Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
!#
$
%
%
&
&
"
"
"
!
"
$$
(
Digitally signed
by SACHIN
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!
"
#
$
!
%
'
$
)
!
-2-
&
"
''
(
& ''
&
#
)
)
*
!+
*
!
*
#
*
*
, "
*
)
, "
-
'
*
)
)
(
(
.
)
)
.
)
)
/01
*
-3-
"
(
.
&
)
)!
23 /44355/067 2/83 9:531 62:7 :06;/
>2/5530?:0? /0 <;13; 1/631
53/;031
:0?53
<
-
)=1?3
<=;6 /443/5
' 4/7731 @A 623
<9
62:7
<=;6
:0
, "
;:395A 76/631 623 9/>67 <9 623 >/73 /;3 62/6 623
;374<01306
0?:033;
<
B/7 /44<:0631 /7 /0
53>6;:>/5!
77:76/06
C3>=6:83
134/;6D306/5 :0E=:;A B/7 :0:6:/631
/?/:076 2:D 9<; 0<6 6/F:0? 76347 6< 4;38306 353>6;:>:6A
62396
23 1:7>:45:0/;A /=62<;:6A 4/7731 /0 <;13; >307=;:0?
;374<01306
1:7>:45:0/;A
<
=;:0?
4;<>331:0?7
/
430130>A
134/;6D306/5
<9
4;<D<6:<0
><DD:6633 B/7 2351 /01 623 >/73 <9 ;374<01306
<
F346 :0 / 73/531 ><83;
77:76/06
C3>=6:83
0 623 D3/0B2:53
B/7
0?:033;7 45/>31 @35<B 2:D :0 623 <;13; <9
730:<;:6A B3;3 4;<D<631 /7 43; / 0<6:9:>/6:<0 1/631
#
&
;34;37306/6:<0 1/631
;374<01306
&
<
7=@D:6631
/
& 6< ;376<;3 2:7 730:<;:6A :0
-4-
623 >/1;3 <9
77:76/06
/@<83 3D45<A33
<
C3>=6:83
' && /01 6< ?:83 2:D 4;<D<6:<0 @A
<430:0? 623 73/531 ><83;
;374<01306
<
3993>6 9;<D
0?:033; /01 6< 45/>3 2:D
23 ;34;37306/6:<0 7=@D:6631 @A
B/7 0<6 ><07:13;31 9<; 4;<D<6:<0 B:62
#
&
23;39<;3 23 7=@D:6631 /0<623;
#
-
;34;37306/6:<0 1/631
/7 ;374<01306
<
B/7
0<6 ?:830 623 @3039:6 <9 4;<D<6:<0 B:62 3993>6 9;<D 623
1/631
#
&
23 9:531
=;:0? 430130>A <9
<
<
4;<D<631 ;374<01306
'
1/631
, "
<
/7
, "
623 /44355/06
C3>=6:83
0?:033; <0
<0 :0G>2/;?3 @/7:7 7=@H3>6 6< 623 ;37=56 <9 623
B;:6 436:6:<0 9:531 :0
'
<
23 53/;031
-
H=1?D306 <9 /
<
, "
:0?53 )=1?3 :0 63;D7 <9 623 <;13;
' 2351 62/6 623 :77=3 B/7 ><83;31 @A 623
:8:7:<0
30>2 <9 62:7
<=;6 :0 623 >/73 <9
I
<
623;39<;3 623 <;13; <9 4;<D<6:<0 1/631
' -"
,J /01
'
53/8:0?
