Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
MONDAY, THE 20TH DAY OF JANUARY 2025/30TH POUSHA, 1946
MACA NO. 45 OF 2021
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 30.09.2020 IN O.P.(M.V) NO.1616 OF
2018 OF MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL ,KOZHIKODE
APPELLANT/3RD RESPONDENT :
THE BRANCH MANAGER
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, BRANCH OFFICE,
KUNNAMANGALAM, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT CO-OPERATIVE BANK
BUILDING, KP11/560L, MAIN ROAD, KUNNAMANGALAM,
KOZHIKODE-673571 NOW REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER,
REGIONAL OFFICE, “SHARANYA”, HOSPITAL ROAD, KOCHI-11.
BY ADVS.
MATHEWS JACOB (SR.)
SRI.P.JACOB MATHEW
SMT.PREETHY R. NAIR
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS :
MUJEEB RAHMAN A.P.,
S/O.HYDRU, ANGATTAPOYIL HOUSE, KODIYATHUR P.O.,
MUKKOM, KOZHIKODE TALUK-673602.
RUBEENA,
AGED 39 YEARS
W/O.MUJEEB RAHMAN A.P., ANGATTAPOYIL HOUSE,
KODIYATHUR P.O., MUKKOM, KOZHIKODE TALUK-673602.
SHANU RAHMAN A.P.,
AGED 20 YEARS
S/O.MUJEEB RAHMAN A.P., ANGATTAPOYIL HOUSE,
KODIYATHUR P.O., MUKKOM, KOZHIKODE TALUK-673602.
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
ABIN RAHMAN,
AGED 11 YEARS (MINOR), S/O.MUJEEB RAHMAN A.P.,
ANGATTAPOYIL HOUSE, KODIYATHUR P.O., MUKKOM,
KOZHIKODE TALUK-673602,
REPRESENTED BY HIS FATHER 1ST RESPONDENT.
BY ADVS.
SADIQALI M
VISHAL L.(K/2060/2024)
NIMOD A.R., AMICUS CURIAE
THIS
HEARING
ON
FOLLOWING:
MOTOR
ACCIDENT
22.11.2024,
CLAIMS
THE
COURT
APPEAL
ON
HAVING
20.1.2025
COME
UP
FOR
DELIVERED
THE
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
MONDAY, THE 20TH DAY OF JANUARY 2025/30TH POUSHA, 1946
MACA NO. 2000 OF 2022
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 30.09.2020 IN O.P.(M.V) NO.1616 OF
2018 OF MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL ,KOZHIKODE
APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS :
MUJEEB RAHMAN A.P
AGED 46 YEARS
ANGATTAPOYIL HOUSE, P.O. KODIYATHUR,
MUKKOM, KOZHIKODE TALUK, PIN - 673602
RUBEENA
AGED 41 YEARS
W/O MUJEEB RAHMAN A.P., ANGATTAPOYIL HOUSE,P.O
KODIYATHUR,MUKKOM ,KOZHIKODE TALUK, PIN - 673602
SHANU RAHMAN.AP,
AGED 22 YEARS
S/O MUJEEB RAHMAN A.P, ANGATTAPOYIL HOUSE,P.O
KODIYATHUR,MUKKOM ,KOZHIKODE TALUK, PIN - 673602
ABIN RAHMAN,AGED 13 YEARS,(MINOR)
S/O MUJEEB RAHMAN A.P,
REP BY FATHER MUJEEB RAHMAN A.P.,
AGED 46 YEARS ,S/O HYDRU,
ANGATTAPOYIL HOUSE, P.O. KODIYATHUR,
MUKKOM, KOZHIKODE TALUK, PIN - 673602
BY ADVS.
SALMANUL FASIL O.P.
SADIQALI.M
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
RUJEESH RAHMAN
AGED 26 YEARS, S/O LATE MUHAMMED,
THADAYIL HOUSE, P.O, KODIYATHUR,
MUKKOM ,KOZHIKODE TALUK, PIN - 673602
SHIHAB A.P
AGED 44 YEARS
S/O HYDRU , ANGATTAPOYIL HOUSE,P.O KODIYATHUR,
MUKKOM ,KOZHIKODE DT, PIN - 673602
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.
