Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
MAC App. No. 01 of 2019
BRANCH MANAGER,
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD.
APPELLANT
VERSUS
BISHNU MAYA MUKHIA & ORS.
RESPONDENTS
Date: 28.02.2020
CORAM:
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
For Appellant
For Respondents
R-1 to R-4
Mr. Pema Ongchu Bhutia, Advocate.
Ms. Tashi Doma Bhutia, Advocate.
Ms. Pritima Sunam, Advocate.
R-5
None.
R-6
None.
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
1.
The instant Appeal assails the Judgment of the learned
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Sikkim at Gyalshing in MACT Case
No.06 of 2018 (Smt. Bishnu Maya Mukhia and Others v. Shri Bikram
Tamang and Others), dated 30.10.2018, on two counts viz. the income
of the deceased which has been calculated by the learned Tribunal as
Rs.320/- (Rupees three hundred and twenty) only, per day, instead of
Rs.242/- (Rupees two hundred and forty two) only, per day, as the
amount that the deceased was allegedly earning at the time of the
accident. Inclusion of Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees two lakhs) only, in the
compensation granted on account of “loss of love and affection” is also
impugned.
2.
The facts in the case are not in dispute and therefore are
not being reiterated herein, suffice it to state that the vehicle in which
the deceased, the husband of the Respondent No.1 and father of
Respondents No.2 to 4, was travelling met with an accident on
Page 1
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
20.04.2016 at “Tafel Bhir,” Rinchenpong, West Sikkim wherein he
succumbed to his injuries at the place of accident. The learned Tribunal
after considering the entire evidence on record granted compensation of
Rs.15,23,800/- (Rupees fifteen lakhs, twenty three thousand and eight
hundred) only, to the Respondents No.1 to 4.
3.
Assailing the quantum calculated on the loss of income of
the deceased learned Counsel for the Appellant submitted that the
income of the deceased ought to have been computed by the learned
Tribunal as Rs.242/- (Rupees two hundred and forty two) only, per day,
instead of Rs.320/- (Rupees three hundred and twenty) only, per day.
That, prior to the accident which took place on 20.04.2016, the
Government rates for semi-skilled workers was Rs.242/- (Rupees two
hundred and forty two) only, per day. Vide Notification bearing
No.11/DL
dated
15.09.2017
issued
by
the
Labour
Department,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok the daily wages for semi-skilled
workers was raised to Rs.320/- (Rupees three hundred and twenty)
only, per day. The accident having occurred on 20.04.2016, the daily
wage of the deceased ought not to have been calculated on the revised
rates reflected supra.
4.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.1 to 4 did not
seriously contest the contention of learned Counsel for the Appellant
pertaining to loss of income of the deceased or inclusion of loss of love
and affection in the quantum of the Award. However, it is submitted
that no computation towards Future Prospects on grounds that the
deceased was self-employed has been taken into consideration by the
learned Tribunal as ruled in the decision of National Insurance Company
Limited vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors.1. Learned Counsel also submits that loss of
Parental consortium in terms of Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs.
Nanu Ram and Ors.2 has not been calculated by the learned Tribunal.
5.
In rebuttal, learned Counsel for the Appellant urged that the
issue of Future Prospects and Parental consortium have not been raised
AIR 2017 SC 5157
MANU/SC/1012/2018
Page 2
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
by a Cross Objection by the Respondents No.1 to 4 and cannot be
agitated before this Court without written averments.
6.
I have heard and considered the rival submissions of
learned Counsel for the parties. I have also perused the impugned
Judgment including the documents and evidence on record.
7.
The income of the deceased ought to have been calculated
as Rs.242/- (Rupees two hundred and forty two) only, per day, instead
of Rs.320/- (Rupees three hundred and twenty) only, in terms of
Notification bearing No.11/DL dated 15.09.2017 of the Department of
Labour, Government of Sikkim considering that the accident took place
on 20.04.2016 and the said Notification came to be issued subsequently
and thus cannot be applied retrospectively.
8.
