Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
1IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 28-01-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P. DHANABAL
SA No. 577 of 2018
AND
CMP No. 6747 of 2024
The Executive Officer
Thiruvenkatanatha Perumal, And
Vaidhyanathasamy Temple, Sulur.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. Ramasamy (Died)
S/o Kumarasamy Gounder,
4/125, Arankulam, Paruvai, Palladam.
2. Arukutty,
S/o Kumarasamy Gounder,
4/125 Arankulam, Paruvai, Palladam.
3. The Joint Commissioner.
Hindu Religious Endowment Department,
Dr.Balasundaram Road, Coimbatore.
4. The Sub Registrar,
Sub Regisrar Sub Registrar Office, Sulur,
Coimbatore District.
5. Eswaran
S/o. Late Ramasamy,
No.4/16, Poonguttai Thottam, Arakulam,
Paruvai, Palladam.
6. Jayalakshmi
D/o. Late Ramasamy,
No.3/63, Perumal Koil St,
Karadivavi, Palladam.
__________
Page1 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
7. Padmavathi
D/o. Late Ramasamy,
No.4/167A, Mulathottam, Arakulam,
Paruvai, Palladam.
8. Senthil Kumar
S/o. Late Ramasamy,
No.4/125, Arakulam, Palladam.
(R1 died, RR5 to 8 are brought on record as
LRs of the deceased R1 vide Court order dated
07/03/2024 made in CMP No 4124 of 2024 in
SA
No.
of
2018)
..Respondent(s)
Prayer : Second Appeal filed under Section 100 CPC, 1908, to set aside the
decree and judgment made in AS. No.1/2014 dated 24/04/2018 on the file of
Principal Subordinate judge, Tiruppur, reversing the decree and judgment made
in OS. No.143/2011 dated 29/10/2013 on the file of District Munsif Court,
Palladam.
For Appellant(s):
Mr.R.T.Doraisamy
For Respondent(s):
Mr.N.Damodaran
for R2, R5 to R8
Mr.M.Gurunathan
Government Advocate
for R3 & R4
__________
Page2 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
JUDGMENT
The second appeal has been preferred as against the decree and judgment
dated 24.04.2018 passed by the Principal Subordinate Court, Tiruppur, in
A.S.No.1 of 2014, wherein the respondents herein have preferred the said
appeal as against the decree and judgment dated 29.10.2013 passed in
O.S.No.143 of 2011, on the file of the District Munsif Court, Palladam.
Originally, the respondents herein have filed the suit for declaration before the
Trial Court and the same was dismissed. Challenging the same, the First
Appellate Court reversed the judgment of the Trial Court and decreed the suit.
Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment, the present second appeal has been
preferred by the second defendant.
2. For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as per their
rank in the Trial Court and at appropriate places, their rank in the present second
appeals would also be indicated.
3. The brief averments of the plaint are as follows :
The suit property originally belonged to Sreeranga Gounder and
Karuppakal through registered sale deed dated 24.01.1928. After the demise of
Sreeranga Gounder, the said properties were partitioned among his legal heirs
and his brother Karuppa Gounder through registered Partition Deed dated
22.04.1948. The said Sreeranga Gounder had two sons namely Karuppa
__________
Page3 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
Gounder and Kumarasamy Gounder. The plaintiffs are sons of Kumarasamy
Gounder. As per the Partition Deed dated 22.04.1948, 'B' schedule property was
allotted to Kumarasamy Gounder and the suit properties are one among the
properties of the above said 'B' schedule property. After the demise of
Kumarasamy Gounder, his daughters Chellammal and Rasammal have executed
registered Release Deed dated 15.09.2006 in favour of their brothers Ramasamy
Gounder and Arukutty Gounder, who are the plaintiffs herein. Both the
plaintiffs are in joint possession and enjoyment of the suit properties by
cultivating the lands. The plaintiffs have title deeds for the properties situated in
S.F.No.81 and the same was sub-divided and the present survey number is 81/2.
