Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED:
29.04.2026
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE C.V. KARTHIKEYAN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE K.RAJASEKAR
CMA No. 2567 of 2022
The Divisional Manager
Royal Sundaram General Insurance Company Ltd.,
Pondicherry.
... Appellant/2nd Respondent
Vs
1.
Padmavathy
W/o. Sivasubramanian
2.
Sri Nilaveni
D/o. Sivasubramanian
3.
Vedhasya
D/o. Sivasubramanian
4.
Jayabalan
S/o. Jayabalan
...Respondents/Petitioners
(minors rep. by their mother/next friend
1st respondent herein)
5.
J.Purushothaman
S/o. Sri Jayaraman
6.
Natarajan
7.
The Divisional Manager
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
... Respondent / Respondent-1
... Respondent / Respondent-3
National Insurance Company Ltd.,
Puducherry.
... Respondent / Respondent-4
Prayer: Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed under Section 173 of Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 against the Judgment and Decree dated 23.01.2018 made
in M.C.O.P.No. 28 of 2016 on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (II
Additional District Court) Puducherry.
***
For Appellant
: Mr. Elveera Antionettee Ravindran
For RR 1 to 4
: Mr. r.Sreedhar
For 7th Respondent : Mr.S.Arunkumar
JUDGMENT
(Order of the Court was made by K.RAJASEKAR, J.)
This Appeal has been filed by the second respondent /Insurance
Company in M.C.O.P.No. 28 of 2016 challenging the Judgment and Decree
dated 23.01.2018, wherein the Tribunal has held that the second respondent
shall indemnify the owner of Tempo traveller and pay entire compensation
and rejected the contentions of the second respondent that the accident was
taken place due to the negligent act of driver of respondent No.4.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2. For convenience, the parties are referred to by their litigant status
before the Tribunal.
3. The facts of the case are that on 05.07.2008, at about 10:30 p.m.,
the deceased Mr.Sivasubramanian, and others were traveling from
Pondicherry to Chennai Airport in a Tempo Traveller with registration
number TN 32 C 9663. Near Molasur on the Pondy-Tindivanam National
Highway, the driver of the Tempo Traveller drove it rashly and negligently,
dashed with a lorry bearing registration number TN 32 B 1459, which was
parked on the left side of the road. The accident resulted in injuries to two
passengers and also the driver of the Tempo Traveller. Subsequently, both
passengers succumbed to their injuries. Two separate claim petitions have
been filed by the respective defendants under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act.
4. In the claim petition, orginally the claimants sought compensation
only from the owner and insurer of the Tempo Traveller. Subsequently, after
the Insurance Company filed its counter, the owner and insurer of the lorry
were also impeaded as parties.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
5. The second respondent has filed an counter and additional counter
stating that the lorry was improperly parked in the middle of the road and
that adequate precautions were not taken, leading to the accident. Therefore,
the driver of Lorry is responsible for the accident and the insurer of Tempo
traveller is not liable to pay compensation.
6. The second respondent/Insurance Company also contested the
quantum of compensation claimed under the various headings, stating it is
excessive.
7. The owners of both vehicle have not contested the claim. The fifth
respondent, the insurance company of the lorry, has filed a counter,
submitting that a criminal case was registered only against the driver of the
Tempo Traveller and the final report filed confirming his negligence.
Furthermore, the lorry was parked on the left side of the road with due care
and caution and that the driver of the Tempo Traveller negligently drove the
same at high speed, resulting in the accident. Therefore, the insurer of the
lorry is not liable to pay compensation.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
8. Before the Tribunal, the claimants examined PW-1 to PW-3, and
Exhibits P-1 to P-15 were marked. On the side of respondents' No.2, RW-1
and RW-2, were examined.
9. After considering the evidence, the Tribunal has ruled that the
driver of Tempo Traveller acted negligently and caused the accident.
Consequently, held that the second respondent as insurer shall pay
compensation quantified as Rs. 13,54,600/- and to indemnify the first
respondent.
10. Aggrieved over the fixing negligence on the driver of the Tempo
Traveller to the extent of 100%, the Insurance Company of the Tempo
Traveller filed this appeal challenging both the negligence and the quantum
of compensation.
