Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 22nd JULY, 2019
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IA No.01 of 2018 in MAC App No.04 of 2019
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
versus
Respondents :
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo and Others
Application under Section 173(1)
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Sushant Subba and
Advocates for the Appellant.
Mr.
Madan
Kumar
Sundas,
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Mr. K. B. Chettri and Mr.
Umesh Gurung, Advocate for Respondents No.1 to 3.
Mr. Yogesh Gurung, Advocate for Respondent No.4.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O R D E R (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The
Appellant
Company
has
filed
the
instant
Application under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
(M. V. Act), seeking condonation of 274 days delay which
occurred in filing the Appeal.
It is averred that the delay
occurred on account of the various grounds as detailed herein;
“a.
That the Impugned award was passed by the Learned
Member, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim at
Gangtok in M.A.C.T. Case No.10 of 2016 on 28.02.2018.
I.A. No.01 of 2018 in MAC App No.04 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo and Others
b.
That the certified copy of impugned award was received
by Branch Office at Gangtok from Advocate Ms. Vidya
Lama on 20.03.2018.
c.
That the Impugned award was studied by Branch office at
Gangtok and further forwarded to Kolkata Regional Office
on 30.03.2018.
d.
That due to incomplete documents the Kolkata Regional
Office returned back the file to Branch Office at Gangtok
for rectification on 10.04.2018.
e.
That the Branch Office at Gangtok again forwarded the
said file with complete documents to Kolkata Regional
Office on 13.04.2018.
f.
That the Branch Office at Gangtok received an email on
19.04.2018 from Kolkata Regional Office, with an
instruction to prefer an appeal before this Hon’ble High
Court.
g.
That the Branch Office at Gangtok had initially appointed
Counsel Shri Thupden G. Bhutia on 11.05.2018 to file an
appeal before this Hon’ble High Court and the said
appointment letter was received by him on 23.05.2018.
h.
That the Counsel Shri Thupden G. Bhutia on first week of
November, 2018, expressed his inability to file the instant
appeal, stating his personal difficulties.
i.
That the Branch Office at Gangtok, thereafter appointed
Shri Mandan Kumar Sundas on 09.12.2018 for filing the
instant appeal against the impugned Judgment before this
Hon’ble High Court.
j.
That by the last week of December, 2018 Shri Madan
Kumar Sundas, had collected all the required documents
and completed the Memorandum of Appeal to be filed
before this Hon’ble High Court.
k.
That from 8th January, 2019, Counsel Shri Madan Kumar
Sundas was on paternity leave for one month.
l.
That in the first week of February, 2019, Memorandum of
Appeal was submitted to Branch Office at Gangtok by
Advocate Shri Madan Kumar Sundas for verification and
approval and the same was further forwarded to Kolkata
Regional Office.
m.
That the same had taken few days to verify and for
signature.”
Hence, the occurrence of the delay.
I.A. No.01 of 2018 in MAC App No.04 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
2.
vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo and Others
A response was filed to the said Application objecting
to the grounds advanced and it was averred that the MV Act is a
social and beneficial legislation and as such the Award which has
been passed by the Learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
East Sikkim, at Gangtok (hereinafter, Learned Claims Tribunal)
cannot be treated lightly by the Appellant Company. That, the
grounds given by the Appellant Company do not suffice to
condone the delay and the Respondents No.1 to 3 ought not to
bear the brunt for the lethargy and fault of the Appellant
Company. Hence, the Application be dismissed.
3.
While reiterating the points raised in the averments
Learned Counsel for the Appellant Company in his verbal
submissions contended that it is a settled position of law that
Government and Government Undertakings have been permitted
some flexibility in case of condonation of delay on account of
time required for processing the papers by such Offices. In this
context, various High Courts and the Hon’ble Supreme Court
have
upheld
this
view
in condoning such
delay.
In the
circumstances, the said Application be considered and delay
condoned.
4.
Learned Senior Counsel refuting the contentions held
that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Office of the Chief Post Master
General and Ors. vs. Living Media India Ltd. & Anr.
has observed
that delay cannot be condoned if there is no proper explanation
except
mentioning
AIR 2012 SC 1506
various
dates.