While so, when the plaintiffs applied for Encumbrance Certificate for the suit
properties on 13.09.2010, they came to know that the defendants have registered
their objection pertaining to the suit properties in S.F.No.81/2, 77/1C, 1H, 1F
stating that the same belonged to the second defendant. The defendants 1 and 2
have no any right over the suit properties and the plaintiffs are the absolute
owners of the suit properties. Therefore, the plaintiffs filed the suit for
declaration as against the defendants 1 and 2 and mandatory injunction directing
the third defendant to delete the entries made in the records of the Sulur Sub
Registrar office.
__________
Page4 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
4. The brief averments of the written statement filed by the second
defendant are as follows :
The suit is not maintainable in law and on facts and the plaintiffs are put
to strict proof of all the allegations except those that are specifically admitted by
this defendant. The plaintiffs have to prove that the suit properties to an extent
of 3.24 acres belonged to them and other averments made in the plaint in respect
of those properties. The plaintiffs have suppressed the material facts and with
malafide intention to grab the second defendant's land, filed the suit. The
plaintiffs have purchased only the properties in S.F.No.81. Originally, the suit
properties and other properties were granted in favour of the temple by the
Ancient Kings for day-to-day affairs of the temple. As per records maintained
by the second defendant and superior authorities, the suit properties are
absolutely belonged to the second defendant and he is the absolute owner of the
suit properties. Originally, the second defendant was having more than 402
acres for maintaining the second defendant temple. As per the settlement
proceedings the suit properties were granted in favour of the second defendant.
The plaintiffs themselves admitted that the second defendant is the real owner
of the suit properties. There is no cause of action for the suit and the suit is
liable to be dismissed.
__________
Page5 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
5. Based on the above said pleadings and after hearing both sides and
perusing the records, the Trial Court framed the following issues:
"(i) Whether the plaintiffs have got valid title and they are in lawful
possession and enjoyment of the suit property ?
(ii) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to declaration and consequential
relief of permanent injunction as prayed for?
(iii) To what other reliefs the plaintiffs are entitled to ?”
6. In order to prove the case before the Trial Court, on the side of
plaintiffs, the first plaintiff has examined himself as PW1 and one another
witness PW2 and marked Ex.A1 to Ex.A36. On the side of the defendants, no
witnesses
were
examined
and
no
documents
have
been
marked.
7. After evaluating the oral and documentary evidences and hearing both
sides, the Trial Court dismissed the suit through decree and judgment dated
29.10.2013. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment, the plaintiffs have
preferred an appeal in AS No.1 of 2014 on the file of the Principal Subordinate
Court, Tiruppur, on various grounds.
__________
Page6 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
8. The First Appellate Court, after hearing both sides and perusing the
records, framed the following point for determination :
“ (i) Whether the plaintiffs have proved their claim of title to the
suit properties?
(ii) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the reliefs as prayed for?
(iii) Whether the decree and the judgment of the Trial Court is
liable to be set aside ?”
9. After hearing both sides and perusing the records, the First Appellate
Court set aside the decree and judgment passed by the Trial Court and decreed
the suit as prayed for in the plaint. Aggrieved by the said decree and judgment
of the First Appellate Court, the present second appeal has been preferred by the
second defendant.
10. Heard Mr.R.T.Doraisamy, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
and Mr.M.Gurunathan, learned Government Advocate appearing for the
respondent 3 and 4, Mr.N.Damodaran, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents 2, 5 to 8.
11. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant would submit that
the suit properties are the Inam properties and the said properties were given to
__________
Page7 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
the temple by the Ancient Kings who ruled in the locality long back and
therefore the temple is the owner of the lands measuring about 402 acres in that
village and the plaintiffs attempted to encroach those properties and thereby sent
a letter to the Registrar Office to protect the said temple properties. Therefore,
they objected to grant decree in favour of the plaintiffs before the Trial Court.
The Trial Court correctly appreciated the facts and dismissed the suit. However,
the First Appellate Court considering the evidence without appreciating the
facts, erroneously decreed the suit. However, during the pendency of the appeal,
based on the direction of this Court they ascertained through the Joint Director,
Survey Department, District Collector, Tiruppur, that the S.Nos.77 and 81
Paruvayi Village are not belonging to the temple and they are not the Inam
lands issued by the Kings in favour of the temple. Therefore, prays the Court to
pass appropriate orders based on the records.