11.
The learned counsel for the appellant/second respondent
submitted that there is ample and clear evidence on record to show that the
lorry was parked recklessly on the left side of the road without proper safety
measures. This fact alone is sufficient to show that the lorry driver acted
negligently and caused the accident. The Tribunal has not properly
appreciated this aspect or the manner in which the accident occurred. The
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Tribunal ought to have taken into account and accordingly, the negligence
shall be fixed on the driver of the lorry. He further relied on the evidence of
the person who traveled in the Tempo Traveller PW-1 and the person
witnessed the occurrence- PW-2, and also the driver of the Tempo Traveller
RW-2 to substantiate his case that the lorry driver also contributed to the
accident. He also submitted that the compensation awarded is excessive.
Hence, prays to modify the award.
12. Per contra, the learned counsel for the fifth respondent/Insurance
Company of the lorry submitted that the overall sequence of the accident
must be considered. He relied on the pleadings made in the claim petition
and contended that the claimants made no allegation in the claim petition
that the lorry was parked recklessly or on the wrong side. In the absence of
any such pleading or evidence, the failure to examine the lorry driver is not
a fatal as far as the case of the fifth respondent is concerned.
The
Tribunal, after appreciating the entire evidence, more particularly the
evidence of eyewitness to the effect that the lorry driver took safety
measures, rightly attributed the negligence to the Tempo Traveller. He
further submitted that there was sufficient space available on the road to
allow vehicles to pass in both directions. In such circumstances, there is no
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
reason for the Tribunal to fix / or apportion any negligence on the lorry
driver.
13. The learned counsel for the claimants submitted that, their case is,
the driver of the Tempo Traveller drove the vehicle at high speed. They have
filed the claim petition seeking compensation solely from the owner and
insurer of Tempo Traveller, and further submit that they are entitled to the
compensation as claimed, that there is no infirmity in the order passed by
the Tribunal and accordingly, prays to confirm the award passed by the
Tribunal.
14. We have considered the submissions on both sides and perused
the materials available on record.
15. The core issue before this Court is whether the accident occurred
due to the negligent act of the driver of Tempo Traveller or the lorry driver
or is there any contibutory negligence on the part of the lorry driver or not?
16. Admittedly, in this case, the passenger in the Tempo Traveller,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
testified as PW-1. He stated in his chief examination that he and the others
including deceased Subramanian and Sundari Ramesh were traveling in the
Tempo Traveller. The deceased were seated next to the driver when the
vehicle, traveling at high speed, approached Molasur. Because it was night
time, the driver was unable to see a parked lorry and dashed into its rear,
resulting in fatal injuries to the deceased. Although they were taken to the
hospital, both the injured died. The driver of the Tempo Traveller also
sustained injuries.
17. During cross-examination, it was elicited that the driver of Tempo
Traveller drove the vehicle rashly and negligently. It was also elicited that
there were parking lights to indicate the lorry's parked status. He further
reiterated that the only the Tempo Traveller driver was at fault. Similarly,
PW-2, an eyewitness, was examined. According to him, he was traveling in
a vehicle just oppposite to the accident site, and as he was passing the lorry,
he saw the Tempo Traveller approaching at high speed and colliding with
the rear side of the lorry.
18. The second respondent, the Insurance Company of the Tempo
Traveller, examined the driver of the Tempo Traveller as RW-2. He stated
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
that although he drove the vehicle with care and caution, he could not see
the lorry parked on the left side of the road due to the darkness. The lorry
was carrying casuarina poles, and despite his attempts to avoid an accident,
he was unable to avert it and hit the rear side. He argued that if the vehicle
had been parked carefully and cautiously with illuminating parking lights
the accident would not have occurred.
19. The fifth respondent, the Lorry's Insurance Company, argue that
they had no occasion to refute the allegations in the claim petition, nor were
there any other pleadings that required them to deny the contentions raised
by the Tempo Traveller's Insurance Company, hence, they did not choose to
examine the driver of Lorry and the non-examination of the driver of the
lorry shall not lead to any adverse inference.
