Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
TUESDAY, THE 1ST DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 11TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 976 OF 2015
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 02.02.2015 IN WPC NO.20291 OF
2011 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS:
THE GENERAL MANAGER (PERSONAL)
VIJAYA BANK, (HEAD OFFICE),
41/2, M.G.ROAD,, BANGALORE-560001
THE VIJAYA BANK
REPRESENTED BY THE GENERAL MANAGER (PERSONAL),
VIJAYA BANK, (HEAD OFFICE), 41/2, M.G.ROAD,
BANGALORE-560001.
THE DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER
PERSONAL DEPARTMENT (PA&PD),
VIJAYA BANK,, (HEAD OFFICE),
41/2, M.G.ROAD, BANGALORE-560 001.
THE BRANCH MANAGER
VIJAYA BANK,PONNANI BRANCH,
PONNANI, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT-, 679577.
BY ADVS.
SRI.K.ANAND (SR.)
SRI.JOSEPH SEBASTIAN PARACKAL
SMT.LATHA KRISHNAN
SRI.M.N.RADHAKRISHNA MENON
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
V.T.RADHAKRISHNAN, S/O.LATE VELAYUDHAN NAIR, CLERK,
CODE NO.5823, VIJAYA BANK, PONNANI NOW RESIDING AT,
THEMPALATH HOUSE, TRIKANDIYOOR P.O., TIRUR-4,, PIN666164, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, KERALA
BY ADVS.
SRI.B.BIPIN
SRI.R.REJI
SRI.M.V.THAMBAN
SMT.THARA THAMBAN
THIS WRIT APPEAL WAS FINALLY HEARD ON 19.03.2025, THE COURT
ON 01.04.2025 PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
“CR”
JUDGMENT
Muralee Krishna, J.
This is an intra-court appeal filed under Section 5(i) of the
Kerala
High
Court
W.P.(C)No.20291
of
Act,
1958,
by
the
respondents
challenging
the
judgment
in
dated
02.02.2015 passed by the learned Single Judge, whereby the writ
petition filed by the respondent herein was allowed directing the
2nd appellant Bank to admit the respondent as a member of the
Pension Scheme and disburse consequential benefits to him with
effect from 27.04.2010. The respondent was further directed to
refund the entire amount as contemplated under Ext.P5 to the
Bank within six weeks.
2.
The writ petition was one filed by the respondent herein
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking the following
reliefs:
“i) to issue a writ of Certiorari, calling for the records leading
upto Exhibit P11 and quash Exhibit P7 and P11.
ii) to issue declarations as follows:(a) Though petitioner used the word 'resignation' in Exhibit
P2 request to relieve from the service due to health reason,
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
the nature of the request is definitely seeking permission'
from the Bank authorities to relieve him from the duty which
is in effect, a case of Voluntary Retirement. Hence turning
down the request of the petitioner for treating Exhibit P2 as
a request for voluntary retirement by Exhibit P11 order by
the 1st respondent is highly arbitrary, illegal and without any
application of mind.
(b) to declare that using of the word ‘Resignation’ in Exhibit
P2 cannot be used to deny the petitioner's right to join
pension scheme and that the petitioner is entitled and
qualified to join the pension scheme in terms of 9th Bipartite
settlement/ joint note dated 27.04.2010, as his case is
squarely covered under clause A (1) of Exhibit P5 pension
Scheme.
iii). to issue a writ of mandamus or other writ or order
directing the respondents to permit the petitioner to join the
pension scheme as per Exhibit P5 and to accept the
contribution and sanction pension”.
3. The respondent joined the service of the 2nd appellant
Bank on 01.09.1975 in one of its branches at Calicut. On
30.04.2010, he submitted Ext.P2 resignation letter to the Bank
requesting to relieve him with effect from 31.05.2010, due to his
ill-health. By Ext.P3 letter dated 28.05.2010 his resignation was
accepted by the 3rd appellant Deputy General Manager of the
Bank. On the basis of Exts.P2 and P3, the respondent received all
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
his service benefits from the Bank. Meanwhile, the 9th bipartite
settlement dated 27.04.2010 was signed between the Indian
Banks’ Association and Workmen’s Union and the same was
circulated by Ext.P5 circular dated 07.09.2010 of the Bank. As
per paragraph No.1 of Ext.P5, the employees who were in service
of the Bank prior to 29th day of September 1995 and continue to
be in the service of the Bank as on 27th day of April, 2010 were
entitled to give an option in writing within 60 days from the date
of the said Circular to become a member of the Pension Fund. The
respondent exercised his option in writing on 13.09.2010 and he
undertook to refund the service benefits received by him. But, by
Ext.P7 letter dated 03.11.2010, the 3rd appellant rejected his
request.