12. The learned counsel appearing for the respondents would submit that
the properties are under the possession and enjoyment of the plaintiffs and their
predecessors from time immemorial. Originally, the suit properties were
purchased by the grandparents of the plaintiffs through registered sale deed
dated 24.01.1928 and thereafter, partition deed were entered into between the
parties on 22.04.1948. The suit properties are under the possession and
enjoyment of the plaintiffs and their predecessors. While so, the second
__________
Page8 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
defendant has sent a communication to Sulur Sub Registrar Office, the third
defendant not to register as documents in respect of S.Nos.77 and 81. The
second respondent has no right, title, interest over the suit properties and they
wrongly claiming the properties as Inam properties granted in favour of the
temple. The suit properties have no way connected with the second defendant
temple. Before the Trial Court, on the side of the plaintiffs they examined PW1
and PW2 and also marked Ex.A1 to Ex.A36. On the side of the defendants, they
have not examined any witnesses and no documents have been marked.
However, the Trial Court failed to consider the evidence adduced by the
plaintiffs. Even in the absence of any evidence from the defendants the Trial
Court dismissed the suit. However, the First Appellate Court correctly
appreciated the facts and decreed the suit. The defendants have not filed any
documents. Therefore, the First Appellate Court has granted decree based on the
evidence. There is no ground to allow the second appeal. There is no substantial
questions of law involved in this case. Therefore, the second appeal is liable to
be dismissed.
13. This Court, at the time of admitting the second appeal,framed the
following substantial questions of law :
“i. Whether the Lower Appellate Court is justified in law in
decreeing the suit in respect of the suit properties containing
__________
Page9 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
several items, only based on Ex.A1- Sale Deed, which does not
speak about Item Nos.2 and 3 of the suit properties and
specifically deals with only Item No.1 of the suit properties in
respect of S.No.81/2?
ii. Whether the Lower Appellate Court is justified in
reversing the judgment and decree of the Trial Court without
application of mind to the evidence let in by the parties in a
proper and perspective manner ?”
14. This Court heard both sides and perused the records.
15. The plaintiffs have filed the suit for declaration and permanent
injunction as against the defendants. According to the plaintiffs, their
predecessors purchased the properties through a registered sale deed dated
24.01.1928 and thereafter, the partition was effected between the parties through
partition deed dated 22.04.1948 and thereafter, the plaintiffs both are jointly
enjoying the properties without any interruption from anybody. However, the
second defendant sent a letter to the third defendant not to register the case,
thereby they filed the suit for declaration. Before the Trial Court, they examined
PW1 and PW2 and marked Ex.A1 to Ex.A36. On the side of the defendants,
they have not examined any witnesses and no documents have been marked.
__________
Page10 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
The Trial Court dismissed the suit. The First Appellate Court allowed the appeal
and set aside the decree and judgment passed by the Trial Court and decreed the
suit. In fact before the Trial Court, the plaintiffs have examined the witnesses
and marked documents. Ex.A1 is the sale deed dated 24.01.1928 and as per the
sale deed the property in S.F.No.81 was purchased by the predecessors of the
plaintiffs. As per Ex.A2, the said property purchased through sale deed Ex.A1
and other ancestral properties were partitioned through registered partition deed
dated 22.04.1948. Further, the plaintiffs have produced the Revenue Records in
the name of their predecessors. Ex.A6 / patta is for the year 1974, therefore the
plaintiffs established their prima facie case and discharged their initial burden,
however, the defendants have not produced any piece of evidence to rebut the
plaintiffs side evidences. Ex.A1 and Ex.A2 are very old documents and thereby
they cannot be discarded in any way. The Trial Court failed to appreciate the
evidence in a proper perspective and wrongly came to a conclusion that no
parental documents produced for the ancestral property partitioned through deed
dated 22.04.1948. The First Appellate Court after analysing the evidences
correctly set aside the judgment of the Trial Court and decreed the suit as the
documents produced by the plaintiffs established the case of the plaintiffs and
no evidence adduced by the defendants. During the pendency of the appeal, as
per the direction of this Court, the appellants have verified the nature of the
properties through District Collector, Tiruppur and obtained some documents
from the District Collector, wherein the District Collector sent reply that as per
__________
Page11 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
the records S.Nos.77 and 81 of Paruvayi Village, Palladam Taluk. Tiruppur
District, there are no records to show that those properties were granted as Inam
lands given in favour of the temple. Based on those documents the learned
counsel appearing for the appellant also filed memo before this Court that the
S.Nos.77 and 81 of Paruvayi Village which are suit properties herein are not
belongs to the temple. Therefore, based on the memo, the temple is not a owner
of the property whereas the plaintiffs have produced the documents for purchase
of one property and also filed partition deed for other properties and for
possession of other properties for long time. Therefore, the First Appellate
Court has analysed the evidences and decreed the suit.