20. We unable to agree with the said contention since it is admitted
case of the fifth respondent that though at the initial stage, no claim was
made against the fifth respondent ie., Insurance Company of the lorry,
subsequently by way of filing additional counter, the second respopdnent
has taken the stand that their driver is not responsible for the accident and
that only the driver of the lorry is responsible for the accident.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This
pleading should have been addressed by the fifth respondent, insurance
company of Lorry.
21. We have persued the fifth respondent's response, which indicates
that they rightly contested the allegations of negligence against the lorry
driver made by the second respondent. This demonstrates the fifth
respondent was aware of counter-allegations against the lorry driver.
Although PW-1 and PW-2 supported the claimants' case that the driver of
Tempo Traveller was responsible for the accident, the examination of RW-2,
the Tempo Traveller driver, placed contra evidence of PW-1 and PW-2.
Notably, evidence was presented implicating the lorry driver as being
responsible for the accident. Admittedly implicating evidence was placed on
record, even though the claimants did not file a claim against Lorry driver.
When there is implicating evidence placed on record against a party then the
adversary party is expected to present appropriate evidence to dispel the
implicating evidence against him.
22. In this case, there is a categorical evidence placed on record by
the driver of the Tempo Traveller that the lorry driver is responsible for the
accident. In such a situation, the non examination of the driver of the lorry
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
raises adverse inference against the driver of lorry if the evidence of RW-2 is
supported by any carroborated evidence.
23. Be that as it may, the evidence presented by PW-1 and PW-2
before the Tribunal indicates that the driver of the Tempo Traveller RW-2
had driven the vehicle in rash and negligent manner and responsible for the
accident. The RW-2/s defense is that the lorry was parked recklessly in the
middle of the road, causing the accident. At this point, we would like to cite
the relevant rules and regulations pertaining to vehicle parking on roads,
streets, highways, etc. And the observation made by the Apex Court in this
regard.
24. In [Sushma Vs. Nitin Ganapati Rangole and Others] (2024
SCC Online SC 2584) outlines the statutory provisions applicable to
situations involving vehicle parking in the following manner:
“25. Common sense requires that no vehicle can
be left parked and unattended in the middle of the road
as it would definitely be a traffic hazard posing risk to
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
the other road users.
26. We shall briefly refer to the statutory
provisions applicable to the situation at hand.
27. A highway or a road is a public place as
defined in Section 2(34) of the Act: “2(34) “public place” means a road, street, way
or other place, whether a thoroughfare or not, to
which the public have a right of access, and includes
any place or stand at which passengers are picked up
or set down by a stage carriage;”
28. Section 121 of the Act provides that the driver
of a motor vehicle shall make such signals and, on such
occasions, as may be prescribed by the Central
Government.
29. Section 122 of the Act provides that no person
in charge of a motor vehicle shall cause or allow the
vehicle or any trailer to be abandoned or to remain at
rest on any “public place” in such a position or in such a
condition or in such circumstances so as to cause or
likely to cause danger, obstruction or undue
inconvenience to other users of the public place or to the
passengers.
30. Section 126 of the Act provides that no person
driving or in charge of a motor vehicle shall cause or
allow the vehicle to remain stationary in any public
place.
31. Section 127(2) of the Act provides that where
any abandoned, unattended, wrecked, burnt or partially
dismantled vehicle is creating a traffic hazard, because
of its position in relation to the public place, or its
physical appearance is causing the impediment to the
traffic, its immediate removal from the public place by a
towing service may be authorised by a police officer
having jurisdiction.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
32. Regulation 15 of the Rules of Road Regulation,
1989 which were prevailing on the date of the incident
provides that every driver of a motor vehicle shall park
the vehicle in such a way that it does not cause or is not
likely to cause danger, obstruction or undue
inconvenience to other road users. It casts a duty on the
drivers of a motor vehicle stating that the vehicle shall
not be parked at or near a road crossing or in a main
road.
