Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED: 10.04.2019
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
Reliance General Insurance Company
Limited,
Himalaya House, 8th Floor,
38-B, J.L. Nehru Road,
Kolkata, 700071.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre,
Rongyek, Bhusuk Road,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2.
Mrs. Karuna Chettri,
Wife of Mr. Nirmal Chettri,
R/o 49 K.M. Sarani,
South Port, Kolkata,
West Bengal.
Appeal under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Manish Kumar Jain, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Mr. Deepu Prasad and Ms. Phurba Diki,
Advocates for Respondent No. 1.
None present for Respondent No. 2.
--------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J
1.
Assailing the award granted by the learned Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim at Gangtok (for short
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
'learned Tribunal') in MACT Case No. 14 of 2016 (Sa-Ngor
Chotshog Centre vs. Mrs. Karuna Chettri & Anr.), the instant
Appeal has been preferred. The learned Tribunal awarded
compensation amounting to Rs.15,02,500/- (Rupees fifteen
lakhs, two thousand and five hundred) only, to the Respondent
No. 1, on account of the death of Tamding Wangchuk
(hereinafter 'deceased'), having reached a finding that the
cause of accident was due to the rash and negligent act of the
driver one Nirmal Chettri, and that the Respondent No. 1 was
the legal representative of the deceased.
2.
The
Respondent
No.
herein
was
the
Claimant
(hereinafter „Respondent No. 1 Centre‟) and Respondent No. 2
was the Opposite Party No. 1 before the learned Tribunal. The
Appellant herein was the Opposite Party No. 2 before the
learned Tribunal. Parties shall be referred to in their order of
appearance before this Court.
3.
The facts which have led to the instant Appeal are that
the deceased aged about 32 years, was a permanent resident
of the Respondent No. 1 Centre, a monastic institution and a
study centre under the Shakya clan of Buddhism in Gangtok,
East Sikkim. He had renounced the world having severed all
ties with his family since the age of nine, was working as a
Teacher at the Respondent No. 1 Centre and earning a monthly
salary
of
Rs.10,000/-
(Rupees
ten
thousand)
only.
On
20.08.2012, the deceased was travelling in vehicle bearing
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
Registration No. WB-76-4625 (Tata Spacio), driven by one
Nirmal Chettri, which met with an accident at Hanuman Jhora
under the jurisdiction of Kalimpong Police Station, District
Darjeeling, West Bengal, at around 20:00 Hrs. On 21.08.2012,
the deceased succumbed to his injuries in a Hospital in
Kalimpong. One Jiten Chettri lodged the First Information
Report pertaining to the accident on 21.08.2012 at 7.15 Hrs at
Reang Police Post, under Kalimpong Police Station where a case
under Sections 279, 337, 338, 304A of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 (for short 'IPC, 180') was registered against the driver of
the vehicle. The body of the deceased, on completion of inquest
and post mortem examination was handed over to the Manager
of the Claimant Centre for the last rites. The cause of accident
was, as per witnesses, due to the rash and negligent driving of
the driver Nirmal Chettri. The Respondent No. 1 Centre thus
sought compensation of Rs.21,42,500/- (Rupees twenty one
lakhs, forty two thousand and five hundred) only, claiming to
have suffered a major setback by losing an eminent scholar.
4.
The Appellant denied and disputed the claim of the
Respondent No. 1 Centre on grounds that the deceased had no
relation with the Respondent No. 1 Centre and was not
dependent on his alleged income of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees ten
thousand) only, per month. Besides his needs were provided by
the Respondent No. 1 Centre of which he was a spiritual head
but never a Teacher. That, the parents of the deceased were
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
not impleaded as parties, hence the claim petition suffers from
mis-joinder and non-joinder of parties over and above which
the rash and negligent driving could not be established as
apparent from the Judgment of acquittal rendered by the Court
of the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Kalimpong in
G.R. Case No. 126 of 2012 (State vs. Nirmal Chettri). That the
documents are manufactured and fabricated for the purposes of
the case, hence, the claim petition was liable to be dismissed.
5.
The Respondent No. 2 the owner of the vehicle, in her
Written Objection before the learned trial Court averred that
although the cause of accident has been shown to be due to the
rash and negligent act of the driver, however the driver was in
fact acquitted in the criminal case registered against him,
therefore rash and negligent driving has remained unproved.
