Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
S.B. : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. K. AGNIHOTRI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC. App. No.15 of 2015
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
United India Insurance Company
Limited,
Registered Office at,
Office No.7, GF, 150 BBC
Complex,
Kilokri Ring Road, Opposite
Maharani Bagh,
New Delhi-110014.
Versus
Respondents
:
1.
Mr. Jit Man Rai,
Son of Late Lak Man Rai,
Aged about 53 years,
2.
Mrs. Bimla Rai,
Wife of Mr. Jit Man Rai,
Aged about 44 years,
Both are residents of
Sudunglakha,
Rhenock P.O. & P.S. Rhenock,
East Sikkim.
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor
Vehicle Act, 1988.
--------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Thupden G. Bhutia, Advocate for the
Appellant.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Mr. J. K.
Kharka and Ms. Malati Sharma, Advocates for
the Respondents.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
JUDGMENT
(27th June 2016)
S. K. Agnihotri. J
1.
The present appeal, under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicle’s Act, 1988 (for short “MVA”), is directed
against the judgment and order dated 27th February,
2015 rendered by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (for
short “MACT”) East Sikkim, Gangtok.
2.
The indisputable facts leading to filing of the
instant appeal are that one Mr. yogesh Rai, aged about
25 years, working in the Indian Air Force as a Airman,
while driving a Motor Cycle bearing registration No.DL3SCA-8971, owned by him, met with an accident on
01.06.2014.
It is stated that one Sishir Rai was also
riding pillion, when the accident took place at Mandi
House, Gole Chakker, New Delhi at about 4.30 pm. Mr.
Yogesh Rai, sustained head injuries and succumbed to it,
later in the day.
3.
The
claimants
(the
respondents
herein,)
parents of the deceased, filed a claim petition under
Section 166 of MVA, seeking compensation to the tune of
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
Rs.60,99,444/- (Rupees sixty lakhs ninety nine thousand,
four hundred forty four) only.
4.
The Learned Member, MACT, East Sikkim at
Gangtok, by the impugned award determined the total
compensation to the tune of Rs.45,33,958/- (Rupees
forty five lakhs thirty three thousand nine hundred fifty
eight) only. However, having regard to the contributory
negligence of the deceased, the above amount was
slashed
to
the
extent
of
50%
which
Rs.22,66,979/- (Rupees twenty two
comes
to
lakhs sixty six
thousand nine hundred seventy nine) only and it was
directed to be paid, accordingly.
5.
Feeling
aggrieved,
Company has come
the
appellant/Insurance
up with the instant appeal, on the
grounds, inter-alia, that the claim of the petitioner cannot
be more than the liability of the Insurance Company as
limited to the extent of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh),
specifically provided in the policy itself.
6.
Mr.
Thupden
G.
Bhutia,
Learned
Counsel
appearing for the Appellant/Insurance Company would
contend that deceased was insured/owner of the vehicle
and as such the claimants, being legal heirs, are not
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
entitled to any claim under provisions of Section 165 of
MVA. Thus, the awarded compensation deserves to be set
aside. It is further urged, that the accident had taken
place on account of negligence of the driver of the vehicle
and as such his legal heirs are not entitled to any relief
under provisions of Section 166 of MVA. The principle of
multiplier on the basis of the age of deceased was
wrongly applied, when legal heirs are the parents of the
deceased. The deceased was a bachelor and the age of
the deceased’s mother is 42 years and as such on the
basis of the age of the parents only, multiplier can be
applied. The Learned Counsel would further contend that
the insurer is liable to indemnify the insured in respect of
a third party. In the case on hand, the insured himself
was the owner and driving the Motor Cycle. It is also
contended that the ratio laid down in National Insurance
Company Limited vs. Balakrishnan and Another1 is
applicable in case of gratuitous occupant of the vehicle in
case of “comprehensive/package policy”.
The deceased
cannot be held an occupant of the vehicle. The policy
provided for personal accident cover (PAC), on the basis
of payment of premium, fixing the liability to a sum of
1. (2013) 1 SCC 731
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
Rs.1,00,000/-
(Rupees
one
lakh)
only,
as
above
submitted.
7.
Opposing the submission of the appellant, Mr.
N. Rai, Learned Senior Counsel, appearing for the
respondents/claimants would contend, in support of the
impugned
award,
submitting
that
the
policy
being
package policy, the driver is equally entitled to the
compensation as awarded by the Tribunal. Referring to a
decision of the Supreme Court in Ningamma & Anr. Vs.
