Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Writ Appellate Jurisdiction)
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean,
I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University,
Near Pushpa Gujral Science City,
Ibban, Kapurthala-144603,
Distt. Kapurthala, Punjab.
…
Versus
1.
Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh,
Through its President, Mr. Karma Gyatso Bhutia,
S/o Mr. Karma Sonam Bhutia,
R/o Dhajay, Near Ranka Senior Secondary School,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh,
Through its General Secretary, Mr. Sujendra Rai,
S/o Shri Ashman Rai,
R/o Lower Wok,
P.O. Wok & P.S. Jorethang, South Sikkim.
3.
Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh,
Through its Treasurer, Mr. Gyurmee Bhutia,
S/o Mr. Passang Bhutia,
R/o Ghurpisey, Namchi,
P.O. & P.S. Namchi, South Sikkim.
4.
State of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok.
5.
Secretary,
Social Justice Empowerment and Welfare Department,
Samaj Kalyan Bhawan-Bal Bhawan,
Lumsay, 5th Mile, Tadong, Gangtok,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
6.
Secretary,
Department of Social Justice Empowerment,
Room No. 721-A Wing,
Shastri Bhawan,
Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road,
Government of India.
7.
The Principal,
I.T.F.T. Education Group,
SCO 1-2-3,
Level III, 17 D, Sector-17,
Chandigarh-160017,
Punjab.
Appellant
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
8.
Additional Chief Secretary,
Education Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
9.
Indira Gandhi National Open University,
Regional Centre, Gangtok,
5th Mile, Tadong,
P.O. Tadong, P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
10.
University Grants Commission,
Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg,
New Delhi, Pin-110002.
11.
Secretary,
Ministry of Tribal Affairs,
Ground Floor, D Wing,
Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi,
Pin-110001.
…
Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, J.
For the appellant
:
Mr. A.K. Upadhyaya, Senior Advocate with Mr. D.K.
Siwakoti and Mr. Sonam Rinchen Lepcha,
Advocates.
For the respondent :
nos. 1, 2 and 3
Mr. Gulshan Lama, Advocate.
For the respondent :
nos. 4, 5 and 8
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Addl. Advocate General, Sikkim
with Mr. Sujan Sunwar, Asstt. Govt. Advocate.
For the respondent : Mr. Karma Thinlay, Central Government Counsel
with nos. 6, 10 and 11 Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Advocate.
For the respondent
No. 9
For the respondent
No. 7
: Mr. Leonard Gurung, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
20.11.2020
Date of judgment
:
20.11.2020
: None.
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
( Arup Kumar Goswami, CJ )
This appeal under Rule 148 of the Sikkim High Court (Practice and
Procedure) Rules, 2011, for short, the P.P. Rules, is preferred challenging
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
the orders dated 22.07.2019, 06.09.2019 and 18.10.2019 passed in
W.P.(C) No. 60 of 2016 as well as order dated 03.09.2019 passed in
Review Pet.(C) No. 01 of 2019 by which review of the order dated
22.07.2019 was prayed for. However, at the very outset, Mr. A. K.
Upadhyaya, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant submits
that this appeal may not have been taken to be preferred against the
orders dated 06.09.2019 and 18.10.2019.
2.
Learned counsel appearing for the parties submit that since all the
parties are represented, save and except respondent no.7, who had not
entered its appearance despite service effected pursuant to the notice
issued in the application for condonation of delay, and since any order
passed in this appeal will not in any way prejudice the respondent no.7, the
appeal may be taken up for disposal at the admission stage.
3.
In view of the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties
and on being satisfied that having regard to the relief prayed for by the
appellant any order passed in the appeal will not cause any prejudice to the
respondent no.7, we dispense with notice to respondent no.7 and take up
the appeal for disposal at the admission stage.
4.
Mr. Upadhyaya submits that on 15.05.2019, a direction was given
by the learned Single Judge directing respondent no. 4 (who is the
appellant herein) to submit a fresh comprehensive representation to
respondent no. 8 of the writ petition, University Grants Commission(UGC)
by 20.05.2019, annexing a comparative chart of the syllabi of course in
Bachelor in Airlines Tourism and Hospitality Management (B.Sc. ATHM) and
a comparative chart for the course of Bachelor of Health and Spa and
Resort Management (BHSRM) with the changes in their nomenclature.