While addressing the issue flagged by learned Counsel for
the Respondents No.1 to 4 that Future Prospects and Parental
consortium was not granted by the learned Tribunal, although it has
vehemently been objected to by learned Counsel for the Appellant, in
Raj Rani and Ors. vs. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. and Ors. 3, it was held as
follows;
“13. …… It is not necessary in a proceeding
under the Motor Vehicles Act to go by any rules of
pleadings or evidence. Section 168 of the Act speaks
about grant of just compensation. The Court‟s duty
being to award just compensation, it will try to arrive
at the said finding irrespective of the fact as to
whether any plea in that behalf was raised by the
claimant or not.”
This observation soundly quells the aforementioned argument raised by
learned Counsel for the Appellant.
9.
So far as the question of Future Prospects is concerned in
Pranay Sethi (supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under;
“61. ...
(iii) While determining the income, an addition of
50% of actual salary to the income of the deceased
towards future prospects, where the deceased had a
permanent job and was below the age of 40 years,
should be made. The addition should be 30%, if the
age of the deceased was between 40 to 50 years. In
(2009) 13 SCC 654
Page 3
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
case the deceased was between the age of 50 to 60
years, the addition should be 15%. Actual salary
should be read as actual salary less tax.
(iv) In case the deceased was self-employed or
on a fixed salary, an addition of 40% of the
established income should be the warrant
where the deceased was below the age of 40
years. An addition of 25% where the deceased was
between the age of 40 to 50 years and 10% where
the deceased was between the age of 50 to 60 years
should be regarded as the necessary method of
computation. The established income means the
income minus the tax component.”
(Emphasis supplied)
On the touchstone of the ratio supra it is evident that an addition of
40% of the established income of the deceased, aged about 35 years
and self-employed should be added towards future prospects.
10.
On the question of “consortium” the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. (supra) while allowing consortium
not only to the spouse but also to the children and parents of the
deceased held as follows;
“8.7 A Constitution Bench of this Court in
Pranay Sethi (supra) dealt with the various heads
under which compensation is to be awarded in a
death case. One of these heads is Loss of
Consortium.
In
legal
parlance,
"consortium"
is
a
compendious term which encompasses 'spousal
consortium', 'parental consortium', and 'filial
consortium'.
The right to consortium would include the
company, care, help, comfort, guidance, solace and
affection of the deceased, which is a loss to his
family. With respect to a spouse, it would include
sexual relations with the deceased spouse.
Spousal consortium is generally defined as
rights pertaining to the relationship of a husbandwife which allows compensation to the surviving
spouse for loss of "company, society, co-operation,
affection, and aid of the other in every conjugal
relation."
Parental consortium is granted to the child
upon the premature death of a parent, for loss of
"parental
aid,
protection,
affection,
society,
discipline, guidance and training."
…………………………………………………………………………………
Parental Consortium is awarded to children
who lose their parents in motor vehicle accidents
under the Act.
Page 4
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
A
few
High
Courts
have
awarded
compensation on this count. However, there was no
clarity with respect to the principles on which
compensation could be awarded on loss of Filial
Consortium.
The amount of compensation to be awarded
as consortium will be governed by the principles of
awarding compensation under 'Loss of Consortium'
as laid down in Pranay Sethi (supra).
In the present case, we deem it appropriate to
award the father and the sister of the deceased, an
amount of Rs.40,000 each for loss of Filial
Consortium.”
…………………”
(Emphasis supplied)
In Rajesh and Ors. v. Rajbir Singh and Ors.4 the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held as follows;
“20. … In legal parlance, “consortium” is
the right of the spouse to the company, care,
help, comfort, guidance, society, solace,
affection and sexual relations with his or her
mate. That non-pecuniary head of damages has
not been properly understood by our courts.
