The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
05. 10.2009 and then reinstated on 20.07.2010. In the meantime, he was earlier dismissed from service on 23.10.2007 but reinstated on 05.05.2008. There were serious allegations of WA NO. 334 OF 2014 2025:KER:30678 mismanagement raised against the 1st respondent. According to the appellants, when the audit was conducted in the Bank it was found that the 1st respondent had drawn an excess salary of Rs.3,05,554/-. It is true that in Ext.R1(e) this Court directed the Joint Registrar to take a decision regarding the entitlement of the 1st respondent for the salary drawn during the period he worked as Assistant Secretary or the Secretary. In that Judgment, it was found that the impact of the decision of the Joint Registrar refusing to approve the suggestion of the Society to grant exemption from educational qualification to the 1st respondent would entitle only to be at least the re-positioning of the 1st respondent in the hierarchy of the establishment. But in that judgment, it was not found categorically that the 1st respondent was not liable to repay any amount to the appellant Bank in respect of the excess salary drawn. In pursuance to the direction in Ext.R1(e) judgment, Ext. R1(f) order was passed by the Joint Registrar. In that order it was found that the 1st respondent is liable to pay the excess drawn salary to the appellant Bank.
11. It is stated in the appeal memorandum that another matter is pending between the parties before the Arbitration Court WA NO. 334 OF 2014 2025:KER:30678 for recovery of more than Rs.9,00,000/- from the 1st respondent. In view of Rule 198(7) of KCS Rules, the Bank cannot issue a nonliability certificate for disbursal of pensionary benefits due to the 1st respondent. The learned Single Judge failed to consider this aspect while passing the impugned judgment. In such circumstances, the impugned judgment is only liable to be set aside. In the result, the writ appeal is allowed by setting aside the judgment dated 06.12.2013 in W.P.(C)No.24318 of 2012 and the writ petition stands dismissed. Sd/ANIL K.NARENDRAN, JUDGE Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE sks
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WA NO. 334 OF 2014
2025:KER:30678
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 334 OF 2014
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 06.12.2013 IN WPC NO.24318 OF 2012 OF
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS 1 AND 2:
THE KADAVOOR SERVICE CO-OPERATIVE BANK LTD
KADAVOOR.P.O., MUVATTUPUZHA. PIN-686 671. REP. BY ITS
SECRETARY.
THE ADMINISTRATOR,KADAVOOR SERVICE CO-OPERATIVE BANK
LTD.NO.1882, KADAVOOR.P.O., MUVATTUPUZHA, PIN-686 671.
BY ADV SRI.K.A.SALIL NARAYANAN
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER AND RESPONDENTS 3 AND 4:
P.J.CHACKO,RETIRED ACCOUNTANT, THE KADAVOOR SERVICE COOPERATIVE BANK LTD.NO.1882, KADAVOOR.P.O., MUVATTUPUZHA,
RESIDING AT PITTAPILLIL VEEDU, KADAVOOR.P.O.,
KOTHAMANGALAM. 686 671.
THE ASSISTANT REGISTRAR OF CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES
OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT REGISTRAR, KOTHAMANGALAM, PIN-686
691.
KEALA STATE CO-OPERATIVE EMPLOYEES PENSION BOARD
P.B.NO.85, KALA NIVAS, T.C.27/156, CHINMAYA LANE,
KUNNUMPURAM, NEAR AYURVEDA COLLAGE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
PIN-695 001. REP. BY ITS SECRETARY.
BY ADV P.P.JACOB
SMT.VINITHA.B, SR.G.P
SRI.M SASINDRAN, SC, KSCEPB
THIS WRIT APPEAL WAS FINALLY HEARD ON 19.03.2025, THE COURT ON
10.04.2025 PASSED
THE FOLLOWING:
WA NO. 334 OF 2014
Muralee Krishna, J.
