The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. In view of the aforesaid legal position, the promotion of Petitioner No. 2 from the post of Peon to that of Assistant Teacher constitutes a promotion and not a fresh appointment, therefore, the concept of the Pavitra Portal would not be applicable. The promotion of Petitioner No. Narwade/Ajay wp-6294-2026.odt 2, therefore, deserves to be approved.
15. As far as the order passed by the Appellate Authority is concerned, the said Authority has remanded the matter to the Respondent No.3 for fresh consideration in view of the Government Resolution of 2026. However, in our view, the said Government Resolution of 2026 cannot be made applicable retrospectively to the petitioner’s case, since the promotion of Petitioner No.2 was pursuant to the Government Resolution of 2005. In such circumstances, the remand of the matter for reconsideration on the basis of the subsequent Government Resolution is unwarranted. We are, therefore, inclined to set aside the order passed by the Appellate Authority.
16. In view of aforesaid discussion, we find that the impugned orders are unsustainable. We are, therefore, inclined to allow this Writ Petition. In the result, we pass the following order. :: ORDER :: (i) Writ Petition is allowed in terms of prayer Clauses – B, C and D. (ii) Narwade/Ajay Respondent No. 3 shall undertake the exercise wp-6294-2026.odt of granting approval to the promotion of Petitioner No. 2 as an Assistant Teacher and release his salary within a period of three (3) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. (iii) Rule is thus made absolute in the above terms. (ABASAHEB D. SHINDE, J.) Narwade/Ajay (N. B. SURYAWANSHI, J. )
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:43177-DB
wp-6294-2026.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO.6294 of 2026
1.
The Headmaster,
Sadguru Narayangiri Vidyalaya,
Virgaon,Tq. Vaijapur,
Dist. Chh. Sambhajinagar.
2.
Kisan Yashwant Atre,
Age: 49 years, Occu.: Service,
R/o. Virgaon, Tq. Vaijapur,
Dist. Chh. Sambhajinagar.
...Petitioners
VERSUS
1.
The State of Maharashtra,
Through its Secretary,
School Education Department,
Government of Maharashtra,
Mantralaya, Mumbai-32
2.
The Deputy Director of Education,
Chh. Sambhajinagar.
3.
The Education Officer (Secondary),
Zilla Parishad, Chh. Sambhajinagar. ...Respondents
…
Mr. Chandrakant K. Shinde, Advocate for the Petitioners.
Mr. S. K. Tambe, AGP for the State
...
CORAM
: NITIN B. SURYAWANSHI
AND
ABASAHEB D. SHINDE, JJ.
RESERVED ON
: 18.08.2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 23.09.2026
Narwade/Ajay
wp-6294-2026.odt
JUDGMENT (Per Abasaheb D. Shinde J.) :1.
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. With the
consent of the parties, the Writ Petition is heard finally at
the stage of admission.
2.
By the present Writ Petition filed under Article 226
of the Constitution of India, the Petitioners have put forth
the following main prayers :
B) It be held and declared that, the promotion order dated
01/06/2025 promoting the petitioner no. 2 from the post of
Sevak/Peon to Assistant Teacher is legal and proper, hence,
deserves to be granted approval by the respondent no. 3 - the
Education Officer (Secondary), Zilla Parishad, Chhatrapati
Sambhajinagar.
C) By issue of writ of mandamus or any other appropriate
writ, order or direction in the like nature, the respondent no. 3
- the Education Officer (Secondary), Zilla Parishad,
Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar may kindly be directed to grant
approval to the promotion of the petitioner no. 2 as an
Assistant Teacher and release his monthly salary.
D) By issue of writ of certiorari or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction in the like nature, the impugned order dated
04/09/2025 issued by the respondent no. 3 - the Education
Officer (Secondary), Zilla Parishad, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar
and order dated 23/04/2026 issued by the respondent no. 2 the Deputy Director of Education, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar,
may kindly be quashed and set aside in the interest of justice.
FACTUAL MATRIX :
3.
It is the case of the Petitioners that, Petitioner No. 1
is the Headmaster of Sadguru Narayangiri Vidyalaya,
Virgaon, Tq. Vaijapur, Dist. Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar,
Narwade/Ajay
wp-6294-2026.odt
which is a secondary school run and administered by a
private management. Petitioner No. 2 possesses the
qualification of BA. B.Ed. and was initially appointed as a
Peon in the Petitioner No. 1 - School w.e.f. 01.07.1996, on
probation. Upon completion of the probation period, his
services were confirmed as a permanent employee on a nogrant-aid basis. Respondent No. 3 granted approval to his
permanent appointment vide order dated 27.08.2009.
Respondent No.2 has also issued a Shalarth ID in his
favour.
4.