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. , and a decision of this
Court in The Branch Manager, New India Assurance
Company Ltd., Gangtok Vs. Smt. Jasu Subba & Ors.3, Mr.
Rai, would further contend that in case of package policy,
taken by the deceased, who is the owner of the vehicle
irrespective of the limited liability as provided in the
policy, the insurance company is liable to pay the full
compensation as determined by MACT. It is lastly urged
by him that the compensation awarded by the MACT is
just and proper. The appeal deserves to be dismissed,
accordingly.
2. AIR 2009 SC 3056
3. AIR 2011 SIKKIM 37
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
8.
I have given my anxious consideration to the
submissions
advanced
by
the
Learned
Counsels,
appearing for the parties, perused pleadings, impugned
award and also documents, appended thereto.
9.
There is no dispute on the facts of the case as
the accident of Late Yogesh Rai, son of the respondents
claimants, driving a Motor Cycle, owned by him, met with
an accident and he succumbed to injuries sustained
thereon, on the same day i.e., 01.06.2014 at Mandi
House, Gole Chakker, New Delhi.
10.
The Learned Member, MACT, East Sikkim, at
Gangtok, relying on a decision of the Supreme Court in
Balakrishnan’s case1 (supra) came to the conclusion that
the policy, being a package policy, covers the deceased
owner-cum-driver
and
as
such
calculating
the
compensation under several headings, loss of earnings,
funeral expenses, loss of estate, loss of love affection and
future prospects, etc. determined the awarded amount.
Further holding that there was a contributory negligence
on the part of the deceased, referring to a decision of this
Court in Branch Manager, National Insurance Company
Limited vs. Master Suraj Subba and Another, 2013(4)
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
TAC 32 (Sikkim), awarded 50% of the total determined
compensation hereinabove to the tune of Rs.22,66,979/(Rupees twenty two lakhs, sixty six thousand nine
hundred and seventy nine) only.
11.
In the aforestated factual matrix, it is apt as
this stage to refer to certain judicial pronouncements, laid
down by the Supreme Court.
12.
In Dhanraj vs. New India Assurance Co. Ltd.
and Anr.4,
cited
by
the
Learned Counsel for the
Appellant/Insurance Company, the appellant along with
some other persons travelling in his own jeep, met with
an accident wherein the appellant as well as the other
passenger received injuries, examining the scope of
Section 147 of the MVA, 1988 it was held as under:“8. Thus, an insurance policy covers
the liability incurred by the insured in
respect of death of or bodily injury to any
person (including an owner of the goods or
his authorised representative) carried in
the vehicle or damage to any property of a
third party caused by or arising out of the
use of the vehicle. Section 147 does not
require an insurance company to assume
risk for death or bodily injury to the owner
of the vehicle.
9. In the case of Oriental Insurance
Co. Ltd. V. Sunita Rathi it has been held
that the liability of an insurance company is
only for the purpose of indemnifying the
insured against liabilities incurred towards
a third person or in respect of damages to
4. (2004) 8 SCC 553
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
property. Thus, where the insured i.e. an
owner of the vehicle has no liability to a
third party the insurance company has no
liability also.”
13.
In yet another case, Oriental Insurance Co.
Ltd. vs. Meena Variyal and others5 wherein a Regional
Manager in a Company was provided with a car by the
employer. The said vehicle driven by him met with an
accident resulting into death of the Regional Manager.
The widow and daughter of the Manager filed a claim
petition under Section 166 of the Act, against the
employer
and
also
against
the
appellant/Insurance
Company, the Supreme Court held as under:“12. Chapter XI of the Act bears a
heading, “Insurance of Motor Vehicles
against third-party risks”. The definition of
“third party” is an inclusive one since
Section 145(g) only indicates that “third
party” includes the Government. It is
Section 146 that makes it obligatory for an
insurance to be take out before a motor
vehicle could be used on the road. The
heading of that section itself is “Necessity
for insurance against third-party risk”. No
doubt, the marginal heading may not be
conclusive. It is Section 147 that sets out
the requirement of policies and limits of
liability. It is provided therein that in order
to comply with the requirements of Chapter
XI of the Act, a policy of insurance must be
a policy which is issued by an authorised
insurer; or which insures the person or
classes of persons specified in the policy to
the extent specified in sub-section (2)
against any liability which may be incurred
by the owner in respect of the death of or
bodily injury or damage to any property of
a third party caused by or arising out of the
use of the vehicle in a public place. With
5. (2007) 5 SCC 428
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
effect from 14-11-1994, injury to the
owner of goods or his authorised
representative carried in the vehicle was
also added. The policy had to cover death
of or bodily injury to any passenger of a
public service vehicle caused by or arising
out of the use of the vehicle in a public
place. Then, as per the proviso, the policy
shall not be required to cover liability in
respect of the death, arising out of and in
the course of his employment, of the
employee of a person insured by the policy
or in respect of bodily injury sustained by
such an employee arising out of and in the
course of his employment, other than a
liability arising
under the Workmen’s
Compensation Act, 1923 in respect of the
death of, or bodily injury to, an employee
engaged in driving the vehicle, or who is a
conductor, if it is a public service vehicle or
an employee being carried in a goods
vehicle or to cover any contractual liability.
