Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 12 of 2018
The Branch Manager,
The New India Assurance Company Limited,
Darjeeling Branch,
West Bengal.
… Appellant
Versus
1. Tshering Doma Tamang (Minor),
D/o Late Harka Bahadur Tamang,
2. Mrs. Hem Rupa Manger,
W/o Late Harka Bahadur Tamang,
Both permanent residents of Panchgarey,
Turuk, South Sikkim,
At present: Residing at Assangthang,
Namchi, South Sikkim.
3. Shri Mohan Sothang,
Son of Jash Bahadur Sothang,
Resident of Tukver Tea Estate,
Darjeeling, West Bengal.
4. Shri Subed Loksam,
S/o Shri Tildhoj Loksam,
Resident of Kankaybong Busty,
P.O. & P.S. Lodhama,
District Darjeeling, West Bengal.
…. Respondents
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988.
Appearance:
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Tarun Choudhary, Advocate for the Respondent Nos. 1
and 2.
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Legal Aid Counsel for the Respondent
Nos.3 and 4.
Date of hearing : 09.11.2019
Date of judgment: 12.11.2019
-------------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan,
1.
The present appeal preferred by the Appellant raises a
singular question as to whether the Appellant could be held to
be liable to pay the compensation as determined by the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal (in short “the learned Tribunal”) on
the basis of an insurance policy (exhibit-6) which the Appellant
claim
to
be
fake?
The
Appeal
does
not
question
the
determination of the learned Tribunal that the Respondent Nos.
1 and 2 were entitled to compensation and the extent of
compensation granted. This Court shall therefore, examine only
the singular issue raised by the Appellant without disturbing
the determination on other issues.
2.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, learned Counsel for the Appellant
submitted that the impugned judgment and award both dated
30.06.2018 on the aforesaid aspect are not sustainable as the
learned Tribunal could not determine whether the insurance
policy (exhibit-6) exhibited by Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 was
genuine or not and that the Appellant ought to have been given
an opportunity to allege and prove that it was fake. Mr. Tarun
Choudhary, learned Counsel for Respondent Nos. 1 and 2
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
submits that although, the insurance policy (exhibit-6) had
been filed along with the claim petition the Appellant had failed
to question the genuineness of the said document in its written
objection and as such they were precluded from raising the
issue belatedly. Mr. Ajay Rathi, learned Legal Aid Counsel for
Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 submit that it is settled principle of
law that a person who asserts a particular fact is required to
affirmatively establish the same and since it was the Appellant
who had asserted that the insurance policy (exhibit-6) was fake
their failure to prove the fact would enure in favour of the
Respondent Nos. 3 and 4.
3.
The basic facts before the learned Tribunal for the effective
determination of the present appeal were that on 29.03.2016
First Information Report (in short “the FIR”) was lodged by
Vaishali Thapa stating that her sister Tshering Doma Tamang
(Respondent No.1) studying at Assangthang School was hit by a
vehicle No.WB-76-8185 near Helipad, Namchi on 29.03.2016,
she had sustained serious injuries on her left foot and
evacuated to Namchi Hospital. On 14.11.2016 a claim petition
was filed by Respondent No.1-a minor aged 8 years and her
mother Hem Rupa Manger (Respondent No.2) before the learned
Tribunal. The opposite parties were the Branch Manager,
Darjeeling, New India Assurance Company Limited (Appellant),
the owner of the vehicle-Mohan Sotang (Respondent No.3) and
the driver of the vehicle-Subed Loksam (Respondent No.4).
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
4.
In the claim petition filed by the Respondent Nos. 1 and 2
the name of the Respondent No.3 was given as the owner of the
vehicle and the Appellant as the insurer of the vehicle. Amongst
the various documents filed by Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 in the
claim petition a photocopy purporting to be certified to be true
copy
of
insurance
policy
bearing
policy
no.51230531130200000868 of the vehicle allegedly issued by
the Appellant was sought to be relied upon. The claim petition
did not disclose how the insurance policy (exhibit-6) was
obtained by Respondent Nos.1 and 2.
5.
The Appellant filed written objection on 04.08.2017. In
paragraph 8 thereof the Appellant stated “The policy if found
would be considered subject to its validity terms and conditions,
stipulations, restriction and limitation.” In paragraph 10 the
Appellant had submitted “The insured may kindly be directed to
produce the original insurance policy before the Hon’ble Tribunal,
failing which, this answering respondents shall produce the copy
of the policy which may kindly be exhibited and read in
evidence.” In paragraph 23 the Appellant sought leave to file
additional and amended written objection if necessary.
