Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:53212
936-FA-870-14.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
936 FIRST APPEAL NO. 870 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 863 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 864 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 865 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 866 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 867 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
AND
936-FA-870-14.odt
FIRST APPEAL NO. 868 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 869 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 871 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 872 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 873 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 874 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 875 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1331 OF 2018
Arjun Nana Dhage (Died) Through L.Rs. Vilas Arjun Dhageand Another
936-FA-870-14.odt
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1332 OF 2018
Dattatraya Rambhau Mhaske
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1333 OF 2018
Dhondiba Daulat Mhaske (Died) Through L.Rs. Daulat Dhondiba Mhaske
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1334 OF 2018
Raju Bahirnath Dhage And Another
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1335 OF 2018
Babasaheb Vithoba Dusunge
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2403 OF 2014
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2923 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2924 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
936-FA-870-14.odt
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Others
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 4437 OF 2023
Sushila Namdeo Kale And Another
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1945 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1946 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1947 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1948 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1949 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
936-FA-870-14.odt
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1950 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1951 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1953 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1954 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1955 OF 2015
The Executive Director, Krishna Khore Mahamandal, Minor Irrigation
Division-1, Ahmednagar
VERSUS
The State Of Maharashtra And Another
……
Mr. G.B. Rajale, D.R. Jethliya, Advocate for Acquiring Body
Mr. D.A. Bide, Advocate h/f Mr. M.R. Khutwad, D.R. Jayabhar, R.K. Temkar
N.C. Garud and N.B. Narwade, P.V. Barde, Advocates for respective
Claimants
Mr. A.M. Phule, AGP for State
……
936-FA-870-14.odt
CORAM : SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE, J.
DATE
: 23 OCTOBER, 2026
PER COURT :
1.
The following matters are not on board, upon mentioning, taken on
board.
FA/1945/2015,
FA/1948/2015,
FA/1946/2015,
FA/1949/2015,
FA/1947/2015,
FA/1950/2015,
FA/1945/2015,
FA/1951/2015,
FA/1953/2015, FA/1954/2015, FA/1945/2015, FA/1954/2015.
2.
Heard Mr. G.B. Rajale and Mr. D.R. Jethliya, learned Advocates for
the acquiring body; Mr. D.A. Bide, learned Advocate holding for Mr. M.R.
Khutwad, and Mr. D.R. Jayabhar, Mr. R.K. Temkar, Mr. N.C. Garud, Mr. N.B.
Narwade and Mr. P.V. Barde, learned Advocates for the respective claimants;
and Mr. A.M. Phule, learned AGP for the State. In some matters, Mr. Mukul
Kulkarni had earlier appeared on behalf of the acquiring body. As it is
informed that now Mr. Mukul Kulkarni is not on the panel. Therefore, this
Court is requested to Mr. Rajale to appear in the remaining matters also. Mr.
Rajale graciously accepted the request and worked out the matters.
3.
These connected appeals arise from the common Judgments and
Awards dated 29.03.2012 and 28.03.2012 passed by the learned 2nd Joint
Civil Judge, Senior Division, Ahmednagar, in the Land Acquisition
References mentioned in the chart given below. The acquiring body
challenges the enhancement granted towards fruit-bearing trees, whereas
936-FA-870-14.odt
the claimant-appellants seek further enhancement of compensation for their
acquired lands. The particulars of the appeals, Land Acquisition References,
survey/gat numbers and areas acquired, as available from the record, are set
out below.
LANDS ACQUIRED FROM VILLAGE TAKLI KAZI — AWARD DATED 29.03.2012
Sr.
FAs filed by
No. Acquiring Body
FAs filed by the
Claimants
LAR No.
Gat No(s).
Area
Acquired
870 of 2014
1331 of 2018
248/2000
71 R
16 R
863 of 2014
1332 of 2018
246/2000
1 H 15 R
14 R
864 of 2014
—
210/2000
0.01 R
865 of 2014
—
247/2000
87 R
866 of 2014
1335 of 2018
249/2000
1 H 44 R
867 of 2014
—
218/2000
87 R
0.02 R
05.5 R
1 H 53.5 R
0.43 R
0.40 R
868 of 2014
4437 of 2023
211/2000
869 of 2014
1334 of 2018
216/2000
0.055 R
871 of 2014
—
202/2000
0.41 R
872 of 2014
—
212/2000
0.59 R
873 of 2014
—
252/2000
1 H 68 R
874 of 2014
—
207/2000
2 H 12 R
875 of 2014
—
215/2000
0.30 R
2403 of 2014
—
251/2000
0.41 R
2923 of 2015
1333 of 2018
250/2000
1 H 12 R
217/2000
0.50 R
0.02 R
0.01 R
0.64 R
0.02 R
0.05.5 R
2924/2015
—
936-FA-870-14.odt
LANDS ACQUIRED FROM VILLAGE NARAYANDOH — AWARD DATED 28.03.2012
Sr.