Sub-section (2) only sets down the limits of
the policy.”
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
22. In New India Assurance Co. Ltd.
v. Rula this Court postulated that the
contract of insurance in respect of motor
vehicles has to be construed in the light of
Sections 146(1), 147(5) and 149(1) of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The manifest
object of Section 146(1), which contains a
prohibition on the use of motor vehicles
without an insurance policy having been
taken in accordance with Chapter XI of the
Act is to ensure that the third party, who
suffers injuries due to the use of the motor
vehicle, may be able to get damages from
the owner of the vehicle and recoverability
of the damages may not depend on the
financial condition or solvency of the driver
of the vehicle who had caused the injuries.
Thus, any contract of insurance
under
Chapter XI of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
contemplates a third party who is not a
signatory or a party to the contract of
insurance but is, nevertheless, protected by
such contract. That this was the object was
reiterated in New India Assurance Co. v.
Kamla wherein it was stated that the raison
d’etre for the legislature making it
prohibitory for motor vehicles being used in
public places without covering third-party
risks by policy or insurance is to protect the
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
members of the community who become
sufferers on account of accidents arising
from the use of motor vehicles. The object
of Chapter XI has thus always been
recognized as one intended to protect third
parties as understood in the context of the
Act unless of course there is a special
contract in respect of protection to others.”
14.
In other case Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. vs.
Jhuma Saha (SMT) And Others6, wherein the deceased
was the owner of an insured vehicle, Maruti van, while
driving the vehicle, he dashed it with a tree, causing
injuries and later he succumbed thereto. The question as
to whether under provisions of Section 147(1)(b) & 166
of the MVA, 1988 the jurisdiction of the Tribunal is
confined to a third-party only, the Supreme Court held as
under:“10. The deceased was the owner of
the vehicle. For the reasons stated in the
claim petition or otherwise, he himself was
to be blamed for the accident. The accident
did not involve motor vehicle other than
the one which he was driving. The question
which arises for consideration is that the
deceased himself being negligent, the claim
petition under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 would be maintainable.
11. Liability of the insurer Company
is to the extent of indemnification of the
insured against the respondent or an
injured person, a third person or in respect
of damages of property. Thus, if the
insured cannot be fastened with any
liability under the provisions of the Motor
Vehicles Act, the question of the insurer
being liable to indemnify the insured,
therefore, does not arise.
6. (2007) 9 SCC 263
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
xxxxxxxxxxxxx
13. The additional premium was not
paid in respect of the entire risk of death or
bodily injury of the owner of the vehicle. If
that be so, Section 147(b) of the Motor
Vehicles Act which in no uncertain terms
covers a risk of a third party only would be
attracted in the present case”.
15.
In Oriental Insurance Company Limited vs.
Rajni Devi and Others,7 the identical issue came up for
consideration, wherein, it was held as under:“7. It is now a well-settled principle
of law that in a case where third party is
involved, the liability of the insurance
company would be unlimited. Where,
however, compensation is claimed for the
death of the owner or another passenger of
the vehicle, the contract of insurance being
governed by the contract qua contract, the
claim of the insurance company would
depend upon the terms thereof. The
Tribunal, in our opinion, therefore, was not
correct in taking the view that while
determining the amount of compensation,
the only factor which would be relevant
would be merely the use of motor vehicle.”
16.