REP BY ITS BRANCH MANAGER, BRANCH OFFICE
KUNNAMANGALAM, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT
CO-OPERATIVE BANK BUILDING, KP 11/506L,
MAIN ROAD KUNNAMANGALAM,KOZHIKODE-, PIN - 673571
BY ADVS. SRI. MATHEWS JACOB (SR.)(M-186)
SRI. JACOB MATHEW P
SRI. NIMOD A.R., AMICUS CURIAE
THIS
MOTOR
ACCIDENT
CLAIMS
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
ADMISSION ON 22.11.2024, THE COURT ON 20.1.2025 DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
‘C.R.’
EASWARAN S., J.
------------------------M.A.C.A Nos.45 of 2021 & 2000 of 2022
----------------------------------Dated this the 20th day of January, 2025
JUDGMENT
“Death is certain in life but yet the timing remains uncertain.”
Death of a 15-year old child is inconsolable. No amount can compensate
the parents for loss of their ward. Yet the award of compensation will
remain thin commiseration.”
1.
In these appeals this Court is called upon to decide the
quantum of compensation required to be awarded on account of the death
of a minor Child. M.A.C.A. No.45 of 2021 is preferred by the insurance
company and M.A.C.A. No.2000 of 2022 is preferred by the claimants
aggrieved by the quantum of compensation awarded by the tribunal.
2. Brief facts for disposal of these appeals are as follows:
On 24.04.2018 at 12.30 pm, while one Yasin Hydar A.P., a
student, aged 15 years, was travelling in a car bearing Registration
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
No.KL-57-K-4410 and when it reached at Kalandithazham, it hit against an
autorickshaw bearing Registration No.KL-57-4074. As a result of the
accident, the deceased was thrown out of the car resulting in serious
injuries and later succumbing to the injuries. On behalf of the claimants,
Exts.A1 to A6 documents were marked. No oral or documentary evidence
was produced on the side of the insurance company. The tribunal
proceeded to fix the notional income of the deceased at Rs.18,000/- per
month and deducted half (½) of the same towards the personal expenses
and granted a total compensation of Rs.17,47,000/- (Rupees Seventeen
Lakh Forty Seven Thousand only).
3.
According to the Insurance Company the grant of
compensation is exorbitant whereas, the claimants contended that the
compensation awarded by the tribunal is insufficient.
4. Heard Sri. Mathews Jacob, the learned Senior counsel assisted
by Smt. Preethi R Nair, the learned counsel appearing for the insurance
company, Sri. M. Sadiqali, the learned counsel appearing for the claimants
and Sri. Nimod A.R., the learned Amicus Curiae appointed by this Court.
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
5. The appeal preferred by the insurance company shall be dealt
with first since the decision of this Court in this appeal will have an impact
on the appeal preferred by the claimants. Sri. Mathews P. Jacob, the
learned Senior counsel assisted by Smt. Preethy R Nair, appearing for the
insurance company contended that the tribunal erred in fixing the notional
income at Rs.18,000/- per month. In respect of a child who is aged less
than 15 years, according to the learned Senior counsel, the tribunal could
not have fixed the notional income and should have applied the principles
of global compensation as enunciated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Meena Devi vs. Nunu Chand Mahto @ Nemchand Mahto and
Others [2023 (1) SCC 204]. Reliance is also placed on the judgment of this
Court in Preethu and others vs. Sukumaran P and another [MACA
No.595 of 2021 dated 6.9.2024 rendered by E.S.(J)]. It is further submitted
that the tribunal had applied 50% of the income towards future prospects
whereas, only 40% can be taken. This, according to the learned Senior
counsel, is an alternate submission if this Court finds that the fixation of
the notional income is inevitable.
6.
On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
claimants contended that it has become the necessity of the day to revisit
the law laid down by this Court on this point. Referring to the decision of
this Court in National Insurance Company vs. K.K. Assainar and
others [2019 (4) KLT 39], the learned counsel submitted that the
principles laid down by this Court in the above decision requires to be
revisited in the light of the subsequent judgments rendered by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court.
7. Sri. Nimod A.R., the learned Amicus Curiae submitted that
irrespective of the age of the deceased/claimant, even if the claimant or the
victim being a minor, the Court should apply the minimum wages to arrive
at the notional income. This according to the learned Amicus Curiae is
inevitable because the principle enshrined under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 requires the tribunal and the court to fix just and fair
compensation. The learned Amicus Curiae, referring to the reasoning given
by this Court in Assainar (Supra), submitted that since this Court wanted
to devise a formula while dealing with a claim arising out of the death of a
minor, the compensation should not go below the schedule fixed under
Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act and therefore, this Court had
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
undertaken the exercise the Assainar (supra). However, the Parliament,
by an amendment to the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 omitted the Second
Schedule and the same was notified with effect from 1-4-2022. This
omission will have an impact on the consideration of the claim petitions.