That, at the time of the accident, the documents pertaining to
the vehicle were valid as also the Insurance Certificate, the
terms of which were not violated, hence the Opposite Party No.
1 had no liability.
6.
The learned Tribunal framed a single issue which is
extracted as follows;
“Whether the Claimant is entitled to the
compensation claimed? If so, who is liable to
compensate him?”
The learned Tribunal then pronounced the impugned Judgment
based on the evidence and documents furnished before it.
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
7.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant before this Court,
reiterated the argument pertaining to non-joinder of necessary
parties as the legal representatives of the deceased being his
parents, were not added as parties. That, rash and negligent
act of the driver is unestablished, besides the Respondent No. 1
Centre failed to show dependency on the deceased. That, the
compensation awarded was exorbitant without application of
mind by the learned Tribunal and hence on these grounds
alone, the claim petition deserved to be dismissed.
8.
Per contra, learned Counsel Mr. Ajay Rathi for the
Respondent No. 1 Centre, while relying on the decision of
Montford Brothers of St. Gabriel and Another vs. United India
Insurance and Another1,
contended that the Hon'ble Supreme
Court has clarified who a „legal representative‟ is. That, in terms
thereof the Respondent No. 1 Centre is well within the ambit of
„legal representative‟ hence the question of impleading the
parents as parties did not arise as the deceased had severed all
ties with his family. That, no error arises in the calculation of
compensation, therefore the impugned Judgment warrants no
interference.
9.
I have heard in extenso and considered the rival
submissions of learned Counsel for the parties. I have also
perused the impugned Judgment including the documents and
evidence on record.
(2014) 3 SCC 394
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
10.
Taking up the first question with regard to rash and
negligent driving, it was the contention of both the Appellant
and the Respondent No. 2 that the criminal case registered
against the driver had resulted in an acquittal, hence the
question of rash and negligent driving did not arise. It would be
appropriate to state here that in a criminal trial the matter is to
be proved beyond a reasonable doubt, however this is not the
standard required while considering a matter before the Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal. On this question, we may refer to
the decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in N.K.V. Bros. (P)
Ltd. vs. M. Karumai Ammal and Others 2, wherein it was held as
follows;
“2.The Facts: A stage carriage belonging to
the petitioner was on a trip when, after nightfall,
the bus hit an overhanging high tension wire
resulting in 26 casualties of which 8 proved
instantaneously fatal. A criminal case ensued but
the accused-driver was acquitted on the score
that the tragedy that happened was an act of
God. The Accidents Claims Tribunal, which tried
the claims for compensation under the Motor
Vehicles Act, came to the conclusion, affirmed by
the High Court, that, despite the screams of the
passengers about the dangerous overhanging
wire ahead, the rash driver sped towards the
lethal spot. Some lost their lives instantly:
several lost their limbs likewise. The High Court,
after examining the materials, concluded:
We therefore sustain the finding of the
Tribunal that the accident had taken place due to
the rashness and negligence of RW 1 (driver)
and consequently the appellant is vicariously
liable to pay compensation to the claimant.
The plea that the criminal case had ended in
acquittal and that, therefore, the civil suit must
follow suit, was rejected and rightly. The
(1980) 3 SCC 457
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
requirement of culpable rashness under Section
304-A IPC is more drastic than negligence
sufficient under the law of tort to create liability.
The quantum of compensation was moderately
fixed and although there was, perhaps, a case
for enhancement, the High Court dismissed the
cross-claims also. Being questions of fact, we are
obviously unwilling to reopen the holdings on
culpability and compensation.
Thus it is a settled position of law that a conviction recorded by
a Criminal Court is enough to hold that the driver had driven
the vehicle rashly and negligently but his acquittal on the other
hand would be no ground to dismiss the claim petition.
11.
The witness for the Respondent No. 1 Centre, Jamyang
Sangpo Bhutia, as pointed out by the learned Tribunal at
Paragraph 6 of his Evidence-on-Affidavit Exhibit 10, stated that
the cause of accident was the rash and negligent act of the
accused driver, Mr. Nirmal Chettri as he was driving the vehicle
rashly
and
negligently.