16. During the pendency of the appeal, the respondents have filed a
petition under Order XLI Rule 27 r/w. Section 151 of CPC to receive the
documents as additional evidence. Those documents are letters sent by the first
respondent to the third respondent with respect to the properties belonging to
the temple on various dates. The respondent who is the appellant in the main
appeal has not filed counter. However, filed memo stating that the appellant had
sought for information in respect of S.Nos.77 and 81, Paruvai Village, Palladam
Taluk, Tiruppur District, in respect of property details and Inam details in the
said survey numbers in favour of the temple from the Assistant Commissioner,
Survey of Land and Registration Department, Tiruppur, as well as from the
__________
Page12 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
District Collector, Tiruppur, by request letter dated 06.12.2024. The
communication dated 23.12.2024, the office of the District Collector, Tiruppur,
had issued reply stating that there is no Inam granted in the said survey numbers
and there is no Inam Fair Register is available in the said survey numbers i.e.
S.Nos.77 and 81. As per the request letter dated 06.12.2024, the Office of the
Collector also issued the FMB Sketch and SR Register and also obtained
Encumbrance Certificate in respect of S.Nos.77 and 81, Paruvai Village. All the
above said documents disclosed the fact that the S.Nos.77 and 81, Paruvai
Village is no way connected to the temple. Therefore, in view of the above said
memo filed by the appellant and communications between the first defendant
and the second respondent has been obtained after filing of the second appeal, it
is appropriate to allow this petition and to receive those documents.
Accordingly, those documents are received and marked as Ex.A37 to Ex.A42.
17. As far as, the substantial questions of law formulated by this Court are
concerned viz.,
(i) Whether the Lower Appellate Court is justified in law in decreeing the
suit in respect of the suit properties containing several items, only based on
Ex.A1- Sale Deed, which does not speak about Item Nos.2 and 3 of the suit
properties and specifically deals with only Item No.1 of the suit properties in
respect of S.No.81/2?
__________
Page13 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
According to the plaintiffs, their predecessors purchased the property in
SF No.81 and SF No.77 was also enjoyed by them thereby SF No.77 is
ancestral property. Subsequent to the purchase of SF No.81 the properties were
partitioned between their predecessors. While so, the second defendant sent a
letter to the Registrar Office not to entertain any registration of documents in
respect of the properties in SF No.81 and 77 thereby the suit has been filed.
Initially, the defendants contested the suit and claimed that the properties are
temple properties. The Trial Court dismissed the suit, but the First Appellate
Court reversed the judgment and decree of the Trial Court and allowed the
appeal and decreed the suit. During pending of the second appeal, as per the
direction of this Court, the appellant verified the title of the property and the suit
in SF Nos.81 and 77 are not related to the second defendant temple. As per
available records with the concerned Government officials the suit properties
are not Inam lands and not granted to the temple. Therefore, the appellant /
second defendant temple itself now conceded that the suit properties are not
belongs to the temple. The respondent 1 and 2 / plaintiffs have proved their case
through reliable evidences.