When the
matter
was taken
up
for
consideration
on 22.07.2019,
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
submissions were advanced on behalf of the appellant that necessary steps
had been taken in terms of order dated 15.05.2019 but the learned
Counsel appearing for UGC submitted that no representation had been
received in terms of the order dated 15.05.2019. It is submitted that the
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant
did
not
have
the
copy
of
the
representation on that day with him when the matter was taken up on
22.07.2019. On the basis of the submission of the learned Counsel
appearing for UGC, it was construed that no action was taken by the
appellant and accordingly, learned Single Judge directed the appellant to
pay a sum of Rs.1.00 lakh each to each of the petitioners. Learned Senior
Counsel submits that though references were made in the order dated
22.07.2019 to some previous orders, it would be apparent that the
direction to pay a sum of Rs.1.00 lakh each to each of the students was on
account of alleged non-compliance of the order dated 15.05.2019 and such
alleged non-compliance was accepted by the Court only because of the
incorrect submission made by the learned Counsel for UGC. It is submitted
that though the writ petition was filed by the office bearers of Sikkim
Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh through its President, General
Secretary and Treasurer as petitioner nos. 1, 2 and 3, in the writ petition, a
list of 236 students, shown to be affected students is enclosed and,
therefore, amount payable by the appellant will be to the tune of Rs. 2.36
crores. It is submitted by him that amount directed to be paid, as would be
evident from the order dated 22.07.2019, is by way of compensation, and
that too, on a factually wrong premise.
5.
Learned Senior Counsel submits that against the said order dated
22.07.2019, a review petition was filed being Review Pet.(C) No. 01 of
2019 enclosing thereto the representation dated 16.05.2019 submitted by
the appellant before UGC which was also duly acknowledged on 20.05.2019
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
and accordingly, had prayed for review of the order. However, the review
petition was also rejected. It is submitted that when the representation was
filed by the appellant in terms of order dated 15.05.2019 was placed on
record of the review petition, the learned Single Judge ought to have
reviewed the order dated 22.05.2019 and failure to do so had occasioned
irreparable loss and injury to the appellant.
6.
He submits that pursuant to the representation dated 16.05.2019,
in terms of the order of this Court dated 15.05.2019 a meeting was
convened
on
06.09.2019
by
UGC.
Subsequently,
an
order
dated
25.09.2019 was issued by UGC, in effect, rejecting the prayer made in the
representation as against which the appellant had filed a writ petition
before the Punjab & Haryana High Court, registered as CWP No.
29701/2019. He has also submitted that against the orders dated
22.07.2019 and 06.09.2019 passed in Writ Petition (C) No. 60 of 2016 as
well as order dated 03.09.2019 passed in Review Pet.(C) No. 01 of 2019,
the appellant had filed a Special Leave Petition, which was registered as
SLP(C) No. 22416 of 2019 and the same was listed on 30.09.2019.
However, the said petition was withdrawn with liberty to approach the High
Court and the Hon’ble Supreme Court had passed an order on 30.09.2019
dismissing the petition as withdrawn with liberty as prayed for.
7.
The writ petitioners as respondent nos.1 to 3 had filed an affidavit
in the appeal. It is submitted on the basis thereof by Mr. Gulshan Lama,
learned Counsel for the respondent nos. 1, 2 and 3 that the appellant is
adopting dilatory tactics to the detriment of the writ petitioners. It is
contended that various orders reflected in the order dated 22.07.2019 will
go to show the callous conduct of the appellant. He submits that as the
appellant had been negligent in complying with various directions issued
from time to time, on an earlier occasion, cost of Rs.1 lakh was imposed on
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
the appellant. He has submitted that when the welfare of the students was
involved, the appellant not only ought to have produced the representation
but also ought to have filed a compliance report. He submits that there is
no merit in the appeal and therefore, no interference is called for with the
orders of the learned Single Judge and the appeal deserves to be
dismissed.