Recently
in
National
Insurance
Company
Limited vs. Balakrishnan1 (supra), the supreme Court
had an occasion to examine the difference between “Act
policy” and ”comprehensive/package policy”, wherein a
7. (2008) 5 SCC 736
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
respondent/claimant being the Managing Director of the
Respondent/Company
met
with
an
accident
while
travelling in a Motor vehicle belonging to a Company. It
was
contended
before
the
Supreme
Court
by
the
appellant insurer that even assuming respondent not to
be the owner and a non-fare paying passenger, he would
not be covered under the policy, wherein the Supreme
Court held that the owner of the insured vehicle is not
entitled to compensation under provisions of Section 147
of MVA. The Supreme Court held as under:“24. It is extremely important to
note here that till 31-12-2006 the Tariff
Advisory Committee and, thereafter, from
1-1.2007 IRDA functioned as the statutory
regulatory authorities and they are entitled
to fix the tariff as well as the terms and
conditions of the policies issued by all
insurance companies. The High Court had
issued notice to the Tariff Advisory
Committee and IRDA to explain the factual
position as regards the liability of the
insurance companies in respect of an
occupant in a private car under the
“comprehensive/package policy”. Before
the High Court, the competent authority of
IRDA had stated that on 2-6-1986, the
Tariff Advisory Committee had issued
instructions to all the insurance companies
to
cover
the
pillion
rider
of
a
scooter/motorcycle
under
the
“comprehensive policy” and the said
position continues to be in vogue till date.
It
had
also
admitted
that
the
“comprehensive policy” is presently called a
“package policy”. It is the admitted
position, as the decision would show, the
earlier Circulars dated 18-3-1978 and 2-61986 continue to be valid and effective and
all insurance companies are bound to pay
the compensation in respect of the liability
towards an occupant in a car under the
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
“comprehensive/package
policy”
irrespective of the terms and conditions
contained in the policy. The competent
authority of the IRDA was also examined
before the High Court who stated that the
Circulars dated 18-3-1978 and 2-6-1986 of
the Tariff Advisory Committee were
incorporated in the Indian Motor Tariff
effective from 1-7-2002 and they continue
to be operative and binding on the
insurance companies. Because of the
aforesaid factual position, the Circulars
dated 16-11-2009 and 3-12-2009, that
have been reproduced hereinabove, were
issued.
(Emphasis Supplied)
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
26. in view of the aforesaid factual
position, there is no scintilla of doubt that a
“comprehensive/package
policy”
would
cover the liability of the insurer for
payment of compensation for the occupant
in a car. There is no cavil that an “Act
policy” stands on a different footing from a
“Comprehensive/package policy”. As a
circulars have made the position very clear
and IRDA, which is presently the statutory
authority, has commanded the insurance
companies
stating
that
a
“comprehensive/package policy” covers the
liability, there cannot be any dispute in that
regard. We may hasten to clarify that the
earlier pronouncements were rendered in
respect of the “Act policy” which admittedly
cannot cover a third-party risk of an
occupant in a car. But, if the policy is a
“comprehensive/package
policy”,
the
liability would be covered. These aspects
were not noticed in Bhagyalakshmi and,
therefore, the matter was referred to a
larger Bench. We are disposed to think that
there is no necessity to refer the present
matter to a larger Bench as IRDA, which is
presently the statutory authority, has
clarified the position by issuing circulars
which have been reproduced in the
judgment by the Delhi High Court and we
have also reproduced the same.”
17.
Mr. Rai, had further referred to a decision of
this Court in Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha vs. The
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company
Limited (MAC App. No. 24 of 2014) rendered on 28
April, 2016
th
wherein the Single Judge held that a
comprehensive package policy covers the occupants of a
private car, holding as under:“15. From the discussions and
decisions referred to above, it is clear that
Section 147 of the Act covers only a third
party and does not extend to the owner of
the vehicle. Further, if the owner has
covered himself from such risks the insured
would be bound to reimburse the owner
strictly in terms thereof. “
18.
The provisions of Section 146 obligates the
owner of the Motor vehicle to take insurance for use of
the vehicle on the road. Section 147 of MVA requires an
insurance company to cover the liability incurred by the
insured in respect of death of or bodily injury to any
person (including an owner of the goods or his authorised
representative) carried in the vehicle or any property,
caused by the use of the vehicle. The purpose of the
policy is to indemnify the insured against liabilities
incurred towards other persons (a third party) in respect
of the damages caused to him and the property. The
Supreme Court held in Dhanraj4 (supra) that insurance
policy covers the liability incurred by the owner of the
vehicle to the third party, not to the death or bodily
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
injury to the owner of the vehicle. In the case on hand,
the owner knowing fully well, has taken personal accident
cover (PAC) by making a premium of Rs.50/- (Rupees
fifty)
annually.
The
accident
led
to
death
of
the
owner/insured in the policy. The policy which is a
comprehensive/package
policy,
there
accident
was
personal
clearly
indicates
cover
that
limited
to
Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh), it reads as under:SCHEDULE OF PREMIUM
OWN DAMAGE
A:OD-BASIC
1,093.47
B:T.P-BASIC
LIABILITY
355.00
“Compulsory PA to
owner-Driver
Amount 100000
GROSS (A): Rs.1,093.00
GROSS (B)
Stamp Duty :
Gross OD & TP
(A) + (B)
50.00
: Rs.
