Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:1:2025:KER:26097
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. KRISHNA KUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(KAT) NO. 81 OF 2025
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 02.09.2024 IN OA (EKM) NO.172 OF 2022 OF
KERALA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL AT THIRUVANANTHAPURAM (ADDITIONAL BENCH,
ERNAKULAM)
PETITIONER/S:
THE KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION,
THULASI HILLS, PATTOM PALACE P O, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, PIN - 695004
SECRETARY,
KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION, THULASI HILLS, PATTOM
PALACE P O, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695004
THE DISTRICT OFFICER,
THE KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION, DISTRICT OFFICE,
THRISSUR, PIN - 680020
BY ADV P.C.SASIDHARAN
RESPONDENT/S:
HIMA K.S,D/O SIVARAMAN K.K,
AGED 37 YEARS
KARIPPERY HOUSE, ANCHERY P.O, THRISSUR, PIN - 680006
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:2:2025:KER:26097
VIJI A.S,
AGED 31 YEARS
D/O SIDDHARTHA KUMAR A, AKAVALAPPIL HOUSE, MANITHARA,
AVANOOR P.O, THRISSUR, PIN - 680541
RAMYA O.S,
AGED 37 YEARS
D/O SIVARAMAN O.M, THATHUVARA HOUSE, CHEMBUCHIRA P.O,
KARICHAL THRISSUR, PIN - 680684
RENJITHA T.C,
AGED 31 YEARS
D/O CHANDRAN T.M, MANAKKALATH HOUSE, THANDIALAM,
VELLATTANJUR P.O, THRISSUR, PIN - 680601
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY CHIEF SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS DEPARTMENT,
SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
GENERAL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
DIRECTOR OF GENERAL EDUCATION,
DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL EDUCATION, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN 695001
DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION,
OFFICE OF DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION, THRISSUR, PIN 680001
BY ADV ARUNA A
SENIOR GOVERNMENT PLEADER SHRI A.J.VARGHESE
THIS OP KERALA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION
ON 24.03.2025, THE COURT ON 26.03.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:3:2025:KER:26097
JUDGMENT
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
A.Muhamed Mustaque, J.
A notification was issued for the post of Last Grade Servants in
various departments in 14 districts, including Thrissur district, by the
Kerala Public Service Commission (PSC) on 12/05/2017. The ranked
list came into force on 30/06/2018. The ranked list was due to expire
on 29/06/2021. The PSC extended the validity period of the ranked
list due to the outbreak of COVID-19 up to 04/08/2021. However,
taking note of the COVID pandemic and based on different challenges
before this Court and the Tribunal, the ranked list period was
extended and finally expired on 29/09/2021. On 02/08/2021, the
office of the Deputy Director of Education, Thrissur, reported 11
vacancies for the post of Office Assistants in Thrissur district. It was
mentioned in the proforma that these 11 vacancies were anticipated
vacancies. On 04/08/2021, a request was made from the office of
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:4:2025:KER:26097
the Deputy Director of Education, Thrissur, to revoke 8 vacancies out
of the 11 vacancies reported. It was stated that out of those who
were promoted as Lab Assistants from the post of Office Assistants,
8 had relinquished their promotion, and therefore, only 3 vacancies
exist. Accordingly, it was requested that Proforma ID 21505, dated
02/08/2021, be revoked in respect of 11 vacancies. On 03/08/2021,
another proforma was forwarded from the office of the Education
Department, reporting 11 vacancies. This proforma stated that 11
vacancies existed as on 01/08/2021. The PSC, acting on a letter
dated 04/08/2021, advised on 3 vacancies. Thereafter, it is seen that
on 22/11/2021, a request was made from the Deputy Director of
Education to issue advice for 8 vacancies; PSC did not act on that
request.
2.
The respondents are the applicants before the Tribunal.
They were included in the ranked list for appointment as Office
Assistants in Thrissur District. They approached the Tribunal, seeking
a direction to the PSC to issue advice for vacancies based on the
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:5:2025:KER:26097
Proforma for reporting vacancies issued by the Deputy Director of
Education.
3.
The PSC took the stand that they issued advice for 3
substantive vacancies, and 8 out of the 11 vacancies arose after
03/08/2021; and since the ranked list expired on 04/08/2021, they
cannot issue advice for the subsequently arisen vacancies. The case
was filed in the year 2022. If the ranked list expired on 04/08/2021,
PSC was justified in its stand.
4.
Two questions arise: first, about vacancies that arose after
the expiry of the ranked list on 04/08/2021; and second, about the
effect of the cancellation of the proforma.
Point No. i
5.
