Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
M.A.C.A. No. 1274/2024
:1:
2025:KER:29171
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE JOHNSON JOHN
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MACA NO. 1274 OF 2024
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 13.09.2023 IN OP(MV) NO.806 OF 2017 OF
MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, ALAPPUZHA
APPELLANT/3RD RESPONDENT:
THE BRANCH MANAGER,
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LIMITED, ALAPPUZHA,
NOW REPRESENTED BY ITS ASSISTANT MANAGER, REGIONAL OFFICE,
'SHARANYA', HOSPITAL ROAD, KOCHI –, PIN – 682 011.
BY ADVS.
SRI. P.JACOB MATHEW
SRI. MATHEWS JACOB (SR.)
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS AND RESPONDENTS 1 AND 2:
PADMAKUMARI, W/O. LATE AJITH KUMAR S. @ AJITHA KUMAR, AGED
61, MADHAVATHU HOUSE, AMBALAPPUZHA P.O., AMBLAPPUZHA SOUTH
GRAMA PANCHAYAT, AMBLAPPUZHA VILLAGE/TALUK, ALAPPUZHA
DISTRICT,, PIN – 688 561
POORNIMA A., D/O. LATE AJITH KUMAR S., @ AJITHA KUMAR, AGED
39, MADHAVATHU HOUSE, AMBALAPPUZHA P.O., AMBLAPPUZHA SOUTH
GRAMA PANCHAYAT, AMBALAPPUZHA VILLAGE/TALUK, ALAPPUZHA
DISTRICT,, PIN – 688 561.
ANEESH KUMAR,
S/O. AJITH KUMAR S., @ AJITHA KUMAR, AGED 37, MADHAVATHU
HOUSE, AMBALAPPUZHA P.O., AMBLAPPUZHA SOUTH GRAMA
PANCHAYAT/ VILLAGE, AMBLAPPUZHA TALUK, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT,,
PIN – 688 561.
HARILAL, AGED 34, S/O. PONNAPPAN, PUTHENPARAMBU VEEDU, WARD
NO.10, KOILMUKKU MURI, EDATHUA VILLAGE/P.O., ALAPPUZHA
M.A.C.A. No. 1274/2024
:2:
2025:KER:29171
DISTRICT, PIN – 689 573.
APPUKKUTTAN NAIR,
S/O. RAGHAVAN PILLAI, ASA SADANAM, KAROOR MURI, WARD NO.11,
PURAKKAD VILLAGE/P.O., AMBALAPPUZHA TALUK, ALAPPUZHA
DISTRICT,, PIN – 688 561.
BY ADVS.
R1 TO R3 BY SRI. S.K.BALACHANDRAN
SRI. K.M.BIJU(K/563/2008)
SRI. A.S.FARIDIN(K/1404/2003)
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
02.04.2025, THE COURT ON 04.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
M.A.C.A. No. 1274/2024
:3:
2025:KER:29171
JOHNSON JOHN, J.
--------------------------------------------------------M.A.C.A No.1274 of 2024
-------------------------------------------------------Dated this the 4th day of April, 2025.
JUDGMENT
The 3rd respondent insurance company in O.P.(MV) No. 806 of
2017 on the file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Alappuzha filed
this appeal challenging the liability of the insurance company to pay
compensation.
2.
deceased
The claim petitioners are the legal representatives of the
Ajith
Kumar.
According
to
the
claim
petitioners,
on
25.12.2011, while the deceased was travelling in an auto rickshaw
driven by the 2nd respondent, motorcycle ridden by the 1 st respondent in
a rash and negligent manner hit the autorickshaw and the deceased,
who
sustained
severe
injuries,
succumbed
to
his
injuries
while
undergoing treatment in the hospital on 13.01.2012.
3.
According to the claim petitioners, the accident occurred
because of the negligence on the part of respondents 1 and 2. The 3 rd
respondent is the insurer of the autorickshaw.
M.A.C.A. No. 1274/2024
:4:
2025:KER:29171
4. Before the Tribunal, PWs 1 to 5 were examined and Exhibits A1
to A14 were marked from the side of the petitioners and no evidence
adduced from the side of the respondents.
5. The Tribunal recorded a finding of composite negligence in the
ratio 50:50 as against respondents 1 and 2 and awarded a total
compensation of Rs.9,69,010/- to the petitioners. The Tribunal also
directed the 3rd respondent to deposit the award amount and permitted
the 3rd respondent to recover 50% of the amount from the 1 st
respondent
6. Heard Sri. Jacob Mathew, the learned counsel for the appellant
and
Sri.
S.K.
Balachandran,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents/claim petitioners.
7. The appellant is challenging the finding of composite negligence
recorded by the Tribunal and the direction to deposit the entire award
amount and thereafter, to recover 50% from the 1st respondent.
