Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
$
$
!
!
!
!
##
%
& %
'
& %
'
()
##
(
)
Digitally signed
by SUMITRA
SHERIGAR
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!"
!
#
!
$
%
*
-2-
&
'
$(
'
)
!
*
+ ,", !-!
,
.
'
#
)
*
/ ,", !-!
. /$$
/ -"-
.
)
(
!0
$(
'
)
!0
,/
)
$
)
)
#
*
#
$-
!- "
$$& !- ,
*(
)
!&
!
#
!
-3-
$
%
-
'
"
$
'
)
!
*
.
.
'!
#
(
*
)
. /$$
/ -"-
!
)
$
)
#
&""
#
)
)
#
$$& !- ,
)
!1
,
$
)
$-
!- "
)
,- /
#
-4-
)
#
%!
)
3 !-!!&$ !- " 456
)
3 !---$
!- & 478
9:;86 <= >?8 :5@A787 456 >?8 B;4:C45>@ 78@D8B>:E8;=
B?4;;85F:5F >?8 GA45>AC 39 B3CD85@4>:35 456 ;:4<:;:>= >3
D4= >?8 B3CD85@4>:35 4H47686 <= >?8
66:>:354;
?4?4DA7
3 $$& !- ,
$-
>?8
:E:; A6F8
937 @?37> I 7:<A54;J
KA6FC85>
:5
4H476
64>86
!
B;4:C D8>:>:35 H4@ 9:;86 A5687
8B>:35
3>37
8?:B;8@
!- "
@ " -- --- /
68B84@86
E:68
85:37
<=
B>
&"" B;4:C:5F B3CD85@4>:35 39
>?8
;8F4;
78D78@85>4>:E8@
>?8
4@?4CC4 H?3 6:86 :5 4 7346 >7499:B 4BB:685>
- -' !- , H?85 @?8 H4@ >74E8;:5F :5 4
4A>3 <847:5F 78F:@>74>:35
3 . /$$
/ -"-
:4FF:3
D8
-5-
$
H?3
?8 B;4:C D8>:>:35 H4@ B35>8@>86 <= >?8 :5@A787
685:86
B3CD85@4>:35
>?8
4BB:685>
:>@
4@86 35 >?8 4<3E8
;:4<:;:>=
>?8
>3
D4=
7:<A54; ?8;6
D73B886:5F@ 456 78B37686 >?8 8E:685B8 39 B;4:C45>
4@
?8
#/
456 C47L86 63BAC85>@
M@
>3
3H587 39 >?8 399856:5F E8?:B;8 H4@ 8M4C:586 4@
C47L86 63BAC85>@ 4@ M@
'
>?8
>3
#
,
4@86 35 >?8 374; 456 63BAC85>47= 8E:685B8
7:<A54; ?8;6 >?4> >?8 4BB:685> H4@ 6A8 >3 >?8 74@?
456 58F;:F85> 67:E:5F <= >?8 67:E87 39 >?8 4A>3
?8;6 >?4> >?8 68B84@86
>?8789378
> 9A7>?87
4@?4CC4 H4@ 4 B33;:8 456
4DD;:86 53>:354; :5B3C8 456 68>87C:586 >?8
B3CD85@4>:35 4@ 93;;3H@
+
!
$
'
,
,-./
3@@ 39 3E8 456 4998B>:35
)336 456 53A7:@?C85>
74E8;:5F 8MD85@8@
3@@ 39 :5B3C8 6A7:5F
>784>C85> D87:36
>>85645> B?47F8@
0 123
@
-- --- /
@ - --- /
@ - --- /
@ --- /
@
--- /
-6-
86:B4; 8MD85@8@
)A5874; 8MD85@8@
3-+
,
?8
@ ! !,- /
@ $- --- /
" " 4 (
/
7:<A54; 6:78B>86 >?8 :5@A787 >3 D4= >?8
B3CD85@4>:35 4;35F H:>? :5>878@>
8:5F 4FF7:8E86 <= >?8
GA45>AC 39 B3CD85@4>:35 4H47686 <3>? >?8 B;4:C45>@ 4@
H8;; 4@ >?8 :5@A787 478 :5 >?8:7 78@D8B>:E8 4DD84;@
?8
B35>85686
>?4>
;847586
B3A5@8;
>?8
B;4:C45>@
8E85
>?3AF?