33. These legal provisions leave no room for doubt that
the person in control of the offending truck acted in sheer
violation of law while abandoning the vehicle in the
middle of the road and that too without taking
precautionary measures like switching on the parking
lights, reflectors or any other appropriate steps to warn
the other vehicles travelling on the highway. Had the
accident taken place during the daytime or if the place of
accident was well illuminated, then perhaps, the car
driver could have been held equally responsible for the
accident by applying the rule of last opportunity. But the
fact remains that there was no illumination at the
accident site either natural or artificial. Since the
offending truck was left abandoned in the middle of the
road in clear violation of the applicable rules and
regulations, the burden to prove that the placement of the
said vehicle as such was beyond human control and that
appropriate precautionary measures taken while leaving
the vehicle in that position were essentially on the person
in control of the offending truck. However, no evidence
was led by the person having control over the said truck
in this regard. Thus, the entire responsibility for the
negligence leading to the accident was of the truck
owner/driver.
34. In view of the above discussion, the view expressed
by the High Court that if the driver of the car had been
vigilant and would have driven the vehicle carefully by
following the traffic rules, the accident may have been
avoided is presumptuous on the face of the record as the
same is based purely on conjectures and surmises.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Nothing on record indicates that the car was being
driven at an excessively high speed or that the driver
failed to follow the traffic rules. The High Court
recorded an incongruous finding that if the offending
truck had not been parked on the highway, the accident
would not have happened even if the car was being
driven at a very high speed. Therefore, the reasoning of
the High Court on the issue of contributory negligence is
riddled with inherent contradictions and is paradoxical.
35. The Courts below erred in concluding that it is a
case of contributory negligence, because in order to
establish contributory negligence, some act or omission
which materially contributed to the accident or damage
should be attributed to the person against whom it is
alleged.
36. In the case of Pramodkumar Rasikbhai Jhaveri v.
Karmasey Kunvargi Tak, this Court while referring to a
decision of the High Court of Australia in Astley v.
Austrust Ltd.7, went on to hold that: “… where, by his negligence, if one party places
another in a situation of danger which compels that
other to act quickly in order to extricate himself, it
does not amount to contributory negligence, if that
other acts in a way which, with the benefit of hindsight
is shown not to have been the best way out of the
difficulty.” (2002) 6 SCC 455 (1999) 73 ALJR 403. In
the very same judgment, this Court also referred to
and approved the view taken in Swadling v. Cooper8,
as below: “Mere failure to avoid the collision by taking some
extra ordinary precaution, does not in itself constitute
negligence.” (emphasis supplied)”
25. In Shammi Sharma & Others Vs. Ran-- Singh and Others
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
arising out of SLP (C) No.21699 of 2018, the very same provision of Motor
Vehicles Act and Motor Vehicles Rules have made out.
“14.2 A perusal of the above provisions would
clearly indicate that no vehicle can be left in a dangerous
position or abandoned or to remain at rest on any public
place in such a position or in such a condition or in such
circumstances as to cause or likely to cause danger,
obstruction or undue inconvenience to other users of the
public place or to the passengers. The aforesaid rules
also mandate that two (2) red parking lights, one on each
side in the rear is to be provided and it should remain lit
even when the vehicle is kept stationery on the road. Such
rear lamps/lights which is required to be lit is to be
visible from a distance of 155 meters. Thus, above
provisions make it explicitly clear that a driver of such
vehicle who intends to park the vehicle is expected to take
all possible care and caution to prevent any untoward
incident occurring apart from the parking lights being lit,
so that other users of road would be able to clearly see
the parked vehicle and accordingly they can manoeuvre
their vehicle. ”
26. In this case, a rough sketch of the road indicating the place of
occurrence was presented before the Tribunal. We have also seen the rough
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
sketch, marked as Exhibit R-3, which indicates that the width of the road, is
24 feet, though it is termed a National Highway. New road construction is
also underway adjacent to the existing road. Since the road is 24 feet wide,
only 12 feet is available on each side commutation of vehicles. The lorry
carrying the casuarina poles is reportedly 8 feet wide. This shows that the
lorry, parked on the road, occupied most of one side. Although evidence
suggested the lorry had parking lights illuminated, its parking location
clearly posed a danger to vehicles traveling from Pondicherry to
Dindivanam, south to north. The incident occurred at 10:00 p.m. The Tempo
Traveller driver's evidence shows that, while he drove cautiously (according
to PW-1 and PW-2, he was also driving at high speed) and admitted that he
had seen the lorry blocking the road at a short distance and was unable to
avoid the accident.
