Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:SHC:4
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 3rd March, 2025
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON‟BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.02 of 2025
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
SBI General Insurance Company Limited
versus
Respondent
:
Songmit Lepcha and Others
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Rahul Rathi, Advocates for the Appellant.
Mr. Sushant Subba, Advocate for the Respondents No.1 to 4.
Ms. Anusha Basnett, Advocate for the Respondents No.5 and 6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
J U D G M E N T(O R A L)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The only grievance raised by the Appellant, in this
Appeal, which assails the Judgment of the Learned Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal, Namchi, Sikkim, dated 28-11-2024, in MACT Case
No.06 of 2022 (Songmit Lepcha and Others vs. The Branch Manager,
SBI General Insurance Company Limited and Others), is the alleged
erroneous compensation of ₹ 40,22,908/- (Rupees forty lakhs,
twenty two thousand, nine hundered and eight) only, granted to
the Claimants (Respondents No.1 to 4 herein).
It is urged that
only ¼ (one-fourth) was deducted from the loss of earnings of the
deceased while computing the award, when such deduction ought
to have been ½ (one-half), in terms of the Judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Sarla Verma (Smt) and Others vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation and Another
(2009) 6 SCC 121
as the deceased was a twenty-two year
2025:SHC:4
MAC App. No.02 of 2025
The Branch Manager, SBI General Insurance Company Limited vs. Songmit Lepcha and Others
old bachelor at the time of the unfortunate accident.
That, the
compensation is accordingly required to be re-computed and
modified, in view of the obvious error made therein.
That, no
other grounds are being pressed in this Appeal.
2.
Respondent No.1 is the mother of the deceased who is
a widow and Respondents No.2, 3 and 4 are his younger siblings.
Respondents No.5 and 6 are the owner and driver of the vehicle
respectively.
3.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.1, 2, 3 and 4
and Respondents No.5 and 6 concede to the submissions advanced
by Learned Counsel for the Appellant, however they submit that
the compensation may be computed as deemed “just” by this
Court.
4.
I have heard the submissions advanced by Learned
Counsel for the parties.
I have also perused the records of the
case including the impugned Judgment.
5.
The facts that led to the accident, briefly narrated are
that; the deceased a resident of Pedong village, District Kalimpong,
West Bengal, was working as a “Boomer Helper” in Surya Pest
Control Services Company and posted at Tunnel 9 and 10, SevokeRangpo Railway project. On 04-02-2022, when he was driving a
Scooty and was on his way to work at the Railway project NH10,
one Tata Truck driven at high speed by Respondent No.6, hit the
scooty driver, at 11th Mile Tarkhola, resulting in his death.
6.
The concept of “just compensation” has been succinctly
explained by the Supreme Court in a litany of cases which for
brevity
are
not
being
discussed
here.
Apart
from
“just
compensation” the Supreme Court in Sarla Verma (supra) has also
2025:SHC:4
MAC App. No.02 of 2025
The Branch Manager, SBI General Insurance Company Limited vs. Songmit Lepcha and Others
discussed the percentage that ought to be deducted as personal
and living expenses of the deceased.
The relevant paragraph is
extracted hereinbelow;
“32. Thus even if the deceased is survived by
parents and siblings, only the mother would be
considered to be a dependant, and 50% would be
treated as the personal and living expenses of the
bachelor and 50% as the contribution to the family.
However, where the family of the bachelor is large
and dependent on the income of the deceased, as in
a case where he has a widowed mother and large
number of younger non-earning sisters or brothers,
his personal and living expenses may be restricted to
one-third and contribution to the family will be taken
as two-third.”
[emphasis mine]
(i)
On the anvil of this observation, it is appropriate in the
instant matter to place loss of earning at 1/3 (one-third) and not ¼
(one-fourth), considering the number of family members of the
deceased, who were dependant on his income and the fact that he
had a widowed mother.
7.
While perusing the impugned Judgment it appears that
under the head “loss of consortium”, the Learned MACT has
granted
₹
30,000/-
(Rupees
thirty
thousand)
only,
to
the
Respondent No.1 and ₹ 10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand) only,
each, to the Respondents No.2, 3 and 4.
(i)
On this aspect relevant reference is made to the
decision in Magma General Insurance Company Limited vs. Nanu Ram
alias Chuhru Ram and Others .
The Supreme Court addressed the
issue of consortium and stated as follows;
“21. A Constitution Bench of this Court
in Pranay Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC 680] dealt with the various
heads under which compensation is to be awarded in
a death case. One of these heads is loss of
consortium. In legal parlance, “consortium” is a
compendious term which encompasses “spousal
consortium”, “parental consortium”, and “filial
consortium”. The right to consortium would include
the company, care, help, comfort, guidance, solace
(2018) 18 SCC 130
2025:SHC:4
MAC App. No.02 of 2025
The Branch Manager, SBI General Insurance Company Limited vs. Songmit Lepcha and Others
and affection of the deceased, which is a loss to his
family. With respect to a spouse, it would include
sexual relations
with
the
deceased
spouse:
[Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9 SCC 54].
21.1. Spousal consortium is generally defined
as rights pertaining to the relationship of a husbandwife which allows compensation to the surviving
spouse for loss of “company, society, cooperation,
affection, and aid of the other in every conjugal
relation”. [Black's Law Dictionary (5th Edn., 1979).]
21.2. Parental consortium is granted to the
child upon the premature death of a parent, for loss
of “parental aid, protection, affection, society,
discipline, guidance and training”.
21.3. Filial consortium is the right of the
parents to compensation in the case of an accidental
death of a child. An accident leading to the death of a
child causes great shock and agony to the parents
and family of the deceased. The greatest agony for a
parent is to lose their child during their lifetime.
