Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P.G. AJITHKUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 21ST DAY OF JUNE 2023 / 31ST JYAISHTA, 1945
O.P.(FT) NO. 6 OF 2016
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 05.08.2016 IN I.A.NO.51 OF 2016
IN O.A.NOS.7 OF 2014 AND 8 OF 2014 BEFORE THE I
ADDITIONAL DISTRICDT COURT, KOZHIKODE/TRIBUNAL UNDER THE
KERALA FOREST (VESTING & MANAGEMENT OF ECOLOIGICALY
FRAGILE LANDS) ACT, 2003
PETITIONERS:
THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, DEPARTMENT OF FORESTS AND
WILDLIFE,THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
THE CUSTODIAN OF ECOLOGICALLY FRAGILE LANDS
VESTED IN GOVERNMENT (THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF
CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS), FOREST HEADQUARTERS,
VAZHUTHACAUD, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
BY ADV SRI.NAGARAJ NARAYANAN, SPL. G.P. FOR
FOREST
RESPONDENTS:
P.K.HARIS (DIED)
S/O. A.K.KADERKUTTY, HARRYLAND ESTATE,
P.O.PERIA, NORTH WAYANAD.
K.C.KAMALUDHEEN MUSALIYAR
S/O. THANL KOYA, HARRYLAND ESTATE, P.O.PERIA,
NORTH WAYANAD.
O.P.(FT) No.6 of 2016
PUTHIYA KOTTEL JEMEELA
D/O. A.K.KADERKUTTY, HARRYLAND ESTATE,
P.O.PERIA, NORTH WAYANAD.
4*
UMAIBAN HARRIS,
AGED 70 YEARS, W/O. LATE P.K.HARRIS, PALLICOON,
BUNGALOW, CHETHANKUNNU, TELLICHERRY, PIN670101. ADDL. R4 TO ADDL. R7 ARE IMPLEADED AS
THE LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES OF DECEASED R1 AS PER
THE ORDER DATED 19/1/2023 IN IA NO.1/2022 IN
OP(FT) 6/2016.
5*
P K JAMEELA,
AGED 80 YEARS, SISTER OF LATE P.K.HARRIS,
"SITARA", 48 KEERTHI NAGAR, ASRAMOM, KOLLAM
DISTRICT, PIN-691002.
6*
P.K.HASHIM
AGED 77 YEARS, BROTHER OF LATE P.K.HARRIS,
P.K.BUNGALOW, OLD POST OFFICE ROAD, KANNUR
DISTRICT, PIN-670001.
7*
P.K.RAFIA,
AGED 75 YEARS, W/O.KUNJA AHAMMED KOYA, BELLA
VISTA, VAZ LANE, MANGALORE, PIN - 575002.
*ADDL. R4 TO ADDL. R7 ARE IMPLEADED AS THE
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES OF DECEASED R1 AS PER THE
ORDER DATED 19/1/2023 IN IA NO.1/2022 IN OP(FT)
6/2016.
BY ADVS.
N.JAMES KOSHY
T.SANJAY
MIDHUN R.
THIS OP (FOREST TRIBUNAL) HAVING COME UP FOR FINAL
HEARING ON 21.06.2023, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
O.P.(FT) No.6 of 2016
JUDGMENT
P.G. Ajithkumar, J.
The respondents in O.A.Nos.7 of 2014, 8 of 2014, 5 of
2010 and 6 of 2010 on the file of the Tribunal under Kerala
Forest (Vesting and Management of Ecologically Fragile Land)
Act, 2003, Kozhikode (for short “the Tribunal”) have filed this
Original Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
They challenge the order of the Tribunal dated 05.08.2016 in
I.A.No.51 of 2016 in the aforesaid original applications. The
petitioners sought to set aside the report of the Advocate
Commissioner dated 22.04.2016 submitted in the aforesaid
original applications for which I.A.No.51 of 2016 was filed. It
was dismissed as per the impugned order.
2.
On 07.10.2016, urgent notice on admission was
directed to be served on the respondents. An interim order
directing the parties to maintain status quo of the properties
in dispute was ordered for a period of two weeks. The said
interim order was extended from time to time.