6.
The Respondent Nos.3 and 4 appeared before the learned
Tribunal on 25.05.2017 through an Advocate who undertook to
file Vakalatnama. The said Advocate appeared on their behalf
on 23.06.2017 as well, but on 04.08.2017 they were marked as
absent. On 29.08.2019 they continued to be marked absent and
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
on that date the learned Tribunal framed three issues. The
order dated 08.09.2017 records that the Respondent Nos. 3 and
4 were absent on that date as well and proceeded ex-parte.
Thereafter, they did not appear before the learned Tribunal nor
file any written objection to the claim. Consequently, the
Respondent No.3-the owner of the vehicle did not confirm or
deny the insurance policy (exhibit-6) filed by the Respondent
Nos. 1 and 2. On 07.10.2017 evidence on affidavit of
Respondent No.2, her witnesses-Arjun Rai and Suresh Rai were
filed. Their evidences were authenticated and the said witnesses
were cross-examined on 04.11.2017. On the request of the
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 summonses were issued to Dr.
Deokota and Dr. Mohpal pursuant to which they were examined
on 02.12.2017. Thereafter, one Bishnu Kant Sharma was
examined on behalf of the Respondent Nos.1 and 2 on
15.02.2018 and 16.03.2018 was set for evidence of the
Appellant.
7.
On 05.04.2018 the Appellant filed an application under
Order VIII Rule 9 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 ( in short “the CPC”). It was averred that
recently while scrutinising the documents the officials of the
Appellant learnt that the insurance policy (exhibit-6) as
furnished and exhibited by the Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 was a
fake policy and as such it was prayed that the Appellant may be
permitted to file additional written statement and the relevant
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
documents. Although time was granted to Respondent Nos. 1
and 2 to file a reply the order dated 30.04.2018 reflects that the
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 submitted that they do not desire to
file a reply. The matter was heard on the said application and
order dated 11.05.2018 was passed.
8.
The
learned
Tribunal
however,
rejected
the
vide
order
dated
11.05.2018
but
allowed
additional
application
documents to be produced by the Appellant. Pursuant thereto,
on 20.05.2018 Sonam Tshering Sherpa, Branch Manager of the
Appellant at Namchi filed his evidence on affidavit. Sonam
Tshering Sherpa deposed that on verification it was found that
the Appellant had issued insurance policy to one Depen Rai for
a motor cycle bearing the same policy number of the insurance
policy (exhibit-6) produced by the Respondent Nos. 1 and 2. He
filed certified copy of the insurance policy (exhibit-A). He
categorically deposed that the insurance policy (exhibit-6)
exhibited by the Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 was fake and gave
details as to why it was so. Sonam Tshering Sherpa also
exhibited the investigation report (exhibit-B) of one Rupa
Dhakal which reported that the insurance policy (exhibit-6) filed
by Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 did not have QR code and thus
found to be fake.
9.
On
30.06.2018
the
learned
Tribunal
rendered
its
judgment. It was held that the Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 are
entitled to the compensation claimed by them. The plea of the
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
Appellant that the insurance policy (exhibit-6) produced by the
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 being fake was rejected by the learned
Tribunal on several grounds. It was held that Respondent Nos.
1 and 2 had produced the insurance policy (exhibit-6) believing
it to be genuine; the Appellant had filed the insurance policy
(exhibit-A) at a belated stage of trial i.e. after filing their written
objection, after settlement of issues and after examination of
Respondent No. 2 and their witnesses; the Appellant failed to
examine the Branch Manager of the Darjeeling Branch who had
purportedly issued the insurance policy (exhibit-6) and Rupa
Dhakal the investigator; the Appellant had not filed any
complaint against the Respondent No. 3 for obtaining fake
insurance; It was unbelievable that the Respondent No.3 (the
insured) would obtain a fake certificate by paying premium at
his risk and cost. The learned Tribunal held that on perusal of
the insurance policy (exhibit-6) filed by the Respondent Nos. 1
and 2 and the insurance policy (exhibit–A) filed by the Appellant
it is difficult to identify which was fake and which genuine.
10. An insurance policy is a policy obtained by the insured
from the insurer on payment. In the present case vis-a-vis the
insurance
policy
(exhibit-6)
the
insured
is
purportedly
Respondent No.3. The insurer is the Appellant. The Appellant
has given evidence that the insurance policy (exhibit-6) is fake.