Thereafter,
the
respondent
submitted
Ext.P8
representation dated 14.02.2011 to the 2nd appellant to treat
Ext.P2 request as the one made for voluntary retirement. Since
no action was followed in Ext.P8 representation the respondent
approached this Court by filing W.P.(C)No.6992 of 2011 and that
writ
petition was disposed of
by Ext.P9
judgment
dated
07.03.2011 directing consideration of Ext.P8 representation.
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
Pursuant to Ext.P9 judgment, the 1st appellant offered a personal
hearing to the respondent and thereafter by Ext.P11 order dated
25.05.2011, Ext.P8 representation was rejected. Contending that
the respondent made Ext.P2 with an intention to give him
voluntary retirement and not as a resignation, he filed the
W.P.(C)No.20291 of 2011 before this Court. By the impugned
judgment dated 02.02.2015, the learned Single Judge allowed the
writ petition directing the 2nd appellant to extend the benefit of the
Pension Scheme to the respondent, holding that no employee after
putting more than 35 years of service will be interested to forfeit
his past service
4. Heard the learned counsels on both sides.
5. The learned counsel for the appellants submitted that
there
is
a
retirement.
difference
between
resignation
and
voluntary
In the instant case the respondent has submitted
Ext.P2 request to accept his resignation with effect from
31.05.2010 and that was accepted by Ext.P3 letter dated
28.05.2010. Ext.P5 circular was issued on 07.09.2010. On coming
to know about Ext.P5, the respondent subsequently came up with
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
a request that Ext.P2 has to be treated as a request for voluntary
retirement and not as a resignation. Clause 6 of Ext.P5 Scheme is
applicable to the ex-employees who ceased to be in service on
account of Vijaya Bank (Employees) Voluntary Retirement
Scheme-2000 after rendering service for a minimum period of 15
years. As per Clause 7 of Ext.P5 Scheme, the option to join the
Pension Scheme shall not be extended to those employees who
ceased to be in the service of the Bank in any manner other than
the categories mentioned in Clause 6. Though Clause 7 of Ext.P5
has
been
struck
down
by
the
Karnataka
High
Court
in
W.P.(C)No.24158 of 2011 and connected cases and it was affirmed
by the Division Bench, while dismissing the Special Leave Petition,
the Apex Court ordered that the question of law arises in the
context of challenge with reference to Clause 7 of Ext.P5 Scheme
shall be left open. As per Clause 22 of the Vijaya Bank (Employees
Pension) Regulations, 1995 a resigned employee is not qualified
for pensionary benefits. After finding that there is a difference
between resignation and voluntary retirement, the learned Single
Judge ought not have allowed the writ petition. In support of his
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
argument regarding the difference between voluntary retirement
and resignation, the learned counsel relied on the judgment of the
Apex Court in Senior Divisional Manager, Life Insurance
Corporation India Ltd. v. Shree Lal Meena [(2019) 4 SCC
479].
6. The learned counsel for the respondent would submit that
the respondent was suffering from mental illness and it was for
that reason he submitted Ext.P2 resignation letter which actually
he meant as a request for voluntary retirement. Though he
subsequently submitted Ext.P8 request to treat Ext.P2 as a letter
of voluntary retirement, it was not accepted by the Bank. The
learned Single Judge made correct findings in the impugned
judgment and hence no interference is warranted.
7.