>?8=
?4E8
B;4:C86
B3CD85@4>:35 4@ 68D85685>@ 39 >?8 68B84@86
>?8
4@?4CC4
7:<A54; 94:;86 >3 F745> 45= B3CD85@4>:35 A5687 >?8
?846 I;3@@ 39 68D85685B=J 35 >?8 F73A56 >?4> >?8 68B84@86
H4@ 4F86 ,- =847@ 4@ 35 >?8 64>8 39 ?87 684>? 456
B;4:C45>
456 ! <8:5F @35 456 64AF?>87/:5/;4H 39 >?8
68B84@86 H878 53> 68D85685>@ 35 >?8 :5B3C8 39 >?8
68B84@86 937 >?8:7 ;:E8;:?336
B3CD85@4>:35 39
@!!
?8
7:<A54; 4H47686 >3>4;
!,- / A5687 E47:3A@ ?846@ <A>
6:6 53> 4H476 45= B3CD85@4>:35 A5687 >?8 ?846 I;3@@ 39
68D85685B=J 456 9A7>?87 @A<C:>>86 >?4> >?8
7:<A54; 94:;86
-7-
>3
4H476
468GA4>8
B3CD85@4>:35
A5687
>?8
3>?87
B35E85>:354; ?846@
;847586 B3A5@8; 937 >?8 :5@A787
B35>85686 >?4> >?8 B3CD85@4>:35 4H47686 <= >?8
7:<A54;
:@ 8MB8@@:E8 456 685:86 :>@ ;:4<:;:>= >3 D4= :> 4@ >?8
B;4:C45>@ 478 53> 68D85685>@ 39 >?8 68B84@86
"
5 D87A@4; 39 >?8 :CDAF586 KA6FC85> 456
4H476 D4@@86 <= >?8
7:<A54;
:> 4DD847@ >?4> >?8
68B84@86 H4@ 4F86 ,- =847@ 4@ 35 >?8 64>8 39 ?87 684>?
3H8E87
4@ @A<C:>>86 <= >?8 ;847586 B3A5@8; 937 >?8
B;4:C45>@ :> :@ A56:@DA>86 94B> >?4> >?8 68B84@86 H4@ 4
33;:8 4F7:BA;>A74;
;4<3A787
?85B8
B35>7:<A>86 937 >?8 H8;; <8:5F 39 >?8 94C:;=
B:7BAC@>45B8@ 4 53>:354; :5B3C8 39
:5>3 4BB3A5> 456
D73@D8B>@
<8
?4E8
5687 >?8
@ " --- / :@ >4L85
-1 39 :> :@ B35@>7A86 4@ ;3@@ 39 9A>A78
?A@ >?8 >3>4; :5B3C8 39 >?8 68B84@86 H3A;6
@ " "-- / D87 C35>?
