Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed
JOHN Digitally
by JOHN TELEN
TELEN KOM
Date:
2022.04.08
KOM 15:51:07 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.1057 of 2018
1.
The Governing Body, Mayai Lambi College, Yumnam
Huidrom, Rep. by its Secretary, Shri. L. Prakash Singh about 56
years, s/o (L) Nipamacha Singh, R/o Yumnam Huidrom, PO &
PS Wangoi, Imphal West District, Manipur-795009.
2.
The Governing Body, Thambal Marik Lambi College,
Oinam, Bishenpur District, Rep. by its Secretary, Shri W. Debit
Singh about 50 years, s/o W. Mangi Singh, R/o Oinam Mamang
Leikai, PO & PS Nambol, Bishenpur District, Manipur-795134.
……. Petitioners
– Versus –
1. State of Manipur, Rep. by the Commissioner (University &
Higher Education), Government of Manipur, Secretariat New
Building, Babupara, PO & PS Imphal West, Imphal West
District, Manipur-795001.
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 1
2. The Commissioner/Secretary, Department of Finance,
Government
of
Manipur,
Secretariat
New
Building,
Babupara, PO & PS Imphal West, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001.
3. The Director, University and Higher Education, Government
of Manipur, Neitaipat Chuthek, Imphal PO & PS Imphal,
Imphal West District Manipur-795001.
4. The Chairman, Manipur Rural Bank, Keishampat Head
Office, Imphal West District, PO & PS Keishampat, Manipur795001.
5. The Branch Manager, Manipur Rural Bank, Nambol Branch,
Nambol, Bishnupur District, Manipur-795134.
6. The Branch Manager, State Bank of India, Bishenpur Branch,
Bishenpur District, Manipur-795134.
7. The Branch Manager, State Bank of India (RUSA) Bishenpur
Branch, Bishenpur District, Manipur-795134.
8. The Branch Manager, State Bank of India, Nambol Branch,
Nambol, Bishnupur District, Manipur-795134.
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 2
9. The Principal i/c, Mayai Lambi College, Yumnam Huidrom,
Mayai Lambi, Yumnam Huidrom, Imphal Manipur-795009.
10. The Principal i/c, Thambal Marik College, Oinam, Tiddim
Road, Bishenpur District, Manipur-795135.
….Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. D. Julius Riamei, Adv.
For the Respondents
:
Ms. Monomala, GA & Mr.
H.S. Paonam Sr. Adv. Proforma
Respondents.
Date of Order
:
25.02.2022.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Oral)
[1]
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioners seeking to
quash the impugned order dated 20.10.2018 passed by the first respondent
and to direct the respondents to allow the petitioners’ function till the handing
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 3
over and taking over of Mayai Lambi College, Yumnam Huridrom and
Thambal Marik College, Oinam are completed.
[2]
The case of the petitioners is that they are the Governing
Bodies of two Colleges, namely, Mayai Lambi Collge, Yumnam Huridrom
and Thambal Marik College, Oinam, which have been taken over and
converted into full-fledged Government Colleges under the Department of
Higher Education, Government of Manipur vide order dated 28.6.2018.
Pursuant to the said Colleges being converted into Government Colleges,
the petitioners stood abolished. Aggrieved by the order dated 28.6.2018, the
petitioners have filed W.P.(C) No.608 of 2018 and by the order dated
16.7.2018, the said writ petition was disposed of by granting liberty to the
petitioners to submit a representation to the State Government.
[3]
In compliance with the order, the petitioners have submitted a
representation on 25.7.2018 to the Commissioner (Hr. & Tech. Education)
requesting to allow them to function till the completion of all formalities of
handing over and taking over of the College assets and properties and also
to verify the list of teaching and non-teaching staff submitted by the
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 4
Governing Bodies.
Since the first respondent failed to consider the
representation, the petitioners have filed W.P.(C) No.858 of 2018.
