The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
01. 01.2021, thereby, superseding the applicants who claim to have attained seniority on being granted promotion prior in point of time to the 2nd batch candidates. In that case, those incumbents who were granted promotion to the post of Supervisor vide E.O. No.89, dated 02.08.2021, were required to be impleaded in the OA before the learned CAT, as apparently a right had been created in their favour upon grant of such promotion, which was likely to be affected upon adjudication of the grievances raised by the applicants. The learned CAT, however, has chosen to quash the clarification letter dated 25.05.2021 leaving the promotion of the 20 incumbents to the post of Supervisor vide order dated 02.08.2021 untouched. This of course would cause incomplete adjudication on the issue involved and adversely affect the incumbents who were promoted vide order dated 02.08.2021 to the post of Supervisor. The order of the learned CAT therefore, suffers from errors on law on this count. [10] Learned counsel for the applicants has, however, submitted that such a plea was not raised by the C&AG in its counter affidavit before the learned CAT. Such a plea in the present writ petition should not be entertained. [11] However, this court is of the opinion that if the necessary parties are not impleaded in such an adjudication concerning the rival claims of applicants with those persons relating to prom…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)(CAT) No.1 of 2023
The Comptroller and Auditor General of India and another
....... Petitioners(s)
VERSUS
Sri Hare Krishna Roy and others
...... Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, CGC.
Mr. P. Roy, Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate,
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. D. PURKAYASTHA
_O_R_D_E_R_
22/01/2024
Heard Mr. Biswanath Majumder, learned Central Government
Counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. P. Roy, Barman, learned senior
counsel assisted by Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel together with
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, learned counsel for the applicants/respondents herein.
[2]
By the impugned order dated 28th March, 2023, the learned Central
Administrative Tribunal (CAT in short), Guwahati Bench has quashed the
circular dated 25.05.2021 which was on the subject of clearance of doubt on the
promotion of Assistant Supervisors and Supervisors for the panel year of 2021.
The office of Comptroller & Auditor General of India (C&AG in short)
undertook a cadre restructuring of Group B & C - Main Cadres for filling up the
newly created post of Assistant Supervisors (Accounts) and Assistant Supervisors
(Audit) vide circular dated 15.10.2020. Certain senior accountants, including the
applicants submitted their willingness to attend mandatory training for appearing
in the Centralized Examination for Promotion to the post of Assistant Supervisor.
Upon completion of their training, they appeared in an evaluation examination
held on 19.12.2020 and all of them were declared successful. Out of 22 Senior
Accountants, 16 Senior Accountants from the panel list were promoted to the
post of Assistant Supervisors (Accounts) as per seniority vide order dated
31.12.2020 (Annexure-5). Further, 4(four) Assistant Supervisors were promoted
to the post of Supervisor as per availability of sanctioned post vide order dated
18.01.2021 on the condition that such promotion will be effective from
01.01.2021 notionally and actually from the date of their taking over of the
charge. Later, vide circular dated 15.02.2021, the office of the C&AG decided to
relax the norms prescribed for promotion as Assistant Supervisor on successful
completion of training for being eligible to be considered for promotion as
Assistant Supervisor for the panel year 2021 as one time relaxation. The
concerned Senior Accounts Officers were offered promotion to officiate as
Assistant Supervisors (Accounts) by relaxation of prescribed norms with a
condition that they have to mandatorily complete the training successfully along
with evaluation test during the panel year 2021 itself. Thereafter, 59 Senior
Accountants were declared passed in the training evaluation examination which
was held on 07.07.2021. Subsequently, 20 Assistant Supervisors (Accounts) were
provisionally promoted to the post of Supervisor (Accounts) with effect from
01.01.2021 notionally vide order dated 03.08.2021. The applicants who are the
respondents herein thereafter approached the learned CAT being aggrieved by
the order dated 03.08.2021 alleging that 20 Supervisors had superseded the
applicants, who had already passed the 1st batch of evaluation examination held
on 19.12.2020. Out of that 1st batch the top 5 Assistant Supervisors were
promoted to the post of Supervisors and rest of them were made to wait for their
provisional promotion to the post of Supervisor. But in terms of the relaxation
vide Circular dated 15.02.2021, another 64 Senior Accountants were
provisionally promoted to the post of Assistant Supervisor (Accounts) on
23.03.2021, out of whom 62 candidates appeared in the evaluation examination
and 60 candidates passed the evaluation examination. Out of those provisionally
promoted Assistant Supervisors, 20 Assistant Supervisors have been promoted to
the post of Supervisor vide order dated 02.08.2021 whereas the Assistant
Supervisors, who were promoted on the basis of successful completion of
training and passing out 1st batch of evaluation examination, were not considered
for promotion to the post of Supervisor. It was contended before the learned CAT
that respondent C&AG had promoted the Assistant Supervisors from the 2nd
batch superseding the 1st batch of Assistant Supervisors in violation of evaluation
examination and seniority. The learned CAT upon consideration of the rival
submissions of the applicants and official respondents who is the petitioner
herein choose to quash the order dated 25.05.2021 which was on the subject of
clearance of doubt on the promotion of Assistant Supervisors and Supervisors for
the panel year of 2021. Respondent-C&AG was directed to take proper steps
with regard to promotion of the applicants to the post of Supervisor (Accounts)
vis-à-vis the 2nd batch candidates who had admittedly been promoted to the post
of Supervisor and to fix their seniority from the date of their regular promotion to
the post of Assistant Supervisor, with consequential benefits.
