Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 8th MAY, 2019
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IA No.01 of 2018 in MAC App. No.05 of 2018
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd.
versus
Respondents :
Jarun Maya Rai and Others
Application under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 read with Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Manish Kr. Jain, Advocate for the Appellant.
Ms. Yanzee Pinasha, Advocate for Respondent No.1.
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Advocate (Legal Aid) for Respondent No.2.
Ms. Panila Theengh and Ms. Tashi Doma Bhutia, Advocates
for Respondents No.3 and 4.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O R D E R (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioner/Appellant-Insurance Company, seeks
condonation of 107 days delay in filing the Appeal, which assails
the Judgment and Award of the Learned Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal, South Sikkim, at Namchi (hereinafter, Claims Tribunal),
in MACT Case No.01 of 2016 (Branch Manager, Reliance
Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Smt. Jarun Maya Rai and Others) and
MACT Case No.11 of 2014 (Deki Lepcha vs. Bir Bahadur Rai and
Others). The Petition is purported to be under Section 173(1) of
I.A. No.01 of 2019 in MAC App. No.05 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited
vs. Jarun Maya Rai and Others
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (hereinafter, MV Act), read with
Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 (hereinafter, Limitation
Act).
2.
The grounds averred in the Petition for delay which
was filed on 24-05-2018 are as follows;
“………………………………………………………………………………………
1.
That this day, the petitioner/Appellant has filed an Appeal
challenging the judgment and Award passed by the
Learned Member, Motor Accident Claim Tribunal, South
Sikkim at Namchi, in MACT case No.01 of 2016 (Branch
Manager Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd versus Smt.
Jarun Maya Rai and others) along with the impugned
judgment of MACT Case no.11 of 2014 (Deki Lepcha
versus Bir Bahadur Rai and Others).
2.
That the judgment in the aforesaid case was pronounced
by the Ld. Claim Tribunal (sic) on 11/9/2017 as such
the appeal challenging the said judgment ought to have
been filed by the petitioner appellant on or before the
11/12/2017. The appeal was filed on the said date and
there was no delay initially in filling (sic) the appeal
before this Hon’ble Court.
3.
That on the said date the said memo could not be
registered due to certain defects which were cleared and
re-filed before this Hon’ble Court on 01/02/2018. The
delay in curing the defects was due to the sending the
entire file again to its regional office at Kolkatta, taking
legal opinion and sending the same for filling (sic) before
this Hon’ble Court.
4.
That on the said date there were again defects stating
that the memo of appeal have to filed along with the
petition of condonation of delay petition, hence this
petition has been filed today.
5.
That the application for certified copies of the judgment
was made on 16/12/2013 and the same was obtained
on 28/12/2013 when the information was given by its
investigator. Thereafter, the entire file was sent to the
Kolkatta for seeking it legal opinion in the instant matter
(sic).
6.
That thereafter the advocate informed the company about
the said facts and finally the Appellant company had
taken decision to file the appeal along with the petition of
condonation of delay. There has been a delay of 107
days in filling (sic) the instant appeal before the Hon’ble
High Court. There has been delay in filling (sic) the
I.A. No.01 of 2019 in MAC App. No.05 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited
vs. Jarun Maya Rai and Others
appeal but same was on account of circumstances beyond
the control of parties mentioned herein above.
7.
That this petition praying for condonation of delay of 107
days has been filed bonafide for the ends of justice.
8.
That the accompanying memo of appeal may be read as
part and parcel of this petition and the appellant may be
allowed to refer and rely upon the same during the time
of hearing of the petition.
9.
That the appellant state that the memo of appeal has
been filed on account challenging the false and fabricated
insurance policy which has not been issued by the
appellant company and the Learned Member Tribunal
have wrongly fastened the liability upon the Appellant.
………………………………………………………………………………………”
It was thus prayed that the delay be condoned.
3.
While making his verbal submissions before this
Court, Learned Counsel for the Appellant admitted to some
errors in the averments made in the said Petition, viz., the dates
pertaining to application for certified copy of the Judgment
having been made on 16-12-2013 and obtained on 28-12-2013,
whereas challenge was to the Judgment in MACT Case No. 11 of
2014, dated 30-05-2015.
It was further urged that the errors
may be ignored by the Court which are inadvertent. That, this
Court may kindly consider the pith and substance of the Petition
inasmuch as 107 days delay has been explained in the
averments and that the delay be condoned in the larger interest
of justice.
4.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent No.1 objected
to the Application for delay and contended that a Review
Application had been filed before the Learned Claims Tribunal on
19-03-2016 against the impugned Judgment dated 30-05-2015,
I.A. No.01 of 2019 in MAC App. No.05 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited
vs. Jarun Maya Rai and Others
of which the Order was pronounced on 11-09-2017.
Thus, a
period of 262 days had lapsed in the interim which has not been
addressed by the Appellant in his Petition.
Consequently, the
delay has not been computed correctly, besides which no
provision for review emanates in the MV Act and the Petition
deserves a dismissal.
5.
Objecting to the Petition, Learned Counsel for the
Respondent No.2 for his part contended that the period of
limitation
started
to
run
from
30-05-2015,
the
date
of
pronouncement of the impugned Judgment and Award in MACT
Case No.11 of 2014, hence the delay has been wrongly
calculated as the Appeal before this Court was filed only on 2405-2018.
That, no right accrues under Section 173 of the MV
Act to file a Review Petition, which was however resorted to by
the Appellant before the Learned Claims Tribunal culminating in
the Order rejection by the Tribunal, dated 11-09-2017.