<=6 623 436:6:<03; 9;<D ><07:13;:0? 2:D 9<; 4;<D<6:<0
-5-
1=;:0? 623 134/;6D306/5 4;<D<6:<0 ><DD:6633 :7 5:/@53 6<
@3 E=/7231
23 53/;031
:0?53 )=1?3 :77=31 / 1:;3>6:<0 6<
623 /44355/067 6< ><07:13; 623 >/73 <9 623 436:6:<03; :0
/>><;1/0>3 B:62 5/B 9<; 9=;623; 4;<D<6:<0
23 /44355/067
@3:0? /??;:3831 @A 623 7/:1 <;13; /;3 @39<;3 62:7
#
53/;031
><=0735
9<;
<=;6
/44355/067
><0630131 62/6 623 4;<D<6:<0 6< 623 03C6 2:?23; 4<76 :7
7=@H3>6
6<
1=3
7/6:79/>6:<0
<9
D/:06/:0:0? / >53/0 73;8:>3 ;3><;1
/44355/067
/01
3 ><063017 62/6 /963;
623 134/;6D306/5 30E=:;A B/7 ><0>5=131 623 1:7>:45:0/;A
/=62<;:6A 4/7731 /0 <;13; >307=;:0? 623 ;374<01306
3 623;39<;3 ><063017 62/6 ;374<01306
<
<
B/7 0<6
306:6531 6< @3 ><07:13;31 9<; 4;<D<6:<0 /01 23 B/7 0<6
306:6531 9<; ?366:0? 623 73/531 ><83; <43031
3 ><063017
62/6 623 5/B :7 B355 7366531 :0 8:3B <9 623 H=1?D306 <9 623
<0K@53
43C
'
!
<=;6 :0 623 >/73 <9
*+ *
*,+- '.
;34<;631 :0 "##" $ %
"&# /01 623
9<55<B:0? H=1?D3067(
:!
6/63 <9
/01 /0<623;
L=;372:
-6-
I
::!
--&! -
0:<0 <9 01:/ /01
I
:::!
:8!
8!
8:!
J
,!
#
;7
/H/762/0 %
/;D/; I
! #
;7
/H/?<4/5/0 /01
;7 I
0:<0 <9 01:/ %
;7
/D
72:72
;/D:0
/0F
:C:6
2/0F/;
:766 /01
;7
/5
' J
<553>6<; <9 2/0H/8=;
=44 '!
<2/0/0
J
6/63 <9
I --
!7
# J
;:720/0
J
2/:;D/0
61 /01
0; I
=;8/0>2/5
'!
' -J
3 9=;623; ><0630131 62/6 /0 <;13; <9 >307=;3
:7 / D:0<; 4=0:72D306 /01 623;39<;3 623 ;374<01306
<
B/7 0<6 306:6531 6< @3 4;<D<631 B:62 3993>6 9;<D 623 1/63
2:7 H=0:<;7 B3;3 4;<D<631
53/;031
3 623;39<;3 ><063017 62/6 623
:0?53 )=1?3 ><DD:6631 /0 3;;<; :0 ?;/06:0? 623
@3039:6 B:62 3993>6 9;<D 623 1/63 B230 623 H=0:<;7 <9
;374<01306
<
B3;3 4;<D<631
-7-
623 53/;031 ><=0735 9<; ;374<01306
<
><0630131 62/6 /6 623 134/;6D306/5 30E=:;A 62<=?2
623;3 :7 0< 9:01:0? /?/:076 ;374<01306
<
@=6 A36 623
1:7>:45:0/;A /=62<;:6A >=;7<;:5A >307=;31 ;374<01306
<
3 7=@D:67 62/6 / 43;=7/5 <9 623 <;13; <9 623 1:7>:45:0/;A
/=62<;:6A :67359 72<B7 62/6 623 ;374<07:@:5:6A <9 D/:06/:0:0?
623 5:03 /01 307=;:0? 62/6 623;3 :7 0< 62396 <9 353>6;:>:6A :7
=4<0 623
:03D/0
)=0:<;
0?:033; /01 623
>><=067
=43;:06301306
3 ><063017 62/6 623 ;374<01306
B/7 /0
C3>=6:83
77:76/06
<
0?:033; /01 623 D/:0630/0>3
<9 623 5:03 <; 6/F:0? 76347 6< 76<4 62396 <9 353>6;:>:6A /963;
623 7/D3 B/7 ;34<;631 @A 623 D363; ;3/13;
B:62:0 2:7 H<@ 4;<9:53
3 ><063017 62/6 /0 <;13; <9 >307=;3
:7 4/7731 B/;0:0? 623 ;374<01306
/>67
B/7 0<6
<
0<6 6< ;343/6 7=>2
3 623;39<;3 ><063017 62/6 3C>346 /0 <;13; <9
>307=;3 623;3 :7 0< 73;:<=7 <;13; <9 4=0:72D306 4/7731
/?/:076 ;374<01306
=013; 623
<06;<5 /01
<
0 /11:6:<0 23 ><063017 62/6
D45<A337K
443/5!