[4]
By the order dated 14.09.2018, W.P.(C) No.858 of 2018 came
to be disposed of by directing the first respondent to consider and dispose of
th representation of the petitioners within a period of one month from the date
of receipt of a copy of the order.
Since the order of this Court dated
14.9.2018 has not been complied with, the petitioners have filed Contempt
Case No.177 of 2018 and pending Contempt Case, the first respondent
passed the impugned order dated 20.10.2018 rejecting the representation of
the petitioners. Challenging the same, the petitioners have filed the present
writ petition.
[5]
Resisting the writ petition, the 9 th respondent filed affidavit-in-
opposition stating that while disposing of W.P.(C) No.608 of 2018, this Court
clearly expressed the view that once the Government has taken a decision
to take over the Colleges and convert these Colleges into full-fledged
Government Colleges, normally the Governing Body would rendered nonfunctional, as it would be the State Government who would look after the
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 5
affairs and administration of the Colleges. It is stated that it is not mandatory
to follow handing over and taking over and it is the Government to decide in
the circumstances. In the present case also, six Government Aided Colleges
have been taken over by the Government and out of six, only the present
petitioners have grievances against the order dated 28.6.2018.
The
grievances of the Governing Body to remain in office is only to manipulate
the lists of teaching and non-teaching staff of the College.
The
representation of the petitioners was rejected by the competent authority for
the reasons stated in the order dated 20.10.2018.
Hence, prayed for
dismissal of the writ petition.
[6]
Assailing the impugned order, Mr.D.Julius Riamei, learned
counsel for the petitioner submitted when the petitioners filed Contempt Case
No.177 of 2018 for non-compliance of the order dated 14.9.2018 and on the
issuance of legal notice dated 25.10.2018 to the respondents, the impugned
order rejecting of the representation of the petitioner came to be passed
back-dating as 20.10.2018 in order to avoid the contempt proceedings. He
would submit that the necessity of handing over and taking over is to create
transparency in the conversion of the Colleges and most importantly to
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 6
ensure that all the assets and properties, bank accounts and teaching and
non-teaching staff of the Colleges are handed over to the Government free
of liabilities and encumbrances in any manner and also to avoid
discrepancies in future.
[7]
The learned counsel further submitted that while it is the
convention and norms followed by the State Government in handing over
and taking over from the respective Governing Bodies of the Government
Aided College or Private Colleges, as the case may be, the petitioners have
been denied and deprived of handing over and taking over in a fair and
transparent manner creating clouds and doubts and grey areas in the
conversion process. According to the learned counsel, the petitioners are
challenging the conversion of the Colleges into full-fledged Government
College per se but is only asking for formal execution of handing over and
taking over as done earlier, particularly, Jiri College. In view of the above,
the learned counsel for the petitioners prayed for setting aside the impugned
order and allow the petitioners’ function till the handing over and taking over
process of the Colleges are completed.
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 7
[8]
Per contra, Ms. Monomala, learned Government Advocate,
appearing for the respondents submitted that consequent upon the taking
over of the Colleges by the Government, the whole area of land, building,
other infrastructure, property/assets either movable or immovable and all the
monetary fund of any kind of belonging to the Colleges in question shall be
deemed acquired, possessed and owned by the Department of Higher
Education. As such, the continuation of the Governing Bodies do not arise.
She would submit that after due consideration and examination of the
request of the petitioners, the impugned order has been passed and there is
no illegality in it. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.
[9]
This Court considered the rival submissions and perused the
materials available on record.
[10]
The grievance of the petitioners is that till handing over and
taking over of Mayai Lambi College and Thambal Marik College are fully
completed, the respondents are to be directed to allow the petitioners to
function as such. Further grievance of the petitioners is that though the
Government had taken the overall administration of the two Colleges, the
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 8
only issue pending is absorption of 11 employees, which includes the
teaching and non-teaching staff of Thambal Marik College.
