Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 1st November, 2021
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
:
Appellant
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited
versus
Respondent
:
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri and Others
Appeal under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
----------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Thupden G. Bhutia, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Tarun Choudhary, Advocate for the Respondents No.1 to 3.
None present for the Respondent No.4.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Issues raised in the instant Appeal pertain to the
deduction of one-third of the income of the deceased, a thirty one
year old bachelor, in consideration of the expenses which he would
have incurred towards maintaining himself had he been alive, when
the deduction instead, it is asserted, ought to have been 50%.
That, considering the age of the deceased, the Multiplier of “16”
ought to have been adopted by the Learned Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, South Sikkim at Namchi, instead of “17” for the purpose
of calculating the Loss of Earning of the deceased, in terms of the
ratio of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sarla Verma (Smt) and Others
vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 1.
Rs.25,000/-
(Rupees
twenty
five
Litigation Costs of
thousand)
only,
as
also
compensation towards Loss of Love and Affection of Rs.50,000/1
(2009) 6 SCC 121
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
(Rupees fifty thousand) only, each, granted to the Respondents
No.1, 2 and 3/Claimants, were also assailed.
2.(i)
The arguments put forth by Learned Counsel for the
Appellant/National
Insurance
Company Limited
was that the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the ratio of Sarla Verma supra had held
that if the deceased was a bachelor and the claim was filed by the
parents, the deduction would normally be 50% from the income, as
personal and living expenses of the bachelor. That, subject to
evidence to the contrary, the father was likely to have his own
income and would not be considered to be a dependant, hence the
mother alone would be considered to be a dependant. That, in the
absence of any evidence to the contrary, the brothers and sisters
of the deceased bachelor would not be considered as dependants
because they would usually either be independent and earning, or
married, or be dependant on the father. Thus, even if the deceased
was survived by the parents and siblings, only the mother would be
considered to be a dependant. The deduction of personal expenses
of a bachelor would be 50% and 50% would be the contribution to
the family. That, this observation was affirmed by the ratio in
Reshma Kumari vs. Madan Mohan2,
whereby the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that the standards fixed by the Court in Sarla Verma
supra on the aspect of deduction for personal and living expenses
must ordinarily be followed unless a case for departure is made out
by the Claimants. That, in the instant case, no such departure has
been shown by the Respondents No.1, 2 and 3/Claimants to justify
deduction of one-third only.
(2013) 9 SCC 65
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
That, for the determination of Multiplier, in the ratio of
(ii)
Sarla
Verma
supra,
the
appropriate
choice
of
Multiplier
in
accordance with the age of the deceased had been prepared,
hence, the Multiplier to be adopted in the instant case was “16”
considering that the deceased was thirty one years of age at the
time of the accident and not the Multiplier of “17,” as erroneously
selected by the Learned Tribunal. That, in National Insurance
Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and Others3,
the Constitution
Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court propounded that reasonable
figures on Conventional Heads namely Loss of Estate, Loss of
Consortium and Funeral Expenses be made at the rate of
Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand) only, Rs.40,000/- (Rupees
forty thousand) only, and Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand)
only, respectively. The said Conventional Heads envisages no
calculation for “Loss of Love and Affection” or “Litigation Costs” as
included by the Learned Tribunal which has thus erroneously
calculated these amounts into the compensation to be granted to
the Respondents No.1 to 3. The Income Certificate Exhibit 12 of
the deceased, issued by the Block Development Officer, Block
Administrative
Centre,
Namchi
South
Sikkim,
bearing
Memo
No.2679/BAC (Namchi), dated 18.02.2017, was conceded as
correct and the Appellant chose not to contest the contents of the
document.
3.
While conceding to the arguments of Learned Counsel
for the Appellant that the Multiplier of “16” ought to have been
chosen by the Learned Tribunal instead of “17,” Learned Counsel
for the Respondents No.1 to 3 canvassing his stand, contended
(2017) 16 SCC 680
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
that “Loss of Love and Affection” calculated at Rs.50,000/- (Rupees
fifty thousand) only, each to the Respondents No.1 to 3 cannot be
said to be erroneous as the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Magma
General Insurance Company Limited vs. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram
and Others4, also allowed calculation in the compensation for “Loss
of Love and Affection.” That, further in the said Judgment, the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
interpreted
“Consortium”
to
be
a
compendious term which encompasses “Spousal Consortium,”
“Parental Compensation” as well as “Filial Consortium.” That, Filial
Consortium at the rate of Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand)
only, per parent, ought to have been added in terms of the law laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in this context. That, the
evidence on record reveals with clarity that all the family members
of the deceased were dependant on him including his sixty five
year old father. This evidence was not disputed or decimated by
the Appellant before the Learned Tribunal hence, apart from the
wrong
choice
of
Multiplier
made
by
the
Learned
Tribunal,
compensation awarded by the Learned Tribunal towards the head
of “Loss of Love and Affection” requires no interference, as also
deduction of one-third of the income of the deceased towards his
personal
and
living
expenses,
considering
the
number
of
dependants on him. Hence, the Appeal be allowed only to the
extent of choice of the Multiplier.
