Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 11-06-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE S. M. SUBRAMANIAM
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE N.SENTHILKUMAR
WA No. 857 of 2026
and
C.M.P.No.9068 of 2026
The Commissioner,
Erode City Municipal Corporation,
Erode.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. Gowrishankar N
S/oO.K.Nagappan,
Computer Operator,
Erode City Municipal Corporation,
Erode- 638 112.
2. Principal Secretary to Government
Municipal Administration and Water Supplies
Department,Fort St. George,
Chennai-600009.
..Respondent(s)
Writ Appeal filed under Clause 15 of Letters Patent to set aside the
Order passed in WP.No.26755 of 2024 dated 14.08.2025.
For Appellant(s):
Mr.Vijay Narayan, Advocate General,
assisted by Mr.M.Rajamathivanan
For Respondent(s):
Mr.G.Bala for
M/S.G.Bala & Daisy for R1
JUDGMENT
(Judgment of the Court was delivered by S.M.Subramaniam J.)
The present intra Court Appeal has been instituted under Article 15 of
the Letters Patent by the Commissioner, Erode City Municipal Corporation
__________
Page1 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
challenging the writ order dated 14.08.2025 in W.P.No.26755 of 2025.
2. The facts in brief are that the 1st respondent/writ petitioner was
appointed as a Computer Operator in Suramapatti, Grade-II Municipality, as
consolidated employee. After constitution of Erode City Municipal Corporation
the territorial jurisdiction was expanded by G.O.Ms.No.121, Municipal
Administration and Water Supply Department dated 20.12.2012 and the
adjoining area of 4 Grade-III Municipalities, 2 Town Panchayats and 5 Village
Panchayats are merged with the Erode City Municipal Corporation. The 1 st
respondent filed a Writ of Mandamus seeking a direction to the respondent to
regularise the service of the petitioner on completion of 3 years of service from
the date of his initial appointment in the light of the Division Bench judgment
passed in W.A.No.1615 of 2018 dated 23.11.2023, G.O.(2D)No.64, Municipal
Administration and Water Supply Department dated 08.08.2019 and G.O.(2D)
No.68 Municipal Administration and Water Supply Department dated
27.08.2019, with all consequential service and monetary benefits.
3. The Writ Court held that the judgment of the Division Bench dated
23.11.2023 in W.A.No.1615 of 2018 squarely applies to the case of the 1 st
respondent and allowed the writ petition in terms of the order in W.A.No.1615
of 2018. The facts relating to the present case are not recorded by the writ
Court while passing the impugned writ order.
__________
Page2 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
4. Mr. Vijay Narayan, the learned Advocate General appearing on
behalf of the appellant would mainly contend that the decision, based on
which the writ order impugned has been passed, is not applicable to the facts
of the present case. Facts are not identical. Legal position has not been
considered by the Writ Court. The post of Computor Operator has been
eliminated by the Government vide G.O.Ms.No.152, Municipal Administration
and Water Supply Department dated 20.10.2022. Therefore, the appellant is
not in a position to implement the impugned order of the Writ Court to
regularise the services of the 1st respondent in the post of Computor Operator
on completion of his 3 years of service in the consolidated pay.
5. The learned Advocate General drew the attention of this Court with
reference to the policy decision taken by the Government in G.O.
(Standing)No.152, Municipal Administration and Water Supply Department
dated 20.10.2022, wherein the post of Computor Operator has been
eliminated as far as the Erode City Municipal Corporation, is concerned. He
referred to G.O.(2D) No.64, Municipal Administration and Water Supply dated
18.08.2019, which relates to one Mr.M.Gajendran and 30 others, who filed the
writ petition in W.P.No.17855 of 2014 and a Contempt Petition No.763 of
2019. The said order was passed in respect of 27 NMR daily wage workers,
based on the writ order and under the threat of the contempt proceedings.
Even then, the facts are distinguishable. These 27 petitioners whose services
were brought under the regular establishment through G.O.(2D) No.64, cannot
__________
Page3 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
be applied in respect of the 1st respondent who was engaged as a Computor
Operator on consolidated pay. In G.O.(2D)No.68, Municipal Administration
and
Water
Supply
Department
dated
27.08.2019,
the
case
of
Mr.M.Udyakumar and 20 others were considered, since they were engaged as
NMR workers and therefore, the writ order is infirm on the ground of nonconsideration of factual discrepancies between the present case and the writ
appeal order which is relied on.