The Respondent No.3 has chosen not to give his version before
the learned Tribunal and he was proceeded ex-parte.
The
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
Respondent No.2 exhibited a photocopy purporting to be
certified to be true copy of the insurance policy (exhibit-6).
During her cross-examination she admitted that she was
unaware about the documents and the insurance policy of the
vehicle. There is no evidence at all of the purported insured i.e.
Respondent No.3 with regard to the insurance policy (exhibit-6).
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 are not privy to either of the insurance
policies (exhibit-6 and exhibit-A). The evidence of Respondent
Nos.1 and 2 with regard to the genuineness or otherwise of
insurance policy (exhibit-6) is immaterial as they were not privy
to it. The mere fact that the Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 had
produced the insurance policy (exhibit-6) believing it to be
genuine would not thus turn the table against the Appellant.
The records reveal that the Appellant realized that the
insurance policy (exhibit-6) was not genuine only at the time
when they were required to give evidence before the learned
Tribunal. Thus, filing of the insurance policy (exhibit-A) along
with the application dated 05.04.2018 cannot be termed belated
as it is trite that limitation for alleging fraud or forgery would
arise from the date of knowledge. In any case records reveal
that on 05.04.2018 when the Appellant filed the application
only the Respondent Nos.1 and 2 and their witnesses had been
examined and the said witnesses would not have, ordinarily,
any knowledge about the genuineness of insurance policy
(exhibit-6). The learned Tribunal has held that the Appellant
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
failed to examine the Branch Manager of the Darjeeling Branch
who had purportedly issued the insurance policy (exhibit-6).
The learned Tribunal failed to appreciate that had it allowed the
application dated 05.04.2018 of the Appellant to file additional
written statement; additional evidence may have been led.
Instead, the learned Tribunal permitted the Appellant to file
additional documents only. Thus, the failure of the Appellant to
examine the Branch Manager of the Darjeeling Branch of the
Appellant cannot be held against the Appellant. The learned
Tribunal has also held that it was unbelievable that the
Respondent No.3 would obtain a fake certificate by paying
premium at his risk and cost. However, the learned Tribunal
did not consider that the Respondent No.3 had not even
bothered to file a written statement and assist it in arriving at
the truth. It is unclear as to how the learned Tribunal came to
the conclusion that Respondent No.3 had paid premium for the
said insurance policy (exhibit-6). Although, the Respondent
Nos. 3 and 4 had chosen not to appear before the learned
Tribunal pursuant to the summonses issued by this Court they
have appeared through Mr. Ajay Rathi, learned Legal Aid
Counsel. They have chosen to remain silent even at this stage
and argue only on the various discrepancies in the evidence led
by the Appellant before the learned Tribunal.
11. A perusal of the application dated 05.04.2018 filed by the
Appellant makes it evident that it was only before the date fixed
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
for the Appellant’s evidence that they discovered that the
insurance policy (exhibit-6) was not genuine. Immediately the
Appellant moved an application bringing this fact on record and
seeking a prayer to file additional written statement with
additional documents which was partly turned down. No
opportunity was granted to the Appellant to allege and prove
that the insurance policy (exhibit-6) was fake. Consequently,
the learned Tribunal could not come to a definite conclusion as
to whether the insurance policy (exhibit-6) was genuine or fake.
The contractual liability of the Appellant can be determined only
through the insurance policy (exhibit-6). When admittedly the
learned Tribunal could not determine its genuineness it may
not be correct to fasten liability upon the Appellant without
giving them an opportunity to assert and prove the allegation
made in the application dated 05.04.2018 and in the evidence
on affidavit of Sonam Tshering Sherpa, the Branch Manager of
the Appellant. The judgment of this Court in re: Silli Man Subba
v. Man Bahadur Subba1 relied upon by Mr. Tarun Choudhary is
distinguishable. In the said case the insurance company had
not denied that the policy was issued by its employee. The
evidence produced by the Appellant in this regard prima-facie
does reflect that it needs to be examined during trial. Had the
learned Tribunal permitted the Appellant to file additional
written statement on this limited aspect allowing them to lead
MANU/SI/0073/2014
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
evidence, cross-examination would have churned the truth. The
fact that the accident occurred as a result of which the
Respondent No.1 suffered injuries is not questioned. The fact
that a Tata Sumo vehicle (silver colour) bearing registration
No.WB-76-8185 owned by Respondent No.3 and driven by
Respondent No.4 in a rash and negligent manner is not
disputed. As a result of the accident Respondent No.1 was
permanently disabled and her foot had to be amputated is not
disputed. The fact that Respondent No.3 is the owner of the
said vehicle is not disputed. If the vehicle was in fact insured
with the Appellant through the insurance policy (exhibit-6)
found to be genuine then it would be the Appellant who would
be bound to indemnify the liability of the Respondent No.3. The
Appellant however, asserts that the insurance policy (exhibit-6)
is fake.
