Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1MFA No.101629 of 2014
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 30TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
®
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K.MANMADHA RAO
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.101629 OF 2014 (MV)
BETWEEN:
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER,
THE NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
RAMDEV GALLI, BELGAUM,
INSURER OF TEMPO
BEARING NO.MH-10/AG-5163
VEHICLE INSURED WITH NATIONAL CO.LTD.,
SANGLI BRANCH OFFICE,
JAIN BORDING COMPLEX, SANGLI–416416.
POLICY NO.27-802/31/12/6300003251
PERIOD COVER 23.02.2013 TO 22.02.2014
…APPELLANT
(BY SMT. ARUNA R. DESHPANDE, ADVOCATE)
Digitally signed
by
MOHANKUMAR
B SHELAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
AND:
1.
SMT. VAISHALI
W/O. RAMESH PISE
AGE: 41 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
2.
SMT. PRIYA
W/O PRADEEP VINEHA
AGE: 39 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
3.
SMT. MADHURI
W/O UDAY POKALE
AGE: 37 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
4.
SMT. TEJEASWINI
W/O VAIBHAV KOGALE
-2MFA No.101629 of 2014
AGE: 35 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
5.
SMT. PRIYA
W/O PREETAM BULBULE
AGE: 35 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
6.
SMT. SAPNA
W/O. VISHWANATH MALAVADE
AGE: 31 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
ALL ARE R/O KOLHAPUR
PRESENTLY AT KAKTI
C/O MANISH W/O NARENDRA PETKAR
7.
MR. PRABHUNAND APPASO JEUR
AGE: MAJOR, OCC: BUSINESS,
R/O. DARIBADACHI, TQ: JATH,
DIST: SANGLI, MAHARASHTRA.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. SUNANDA P. PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R6;
NOTICE TO R7-DISPENSED WITH)
THIS MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
173(1) OF THE MOTOR VEHICLES ACT 1988, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE
THE COMMON ORDER DATED 17.01.2014 PASSED IN MVC NO.882/2013
ON THE FILE OF II ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND ADDITIONAL
MACT BELAGAVI BY ALLOWING THE ABOVE APPEAL, IN THE INTEREST
OF EQUITY AND JUSTICE.
THIS MFA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT
ON 22.01.2026 AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K.MANMADHA RAO
-3MFA No.101629 of 2014
CAV JUDGMENT
This appeal is filed under Section 173(1) of Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 (hereinafter referred to as ‘MV Act’) by the Insurance Company
challenging by the Judgment and Award dated 17.01.2014 passed by the
II Additional Senior Civil Judge and Additional Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal, Belgaum (‘the Tribunal’, for short) in MVC No.882/2013.
2.
For convenience, the parties are referred to, based on their
rankings before the Tribunal.
3.
Facts giving rise to the filing of the appeal briefly stated are
as under:
On 13.03.2013, one Dhiraj Vijay Pise was riding the motorcycle
bearing registration No.MH-09/BE-6760 with two pillion riders, namely
Narendra Narayan Petkar, husband of claimant No.1 and father of
claimant No.2 in MVC No.794/2013 and Smt.Lalita Narayan Petkar,
mother of the claimants in MVC No.882/2013 from Ugar to Miraj. When
the motorcycle reached on Maishal-Miraj Road at about 1.50 p.m., a
Tempo bearing Registration No.MH-10/AQ-5163 came from opposite
direction, in a rash and negligent manner and dashed against the said
motorcycle. Due to the impact, the rider of the motorcycle Dhiraj Vijay
Pise and Lalita Narayan Petkar died on the spot and the said Narayan
-4MFA No.101629 of 2014
Petkar was shifted to the Hospital and succumbed to the injuries and a
case was registered against the driver of the Tempo.
Smt.Lalita Narayan Petkar was aged about 60 years and was hale
and healthy prior to the accident. She was doing tailoring work and
earning Rs.6000/- per month. Due to the untimely death of Smt.Lalita
Narendra Petkar, the claimants in MVC No.882/2013 have lost their
financial support. Hence, claimants pray to award compensation of
Rs.25,00,000/- with interest at 12% per annum. The claimants contend
that respondent No.1, the R.C. owner and respondent No.2, the insurer
of said Tempo are jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation.
4.
In response to Court notice, though respondent No.1 has
been served, he remained absent and placed ex parte. Respondent No.2
Insurance Company has entered appearance through his counsel and has
filed objection statement contending that the claimants are residents of
Kolhapur. It is denied that the accident had occurred due to rash and
negligent driving of the driver of the Tempo. He submits that there were
two pillions on the motorcycle, which is in violation of law. He submits
that due to the triple riding, the rider of the motorcycle lost control of the
vehicle and to his own negligence the accident had occurred. He submits
that the driver did not possess valid and effective driving licence and also
violated policy conditions. He mainly contends that all the claimants are
-5MFA No.101629 of 2014
married daughters and they were not dependents to her mother and
hence prays to dismiss the appeal.