5/77:9:>/6:<0
3?=5/6:<07
-&,
:7>:45:0/;A
9<; 72<;6
M623
-8-
=537
-&,! 623 D:0<; 430/56:37 /;3 >307=;3 /01 /57<
B:622<51:0?
<9
4;<D<6:<0
><063017
62/6
1:7>:45:0/;A /=62<;:6A 2/1 <05A :D4<731 >307=;3 /01 1:1
0<6 B:622<51 623 4;<D<6:<0 <9 ;374<01306
<
23;39<;3
23 ><063017 62/6 @A 8:;6=3 <9 623 :D4=?031 <;13;
;374<01306
<
:7 4=0:7231 B:622<51:0? <9 4;<D<6:<0
623;39<;3 ><063017 62/6 623 :D4=?031 <;13; 4/7731 @A 623
53/;031
:0?53 )=1?3 :7 H=76 /01 4;<43; /01 1<37 0<6
B/;;/06 /0A :063;93;30>3 /6 623 2/017 <9 62:7
<=;6
/57< ><063017 62/6 623 E=376:<0 B23623; /0 <;13; <9
>307=;3 B<=51 ><D3 :0 623 B/A <9 ?;/06:0? 4;<D<6:<0 B/7
><07:13;31
<
@A
/
,',-"
:8:7:<0
30>2
62:7
<=;6
:0
' /01 :6 B/7 2351 62/6 /0 <;13; <9
>307=;3 B<=51 0<6 ><D3 :0 623 B/A
62/6 ;374<01306
<9
<
3 623;39<;3 ><063017
:7 >53/;5A 306:6531 6< 623 @3039:6 <9
4;<D<6:<0
,
3 2/83 ><07:13;31 623 7=@D:77:<07 <9 623
53/;031 ><=0735 9<; 623 /44355/067 /01 623 53/;031 ><=0735
9<; 623 ;374<01306
<
-9-
&
43;=7/5 <9 623 <;13; <9 623 1:7>:45:0/;A
/=62<;:6A >307=;:0? 623 ;374<01306
<
72<B7 62/6 623
30E=:;A B/7 :0 ;3743>6 <9 6B< >2/;?37 0/D35A
76347 B3;3 0<6 6/F30 /?/:076 623
:! 62/6
76<03 >;=723;7 B2<
2/1 ><003>631 623:; 76<03 >=66:0? 3E=:4D306 1:;3>65A 6<
<83;23/1
=0/=62<;:N315A
5:037
/01
B3;3
1;/B:0?
353>6;:>:6A
::! 62/6 7<D3 353>6;:> B:;37 B3;3 2/0?:0?