[3]
Let it be indicated herein that the beneficiaries of the relaxation of
norms for promotion i.e. the concerned Supervisors in the 2nd batch were not
impleaded in the original application before learned CAT though the clarification
dated 25.05.2021 by virtue of which they were promoted by relaxation of the
norms, was under challenge and has been quashed by the learned CAT. Being
aggrieved the respondent-C&AG, has approached this Court under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India.
[4]
It is the case of the writ petitioner that though the learned tribunal
has set aside the clarification letter dated 25.05.2021 but it has left the promotion
granted to the 2nd batch of Assistant Supervisors w.e.f. 01.01.2021 untouched.
Applicants were primarily aggrieved by the promotion of the 2 nd batch of
Assistant Supervisors to the post of Supervisors by relaxation of the criteria.
Since the promotion granted to the 2nd batch of Assistant Supervisor to the
Supervisor w.e.f. 01.01.2021 was not challenged and they were not impleaded as
parities before the learned CAT, the quashing of the clarification letter dated
25.05.2021 would make it impractical for the writ petitioner to implement the
order of the learned CAT without touching the promotion granted already in
favour of the 2nd batch of Assistant Supervisors vide letter dated 02.08.2021. The
Assistant Supervisors who were promoted to the post of Supervisors (Accounts)
by virtue of circular dated 15.02.2021 and clarification dated 25.05.2021 were
accommodated on supernumerary posts. The cadre restructuring being
undertaken by the department in terms of the circular dated 15.10.2020 cannot be
implemented if this issue remains unresolved. Therefore, the petitioner, C&AG
has approached this Court.
[5]
The applicants/respondents herein have appeared and filed their
counter affidavit.
Mr. P. Roy, Barman, learned senior counsel for the
applicants/respondents herein has made the following submissions in support of
the impugned order of the learned CAT to oppose the prayer of the writ
petitioner. According to them, the applicants are the beneficiary of the 1st batch
of Senior Accountants who willingly had undergone 2(two) weeks of mandatory
training and successfully passed the training evaluation examination held on
19.12.2020, as a result of which they were granted promotion as Assistant
Supervisor w.e.f. 01.01.2021. The respondents contended that 66 Senior
Accountants were later offered provisional promotion to the post of Assistant
Supervisor by relaxation of norms for successful completion of training as per
memorandum dated 22.03.2021. Later, 59 out of those 66 Senior Accountants
were declared passed in the Training Evaluation Examination on 07.07.2021.
Among these 59 Assistant Supervisors, 20 incumbents were granted promotion to
the post of Supervisor on 02.08.2021which has given rise to the grievances of the
applicants/14 respondents herein, since they were promoted as Assistant
Supervisor much before these 20 incumbents, who are now superseding them for
further promotion to the post of Supervisor.
[6]
Mr.
P.
Roy,
Barman,
learned
senior
counsel
for
the
applicants/respondents further submits that the concerned supervisors who were
beneficiaries of the promotion granted vide order dated 02.08.2021 have not
approached the High Court and, as such, appear to be contented with the order of
the learned CAT. The counter affidavit of the respondent further details the
method of recruitment to the post of Assistant Supervisor (Accounts) by
promotion to be followed in terms of the Circular No.43, dated 15.10.2020 which
inter alia requires completion of mandatory training followed by a centralized
examination.