2025:KER:30678
JUDGMENT
This writ appeal is filed under Section 5(i) of the Kerala High
Court Act, 1958, by respondents 1 and 2 in W.P.(C)No.24318 of
2012. The writ petition was one filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India by the 1st respondent herein who is a retired
Accountant of the 1st appellant Society, seeking a writ of
mandamus
commanding
the
1st
appellant
to
release
the
retirement benefits like gratuity, earned leave surrender, provident
fund, welfare fund and dearness allowance arrears with 12%
interest
from
01.04.2012;
to
direct
the
appellants
and
respondents 2 and 3 herein to forward the pension book of the 1st
respondent to the 3rd respondent; and direct the 3rd respondent
Pension Board to pay eligible pension to the 1 st respondent with
effect from 01.04.2012. After considering the pleadings and
materials on record and the rival submissions of the parties, the
learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition by the impugned
judgment dated 06.12.2013. Paragraph No.6 of that judgment
reads thus:
“6. The facts revealed from the records would indicate that
the refusal of the respondent Society to forward the pension
WA NO. 334 OF 2014
2025:KER:30678
papers and pay the contributions on pension, as also the
refusal to disburse the retirement benefits are unjustifiable.
The respondent Society, hence, is directed to immediately
take steps to disburse the retirement benefits as also
forward the pension papers. The petitioner is directed to
make an application before the Society within a period of
two weeks from today, upon which, the application for
pension shall be forwarded to the respondent Board through
the
3rd
respondent
Assistant
Registrar
and
on
the
respondent Board scrutinizing the application and making a
demand for contribution, the respondent Society shall make
the contribution within a period of one month from the date
of demand of made by the Board, if the same is not
otherwise disputed on computation. The respondent Society
shall also disburse the retirement benefits of the petitioner
within a period of three months from the date of receipt of
a copy of this judgment. If the retirement benefits are not
paid by the Society within three months, then the petitioner
shall be entitled to interest from the date of his retirement
till the date of his payment, which interest shall be paid by
the Society and recovered from the employees who is
responsible for the said delay.”
2.
The 1st respondent entered the service of the 1st
appellant on 16.09.1976 as a Junior Clerk and was subsequently
promoted to higher posts and superannuated on 31.03.2012 while
holding the post of Accountant. According to the 1st respondent,
due to wilful negligence and ill-motive his pension book was not
WA NO. 334 OF 2014
2025:KER:30678
forwarded to the 3rd respondent by the 1st appellant. Therefore,
his retirement benefits were not paid.
3. The appellants filed a counter affidavit dated 18.01.2013
in the writ petition opposing the averments in the writ petition and
producing therewith Exts.R1(a)
to
R1(i) documents.
It
is
contended by the appellants that the 1st respondent owed a huge
amount to the appellant Bank on various counts. The 1 st
respondent was under suspension during various periods and was
dismissed
from
service
on
23.10.2007
and
reinstated
on
05.05.2008. The General Body of the 1st appellant by a resolution
dated 24.03.2012 decided not to forward the pension-related
papers of the 1st respondent, until he clears the entire liability
towards the Bank.
4. The learned Single Judge in the impugned judgment
noticed that in Ext.R1(e) judgment, this Court found that the
salary drawn by the 1st respondent in the post of Assistant
Secretary is entitled to him since the same is remuneration for
work done in the promoted post. The learned Single Judge further
noted that in Ext.R1(e), it was said that any excess salary drawn,
with respect to that drawn during the period of suspension, will be
WA NO. 334 OF 2014
2025:KER:30678
liable to be recovered and it was under that circumstance, by
Ext.R1(e), this Court directed the Joint Registrar to consider the
same and pass orders. The learned Single Judge further noted that
though the Joint Registrar considered the same as evident from
Ext.R1(f), it is seen that the very same amounts demanded by
Ext.R1(d) which was under challenge in Ext.R1(e) has been
directed to recover from the 1st respondent. The learned Single
Judge further opined that this would definitely go against the
specific finding in Ext.R1(e) with respect to the entitlement of the
1st respondent for salary for the period which he has worked in the
promoted post.
5. Heard the learned counsel for the appellants, the learned
counsel for the 1st respondent and the learned Senior Government
Pleader.
6. The learned counsel for the appellant would submit that
as per Rule 198(7) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules
(‘KCS Rules’, in short) which was inserted with effect from
18.08.2010, there is a specific bar against the Society from
sanctioning any retirement benefits to an employee against whom
disciplinary proceedings are pending. The learned Single Judge
WA NO. 334 OF 2014
2025:KER:30678
failed to note the fact that in such circumstances the Bank cannot
issue a non-liability certificate in favour of the 1st respondent. An
arbitration case is pending before the Assistant Registrar of Cooperative Societies for an amount of more than Rs.9,00,000/- due
from the 1st respondent.