27. We are of the view that the lorry, which has 8 feet wide, was
parked on the left side of a road, which is 12 feet of space for on going
vehicles, clearly posed a threat to vehicles traveling at high speeds.
Overtaking the lorry is relatively possible if no vehicles are approaching
from the opposite direction. However, if a driver spots a vehicle coming on
the opposite side, it may not be possible to safely overtake the lorry parked
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
on the highway, especially when the on going vehicle is traveling at high
speed. The place where the lorry is parked clearly indicates that with full
knowledge of possibility of posing danger to the commuting vehicles, the
driver of the lorry acted negligently.
28. We are of the view that considering the aforementioned point,
negligence should be assigned to both drivers and they are equally
responsible for the accident resulting in death of two individuals ie., in the
ratio of 50:50. Therefore, both insurance companies are equally liable to
compensate the dependents of the deceased families.
29. The Tribunal, having considered the evidence presented by PW-3,
determined the monthly income as Rs.6,000/- per month. Even in the
absence of evidence of PW-3, income fixed by the Tribunal fall within the
norms fixed by this Court for arriving notional income. Further, after adding
40% for future prospects and applying the appropriate multiplier, the
Tribunal awarded compensation after deducting personal expenses, which
we also deem reasonable. However, the Tribunal granted consortium to the
wife and awarded compensation for loss of love and affection to the children
and father. As per the dictum of Apex Court in United India Insurance Co.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Ltd., Vs. Satinder Kaur and Ors. [MANU/SC/0500/2020 : (2021) 11 scc
780], loss of consortium encompasses love and affection. Therefore, the
compensation awarded for loss of love and affection is cancelled, and
claimants are each entitled to Rs.40,000/- as loss of consortium. The
remaining compensation under conventional heads awarded is hereby
affirmed. Accordingly the compensation payable is given below:-
Loss of income:
Rs.12,09,600/-
Rs.6,000/- + Rs.2,400/- (40% future
prospects)
= Rs.8,400/- - Rs,2,100/- (¼ personal
expenses)
=Rs.6,300/- x 12 (months) x 16 (multiplier)
Loss of Consortium to the claimants Rs.
40.000/- x 4 each
Rs. 1,60,000/-
Towards Funeral expenses
Rs.
15,000/-
Loss of Estate
Rs.
15,000/-
Total
Rs.13,99,600/-
30. In the result, this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is partly allowed
and the compensation awarded by the Tribunal at Rs.13,54,600/- is hereby
enhanced to Rs.13,99,600/- together with interest at the rate of 7.5% per
annum from the date of filing of Claim Petition till the date of deposit,
excluding the default period, if any. Both the Insurance Companies directed
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
to deposit 50% each of compensation now awarded by this Court along with
interest and costs, less the amount already deposited, if any, within a period
of six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment to the credit
of M.C.O.P.No.28 of 2016 on the file of the II Additional District Court,
Puducherry. On such deposit, the appellants are permitted to withdraw the
amount now determined by this Court along with interest and costs, less the
amount already withdrawn, if any, as per the apportionment fixed by the
Tribunal. The Tribunal shall disburse the amount now awarded by this Court
by directly giving credit to the Savings Bank Account of the claimants. Since
this Court has enhanced the compensation, the claimants are directed to pay
the necessary Court fee, if any, on the enhanced compensation. In other
aspects, the award of the Tribunal shall stands confirmed. There shall be no
order as to costs in the present appeal.
(C.V.K.,J.)
(K.R.S.,J.)
29-04-2026
Index:Yes / No
Speaking / Non-Speaking order
vsg
To
II Additional District Court,
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Puducherry.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
(2/2)
C.V.KARTHIKEYAN, J.
And
K.RAJASEKAR, J.
vsg
CMA No. 2567 of 2022
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
29.04.2026
(2/2)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review