It is further the case of the Petitioners that one
Assistant Teacher, namely, Sayyad Majak Begubhai, serving
in the said School, superannuated on 31.05.2025. The
School Management, in its meeting dated 23.06.2025,
resolved to promote Petitioner No. 2 to the said post by
virtue of Clause 8 of the Government Resolution dated
10.06.2005 (for short hereinafter called as “Government
Resolution of 2005”). Accordingly, the Management
promoted Petitioner No.2 as an Assistant Teacher w.e.f
01.06.2025. The Management submitted a proposal
seeking approval of the said promotion to Respondent No.
Narwade/Ajay
wp-6294-2026.odt
3 on 09.07.2025.
5.
Respondent No. 3, by the impugned order, rejected
the said proposal thereby refusing to grant approval to the
promotion of Petitioner No. 2 on the ground that the post
on which Petitioner No. 2 was promoted ought to have
been filled through the Pavitra Portal.
6.
Being aggrieved by the said decision, Petitioner No.
2 preferred an appeal before the Divisional Grievance
Redressal Committee headed by Respondent No. 2 - the
Deputy Director of Education. Upon hearing the parties,
Respondent No. 2, vide order dated 23.04.2026, remanded
the proceedings to Respondent No. 3 for decision afresh in
accordance with the Government Resolution of 2005 and
the Government Resolution dated 25.03.2026 (for short
hereinafter called as “Government Resolution of 2026”).
The Petitioners, therefore, have approached this Court.
SUBMISSIONS :7.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioners submits that,
Petitioner No. 2 is duly qualified for being promoted to the
post of Assistant Teacher and was accordingly promoted
Narwade/Ajay
wp-6294-2026.odt
after following the due procedure of law. He further
submits that, when Petitioner No. 2 was promoted, the
Government Resolution of 2005 was in vogue, which
provides for promotion of an employee from a nonteaching post to a teaching post. Since the said promotion
is not a fresh appointment, the same need not be made
through the Pavitra Portal. He further submits that, the
Appellate Authority was also not justified in remanding the
matter back in view of the Government Resolution of 2026.
He has placed reliance on the orders passed by the
Coordinate Bench of this Court in Writ Petition No. 3167 of
2019, as well as by the Nagpur Bench in Writ Petition No.
7706 of 2022, to contend that promotion from a nonteaching post to a teaching post is permissible. He
therefore,
urged
that
the
impugned
orders
are
unsustainable and deserve to be quashed and set aside.
8.
Per contra, learned AGP supported the impugned
orders.
CONSIDERATION :9.
We have heard learned Counsel for the Petitioners
and learned AGP and have perused the record.
Narwade/Ajay
10.
wp-6294-2026.odt
It is pertinent to note that the Government
Resolution of 2005 was issued for implementation of the
scheme of Shikshan Sevak in private aided Secondary and
Higher Secondary Schools as well as Junior Colleges.
Clause 8 of the said Government Resolution, which permits
promotion from a non-teaching post to a teaching post,
reads thus :"८. शिक्षकेतर कर्मचाऱ्याने माध्यमिक शिक्षकांसाठी वा कनिष्ठ महाविद्यालयीन
शिक्षकांसाठी आवश्यक ती शैक्षणिक अर्हता प्राप्त केली आणि जर त्या संवर्गाचे पद
माध्यमिक शाळे त वा उच्च माध्यमिक शाळे त/ कनिष्ठ महाविद्यालयात उपलब्ध असेल
तर, अशा प्रकरणी सदरहू शिक्षकेतर कर्मचाऱ्यास शिक्षणसेवक म्हणूनच नियुक्ती
द्यावी लागेल व त्यांना शिक्षणसेवकांचेच मानधन आणि इतर सर्व अटी व शर्ती लागू
होतील. मात्र अशा शिक्षकेतर कर्मचाऱ्याची पूर्वीची सेवा ही सेवानिवृत्ती वेतनासाठी
ग्राह्य धरता येईल.”
11.
Admittedly, Petitioner No. 2 was promoted to the
teaching post when the aforesaid Government Resolution
was in vogue. Consequently, the promotion of Petitioner
No. 2 is required to be considered in accordance with the
Government Resolution of 2005.
12.
Having held that Petitioner No. 2 is entitled to derive
the benefits available under Clause 8 of the Government
Resolution of 2005, it is necessary to examine the nature
and effect of the said provision. The said Clause
contemplates a promotional avenue to an employee
Narwade/Ajay
wp-6294-2026.odt
belonging to the non-teaching staff. The said Clause fell for
consideration before this Court on several occasions, and
more particularly in the case of Usha Baliram Masal Vs.
