Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 24.7.2023 IN WP(C)NO.14240 OF 2019 OF
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS:
THE CHIEF MANAGER, SYNDICATE BANK
THALASSERY, PIN - 670101
THE REGIONAL MANAGER,SYNDICATE BANK, REGIONAL OFFICE,
KANNUR, PIN - 670003
THE GENERAL MANAGER,STAFF WELFARE DIVISION, PERSONNEL
DEPARTMENT,SYNDICATE BANK, HEAD OFFICE, MANIPALTHE
APPELLANTS IS REPRESENTED IN THIS APPEAL BY ASSISTANT
GENERAL MANAGER OF CANARA BANK,REGIONAL OFFICE - II,
ERNAKULAM ON ACCOUNT OF THE MERGER OF THE SYNDICATE BANK
WITH CANARA BANK WHO IS DULY AUTHORISED AND EMPOWERED TO
REPRESENT APPELLANTS 1 TO 3, PIN - 576104.
BY ADV R.S.KALKURA
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
K.BABURAJAN,AGED 64 YEARS,S/O.KURUMBAN, KUNIYIL HOUSE,
PUTHUPPANAM(P.O), VATAKARA, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT, PIN –
673105
SRI.R.BINDU SASTHAMANGALAM
THIS WRIT APPEAL WAS FINALLY HEARD ON 18.03.2025, THE COURT ON
2.4.2025 PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
“CR”
JUDGMENT
Muralee Krishna, J.
This writ appeal is filed under Section 5(i) of the Kerala High
Court Act, 1958, by the respondents in W.P(C)No.14240 of 2019
challenging the judgment dated 24.07.2023 passed by the learned
Single Judge whereby Ext.P6 letter dated 12.04.2019 issued by the
3rd appellant rejecting the application filed by the respondent herein
to permit him to opt the Pension Scheme as provided in Ext.P3
Circular dated 13.07.2018 was set aside and consequentially
directed the appellants to reconsider the respondent’s claim as
expeditiously as is possible, at any rate, within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of a copy of that judgment.
2. The writ petition was one filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India by the respondent herein seeking a writ of
certiorari to quash Ext.P6 letter dated 12.04.2019 issued by the 3 rd
appellant rejecting the application filed by the respondent opting for
Pension Scheme provided under Ext.P3 Circular for compulsorily
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
retired employees, to declare that the respondent is eligible for the
benefit of the Pension Scheme envisaged under Ext.P3 Circular and
the appellants are bound to consider Exts.P4 and P5 applications
submitted by the respondent; and a writ of mandamus commanding
the appellants to consider Ext.P4 application dated 26.10.2018
submitted by the respondent for Pension and to allow the same as
envisaged under Ext.P3 Circular.
3. According to the respondent, he joined service in Syndicate
Bank as a Sub Staff on 02.05.1983 and was relieved from service
under the Compulsory Retirement Scheme on 29.04.2005. As per
the Pension Scheme existed at the time of retirement of the
respondent, he was not eligible for opting pension benefits as his
retirement was under the Compulsory Retirement Scheme. In 2016
a second opportunity was given to the employees who were in the
service of the Bank on 29.09.1995 and retired thereafter, to exercise
their option to join the Pension Scheme. Consequently, the
respondent made Ext.P1 request dated 10.04.2016 to the 3rd
appellant to extend the benefit to him. But that request was rejected
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
by the 3
rd
2025:KER:27553
appellant by Ext.P2 communication dated 24.05.2016.
Thereafter Ext.P3 Circular dated 13.07.2018 was issued by the Bank
incorporating new guidelines extending another option of Pension for
compulsorily retired employees of the Bank. The last date for
submission of the request with relevant annexures was on
22.08.2018. Except uploading Ext.P3 Circular in the Bank’s Website,
no separate notice was published by the Bank either on the notice
board or in any other form. The respondent came to know about the
Circular only on 11.10.2018 and then he submitted Ext.P4
application dated 26.10.2018. Since the application was delayed for
50 days, he submitted Ext.P5 written request dated 01.11.2018
along with Ext.P4. However, the application of the respondent was
rejected by the 3rd appellant vide; Ext.P6 letter dated 12.04.2019.