The rival submissions have been heard in extenso and
4.
all
documents
Judgment.
(2018) 18 SCC 130
on
record
perused,
including
the
impugned
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
5.
The Respondents No.1 to 3 were before the Learned
Tribunal with a Claim Petition under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, (for short, the “M.V. Act”). The deceased, aged
about thirty one years, being the son of Respondents No.1 and 2
and the brother of the Respondent No.3, earning a monthly income
of Rs.30,000/- (Rupees thirty thousand) only, succumbed to a
motor accident near Bhati Khola, Bhanjyang, South Sikkim on
26.03.2017 when travelling in vehicle bearing Registration No.SK04-P-1481 (Maruti Van) as its occupant. The Learned Tribunal, on
due consideration of the facts and evidence placed before it,
granted compensation amounting to Rs.42,85,000/- (Rupees forty
two lakhs and eighty five thousand) only, to the Respondents No.1
to 3 under the following heads;
Loss of Earning:
Rs.40,80,000/-
Funeral Expenses:
Rs.15,000/-
Loss of Estate:
Rs.15,000/-
Loss of Love and Affection:
Rs.1,50,000/-
Litigation Cost:
Rs.25,000/-
Total:
Rs.42,85,000/-
Hence, aggrieved with the said compensation awarded to the
Respondents No.1 to 3 on the grounds as reflected hereinabove,
the Appellant is before this Court.
6.(i)
On due consideration of the arguments placed before
me, it is relevant to note that the choice of Multiplier by the
Learned Tribunal is indeed erroneous in view of the categorical
pronouncement in Sarla Verma supra which had prepared a Chart
for fixing the applicable Multiplier in accordance with the age of the
deceased. Hence, the Multiplier to be adopted in the instant case,
as duly conceded by Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.1 to
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
3, is “16” and not “17” in consideration of the Victim being thirty
one years at the time of the accident.
(ii)
While considering the amount granted by the Learned
Tribunal under the head of “Loss of Love and Affection,” Learned
Counsel for the Respondents No.1 to 3 contended that the amount
stood justified in view of the pronouncement in Magma General
Insurance Company Limited supra. In this context, it is relevant to
mention that a Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Pranay
Sethi
supra
propounded
that
reasonable
figures
on
Conventional Heads such as Loss of Estate, Loss of Consortium and
Funeral Expenses should be included in the compensation at the
rate of Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand) only, Rs.40,000/(Rupees forty thousand) only
and Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen
thousand) only, respectively. In the subsequent Judgment of
Magma General Insurance Company Limited supra, a two Judge Bench
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, while granting compensation to the
Claimants therein, had included “Loss of Love and Affection” under
the heads while calculating the compensation.
(iii)
It may be apposite to notice that in Pranay Sethi, supra
the Hon’ble Supreme Court had expounded the concept of “binding
precedents” and held inter alia as follows;
“15. Presently, we may refer to certain decisions which
deal with the concept of binding precedent.
16. In State
of
Bihar v. Kalika
Kuer [State
of
Bihar v. Kalika Kuer, (2003) 5 SCC 448], it has been held:
(SCC p. 454, para 10)
“10. … an earlier decision may seem to be incorrect to a
Bench of a coordinate jurisdiction considering the question
later, on the ground that a possible aspect of the matter
was not considered or not raised before the court or more
aspects should have been gone into by the court deciding
the matter earlier but it would not be a reason to say that
the decision was rendered per incuriam and liable to be
ignored. The earlier judgment may seem to be not correct
yet it will have the binding effect on the later Bench of
coordinate jurisdiction. …”
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
The Court has further ruled: (SCC p. 454, para 10)
“10. … Easy course of saying that earlier decision
was rendered per incuriam is not permissible and the
matter will have to be resolved only in two ways — either
to follow the earlier decision or refer the matter to a larger
Bench to examine the issue, in case it is felt that earlier
decision is not correct on merits.”