Hind Seva Mandal (Writ Petition No.3167 of 2019) decided
on 30.09.2019, wherein this Court observed thus:
5. The petitioner is seeking benefit of Government Resolution
dated 10.06.2005, though the statute does not prescribe
promotional channel from non-teaching to teaching staff,
however, the State through it's School Education and Sports
Department, Mantralaya,Mumbai has issued Government
Resolution dated 10.06.2005. Clause 8 of the said Government
Resolution reads thus"८. शिक्षकेतर कर्मचा-याने माध्यमिक शिक्षकांसाठी वा कनिष्ठ महाविद्यालयीन शिक्षकांसाठी
आवश्यक ती शैक्षणिक अर्हता प्राप्त केली अणि जर त्या संवर्गाचे पद माध्यमिक शाळे त वा
उच्च माध्यमिक शाळे त / कनिष्ठ महाविद्यालयात उपलब्ध असेल तर, अशा प्रकरणी सदरहू
शिक्षकेतर कर्मचा-यास शिक्षणसेवक म्हणूनच नियुक्ती द्यावी लागेल व त्यांना
शिक्षणसेवकांचेच मानधन आणि इतर सर्व अटी व शर्ती लागू होतील. मात्र अशा शिक्षकेतर
कर्मचा-याची पूर्वीची सेवा ही सेवानिवृत्ती वेतनासाठी ग्राहय धरता येईल."
Reading the said clause, it is manifest that a nonteaching employee after acquiring the qualification can be
appointed as 'Shikshan Sevak' in the secondary school or the
junior college and his earlier services shall be counted for the
purpose of pension. The only rider is that he is to be appointed
as 'Shikshan Sevak' and he would be paid honorarium as
applicable to 'Shikshan Sevak'.
6.
The Clause 8 read as it is, is in the nature of providing a
promotional avenue to an employee of non-teaching staff. The
Clause 8 clarifies that earlier services shall be counted for the
purpose of pensionary benefits. It would not be a case of an
appointment afresh but promoting a person from the nonteaching staff though as 'Shikshan Sevak.
13.
Relying upon the judgment of Usha Baliram Masal
(supra) the Coordinate Bench of this Court at Nagpur in
the case of Shri. Suhas s/o Rangraoji More Vs. State of
Narwade/Ajay
wp-6294-2026.odt
Maharashtra and Others (Writ Petition No.7706 of 2022)
has taken a similar view. The relevant observations of the
said judgment read thus :“16. In this regard, it needs to be noted that the
petitioner was appointed as a Peon on a regular permanent
post. His promotion as Shikshan Sevak deprives him of the
pay scale as well as other service benefits that he enjoyed
in the post of lower grade. Evidently, such promotion does
not enhance his prospect but severally prejudices his
interest in every way. This anomaly can only be obliterated
by treating the promotional post as that of the Assistant
Teacher and by granting regular pay scale and other service
benefits enjoyed by Assistant Teacher, albeit, the
promotional post is termed as Shikshan Sevak.
21.
Under the circumstances, it is held that (i) Clause 8
of G.R. dated 10.06.2005, which stipulates promotion of
non teaching staff as Shikshan Sevak on payment of
honorarium is arbitrary and discriminatory. (ii) The
petitioner is entitled to be appointed as Assistant Teacher
with the prescribed pay scale at par with pay scale of other
similarly placed promotees. (iii) Respondent No.5 Management to modify the appointment order dated
29.10.2021 to the extent of appointing/promoting the
petitioner as Assistant Teacher instead of Shikshan Sevak.
(iv) Respondent No.5 – Management, is directed to submit
the proposal to respondent No.4 for approval of
appointment/promotion of the petitioner as Assistant
Teacher with pay scale of Assistant Teacher within four
weeks from the date of the order. (v) Respondent No.4 to
consider the same as expeditiously as possible in any event
within four weeks from the date of the receipt of the
proposal.”
14.
In view of the aforesaid legal position, the promotion
of Petitioner No. 2 from the post of Peon to that of
Assistant Teacher constitutes a promotion and not a fresh
appointment, therefore, the concept of the Pavitra Portal
would not be applicable. The promotion of Petitioner No.
Narwade/Ajay
wp-6294-2026.odt
2, therefore, deserves to be approved.
15.
As far as the order passed by the Appellate Authority
is concerned, the said Authority has remanded the matter
to the Respondent No.3 for fresh consideration in view of
the Government Resolution of 2026. However, in our view,
the said Government Resolution of 2026 cannot be made
applicable retrospectively to the petitioner’s case, since the
promotion of Petitioner No.2 was pursuant to the
Government Resolution of 2005. In such circumstances, the
remand of the matter for reconsideration on the basis of
the subsequent Government Resolution is unwarranted. We
are, therefore, inclined to set aside the order passed by the
Appellate Authority.
16.
In view of aforesaid discussion, we find that the
impugned orders are unsustainable. We are, therefore,
inclined to allow this Writ Petition. In the result, we pass
the following order.
:: ORDER ::
(i)
Writ Petition is allowed in terms of prayer
Clauses – B, C and D.
(ii)
Narwade/Ajay
Respondent No. 3 shall undertake the exercise
wp-6294-2026.odt
of granting approval to the promotion of Petitioner
No. 2 as an Assistant Teacher and release his salary
within a period of three (3) months from the date of
receipt of a copy of this order.
(iii)
Rule is thus made absolute in the above terms.
(ABASAHEB D. SHINDE, J.)
Narwade/Ajay
(N. B. SURYAWANSHI, J. )
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review