FAs filed by
No. Acquiring Body
FAs filed by the
Claimants
LAR No.
Gat No(s).
Area
Acquired
1945/2015
—
233/2000
113 (1/5
share)
62 R
04 R (pk)
1946/2015
—
224/2000
122/2
1 H 169 R
1947/2015
—
229/2000
49 R
1948/2015
—
220/2000
23 R
1949/2015
—
225/2000
43 R
1950/2015
—
259/2000
24 R
1 H 75 R
02 R
11 R
02 R
1951/2015
—
219/2000
1953/2015
—
227/2000
78 R
1954/2015
—
222/2000
70 R
1955/2015
—
226/2000
78 R
4.
The notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
(for short, “the Act”) was published on 24.07.1997. The Special Land
Acquisition Officer (SLAO) made the award under Section 11 of the Act on
07.07.1999. Compensation was determined at Rs.470/- per R and
Rs.1,250/- per R, as applicable, in addition to compensation for fruit-bearing
trees. The claimants accepted the compensation under protest and sought
references under Section 18 of the Act, contending that the compensation
was inadequate.
5.
Before the learned Reference Court, the claimants relied upon sale-
deed material and private valuation reports at Exhibits 11/1, 11/2, 15/1,
12/2, 17/1, 17/2, 16/1, 16/2, 13/1, 13/2, 19/1, 19/2, 12/1, 18/1, 18/2
and 16/1 to 16/3. The learned Reference Court also referred to books
936-FA-870-14.odt
authored by Prof. Prakash P. Deshmukh, Mr. A.V. Patil and Mr. D.P. Bore. By
the impugned awards, it enhanced compensation for the acquired lands and
the fruit-bearing trees. The acquiring body challenges the enhancement
granted for the trees, while the claimant-appellants seek further
enhancement of compensation for their lands.
6.
The learned Reference Court awarded compensation at Rs.1,500/-
per R for jirayat land and Rs.2,250/- per R for seasonally irrigated land. The
SLAO had fixed the rates at Rs.470/- per R and Rs.1,250/- per R, as
applicable. Thus, the enhancement in the land-compensation component is
within four times the respective rates determined by the SLAO. Having
regard to the State Government policy that awards involving enhancement
of compensation up to four times the rates granted by the SLAO are not to
be challenged, no interference with the land rates is warranted at the
instance of the acquiring body on that ground. The dispute requiring
examination principally concerns the enhancement granted for fruit-bearing
trees and the further enhancement sought by the claimants.
7.
The acquiring body has assailed the enhancement granted by the
learned Reference Court towards fruit-bearing trees. The claimants, on the
other hand, seek further compensation for their acquired lands. Their
contention is that the SLAO treated the acquired lands as dry lands, and that
the compensation determined for the lands therefore requires enhancement
in the claimants’ appeals.
8.
936-FA-870-14.odt
Learned counsel Mr. G.B. Rajale and Mr. D.R. Jethliya, appearing for
the acquiring body, submit that although the notification under Section 4 of
the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, was published on 24.07.1997, possession of
the acquired lands had, in fact, been taken with the consent of the claimants
on 10.01.1994. They submit that a panchanama was prepared at the time of
taking possession and that construction of the project had also commenced
in the year 1994 itself. Subsequently, as some of the claimants raised
objections regarding the number of trees recorded in the panchanama
prepared in the year 1994, another panchanama was drawn in their
presence. On the basis of the two panchanamas, a valuation report was
obtained from the Government official, and the number of trees and their
valuation, as reflected in the relevant reports, were considered by the SLAO
while determining compensation.
9.
Learned counsel for the acquiring body submit that the SLAO
determined compensation towards the fruit-bearing trees on the basis of the
valuation furnished by the Government official and that the compensation
so awarded is just, proper and reasonable. They further submits that the
claimants, before the learned Reference Court, relied upon the reports
prepared by the private valuer, Mr. Bhujbal, who was examined at Exhibit 8.