8. The learned counsel for the appellant argued that the evidence
of PW4 and Exhibit A7 final report in Crime No. 393 of 2011 of Edathua
M.A.C.A. No. 1274/2024
:5:
2025:KER:29171
Police Station will show that the negligence on the part of the 1 st
respondent caused the accident and there is nothing in the evidence of
PW4 Investigating Officer and Exhibit A7 charge sheet to indicate any
negligence on the part of the 2nd respondent, driver of the autorickshaw.
9. PWs 1 to 3 and 5 are the occurrence witnesses examined from
the side of the petitioners to prove composite negligence on the part of
respondents 1 and 2.
10. PW1 is the wife of the deceased and she was also a passenger
in the autorickshaw involved in the accident. According to PW1, the 2 nd
respondent was driving the auto rickshaw in an excess speed and in
negligent manner and that there was negligence on the part of the 1 st
respondent, rider of the motorcycle and the 2 nd
respondent, driver of
the auto rickshaw.
11. PW2 deposed that he witnessed the occurrence and according
to PW2, both the vehicles were in over-speed and the accident occurred
when the driver of the auto rickshaw suddenly turned the vehicle
towards right. The 2nd respondent, driver of the autorickshaw is
M.A.C.A. No. 1274/2024
:6:
2025:KER:29171
examined as PW3.
According to PW3, the motorcycle was ridden in
over-speed. However, he also stated that at the time of occurrence, he
was also driving the auto rickshaw in speed and that there was
negligence on the part of the rider of the motorcycle and the driver of
the autorickshaw.
12. PW5 is another occurrence witness and he also deposed that
there was negligence on the part of the driver of the auto rickshaw and
rider of the motorcycle and that the accident occurred when the driver of
auto rickshaw suddenly turned the vehicle towards right.
13.
In New India Assurance Co.Ltd. v. Pazhaniammal and
Others (2011(3) KHC 595), this Court held that as a general rule,
production of the police charge sheet is prima facie sufficient evidence of
negligence for the purpose of a claim under Section 166 of the Motor
vehicles Act. In the said decision, it was also held that if any one of the
parties do not accept such charge sheet, the burden must be on such
party to adduce oral evidence and if oral evidence is adduced by any
party in a case where charge sheet is filed, the Tribunals should give
further opportunity to others also to adduce oral evidence and in such a
M.A.C.A. No. 1274/2024
:7:
2025:KER:29171
case, the charge sheet will pale into insignificance and the dispute will
have to be decided on the basis of the evidence. It was further held that
in all other cases, such charge sheet can be reckoned as sufficient
evidence of negligence in a claim under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act.
14.
The decision of the Hon'ble Supreme court in Mathew
Alexander v. Muhammed Shafi (2023 INSC 621) shows that strict
proof of an accident caused by a particular vehicle in a particular manner
need not be established by the claimants and that the claimants need
only to establish their case on the touchstone of preponderance of
probabilities. In the said case, it was also held that the standard of proof
beyond reasonable doubt cannot be applied while considering the
petition seeking compensation on account of death or injury in a road
traffic accident.
15.
In Jiju Kuruvilla v. Kunjujamma Mohan [2013 (3) KLT
261], the Honourable Supreme Court held thus:
“24. The mere position of the vehicles after accident, as shown in a Scene
Mahazar, cannot give a substantial proof as to the rash and negligent driving on
the part of one or the other. When two vehicles coming from opposite directions
collide, the position of the vehicles and its direction etc. depends on number of
M.A.C.A. No. 1274/2024
:8:
2025:KER:29171
factors like speed of vehicles, intensity of collision, reason for collision, place at
which one vehicle hit the other, etc. From the scene of the accident, one may
suggest or presume the manner in which the accident caused, but in absence of
any direct or corroborative evidence, no conclusion can be drawn as to whether
there was negligence on the part of the driver. In absence of such direct or
corroborative evidence, the Court cannot give any specific finding about
negligence on the part of any individual.”
16. It is pertinent to note that the appellant insurance company
has not examined any witness before the Tribunal and therefore, on a
careful re-appreciation of the available evidence, I find no reason to
interfere with the finding of the Tribunal regarding composite negligence
on the part of respondents 1 and 2.
17.
The learned counsel for the appellant insurance company
argued that in spite of recording a finding of composite negligence in the
ratio of 50:50, the Tribunal directed the appellant insurance company to
pay the entire award amount to the claim petitioners and thereafter, to
recover 50% of the amount from the 1st respondent and the said
direction is not legally sustainable.
18.
But, the learned counsel for the claim petitioners cited the
decision of the Honourable Supreme Court in Khenyei v. New India
M.A.C.A. No. 1274/2024
:9:
2025:KER:29171
Assurance Co. Ltd. and others [2015 (3) KHC 70], wherein the
Honourable Supreme Court held that when the accident is caused by
composite negligence, it is open to a claimant to recover entire
compensation from one of the joint tort feasors as the liability of joint
tort feasors is joint and several.
19. In view of the above legal position, I find that the contention
of the appellant in this regard is not legally sustainable. Therefore, I find
that this appeal is devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed.
In the result, this appeal is dismissed.
sd/JOHNSON JOHN,
JUDGE.
Rv
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review