[11]
It appears that earlier, challenging the order dated 28.6.2018 to
the extent of abolishing the petitioners without having undertaken necessary
arrangements for handing over the College assets and properties, bank
accounts and staff, the petitioners have field W.P.(C) No.608 of 2018 before
this Court. By the order dated 16.7.2018, this Court disposed of the said writ
petition. The operative portion of the order dated 16.7.2018 reads thus:
“7. Accordingly, the present petition is closed with liberty
to the petitioners to file appropriate representation to the
State Government and it would be within the wisdom of
the State Government to pass appropriate order as it
may consider appropriate.”
[12]
Pursuant to the direction of this Court, the petitioners submitted
a representation dated 25.7.2018 to the Commissioner of Higher and
Technical Education to permit them to function as such till the completion of
all formalities of handing over of the College assets and properties and
making payment of due salaries for five months to the employees. In the
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 9
said representation, the petitioners have also requested to act upon the
verified list of teaching and non-teaching staff submitted by the present
Governing Bodies. Since the first respondent failed to take action on the
representation of the petitioners, the petitioners have filed W.P.(C) No.858
of 2018 before this Court.
[13]
By the order date 14.9.2018, this Court disposed of the writ
petition. The operative portion of the order reads thus:
“When the matter was taken up for consideration, Shri
PH. Sanajaoba, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner submits that the instant writ petition can be
disposed of by issuing an innocuous order and
accordingly, the writ petition stands disposed of with a
direction that the respondents and in particular,
respondent No.1 shall consider and dispose of the said
representation dated 25.7.2018 submitted by the
petitioners within a period of one month from the date of
receipt of a copy of this order and issue a speaking order
in respect thereof.”
[14]
It also appears that since the respondents failed to comply with
the order dated 14.9.2018, the petitioners have filed Contempt Case No.177
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 10
of 2018 and this Court admitted the Contempt Case on 25.10.2018 and
issued notice to the contemnors, thereby directing the Contempt Case to be
listed after four weeks for reporting compliance.
[15]
Pending Contempt Case, the first respondent passed the
impugned order dated 20.10.2018 rejecting the representation of the
petitioners. While rejecting the representation of the petitioners, the first
respondent observed as under:
“6. Now, therefore, in view of the above-facts and
circumstances, the Governor of Manipur is pleased to
order that after due consideration and minute
examination of the prayer of the petitioners for allowing
the Governing Bodies of Mayai Lambi College,
Yumnam Huidrom and Thambal Marik College, Oinam
to function as such till the completion of al formalities
of handing over of College assets and properties is
rejected.”
[16]
The order dated 28.6.2018 has been passed as a natural
consequence of the decision taken by the State Cabinet to take over six
Colleges, including Mayai Lambi College and Thambal Marik College and to
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 11
convert them to full-fledged Colleges and consequent upon the taking over
by the Government, the whole area of land, building and other infrastructure,
property/assets shall be deemed acquired, possessed and owned by the
Department of Higher Education, Government of Manipur.
[17]
The petitioners now claim that while it is the convention and
norms followed by the State Government in handing over and taking over
from the respective Governing Bodies of the Government Aided College or
Private College and the same has been extended to similarly placed
Colleges, the petitioners have been denied and deprived of the handing over
and taking over in a fair and transparent manner.
[18]
The specific case of the petitioners is that an actual handing
over and taking over by following the conventions and norms was done to
Tamenglong College vide order dated 16.3.1996, published in Manipur
Gazette on 10.6.1996; Chandel College, vide order dated 26.07.1996,
published in Manipur Gazette on 13.9.1996 and Jiri College, Jiribam vide
order dated 8.12.2016 and annexed the orders in respect of Jiri College
along with the writ petition.
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
However, in the case on hand, no formal
Page 12
execution of the handing over and taking over as done in the case of Jiri
College, has not done. To rebut the said plea of the petitioners, the
respondents have not produced any materials.
[19]
This Court is of the view that once the Government has taken a
decision to take over the Government Aided Colleges and convert the
Colleges into full-fledged Government Colleges, normally, the Governing
Body also would be rendered non-functional as it would be the State
Government who would look after the affairs and administrations of such
Colleges. Even though the two Colleges in question have been taken over
by the Government and converted into full-fledged Government Colleges,
according to the petitioners, there are still certain fundamental issues yet to
be settled between the Government and the Governing Bodies of the said
Colleges and their Trusts.