[7]
Respondents have categorically stated in the following terms at
praragraph-11of the counter affidavit:
“That, Respondent Nos. 1 to 14 had expressed their willingness to
undergo Training and only after undergoing such training, the Respondents
were allowed to sit for the Centralized Examination, which they
successfully passed. It is only after clearing of these 2(two) stages, that,
the Respondent Nos. 1 to 14 were promoted to the post of Assistant
Supervisor, vide E.O. No.556, dated 31.12.2020. But surprisingly, the 20
incumbents whose promotion to the post of Supervisor has been
challenged in O.A. 041/260/2021, were granted provisional promotion to
the post of Assistant Supervisor without even submitting their willingness
to undergo training or successfully passing Centralized Examination,
clearly in violation of the prescribed norms. Thus, the subsequent
promotion of those 20 incumbents to the post of Supervisor, vide E.O.
No.89, dated 02.08.2021, w.e.f. 01.01.2021 notionally, is ipso facto illegal
and arbitrary, as at the relevant time, those incumbents did not even
submit their willingness to undergo mandatory training, and even then,
they have been preferred with promotion to the post of Supervisor
superseding the Respondents who had already undergone mandatory
training & successfully passed Centralized Examination at the relevant
time”.
[8]
Mr.
P.
Roy,
Barman,
learned
senior
counsel
for
the
applicants/respondents submits that an anomaly has been created by granting
promotion on the basis of relaxation criteria devised by the department vide
clarification dated 25.05.2021 which the learned CAT proceeded to quash. The
department may be left to work out and resolve the anomaly which resulted out
of the clarification letter dated 25.05.2021. As such, the order of the learned CAT
may be left untouched.
[9]
We have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the pleadings placed from the record. The bare facts of
the case of the applicants and the 20 incumbents who were promoted to the post
of Supervisor vide order dated 02.08.2021 have been detailed in the foregoing
paragraphs and need not be repeated again. The broad features of the case of the
parties, if duly summarized, creates an impression that on account of
restructuring exercise undertaken by the office of the C&AG of India vide its
circular dated 15.10.2020, certain Senior Accountants, like the applicants/private
respondents, got promotion after mandatory training of 2(two) weeks and
successfully passing evaluation examination by order dated 31.12.2020 to the
post of Assistant Supervisor (Accounts). Later on the criteria for mandatory
training was relaxed by the department vide circular dated 22.03.2021 which led
to the promotion of 66 Senior Accountants to the post of Assistant Supervisor
who later on participated in the training evaluation examination on 07.07.2021
and 20 out of 59 successful candidates of the post of Assistant Supervisor (2nd
batch) have been promoted to the post of Supervisor vide E.O. No. 89 dated
02.08.2021. The grievance of the applicants is directed against this promotion
granted to those 20 Assistant Supervisors who completed the evaluation
examination after relaxation of the criteria of completion of training, but after the
applicants were promoted by order dated 31.12.2020 w.e.f. 01.01.2021 and that
too after the applicants had willingly participated in the mandatory 2(two) weeks
training and successfully passed the evaluation examination. The applicants seem
to be aggrieved as the promotion granted to those 20 incumbents to the post of
Supervisor out of the 2nd batch of the Assistant Supervisor would relate back to
01.01.2021, thereby, superseding the applicants who claim to have attained
seniority on being granted promotion prior in point of time to the 2nd batch
candidates. In that case, those incumbents who were granted promotion to the
post of Supervisor vide E.O. No.89, dated 02.08.2021, were required to be
impleaded in the OA before the learned CAT, as apparently a right had been
created in their favour upon grant of such promotion, which was likely to be
affected upon adjudication of the grievances raised by the applicants. The learned
CAT, however, has chosen to quash the clarification letter dated 25.05.2021
leaving the promotion of the 20 incumbents to the post of Supervisor vide order
dated 02.08.2021 untouched. This of course would cause incomplete adjudication
on the issue involved and adversely affect the incumbents who were promoted
vide order dated 02.08.2021 to the post of Supervisor. The order of the learned
CAT therefore, suffers from errors on law on this count.
[10]
Learned counsel for the applicants has, however, submitted that such
a plea was not raised by the C&AG in its counter affidavit before the learned
CAT. Such a plea in the present writ petition should not be entertained.
[11]
However, this court is of the opinion that if the necessary parties are
not impleaded in such an adjudication concerning the rival claims of applicants
with those persons relating to promotion to the post of Supervisor it would lead
to miscarriage of justice. Therefore, the impugned order is set aside. The mater is
remitted to the learned CAT to decide the original application afresh after
allowing the applicants to implead the concerned incumbents who were promoted
as supervisor vide order dated 02.08.2021 as respondents in the OA. Applicants
are allowed to implead the concerned respondents in the original application
through a proper amendment application.
[12]
Accordingly, the instant petition is disposed of. Pending
application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(S. D. PURKAYASTHA), J
Munna S MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2024.01.30 11:23:35 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review