>?45 '
H3A;6
'>? 39 ?87 :5B3C8
@ >?8 68D85685>@ 478 C378
@ ! !-- / @?3A;6 <8
-8-
686AB>86 >3H476@ ?87 D87@354; 8MD85@8@
85B8
>?8
C35>?;= :5B3C8 39 >?8 68B84@86 937 >?8 DA7D3@8 39
B4;BA;4>:5F
B3CD85@4>:35
A5687
>?8
-- /
5 E:8H 39 >?8 D7:5B:D;8
39 ;4H ;4:6 63H5 :5 >?8 B4@8 39
B35@:687:5F
68D85685B=J @?4;; <8
@
?846
I;3@@
>?8 4F8 39 >?8 68B84@86 >?8 CA;>:D;:87 4DD;:B4<;8 >3 >?8
B4@8 35 ?456 :@ I $J
85B8 >?8 B3CD85@4>:35 D4=4<;8
A5687 >?8 ?846 I;3@@ 39 68D85685B=J @?4;; <8
! M $ H?:B? 4C3A5>@ >3
&
@ - !&
%
B;4:C45>@
)A7>?87 :5 E:8H 39 ;4H ;4:6 63H5 <= >?8
&
"
D8M
! " #
&
' (
)
*
>?8
456 ! <8:5F >?8 @35 456 64AF?>87/:5/;4H
456 >?8 B;4:C45>@
68B84@86
-- / M
-- /
3A7> :5 >?8 B4@8 39
$
@
3 $ 456 ' <8:5F F7456B?:;6785 39 >?8
478 85>:>;86 >3 B3CD85@4>:35 39
@ '- --- /
84B? >3H476@ 9:;:4; B35@37>:AC 456 >?8789378 >?8 B;4:C45>@
478 85>:>;86 >3 >3>4; B3CD85@4>:35 39
>?8 ?846 I;3@@ 39 B35@37>:ACJ
85>:>;86 937 45 4C3A5> 39
@ ! -- --- / A5687
?8 B;4:C45>@ 478 4;@3
@ , --- / 84B? A5687 >?8
-9-
?846@ I;3@@ 39 8@>4>8J 456 I9A5874; 8MD85@8@J 4@ D87 >?8
68B:@:35 :5 >?8 B4@8 39 $
>?8
%
&
)A7>?87 :> :@ 937>?B3C:5F 973C >?8 78B376@ >?4>
68B84@86
@A998786
:5KA7:8@
@?8
>?8
3E875C85>
3@D:>4; 937 9:7@> 4:6 456 >?87849>87 @?8 >33L
- -' !- , >3
>3
4>@4;=4
' -' !- ,
3@D:>4;
>3
5:>86
@?:9>86
4BB:685>
- -' !- ,
9A7>?87 >784>C85> 4>
H4@
:5
?4?4DA74
.4;4<A74F:
973C
A<@8GA85>;= @?8 H4@ @?:9>86
:98
3@D:>4; .4;4<A74F: H?878:5 @?8 >33L
>784>C85> 973C
, -' !- , >3 !$ -' !- , 456 @?8 6:86 35
!' -' !- , 6A8 >3 >?8 :5KA7:8@ @A@>4:586 :5 >?8 4BB:685>
?8 B;4:C45>@ ?4E8 D736AB86
:@B?47F8
,
78@B7:D>:35@ 78F476:5F >?8
86:B4;
:;;@ 456 &'
4<
8D37>@
>784>C85> >4L85 <= >?8 68B84@86 :5 >?8 ?3@D:>4;@ 847;:87 >3
?87 684>?
7:<A54;
?8789378 >?8 B3CD85@4>:35 F745>86 <= >?8
A5687
I>74E8;:5F
>?8
8MD85@8@J
?846@
I9336
I4>>85645>
53A7:@?C85>J
B?47F8@J
IC86:B4;
8MD85@8@J 456 I9A5874; 8MD85@8@J 638@ 53> 78GA:78 45=
C36:9:B4>:35
- 10 -
BB376:5F;= >?8 B3CD85@4>:35 :@ 78/68>87C:586
4@ 93;;3H@
+
,-./
3@@ 39
!
$
'
,
"
8D85685B=
3@@ 39 9:;:4; B35@37>:AC
)336 456 53A7:@?C85>
74E8;:5F 8MD85@8@
>>85645> B?47F8@
86:B4; 8MD85@8@
3@@ 39 8@>4>8
)A5874; MD85@8@
3-+
!
