Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM, GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
--------------------------------------------------------------HON’BLE SHRI SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, A.C.J.
--------------------------------------------------------------C.M. Appl No. 247 of 2015
in
MAC App No. 21 of 2015
The Branch Manager,
Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Himalaya House, 8th Floor,
38-B, J.L. Nehru Road,
Kolkata – 700 071.
...
APPELLANT
...
RESPONDENTS
Versus
1.
Smt. Ali Maya Sharma,
D/o Parmananda Sharma,
Saureni Assem Lingzey,
East Sikkim.
2.
Suraj Maya Sherpa,
Wife of Shri P.G. Sherpa,
R/o Nimachen, Rongli,
East Sikkim.
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988.
-------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance :
Mr. Manish Kr. Jain, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. N. Rai, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chettri,
Advocate for Respondent No. 1.
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Advocate for Respondent No. 2.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
JUDGMENT
(18.07.2016)
SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, ACJ.
The instant Appeal is directed against the Judgment
and Award dated 29.11.2013 rendered by the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, East and North Sikkim at Gangtok (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the Tribunal”), whereunder, the appellant herein
was directed to pay compensation to the tune of Rs.5,94,732.59
(Rupees five lakh ninety four thousand seven hundred thirty two
and paise fifty-nine) only with interest @ 10 % per annum to
the Claimant-first Respondent, herein.
The claim petition was
filed under Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (M.V.
Act) against the appellant-Insurance Company as well as the
owner of the vehicle, second-Respondent, seeking compensation
to the tune of Rs.5,20,071.39.
2.
The facts, in brief, leading to filing of the instant
Appeal, are that the first-respondent, an old lady, met with an
accident, while walking on the road side at Jalipool, East Sikkim
on 15.07.2011, as hit by the vehicle Tata Tipper Truck bearing
registration No. SK-03/3074.
She sustained 60% locomotor
disability, as certified by the Central Referral Hospital, Tadong.
It was noticed that the first-respondent was aged about 60
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
years at the time of accident. The learned Tribunal holding the
notional income of the claimant/first-respondent as Rs.3,000/per month, being the house-wife, held that the Insurance
Company is fully liable, on the premise that the vehicle was fully
insured at the time of accident.
compensation
on
different
The Tribunal calculated the
heads
i.e.
loss
of
earning,
transportation to hospital, medical expenses, future medical
expenses and pain and suffering, and determined the total sum
to the tune of Rs.5,94,732.59.
Resultantly, the Tribunal
awarded the said sum with an interest of 10% per annum from
the date of filing of Claim Petition till full and final payment is
made.
During
pendency
of
this
Appeal,
the
entire
compensation amount is paid.
3.
It is appropriate to mention that the appellant herein
was ex-parte, as the appellant did not appear and participate in
the trial before the Tribunal.
Feeling aggrieved, the instant
Appeal is filed under the provision of Section 173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988.
Along with the appeal, the appellant has
preferred an application for condonation of delay of 532 days.
Reasons for the condonation of delay as projected by the
appellant/applicant are that the appeal is required to be filed on
or before 28.02.2014 as the impugned judgment and award was
pronounced on 29.11.2013.
It is stated that the application for
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
obtaining the certified copy of the said judgment and award was
made on 16.12.2013 which was made available on 28.12.2013.
Thereafter time was taken to obtain opinion and as such delay
to the extent of 532 days was bona fide, which deserves to be
condoned.
The appellant/applicant was given one more
opportunity to file better particulars.
Subsequently, it was
stated that the file of the case reached the office of the
appellant in January, 2014, thereafter, 2 - 3 months time was
taken for opinion. In the meantime, certain relevant documents
were to be located and the investigator took the task of locating
the documents. The investigator collected the documents from
all authorities including the police and completed the collection
of documents by the end of September, 2014. Thereafter, the
file was sent to the office of the Advocate in the month of
October, 2014.
Some more documents were required by the
Advocate as such further documents were collected and sent
back to the office of the Advocate by the end of month of
December, 2014.