[20]
In fact, in their representation dated 25.7.2018, the petitioners
have specifically stated that the fundamental issues including the rights to
properties and the rights to handing over and the Government did not follow
any procedural law in taking over the properties of the Colleges, which is
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 13
owned and run by the Trust, a purely private bodies.
In the said
representation, the petitioners have also claimed denying rights to handing
over the assets of the Colleges by the Governing Bodies amounts to violation
of Article 14 of the Constitution of India i.e. equality with Tamenglong College
and United College, Chandel etc.
[21]
On a thorough reading of the impugned order, this Court finds
that the aforesaid aspects of the matter canvassed by the petitioners in their
representation dated 25.7.2018 have not been considered by the first
respondent while issuing the impugned order. In the impugned order, the
first respondent merely by referring the earlier litigations and directions of
this Court, simply rejected the representation. Such approach adopted by
the first respondent is unsustainable. When the respondents have raised a
plea that denying the rights to handing over the assets of the Colleges by the
Governing Bodies amounts to violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of
India and the petitioners have been denied and deprived of the handing over
and taking over in a fair and transparent manner, it is the bounden duty of
the first respondent to consider the said aspect while issuing the impugned
order. In the case on hand, the first respondent has failed to do the same
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 14
and the impugned order came to be passed during the pendency of the
Contempt Case to avoid the contempt proceedings against the respondents.
[22]
The petitioners claim that till the handing over and taking over
of Mayani Lambi College and Thambal Marik College are completed, they
will have to be allowed to function. Admittedly, the said aspect has not been
considered by the first respondent in the impugned order. Therefore, this
Court is of the view that the impugned order has been passed in a hurried
manner.
[23]
While pendency of the writ petition, the writ petitioners have
filed additional affidavit dated 24.02.2022 by enclosing the orders dated
17.03.2019 and 24.12.2021 and prayed this Court that this Court may issue
directions to the respondent Nos. 1 to 3 for considering the 11(eleven)
employees of Thambal Marik Lambi College for absorption in the interest of
justice.
[24]
By showing the additional affidavit dated 24.02.2022, Mr. D.
Julius Riamei, learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that this Court
may direct the respondents to allow the petitioners to functions until the
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 15
handing and taking over of the Mayai Lambi College, Yumnam Huidrom and
Thambal Marik College Oinam are completed. Mr. D. Julius Riamei, learned
counsel for the petitioners further stated that the Government had taken the
overall administration of the subject two Colleges and the only issue pending
is absorption of 11(eleven) employees(Teaching Staff-5 and Non-Teaching6) of the Thambal Marik College.
[25]
Mr. D. Julius Riamei, learned counsel for the petitioners further
submitted that suitable direction may be issued to the respondents for
considering the absorption of the said 11(eleven) employees of the Thambal
Marik College.
[26]
By reading the said orders dated 17.03.2019 and 24.12.2021,
it is made clear that though the taking over of overall administration of the
subject two Colleges completed and the only issue pending before the
respondents are that the absorption of 11(eleven) employees (Teaching
Staff-5 and Non-Teaching-6) of the Thambal Marik College. Therefore, in the
interest of justice it is fair enough to issue direction to the respondents though
the subject Colleges were taken over by the Government the overall
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 16
administration, to consider the said 11(eleven) employees of Thambal Marik
College for absorption in the interest of justice.
[27]
In the above circumstances,
(a) the writ petition is disposed of .
(b) the respondent Nos. 1 to 3 are hereby directed to
absorb the 11(eleven) employees (Teaching Staff-5
and Non-Teaching-6) of the Thambal Marik College,
Oinam.
(c) the said exercise shall be done within a period of
8(eight) weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this
order.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
John Kom
WP(c)No.1057 of 2018
Page 17
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review