/01 2/1 9/5530 6< 623 ?;<=01 /01 0< 76347 B3;3 6/F30
1:7>:45:0/;A /=62<;:6A /963; 43;=7:0? 623 ;34<;6 <9 623
30E=:;A <99:>3; 2351 62/6 :0 ;3743>6 <9 62396 <9 353>6;:>:6A
623 D363; ;3/13; 2/1 D306:<031 /@<=6 623 62396 <9
353>6;:>:6A :0 623
3?:763; /01 623
3>6:<0
99:>3; B2<
B/7 ;374<07:@53 9<; 6/F:0? />6:<0 1:1 0<6 6/F3 /0A />6:<0
:F3B:73 :0 ;3743>6 <9 353>6;:> B:;37 62/6 2/1 9/5530 6< 623
?;<=01 623 1:7>:45:0/;A /=62<;:6A 2351 62/6 :6 B/7 623 1=6A
<9 623
:03D/0 /01 623
3>6:<0
99:>3; 6< 307=;3 62/6 623
5:037 B3;3 4;<43;5A D/:06/:031
23 1:7>:45:0/;A /=62<;:6A
623;39<;3 4;<>33131 /?/:076 623
3>6:<0
99:>3; /7 B355 /7
- 10 -
:03D/0 /01 23 :D4<731 430/56A
;374<01306
<
7=43;:<; <9 623
7 9/; /7 623
:7 ><0>3;031 7:0>3 23 B/7 623 <99:>:/5
3>6:<0
<9 >307=;3 B/7 4/7731
99:>3; /01 623
:03D/0 /0 <;13;
2:7 B/7 =42351 @A 623 /44355/63
/=62<;:6A
-
23 1:>6:<0/;A D3/0:0? <9 M>307=;3K :7 9<55<B7(
'
23;39<;3
;374<01306
<
:6 :7 D<;3 62/0 /44/;306 62/6 623
B/7
>307=;31
0<6
@3>/=73
<9
><D45:>:6A @=6 @3>/=73 23 B/7 / 7=43;:<; <9 623
99:>3; /01 623 :03D/0
4;:D/;:5A /?/:076 623
2:7
3>6:<0
0 <623; B<;17 623 >2/;?37 B3;3
3>6:<0
99:>3; /7 B355 /7 623
:03D30 /7 :6 B/7 623:; ;374<07:@:5:6A 6< 6/F3 76347 6< 76<4
623 62396 <9 353>6;:>:6A /01 /57< D/:06/:0 623 5:037
623;39<;3 38:1306 62/6 623 ;374<01306
<
6 :7
B/7 >/7=/55A
8:7:631 B:62 /0 <;13; <9 >307=;3 B2:>2 :7 / D:0<; 430/56A
374<01306
<
B2< B/7 306:6531 6< 4;<D<6:<0 6< 623
- 11 -
03C6
2:?23;
4<76
<9
C3>=6:83
0?:033;
B/7
0<6
><07:13;31 :0 8:3B <9 623 430130>A <9 623 134/;6D306/5
30E=:;A /01 623;39<;3 /7 43; 623 4;38/5306 ;=537 ;35/6:0? 6<
4;<D<6:<0 / 73/531 ><83; 4;<>31=;3 B/7 /1<4631
<9 623 <;13; <9 >307=;3
623 ;374<01306
<
0 8:3B
B/7 0<6
?:830 623 @3039:6 <9 4;<D<6:<0 @=6 B/7 623;3/963; ?;/0631
4;<D<6:<0 <0 :0G>2/;?3 @/7:7 D3/0:0? 623;3@A 62/6 623
;374<01306
<
<9
0?:033;
C3>=6:83
623 53/;031
B/7 45/>31 @35<B 2:7 H=0:<;7 :0 623 >/1;3
6 :7 62:7 62/6 B/7 >2/5530?31 @39<;3
:0?53 )=1?3 /01 623 53/;031
:0?53 )=1?3
;35A:0? =4<0 623 H=1?D306 :0 623 >/73 <9 623
I
,
,
' -"
,
1:74<731 <99 <0
&J 2351 62/6 623 :77=3 B/7 9=55A ><83;31 @A 623
H=1?D306 <9 623
<
<
:8:7:<0
30>2
23;39<;3 623 ;374<01306
B/7 306:6531 6< @3 4;<D<631 9;<D 623 1/63 2:7 H=0:<;7
B3;3 4;<D<631 0<6B:6276/01:0? 623 <;13; <9 >307=;3
7 ;:?265A ><0630131 @A 623 53/;031 ><=0735 9<;
623 ;374<01306
<
3?=5/6:<07
-&, 4;37>;:@3
- 12 -
D:0<; 430/56:37 <03 <9 B2:>2 :7 >307=;3 /01 /0<623; :7
B:622<51:0?