Only a photocopy of the insurance policy (exhibit-6)
was filed by Respondent No.1 and 2. The said photocopy of the
insurance policy (exhibit-6) bears the seal of Namchi police
station only and is not certified copy as claimed by the
Respondent No.1 and 2 in the list of documents. The original
would have been with Respondent No.3 if it was genuine.
Respondent No.3 did not produce the original of the insurance
policy (exhibit-6) if it existed or depose as to how he procured it.
The only question which requires determination is whether the
insurance policy (exhibit-6) is fake. The silence maintained by
the Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 throughout the proceedings before
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
the learned Tribunal also does not assist the Court in arriving
at the truth. In the circumstances, this Court is of the
considered view that the impugned judgment on the aspect of
the genuineness of the insurance policy (exhibit-6) is incorrect
and liable to be set aside. Although, the Appellant has not
challenged the order dated 11.05.2018 passed by the learned
Tribunal, this Court is of the view that the said order is an
impediment towards the search for truth and therefore, the
Appellant must be given an opportunity to allege and prove
what
they
assert
in
the
application
dated
05.04.2018.
Consequently, the findings of the learned Tribunal on the
aspect of genuineness of the insurance policy (exhibit-6) and
the
liability
of
the
Appellant
to
pay
the
compensation
determined in the impugned judgment and award both dated
30.06.2018 are set aside.
12. The file in MACT Case No. 10 of 2016 is restored before
the learned Tribunal. The learned Tribunal shall permit the
Appellant to file additional written statement along with any
document they seek to prove in support of their allegation that
the insurance policy (exhibit-6) is fake. The Respondents shall
be at liberty to file their response if they so desire and if the
Appellant chooses to lead oral and documentary evidence (on
this limited aspect) the learned Tribunal shall give opportunity
to the Respondents to counter the same as per law including
permitting them to lead additional evidence. On completion the
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
learned
Tribunal
shall
fix
the
liability
for
payment
of
compensation in the light of the evidence available before it.
13. The Supreme Court vide order dated 10.07.2019 had
directed the Appellant to deposit the entire award amount along
with accrued interest before the learned Tribunal and on such
deposit being made an amount of Rs.5 lakhs be disbursed to
the guardian of Respondent No.1. The rest of the amount was
directed to be invested in a fixed deposit till the appeal is
decided by this Court so that the deposit may enure the benefit
in favour of the succeeding party.
An affidavit of compliance
was filed by the Appellant. Mr. Tarun Choudhary, learned
Counsel for Respondent Nos.1 and 2 also confirmed receipt of
Rs.5 lakhs on behalf of Respondent No.1. In the circumstances,
this Court is of the view that the amounts invested in a fixed
deposit should continue until the final determination on the
question of liability for payment of compensation by the learned
Tribunal. The fixing of the liability for payment of compensation
between the Appellant and the Respondent No.3 would also
determine who would ultimately have to bear the payment of
Rs.5 lakhs made to the Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 as per the
order dated 10.07.2019 passed by the Supreme Court.
14. The learned Tribunal is requested to determine the
question of genuineness of the insurance policy (exhibit-6) and
render its judgment on the liability of the compensation payable
to Respondent Nos.1 and 2 at the earliest convenience.
MAC Appeal No. 12 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Minor Tshering Doma Tamang & Ors.
15. The appeal stands allowed as indicated above. The
impugned judgment and award both dated 30.06.2018 are set
aside to this limited extent and the matter remanded for
determination on the question of genuineness of the insurance
policy (exhibit-6) and for fixing the liability of the compensation
payable.
16. The observations of this Court on the insurance policies
(exhibit-6 and exhibit-A) have been made for determination of
the present dispute. The learned Tribunal shall not be bound by
any such observation and determine the questions solely based
on the evidence led by the parties.
17. A copy of the judgment shall be forwarded to the Court of
the learned Tribunal, South Sikkim at Namchi.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
12.11.2019
to/
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review