The loss of companionship, love, care and
protection, etc., the spouse is entitled to get,
has to be compensated appropriately. The
concept of non-pecuniary damage for loss of
consortium is one of the major heads of award
of compensation in other parts of the world
more particularly in the United States of
America, Australia, etc. English courts have also
recognised the right of a spouse to get
compensation even during the period of
temporary disablement. By loss of consortium,
the courts have made an attempt to
compensate the loss of spouse's affection,
comfort,
solace,
companionship,
society,
assistance, protection, care and sexual relations
during
the
future
years.
Unlike
the
compensation awarded in other countries and
other jurisdictions, since the legal heirs are
otherwise adequately compensated for the
pecuniary loss, it would not be proper to award
a major amount under this head. ………”
Hence, on the anvil of the aforestated ratio in Magma General Insurance
Co. Ltd.
(supra) and Rajesh and Ors. (supra) the Respondent No.1 is
entitled to Spousal consortium and Respondents No.2 to 4 are entitled
(2013) 9 SCC 54
Page 5
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
to Parental compensation to the sum as reflected in the ratio of Magma
General Insurance Co. Ltd. (supra).
11.
The deceased was approximately 35 years of age at the
time of the accident therefore the Multiplier of “16” was rightly adopted
by the learned trial Court in consonance with the decision in Sarla Verma
(Smt.) and Others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another . In
my
considered opinion, there is no requirement for computing loss of love
and affection in the Award. The Litigation Costs awarded by the learned
Tribunal are not contested by the Appellant and is accordingly allowed.
12.
Consequently,
in
light
of
the
aforesaid
facts
and
circumstances, the Judgment of the learned trial Court stands modified
to the extent below;
Annual Income of the deceased
Rs.87,120.00
(Rs.242/-x30x12)
Add 40% of Rs.87,120/- as future prospects
Rs.34,848.00
Yearly income of the deceased
Rs.1,21,968.00
Less 1/3rd of Rs.1,21,968.00
Rs.40,656.00
[deducted from the said amount in consideration of
the instances which the victim would have incurred
towards maintenance had he been alive.]
Net yearly income
Rs.81,312.00
Multiplier of ‘16’ adopted in terms of
Sarla Verma’s case (Rs.81,312 x 16)
Rs.13,00,992.00
Add Loss of Spousal consortium [payable to
Respondent No.1]
Rs.40,000.00
Add Loss of Parental consortium [Rs.40,000/- each,
payable to Respondents No. 2 to 4, respectively]
Rs.1,20,000.00
Add Funeral expenses
Rs.15,000.00
Add Loss of estate
Rs.15,000.00
Add Litigation costs
Rs.25,000.00
Total
Rs.15,15,992.00
(Rupees fifteen lakhs, fifteen thousand, nine hundred and ninety two)
only.
(2009) 6 SCC 121
Page 6
Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
The Respondents No.1 to 4 shall be entitled to simple
13.
interest @ 9% per annum on the above amount instead of 10% granted
by the learned Tribunal, with effect from the date of filing of the Claim
Petition before the learned Tribunal till full realisation.
The awarded amount shall be paid to the Respondents No.1
14.
to 4 within one month from today by the Appellant, failing which, the
Appellant shall pay simple interest @ 12% from the date of filing of the
Claim Petition till realisation, duly deducting the amounts, if any,
already paid by it to the Respondents No.1 to 4.
The awarded amount of compensation shall be divided
15.
amongst the Claimant-Respondent No.1 being the spouse of the
deceased and Claimants-Respondents No.2 to 4 being his minor
children.
(i) From the amount awarded, Claimant-Respondent
No.1, spouse of the deceased is entitled to 40%, along
with interest as specified above.
(ii) 60% of the total amount awarded shall be divided
equally amongst the Claimants-Respondents No.2 to 4, of
which 50% of the share of each child shall be kept in
individual Fixed Deposit in a Nationalised Bank, until the
child attains the age of majority. The remaining 50% of
each of the minor’s share shall be expended on their
education.
16.
Appeal allowed to the extent above.
17.
MAC App. No.01 of 2019 stands disposed of accordingly.
18.
No order as to costs.
19.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the learned Tribunal for
information.
Judge
28.02.2020
ml
Approved for reporting: Yes
Page 7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review