8.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, learned Additional Advocate General, Sikkim
appearing for respondent nos. 4,5 and 8 supports the contentions of the
learned counsel for the appellant and submits that but for the wrong
submission of learned Counsel for UGC, no occasion would have arisen for
direction to make payment of compensation amounting to Rs.2.36 crores.
He further submits that when the incorrect submission made by the learned
Counsel appearing for UGC was pointed out by the appellant by filing a
review petition enclosing thereto the copy of the representation dated
16.05.2019, the order dated 22.07.2019 ought to have been reviewed.
9.
Mr.
Karma
Thinlay,
learned
Senior
Counsel
appearing
for
respondent no. 6 as well as UGC submits that he was not instructed by
UGC that it had received a copy of the representation dated 16.05.2019
submitted by the appellant and therefore, he had made the submission as
noted in the order dated 22.07.2019. He has further submitted that even
though
the
appellant
may
have
submitted
the
representation
on
16.05.2019, the appellant had not pursued the matter and therefore, there
was laches and negligence on the part of the appellant. He further submits
that if the appellant had produced the representation, then there would
have been no occasion for passing the order dated 22.07.2019.
10.
Mr. Leonard Gurung, learned Counsel appearing for respondent no.
9 submits that he does not have much to offer in the present proceedings.
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
11.
Though
none
of
the
respondents
had
raised
the
plea
of
maintainability of the appeal and no such plea had also been taken by the
respondent nos. 1 to 3 in the affidavit filed in the writ appeal, we had
entertained some doubts about the maintainability of the appeal against
the two orders dated 22.07.2019 and 03.09.2019 and had accordingly,
sought for the response of Mr. Upadhyaya.
12.
Mr. Upadhyaya, learned Senior Counsel, responding to the question
posed by the Court, submits that the direction to pay Rs.1.00 lakh each to
each of the students is by way of compensation and therefore, such a
direction as contained in the order dated 22.07.2019 being a judgment
within the meaning of Rule 148 of the P.P. Rules, the appeal is
maintainable. He submits that the appeal is also maintainable against
rejection of the prayer for review. He has further submitted that the orders
dated 22.07.2019 and 03.09.2019 have worked serious injustice to the
appellant for its no fault. He has placed reliance in the cases of Shah
Babulal Khimji vs Jayaben D. Kania And Anr. , reported in (1981) 4
SCC 8 and Midnapore Peoples’ Coop. Bank Ltd. & Ors. vs. Chunilal
Nanda & Ors., reported in (2006) 5 SCC 399.
13.
Rule 148 (1) of the P.P. Rules reads as under: “148. Letters Patent Appeals:- (1) An appeal shall lie to the
Division Bench, not being a judgment passed in the exercise of
appellate jurisdiction in respect of a decree or order made by a
Court subject to the superintendence of the High Court, and not
being an order made in the exercise of revisional jurisdiction,
and not being sentence or order passed or made in exercise of
Criminal jurisdiction of a Judge of the High Court sitting singly.”
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
14.