6. Mr.Bala, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the 1 st respondent
would submit that though the 1st respondent was engaged as consolidated pay
Computer Operator, he is continuing in service for the past about 20 years.
Considering the length of services rendered by him and taking into
consideration the mitigating factors, the writ Court, relying on the order of the
Division Bench, granted the benefit of regularisation. Several such temporary
employees are brought under regular establishment in the time scale of pay.
Therefore, the benefits extended to other similarly placed persons was
granted to the 1st respondent, which cannot be termed as perverse.
7. This Court has considered the submissions made by the learned
Advocate General, Mr.Vijay Nayaran as well as the learned counsel for the
respondent, Mr.Bala.
__________
Page4 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
8. The governing legal principles for appointment, regularisation and
permanent absorption are well setted in catena of judgments by the
Constitutional Courts across the country and the Hon’ble Apex Court of India.
9. The leading
case in the
matter of regularisation, permanent
absorption and appointment is the judgment of the Constitutional Bench of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of State of Karnataka vs. Uma
Devi reported in 2006(4) SCC 1.1
10. The Constitution Bench in unequivocal terms reiterated that all
appointments to public posts are to be made strictly in accordance with the
Service Rules in force. Illegal and irregular appointments cannot be validated
nor be regularised in violation of the service rules applicable to the posts.
Illegal and irregular appointments resulted in unconstitutionality, not only
affecting the efficiency in public institution, but would result in infringement of
the rights of lakhs and lakhs of meritorious youth, who all are longing to
secure public employment through open competitive process. By encouraging
the illegal and irregular appointments, rule of reservation is dispensed with.
Merits are compromised. Efficient public administration is the constitutional
mandate and through illegal and irregular appointment, efficiency in public
administration, at no point of time, be
achieved in our great nation. The
importance of adhering to the mandates of equal opportunity in public
2006(4) SCC 1.
__________
Page5 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
employment, unless
materialised in all spheres,
development of our nation and this exactly
Constitutional
Bench in force emphasised
it would affect the
is the reason why the
that
irregular and illegal
appointment, at any circumstances, be regularised either by the Government
or by the Courts.
11. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, at one point, issued a
direction, in the case of State of Rajasthan vs. Dayalal reported in 2011(2)
SCC 4292 considering the scope of regularisation of irregular appointments in
all possible eventuality and laid down well settled principles relating to
regularisation.
The Hon’ble Apex Court ruling that “The High Courts in
exercising the power under Article 226 of the Constitution will not issue
directions for regularisation, absorption or permanent continuance, unless the
employee claim regularisation had been appointed in pursuance of the regular
recruitment in accordance with the relevant rules in an Open Competitive
process, against the sanctioned vacant post. The equality Clause contained in
Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India should be scrupulously followed
and Courts should not issue a direction for regularisation of services of an
employee which would be violative of the constitutional scheme. While
something that is irregular for want of compliance with one of the elements in
the process of selection which does not also go to the root of the process, can
2011(2) SCC 429
__________
Page6 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
be regularized, backdoor entries, appointments contrary to the constitutional
scheme and/or appointment of ineligible candidate, cannot be regularized.
12. The Constitution Bench in Uma Devi’s case cited supra, paragraph
No. 54 clarified that those decisions which run counter to the principles settled
in Uma Devi’s case, for which, direction running counter to what the
Constitutional Court held will stand denuded of their status as precedents.
The Constitutional Bench judgment is the law in force as on today. Therefore,
any judgment passed by the Courts across the country running counter to the
principles laid down in Uma Devi’s case would denude to lose their status as
precedent and such judgment are to be strictly confined to the facts in that
particular case and the said judgment cannot be followed as precedent.
Therefore, while the High Court relying on the judgment of the Division Bench
of the same High Court or different High Court in the matter of regularisation
and permanent absorption, the facts to the case to be considered for grant of
relief relating to regularisation or permanent absorption.
13. In the present case, the impugned writ order does not deal with any
of the facts relating to the 1st respondent or the facts in the case of the
Commissioner Corporation of Chennai vs. Principal Secretary to
Government and others in W.A.No.1615/2018 dated 23.11.2023
__________
Page7 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
14. Let us now consider the facts of the present case as well as the
Government policy relating to the post of Computer Operator in Erode City
Municipal Corporation.
