendant. It is indeed for
the plaintiff to prove that the injury occurred due to the negligence of
the defendant and the mere fact that an accident has occurred the
cause of which is unknown, is not, evidence of negligence. But, the
peculiar circumstances, constituting the event or accident in a
particular case may themselves proclaim negligence of somebody
as the cause of the accident. Satisfaction of this condition alone is
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
not sufficient for res ipsa to come into play, and it has to be further
satisfied that the event which caused the accident was within the
defendant's control. Thus, the two-fold requirement for the
application of the maxim is that the res must not only speak of
negligence, but pin it on the defendant. [see Syad Akbar v. State of
Karnataka [(1980) 1 SCC 30]]. I note that these essential
requirements have been met by the plaintiff in the case at hand. The
defendant, on the other hand, had not produced any evidence
whatsoever to substantiate their contentions. The conclusions thus
arrived at by the trial court and the District Court on the said count
do not merit any interference.
9. Now I proceed to examine the next contention put forth by
the defendant that Ext.A2 certificate assessing the disability suffered
by the plaintiff ought not to have been acted upon or relied on by the
courts since the same was not substantiated by any other medical
evidence regarding the injury suffered by the plaintiff. The reliability
of Ext. A2 disability certificate had been considered by the trial court
elaborately. The deposition of the doctor (PW2) who served in the
Medical College Hospital, Thiruvananthapuram, who had issued the
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
certificate is also seen to have been scrutinised by the court
thoroughly. The principal objection put forth against Ext.A2 and the
deposition of PW2 is that nothing had been produced to show that
the plaintiff had been an inpatient at the Medical College Hospital
and that a doctor attached to the Medical College has no authority
to issue a certificate to a patient who is a stranger and not treated in
the said hospital. These objections had been rightly found by the
trial court to be of technical in nature and had been turned down by
the First Appellate Court too. Nothing to controvert the findings
arrived at by the said courts has been brought to my notice.
10. Contentions have been put forth regarding the correctness
of the amounts awarded by the court as damages to the plaintiff.
The different heads under which various amounts have been
awarded and their quantification have been challenged and termed
to be devoid of evidence. Mindful of the jurisdiction exercised by this
Court in a second appeal wherein the substantial questions of law
alone arise for consideration, the said contention does not merit
consideration and is declined.
11. Owners or operators/ managers of public places like
RSA NO.1060/2010
2025:KER:24766
theatres and malls have an obligation/duty/responsibility to maintain
such premises safe and danger-free. They should be made safe for
anyone who may enter the said premises whether or not they are
customers or viewers who pay to avail the facilities provided therein.
Anyone who runs such a place of open public access, must keep
entrances and exits clear from any unreasonable dangers and must
repair any dangers that exist or may potentially arise. If such
persons are negligent in their duty to maintain the premises and in
keeping visitors safe, they shall be liable for any injuries caused by
the danger that lurks therein.
Conclusion
12. The above discussion answers the substantial
questions of law in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant.
Accordingly, I find no reason to interfere with the judgment and
decree of the District Court and the Sub Court.
R.S.A. is dismissed with costs.
Sd/-
SYAM KUMAR V.M.
JUDGE
csl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review