In the said circumstance, the respondent filed the writ petition.
4. The appellants filed a counter affidavit dated 12.08.2019 in
the writ petition opposing the averments in the writ petition and
producing therewith Annexures R1(a) and R1(b) documents. It was
contended by the appellants that the information regarding Ext.P3
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
Circular was displayed in the notice boards in the Regional Office,
Branches and Zonal Offices of the Bank and in the Bank’s Website
under Retirees Portal. According to the appellants, Ext.P6 order has
been passed after considering all the materials placed before the 3rd
appellant, after applying his mind. The respondent having submitted
the Pension Option form beyond the date stipulated was disentitled
for any relief. Though it is contended in the counter affidavit that a
personal intimation by Annexure R1(b) letter dated 12.04.2019 was
sent to the respondent, at the time of arguments, the learned
counsel for the appellants fairly conceded before the learned single
judge that the pleading in that regard is a mistake and actually
Annexure R1(b) is the copy of Ext.P6.
5. After considering the materials on record and the submission
made at the Bar, the learned Single Judge disposed of the writ
petition as said above, taking the case as a singular circumstance.
Paragraphs 11 and 12 of that judgment read thus:
“11. Even though the Bank says that they had published
the subsequent circular, dated 21.08.2018, on their
premises, as also have been uploaded on the internet
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
website, no evidence to substantiate the same has been
placed on record. This does not mean that this Court is
dissuaded from accepting their statement, but that it is
also equally possible that petitioner is right in saying that
he was not aware of either the Regulations or the Circular.
There can be no two ways about it because, the exercise
of option by the petitioner was for his own benefit and it
defies logic as to why he should not have done so, had he
been aware of Ext.P3 Regulations and the Circular dated
21.08.2018.
12. I am, therefore, of the firm view that though, in normal
circumstances, no concession could have been granted,
this is a deserving case where the petitioner’s claim ought
to be reconsidered by the Bank, adverting to the factual
factors presented. This is more so because, going by the
statement filed by the Bank, they were also aware that
individual notices ought to have been issued to persons
like the petitioner; and, interestingly, they assert they did
so, but which has now been explained to be a mistake.
In the afore circumstances, taking into account the
singular circumstances presented in this case and without
meaning it to be treated as a precedent in any other
matter, I order this writ petition and set aside Ext.P6; with
a consequential direction to the competent Authority of the
Bank to reconsider the petitioner’s claim, after affording
him an opportunity of being heard; thus culminating in an
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
appropriate order and necessary action thereon, as
expeditiously as is possible, but not later than two months
from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
Needless to say, if, through the afore exercise, the
petitioner is found entitled to exercise his option as per
Ext.P3 Regulations, such opportunity shall be made
available to him; and all beneficial consequences shall also
follow, without any avoidable delay thereafter.”
6. Heard learned counsel on both sides.
7. The learned counsel for the appellants would submit that the
Bank has published the information regarding Ext.P3 Circular in the
notice boards of all its Branch Offices, Zonal Offices and the Regional
Office. The information was published in the Bank’s Website under
the Retirees Portal. It is true that there is a mistake in the counter
affidavit regarding the sending of individual notice to the respondent.
In fact, Annexure R1(b) is not a notice sent to the respondent and
instead, it is a copy of Ext.P6 communication sent to the respondent
rejecting his request. However, the non-information of the Pension
Scheme to the respondent personally assumes no importance, since
it is impossible to send individual information to all the retirees as
they will be residing in different locations other than in the addresses
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
provided in the Bank. The publication of Ext.P3 Circular in the notice
boards of the Bank as well as in the Retirees Portal is sufficient notice
to all the persons concerned.
8. On the other hand the learned counsel for the respondent
argued that the respondent retired from service in the year 2005.