8. I have considered the rival submissions raised across the Bar.
9. The primary question that falls for consideration of this Court
is as to whether this Court should follow the principles laid down by the
learned Single Bench in Assainar (Supra) and if so, what would be the
impact of the omission of the second schedule to the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988.
10. Although while considering the claim for compensation on
account of the death of a minor child, the courts and tribunal should always
adopt a liberal approach, the empathy alone cannot govern the
consideration of court.
11. Before delving deep into the issue, it is expedient to consider
various precedents on this point.
12.
In National Insurance Company vs. K.K. Assainar
and others [2019 (4) KLT 39]), a learned Single Bench of this Court
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
formulated a method by which, the claim of the minor child could be dealt
with by the tribunal and court. Paragraph No.18 of the judgment in
Assainar (Supra) reads as under:
”18. Once it is accepted that the multiplier to be applied while
computing compensation for dependency is '15' and the mode of
assessment is as provided for in the Second Schedule to the Act, viz,
that one third shall only be deducted from the notional income to
determine the multiplicand, as it is found that the compensation
payable under the un amended S.163A is Rs.2,40,000/-, it can be
seen, though it is provided in the Second Schedule that the notional
income of a non earning person shall be reckoned at Rs.15,000/-, the
notional income in respect of children below the age of 15 is actually
contemplated to be reckoned at Rs.24,000/-. In other words, having
regard to the fact that S.163A is a provision introduced only with
effect from 14/11/1994, and having regard to the compensation
granted by various Courts in cases involving death of children
during the said period, I am of the view that Rs.24,000/- can be fixed,
except in exceptional cases where a different yardstick has to be
followed, as the notional income of the children died in accidents till
the end of the financial year 1995-96. But the said amount cannot be
reckoned as the notional income in cases arising in the subsequent
years, as it is common knowledge that rupee value has come down
drastically thereafter and the effect of inflation in the subsequent
years has therefore, to be off setted. In Chetan Malhotra & Others v.
Lala Ram & Others, CDJ 2016 DHC 865, the Delhi High Court has
made an endeavour to bring in uniformity in the compensation
granted in cases involving death of children. In the said case, it was
found that having regard to the fluctuating trends in consumer price
index, the cost inflation index determined and notified by the
Ministry of Finance in Government of India under S.48 of the Income
Tax Act, 1961, for each financial year would be a better method to
offset the effect of inflation on the real value of money. The view
expressed in the said case appears to be sound and can be accepted. A
table showing the cost inflation index notified by the Government of
India from time to time, the corresponding money value for
Rs.24,000/- applying the cost inflation index up to the year 2018-19
and the nearest thousand of the money value arrived at, is furnished
hereunder for ready reference:
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
SCHEDULE 2
COST
SL
NO
COST
FINANCIAL
INFLATIINFLATION
VALUE
ON NEW
YEAR
INDEX
INDEX
VALUE TO
NEAREST
THOUSAND
1995-96
24000
24000
1996-97
26.050
26,000
1997-98
28,270
28,000
1998-99
29,979
30,000
1999-00
33,224
33,000
2000-01
34,676
35,000
2001-02
36,384
36,000
2002-03
38,204
38,000
2003-04
39,659
40,000
2004-05
41,114
41,000
2005-06
42.570
43,000
2006-07
44,389
44,000
2007-08
46,936
47,000
2008-09
49,847
50,000
2009-10
53,849
54,000
2010-11
60,762
61,000
2011-12
66,947
67,000
2012-13
72,769
73,000
2013-14
80,046 80,000
2014-15
87,322
87,000
2015-16
92,416
92,000
2016-17
96,055
96,000
2017-18
98,965
99,000
2018-19
101,876
102,000
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
In other words, the notional income of children died after the financial
year 1995-96 can be determined applying the above table and I have no
doubt, the same would certainly provide uniformity in the awards.”