If the directions in the judgment of the
learned Single Judge are complied and if the arbitration case is
allowed, the appellants will not be in a position to recover any
amount from the 1st respondent.
7. The learned counsel for the 1st respondent argued that in
Ext.R1(e) judgment dated 29.01.2009 in W.P.(C)No.38125 of
2008 which was one filed by the 1st respondent, it was found that
if the 1st respondent had discharged his duties and responsibilities
attached to the office to which he was promoted, his entitlement
to remuneration for the work done cannot be denied. If there were
overdraws, the same has to be taken care of while adjusting the
total amount that may be due to the 1st respondent. This judgment
is not challenged by the appellants and hence they cannot now
deny retirement benefits to the 1st respondent.
8. The learned Senior Government Pleader would argue that
while passing the impugned judgment the effect of Rule 198 (7)
WA NO. 334 OF 2014
2025:KER:30678
of the KCS Rules was not considered by the learned Single Judge.
9. Rule 198(7) of the KCS Rules which was inserted with
effect from 18.08.2010 reads thus:
“(7) In the event of any pendency of disciplinary proceedings
against any employee of a co-operative society or any cooperative institution pursuant to any charge of grave
misconduct, irregularity, corruption or other charge involving
moral turpitude, no retirement benefits shall be sanctioned
to such employee or retired employee and in case of
sanctioning of any retirement benefits to any such employee
or retired employee, the name and designation of the
sanctioning authority together with the reason for such
sanctioning shall be recorded by the sanctioning authority
by himself and such authority shall be held responsible for
any loss to the society owing to such sanctioning of
retirement benefits if found that such sanctioning was
unwarranted.”
10. The 1st respondent who was in service of the 1st appellant
with effect from 16.09.1976 was under suspension during
different periods, such as from 19.11.1987 to 06.02.1991,
19.12.1994
to
21.02.1997,
22.03.1997
to
02.07.1998,
11.03.2007 to 22.10.2007, 10.01.2009 to till dismissal on
05.10.2009 and then reinstated on 20.07.2010. In the meantime,
he was earlier dismissed from service on 23.10.2007 but
reinstated on 05.05.2008. There were serious allegations of
WA NO. 334 OF 2014
2025:KER:30678
mismanagement raised against the 1st respondent. According to
the appellants, when the audit was conducted in the Bank it was
found that the 1st respondent had drawn an excess salary of
Rs.3,05,554/-. It is true that in Ext.R1(e) this Court directed the
Joint Registrar to take a decision regarding the entitlement of the
1st respondent for the salary drawn during the period he worked
as Assistant Secretary or the Secretary. In that Judgment, it was
found that the impact of the decision of the Joint Registrar refusing
to approve the suggestion of the Society to grant exemption from
educational qualification to the 1st respondent would entitle only
to be at least the re-positioning of the 1st respondent in the
hierarchy of the establishment. But in that judgment, it was not
found categorically that the 1st respondent was not liable to repay
any amount to the appellant Bank in respect of the excess salary
drawn. In pursuance to the direction in Ext.R1(e) judgment, Ext.
R1(f) order was passed by the Joint Registrar. In that order it was
found that the 1st respondent is liable to pay the excess drawn
salary to the appellant Bank.
11. It is stated in the appeal memorandum that another
matter is pending between the parties before the Arbitration Court
WA NO. 334 OF 2014
2025:KER:30678
for recovery of more than Rs.9,00,000/- from the 1st respondent.
In view of Rule 198(7) of KCS Rules, the Bank cannot issue a nonliability certificate for disbursal of pensionary benefits due to the
1st respondent. The learned Single Judge failed to consider this
aspect
while
passing
the
impugned
judgment.
In
such
circumstances, the impugned judgment is only liable to be set
aside.
In the result, the writ appeal is allowed by setting aside the
judgment dated 06.12.2013 in W.P.(C)No.24318 of 2012 and the
writ petition stands dismissed.
Sd/ANIL K.NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
sks
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review