As per the said reports, the valuer claimed to have visited the acquired lands
on 01.06.1996 and recorded the number and valuation of trees situated in
Gat Nos. 207, 214, 215, 217, 204, 210, 209, 216, 218, 203, 206, 220, 53, 55
936-FA-870-14.odt
and 60. Mr. Rajale submits that, considering the total acquired area of 58
hectares and 56 R, it is highly improbable that the valuer could have
inspected the entire acquired area and prepared the valuation report.
10.
Learned counsel Mr. Rajale further submits that the private valuation
reports are not reliable and appear to have been prepared to secure
enhanced compensation towards the fruit-bearing trees. Inviting attention to
the reports, he submits that the prescribed formats appear to have been
completed by filling in the blank spaces, without any supporting rough notes
or contemporaneous record of the alleged inspection. He further submits
that the reports do not disclose the methodology adopted for determining
the valuation of the trees. Neither any Government Resolution supporting
the rates adopted nor any rate chart issued by the A.P.M.C. was produced
along with the reports. He, therefore, contends that the learned Reference
Court ought not to have relied upon such reports to enhance the
compensation awarded by the SLAO.
11.
Learned counsel Mr. Rajale further submits that the learned
Reference Court was not justified in relying upon the contents of textbooks
to determine the age, height and nature of the trees or their market value,
particularly when the compensation had already been determined by the
SLAO on the basis of the valuation furnished by the Government official. He
submits that the enhancement ought to have been determined on the basis
936-FA-870-14.odt
of reliable evidence adduced by the claimants and not merely on the
strength of the private valuation reports read with the contents of textbooks.
On these grounds, learned counsel for the acquiring body prays that the
appeals filed by it be allowed.
12.
Per contra, learned counsel for the claimants submit that the learned
Reference Court did not accept the private valuation reports in their entirety.
According to them, the reports and reference books were considered for
assessing the age of the trees and the prevailing market rates, together with
the other material on record. They submit that the number of trees recorded
by the SLAO is not in dispute and corresponds with the number stated in the
private reports. They further contend that possession in 1994 was taken for
the purpose of carrying out the project, but the actual work commenced in
1997, and rely upon the panchanama prepared in 1997.
13.
Learned counsel Mr. Barde, taking the Court through the record and
proceedings in First Appeal No.1945 of 2015, submits that the rate chart of
the Ahmednagar Agricultural Produce Market Committee (A.P.M.C.) was
also placed before the learned Reference Court. He submits that the number
of trees otherwise is not in dispute and that the enhancement granted by the
learned Reference Court is reasonable, particularly as it did not grant 100%
enhancement.
14.
936-FA-870-14.odt
Learned counsel Mr. Bide holding for learned counsel Mr. M.R.
Khutwad for the claimants submits that the valuation reports were not relied
upon for every aspect of the assessment. As regards Gat No.209, he points
out that, out of 400 pomegranate trees stated to have been acquired, 200
were treated as saplings and compensation of Rs.7,000/- was awarded for
those 200 saplings.
15.
As regards First Appeal Nos. 1331 of 2018, 1332 of 2018, 1333 of
2018, 1334 of 2018 and 1335 of 2018, learned counsel Mr. Bide submits
that the claimants had placed on record, along with a list of documents, a
copy of the sale deed dated 23.01.1995 relating to 40 R of land in the
acquired village, sold for a consideration of Rs.1,00,000/-. He submits that
the sale instance related to dry land and ought to have been considered by
the learned Reference Court. Instead, the learned Reference Court relied
upon the rate fixed in another Land Acquisition Reference. On the basis of
the sale deed, he submits that the claimants are entitled to compensation at
Rs.5,000/- per R by treating the acquired lands as irrigated lands. He further
submits that the lands from Gat Nos.206, 216 and 218 were treated as
irrigated by the SLAO, whereas, in respect of other two Gat Nos. 207 and
209, compensation was awarded for the well and the lands were treated as
dry lands, He therefore seeks the irrigated-land rate in the aforesaid appeals.
16.
Learned counsel Mr. D.R. Jayabhar, Mr. R.K. Temkar, Mr. N.C. Garud
and Mr. N.B. Narwade, for the respective claimants supoort the impugned
936-FA-870-14.odt
judgments and awards by contending that the learned Reference Court has
properly appreciated the evidence on record and thereby enhancing the
compensation towards the land and trees and pray to dismiss the appeals
filed by the acquiring body.
17.
