Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 14TH DAY OF JANUARY 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 100566 OF 2016 (MV-D)
BETWEEN
THE BRANCH MANAGER
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED,
IST FLOOR SLV TOWERS, 4TH MAIN ROAD,
PARVATHINAGAR BALLARI
REPRESENTED BY ITS
AUTHORISED SIGNATORY
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED,
EAST WING 5TH FLOOR
28 CENTENARY BUILDING
M.G. ROAD, BENGALURU.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. G.N. RAICHUR, ADVOCATE)
BHARATHI
HM
AND
1.
SMT. SHARADAMMA
W/O. LATE DEVENDRAGOUDA,
AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O: RAMDURGA,
TQ: GANGAVATHI,
DIST: KOPPAL.
2.
GAVISIDDANAGOUDA
S/O. LATE DEVENDRAGOUDA,
AGE: 12 YEARS,
OCC: NOT MENTIONED,
R/O: RAMDURGA,
TQ: GANGAVATHI,
BHARATHI H M
Location: HIGHCOURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
DIST: KOPPAL.
3.
KUMARI KAVERI
D/O. LATE DEVENDRAGOUDA,
AGE: 10 YEARS,
OCC: NOT MENTIONED,
R/O: RAMDURGA,
TQ: GANGAVATHI,
DIST: KOPPAL.
4.
HANUMANAGOUDA
S/O. LATE DEVENDRAGOUDA,
AGE: 6 YEARS,
OCC: NOT MENTIONED,
R/O: RAMDURGA,
TQ: GANGAVATHI,
DIST: KOPPAL,
PETITIONER NO.2 TO 4 ARE MINORS
AND STUDENTS THEIR NATURAL
GUARDIAN AND MOTHER I.E. PETITIONER NO.1.
5.
SMT. DEVAMMA
W/O. LATE HANUMANAGOUDA,
AGE: 57 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O: RAMDURGA,
TQ: GANGAVATHI,
DIST: KOPPAL.
6.
MAHESH
S/O. VENKOBAPPA @ YANKAPPA,
AGE: 23 YEARS,
OCC: DRIVER OF TRACTOR BEARING
REGN NO.KA-37TA-5450 &
TRALLY NO.KA-37/411
R/O. CHIKKA MADINAL
TQ: GANGAVATHI,
DIST: KOPPAL.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
7.
VENKATESH MELSAKARI
S/O. EARAPPA @ VEERAPPA,
AGE: 43 YEARS,
OCC: OWNER OF TRACTOR BEARING
REGN NO.KA-37/TA-5450,
R/O: CHIKKA MADINAL,
TQ: GANGAVATHI,
DIST: KOPPAL.
8.
SMT. RENUKA
W/O. CHANDRANATH
AGE: NOT MENTIONED,
OCC: OWNER OF TRALLY BEARING
REGN KA-37/411,
R/O: KAMPASAGAR VILLAGE,
POST: HITNAL,
TQ & DIST: BALLARI.
9.
THE MANAGER,
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
ISLAMPUR CBS CIRCLE, GANGAVATHI.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. VIDYASHANKAR G. DALWAI &
SMT. VEENA HEGDE, ADVOCATES FOR R1-R5;
(R2-R4 ARE MINORS REPRESENTED BY R1)
SRI. NAGARAJ J. APPANNANAVAR, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. LAXMAN T. MANTAGANI, ADVOCATE FOR R6 & R7;
SRI. M.B. GUNDAWADE, ADVOCATE FOR R8;
SRI. S.S. JOSHI, ADVOCATE FOR R9)
THIS MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER
SECTION 173(1) OF THE MOTOR VEHICLE ACT PRAYING TO
CALL FOR THE RECORDS AND HEAR THE PARTIES AND SET
ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 31.10.2014 PASSED
BEFORE THE COURT OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND MEMBER
MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL AT GANGAVATHI MVC
NO.100/2014 BY ALLOWING THIS APPEAL WITH COST IN THE
ENDS OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
THIS APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR
JUDGMENT
ON
09.01.2026
AND
COMING
ON
FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT THIS DAY, DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
This
is
the
appeal
filed
by
respondent
No.4
in
M.V.C.No.100/2014 under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988, (in short, ‘M.V. Act’) praying for setting aside the
judgment
and
award
dated
31.10.2015
passed
against
respondent No.4 in M.V.C.No.100/2014 on the file of the learned
Senior Civil Judge and M.A.C.T. at Gangavathi (in short, ‘the
Tribunal’).
2.
Parties would be referred with their ranks as they
were before the Tribunal for sake of convenience and clarity.
3.
The claimants have filed claim petition under Section
166 of M.V. Act claiming for compensation in respect of the
death
of
husband
of
petitioner
No.1-Devendragouda,
who
sustained accident in the road traffic accident that had taken
place on 23.03.2013 at about 02.30 p.m. involving motorcycle
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
bearing registration No.KA-37/Q-1822 and tractor and trailer
bearing No.KA-37/TA-5450 – KA-37/411.
4.