Though the plaintiffs have produced the documents Ex.A1/sale deed in
respect of S.No.81/2, they also produced the documents like patta and other
documents for possession and when the defendants have no any right over the
property, the defendants not even produced the documents to substantiate their
contention, subsequently admitted that the properties are not belongs to the
__________
Page14 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
temple and when the plaintiffs have proved their long possession, enjoyment
and produced the documents the First Appellate Court has justified in decreeing
the suit.
(ii) Whether the Lower Appellate Court is justified in reversing the
judgment and decree of the Trial Court without application of mind to the
evidence let in by the parties in a proper and perspective manner ?
The Trial Court dismissed the suit on the ground that Ex.A1 referred the
property situated in SF No.81 and not referred the other suit items of the
properties. In Ex.A1, the vendor stated that it was his self acquired properties.
While so, no documents produced for that and Ex.A2 partition deed four items
were referred but no reference about the acquisition of the properties. Though
revenue records produced by the plaintiffs those records are not sufficient and
thereby dismissed the suit. However, the First Appellate Court in the judgment
stated that as per Ex.A1, SF No.81 was purchased by the plaintiffs’ predecessors
through sale deed dated 24.01.1928. As per Ex.A2 / partition deed dated
22.04.1948 all the properties were partitioned. Ex.A6 / patta has been granted in
the name of grandfather of the plaintiffs in the year 1974. Therefore, the
plaintiffs proved their title and possession and the defendants have not produced
any piece of evidence, thereby decreed the suit. As far as the findings of the
Trial Court are concerned, all the documents are old documents, more than 60
years old registered documents. Though Ex.A1, first item of the suit property
__________
Page15 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
was purchased, other items were partitioned as they are their ancestral
properties. For ancestral properties there may not be any title deeds and revenue
records only could be maintained. Once the plaintiffs established their case
through registered documents, they discharged their initial burden and the
defendants have to prove the contrary, but the defendants did not produced any
piece of evidences it their favour. Therefore, the findings of the First appellate
Court that the plaintiffs failed to established their case is not correct.
The First Appellate Court based on the documents and the evidences
adduced by the plaintiffs and in the absence of any contra evidence to the
plaintiffs' side evidence, correctly appreciated the facts and based on the
documents after applying of mind and after analysing the evidences reversed the
judgment of the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court has appreciated the
facts in a proper perspective manner and therefore, the First Appellate Court is
justified in reversing the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court.
18. In view of the above said discussions and the answers to the
substantial questions of law and the memo filed by the appellant, this appeal has
no merits and deserves to be dismissed.
__________
Page16 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
19. In the result,
i. CMP No. 6747 of 2024 is allowed.
ii.the Second Appeal is dismissed. No costs.
27-01-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
MTL
To
1. The Joint Commissioner
Hindu Religious Endowment Department,
Dr.Balasundaram Road, Coimbatore
2. The Sub Registrar
Sub Regisrar Sub Registrar Office, Sulur,
Coimbatore District.
__________
Page17 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
APPENDIX:
Additional Documents:
Ex.A.37 01.12.2007 Letter sent by the 1st respondent herein to the
3rd respondent herein with respect to the
properties belonging to the temple.
Ex.A.38 29.03.2012 Letter sent by the 1st respondent herein to the
3rd respondent herein with respect to the
properties belonging to the temple.
Ex.A.39 18.10.2023 Letter sent by the 1st respondent herein to the
3rd respondent herein with respect to the
properties belonging to the temple.
Ex.A.40 03.01.2023 Letter sent by the 1st respondent herein to the
3rd respondent herein with respect to the
properties belonging to the temple.
Ex.A.41 02.03.2023 Letter sent by the 1st respondent herein to the
3rd respondent herein with respect to the
properties belonging to the temple.
Ex.A.42 27.09.2023 Letter sent by the 1st respondent herein to the
3rd respondent herein with respect to the
properties belonging to the temple.
28-01-2026
__________
Page18 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 577 of 2018
and CMP No.6747 of 2024
P.DHANABAL, J.
MTL
SA No. 577 of 2018
AND CMP NO. 6747 OF 2024
28-01-2026
__________
Page19 of 19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review