Whereas Ext.P3 Circular was issued in the year 2018. One cannot
expect to go through all the notices published in the Retirees Portal
in the Bank’s Website. Therefore, the delay caused in submitting an
application pursuant to Ext.P3 cannot be taken as a ground to reject
the request of the respondent.
9. The respondent retired from the service in the year 2005. At
the time of his retirement, he was not eligible to apply for Pensionary
Benefits. Subsequently, on 13.07.2018 the Bank issued Ext.P3
Circular incorporating new guidelines extending another option of
Pension for compulsorily retired employees of the Bank. This Circular
was published in the notice boards of the Bank, viz; its Branches,
Regional Office and also Zonal Offices. It was published in the
Retirees Portal of the Bank’s Website. The respondent made an
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
option to include him in the Pension Scheme after the last date fixed
for submitting that application. He ought to have submitted the
application on or before 11.09.2018 but submitted Ext.P4 application
only on 12.10.2018. For the said reason, his application was rejected
by the Bank by Ext.P6 letter dated 12.04.2019.
10. It is after a period of more than 13 years of the retirement
of the respondent, Ext.P3 Circular was issued by the Bank. Under
that circumstance, we find force in the submissions of the learned
counsel for the appellants that it was not possible for the Bank to
send individual letters to all the retired employees intimating about
Ext.P3 Circular, as the retired employees would have settled in
different places, other than the address provided in the Bank. The
Bank published Ext.P3 Circular in the notice board of its Branches,
Regional Office and also Zonal Offices as well as in the Retirees
Online Portal. It is for better administration the cut-off date is usually
fixed by the institutions for submitting certain applications. In the
case of Special Schemes also such cut-off dates are fixed for the
purpose of ascertaining the total number of persons who would opt
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
the Scheme and to facilitate the institution concerned to manage the
application in a proper manner and to disburse the benefits, etc.
Such a fixation of a cut-off date is highly essential for the
management of the Scheme, especially when considering the fact
that in the absence of such a cut-off date, applications would come
one after another at the whims and fancies of the applicants, which
would include afterthought also. In such circumstances, the
appellants cannot be found fault in rejecting Ext.P4 application
submitted by the respondent after the cut off date.
11. During the course of arguments, the learned counsel
appearing for the respondent placed reliance on the judgments of
the Apex Court in Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam v. Bachan
Singh [AIR 2009 SC 2745] and Calcutta Port Trust v. Anadi
Kumar Das (Capt.) [(2014) 3 SCC 617] to argue that unless the
appellants produce any record showing that Ext.P3 Circular was
actually intimated to the respondent, they cannot deny the benefit
of the Circular to the respondent.
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
12.
2025:KER:27553
In Bachan Singh [AIR 2009 SC 2745] the Apex Court
by considering the non information of the instructions regarding the
pension scheme to the retired employees of the appellants therein
held as under:
“In view of the law as has been articulated in a large number
of cases where this court has observed that any discriminatory
action on the part of the Government would be liable to be
struck down. Hence, in this case, it would be totally
unreasonable and irrational to deny the respondent the
pensionary benefits under the scheme particularly when the
appellants have failed to produce any record showing that the
instructions dated 6.8.1993 and 9.8.1994 were actually got
noted in writing by the respondent. In the absence of any such
material it can well be inferred that the respondent had no
knowledge about the options called by the appellants”.
13.
In Anadi Kumar Das [(2014) 3 SCC 617] the Apex
Court on considering a similar issue of non-intimation of the pension
scheme to the retired employees held thus:
“We would like to observe that whenever an employer
introduces the Pension Scheme or makes the same applicable
to retired employees and give them opportunity to exercise
option, the circulars/instructions issued for that purpose
should either be communicated to the retirees or made known
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
to them by some reasonable mode. Mere display of such
notice/instructions on the notice board of the Head Office
cannot be treated as an intimation thereof to the retired
employees/officers. The employer cannot presume that all the
retirees have settled in the city where the Head Office is
located. If the employees belong to the services of the Central
Government or its agencies/instrumentalities, they are likely
to settle in their native places which may be far away from the
seat of the Government or Head Office of the establishment or
organisation. The retirees are not expected to frequently travel
from their native places to the seat of the Government or Head
Office to know about additional benefits, if any, extended by
the Government or their establishment/ rganization and it is
the duty of the employer to adopt a suitable mechanism for
communicating the decision to the retired employees so as to
enable them to exercise option. This could be done either by
publishing a notice in the newspaper about which the retirees
are told at the time of their retirement or by sending copies of
the circulars/instructions to the retirees or by sending a copy
thereof to the association of the employees and/or officers
with a direction to them to circulate the same among the
concerned retirees. By taking advantage of the modern
technology,
the
employer
can
also
display
the
circulars/instructions on a designated website about which
prior information is made available to the employees at the
time of their retirement. If one of these modes is not adopted,
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
the retired employees can legitimately complain that they
have been denied right to exercise the option and can seek
intervention of the Court”.