It is the contention of claimants that when deceased
was proceeding in his motorcycle from Chikka Madinal on left
side of Chikka Madinal-Hudejali public road, the tractor and
trailer bearing No.KA-37/TA-5450 – KA-37/411 being driven by
its driver rashly and negligently and the power poles loaded in
the trailer touched the motorcycle and caused the accident. Due
to the accident, deceased fell down and sustained grievous
injuries and shifted to Dr.Mallanagouda Hospital, Gangavathi for
initial treatment and thereafter to Hubballi Hospital for further
treatment and on the way to Hubballi hospital at about 06.30
p.m. he succumbed to those injuries. The claimants being the
wife, children and mother of deceased have filed the claim
petition claiming compensation under different heads.
5.
After receipt of notice respondent No.1 & 2-the driver
and owner of tractor bearing registration No.KA-37/TA-5450
have filed their written statement contending that respondent
No.1 had possess valid and effective driving licence as on the
date of accident and the tractor is covered with valid insurance
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
with respondent No.4. The accident happened due to rash and
negligent riding of motorcycle by deceased Devedragouda and
thus, they are not liable to pay compensation.
6.
Respondent No.4, the insurer of tractor has filed its
written statement wherein it contended that the petition is not
maintainable in law. Only because of negligent riding of
deceased, the accident happened. The respondent No.4 is not
liable to pay compensation, as respondent No.1 was not having
valid driving licence and respondent No.2 being the owner of
tractor
has
violated
the
terms
and
conditions
of
policy.
Respondent No.1 was not authorized to drive T.T. unit. Petition is
bad, as the owner and insurer of motorcycle are not made as
parties. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the petition.
7.
Respondent No.5 is the insurer of trailer and filed its
written statement wherein it contended that the trailer was not
validly covered with insurance as on the date of accident. The
liability of respondent No.5 is subject to terms and conditions of
insurance policy. Respondent No.1 was not having valid and
effective driving licence. Respondent No.3 has violated the terms
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
and conditions of the policy. Hence, prayed for dismissal of
petition.
8.
On behalf of claimants, claimant No.1 was examined
as PW.1, apart from examining a witness as PW.2 and marking
Exs.P.1 to P.14 before the Tribunal. On behalf of respondents,
three witnesses are examined as RW.1 to RW.3, apart from
marking Exs.R.1 to R.4 before the Tribunal.
9.
After recording evidence of both sides and hearing
arguments of both sides, the Tribunal came to the conclusion
that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of
driver of the tractor and he was having valid and effective driving
licence and thus, has fastened the liability of 50% each to the
tractor and trailer respectively and also directed to pay the
compensation to the respective insurance companies.
10.
In the meanwhile respondent No.5-the insurer of
trailer bearing No.KA-37/411 for which, respondent No.3 is the
owner of the vehicle has fulfilled its liability.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
11.
Aggrieved by the judgment and award fastening
liability of 50% on the tractor, the insurer of tractor i.e.,
respondent No.4 has preferred the present appeal.
12.
Learned counsel for the appellant Sri G.N. Raichur
appeared through V.C. would submit that the respondent No.4 is
not liable to pay compensation for following grounds i.e. the
tractor is used for commercial purpose and the tractor is insured
with it and it ought to have been used only for agricultural
purpose; furthermore, the driver of tractor was having D.L. only
to run tractor. If trailer is attached to it, then the tractor no
longer would be light motor vehicle and thus, the driver was not
having valid and effective driving licence to drive the tractor cum
trailer; furthermore, the electric poles were protruded from the
trailer and thus, the owner of trailer has violated the terms and
conditions of the policy and it ought not to have been protruded
from the trailer and thus, the insurer of tractor is not liable to
make good the compensation. He would further submit that the
Tribunal has included future prospects to the total compensation
income and awarded interest also on future prospects which is
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
not permissible. For these reasons, he prayed for allowing the
appeal.
13.
Learned counsel for respondent No.1 Sri. Laxman T.
Mantagani for respondent Nos.6 & 7, the driver and owner of the
tractor would submit that driver was having valid and effective
driving licence to drive the tractor and merely because trailer is
attached to it, it cannot be said that he is not having driving
licence to run it. He would further submit that the tractor is used
only for agricultural purpose i.e., the electric poles were being
transported in the tractor-trailer to lay them in the agricultural
property of respondent No.7 and hence, there is no violation of
policy conditions. Hence, prayed for dismissal of appeal.
14.
Learned counsel for respondent No.9, Sri S. S. Joshi
would submit that he has already satisfied the award by
depositing 50% of the total compensation amount as ordered in
the M.V.C. petition.
15.
Having heard the arguments of both sides and
verifying the appeal papers along with Trial Court records, the
points that would arise for consideration are:
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
i)
Whether holding of driving licence by the driver
of tractor will become invalid when trailer is
attached to it?
ii)
Whether appellant establish that the tractor was
used for commercial purpose and terms and
conditions of the policy are violated?
iii) Whether future mesne profits shall not be added
to calculate interest?
16.