17. In G.L. Batra v. State of Haryana [G.L.Batra
v. State of Haryana, (2014) 13 SCC 759 : (2015) 3 SCC
(L&S) 575], the Court has accepted the said principle on the
basis of judgments of this Court rendered in Union of
India v. Godfrey Philips India Ltd. [Union of India v. Godfrey
Philips India Ltd., (1985) 4 SCC 369: 1986 SCC (Tax)
11], Sundarjas
Kanyalal
Bhatija v. Collector,
Thane [Sundarjas Kanyalal Bhatija v. Collector, Thane,
(1989) 3 SCC 396] and Tribhovandas Purshottamdas
Thakkar v. Ratilal
Motilal
Patel
[Tribhovandas
Purshottamdas Thakkar v. Ratilal Motilal Patel, AIR 1968 SC
372]. It may be noted here that the Constitution Bench
in Madras Bar Assn. v. Union of India [Madras Bar
Assn. v. Union of India, (2015) 8 SCC 583] has clearly
stated that the prior Constitution Bench judgment in Union
of India v. Madras Bar Assn. [Union of India v. Madras Bar
Assn., (2010) 11 SCC 1] is a binding precedent. Be it
clarified, the issues that were put to rest in the earlier
Constitution Bench judgment were treated as precedents by
the later Constitution Bench.
20. In the context, we may fruitfully note what has
been stated in Pradip Chandra Parija v. Pramod Chandra
Patnaik [Pradip Chandra Parija v. Pramod Chandra Patnaik,
(2002) 1 SCC 1]. In the said case, the Constitution Bench
was dealing with a situation where the two-Judge Bench
[Pradip Chandra Parija v. Pramod Chandra Patnaik, Civil
Appeal No. 791 of 1993, order dated 24-10-1996 (SC)]
disagreeing with the three-Judge Bench [Nityananda
Kar v. State of Orissa, 1991 Supp (2) SCC 516 : 1992 SCC
(L&S) 177] decision directed the matter to be placed before
a larger Bench of five Judges of this Court. In that scenario,
the Constitution Bench stated : (SCC p. 4, para 6)
“6. … In our view, judicial discipline and propriety
demands that a Bench of two learned Judges should follow
a decision of a Bench of three learned Judges. But if a
Bench of two learned Judges concludes that an earlier
judgment of three learned Judges is so very incorrect that
in no circumstances can it be followed, the proper course
for it to adopt is to refer the matter before it to a Bench of
three learned Judges setting out, as has been done here,
the reasons why it could not agree with the earlier
judgment. …”
21. In Chandra Prakash v. State of U.P. [Chandra
Prakash v. State of U.P., (2002) 4 SCC 234 : 2002 SCC
(L&S) 496] , another Constitution Bench dealing with the
concept of precedents stated thus : (SCC p. 245, para 22)
“22. …The doctrine of binding precedent is of utmost
importance in the administration of our judicial system. It
promotes certainty and consistency in judicial decisions.
Judicial consistency promotes confidence in the system,
therefore, there is this need for consistency in the
enunciation of legal principles in the decisions of this
Court. It is in the above context, this Court in Raghubir
Singh [Union of India v. Raghubir Singh, (1989) 2 SCC
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
754] held that a pronouncement of law by a Division
Bench of this Court is binding on a Division Bench of the
same or smaller number of Judges. …”
24. In Rajesh [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9 SCC
54: (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 817 :
(2014) 1 SCC (L&S) 149] the three-Judge Bench had
delivered the judgment on 12-4-2013. The purpose of
stating the date is that it has been delivered after the
pronouncement made in Reshma Kumari case [Reshma
Kumari v. Madan Mohan, (2013) 9 SCC 65 : (2013) 4 SCC
(Civ) 191 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 826]. On a perusal of the
decision in Rajesh [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9 SCC 54
: (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 817 : (2014)
1 SCC (L&S) 149], we find that an attempt has been made
to explain what the two-Judge Bench had stated in Santosh
Devi [Santosh Devi v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., (2012) 6
SCC 421 : (2012) 3 SCC (Civ) 726 : (2012) 3 SCC (Cri) 160
: (2012) 2 SCC (L&S) 167]. The relevant passages read as
follows: (Rajesh case [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9 SCC
54 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 817 :
(2014) 1 SCC (L&S) 149] , SCC p. 61, paras 8-9)
“8. Since, the Court in Santosh Devi case [Santosh
Devi v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., (2012) 6 SCC 421 :
(2012) 3 SCC (Civ) 726 : (2012) 3 SCC (Cri) 160 : (2012)
2 SCC (L&S) 167] actually intended to follow the principle
in the case of salaried persons as laid down in Sarla
Verma case [Sarla Verma v. DTC, (2009) 6 SCC 121 :
(2009) 2 SCC (Civ) 770 : (2009) 2 SCC (Cri) 1002] and to
make it applicable also to the self-employed and persons
on fixed wages, it is clarified that the increase in the case
of those groups is not 30% always; it will also have a
reference to the age. In other words, in the case of selfemployed or persons with fixed wages, in case, the
deceased victim was below 40 years, there must be an
addition of 50% to the actual income of the deceased
while computing future prospects. Needless to say that the
actual income should be income after paying the tax, if
any. Addition should be 30% in case the deceased was in
the age group of 40 to 50 years.