13. The primary reason given by this Court while rendering the
above judgment appears to be that while the tribunal or the court considers
the claim for compensation in respect of the death of a minor, at any rate,
the compensation should not go below the amount fixed under the Second
Schedule to Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act.
14. In Kajal Vs. Jagadish Chand and Others [2020 (4)
SCC 413], the Hon’ble Supreme Court considered the claim for
compensation in respect of a 100% disabled minor child wherein the Apex
Court held that while fixing the claim for compensation on account of
permanent disability, the minimum wages prevailing in the State has to be
applied.
15. In Master Ayush vs. The Branch Manager, Reliance
General Insurance Company Limited and Another [2022 (7) SCC
738], the same method was adopted by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. In
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
fact in Master Ayush (Supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court went one step
further from the decision of Kajal (Supra) and granted the compensation
for permanent disability by fixing the notional income in terms of the
minimum wages prevalent in the State.
16. In Meena Devi vs. Nunu Chand Mahto @ Nemchand
Mahto and Others [2023 (1) SCC 204], the Hon’ble Supreme Court dealt
with the claim for compensation in respect of the death of a minor and
found that the Apex Court itself had deviated from the Second Schedule to
the Motor Vehicles Act in Kishan Gopal vs. Lala and Others [2014 (1)
SCC 244] and fixed the notional at Rs.30,000/- per annum.
17. In Kusmi Devi vs. Md. Kasim and Another [2023 ACJ
1658] the Hon’ble Supreme Court applied the principles of global
compensation and granted an amount of Rs.6 Lakhs as a consolidated
amount towards compensation on account of the death of a minor.
18. The principle that could be deciphered from a reading of the
exposition of the law is that the Supreme Court had formed a clear cleavage
of opinion while fixing the compensation in respect of the death of a minor
and disability compensation to a minor. At one hand, the Hon’ble Supreme
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
Court adopted fixation of a consolidated amount as well as applied the
global compensation method, but, whereas, in the case of disability, it
applied the notional income. Therefore, it is quite natural that the courts
will be in a dilemma as to whether in case of a death, a global compensation
method must be adopted whereas, in the case of a disabled person, the
calculation of the compensation is done by adopting a multiplier system by
fixing the notional income.
19. Can it be said that a claim under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act on account of a death has to be ranked lower in pedestal than
that of a claim in respect of a 100% disabled person? By holding that in
cases of compensation on account of 100% disability of a minor child would
be ranked above that of a case of a death would certainly create two classes.
Such a differentiation is not permissible while entertaining a claim under
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act. The Parliament never intended to
create two classes of claimants while dealing with an application under
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act. Perhaps, this is a strong indication
as to the manner in which the court should proceed to deal with a claim
arising on account of the death of a minor child.
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
20.
2025:KER:4877
What will be the impact of the omission of the Second
Schedule to the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 with effect from 1.4.2022?
Normally, when the Parliament amends the provisions of any Statute it is
common to be accompanied by a repeal and saving clause. However, in this
case there is none. That means that the Second Schedule of the Motor
Vehicles Act is taken away from the Statute.
21. The impact of the said omission on the claim petitions which
are pending either before the tribunal or before this Court in appeal is also
required to be addressed. As stated earlier, when the Second Schedule itself
is omitted, this Court will have to presume that the Second Schedule was
never in the Statute and, therefore, such claim petitions or appeals arising
out of the claim petitions must be considered as though there is no Second
Schedule in the Statute. It must be noted that the omission will not have
any impact on the claim petitions preferred under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act. Suffice to say, while considering the claim petition filed under
Section 166, the tribunal is not fettered by any ceiling limit, especially in the
absence of a Second Schedule.
22.
The Second Schedule was necessitated because of the
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
provisions of Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act as it stood prior to the
amendment. Section 163A reads as follows:
Special Provisions as to Payment of Compensation on
a structured formula basis – (1) Notwithstanding anything
contained in this Act or in any other law for the time being in
force or instrument having the force of law, the owner of the
motor vehicle or the authorised insurer shall be liable to pay in
the case of death or permanent disablement due to accident
arising out of the use of motor vehicle, compensation, as
indicated in the Second Schedule, to the legal heirs or the
victim, as the case may be.
Explanation- For the purposes of this sub-section, “permanent
disability” shall have the same meaning and extent as in the
Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923.