In Shah Babulal Khimji (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court was
considering Clause 15 of the Letters Patent of the High Court of Bombay. It
was observed that the concept of a judgment as defined by Code of Civil
Procedure,1908(CPC) seems to be rather narrow and the limitations
engrafted by Section 2(2)CPC cannot be physically imported into the
definition of the word “judgment” as used in Clause 15 of the Letters Patent
because the Letters Patent has not used the term “order” or “decree” and
accordingly, observed that intention, therefore, of the givers of the Letters
Patent was that the word “judgment” should receive a much wider and
more liberal interpretation than the word “judgment” used in the CPC. It
was also cautioned that at the same time it cannot be said that any order
passed by a trial judge would amount to a judgment as otherwise there will
be no end to the number of orders which would be appealable under the
Letters Patent. The Hon’ble Supreme Court held that a judgment can be of
three kinds, namely, a final judgment, a preliminary judgment and an
intermediary or interlocutory judgment. A final judgment is one which
decides all the questions or issues in controversy so far as the trial judge is
concerned and leaves nothing else to be decided. This would mean that by
virtue of the judgment, the suit or action brought by the plaintiff is
dismissed or decreed in part or in full. Such an order passed by the trial
judge indisputably and unquestionably is a judgment within the meaning of
the Letters Patent and even amounts to a decree so that an appeal would
lie from such a judgment to a Division Bench. A preliminary judgment may
take two forms – where the trial judge by an order dismisses the suit
without going into the merits of the suit but only on a preliminary objection
raised by the defendant or the party opposing on the ground that the suit is
not maintainable. In such an event in any case the suit is finally decided in
one way or the other. The other kind of preliminary judgment would be
where the trial judge passes an order after hearing preliminary objections
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
raised by the defendant relating to maintainability of the suit, e.g. bar of
jurisdiction, res judicata, a manifest defect in the suit, absence of notice
under Section 80 CPC and the like, and these objections are decided by the
trial judge against the defendant. In such an event the suit is not
terminated but continues and has to be tried on merits but the order of the
trial judge rejecting the objections doubtless adversely affects a valuable
right of the defendant who, if his objections are valid, is entitled to get the
suit dismissed on preliminary grounds. Thus, such an order even though it
keeps the suit alive, undoubtedly decides an important aspect of the trial
which affects a vital right of the defendant and must, therefore, be
construed to be a judgment so as to be a appealable to a larger Bench. So
far as intermediary or interlocutory judgment is concerned it was observed
that most of the interlocutory orders which contain the quality of finality
are clearly specified in clauses (a) to (w) of the Order 43 Rule 1 CPC which
had already been held to be judgments. There would be interlocutory
orders though not covered under Order 43 (1) CPC, which also possess the
characteristics and trappings of finality in that the orders may adversely
affect a valuable right of the party or decide an important aspect of the trial
in an ancillary proceeding but such adverse effect on the party concerned
must be direct or immediate rather than indirect or remote. It was held
that every interlocutory order cannot be regarded as a judgment but only
those orders would be judgments which decide matters of moment or affect
vital and valuable rights of the parties and which works serious injustice to
the party concerned.
15.
In paragraph 103, the Hon’ble Supreme Court quoted as follows:“103. …………We might mention here that under clause (w) of
Order 43 Rule 1 an order granting an application is appealable.
On a parity of reasoning, therefore, an order dismissing an
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
application for review would also be appealable under Letters
Patent being a judgment though it is not made appealable
under Order 43 Rule 1.”
16.
Hon’ble Supreme Court at paragraph 115 observed that every
interlocutory order cannot be regarded as judgment but only those orders
would be judgments which decide matters of moment or affect vital and
valuable rights of the parties and which work serious injustice to the party
concerned.
17.
At paragraph 120, the Hon’ble Supreme Court laid down some of
the principles for guidance in deciding whether an order passed by the trial
judge amounts to a judgment within the meaning of the Letters Patent.
Paragraph 120 reads as follows: “120. Thus, these are some of the principles which might guide
a Division Bench in deciding whether an order passed by the
trial Judge amounts to a judgment within the meaning of the
letters patent. We might, however, at the risk of repetition give
illustrations of interlocutory orders which may be treated as
judgments:
(1) An order granting leave to amend the plaint by introducing
a new cause of action which completely alters the nature of the
suit and takes away a vested right of limitation or any other
valuable right accrued to the defendant.
(2) An order rejecting the plaint.
(3) An order refusing leave to defend the suit in an action
under Order 37, of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(4) An order rescinding leave of the trial Judge granted by him
under clause 12 of the letters patent.
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
(5)
An
order
deciding
a
preliminary
objection
to
the
maintainability of the suit on the ground of limitation, absence
of notice under Section 80, bar against competency of the suit
against the defendant even though the suit is kept alive.
(6) An order rejecting an application for a judgment on
admission under Order 12 Rule 6.
(7) An order refusing to add necessary parties in a suit under
Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(8) An order varying or amending a decree.
(9) An order refusing leave to sue in forma pauperis.
(10) An order granting review.
(11) An order allowing withdrawal of the suit with liberty to file
a fresh one.