0 123
@
- !&
-- /
@ ! -- --- /
@ - --- /
@ - --- /
@ --- /
@ ! !,- /
@ , --- /
@ , --- /
/
"5 " 4 (
> :@ 46C:>>86 94B> >?4> >?8 4DD8;;45> :5
)
3 !-!!&$ !- " :@ 45 :5@A787 39 >?8 399856:5F E8?:B;8 456
5@A745B8
3;:B= H4@ E4;:6 4@ 35 >?8 64>8 39 >?8 4BB:685>
3H8E87 :> ?4@ B;4:C86 >?4> >?8 D3;:B= B3E8786 35;= $
D4@@85F87@ <A> >?878 H878
, D4@@85F87@ >74E8;:5F :5 >?8
399856:5F E8?:B;8 4> >?8 >:C8 39 4BB:685> 456 >?8789378
>?878 H4@ E:3;4>:35 39 B356:>:35@ 39 >?8 D3;:B= 39 :5@A745B8
456 ?85B8 :> H4@ 53> ;:4<;8 >3 D4= 45= B3CD85@4>:35
- 11 -
$
3H8E87 :> :@ H8;; @8>>;86 >?4> :9 >?8 B;4:C45>@
478 >?:76 D47>:8@ >3 >?8 :5@A745B8 D3;:B= 8E85 :9 >?878 :@
E:3;4>:35 39 45= B356:>:35@ 39 D3;:B= >?8 :5@A787 :@ ;:4<;8 >3
D4= B3CD85@4>:35 H:>? ;:<87>= >3 78B3E87 >?8 @4C8 973C
>?8 :5@A786 3H587 39 >?8 E8?:B;8
?8789378 >?8 :5@A787
?4@ 94:;86 >3 C4L8 3A> 45= F73A56 >3 @8> 4@:68 >?8
:CDAF586 KA6FC85> 456 4H476 39 >?8
7:<A54; :5 :>@
85>:78>= 4@ @3AF?> 937 :5 >?8:7 4DD84;
'
5 >?8 78@A;> H8 478 39 >?8 B35@:68786 E:8H >?4>
>?8 4DD84;@ 9:;86 <= >?8 B;4:C45>@ 456 :5@A787 68@87E8 >3
<8 4;;3H86 :5 D47> 456 >?8789378 H8 D73B886 >3 D4@@ >?8
93;;3H:5F
:
3>? >?8 4DD84;@ 478
::
?8 :CDAF586 KA6FC85> 456 4H476 64>86
$-
+ "
!- " D4@@86 <= >?8
A6F8 456
66:>:354;
4>
3 $$& !- , :@ C36:9:86
,
85:37
:E:;
?4?4DA7 :5
- 12 -
:::
?8
B3CD85@4>:35
4H47686
7:<A54; :@ 85?45B86 973C
>3 4 @AC 39
:E
<=
@!!
>?8
!,- /
@ $ '" ",- /
?8 @4:6 4C3A5> :@ D4=4<;8 <= >?8 :5@A787
4;35F H:>? :5>878@> 4> >?8 74>8 39
1 D87
455AC 973C >?8 64>8 39 B;4:C D8>:>:35 >:;;
>?8 64>8 39 68D3@:>
E
?8 :5@A787 :@ 6:78B>86 >3 68D3@:> >?8
85?45B86
B3CD85@4>:35
<89378
>?8
7:<A54; H:>?:5 4 D87:36 39 $- 64=@ 973C
>?8
64>8
78B8:D>
B3D=
>?:@
KA6FC85> 94:;:5F H?:B? >?8 :5@A787 @?4;;
D4= :5>878@> 4> >?8 74>8 39 &1 D87 455AC
456 78B3E87 >?8 8MB8@@ :5>878@> 973C >?8
D87@35
78@D35@:<;8
>?8
68;4=
:5
68D3@:>:5F >?8 4C3A5>
E:
?8 :5@A787 :@ 85>:>;86 >3 78B3E87 >?8
B3CD85@4>:35
4C3A5>
973C
>?8
- 13 -
:5@A786 3H587 39 >?8 E8?:B;8 :5 >?8 @4C8
D73B886:5F@
E::
?878 @?4;; 53 37687 4@ >3 B3@>@
E:::
?8 4H476 @?4;; <8 674H5 4BB376:5F;=
.(
&
!'
!
.(
&
:@>
;
!
!
%
'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review