(2) In any claim for compensation under sub-section (1), the
claimant shall not be required to plead or establish that the
death or permanent disablement in respect of which the claim
has been made was due to any wrongful act or neglect or default
of the owner of the vehicle or vehicles concerned or of any
other person.
(3) The Central Government may, keeping in view the cost of
living by notification in the Official Gazette, from time to time
amend the Second Schedule.”
23. It is pertinent to mention that the Second Schedule was later
amended by the parliament by raising the limit of compensation to
Rs.5 lakhs which was later omitted w.e.f 1.4.2022. But it must be noted that
with effect from 1.4.2022, the payment of compensation under Section
163A is replaced by Section 164 of the new Act which reads as under:
164. Payment of compensation in case of death or
grievous hurt, etc. - (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in this
Act or in any other law for the time being in force or instrument
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
having the force of law, the owner of the motor vehicle or the
authorised insurer shall be liable to pay in the case of death or
grievous hurt due to any accident arising out of the use of motor
vehicle, a compensation, of a sum of five lakh rupees in case of
death or of two and a half lakh rupees in case of grievous hurt to
the legal heirs or the victim, as the case may be.
(2) In any claim for compensation under sub-section (1), the
claimant shall not be required to plead or establish that the death
or grievous hurt in respect of which the claim has been made was
due to any wrongful act or neglect or default of the owner of the
vehicle or of the vehicle concerned or of any other person.
(3) Where, in respect of death or grievous hurt due to an accident
arising out of the use of motor vehicle, compensation has been
paid under any other law for the time being in force, such amount
of compensation shall be reduced from the amount of
compensation payable under this section.
24. It must be borne in mind that Section 164 has been brought
into the Statue with effect from 1.4.2022. If that be so, it cannot have any
retrospective operation. Still further, Section 166 and Section 164 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 as amended by Act 32 of 2019 intend to operate
on a different field altogether. Therefore, in the light of the aforesaid
provisions, this Court is of the considered opinion that Section 164 of the
new Act having come into effect from 1.4.2022 will apply to those
applications which are filed after 1.4.2022 and cannot govern the
consideration of the claim petitions which were filed prior to that.
25. Even otherwise the operation of the erstwhile Second Schedule or
the newly inserted provision under Section 164 of the Act cannot govern the
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
consideration of a claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 and the courts or tribunal need not confine itself to the ceiling
limit fixed under the aforementioned provisions.
26. On a close exploration of the various principles guiding the
interpretation of the Statute, it becomes inevitable to conclude that once
the Parliament decided to do away with the Second Schedule to the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, the court will have to proceed as though the said
schedule is not under the Statute and therefore the principles laid down by
this Court in Assainar (Supra) can no longer govern the field and
therefore, the change become inevitable.
27. Still further, the impact of omission to the Second Schedule of
the Motor Vehicles Act must be considered in the light of the well-known
principles of interpretation. As stated above, this Court could not find any
repeal and saving clause when the Parliament decided to omit the Second
Schedule of the Motor Vehicles Act. Under the common law rule, the
consequences of repeal of a Statute are very drastic. Except as to the
transactions past and closed, the Statute after its repeal is completely
obliterated as if it had never been enacted. The effect is to destroy all
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
inchoate rights and all causes of action that may have arisen under the
repealed Statute. Therefore, leaving aside the cases where proceedings
commenced, prosecuted, and brought to the finality before the repeal, no
proceeding under the repealed Statute can be commenced or continued
after the repeal. Another result of repeal under the common law rule is to
revive the law in force at the commencement of the repealed Statute. Thus,
if one Statute is repealed by a second, which, in turn is repealed by a third,
the effect is to revive the first Statute unless a contrary intention is
indicated in the third Statute. The confusion resulting from all these
consequences gave rise to the practice of inserting saving clauses in
repealing Statute. The practice of inserting a saving clause in a repealing
Statute is traceable to the general provisions made under Section 38(2) of
the Interpretation Act, 1889. A similar provision was made in India under
Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 and in corresponding State
legislation.
28. The result of the application of the principles of obliteration
associated with repeal is the continuation of the pending proceedings under
a repealed Statute. It will however depend upon the wording of the saving
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
clause contained in the repealing Act or under Section 6 of the General
Clauses Act. Therefore, the Parliament has the power to lay down the
conditions for continuation of the pending proceedings and to provide that
in cases those conditions are not satisfied the proceedings will terminate.