The 1st respondent was engaged as Computer
Operator on consolidated pay. He is continuing in the said post for about 20
years as consolidated pay employee. The Government issued G.O.Ms.No.64
dated 08.08.2019 wherein 27 NMR daily wage workers are brought under
regular establishment. A reading of the said G.O. would show that the
Government before passing the said G.O.(2D).No.64, examined the proposal
and rejected the claim for regularisation vide letter dated 08.08.2019, since all
the workers are Nominal Muster Roll employees (NMR) and they were not
appointed as per the procedures laid down in the rules in force. Therefore, the
Government took a decision not to regularise the service of NMRs daily wage
workers. However, they secured an order from the High Court in a writ
petition. Then a Contempt Petition was filed. When the Contempt Petition was
filed, the Government, in order to avoid contempt of court, recalled the
Government letter dated 08.01.2019 in respect of those 27 writ petitioners
alone, whose claim for regularisation was rejected and permitted the
Commissioner, Greater Chennai Corporation, to bring the 27 persons into
regular time scale of pay at the entry level vacant posts in Class IV (Sanitary
workers) in Greater Chennai Corporation from the date of issue of orders, as a
special case.
__________
Page8 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
15. A close reading of the Government Order issued in G.O.(2D) 64
would show that it is not an administrative decision taken by the Government
to regularise the services of these NMRs daily wage workers. Their service
are regularised under the threat of the contempt proceedings. Their claim was
initially rejected by the Government in view of the fact that SLP filed was
dismissed at the admission stage. Thus, the said G.O. which is relied on by
the 1st respondent for granting the relief in the writ petition is unacceptable and
based on the said G.O, the relief of regularisation ought not to have been
granted.
Thereafter,
the
Government
issued
G.O.(2D)
No.68
dated
27.08.2019 and an amendment was issued. The amendment states,
the
expression “from the date of issue of orders”, the expression “from the date of
completion of 3 years of service notionally and with all pensionary benefits
from the date of issue of the Government Order”, has been substituted.
16. Pertinently, the policy decision was taken by G.O.Ms.152 dated
20.10.2022 eliminated the post of Computer Operator from the Erode City
Municipal Corporation. Therefore, there is no scope of regularisation of
services of the 1st respondent in the post of Computor Operator. No employee
can be regularised in a non-existing post and the only alternate is that, such
employee, who is engaged on consolidated pay may be considered for
absorption in any other suitable posts if the selection process has been
undertaken by the competent authorities. No doubt, during the selection
process, temporary daily wage consolidated employees may be given due
__________
Page9 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
weightage by award of marks. Some priority may be provided to these
employees, who served in the Corporation for a considerable length of time.
However, the High Court, in exercise of power of judicial review issuing a
direction to regularise in the government post would result in causing
infringement of the right of meritorious candidate who all are waiting to secure
public employment through selection process and in accordance with the
service rules applicable.
17. The learned counsel for the 1 st respondent relied on the judgment of
the Division Bench at Madurai Bench of Madras High Court in W.A.
(MD)Nos.897 & 898 of 2019 dated 15.12.2025 The said case is to be confined
with reference to the facts of the said case . That apart, direction given to
regularise the service is running counter to the ruling of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of State of Rajasthan vs. Dayalal cited supra. More so, in
view of the ruling of the Constitutional Bench in paragraph No.54 of Uma
Devi’s case cited supra, the said judgment has denuded to lose its status as
precedent. The High Court, in such circumstances, may consider the facts and
direct the authorities competent, to consider the case by awarding weight age
of marks, if necessary by grant of age relaxation, to the temporary employees
rendering long service in the Department, Corporation and Government
institutions. But issuing a direction to regularise services undoubtedly, would
result in larger repercussions in matter of public appointments in accordance
__________
Page10 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
with service rules and would fall beyond the realm of powers of the judicial
review of High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
18. For the reasons stated
in the aforementioned paragraphs, this
Court has no hesitation in arriving at a conclusion that the writ order, which is
passed without considering the relevant facts available on record is infirm.
Accordingly, the order dated 14.08.2025 passed by the writ Court is set aside
and the Writ Appeal stands allowed. No costs. Consequently, connected
miscellaneous petition is closed.
(S.M.S.,J.)
(N.S.,J.)
11-06-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
VSI
To
1. Gowrishankar N
S/O.K.Nagappan,
Computer Operator,
Erode City Municipal Corporation,
Erode- 638 112.
2. Principal Secretary to Government
Municipal Administration and Water Supplies
Department,Fort St. George,
Chennai-600009.
__________
Page11 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2204
WA No. 857 of 2026
S.M.SUBRAMANIAM, J.
and
N.SENTHILKUMAR, J.
vsi
WA No. 857 of 2026
11-06-2026
__________
Page12 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review