(12) An order holding that the defendants are not agriculturists
within the meaning of the special law.
(13) An order staying or refusing to stay a suit under Section
10 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(14) An order granting or refusing to stay execution of the
decree.
(15) An order deciding payment of court fees against the
plaintiff.”
18.
At paragraphs 15 and 16 of Midnapore Peoples’ Coop. Bank Ltd.
(supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court laid down as follows:
“15. Interim orders/interlocutory orders passed during the
pendency of a case, fall under one or the other of the following
categories:
(i)
Orders
which
finally
decide
controversy in the main case.
a
question
or
issue
in
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
(ii) Orders which finally decide an issue which materially and
directly affects the final decision in the main case.
(iii) Orders which finally decide a collateral issue or question
which is not the subject-matter of the main case.
(iv) Routine orders which are passed to facilitate the progress
of the case till its culmination in the final judgment.
(v) Orders which may cause some inconvenience or some
prejudice to a party, but which do not finally determine the
rights and obligations of the parties.
16. The term “judgment” occurring in clause 15 of the Letters
Patent will take into its fold not only the judgments as defined
in Section 2(9) CPC and orders enumerated in Order 43 Rule 1
CPC, but also other orders which, though may not finally and
conclusively determine the rights of parties with regard to all or
any matters in controversy, may have finality in regard to some
collateral matter, which will affect the vital and valuable rights
and obligations of the parties. Interlocutory orders which fall
under categories (i) to (iii) above, are, therefore, “judgments”
for the purpose of filing appeals under the Letters Patent. On
the other hand, orders falling under categories (iv) and (v) are
not “judgments” for the purpose of filing appeals provided
under the Letters Patent.”
19.
In Central Mine Planning and Design Institute Ltd. vs. Union
of India and another, reported in (2001) 2 SCC 588, which was noted
in Midnapore Peoples’ Coop. Bank Ltd. (supra), Clause 10 of the Letters
Patent of Patna High Court was considered. In the aforesaid case, an award
of the Industrial Disputes Tribunal directing reinstatement and partial
payment of back wages was challenged in a writ petition. The workmen had
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
claimed interim relief under Section 17-B of the Industrial Disputes Act,
1947. The learned Single Judge directed the employer to pay full wages to
the workmen during the pendency of the writ petition. This order being
challenged in a Letters Patent appeal, it was held by the Division Bench
that the appeal was not maintainable as the order directing payment by the
Single Judge was not a judgment. However, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that an interlocutory order passed in a writ proceeding directing
payment under Section 17-B of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 was a
final determination affecting vital and valuable rights and obligations of
parties and therefore, would fall under the category of intermediary or
interlocutory judgment against which Letters Patent appeal would lie.
20.
It will be relevant to take note of the order dated 15.05.2019 and
accordingly, the same is extracted herein below:
“It is submitted by learned Senior Counsel for Respondent
No. 4 that they have submitted another representation to the
University Grants Commission (UGC), Respondent No. 8, duly
annexing a comparative chart of the syllabus for the courses
offered in their University in Bachelor in Airlines, Tourism and
Hospitality Management (B.Sc. ATHM) the nomenclature of
which was changed to Bachelor of Management (Airlines,
Tourism and Hospitality Management) and also a comparative
chart for the courses of Bachelor in Health, Spa & Resort
Management (BHSRM) changed to Bachelor of Management
(Health, Spa & Resort Management).
Learned Additional Advocate General submits that eight weeks
time may be afforded to the Respondent No. 4 and Respondent
No. 8 to take steps in the matter.
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that five
representatives of the Petitioner-Association also be allowed to
be present before the Respondent No. 8 when the matter is
being taken up by the said Respondent.
Considered submissions.
The Respondent No. 4 shall submit a fresh comprehensive
representation to the Respondent No. 8 by 20.05.2019 duly
annexing a comparative chart of the syllabi of the courses as
detailed supra with their change in nomenclature.
The Respondent No. 8 is directed to consider the
representation filed by Respondent No. 4 in the joint presence
of the representatives of the Respondent No. 4 as also five
representatives of the Petitioner-Association and shall dispose
of the matter within eight weeks from today with a reasoned
order.