29. However, though Section 6 of the General Clauses Act applies to
all types of repeals whether expressed or implied, entire or partial or
whether it be repeal simpliciter or repeal accompanied by fresh legislation,
it has its own limitations. Can it be said that Section 6 will operate when the
provision is omitted from the Statute? Answer is “no”. It has been held by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rayala Corporation (P) Ltd & Another
vs. Director of Enforcement, Delhi [AIR 1970 SC 494] that Section 6
will apply only to repeals and not omissions. Therefore, this Court needs to
tread the path carefully while applying Section 6 of the General Clauses Act.
Under normal circumstances the omission of a provision results in
abrogation or obliteration of that provision in the same way as it happens
in a repeal.
30. In M/s General Finance Company & Another vs. Assistant
Commissioner of Income Tax, Punjab [AIR 2002 SC 3126] the
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
question arose before the Two Judge Bench of the Supreme Court as to the
effect of omission of Section 276-DD of the Income Tax Act, 1961 from
1.4.1989 on a prosecution pending for its violation. Following the earlier
Constitution Bench decisions, it was held by the Supreme Court that
neither the prosecution could be continued nor could the punishment be
imposed as Section 6 of the General Clauses Act was inapplicable to the
omissions. Therefore, it can be safely concluded that, in a case of omission,
the provisions of Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 will not apply.
31. Hence it is inevitable for this Court to conclude that once the
Second Schedule is omitted then the court and tribunal need not confine
itself to any particular limit while granting the compensation on account of
the death of a minor. However, having said so, what should be the way
forward. The only way the impasse could be resolved is by fixing the
notional income of the minor child for which this Court has to deviate from
the principles laid down in Assainar (Supra)
32.
Be that as it may, the more vexatious question as to what
should be next course of action? Should the matter require a reference
before a Larger Bench or can this Court proceed to consider the claim for
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
compensation by fixing the notional income. The answer would depend
upon how far the principles enunciated by the Supreme Court could be
applied here.
33. In Master Ayush (Supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court,
while considering a case of a minor lying in a paraplegic stage applied the
notional income by calculating it with reference to the notification issued
under the provisions of the Minimum Wages Act which was prevalent in
the State from which the claim arose. This gives a clear indication that the
application of the Second Schedule to the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 was
never accepted by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
34.
Pertinently, it must be noted that the income fixed in the
Second Schedule to the Motor Vehicles Act is Rs.15,000/- per annum.
However, this was felt highly inadequate and therefore, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court did not apply while considering the case in Kishan Gopal
(Supra) and applied Rs.30,000/- as the notional income per annum. The
decision in Kishan Gopal (Supra) has been referred to by this Court only
to indicate that the Hon’ble Supreme Court had always felt that the
notional income fixed in the Second Schedule of the Motor Vehicles Act,
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
1988 was inadequate. Be that as it may, now that the Second Schedule of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 stands omitted by the Parliament, it becomes
irrelevant insofar as the decision in these appeals are concerned.
35.
Now the crucial question would be what should be the
method to be followed while fixing the notional income in the case of a
death of a minor. The stand of the insurance company that the claim for
compensation for permanent disability and claim on account of death are
to be considered differently is deplorable. It is pointed out that in a case of
100% paraplegic child, the penury caused to the family will be more than
that in the case of death of a minor child. The tragic loss of a minor child in
a motor accident is an unspeakable sorrow that transcends beyond the
boundaries of monetary valuation. No amount of compensation can restore
the innocence lost or joy extinguished.
36. The expectations of the parents while upbringing a child with
a fervent hope that once he reaches the expected heights, the burden of the
family will be taken over by the child and the parents will be relieved. The
said hope can never be compensated by any monetary value. However,
having said so, the compensation can only be a step in aid to pacify the
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
sorrow that was caused to the family on account of the accident.
37. While fixing the compensation in respect of the death of a
minor child, the court will have to take into consideration the legal
obligation of a child under the prevalent law qua the maintenance of the
parents. While keeping in mind that the quantum of compensation to be
awarded is only once, the component of future dependency will have to
include the element of just and fair compensation. Although all children
may not live up to the expectations of the parents, both under the societal
norms and the law as it stands today, the court will have to recognize the
expectations of every parent, which imposes a legal obligation on the
children to maintain them.