This Court vide judgment in OP(KAT) No. 359/2021, dated
17/06/2022, ordered that the ranked list would stand extended by
three months. The PSC had challenged the above judgment before
the Apex Court. The Apex Court dismissed the above challenge in
SLP No.104-113/2023 on 29/07/2024.
Therefore, based on the
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:6:2025:KER:26097
direction of this Court, the validity of the ranked list was extended
upto 29/09/2021. According to the Department of Education, 8
vacancies arose as detailed below.
31/08/2021
By transfer appointment
By transfer appointment
08/09/2021
By transfer appointment
10/09/2021
By transfer appointment
23/09/2021
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:7:2025:KER:26097
15/09/2021
By transfer appointment
13/10/2021
By transfer appointment
02/11/2021
By transfer appointment
22/11/2021
By transfer appointment
Out of the 8 vacancies, 5 vacancies arose prior to 29/09/2021.
6.
The argument of the learned Standing Counsel for the PSC
is that all these vacancies have arisen after the expiry of the ranked
list and, therefore, in the light of the judgments of the Full Bench of
this Court in Vimala Kumari v. State [1994 KHC 295] and Kerala
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:8:2025:KER:26097
Public Service Commission and Another v. Sheejamol M. C.
and Others [2020 (5) KHC 555], as well as the judgments of the
Division Bench in Balakrishnan v. PSC [1994 KHC 119] and
Public Service Commission v. Govindan [2000 KHC 9], this
Court cannot direct the PSC to make appointments based on such
vacancies.
7.
The Court cannot direct issuance of advice from the
expired ranked list.
We find that the above judgments have no
application in this matter. Admittedly, 5 vacancies arose before the
expiry of the extended period of the ranked list on 29/09/2021.
Point No.ii
8.
The PSC takes the stand that once the proforma has been
cancelled and revoked, PSC cannot issue advice to the candidates
included in the ranked list, based on the cancelled proforma. This
argument is raised on a wrong impression that there was a
cancellation or revocation of the vacancies reported in the proforma.
There was no clarity on this before the Tribunal. The PSC produced
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:9:2025:KER:26097
the proformas issued to them by the Deputy Director of Education,
which are marked as Exts.P7 and P8 before this Court along with
I.A.No.1/2025. As seen from Ext.P8, what was cancelled was Ext.P7
proforma dated 02/08/2021. In this proforma, the nature of
vacancies reported was anticipated vacancies as on 1/09/2021.
Thereafter, another proforma was issued on 03/08/2021, wherein 11
vacancies were reported and the nature of the vacancies was stated
as fresh vacancies as on 01/08/2021. There is no cancellation of the
proforma issued on 03/08/2021. Therefore, the PSC cannot contend
that there was revocation or cancellation of the proforma.
The
question then is whether the vacancies that arose subsequently
during the extended period of the ranked list can be treated as a part
of the proforma dated 03/08/2021, wherein it was reported that
vacancies existed on 01/08/2021, although such vacancies did not
exist at that time.
9.
As seen from various records produced before this Court,
there were no substantive vacancies of 11 as on 01/08/2021. The
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:10:2025:KER:26097
vacancies, as referred now, have arisen after 04/08/2021, i.e, the
original date on which the ranked list was to expire, but have arisen
during the extended validity period of the ranked list up to
29/09/2021, by the order of this Court in OP(KAT) No. 359/2021.
There is no embargo under law for the PSC in advising candidates
from a ranked list, though such vacancies were not in existence when
it was reported to PSC, but have arisen during the extended validity
of the ranked list. If substantive vacancies have arisen during the
validity of the ranked list, it does not make any difference for the
PSC, as such vacancies were only probable at the time of submission
of the proforma for reporting vacancies. The PSC resisted this case
as there were no substantive vacancies as on 04/08/2021, and also
on the impression that the Deputy Director of Education had
cancelled or revoked 8 out of 11 reported vacancies. This stand of
the PSC is factually incorrect in the light of the extension of the
validity of the list and also on the fact that there was no cancellation
of the proforma dated 03/08/2021.
In such circumstances, the
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:11:2025:KER:26097
Tribunal was justified in directing the PSC to issue advice memos for
the 5 vacancies that arose during the extended period of the ranked
list.
The original petition stands dismissed.