Learned AGP Mr. Phule, appearing for the State, submits that the
learned Reference Court granted interest under Section 28 of the Act from
the date of publication of the notification under Section 4. He contends that
this is contrary to the decision of this Court in State of Maharashtra v.
Ramesh Tukaram Meshram and Others, reported in 2018 (1) ALL MR 645 ,
and submits that the impugned awards require modification to that extent.
18.
I have considered the submissions advanced on behalf of the
respective parties and, with their assistance, have perused the record and
proceedings, the impugned Judgments and Awards and the evidence
referred to therein. The perusal of impugned awards reflect the
enhancement granted by the learned Reference Court, which is reproduced
herein below:
ENHANCEMENT IN RESPECT OF TREES ACQUIRED FROM VILLAGE TAKLI KAZI
L.R.A.
No.
Land
Gat No.
248/2000
202/2000
207/2000
Nature of
tree
No. of
trees
Pomegranate
Mango
Tamarind
Ber
Mango
Orange
Compensation
awarded by
S.L.A.O. (Rs.)
363066
179093
Compensation
awarded by
Court (Rs.)
1248000
604800
936-FA-870-14.odt
L.R.A.
No.
Land
Gat No.
210/2000
211/2000
212/2000
215/2000
216/2000
217/2000
218/2000
246/2000
247/2000
249/2000
250/2000
Compensation
awarded by
S.L.A.O. (Rs.)
Compensation
awarded by
Court (Rs.)
-
39598
22567
202500
15750
135000
-
34189
219582
20506
31525
40752
188750
10000
800000
113250
18900
202500
226500
37750
12000
12321
63442
22898
67500
337500
135000
12600
-
-
13199
357249
Ber
Considered
Orange
Orange
Drumstick
297674
35587
67500
1228000
In LAR
211/2000
896000
112000
-
Nature of
tree
No. of
trees
Guava
Ber
Custard
apple
Drumstick
Mango
Mango
Ber
Tamarind
Ber
Mango
Custard
apple
Tamarind
Jambhul
Pomegranate
Pomegranate
Ber
Tamarind
Tamarind
Ber
Ber
Mango
Tamarind
Tamarind
Tamarind
Ber
Custard
apple
Mango
Mango
Mango
Mango
Ber
Ber
Drumstick
Custard
apple
Tamarind
Mango
Pomegranate
Ber
Mango
936-FA-870-14.odt
L.R.A.
No.
251/2000
252/2000
Land
Gat No.
Nature of
tree
No. of
trees
Compensation
awarded by
S.L.A.O. (Rs.)
Mango
Considered
Ber
Pomegranate
Guava
Mango
Drumstick
Ber
547796
20035
Compensation
awarded by
Court (Rs.)
In LAR
202/0000
12600
1968000
59850
ENHANCEMENT IN RESPECT OF TREES ACQUIRED FROM VILLAGE NARAYANDOH
L.R.A. No.
233/2000
18476
37750
138600
12000
10837
11594
348594
37750
67500
22050
67500
1152000
11009
67500
48000
101913
81593
40309
28000
679500
53550
37750
12600
405000
226500
45000
out of
1/5
share
Mango
Ber
Guava
Custard
apple
Tamarind
Ber
Custard
apple
Tamarind
Mango
Ber
Mango
Pomegranate
Ber
Custard
apple
Mango
Ber
Custard
apple
Pomegranate
Tamarind
Ber
Tamarind
Ber
Mango
Tamarind
Ber
Ber
Ber
Ber
Custard
apple
220/2000
221/2000
222/2000
122/2
225/2000
226/2000
229/2000
No. of
trees
227/2000
Compensation
awarded by
Court (Rs.)
202500
18900
-
Nature of
tree
219/2000
224/2000
Compensation
awarded by
S.L.A.O. (Rs.)
41794
Land
Gat No.
936-FA-870-14.odt
L.R.A. No.
Land
Gat No.
242/2000
259/2000
19.
121/1
Nature of
tree
No. of
trees
Ber
Ber
Tamarind
Ber
Tamarind
Pomegranate
Ber
Compensation
awarded by
S.L.A.O. (Rs.)
Compensation
awarded by
Court (Rs.)
34650
Already Considered in LAR
No.226/22000
52652
28350
377500
The record indicates that possession of the acquired lands was taken
on 10.01.1994. The claimants also accepted in their evidence that
possession had been taken in 1994. The SLAO awarded compensation for
the trees on the basis of valuation furnished by the Government authority.