38. Sri. A.R Nimod, the learned Amicus Curiae brought to the
notice of this Court the judgment rendered by a learned Single Bench of the
Delhi High Court in MAC. APP. No.242 of 2024 decided on 30.9.2024 in
the case title Royal Sundaram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs.
Zeenat Khan and Others. The issue that arose for consideration before
the Delhi High Court was how to calculate the notional income while
considering a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act. Referring
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
to the decision in Oriental Insurance Company vs. Reena Raghav
[2023 SCC Online Del. 6695], the learned judge proceeded to hold that the
notional income must be fixed adopting the minimum wages of a skilled
labourer. While arriving at a conclusion, the Delhi High Court relied on the
principles laid down by the Apex Court in Kajal (Supra) and applied the
same principles in the case of death also.
39. In United India Insurance Company limited Vs
Jamaluddin Khan and others [2023 SCC Online Delhi 5417], it
was held that the loss of dependency has to be calculated by applying the
multiplier system and while fixing the notional income of a minor child the
notification fixing the minimum wage of a skilled worker has to be applied.
40. The complexity of the application of the principles laid down
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kajal (Supra) and Master Ayush
(Supra) arises, since those cases were concerning the determination of
disability compensation payable to a minor child on account of 100%
permanent disability and were lying in a vegetative state. But it must be
noted that when an argument is raised that the principles laid down by the
Supreme Court in Kajal (Supra) and Master Ayush (Supra) cannot be
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
applied to the facts of the present case since the claim arises on account of
the death of a minor, this Court cannot remain oblivious of the fact that the
non-application of the principles would lead to a clear disparity and would
create two classes of claimants. In one class the victim would be lying in a
paraplegic stage and in the other, the claimants will be imbedded in
profound grief over the death of their child, but cannot claim parity in
compensation. Does the Statute namely, Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 create
different classes of person. We must remember when it is permissible for
the tribunal and courts to apply the multiplier system even if the claimant
is a minor, in case of permanent disability, but to hold that the multiplier
system cannot apply while considering the claim for compensation on
account of death of a minor defies logic and cannot find support of law. By
holding so, the court will create two classes of persons which the statute
never intended.
41. In various classes of persons, whether it is a skilled worker,
coolie worker, home maker or any person doing any specialized work, the
only difference would be the extent of application of the multiplicand.
Otherwise, there is a prescribed system to be followed for calculating the
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
compensation under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
Therefore, it is evident that the Parliament never intended to create two
classes of persons while dealing with an application under Section 166 of
the Motor Vehicles Act. It may be true that in a case of a minor, the
question of applying the extent of multiplicand will always under serious
doubt because the minor will be a non-earning person. It is at this point
where the intervention of the Courts is required.
42. In Angad Tiwari Vs National Insurance Company Ltd
(Civil Appeal 10950 of 2024 decided on 1-10-2024), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that in a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, the courts and tribunals shall not fix the monthly income of the
claimant below that of the minimum wage prescribed under the provisions
of the Minimum Wages Act.
43. However, the doubt will still linger in the minds of the Court
as to what should be the criteria being adopted in the case of the death of a
minor. Considering the prospects in education as well as the probable
income that a minor child may earn in future, it is quite natural that the
court will have its own difficulties in arriving at a particular figure which
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
would represent the notional income of the minor child. Since the Second
Schedule to the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, stands omitted and in the light of
ratio decendi culled out from the precedents cited across the bar, this Court
feels that the best way to resolve the impasse is to apply the multiplier
system while considering a claim under Section 166 on account of the death
of the minor child.
44. Thus, it becomes inevitable for this Court to conclude that the
notional income of the minor child must be fixed before proceeding with
the application of appropriate multiplier. In a given case, if the death of a
student had occurred, depending upon the educational qualification or the
course which was being pursued by him, the court could have arrived at a
reasonable conclusion. It is in this context that the decision of the Delhi
High Court in Zeenat Khan (Supra) assumes importance. In Reena
Raghav (Supra) which was followed by the Delhi High Court in Zeenath
Khan (Supra), the Court upheld the award of compensation and assessed
the income of the deceased by adopting the minimum wage of a skilled
labourer as notified in the State of Uttar Pradesh. Read along with the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Angad Tiwari(supra) , this
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
Court concludes that in a case of a death of a minor child, the application of
the table formulated by this Court in Assainar (Supra) cannot be applied
in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in Kajal (Supra), Master
Ayush (Supra) and Angad Tiwari (Supra). Therefore, it must be held
that while calculating the notional income of the deceased minor child in a
claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, the notification issued
by the State of Kerala in terms of the provisions contained in the Minimum
Wages Act in respect of a skilled worker must be applied. Therefore it is
ordered that the tribunal throughout the State shall apply the multiplier
system
by fixing the multiplicand in accordance with the notification
issued by the State of Kerala under the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 while
considering a claim petition under Section 166 of the Act on account of
death of a minor child.