14.
(Emphasis supplied)
While going through the facts of the aforesaid judgments,
it could be seen that in those cases the appellants have failed to
produce any record showing that the Pension Schemes that were the
subject matter in those appeals were actually intimated to the
employees in any manner. But in the instant case, by virtue of
publication in the Retirees Portal of the Bank’s Website, sufficient
intimation was given to all the retired employees, which was
mentioned as one of the options to give notice by the Apex court in
Anadi Kumar Das [(2014) 3 SCC 617].
15. It is trite that a constitutional Court exercising writ
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India cannot issue
a direction contrary to law nor can the Court direct an authority to
act in contravention of the statutory provisions. In Bihar Eastern
Gangetic Fishermen Cooperative Society Ltd. v. Sipahi Singh
[(1977) 4 SCC 145], a Three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court held
that a writ of mandamus can be granted only in a case where there
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
is a statutory duty imposed upon the officer concerned and there is
a failure on the part of that officer to discharge the statutory
obligation. The chief function of a writ is to compel performance of
public duties prescribed by statute and to keep subordinate tribunals
and officers exercising public functions within the limit of their
jurisdiction.
16.
In Oriental Bank of Commerce v. Sunder Lal Jain
[(2008) 2 SCC 280] the Apex Court held that in order that a writ
of mandamus may be issued, there must be a legal right with the
party asking for the writ to compel the performance of some
statutory duty cast upon the authorities. In the said decision, the
Apex Court noticed that the principles on which a writ of mandamus
can be issued have been stated in 'The Law of Extraordinary Legal
Remedies' by F. G. Ferris and F. G. Ferris, Jr. that, mandamus is,
subject to the exercise of a sound judicial discretion, the appropriate
remedy to enforce a plain, positive, specific and ministerial duty
presently existing and imposed by law upon officers and others who
refuse or neglect to perform such duty, when there is no other
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
adequate and specific legal remedy and without which there would
be a failure of justice.
17.
In State of U.P. v. Harish Chandra [(1996) 9 SCC
309] the Apex Court held that under the Constitution a mandamus
can be issued by the Court when the applicant establishes that he
has a legal right to performance of legal duty by the party against
whom the mandamus is sought and said right was subsisting on the
date of the petition. The duty that may be enjoined by mandamus
may be one imposed by the Constitution or a Statute or by Rules or
orders having the force of law. But no mandamus can be issued to
direct the Government to refrain from enforcing the provisions of law
or to do something which is contrary to law.
18.
In the impugned judgment, the learned Single Judge did
not find on merits that the respondent is entitled to claim the benefit
of Ext.P3 Circular. However, by taking the case as a singular
circumstance, directed the appellants to give the benefit of Ext.P3 to
the respondent. Having considered the pleadings and materials on
record and the submission made at the Bar, we find no legal backing
WA NO. 1898 OF 2023
2025:KER:27553
for issuing such a direction. Therefore, the impugned judgment of
the learned Single Judge is liable to be set aside.
In the result, the writ appeal is allowed by setting aside the
impugned judgment dated 24.07.2023 passed by the learned Single
Judge in WP(C)No.14240 of 2019 and the writ petition stands
dismissed.
Sd/-
ANIL K.NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
MC
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review