No
cross-examination
opportunity given was conducted on this point.
despite
Therefore,
there is no reason for this Court to differ with the finding of the
learned Tribunal.
12.
So far as the question of “legal representative" is
concerned, it is evident that nothing emerged in crossexamination to demolish the claim of the witness for the
Respondent
No.
Centre
that
they
were
the
legal
representatives of the deceased. In Montford Brothers of St.
Gabriel and Another
(supra), the Appellant No. 1 i.e. the
Montford Brothers of St. Gabriel was a charitable society
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1960 and its
members after joining the Appellant Society renounce the world
and are known as “Brother.” That, such a “Brother” severs all
his relations with the natural family and is bound by the
constitution of the Society. The constitution of the Society
provides that whatever the “Brother” receives by way of salary,
subsidies, gifts, pension or from insurance or other such
benefits belongs to the community as by right and goes into the
common purse. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court while discussing
what a “legal representative” means also held that before the
learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal there was no evidence
in support of such pleading that the Claimant is not a legal
representative and therefore the claim petition be dismissed as
not maintainable. The Appellant No. 1 Society, through its duly
authorized agent Appellant No. 2 claimed compensation under
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 in relation to the death of the said
member of the Society in the accident. The Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal awarded compensation to the Claimant. In a
Writ Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the
Hon‟ble High Court set aside the order of the learned Tribunal.
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court, while upholding the order of the
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal discussed what a “legal
representative” would mean as follows;
“9. The Act does not define the term “legal
representative” but the Tribunal has noted in its
judgment and order that clause (c) of Rule 2 of
the Mizoram Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal
Rules,
1988,
defines
the
term
“legal
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
representative” as having the same meaning as
assigned to it in clause (11) of Section 2 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which is as
follows:
“2. (11) „legal representative‟ means a
person who in law represents the estate of a
deceased person, and includes any person who
intermeddles with the estate of the deceased and
where a party sues or is sued in a representative
character the person on whom the estate
devolves on the death of the party so suing or
sued;”
10. From the aforesaid provisions it is
clear that in case of death of a person in a
motor vehicle accident, right is available to
a legal representative of the deceased or
the agent of the legal representative to
lodge a claim for compensation under the
provisions of the Act. The issue as to who is
a legal representative or its agent is
basically an issue of fact and may be
decided one way or the other dependent
upon the facts of a particular case. But as a
legal proposition it is undeniable that a
person claiming to be a legal representative
has the locus to maintain an application for
compensation under Section 166 of the Act,
either directly or through any agent, subject
to result of a dispute raised by the other
side on this issue.
11. The learned counsel for the Insurance
Company tried to persuade us that since the
term “legal representative” has not been defined
under the Act, the provisions of Section 1-A of
the Fatal Accidents Act, 1855, should be taken as
guiding principle and the claim should be
confined only for the benefit of wife, husband,
parent and child, if any, of the person whose
death has been caused by the accident. In this
context, he cited the judgment of this Court in
Gujarat SRTC v. Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai [AIR
1987 SC 1690]. In that case, covered by the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, the claimant was a
brother of a deceased killed in a motor vehicle
accident. The Court rejected the contention of
the appellant that since the term “legal
representative” is not defined under the Motor
Vehicles Act, the right of filing the claim should
be controlled by the provisions of the Fatal
Accidents Act. It was specifically held that the
Motor Vehicles Act creates new and enlarged
right for filing an application for compensation
and such right cannot be hedged in by the
limitations on an action under the Fatal Accidents
Act.
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
12. Para 13 of the Report of Gujarat SRTC
case reflects the correct philosophy which should
guide the courts interpreting the legal provisions
of
beneficial
legislations
providing
for
compensation to those who had suffered loss:
(SCC p. 250)
“13. We feel that the view taken by the
Gujarat High Court is in consonance with the
principles of justice, equity and good conscience
having regard to the conditions of the Indian
society. Every legal representative who suffers
on account of the death of a person due to a
motor vehicle accident should have a remedy for
realisation of compensation and that is provided
by Sections 110-A to 110-F of the Act. These
provisions are in consonance with the principles
of law of torts that every injury must have a
remedy. It is for the Motor Vehicles Accidents
Tribunal to determine the compensation which
appears to it to be just as provided in Section
110-B of the Act and to specify the person or
persons to whom compensation shall be paid.