Finding of this Court on the above points is in the
negative for the following reasons:
i)
The involvement of tractor cum trailer in causing
the accident on 23.03.2013 at 02.30 p.m. at
Chikka
Madinal-Hudejali
Road
near
Chikka
Madinal Village and due to said accident, the
husband of claimant No.1 Sri.Devendragouda
sustained
injuries
and
succumbed to
those
injuries on the same day at about 06.30 p.m. is
not in dispute. The age, income of deceased and
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
quantum of compensation awarded in this case
are also not in dispute.
ii)
The contention raised by the insurer of tractor is
that the trailer was attached to the tractor and
thus, the driving license issued to the driver of
tractor only to run tractor and not for tractortrailer and thus, he was not having valid and
effective driving licence as on the date of
accident.
17.
Said arguments of learned counsel for appellant
cannot be accepted for the simple reason that the license
granted to run tractor will not become ineffective, only because
the trailer was attached to it. In this regard, the learned counsel
for appellant would rely upon the judgment of Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Nagashetty vs. United India Insurance
Co.Ltd. and others1, wherein at paragraph No.10 held as
follows:
“10. We are unable to accept the submissions of Mr
S.C. Sharda. It is an admitted fact that the driver had a
AIR 2001 SC 3356
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
valid and effective licence to drive a tractor. Undoubtedly
under Section 10, a licence is granted to drive specific
categories of motor vehicles. The question is whether
merely because a trailer was attached to the tractor and
the tractor was used for carrying goods, the licence to
drive a tractor becomes ineffective. If the argument of Mr
S.C. Sharda is to be accepted, then every time an owner
of a private car, who has a licence to drive a light motor
vehicle, attaches a roof carrier to his car or a trailer to his
car and carries goods thereon, the light motor vehicle
would become a transport vehicle and the owner would
be deemed to have no licence to drive that vehicle. It
would lead to absurd results. Merely because a trailer is
added either to a tractor or to a motor vehicle by itself
does not make that tractor or motor vehicle a transport
vehicle. The tractor or motor vehicle remains a tractor or
motor vehicle. If a person has a valid driving licence to
drive a tractor or a motor vehicle, he continues to have a
valid licence to drive that tractor or motor vehicle even if
a trailer is attached to it and some goods are carried in it.
In other words, a person having a valid driving licence to
drive a particular category of vehicle does not become
disabled to drive that vehicle merely because a trailer is
added to that vehicle.”
18.
Relying upon the same judgment of the Hon’bel Apex
Court, rightly the Tribunal held that merely because trailer is
attached to the tractor, the driving licence will not be ineffective.
19.
In the instant case, the driver of tractors was having
valid and effective driving licence to drive the tractors as per
Ex.R.3. Thus, he was having a valid and effective driving license
to drive tractor cum trailer.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
20.
The second point of argument of learned counsel for
the appellant is that the tractor is used for commercial purpose
and thus, conditions of policy are violated. Ex.R.1 is the policy
issued in respect of tractor. It reveals that it is Miscellaneous
Vehicles Certificate cum Policy and there were limitations to use
this policy mentioned in the policy cover i.e., the policy covers
the vehicle used for any purpose other than A. Organized Racing,
B. Pace making, C. Reliability Trials, D. Speed testing, E. Use for
Carriage of passengers for hire or reward. Thus, the tractor can
be used for any purpose other than the aforesaid purposes. In
the
instant
case,
the
tractor
cum
trailer
was
used
for
transporting electric poles to the lands of owner of the tractor to
lay those electric poles in his landed property. Hence, the tractor
was being used for the purpose for which it was insured and not
for any other purpose. In this regard, respondent No.2 before
Trial Court has categorically stated in his evidence that he was
transporting the electric poles to his property to lay them in his
agricultural property. Thus, the second contention raised by the
insurer is also not tenable.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
21.
The next point of argument of learned counsel for
appellant is that, the electric poles were protruded from the
trailer and thus, the owner of trailer has violated the terms and
conditions of the policy and it ought not to have been protruded
from the trailer and thus, the insurer of tractor is not liable to
make good the compensation.
However, there is no cross-
examination to P.W.1 & 2 on this point.
Only because, it is
stated in the complaint that the electric pole was touched to the
deceased and accident caused, it cannot be said that electric
poles were protruding from the trailer. There is no direct
evidence to prove this fact. Hence, this contention raised by the
insurer is also not tenable.
22.
The next point of argument of the learned counsel for
insurer is that future prospects are included while computing the
income of deceased and it also carried interest and it is
improper. However, in the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court
in case of National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay
Sethi and others2, there is no such direction. The future
2 (2017) 16 SCC 680
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:437
MFA No. 100566 of 2016
HC-KAR
prospects are to be added to the income of deceased to arrive at
his notional income. Under those circumstances, definitely it shall
also carry interest. Hence, there is no infirmity in the judgment
passed by the Tribunal and it requires no interference. Hence, I
passed the following:
ORDER
i)
The appeal filed under Section 173 (1) of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 filed by the insurance
company is dismissed by confirming the
judgment and award dated 31.10.2015 passed
in M.V.C.No.100/2014
on the file
of the
learned Senior Civil Judge and M.A.C.T. at
Gangavathi with costs.
ii)
Amount in deposit be transmitted to the
Tribunal.
Sd/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
SSP/CT-MCK List No.: 1 Sl No.: 1
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review