9. In Sarla Verma case [Sarla Verma v. DTC, (2009)
6 SCC 121 : (2009) 2 SCC (Civ) 770 : (2009) 2 SCC (Cri)
1002], it has been stated that in the case of those above
50 years, there shall be no addition. Having regard to the
fact that in the case of those self-employed or on fixed
wages, where there is normally no age of superannuation,
we are of the view that it will only be just and equitable to
provide an addition of 15% in the case where the victim is
between the age group of 50 to 60 years so as to make
the compensation just, equitable, fair and reasonable.
There shall normally be no addition thereafter.”
25. At this juncture, it is necessitous to advert to
another
three-Judge
Bench
decision
in Munna
Lal
Jain v. Vipin Kumar Sharma [Munna Lal Jain v. Vipin Kumar
Sharma, (2015) 6 SCC 347 : (2015) 3 SCC (Civ) 315 :
(2015) 4 SCC (Cri) 195]. In the said case, the three-Judge
Bench commenting on the judgments stated thus: (SCC p.
349, para 2)
“2. In the absence of any statutory and a straitjacket
formula, there are bound to be grey areas despite several
attempts made by this Court to lay down the guidelines.
Compensation would basically depend on the evidence
available in a case and the formulas shown by the courts
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
are only guidelines for the computation of the
compensation. That precisely is the reason the courts
lodge
a
caveat
stating
“ordinarily”,
“normally”,
“exceptional circumstances”, etc., while suggesting the
formula.”
26. After so stating, the Court followed the principle
stated in Rajesh [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9 SCC 54 :
(2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 817 : (2014) 1
SCC (L&S) 149] . We think it appropriate to reproduce what
has been stated by the three-Judge Bench : (Munna Lal Jain
case [Munna Lal Jain v. Vipin Kumar Sharma, (2015) 6 SCC
347 : (2015) 3 SCC (Civ) 315 : (2015) 4 SCC (Cri) 195],
SCC pp. 350-51, para 10)
“10. As far as future prospects are concerned,
in Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9
SCC 54 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 817
: (2014) 1 SCC (L&S) 149] , a three-Judge Bench of this
Court held that in case of self-employed persons also, if
the deceased victim is below 40 years, there must be
addition of 50% to the actual income of the deceased
while computing future prospects.”
27. We are compelled to state here that in Munna Lal
Jain [Munna Lal Jain v. Vipin Kumar Sharma, (2015) 6 SCC
347 : (2015) 3 SCC (Civ) 315 : (2015) 4 SCC (Cri) 195], the
three-Judge Bench should have been guided by the principle
stated in Reshma Kumari [Reshma Kumari v. Madan Mohan,
(2013) 9 SCC 65 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 191 : (2013) 3 SCC
(Cri) 826] which has concurred with the view expressed
in Sarla Verma [Sarla Verma v. DTC, (2009) 6 SCC 121 :
(2009) 2 SCC (Civ) 770 : (2009) 2 SCC (Cri) 1002] or in
case of disagreement, it should have been well advised to
refer the case to a larger Bench. We say so, as we have
already expressed the opinion that the dicta laid down
in Reshma Kumari [Reshma Kumari v. Madan Mohan, (2013)
9 SCC 65 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 191 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri)
826] being earlier in point of time would be a binding
precedent and not the decision in Rajesh [Rajesh v. Rajbir
Singh, (2013) 9 SCC 54 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3
SCC (Cri) 817 : (2014) 1 SCC (L&S) 149].