The determination of the compensation payable
and its apportionment as required by Section
110-B
of
the
Act
amongst
the
legal
representatives for whose benefit an application
may be filed under Section 110-A of the Act have
to be done in accordance with well-known
principles of law. We should remember that in an
Indian family brothers, sisters and brothers'
children and some times foster children live
together and they are dependent upon the
breadwinner of the family and if the breadwinner
is killed on account of a motor vehicle accident,
there is no justification to deny them
compensation relying upon the provisions of the
Fatal Accidents Act, 1855 which as we have
already held has been substantially modified by
the provisions contained in the Act in relation to
cases arising out of motor vehicles accidents. We
express our approval of the decision in Megjibhai
Khimji Vira v. Chaturbhai Taljabhai [2 AIR 1977
Guj 195] and hold that the brother of a person
who dies in a motor vehicle accident is entitled to
maintain a petition under Section 110-A of the
Act if he is a legal representative of the
deceased.”
13. From the aforesaid quoted extract it is
evident that only if there is a justification in
consonance with principles of justice, equity and
good conscience, a dependant of the deceased
may be denied right to claim compensation.
Hence, we find no merit in the submission
advanced on behalf of the respondent Insurance
Company that the claim petition is not
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
maintainable because of the provisions of the
Fatal Accidents Act.”
(Emphasis supplied)
The ratio supra puts to rest any doubts raised on „legal
representative.‟ On careful perusal of the pleadings before the
learned Tribunal all that the Appellant has stated is that;
“3. ... The claimants being a institution (sic)
is not dependent upon the income of the
deceased, further the deceased was a earning
(sic) member but a spiritual head at the
institution. That as there is no dependency upon
the income the claim petition cannot sustain on
its present form and as such there is no loss of
dependency.
....................................................................
27. ... The statement that the deceased
had renounced the world and severed all the
relationship with his parents since the age of 9
years and was staying with the petitioner, a
monastic institution and a study center for
Buddhist scholars of shakya clan in Gangtok is
totally false and hence denied in total. The
statement and averments are contrary to the
legal representative as defined in the motor
vehicles act. ...”
Besides the Appellant was not able to establish that the parents
had any links with the deceased or were dependent upon him.
The Appellant also failed to lead any evidence to disprove the
contention of the Respondent No. 1 Centre that the deceased
had renounced all ties with his family and consequently they
were the legal representatives of the deceased. Hence, in
consideration of the facts supra the finding of the learned
Tribunal on this count cannot be faulted.
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
13.
Coming to the question of compensation, the deceased
was aged about 32 years, therefore the Multiplier of “16” was
rightly adopted in consonance with the decision in Sarla Verma
(Smt.) and Others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another3.
14.
The learned Tribunal has granted 50% of monthly income
while computing future prospects, on this point, in National
Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 4, it was held as
follows;
“59.1. The two-Judge Bench in Santosh
Devi [Santosh Devi v. National Insurance Co.
Ltd., (2012) 6 SCC 421] should have been well
advised to refer the matter to a larger Bench as
it was taking a different view than what has been
stated in Sarla Verma [Sarla Verma v. DTC,
(2009) 6 SCC 121] , a judgment by a coordinate
Bench. It is because a coordinate Bench of the
same strength cannot take a contrary view than
what has been held by another coordinate
Bench.
59. In view of the aforesaid analysis, we
proceed to record our conclusions:
59.3. While determining the income, an
addition of 50% of actual salary to the income of
the deceased towards future prospects, where
the deceased had a permanent job and was
below the age of 40 years, should be made. The
addition should be 30%, if the age of the
deceased was between 40 to 50 years. In case
the deceased was between the age of 50 to 60
years, the addition should be 15%. Actual salary
should be read as actual salary less tax.
59.2. As Rajesh [Rajesh v. Rajbir
Singh,
(2013) 9 SCC 54] has not taken note of the
decision in Reshma Kumari [Reshma Kumari
v. Madan Mohan, (2013) 9 SCC 65] , which was
delivered at earlier point of time, the decision
in Rajesh [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9 SCC
54] is not a binding precedent.