Children are valued for their love, affection,
companionship and their role in the family unit.
.....................………………………………………………………………………
24. The amount of compensation to be
awarded as consortium will be governed by the
principles of awarding compensation under “loss of
consortium” as laid down in Pranay Sethi [(2017) 16 SCC
680]. In the present case, we deem it appropriate to
award the father and the sister of the deceased, an
amount of Rs 40,000 each for loss of filial
consortium.”
[emphasis mine]
(ii)
Based on the pronouncement of Magma (supra), “filial
consortium” is to be granted to the mother of the deceased and his
siblings @ ₹ 40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand) only, each.
This
shall be added during the computation of the award.
8.
No compensation was granted to the Respondents No.1
to 4 under the head “loss of estate” by the Learned MACT.
In light
of the observation of the Supreme in National Insurance Company
Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and Others
extracted hereinbelow the
Respondents No.1 to 4 are entitled to such compensation;
“52. ……………………………… It seems to us that
reasonable figures on conventional heads, namely,
loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral
expenses should be Rs 15,000, Rs 40,000 and Rs
15,000 respectively. The principle of revisiting the
said heads is an acceptable principle. But the revisit
should not be fact-centric or quantum-centric. We
(2017) 16 SCC 680
2025:SHC:4
MAC App. No.02 of 2025
The Branch Manager, SBI General Insurance Company Limited vs. Songmit Lepcha and Others
think that it would be condign that the amount that
we have quantified should be enhanced on
percentage basis in every three years and the
enhancement should be at the rate of 10% in a span
of three years. We are disposed to hold so because
that will bring in consistency in respect of those
heads.”
[emphasis mine]
(i)
It is also worth noticing from the above extract of the
decision that for “funeral expenses”, “loss of estate” and “loss of
consortium”, 10% is to be added every three years.
9.
On the bedrock of the discussions that have emanated
hereinabove and while relying on the various decisions of the
Supreme Court on grant of compensation in MACT cases, I am of
the
considered
view
that
compensation
which
is
“just
compensation” is as follows;
Annual income of the deceased (₹ 17,407/- x 12)
₹
2,08,884.00
(+)
₹
₹
83,554.00
2,92,438.00
(-)
₹
97,479.00
Net yearly income
₹
1,94,959.00
Multiplier to be adopted „18‟
(₹1,94,959/- x 18)
[The age of the deceased at the time of death was ’22’
and the relevant multiplier in terms of Paragraph 42 as
per Judgment of Sarla Verma (supra) is „18‟]
₹
35,09,262.00
Add Funeral Expenses @ ₹ 15,000/-
(+)
₹
16,500.00
(+)
₹
16,500.00
(+)
₹
1,76,000.00
=
₹ 37,18,262.00
Add 40% of ₹ 2,08,884/- as Future Prospects
[in terms of Paragraph 59.4 of the Judgment of Pranay
Sethi (supra)]
Less 1/3 of ₹ 2,92,438/[in terms of Paragraph 32 of the Judgment of Sarla
Verma (supra)]
[in terms of Paragraph 52 of the Judgment of
Pranay Sethi (supra) 10% enhanced every three
years, hence 10% of ₹ 15,000 = ₹ 1,500 + ₹ 15,000 =
₹ 16,500/- as the accident occurred on 04-02-2022]
Add Loss of Estate @ ₹ 15,000/[in terms of Paragraph 52 of the Judgment of
Pranay Sethi (supra) 10% enhanced every three
years, hence 10% of ₹ 15,000 = ₹ 1,500 + ₹ 15,000 =
₹ 16,500/- as the accident occurred on 04-02-2022]
Add Loss of Filial Consortium
[₹ 40,000/- each, payable to Respondents No.1 to 4,
in terms of Paragraphs 21 and 24 of the Judgment of
Magma (supra) and Paragraph 52 of the Judgment
of Pranay Sethi (supra) with enhancement @ 10%
in every three years, the figure calculated is
— ₹ 1,60,000/- @ 10%= ₹ 16,000 + ₹ 1,60,000
= ₹ 1,76,000/- as the accident occurred on 04-02-2022]
Total
(Rupees thirty seven lakhs, eighteen thousand, two hundred and sixty
two) only.
2025:SHC:4
MAC App. No.02 of 2025
The Branch Manager, SBI General Insurance Company Limited vs. Songmit Lepcha and Others
10.
The computation of compensation made by the Learned
MACT is modified to the extent above.
11.
The Appellant-Insurance Company is directed to pay
the awarded compensation to the Claimants-Respondents No.1 to
4, within one month from today, with simple interest @ 9% per
annum, failing which, it shall pay simple interest @ 12% per
annum, from the date of filing of the Claim Petition, i.e., 20-072022, till final realization. Amounts, if any, already paid by the
Appellant-Insurance Company to the Claimants-Respondents No.1
to 4, for the instant Claim Petition, shall be duly deducted from the
awarded compensation.
12.
The modified awarded amount of compensation, along
with interest, as specified above, shall be divided amongst the
Claimant-Respondent No.1 and Claimants-Respondents No.2, 3
and 4, in the following manner;
(i)
The Claimant-Respondent No.1, mother of the
deceased, is entitled to 40% of the total
compensation awarded; and
(ii)
The Claimants-Respondents No.2, 3 and 4, being his
siblings, are entitled to 60% of the total awarded
compensation which shall be divided equally amongst
them, i.e., 20% each.
13.
Appeal disposed of accordingly.
14.
No order as to costs.
15.
Copy of this Judgment be sent forthwith to the Learned
MACT for information.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
03-03-2025
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds/sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review