28. In this context, we may also refer to Sundeep
Kumar Bafna v. State of Maharashtra [Sundeep Kumar
Bafna v. State of Maharashtra, (2014) 16 SCC 623 : (2015)
3 SCC (Cri) 558] which correctly lays down the principle that
discipline demanded by a precedent or the disqualification or
diminution of a decision on the application of the per
incuriam rule is of great importance, since without it,
certainty of law, consistency of rulings and comity of courts
would become a costly casualty. A decision or judgment can
be per incuriam any provision in a statute, rule or regulation,
which was not brought to the notice of the court. A decision
or judgment can also be per incuriam if it is not possible to
reconcile its ratio with that of a previously pronounced
judgment of a co-equal or larger Bench. There can be no
scintilla of doubt that an earlier decision of co-equal Bench
binds the Bench of same strength. Though the judgment
in Rajesh case [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9 SCC 54 :
(2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 817 : (2014) 1
SCC (L&S) 149] was delivered on a later date, it had not
apprised itself of the law stated in Reshma Kumari [Reshma
Kumari v. Madan Mohan, (2013) 9 SCC 65 : (2013) 4 SCC
(Civ) 191 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 826] but had been guided
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
by Santosh Devi [Santosh Devi v. National Insurance Co.
Ltd., (2012) 6 SCC 421 : (2012) 3 SCC (Civ) 726 : (2012) 3
SCC (Cri) 160 : (2012) 2 SCC (L&S) 167]. We have no
hesitation that it is not a binding precedent on the co-equal
Bench.”
(iv)
With regard to “Conventional Heads,” the Hon’ble Court
in Pranay Sethi supra observed inter alia as hereunder;
“52. As far as the conventional heads are
concerned, we find it difficult to agree with the view
expressed in Rajesh [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9 SCC
54 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 817 :
(2014) 1 SCC (L&S) 149]. It has granted Rs 25,000 towards
funeral expenses, Rs 1,00,000 towards loss of consortium
and Rs 1,00,000 towards loss of care and guidance for minor
children. The head relating to loss of care and minor children
does not exist. Though Rajesh [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh,
(2013) 9 SCC 54 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC
(Cri) 817 : (2014) 1 SCC (L&S) 149] refers to Santosh
Devi [Santosh Devi v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., (2012) 6
SCC 421 : (2012) 3 SCC (Civ) 726 : (2012) 3 SCC (Cri) 160
: (2012) 2 SCC (L&S) 167], it does not seem to follow the
same. The conventional and traditional heads, needless to
say, cannot be determined on percentage basis because that
would not be an acceptable criterion. Unlike determination of
income, the said heads have to be quantified. Any
quantification must have a reasonable foundation. There can
be no dispute over the fact that price index, fall in bank
interest, escalation of rates in many a field have to be
noticed. The court cannot remain oblivious to the same.
There has been a thumb rule in this aspect. Otherwise, there
will be extreme difficulty in determination of the same and
unless the thumb rule is applied, there will be immense
variation lacking any kind of consistency as a consequence
of which, the orders passed by the tribunals and courts are
likely to be unguided. Therefore, we think it seemly to fix
reasonable sums. It seems to us that reasonable figures on
conventional heads, namely, loss of estate, loss of
consortium and funeral expenses should be Rs 15,000, Rs
40,000 and Rs 15,000 respectively. The principle of
revisiting the said heads is an acceptable principle. But the
revisit should not be fact-centric or quantum-centric. We
think that it would be condign that the amount that we have
quantified should be enhanced on percentage basis in every
three years and the enhancement should be at the rate of
10% in a span of three years. We are disposed to hold so
because that will bring in consistency in respect of those
heads.”
In view of the observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Pranay
Sethi
supra with regard to Binding Precedents and Conventional
Heads, the compensation for “Loss of Love and Affection” cannot
but be disregarded
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
Further, in terms of the Judgment in Sarla Verma supra,
(v)
the deduction of 50% is to be made as Loss of Earning from the
income of the deceased, as the personal and living expenses the
Victim would have incurred had he been alive, bearing in mind that
his age was thirty one at the time of the accident. That apart, only
the parents can be considered fully dependant on him, his sibling
being twenty one years at the time of the accident and therefore in
a position to make efforts to fend for herself.