The appellants are relying on Clauses 6 and 7 of Ext.P5
as well as Regulation 22 (1) of the Vijaya Bank (Employees)
Pension Regulations, 1995, to contend that a person resigns from
the Bank is not entitled for the benefit of Ext.P5 circular and the
Pension Scheme mentioned therein. Clauses 6 and 7 of Ext.P5
read thus:
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
“6. Ex-employees, who:
Ceased to be in service on account of Special Voluntary
Retirement
Scheme,
i.e.,
Vijaya
Bank
(Employees')
Voluntary Retirement Scheme-2000 after rendering service
for a minimum period of 15 years shall be eligible to
exercise an option to join the Pension Scheme subject to
the terms and conditions applicable to retired employees,
who are opting for joining the Scheme.
7.
This option to join the Pension Scheme shall not be
extended to those employees (Officers & Award Staff) who
ceased to be in the service of the Bank in any manner other
than the categories mentioned herein above.”
8. Though Clause 7 of Ext.P5 was struck down by the
Karnataka High Court in W.P.(C)No.24158 of 2011 and connected
cases, it was not disputed that while dismissing the Special Leave
Petition, the Apex Court ordered that the question of law arising
in the contest of challenge with reference to Clause 7 of Ext.P5 is
left open.
9. Clause 22 (1) of the Pension Regulation of the Bank reads
as under:
“Resignation or dismissal or removal or termination of
an employee from the service of the Bank shall entail
forfeiture of his entire past service and consequently
shall not qualify for pensionary benefits”
W.A. No.976 of 2015
10.
2025:KER:27255
In Shree Lal Meena [(2019) 4 SCC 479] the Apex
Court while answering a reference, whether the employees, who
had resigned from service post the date from which the pension
schemes were made applicable, but prior to the date on which the
schemes got notified, would be entitled to the benefit of the
pension schemes in question, considered a similar situation in the
case of Life Insurance Corporation of India (Employees) Pension
Rules, 1995, wherein Rule 23 of that Rules is the same as that of
Clause 22 of the Vijaya Bank Pension Regulations. By considering
the distinction between resignation and voluntary retirement the
Apex Court held thus:
“When the Legislature, in its wisdom, brings forth
certain beneficial provisions in the form of Pension
Regulations from a particular date and on particular
terms and conditions, aspects which are excluded
cannot be included in it by implication. The provisions
will have to be read as they read unless there is some
confusion or they are capable of another interpretation.
We may also note that while framing such schemes,
there is an important aspect of them being of a
contributory nature and their financial implications.
Such financial implications are both, for the contributors
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
and for the State. Thus, it would be inadvisable to
expand such beneficial schemes beyond their contours
to extend them to employees for whom they were not
meant for by the Legislature.”
(emphasis supplied)
11.
The respondent submitted Ext.P2 resignation on
30.4.2010 requesting to permit him to resign from the service of
the Bank with effect from 31.05.2010. The reason for resignation
is stated as ill health due to eyesight and hypertension related
problems. The said request was accepted by Ext.P3 letter dated
28.05.2010 by the Deputy General Manager of the Bank. Ext.P5
circular was issued only on 07.09.2010. It was thereafter the
respondent submitted Ext.P8 request dated 14.02.2011 to treat
Ext.P2 as a request for voluntary retirement. By Ext.P11
proceedings dated 25.05.2011 this request was not accepted by
the General Manager of the Bank.
12. Viewed in the light of Clause 22 of Vijaya Bank
(Employees) Pension Regulations 1995 and the law laid down in
the decision of the Apex Court in Shree Lal Meena [(2019) 4
SCC 479] we hold that the respondent who had resigned from
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
service post the date from which the Pension Scheme was made
applicable by Ext.P5 circular, but prior to the date on which the
schemes got notified is not entitled to seek the benefit of the
Scheme. In such circumstances the impugned judgment of the
learned Single Judge is liable to be set aside.
In the result, the writ appeal is allowed by setting aside the
impugned judgment dated 02.02.2015 passed by the learned
Single judge in W.P.(C)No.20291 of 2011 and the writ petition
stands dismissed.
Sd/ANIL K.NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
sks
W.A. No.976 of 2015
2025:KER:27255
APPENDIX OF WA 976/2015
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure A1
TRUE COPY OF JUDGMENT IN W.P.NOS.2415824160/2011
Annexure A2
TRUE COPY OF ORDER IN CONT.CASE NO.392/14
OF THE KARNATAKA HIGH COURT AT BANGALORE.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review