The principal question is not the number of trees, but whether the material
produced before the learned Reference Court justified the higher valuation
adopted by it. In considering that question, the reliability of the private
valuer’s inspection, the basis of the rates used by him and the evidence
supporting the assessed age and yield of the trees assume importance.
20.
The private valuer, Mr. Bhujbal (Exhibit 8), stated that he had visited
the acquired lands on 01.06.1997. His reports contain the particulars of the
trees and the values assessed, but do not set out rough contemporaneous
field notes or explain in sufficient detail the method by which the age, yield
and market value of each category of tree were determined, reports were
prepared in a prescribed format with the relevant spaces filled in. The
absence of supporting material is material because the reports were relied
upon to support a substantial enhancement over the official valuation.
21.
936-FA-870-14.odt
The relevant portion of paragraph No. 2 of the private valuer’s
deposition reads as follows:
“(2) As per my report I visited to site on 1" June, 1997. It is true to say
that, there is no signatures of Village Talathi on panchnama prepared by
me. Copy supplied to Non-Applicant is the xerox copy obtained from
original. Panchnama produced in Land Reference Appln. No.259/2000 is
shown to me, it does not bears signatures of any panch witnesses. It is
true to say that, applicants were shown the site to me. It is not true to say
that, at the time of my visit to the site, not a single tree was standing in
the lands of the applicants. I have seen the valuation report of Govt.
Valuer. It is true to say that, only on the point of "yielding" & "market rate"
there is difference between my Valuation Report and report of Govt.
Valuer. It is true to say that, I have not produced any correspondence
between Market Committee and me. I have not claimed the market rates
from Market committee. As per my direction, all the applicants were
received the market rates from the Market committee. All the applicants
submitted before me the "Rate Chart" issued by the Market committee. I
have not produced the "market rate chart". I again say that I have not
produced the copy of Market rate chart. If the correspondence with the
agriculturist is available with the applicants I am ready to produce it on
record.”
22.
These admissions bear directly upon the evidentiary value of the
private valuation reports. The reports do not establish that the rates stated
therein were independently verified with the A.P.M.C., nor do they
sufficiently explain the difference in yield and market rates from the official
valuation.
23.
Further, the private valuer claimed to have inspected the entire
acquired area, admeasuring 58 hectares and 60 R, on a single day. Having
regard to the extent of the acquired area, it is difficult to accept that the
entire area could have been inspected in a single day. The valuer claimed to
936-FA-870-14.odt
have inspected the acquired lands in the year 1997; however, the copies of
the reports were supplied to the claimants only in the year 2010. The
evidence before the learned Reference Court commenced in the year 2010,
and the valuer was examined in the year 2011. These circumstances,
considered cumulatively, create serious doubt about the claim that the
valuer had actually inspected the entire acquired area and indicate that the
reports may have been prepared subsequently for the purpose of the
proceedings before the learned Reference Court. The reports, therefore, do
not provide a reliable basis for displacing the valuation determined by the
SLAO.
24.
The learned Reference Court recorded that possession of the
acquired lands had been taken in the year 1994, a fact which was also
admitted by the claimants in their examination-in-chief. The private
valuation reports, however, record the age of the trees as ranging from three
to five years, whereas the private valuer claimed to have inspected the
acquired lands on 01.06.1997. In view of the admitted date of possession,
these age assessments required careful scrutiny, particularly with regard to
the trees acquired from Gat No. 209. In respect of the said Gat number, 400
pomegranate trees were stated to have been acquired, out of which 200
were treated by the learned Reference Court as saplings, for which
compensation of Rs.7,000/- was awarded. In these circumstances, the
possibility cannot be ruled out that some of the trees were planted after
936-FA-870-14.odt
possession was taken in January 1994 and before the award was declared,
with a view to claiming higher compensation.
25.
The learned Reference Court ought to have examined whether the
trees were in existence when possession was taken and whether they were
saplings or grown-up trees at the material time. However, it has not
adequately explained the basis for accepting the higher valuation of the
remaining trees on the strength of the private valuation reports and general
reference books.
26.
The reference books relied upon by the learned Reference Court may
provide general information about the nature, age or yield of trees. They
cannot, however, substitute for reliable evidence connecting the rates and
yield stated in them with the trees actually assessed in these cases. On an
overall consideration of the official valuation, the admissions of the private
valuer and the deficiencies in the reports, the enhancement granted by the
learned Reference Court towards fruit-bearing trees is not supported by
sufficiently reliable evidence.
27.