It may be noticed that the Learned Tribunal has not
(vi)
granted “Loss of Consortium” in its compensation. Reverting back
to the decision in Magma General Insurance Company Limited supra,
the
said
ratio
discussed
“Consortium”
and
concluded
that
“Consortium” can be “Spousal Consortium,” “Parental Consortium”
and “Filial Consortium.” It was further propounded that Consortium
is a special prism reflecting changing norms about the status and
worth of actual relationships. That, modern jurisdictions world over
have recognized the value of a child's consortium which far exceeds
the economic value of the compensation awarded in the death of a
child. Most jurisdictions therefore permit parents to be awarded
compensation under loss of consortium on the death of a child. The
amount awarded to the parents is a compensation for loss of the
love, affection, care and companionship of a deceased child. That,
in case where a parent has lost their child, they are entitled to be
awarded Loss of Consortium under the head of “Filial Consortium.”
Considering that in the ratio of Pranay Sethi supra, “Loss of
Consortium” has been envisaged under the General Damages and
the decision in Magma General Insurance Company Limited supra, has
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
only expanded the concept therein, the Respondents No.1 and 2
are found entitled to “Filial Consortium.”
(vii)
That apart, the Learned Tribunal has also failed to
calculate and include “future prospects” of the deceased in the
compensation granted. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Pranay Sethi
supra, while discussing Future Prospects, inter alia held as follows;
“57. ……………………Taking into consideration the
cumulative factors, namely, passage of time, the changing
society, escalation of price, the change in price index, the
human attitude to follow a particular pattern of life, etc., an
addition of 40% of the established income of the deceased
towards future prospects and where the deceased was below
40 years an addition of 25% where the deceased was
between the age of 40 to 50 years would be reasonable.
…………………………
59.3 While
determining
the
income,
an
addition of 50% of actual salary to the income of the
deceased towards future prospects, where the
deceased had a permanent job and was below the age
of 40 years, should be made. The addition should be
30%, if the age of the deceased was between 40 to 50
years. In case the deceased was between the age of 50 to
60 years, the addition should be 15%. Actual salary should
be read as actual salary less tax.”
[Emphasis supplied]
(viii)
In Kirti and Another vs. Oriental Insurance Company
Limited5 the Hon’ble Court observed inter alia as under;
“12.Third and most importantly, it is unfair on part of
the respondent insurer to contest grant of future prospects
considering their submission before the High Court that such
compensation ought not to be paid pending outcome
of Pranay Sethi [National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi,
(2017) 16 SCC 680 : (2018) 3 SCC (Civ) 248 : (2018) 2 SCC
(Cri) 205] reference. Nevertheless, the law on this point is
no longer res integra, and stands crystallised, as is clear
from the following extract of the aforecited Constitutional
Bench judgment [National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay
Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680 : (2018) 3 SCC (Civ) 248 : (2018)
2 SCC (Cri) 205] : (SCC p. 714, para 59)”
“59.4. In case the deceased was self-employed or on
a fixed salary, an addition of 40% of the established
income should be the warrant where the deceased was
below the age of 40 years. An addition of 25% where the
deceased was between the age of 40 to 50 years and 10%
where the deceased was between the age of 50 to 60
years should be regarded as the necessary method of
computation. The established income means the income
minus the tax component.”
(2021) 2 SCC 166
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
(emphasis supplied)
13. Given how both deceased were below 40 years
and how they have not been established to be permanent
employees, future prospects to the tune of 40% must be
paid. The argument that no such future prospects ought to
be allowed for those with notional income, is both incorrect
in law [Sunita Tokas v. New India Insurance Co. Ltd., (2019)
20 SCC 688 : (2020) 4 SCC (Cri) 436] and without merit
considering the constant inflation-induced increase in wages.
It would be sufficient to quote the observations of this Court
in Hem
Raj v. Oriental
Insurance
Co.
Ltd. [Hem
Raj v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., (2018) 15 SCC 654 :
(2019) 1 SCC (Civ) 293 : (2019) 2 SCC (Cri) 864], as it puts
at rest any argument concerning non-payment of future
prospects to the deceased in the present case: (Hem Raj
case [Hem Raj v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., (2018) 15 SCC
654 : (2019) 1 SCC (Civ) 293 : (2019) 2 SCC (Cri) 864] ,
SCC p. 656, para 7)
“7. We are of the view that there cannot be
distinction where there is positive evidence of income and
where minimum income is determined on guesswork in
the facts and circumstances of a case. Both the situations
stand at the same footing. Accordingly, in the present
case, addition of 40% to the income assessed by the
Tribunal is required to be made.”