405.00
1.00
: Rs.1,498.00
PREMIUM IN WORDS: RUPEES ONE THOUSAND FOUR HUNDRED
NINETY EIGHT ONLY.
19.
In Balakrishnan & Anr1 (Supra), the issue
involved was as to whether insurance company is liable in
respect of an occupant in a private car under the
“comprehensive/package policy”, wherein the Supreme
Court, referring to the instructions of the Tariff Advisory
Committee, issued to all the insurance companies, to
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
cover the pillion rider of a scooter/motorcycle under the
“comprehensive/package
policy”,
held
“comprehensive/package
policy”,
all
that
the
under
occupants
namely, pillion driver of a scooter/motorcycle and/or an
occupant of car, being a gratuitous passenger or a nonfare occupant are covered under the policy.
In the case
on hand, the deceased was the owner of the motor
vehicle and pillion rider did not claim any damages or
compensation against the insured . The compensation is
claimed by the parents of the deceased/insured, who is
the owner of the vehicle. In such a scenario, the ratio laid
down in Balakrishnan’s1 (supra) may not be applicable
to the fact of the case.
In Smt. Jasu Subba & Ors.3 (supra), Learned
Single
Judge
examined
the
case
on
the
basis
of
submissions made by the parties, therein. Thus, I am not
in respectful agreement with the same.
20.
In
Black’s
Law
Dictionary
(Tenth
Edition)
defines “Insurance” as under:“insurance. (17c) 1. A contract by which one
party (the insurer) undertakes to indemnify
another party (the insured) against risk of
loss, damage, or liability arising from the
occurence of some specified contingency.
An insured party usu. pays a premium to the
insurer in exchange for the insurer’s
assumption of the insured’s risk. Although
indemnification provisions are most common
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
in insurance policies, parties to any type of
contract may agree on indemnification
arrangements. 2. The amount for which
someone or something is covered by such an
agreement. – insure, vb.
“Insurance, or as it is sometimes called,
assurance, is a contract by which one party,
for a consideration, which is usually paid in
money either in one sum or at different times
during the continuance of the risk , promises
to make a certain payment of money upon
the destruction or injury of something in
which the other party has an interest. In fire
insurance and in marine insurance the thing
insured is property; in life or accident
insurance it is the life or health of the
person”. 1 George J. Couch, Couch on
Insurance 1.2, at 4-5 (2d ed. 1984)”.
21.
As
defined
herein
above,
the
insurance
company/insurer indemnifies the insured against risk of
loss, damage or liability arising from the occurrence of
some specified contingency. The insured is indemnified
against claims made by a third party, which suffers
damage, injuries or loss on account of the running of the
said motor cycle under the policy. The owner, under PAC
is indemnified to the extent of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one
lakh) as specified in the policy. The Learned Counsel
appearing for the Appellant/insurance company has fairly
submitted to this extent.
22.
The Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
respondents/claimants would refer to a decision of the
High Court of Judicature at Madras in The National
Insurance Co. Ltd., vs. Krishnan & Anr., wherein the
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
Learned
Single
Judge
had
defined
the
“just
compensation” in respect of the amount of Rs.3 lakhs
awarded with interest @ 7.5% per annum, from the date
of claim. In Ningamma & Anr.2 (supra), the Supreme
Court
considered
scope
of
“just
compensation”
as
contemplated under Section 166 of MVA, which is of no
assistance to the facts of the case.
23.
“Just compensation” is not an absolute term, it
cannot be
defined in
compensation”
is
an abstract form. The “just
determinable
in
the
facts
and
circumstances of the case depending on the nature of
policy and injuries caused thereto. It cannot be made
applicable without examining nature of the policy and
other incidental relevant factors.
24.
As a sequel, this Court is of considered view
that the MACT has committed an error in awarding the
compensation to the tune of Rs.22,66,979/- (Rupees
twenty two lakhs sixty six thousand nine hundred and
seventy nine), relying on the ratio laid down by the
Supreme
Court
in
Balakrishnan’s
Accordingly, the award is set aside.
case1
(supra).
2016:SHC:85
MAC App.No.15 of 2015
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Jit Man Rai & Anr.
25.
However, it is ordered that the respondents
shall be entitled to a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one
lakh) under personal accident cover (PAC), payable
forthwith.
26.
Resultantly, the appeal is allowed. No order as
to costs.
( S.K. Agnihotri )
Judge
27-06-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
to
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review