On perusal of individual report placed in each Land References, it
reveals that the acquired trees in all aforesaid gat numbers have suffered the
same fate. The learned Reference Court has utterly failed to give findings as
to why it relied upon the private valuers report and reference books and
enhanced the compensation to an exorbitant extent. Once the learned
936-FA-870-14.odt
Reference Court enhanced the compensation towards the trees to such an
extent, it ought to have justified such enhancement by giving appropriate
findings. Therefore, the enhancement towards the trees cannot be sustained.
28.
The claimants’ prayer for further enhancement of compensation for
the acquired lands rests upon the sale deed dated 23.01.1995. Although a
copy of that document was placed along with the list of documents, the sale
deed was not exhibited before the learned Reference Court. Its contents,
therefore, cannot be treated as substantive evidence of the market value in
these appeals. No application has been made before this Court to lead
additional evidence by bringing that sale deed on record in accordance with
law.
29.
The claimants also contend that certain lands ought to have been
treated as irrigated rather than dry or seasonally irrigated lands and seek a
rate of Rs.5,000/- per R. The rate claimed is sought to be supported by the
aforesaid sale deed, which cannot be relied upon for the reasons stated
above. The learned Reference Court adopted the rates determined in
another Land Acquisition Reference arising from the same project and the
same notification. In the absence of an admissible sale instance or other
sufficient material demonstrating that the rates adopted in the connected
reference were inadequate for the lands in question, no case is made out for
further enhancement.
30.
936-FA-870-14.odt
As regards interest under Section 28 of the Act, this Court in State of
Maharashtra v. Ramesh Tukaram Meshram and Others, reported in 2018 (1)
ALL MR 645, has held that Sections 28 and 34 are pari materia and that,
where possession is taken before publication of the notification under
Section 4, interest is payable from the date of the award and not from the
earlier date of possession or notification. In the present matters, possession
was taken before publication of the notification under Section 4, and the
SLAO made the award under Section 11 on 07.07.1999. The impugned
awards must accordingly be modified to provide for interest under Section
28 in accordance with the said decision, with reference to 07.07.1999 as the
date of the award.
31.
In view of the above discussion, the impugned Judgments and
Awards deserve to be modified by setting aside the enhancement granted by
the learned Reference Court towards the fruit-bearing trees and by
modifying the directions regarding interest, while maintaining the
compensation awarded in respect of the acquired lands. Hence, the
following order:
ORDER
(i)
The First Appeals filed by the claimants are dismissed. The First
Appeals filed by the acquiring body are partly allowed.
(ii)
936-FA-870-14.odt
The common Judgments and Awards dated 29.03.2012 and
28.03.2012 passed by the learned 2nd Joint Civil Judge, Senior Division,
Ahmednagar, in the respective Land Acquisition References are modified to
the extent indicated below.
(iii)
The enhancement granted by the learned Reference Court towards
compensation for fruit-bearing trees is quashed and set aside. The
compensation awarded by the SLAO towards the trees is maintained.
(iv)
Interest under Section 28 of the Act shall be payable in accordance
with the decision of this Court in State of Maharashtra v. Ramesh Tukaram
Meshram and Others, reported in 2018 (1) ALL MR 645 , with reference to
07.07.1999, the date of the award under Section 11 of the Act, and not from
the date of publication of the notification under Section 4 of the Act.
(v)
The compensation awarded by the learned Reference Court in
respect of the acquired lands is maintained.
(vi)
The office shall calculate the amount payable to or recoverable from
the respective claimants under the modified awards, after giving due
adjustment to the amounts already paid and/or withdrawn by them.
(vii)
If, upon such calculation and adjustment, any excess amount is
found to have been received by any claimant towards compensation for
fruit-bearing trees, the concerned claimant shall refund the excess amount,
together with applicable interest, within ten weeks from today.
936-FA-870-14.odt
(viii)
If the concerned claimant fails to refund the excess amount within
ten weeks from today, the Collector, Ahmednagar, shall initiate appropriate
proceedings for recovery of the excess amount, together with applicable
interest, in accordance with law, and submit a compliance report to this
Court regarding the action taken.
(ix)
Conversely, if any amount remains payable to the claimants after
such calculation and adjustment, the same shall be paid in accordance with
law.
(x)
If upon due adjustment, the claimants deposit such amounts, if any,
the acquiring body is permitted to withdraw the same.
(xi)
Modified awards be drawn accordingly.
(xii)
Pending Civil Applications, if any, stand disposed of.
[ SIDDHESHWAR S. THOMBRE ]
JUDGE
S P Rane
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review