(2009) 6 SCC 121
AIR 2017 SC 5157
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
59.4. In case the deceased was selfemployed or on a fixed salary, an addition
of 40% of the established income should be
the warrant where the deceased was below
the age of 40 years. An addition of 25% where
the deceased was between the age of 40 to 50
years and 10% where the deceased was between
the age of 50 to 60 years should be regarded as
the necessary method of computation. The
established income means the income minus the
tax component.”
(Emphasis supplied)
Hence, in view of the ratio of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Pranay Sethi’s case supra, it is evident that where the deceased
was on a fixed salary and below the age of 40 years, an
addition of 40% of the established income should be made
towards future prospects. Exhibit 4 relied on by the Respondent
No. 1 Centre reveals that the deceased was on a consolidated
pay of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand) only, per month.
Thus, 40% shall be calculated as future prospects instead of
50% as calculated by the learned Tribunal.
15.
So far as loss of estate and funeral expenses are
concerned, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Pranay Sethi (supra)
at Paragraph 59.8, inter alia held as follows;
“59.8. Reasonable
figures
on
conventional heads, namely, loss of estate,
loss of consortium and funeral expenses
should be Rs 15,000, Rs 40,000 and Rs
15,000 respectively. ...”
(Emphasis supplied)
In view of the aforecited Judgment, Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen
thousand) only, is granted towards funeral expenses and a sum
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
of Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand) only, granted towards
loss of estate.
16.
With regard to the amount of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees ten
thousand)
only,
having
been
granted
towards
“Cost
of
transportation of the victim to the Hospital and the body of the
victim from Central Referral Hospital, Manipal to Zitlang,
Rangpo, East Sikkim” is concerned, apart from the statement
made by witness for the Respondent No. 1 Centre Jamyang
Sangpo Bhutia at Paragraph 9 of his Evidence-on-Affidavit
Exhibit 10 to the effect that the dead body of the deceased was
then handed over to me for last rites and subsequently the
Sub-Registrar of Births and Deaths, Executive Assistant, Teesta
Gram Panchayat issued the Death Certificate of the deceased to
me, no documents have been furnished to support the claim of
the witness towards payment of transportation. Therefore, the
Respondent No. 1 Centre is not entitled to compensation
towards “cost of transportation.”
17.
The question of compensation on account of loss of love
and affection as granted by the learned Tribunal, in view of the
circumstance is superfluous, hence the Respondent No. 1
Centre is not entitled to compensation towards loss of love and
affection.
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
18.
In conclusion, in light of the above discussions and
findings, the compensation stands re-calculated and modified,
as follows;
Monthly Income of the deceased
Rs.10,000.00
Annual Income of the deceased (Rs.10,000x12)
Rs.1,20,000.00
Add 40% of Rs.1,20,000.00 as future prospects
Rs.48,000.00
Yearly income of the deceased
Rs.1,68,000.00
Less 1/2 of Rs.1,68,000.00
[deducted from the said amount in consideration of
the instances which the victim would have incurred
towards maintenance had he been alive.]
Rs.84,000.00
Net yearly income
Rs.84,000.00
Multiplier of ‘16’ adopted in terms of
Sarla Verma’s case (supra) (Rs.84,000 x 16)
Rs.13,44,000.00
Add Funeral expenses
Rs.15,000.00
Add Loss of estate
Rs.15,000.00
Total
Rs.13,74,000.00
(Rupees thirteen lakhs and seventy four thousand) only.
19.
The Respondent No. 1 Centre shall be entitled to simple
interest @ 9% per annum on the above amount, with effect
from the date of filing of the Claim Petition before the learned
Tribunal, until its full realisation.
20.
The Appellant is directed to pay the awarded amount to
the Respondent No. 1 Centre within one month from today,
failing which, the Appellant shall pay simple interest @ 12% per
annum from the date of filing of the Claim Petition till
realisation, duly deducting the amounts, if any, already paid by
the Appellant to the Respondent No. 1 Centre.
21.
Appeal allowed to the extent above.
MAC App. No. 01 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Sa-Ngor Chotshog Centre and Anr.
22.
No order as to costs.
23.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the learned Tribunal for
information.
24.
Records of the learned Tribunal be remitted forthwith.
(Meenakshi Madan Rai)
Judge
10.04.2019
Approved for reporting: Yes
Internet: Yes
ml
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review