38. The rationale behind the awarding of future
prospects is therefore no longer merely about the type of
profession, whether permanent or otherwise, although the
percentage awarded is still dependent on the same. The
awarding of future prospects is now a part of the duty of the
court to grant just compensation, taking into account the
realities of life, particularly of inflation, the quest of
individuals to better their circumstances and those of their
loved ones, rising wage rates and the impact of experience
on the quality of work.”
(ix)
At this juncture, the provisions of Section 168 of the
M.V. Act may also be pertinently noticed, which provides for “just
compensation.” In Ramla and Others vs. National Insurance Company
Limited and Others6, it was inter alia held as follows;
“5. Though the claimants had claimed a total
compensation of Rs 25,00,000 in their claim petition filed
before the Tribunal, we feel that the compensation which the
claimants are entitled to is higher than the same as
mentioned supra. There is no restriction that the Court
cannot award compensation exceeding the claimed amount,
since the function of the Tribunal or court under Section 168
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is to award “just
compensation”. The Motor Vehicles Act is a beneficial and
welfare legislation. A “just compensation” is one which is
reasonable on the basis of evidence produced on record. It
cannot be said to have become time-barred. Further, there
is no need for a new cause of action to claim an enhanced
(2019) 2 SCC 192
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
amount. The courts
compensation.”
are
duty-bound
to
award
just
On the bedrock of the provision of law and the categorical
pronouncements in the ratios supra, “just compensation,” in my
considered opinion, would also include “Future Prospects” at the
rate of 40% in the income of the deceased.
Litigation Costs calculated by the Learned Tribunal are
(x)
not in the scheme of the law or any of the Judgments of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and is thereby disregarded.
The amount awarded by the Learned Tribunal towards
(xi)
“Loss of Estate” and “Funeral Expenses,” being undisputed are
allowed.
Consequently, in light of the aforesaid facts and
7.
circumstances, the Judgment of the Learned Tribunal stands
modified as follows;
Annual Income of the deceased
(Rs.30,000/- x 12)
Rs.3,60,000/-
Add 40% of Rs.3,60,000/- as Future Prospects
to the Annual Income of the deceased
Rs.1,44,000/-
Total Annual Income
Rs.5,04,000/-
Less 1/2 of Rs.5,04,000/[Deducted from the said amount as expenses that
the deceased would have incurred towards
his maintenance had he been alive]
Rs.2,52,000/-
Net Yearly Income
Rs.2,52,000/-
Multiplier of “16” adopted in terms of
Sarla Verma’s Judgment [Rs.2,52,000/- x 16]
Rs.40,32,000/-
Add Loss of Filial Consortium
[Rs.40,000/- each, payable to
Respondents No.1 and 2 respectively]
Rs.80,000/-
Add Loss of estate
Rs.15,000/-
Add Funeral expenses
Rs.15,000/Total
Rs.41,42,000/-
(Rupees forty one lakhs and forty two thousand) only.
8.
Interest
The Respondents No.1 to 3 shall be entitled to Simple
@
10%
per
annum
on
the
above
amount
of
MAC App. No.02 of 2021
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs.
Shri Laxmi Prasad Chettri & Ors.
Rs.41,42,000/- (Rupees forty one lakhs and forty two thousand)
only, with effect from the date of filing of the Claim Petition before
the Learned Tribunal till full realization.
9.
The awarded amount shall be paid by the Appellant to
the Respondents No.1 to 3 within one month from today with
interest @ 10%, failing which, the Appellant shall pay Simple
Interest @ 12% from the date of filing of the Claim Petition till
realization, duly deducting the amounts, if any, already paid by it
to the Respondents No.1 to 3.
10.
The awarded amount of compensation shall be divided
as follows;
(i) 80% to Respondents No.1 and 2 (at the rate of
40% each); and
(ii) 20% to Respondent No.3.
11.
Appeal allowed to the extent above.
12.
MAC App No.02 of 2021 stands disposed of accordingly.
13.
No order as to costs.
14.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, South Sikkim at Namchi, for information.
15.
Lower Court Records be remitted forthwith.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
01.11.2021
ml
Approved for reporting : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review