On receipt of such documents, a draft appeal
was prepared and sent to the office of the appellant at Kolkata
for vetting and signing. The draft appeal was sent back to the
concerned Advocate for incorporation of some more points and
the same could reach the office of the Advocate only in the
month of February, 2015. Again it was referred to the office of
the appellant for signing in the month of March, 2015.
Some
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
more time was taken to file the appeal, which according to the
appellant/applicant was subsequently filed
on
26.08.2015.
Thus, the delay caused on account of movement of file as
aforestated is bona fide and deserves to be condoned in the
interest of justice.
4.
Learned
applicant
would
counsel
submit
appearing
that
the
for
instant
the
appellant/
Appeal
raises
substantive question of law as to whether the claimant/firstrespondent is entitled to compensation on account of 60%
locomotor disability to the tune of Rs.5,94,732.59 when the
earning of claimant is not proved as no certificate to that effect
has been provided and also the entire calculation made by the
learned Tribunal is erroneous. It is further contented that rash
and negligent driving was proved on the basis of charge-sheet
without any credible facts.
Thus, in the light of aforesaid
substantial questions of law, the delay deserves to be condoned.
Referring to the decision of the Supreme Court in Esha
Bhattacharjee vs. Managing Committee of Raghunathpur
Nafar Academy and others1, wherein the Supreme Court has
laid down general principles for condonation of delay, Mr. Jain
would submit that substantial justice being paramount and
pivotal the technical consideration i.e. non explanation of delay,
may be ignored.
------------------------1
(2013) 12 SCC 649
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
5.
Mr. Jain further relied on a decision of the Supreme
Court in State of Haryana vs. Chandra Mani and others2,
wherein the Supreme Court held that when the State is an
applicant praying for condonation of delay, certain amount of
latitude is permissible.
6.
On the other hand, Mr. N. Rai, learned Senior
Counsel appearing for Respondent No. 1 would submit that the
appellant/applicant had not shown any bona fide reasons as
explained in the application.
The reasons shown are not such
as may come within the ambit of “sufficient cause”. Learned
Senior Counsel would further submit that even otherwise there
is
no
substantial
question
of
law
which
may
outweigh
unexplained reasons set out by the appellant/ applicant.
It is
further contended by the learned Senior Counsel that the
appellant/applicant has not appeared before the Tribunal and as
such the applicant be not permitted to raise any contentions and
ground in the appeal under the provisions of Section 149 of the
M.V. Act.
7.
In rejoinder, referring to a decision of the Supreme
Court in United India Insurance Company Limited vs. Shila
Datta and others3, Mr. Jain would contend that the appellant-----------------------2
(1996) 3 SCC 132
(2011) 10 SCC 509
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
Insurance Company, being a party-respondent, is entitled to
urge all grounds which may be available to it.
8.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the
pleadings and documents appended thereto.
9.
Firstly, I take up the ground as to whether the
appellant is entitled to urge any ground in the appeal when the
appellant had not appeared before the Tribunal.
10.
Indisputably, the appellant-Insurance Company was
a party-respondent to the claim petition and not a mere noticee
and as such there is no estoppel against the appellantInsurance Company to file an appeal and urge all contentions
available to it. The Supreme Court in United India Insurance
Co. Ltd. (supra) has laid down the principles as under:
“14.
When an insurer is impleaded as a party-respondent
to the claim petition, as contrasted from merely being a
noticee under Section 149(2) of the Act, its rights are
significantly different. If the insurer is only a noticee, it
can only raise such of those grounds as are permissible in
law under Section 149(2). But if he is a party-respondent,
it can raise, not only those grounds which are available
under section 149 (2), but also all other grounds that are
available to a person against whom a claim is made. It,
therefore, follows that if a claimant impleads the insurer as
a party-respondent, for whatever reason, then as such
respondent, the insurer will be entitled to urge all
contentions and grounds which may be available to it.
15.
The Act does not require the claimants to implead
the insurer as a party-respondent.
But if the claimants
choose to implead the insurer as a party, not being a
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
noticee under Section 149(2), the insurer can urge all
grounds
and
not
necessarily
the
limited
grounds
mentioned in Section 149(2) of the Act. If the insurer is
already a respondent (having been impleaded as a partyrespondent), it need not seek the permission of the
Tribunal under Section 170 of the Act to raise grounds
other than those mentioned in Section 149(2) of the Act.”