Sd/- A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE, JUDGE
Sd/- P. KRISHNA KUMAR, JUDGE
ms
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:12:2025:KER:26097
APPENDIX OF OP(KAT) 81/2025
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure A1
TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF THE RANKED
LIST FOR THE POST OF LAST GRADE SERVANT IN
THRISSUR DISTRICT IN VARIOUS DEPARTMENTS DATED
30/06/2018 (NO.460/2018/DOR AND CAT.NO.071/2017)
Annexure A2
TRUE COPY OF THE PROFORMA FOR REPORTING VACANCIES
DATED 03/08/2021 ISSUED FROM THE OFFICE OF THE
DEPUTY DIRECTOR OFFICER, THRISSUR
Annexure A3
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY NO. DDETSR/5239/2021-A6
DATED 13/01/2022 ISSUED BY THE SENIOR
SUPERINTENDENT AND STATE PUBLIC INFORMATION
OFFICER, OFFICER OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF THE
EDUCATION,THRISSUR
Annexure A4
TRUE COPY OF THE STATUS OF POT DETAILS DOWNLOADED
FROM THEOFFICIAL WEBSITE OF THE KERALA PUBLIC
SERVICE COMMISSION
Annexure A5
TRUE COPY OF THE APPOINTMENT CHART REGARDING
ADVISE ISSUED ON 06/10/2021 ISSUED BY THE KERALA
PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION, DISTRICT OFFICE
THRISSUR
Annexure A6
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION UNDER RIGHT O
INFORMATION ACT SUBMITTED BY THE 2ND APPLICANT TO
THE DISTRICT PSC OFFICE, THRISSUR DATED
22.11.2021
Annexure A7
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY NO. RIV(1) 2215/2014-2
DATED 13/12/2021 ISSUED FROM THE DISTRICT PSC
OFFICE, THRISSUR
Annexure A8
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION UNDER RIGHT TO
INFORMATION ACT SUBMITTED BY THE 2ND APPLICANT TO
THE 3RD RESPONDENT DATED 22/11/2021
Annexure A9
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY NO.DDETSR/4405/2021-A6
DATED 06/12/2021 ISSUED FROM THE OFFICE OF THE
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:13:2025:KER:26097
3RD RESPONDENT
Annexure A10
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION UNDER RIGHT TO
INFORMATION ACT SUBMITTED BY SRI.RAJITHA.C.R. T
THE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICER,EDUCATION
DEPARTMENT THRISSUR DATED 17/12/2021
Annexure A11
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY NO.DDETSR/5239/2021-A6
DATED 31/12/2021 ISSUED TO SRI.RAJITHA C.R. FROM
THE OFFICE OF THE 3RD RESPONDENT
Annexure A12
TRUE COPY OF THE CIRCULAR NO. C3/149/18/P&ARD
DATED 10/08/2018 ISSUED BY THE SPECIAL SECRETARY
PERSONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS (ADVISE-C)
DEPARTMENT
Annexure A13
TRUE COPY OF THE G.O.MS NO. 13/2021/P&ARD DATED
08/06/2021
Annexure A14
TRUE COPY OF THE G.O.MS NO.5/2021/P&ARD DATED
13/02/2021
Annexure A15
TRUE COPY OF THE G.O.(A) 13/2015/P & ARD DATED
21/03/2015
Annexure R5(a)
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.AD D2/9964/2010/HSE
DATED 26/7/2021
Annexure R5(b)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.A6/9418/2021 DATED
13/10/2021
Annexure R5(c)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.A6/9148/2021 DATED
22.11.2021
Annexure R5(d)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.A6/9418/2021 DATED
03/01/2022
Annexure A16
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION UNDER RIGHT TO
INFORMATION ACT DATED 24.12.2021 FILED BY THE
APPLICANT NO.4
Annexure A17
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY NO. DDETSR/225/2022-A6
DATED 15.01.2022 ISSUED BY THE STATE PUBLIC
[OP(KAT) No.81/2025]
-:14:2025:KER:26097
INFORMATION OFFICER, OFFICE OF THEDEPUTY DIRECTOR
OF EDUCATION
Exhibit P1
THE TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION IN O.A (EKM)
172/2022
Exhibit P2
THE TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT DATED
18/04/2022 FILED BY THE COMMISSION
Exhibit P3
THE TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT OF THE 5TH
RESPONDENT DATED 30/6/2022
Exhibit P4
A TRUE COPY OF M.A (EKM) 1176/2022 DATED 1/7/2022
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REPLY STATEMENT DATED
23/09/2022
Exhibit P6
THE TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN O.A (EKM) 172/2022
DATED 2/9/2024 PASSED BY THE TRIBUNAL
Exhibit P7
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROFORMA FOR REPORTING
VACANCIES DATED 02-08-2021, ISSUED BY THE
ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT OF THE 9TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit P8
THE TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 3/8/2021 ISSUED
BY THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION, THRISSUR TO
THE DISTRICT OFFICER OF THE COMMISSION
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review