Costs
of
travel,
boarding
and
food
for
the
five
representatives of the Petitioner-Association shall be borne by
the Respondent No. 4 from the date that they embark on the
journey till the time they are required by Respondent No. 8.
The modalities on this aspect shall be worked out between the
Petitioners and the Respondent No. 4.
List on 22.07.2019.”
21.
A perusal of the above order dated 15.05.2019 goes to show that
appellant was required to submit a fresh comprehensive representation to
UGC by 20.05.2019 duly annexing a comparative chart of the syllabi of the
courses as indicated with their change in nomenclature and UGC was
directed to consider the representation filed by the appellant in the joint
presence of the representatives of the appellant as also five representatives
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
of the petitioner-Association and UGC was to dispose of the matter within
eight weeks with a reasoned order. The expenses for the meeting to be
attended by the five representatives of the petitioner-Association, was to
be borne by appellant.
22.
Paragraphs 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 13 of the order dated 22.07.2019
read as follows:
“5. Despite clear and unambiguous directions of this Court
dated 15-05-2019 which for brevity is not being reiterated, the
Respondent No.4 has failed to take any steps in compliance
thereof. This is evident from the fact that neither did the
Respondent No.4 inform the Petitioners of the date that was
being fixed by them to appear before the Respondent No.8,
while
the
unequivocal
submissions
of
Counsel
for
the
Respondent No.8 lends credence to the fact that infact no steps
have been taken by the Respondent No.4 before them, nor was
any representation filed.
6. The records of the case reveal that as far as back in 28-092018 the Respondent No.4 voluntarily undertook to take steps
with the Respondent No.8, the University Grants Commission
(UGC), as remedial measures for recognition of the Degrees in
controversy, i.e., Bachelor in Airlines, Tourisms and Hospitality
Management (B.Sc. ATM) and Bachelor in Health, Spa and
Resort Management (BHSRM), for the years 2011 to 2014 and
2012 to 2015.
7. The records also reveal that on 12-10-2018 letter was issued
by the Registrar of the Respondent No.4 to the Respondent
No.8 requesting them to take steps for recognition of the
Courses.
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
8. The Order dated 02-11-2018 observes the callous attitude
adopted by Respondent No.4 towards the circumstance in the
Writ Petition and due to their inaction the Respondent No.4 had
been directed to pay total costs of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one
lakh) only, to the Petitioners.
9. Subsequent thereto, on 14-11-2018 this Court had observed
that the Orders of the Court are being flouted by the
Respondent No.4 and treated callously and not given the
seriousness it deserves.
10. Thereafter, an Order followed on 29-11-2018 wherein the
Respondent No.4 submitted that their representative had met
the Additional Secretary of the UGC, Respondent No.8 on 1610-2018,
sans
documentary
proof
of
such
meeting.
Consequently, the Respondent No.4 sought time to take steps.
The Respondent No.4 was warned that should they fail to take
steps as required they shall compensate each of the students.
x
x
x
13. In view of the non-action of the Respondent No.4 despite
directions of this Court they are directed to pay a sum of
Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only, each to the each of the
Petitioner Students by 31-08-2019 without fail and submit
report before the next date fixed.”
23.
A reading of the aforesaid order would go to show that the learned
Single Judge was led to believe that the appellant had not taken steps in
compliance of the order dated 15.05.2019 as the respondent no.4
(appellant) had not informed the writ petitioners of the date that was fixed
for them to appear before UGC, which belief was further bolstered by the
submission of the learned Counsel for UGC that no steps had been taken by
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
the appellant and that no representation was also filed. After recording the
above conclusion, the learned Single Judge referred to the previous orders
as noticed hereinabove.
24.
In paragraph 10, it was noted that on 29.11.2018 it was observed
that if the respondent no. 4 (appellant) failed to take steps as required,
they should compensate each of the students. Non-action of the respondent
no. 4 (appellant), as is referred to in paragraph 13 of the order dated
22.07.2019 relates to failure of the respondent no. 4 (appellant) to take
steps in compliance of the order dated 15.05.2019.