11.
In the light of aforestated, I am of the considered
view that the appellant being a party-respondent before the
Tribunal is entitled to urge all contentions and grounds available
to it.
12.
On the question of limitation, as the facts posited by
the appellant/applicant and stated hereinabove, clearly indicate
that the appellant/applicant is not diligent in taking up the
matter within reasonable time.
The appellant/applicant very
well knew the limitation as statutorily required. The Supreme
Court
in
Esha
Bhattacharjee
principles broadly,
clearly laid
(supra),
down
while
inter
alia,
laying
the
that
the
“sufficient cause” should be understood in its proper spirit,
philosophy and purpose, in proper perspective to the obtaining
fact-situation. Substantial justice being paramount and pivotal,
the technical considerations should not be given undue and
uncalled for emphasis. Further it is held that lack of bona fides
imputable to party seeking condonation of delay is a significant
and relevant fact.
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
13.
It is not a case, where the substantial injustice as
claimed by the appellant/applicant, has been caused in the facts
of the case, when an old lady of 60 years was hit by a duly
insured vehicle which resulted into permanent disability.
The
amount of compensation is also not so exorbitant which can be
held as antithetical to substantial justice. The movement of files
is not fully and properly explained, thus, it lacks complete bona
fide.
The appellant/applicant has taken months together for
collection of documents without explaining as to what were the
documents needed for filing the appeal.
Substantial time was
taken for sending the file from the office of the Advocate to the
office of the appellant, when professional ethics requires the
officer in-charge to sit with the Advocate with all the files and
swear the affidavit in presence of the Advocate concerned.
Signing of documents and affidavit from the office of the
appellant would not subserve the interest of justice.
14.
The question as to whether the State or a public
authority is entitled to certain amount of latitude came up for
consideration
in
Commissioner
of
Wealth
Tax, Bombay vs. Amateur Riders Club, Bombay4, the
Supreme Court while dismissing the Application for condonation
of delay, held as under: “3.
This explanation is incapable of furnishing a
judicially acceptable ground for condonation of delay.
After the earlier observations of this Court made in
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
several cases in the past, we hoped that the matters
might improve. There seems to be no visible support for
this optimism. There is a point beyond which even the
courts cannot help a litigant even if the litigant is
Government which is itself under the shackles of
bureaucratic indifference. Having regard to the law of
limitation which binds everybody, we cannot find any
----------------------------------4
1994 Supp (2) SCC 603
way of granting relief. It is true that the Government
should not be treated as any other private litigant as,
indeed, in the case of the former the decisions to
present and prosecute appeals are not individual but are
institutional decisions necessarily bogged down by the
proverbial red-tape. But there are limits to this also.
Even with all this latitude, the explanation offered for
the delay in this case merely serves to aggravate the
attitude of indifference of the Revenue in protecting its
common interests. The affidavit is again one of the
stereotyped affidavits making it susceptible to the
criticism that the Revenue does not seem to attach any
importance to the need for promptitude even where it
affects its own interest.”
15.
Further, in State of Haryana vs. Chandra Mani
and others (supra), the Supreme Court held as under: -
“11.
………………………..
It
is
equally
common
knowledge that litigants including the State are accorded
the same treatment and the law is administered in an
even-handed manner.
When the State is an applicant,
praying for condonation of delay, it is common knowledge
that on account of impersonal machinery and the inherited
bureaucratic methodology imbued with the note-making,
file-pushing, and passing-on-the-buck ethos, delay on
the part of the State is less difficult to understand though
more difficult to approve, but the State represents
collective cause of the community.
It is axiomatic that
decisions are taken by officers/agencies proverbially at
slow pace and encumbered process of pushing the files
from
table
to
table
and
keeping
it
on
table
for
considerable time causing delay – intentional or otherwise
– is a routine. Considerable delay of procedural red-tape
in the process of their making decision is a common
feature.
Therefore, certain amount of latitude is not
impermissible. If the appeals brought by the State are lost
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
for such default no person is individually affected but what
in the ultimate analysis suffers, is public interest.