That,
the Petition has been drafted with no attention to detail, hence if
the averments were to be considered, the application seeking a
copy of the impugned Judgment has been made before its
pronouncement, which is indeed congruous. For the reason that
the Petition details no sufficient grounds for the delay, has been
filed carelessly with no attention to the averments made therein,
the Petition ought to be dismissed.
6.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.3 and 4
also objected to the Petition inter alia submitting that the
I.A. No.01 of 2019 in MAC App. No.05 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited
vs. Jarun Maya Rai and Others
Petition neither satisfies nor falls within the ambit of Section
173(1) of the MV Act read with Section 5 of the Limitation Act.
Hence, the Application is not maintainable.
7.
Careful consideration has been afforded to the rival
contentions of Learned Counsel for the parties and records
before this Court perused meticulously.
8.
Having considered the entire materials placed before
me and the submissions of Learned Counsel for the parties, I
deem it essential to narrate the matter with clarity herein.
The
Appellant is assailing the Judgment dated 30-05-2015 in MACT
Case No.11 of 2014 (Deki Lepcha and Others vs. Bir Bahadur Rai
and Others) of the Learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal,
South Sikkim, at Namchi (Learned Claims Tribunal). Evidently,
this matter had been filed before the Learned Claims Tribunal
and Judgment as already stated pronounced on 30-05-2015.
Against this Judgment and Award, the Appellant-Insurance
Company preferred a Review Petition before the same Learned
Claims Tribunal being MACT (Review) Case No.01 of 2016. The
Order of the Learned Claims Tribunal came to be pronounced on
11-09-2017 rejecting the Review Petition. It thus transpires that
the Appellant now assails both the Judgment supra and Review
Petition supra. Neither the averments made by the Petitioner nor
the verbal submission of Learned Counsel for the Petitioner have
articulated these circumstances with clarity.
I.A. No.01 of 2019 in MAC App. No.05 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited
9.
Following
this
is
the
vs. Jarun Maya Rai and Others
anomaly
that
arises
in
Paragraph 5 of the averments in the Petition wherein the
Appellant has stated that he had made an application for
certified copy of the Judgment on 16-12-2013 which was
obtained on 28-12-2013 when information was given by its
Investigator.
It is indeed appalling that such a blatant error
obtains in the averments and it is incomprehensible as to how
certified copies of the impugned Judgment could be sought for in
December, 2013, when the impugned Judgment was pronounced
only on 30-05-2015.
What information the Investigator has
given, who the Investigator averred to in the said paragraph
was, also remains a mystery and which copy was obtained on
28-12-2013 compounds the already mysterious circumstances.
The Appellant has also while seeking condonation of 107 days
failed to explain the date from which he has computed the period
of limitation.
10.
The grounds given for the delay are nothing short of
pathetic since all that emerges therein besides the above
anomalies is that the File went from Gangtok to Kolkata and
back. The Appellant has exhibited a lackadaisical attitude while
filing the Petition and dealt with it not only in a routine manner,
but by harbouring the notion that the Courts are without doubt
to adjudicate for justice dispensation and thereby perforce to
condone the delay.
I.A. No.01 of 2019 in MAC App. No.05 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited
11.
In
this
context,
we
may
vs. Jarun Maya Rai and Others
now
refer
to
the
observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Esha Bhattacharjee
vs. Managing Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar Academy and
Others1
while referring to various authorities on condonation of
delay has summarised guiding principles for condonation or
otherwise inter alia as follows;
“22. To the aforesaid principles we may add
some more guidelines taking note of the present
day scenario. They are:
22.1. (a) An application for condonation of
delay should be drafted with careful concern and
not in a haphazard manner harbouring the notion
that the courts are required to condone delay on
the bedrock of the principle that adjudication of a
lis on merits is seminal to justice dispensation
system.
22.2. (b) An application for condonation of
delay should not be dealt with in a routine manner
on the base of individual philosophy which is
basically subjective.
22.3. (c) Though no precise formula can be
laid down regard being had to the concept of
judicial discretion, yet a conscious effort for
achieving consistency and collegiality of the
adjudicatory system should be made as that is the
ultimate institutional motto.
22.4. (d) The increasing tendency to
perceive delay as a non-serious matter and, hence,
lackadaisical propensity can be exhibited in a
nonchallant manner requires to be curbed, of
course, within legal parameters.”
12.
These principles are to be the guiding light for the
Courts while considering delay Petitions in addition to the other
points laid down in the Judgment. The conduct and confidence
that the Appellant exudes reflects the belief that the Court has
no other option but to condone the delay as the lis is to be
(2013) 12 SCC 649
I.A. No.01 of 2019 in MAC App. No.05 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Reliance General Insurance Company Limited
vs. Jarun Maya Rai and Others
adjudicated on merits, this attitude is indeed misplaced.
The
Petition has been filed with nary a care to detail nor was any
light thrown to explain the delay, therefore resulting in failure to
enumerate sufficient grounds.
Besides, as pointed out by
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.3 and 4, the Appellant
has invoked the incorrect provision of law for condonation of
delay, inasmuch as Section 173(1) of the MV Act lays down that
subject to the provisions of Sub-Section (2) any person
aggrieved by an award of a Claims Tribunal may, within ninety
days from the date of the award, prefer an Appeal to the High
Court. It is infact the second proviso to Section 173 of the MV
Act which is the relevant provision which is to be invoked and
the High Court may entertain the Appeal after the expiry of
ninety days, if it is satisfied that the Appellant was prevented by
sufficient cause from preferring the Appeal in time.
No such
grounds have been put forth as obtains from the discussions
which have ensued hereinabove.
13.
Hence, in conclusion, in view of the totality of the
facts and circumstances, the Petition for condonation of delay
deserves no consideration and is accordingly dismissed as also
the Appeal.
( Justice Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
08-05-2019
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review