5.
The Tribunal on the basis of the pleadings of the parties,
framed issues. The claimant No.1 examined herself as P.W.2 and one
more witness is examined as PW3 and got marked 22 documents as per
Exs.P1 to Ex.P22.
On the other hand, respondent No.2 - Insurance
Company has not led any evidence but by consent Ex.R1-insurance policy
came to be marked. The Tribunal after assessing the oral and
documentary evidence, allowed the claim petition in part and awarded
compensation of Rs.4,28,000/- to the claimants with interest at the rate
of 9% p.a., from the date of petition till the date of realization and held
respondent Nos.1 and 2 jointly and severally liable to pay the
compensation.
6.
The learned counsel appearing for the appellant-Insurance
Company would contend that the Tribunal failed to consider the
mandatory provisions of Section 173(1) of the MV Act, and erred in
entertaining the claim petition despite lack of territorial jurisdiction, as all
the claimants are residents of Kolhapur and the alleged accident occurred
at Sangli. The Tribunal ought to have dismissed the claim petition on this
ground alone.
-6MFA No.101629 of 2014
7.
It is further contended that the Tribunal further erred in not
dismissing the claim petition for non-joinder of necessary parties, as the
owner and insurer of the motor cycle bearing No.MH-09/EE-6760 were
not impleaded. The Tribunal also failed to properly appreciate the
contributory negligence of the rider of the motor cycle, who violated
Section 128 of the MV Act by carrying two pillion riders at the time of the
accident. Further, the award of Rs.3,78,000/- towards loss of estate is
grossly excessive, arbitrary and contrary to settled principles of law and
the binding decision of the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of
A. Manavagala v. A. Krishnamurthy reported in ILR 2004 KAR 3268,
and is therefore liable to be set aside or suitably reduced.
8.
The learned counsel for the respondents No.1 to 6 has placed
reliance on the judgment of this Court in the case of National
Insurance Co.Ltd., v. Alwin Lobo and another reported in 2023 ACJ
2054, wherein held that where the assessment of disability and
compensation by the Tribunal is found to be inadequate or perverse, the
appellate Court is empowered to enhance the compensation even in an
appeal filed by the insurer, by invoking Order XLI Rule 33 of the CPC. The
learned counsel further places reliance on the judgments of this Court as
under:-
-7MFA No.101629 of 2014
•
United India Insurance Company Limited v. Aravind
Madhukar Sutar and another by order dated 11.03.2024
passed in MFA No.102023/2018,
•
Smt.Manisha and another v. Shri Prabhunand Appaso
and another by order dated 28.10.2014 passed in MFA
No.101262/2013 c/w. MFA No.101628/2014.
9.
Heard learned counsel appearing on either side.
10.
Having considered the contentions advanced and on perusal
of the materials available on record, it is relevant to place reliance on the
judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh in the case of
M/s. National Insurance Company Ltd., v. E. Suseelamma, reported
in 2023 SCC OnLine 1725, wherein the scope and ambit of Order XLI
Rule 33 of the Code of Civil Procedure have been elaborately considered
in the context of motor accident claim appeals and held that Order XLI
Rule 33 of the CPC is an enabling provision conferring wide discretionary
power upon the appellate Court to pass such decree or order as ought to
have been passed by the Tribunal, or as the justice of the case may
require, notwithstanding the fact that the appeal is preferred only by one
of the parties and even in the absence of any appeal or cross-objection
by the beneficiary of such relief.
11.
It was further held that in appeals under Section 173 of the
MV Act, the applicability of the Code of Civil Procedure, including Order
-8MFA No.101629 of 2014
XLI Rule 33, is not excluded, and the appellate Court is empowered to
examine the entire award on facts and law. The judgment emphasizes
that the absence of an appeal or cross-objection by the claimants does
not denude the jurisdiction of the appellate Court to mould relief,
provided such exercise does not violate any legal prohibition and does
not cause prejudice to the opposite party. The power under Order XLI
Rule 33 of the CPC, must be exercised with care and caution, but should
not be declined where interference is necessary to prevent injustice or to
bring the award in conformity with settled legal principles.
12.
The approach adopted by the Hon’ble Andhra Pradesh High
Court is in consonance with the consistent view taken by the Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court in the case of United India Insurance Company
Limited v. Aravind Madhukar Sutar and another by order dated
11.03.2024 passed in MFA No.102023/2018, wherein this Court has
observed that technicalities cannot override the duty of the appellate
Court to ensure just compensation, and in the case of A. Manavalagan
v. A. Krishnamurthy reported in ILR 2004 KAR 3268, it has been held
that while exercising appellate jurisdiction, the Court must correct awards
which are contrary to settled principles, particularly under conventional
heads.