The
expression
be
“sufficient
cause”
should,
therefore,
considered with pragmatism in justice-oriented approach
rather than the technical detection of sufficient cause for
explaining every day’s delay.
The factors which are
peculiar to and characteristic of the functioning of the
governmental conditions would be cognizant to and
requires adoption of pragmatic approach in justiceoriented process. The court should decide the matters on
merits unless the case is hopelessly without merit.
No
separate standards to determine the cause laid by the
State vis-à-vis private litigant could be laid to prove strict
standards of sufficient cause. ………….”
16.
In an another case, N.
Krishnamurthy5
the
Supreme
Balakrishnan
Court,
while
vs.
holding
M.
that
condonation of delay is a matter of discretion of the Court, held
as under: “11. Rules of limitation are not meant to destroy the
rights of parties. They are meant to see that parties do
not resort to dilatory tactics, but seek their remedy
promptly. The object of providing a legal remedy is to
repair the damage caused by reason of legal injury. The
law of limitation fixes a lifespan for such legal remedy
for the redress of the legal injury so suffered. Time is
precious and wasted time would never revisit. During
the efflux of time, newer causes would sprout up
necessitating newer persons to seek legal remedy by
approaching the courts. So a lifespan must be fixed for
each remedy.
Unending period for launching the
remedy may lead to unending uncertainty and
consequential anarchy. The law of limitation is thus
founded on public policy. It is enshrined in the maxim
interest reipublicae up sit finis litium (it is for the general
welfare that a period be put to litigation). Rules of
limitation are not meant to destroy the rights of the
parties. They are meant
to see that parties do not
resort
to dilatory tactics but seek their remedy
promptly. The idea is that every legal remedy must be
kept alive for a legislatively fixed period of time.”
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
17.
Subsequently, in Pundlik Jalam Patil (Dead) by
Lrs. Vs. Executive Engineer, Jalgaon Medium Project and
Another6, wherein the State filed the Application before the
High Court seeking condonation of delay of 1724 days in filing
the Appeal against the Award passed by the Civil Judge, the
Supreme Court held as under: ----------------------------5
(1998) 7 SCC 123
(2008) 17 SCC 448
“29. It needs no restatement at our hands that the
object for fixing time-limit for litigation is based on
public policy fixing a lifespan for legal remedy for the
purpose of general welfare. They are meant to see that
the parties do not resort to dilatory tactics but avail their
legal remedies promptly. Salmond in his Jurisprudence
states that the laws come to the assistance of the
vigilant and not of the sleepy.
30.
………………………………….
31.
It is true that when the State and its
instrumentalities are the applicants seeking condonation
of delay they may be entitled to certain amount of
latitude but the law of limitation is same for citizen and
for governmental authorities. The Limitation Act does
not provide for a different period to the Government in
filing appeals or applications as such. It would be a
different matter where the Government makes out a
case where public interest was shown to have suffered
owing to acts of fraud or collusion on the part of its
officers or agents and where the officers were clearly at
cross purposes with it. In a given case if any such facts
are pleaded or proved they cannot be excluded from
consideration and those factors may go into the judicial
verdict. In the present case, no such facts are pleaded
and proved though a feeble attempt by the learned
counsel for the respondent was made to suggest
collusion and fraud but without any basis. We cannot
entertain the submission made across the Bar without
there being any proper foundation in the pleadings.”
2016:SHC:105-DB
CMA No. 247 of 2015
B.M., Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Ali Maya Sharma & Ano.
18.
Applying the well settled principles as aforestated,
the public authorities are entitled to certain amount of latitude,
however, the reasons explained by them must be cogent and
credible.
In the case in hand, the reasons stated by the
appellant do not permit much latitude as sought for by the
appellant/applicant, for condonation of delay.
19.
In the aforesaid premises, I do not find any sufficient
cause necessitating condonation of delay.
application is rejected.
As a sequel, the
Consequently, the Appeal stands
dismissed. No order as to costs.
Sd/Acting Chief Justice
18.07.2016
Approved for Reporting
Internet
jk
: Yes
: Yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review