45. Coming back to the facts of this case, in the light of the
reasoning given by this Court as above, it becomes inevitable that the
appeal preferred by the insurance company has to fail to the extent of
questioning the fixation of the notional income and except to the extent of
fixing 50% future prospects on the notional income. Hence M.A.C.A. No.45
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
of 2021 is partly allowed. The award of the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal, Kozhikode granting 50% of the notional income towards future
prospects is set aside and it is ordered that the claimants are entitled to get
only 40% of the income towards future prospects.
46. Coming to M.A.C.A. No.2000 of 2022, in the light of the
findings rendered by this Court as above, the award of the tribunal requires
modification. The award of the tribunal insofar as fixing the notional
income presumably in terms of the table fixed by this Court in Assainar
(Supra) is liable to be interfered with. Instead of the same, the notional
income must be fixed in terms of the notification issued by the Government
of Kerala under the provisions of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 as it
applies to a skilled worker.
47. In the present case, the accident occurred on 24.4.2018 and
at that point of time, G.O.(P) No.56/2017 dated 28.4.2017 issued by the
State of Kerala was in force. In accordance with the said notification, the
minimum wage fixed by the State of Kerala for a skilled worker is at
Rs.18,900/-. Therefore, the compensation towards loss of dependency has
to be reworked.
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
48. In the result, M.A.C.A. No.2000 of 2022 is allowed. It is
declared that the claimants are entitled to have the notional income of the
deceased Yasin Hydar A.P. fixed at Rs.18,900/-. While calculating 40% of
the notional income towards the future prospects, the amount would come
to Rs.26,460/-. Accordingly the appellants are entitled to get an amount of
Rs.23,81,400/- [26,460X12x15x1/2] towards loss of dependency. The
tribunal has already awarded an amount of Rs.16,20,000/- on that head
and hence the balance would come to Rs.7,61,400/-. Under the
conventional heads of loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral
expenses also, the claimants are entitled to 10% future prospects going by
the decision in National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay
Sethi and Others [2017 (16) SCC 680] and N.Jayasree and others v.
Cholamandalam, MS General Insurance Company Ltd. [(2022)
14 SCC 712]. Since the accident had occurred on April 2018 and the
appeal being the continuation of the proceedings of the original claim, the
future prospects have to be applied twice. Therefore, under the head loss of
estate and funeral expenses, an additional amount of Rs.3,000/- each is
granted. Coming to the head compensation towards pain and sufferings,
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
going by the decision of this Court in Oriental Insurance Company
Limited v. Martin Xavier [2024 KLT OnLine 2579] an amount of
Rs.15,000/- can be granted. However the tribunal has granted only
Rs.10,000/- and hence enhancement of Rs.5000+ future prospects is
granted and the amount thus arrived at Rs.18000/-. Similarly, under the
head loss of consortium also, the claimants are entitled for enhancement at
10% for two occasions and thus an additional amount of Rs.8000/- is
granted.
49.
In the result the appellants are entitled to get enhanced
compensation as follows:
Heads of claim
Enhanced
Amount
by awarded by the compensation
tribunal
16,20,000
7,61,400
Loss of dependency
Amount
awarded
this Court
23,81,400
Loss of estate
18000
15000
Loss of consortium
88000
80000
Pain and sufferings
18000
10000
Funeral expenses
18000
15000
Total
7,83,400
MACA NOS.45 OF 2021 &
MACA NO.2000 OF 2022
2025:KER:4877
Accordingly, the appellants are entitled to get an enhanced
compensation of Rs.7,83,400 /- (Rupees Seven Lakh eighty three thousand
four hundred only) with 8% interest per annum from the date of petition
till realization with proportionate cost. The insurance company shall
deposit the amount within a period of one month from the date of receipt of
a copy of this judgment.
Sd/-
EASWARAN S.,
JUDGE
NS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review