O.P.(FT) No.6 of 2016
3.
During pendency of this Original Petition, the 1 st
respondent
expired
and
his
legal
representatives
were
impleaded as additional respondents 4 to 7.
4.
Heard the learned Special Government Pleader
(Forests)
for
the
petitioners
and
the
learned
counsel
appearing for the respondents.
5.
The Government issued notification No.EFL.10-
1985/2010
dated
03.06.2010
notifying
two
parcels
of
property; the first having an extent of 84.60 hectares and the
second having 24.50 hectares, as ecologically fragile lands
and vesting it to the Government. An erratum notification was
issued on 03.06.2014 correcting the extent of the properties
as 90.1173 hectares and 26.6412 hectares respectively. The
area of the said properties, if converted, is about 290 acres.
An Advocate Commissioner, with the assistance of technical
experts, was appointed initially to inspect the property in
question and file a report. Sri.Sreekanth S.Nair was the
Commissioner. Although he inspected the property and filed
O.P.(FT) No.6 of 2016
an interim order, he could not complete the inspection and file
a final report. In that circumstances, another Advocate,
Sri.Sreenarayanan Unni P.T. was appointed for the inspection
of the property and to file a report. The petitioners would
contend that the said Advocate Commissioner did not conduct
a proper inspection, did not avail assistance of experts
although the court appointed, and without availing assistance
of a Taluk Surveyor for measuring and demarcating the
property, he has availed the services of a private surveyor.
The petitioners further pointing out that the report submitted
by the learned Advocate Commissioner was totally erroneous
and against the true facts, sought to set aside the report. The
learned Tribunal examined the Commissioner as CW1 and
marked the report and plan as Exts.C1 and C2. After
considering
the
matter
in
detail,
the
learned
Tribunal
dismissed I.A.No.51 of 2016, and thereby refused to set aside
the report of the learned Advocate Commissioner.
O.P.(FT) No.6 of 2016
6.
When this matter came up for consideration on
01.06.2023, upon hearing the learned Special Government
Pleader
and
the
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondents, we have directed to call for from the learned
Tribunal, Kozhikode, the order by which the Commissioner
was appointed in O.A.Nos.5 & 6 of 2010 and 7 & 8 of 2014.
The learned Tribunal submitted report dated 06.06.2023,
which reads as follows:“Referring to the above, I may submit that on perusal of
the case records of OA Nos. 5/2010, 6/2010, 7/2014,
8/2014 and the proceeding paper of OA.5/2010 which is
the leading case, it is discernible that an Advocate
Commissioner was appointed suo motu by the Tribunal
as per the proceedings dated 23.05.2015. Name of the
Advocate
Commissioner
mentioned
in
the
so
appointed
is
proceedings
not
seen
paper.
But
Adv.P.T.Sreenarayanan Unni submitted a commission
report
dated
19.05.2016
before
the
Tribunal
on
25.05.2016. Records would show that earlier one Adv.
Srikanth.S.Nair
was
appointed
as
Advocate
Commissioner in the above OA. But no final report is
seen filed by him. The copy of the said proceedings
dated 23.05.2015 is submitted herewith as called for.”
O.P.(FT) No.6 of 2016
7.
The petitioners would allege that the learned
Advocate Commissioner did not avail assistance of the experts
despite the court appointing experts to assist him and that
instead of Taluk Surveyor, the learned commissioner availed
the services of a private surveyor. From the report dated
06.06.2023 of the Tribunal, it is seen that there was no formal
order appointing Sri.Sreenarayanan Unni as an Advocate
Commissioner. It is alleged by the petitioners that the
Commissioner did not properly execute the order. It has now
come out that there is no formal order even appointing the
learned Advocate Commissioner. In such circumstances, it is
impossible to attach any value to the commission as provided
in Order XXVI, Rule 10(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908. Therefore, the only option available is to set aside the
report submitted by learned Advocate Commissioner.
8.