25.
Reading of paragraphs 10 and 13 of the order dated 22.07.2019
leaves no manner of doubt that the direction to pay a sum of Rs.1.00 lakh
each to each of the petitioner students was by way of compensation.
26.
The direction to make payment of compensation by the order dated
22.07.2019 attaches finality so far as that issue is concerned. Such
direction for compensation could not have been passed on presumption. It
will be relevant to note that in the writ petition, the writ petitioners,
amongst others, had prayed for compensation for the affected students. It
was a collateral issue arising out of perceived violation of direction of this
Court, which was evidently not a subject matter of the writ petition. In
Midnapore Peoples’ Coop. Bank Ltd. (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court had observed that an interlocutory order which finally decides a
collateral issue or question which is not a subject matter of the main case is
a judgment for the purpose of filing appeal under the Letters Patent. As
noted earlier, in Shah Babulal Khimji (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court
had also held that an order dismissing an application for review, being a
judgment, will also be appealable under Letters Patent. We are satisfied
that this appeal is maintainable.
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
27.
At this juncture, we would like to make it clear that this Court has
not made any comment on merits with regard to the case of the writ
petitioners or of the respondents in the writ petition. We have confined
ourselves only to the correctness or otherwise of the order dated
22.07.2019 so far as direction to pay compensation to the students is
concerned and the order dated 03.09.2019 passed in Review Pet.(C) No. 01
of 2019.
28.
Materials on record, without any ambiguity, demonstrate that a
representation was submitted by the appellant on 16.05.2019 and receipt
of the said representation was duly acknowledged on 20.05.2019. On
20.06.2019, the Registrar of the appellant had written a letter to the
Secretary, UGC to fix a date in terms of the order of this Court dated
15.05.2019 so that the petitioner-Association may be informed and the
case may be disposed of within eight weeks from 15.05.2019. IA No. 5 of
2019 filed in the writ petition, which is also annexed with the writ appeal,
goes to show that the meeting was scheduled by UGC on 06.09.2019.
29.
Mr. Gulshan Lama had submitted that not only the appellant should
have produced a copy of the representation submitted by the appellant
before the Court on 22.07.2019, but also should have filed a compliance
report. So far as submission of filing of compliance report is concerned, it is
noticed there was no direction for filing of compliance report in the order
dated 15.05.2019. If there was any such direction for filing a compliance
report, certainly it would have been obligatory on the part of the appellant
to have filed a compliance report. It is not the requirement in law that for
each and every direction that may be given during the course of a writ
proceeding, a party to whom a direction is issued must necessarily file a
compliance report. However, as the interest of the students is involved, it
WA No. 02 of 2019
The Dean, I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University vs. Sikkim Students Welfare Association of Chandigarh
would have been appropriate for the appellant to have furnished a copy of
the representation to the learned Counsel so that he could have produced
the same before the court, if so required.
30.
There was no basis for the learned Single Judge to accept the
submission of learned Counsel appearing for the UGC and at the same
time, to reject the submission of learned Counsel for the appellant. Learned
Single Judge also presumed that because no date for meeting is given, the
same is evidently a pointer to the fact that the appellant had not taken
steps. It has come to light that the submission of learned Counsel
appearing for the UGC was not factually correct and he had made the
submission without any basis. It has also transpired that despite being
aware of the order of this Court, no date for meeting was given by UGC
within a period of eight weeks and the meeting finally took place only on
06.09.2019. It was UGC which had not complied with the order of this
Court dated 15.05.2019 in letter and spirit.
31.
It is evident that the order dated 22.07.2019 was based on a
mistaken fact going to the root of the matter. In our considered opinion,
when the representation submitted by the petitioner was brought to the
notice of the Court by way of filing a review petition, it should have been
taken as a sufficient reason in the facts and circumstances of the case to
review the order dated 22.07.2019.
32.
In
view
of
the
above
discussions,
impugned
22.07.2019 and 03.09.2019 are set aside and quashed.
33.
Resultantly, the appeal is allowed. No cost.
( Judge )
jk
( Chief Justice )
orders
dated
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review