-9MFA No.101629 of 2014
13.
By applying the principles laid down in E. Suseelamma’s
case (supra), to the present case, it is clear that the appeal filed by the
insurer brings the entire award under scrutiny before this Court. Merely
because the claimants have not preferred an appeal or filed crossobjections, this Court is not precluded from examining whether the
Tribunal
has
correctly
applied
the
law
governing
assessment
of
compensation. The appellate jurisdiction under Section 173 of the MV
Act, read with Order XLI Rule 33 of the CPC, empowers this Court to pass
such orders as ought to have been passed by the Tribunal to meet the
ends of justice.
14.
In view of the above, it is observed that the object of
invoking Order XLI Rule 33 of the CPC, in motor accident cases is not to
grant a windfall, but to ensure conformity with legal standards governing
compensation. Therefore, if the Tribunal has awarded amounts contrary
to settled principles under particular heads, the appellate Court is
justified in correcting such errors, even if such correction incidentally
benefits a party who has not appealed. The decisive consideration is
whether
the
final
award
represents
just,
fair
and
reasonable
compensation in accordance with law.
15.
After giving thoughtful consideration, this Court holds that
while the findings on negligence and liability do not warrant interference,
- 10 MFA No.101629 of 2014
the award must nevertheless be tested on the touchstone of settled legal
principles governing quantum. The power under Order XLI Rule 33 of the
CPC is therefore available to this Court to mould appropriate relief, to the
extent necessary, so that the compensation ultimately awarded neither
exceeds nor falls short of what the law recognizes as just compensation,
and thereby subserves the object of the MV Act.
16.
The appeal is preferred by the insurer questioning the
common judgment and award dated 17.01.2014 passed by the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal. While examining the legality and correctness of
the award, this Court is conscious of the settled principle that the
jurisdiction under Section 173 of the MV Act is open for consideration on
facts and law. In this context, the power of the appellate Court under
Order XLI Rule 33 of the CPC assumes significance, particularly where the
Court is required to mould relief so as to do complete justice between the
parties.
With regard to the Quantum:
17.
The Tribunal had taken income at Rs.3,500/- per month but
claimant herself contend that her income was Rs.6,000/- per month.
Hence this Court deems it appropriate to consider her monthly income at
Rs.6,000/- and multiplier taken is ‘9’. Hence, loss of dependency works
out as under:Rs.6,000/- less 1/4th = Rs.4,500/- X 12 X 9 = Rs.4,86,000/-
- 11 MFA No.101629 of 2014
18.
As regards filial consortium and loss of love and affection, the
Tribunal has taken Rs.30,000/-. But in view of the Apex Court judgment
in Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v/s Nanu Ram Alias Chuhru
Ram & Ors., reported in 2018 ACJ 2782, Rs.48,000/- each for six
claimants is awarded for filial consortium and
love/affection and
Rs.18,000/- for loss of estate and funeral expenses, considering two
escalations in accordance with the post - 2017 judgments of the Apex
Court and this High Court, where a 10% escalation is applied for every
three years. Accordingly, the reassessment of the compensation as per
the Chart of the High Court Legal Services Authority is as under:
Sl. No.
Head of Compensation
Amount
Loss of Dependency
Loss of Estate
18,000
Funeral Expenses
18,000
Love and Affection (6 claimants)
2,88,000
Total Compensation
8,10,000
19.
4,86,000
Considering the calculations, the total compensation is fixed
at Rs.8,10,000/- with interest at 6% per annum from the date of
petition till realization.
20.
In the result, this Court proceeds to pass the following:
ORDER
i.
The appeal is allowed-in-part.
- 12 MFA No.101629 of 2014
ii.
The judgment and award dated 17.01.2014 passed by
the II Additional Senior Civil Judge and Additional
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Belgaum in MVC
No.882/2013, is modified. The claimants are entitled
for
total
compensation
of
Rs.8,10,000/-
with
interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of
petition till realisation.
iii.
The
Corporation
shall
deposit
the
enhanced
compensation along with interest within six weeks
from the date of receipt of certified copy of this
judgment.
iv.
Apportionment and disbursement shall be in the same
manner as directed by the Tribunal.
v.
Amount in deposit, if any, shall be transmitted to the
Tribunal forthwith.
vi.
The trial Court records, if any, shall be transmitted to
the Tribunal forthwith.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(DR. K.MANMADHA RAO)
JUDGE
KGK, CT:VP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review