Accordingly, I.A No.51 of 2016 is allowed. The
report of the Advocate Commissioner is set aside. The learned
Tribunal will consider whether a fresh commission is to be
O.P.(FT) No.6 of 2016
deputed in O.A.Nos.7 of 2014, 8 of 2014, 5 of 2010 and 6 of
2010. This appeal is accordingly allowed, however, without
prejudice to the right of the parties to move the learned
Tribunal to get a Commissioner appointed, if either of them so
desires.
Sd/ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/P.G. AJITHKUMAR, JUDGE
dkr
O.P.(FT) No.6 of 2016
APPENDIX OF OP(FT) 6/2016
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF O.A.NO. 7/2014 ON THE
FILE
OF
THE
FOREST
TRIBUNAL,
KOZHIKODE.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF O.A.NO. 8/2014 ON THE
FILE
OF
THE
FOREST
TRIBUNAL,
KOZHIKODE.
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF INTERIM REPORT DT. 17-122012
FILED
BY
THE
ADVOCATE
COMMISSIONER BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL.
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMISSION REPORT
DATED 22-04-2016 SUBMITTED BY THE
ADVOCATE
COMMISSIONER,
MR.SREENARAYANAN
UNNI
BEFORE
THE
TRIBUNAL.
EXHIBIT P5
TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION DATED 2105-2016 FILED BY THE DIVISIONAL FOREST
OFFICE, NORTH WAYANAD.
EXHIBIT P6
TRUE COPY OF I.A.50/2016 DATED 01-062016,
THE
SUMMON
THE
ADVOCATE
COMMISSIONER FOR CROSS EXAMINATION.
EXHIBIT P7
TRUE COPY OF I.A.51/2016 DATED 01-062016
IN
O.A.NOS.
5/2010,
6/2010,
7/2014 AND 8/2014 TO SET ASIDE EXHIBIT
P4 ADVOCATE COMMISSION REPORT OF THE
ADVOCATE MR.SREENARAYANAN UNNI.
EXHIBIT P8
TRUE READABLE COPY OF THE DEPOSITION
OF ADV.COMMISSIONER ON EXAMINATION ON
19-07-2016 IN THE ABOVE O.As.
O.P.(FT) No.6 of 2016
EXHIBIT P9
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 08-092016 IN OP(FT) 5/2016.
EXHIBIT P10
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 05-08-2016 OF
THE EFL TRIBUNAL IN IA.NO. 51/2016 IN
OA NOS. 5/2010, 6/2010, 7/2014 AND
8/2014.
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT R1(A)
TRUE COPY OF THE SALE DEED NO.1093 OF
1967 OF THE SRO THALASSERY.
EXHIBIT R1(B)
TRUE COPY OF REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE
NO.RC 14/1970 ISSUED IN RESPECT OF 250
ACRES OF CARDAMOM PLANTATION DATED
04.06.1973.
EXHIBIT R1(C)
TRUE COPY OF THE COFFEE PLANTATION
CERTIFICATE NO.225/1971 IN RESPECDT OF
30 ACRES DATED 08.01.1972.
EXHIBIT R1(D)
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE TALUK
LAND
BORAD
NO.K.DIS.11/1975
DATED
29.05.1975.
EXHIBIT R1(E)
TRUE COPY OF THE INSPECTION REPORT
ISSUED BY THE AGRICULTURAL INCOME TAX
OFFICER,
MANANTHAVADI
DATED
25.03.1977.
EXHIBIT R1(F)
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE
TAHSILDAR,
MANANTHAVADI
DATED
30.11.1999.
EXHIBIT R1(G)
TRUE COPY OF THE PLANTATION TAX PAID
BY THE PETITIONERS DURING 1999 TO
2005.
O.P.(FT) No.6 of 2016
EXHIBIT R1(H)
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE HON'BLE
SUPREME
COURT
IN
CIVIL
APPEAL
NO.2303/1999 DATED 18.11.2004.
EXHIBIT R1(I)
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION DATED
28.12.2006 ISSUED BY THE DIVISIONAL
FOREST OFFICER, MANANTHAVADI.
EXHIBIT R1(J)
TRUE COPY OF THE CHIEF AFFIDAVIT DATED
23.08.2016 FILED BY THE RESPONDENTS
BEFORE THE EFL TRIBUNAL, KOZHIKODE.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review