<9
4;<D<6:<0
:076/06
>/73
;374<01306
<
B/7 8:7:631 B:62 <05A /0 <;13; <9 >307=;3
/01 0<6 /0 <;13; <9 B:622<51:0? <9 4;<D<6:<0
>2/;?37 /?/:076 ;374<01306
<
9 623
B/7 7383;3 6230 623
1:7>:45:0/;A /=62<;:6A B<=51 2/83 :D4<731 / 430/56A <9
B:622<51:0?
<B383;
>307=;3
<9
4;<D<6:<0
6<
;374<01306
23 2/7 >2<730 <05A 6< :D4<73 /0 <;13; <9
23;39<;3 623 ;374<01306
733F 9<; 4;<D<6:<0
<
<83;0D306
-
99:>:/5
-&
B/7 306:6531 6<
0 62:7 ;3?/;1 :6 :7 ;3538/06 6< 0<63
623 <99:>:/5 D3D<;/01=D :77=31 @A 623
1/631
<
3D<;/01=D
/01
</;1 /1<46:0? 623
<
&#
-' 1/631
#
,
--'
B2:>2 ;35/631 6< 623 4;<>31=;3 6< @3 9<55<B31 :0 ;3743>6 <9
4;<D<6:<07 B230 134/;6D306/5 30E=:;A"><=;6 4;<>331:0?7
/;3 4301:0? /?/:076 /0A
@A
53/;031
<&
- "
</;1 3D45<A33 B2:>2 B/7 0<631
:0?53
)=1?3
<9
62:7
B2:>2 ;3/17 /7 9<55<B7(
<=;6
:0
- 13 -
(
) *' +
!
"
#"
$
%
"
&
"
$
%
'
&
"
"
"
!
"
&
"
"
"
- 14 -
"
!
7 ;:?265A ><0630131 @A 53/;031 ><=0735 9<; 623
;374<01306
<
/0 <;13; <9 >307=;3 1:1 0<6 ;3/55A /993>6
623 73;8:>3 ><01:6:<07 <9 623 ;374<01306
/>631 /7 / B/;0:0?
<
@=6 <05A
2:7 623;39<;3 /6 /0A ;/63 >/00<6
134;:83 623 ;374<01306
<
<9 623 4;<D<6:<0/5 4;<743>67
B2:>2 23 B/7 <623;B:73 306:6531 6<
<
'
:8:7:<0
' -"
, 2/1 =42351 623 H=1?D306 <9 623 53/;031
:0?53 )=1?3 :0
30>2 <9 62:7
<&
- "
<=;6 :0
;:6
443/5
B2:>2 B/7 /57< =013;
7:D:5/; >:;>=D76/0>37 /01 623 7/:1 H=1?D306 2/7 @3><D3
9:0/5 /7 623 /44355/067 2/83 />>34631 623 7/D3
H=1?D3067 ;35:31 =4<0 @A 623 53/;031 ><=0735 9<; 623
/44355/067 /;3 1:76:0?=:72/@53 <0 9/>67 /7 :0 62<73 >/737
623;3 B/7 0< 4;37>;:46:<0 <9 430/56A <9 >307=;3 /01
B:622<51:0? <9 4;<D<6:<0
23;39<;3
B230 623 D:0<;
4=0:72D3067 B3;3 1:76:0>6 /01 1:993;306 :0 @<62 623 >/737
623 H=1?D3067 ;35:31 =4<0 @A 623 53/;031 ><=0735 9<; 623
- 15 -
/44355/067 >/00<6 /993>6 623 4;<D<6:<0 62/6 623 ;374<01306
<
:7 306:6531 6<
#
0 62/6 8:3B <9 623 D/663; B3 1< 0<6 733 /0A
3;;<; :0 623 <;13; 4/7731 @A 623 53/;031
B/;;/06:0? :063;93;30>3
>><;1:0?5A
:0?53 )=1?3
623 B;:6 /443/5 :7
,/
(
")
"
,/
( !
:76
<(
<( -
"
"
'
!)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review