That,
no
explanation
I.A. No.01 of 2018 in MAC App No.04 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo and Others
emanates for the delay in the instant matter although various
dates have been mentioned sans reasons. Thus, the Application
deserves a dismissal.
5.
Counsel for the Respondent No.4 filed no objection
nor were verbal submissions made.
6.
and
Learned Counsel for the parties were heard at length
the
impugned
Judgment
and
Award
perused
before
considering the condonation of delay application.
7.
It is pertinent to mention that the Appeal challenges
the quantification of the compensation inter alia on grounds of
the income of the victim. This Court had earlier remanded the
matter back to the Learned Claims Tribunal to clarify the
anomalies arising in the income of the deceased, by way of
examining witnesses. The concerned witness was examined by
the Claimants/Respondents herein and cross-examined by the
Appellant Company and necessary clarifications made. Pursuant
thereto the impugned Judgment came to be pronounced.
8.
The second proviso to Section 173(1) of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, lays down that the High Court may entertain
the Appeal after expiry of a period of ninety days, if it is satisfied
that the appellant was prevented by sufficient cause from
preferring the appeal in time.
Hence, the key consideration is
“sufficient cause”, whether the Appellant Company has been able
to make out “sufficient cause” is the next consideration.
I.A. No.01 of 2018 in MAC App No.04 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo and Others
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Basawaraj and Another
9.
vs.
Special
Land
Acquisition
Officer
while
explaining
the
expression “sufficient cause” would also opine as follows;
“11. The
expression
“sufficient
cause”
should be given a liberal interpretation to ensure
that substantial justice is done, but only so long as
negligence, inaction or lack of bona fides cannot be
imputed to the party concerned, whether or not
sufficient cause has been furnished, can be decided
on the facts of a particular case and no straitjacket
formula is possible. (Vide Madanlal v. Shyamlal
[(2002) 1 SCC 535 : AIR 2002 SC 100] and Ram Nath
Sao v. Gobardhan Sao [(2002) 3 SCC 195 : AIR 2002 SC
1201].)
12. It is a settled legal proposition that law
of limitation may harshly affect a particular party
but it has to be applied with all its rigour when the
statute so prescribes. The court has no power to
extend the period of limitation on equitable
grounds. “A result flowing from a statutory
provision is never an evil. A court has no power to
ignore that provision to relieve what it considers a
distress resulting from its operation.” The
statutory provision may cause hardship or
inconvenience to a particular party but the court
has no choice but to enforce it giving full effect to
the same. The legal maxim dura lex sed lex which
means “the law is hard but it is the law”, stands
attracted in such a situation. It has consistently
been held that, “inconvenience is not” a decisive
factor to be considered while interpreting a
statute.”
[emphasis supplied]
10.
On the anvil of this opinion, it would be essential to
examine whether the grounds put forth by the Appellant
Company qualify as “sufficient cause”.
While carefully walking
through the grounds given by the Appellant Company seeking
condonation of delay it is clear that the impugned Judgment was
pronounced on 28-02-2018, certified copy of the impugned
Award was received by the Branch Office from their Counsel on
20-03-2018.
Pausing here for a moment, the Appellant
Company has failed to reveal when the certified copy of the
(2013) 14 SCC 81
I.A. No.01 of 2018 in MAC App No.04 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo and Others
Judgment was applied for, although the date of Judgment is
revealed. The dates revealed supra indicate a delay in applying
for a copy of the Judgment. Admittedly the Branch Office of the
Appellant Company is at Gangtok, in such a circumstance an
explanation for the delay of almost three weeks for the certified
copy of the impugned Judgment to reach the Branch Office was
imperative but finds no place in the pleadings or verbal
submissions. Thereafter, the impugned Judgment was allegedly
forwarded to Kolkata Regional Office on 30-03-2018. Pursuant
thereto steps were taken on account of incomplete documents
till 19-04-2018, on which date the Branch Office was directed to
prefer an Appeal before this High Court.
More than a month
elapsed before the Counsel so appointed by the Branch Office
received the letter of appointment.
explanation.
This also lacks any
Six months thereafter elapsed on account of the
inability of the Counsel to file the instant Appeal on grounds of
personal
difficulties,
documentation.
The
this
is
Branch
not
Office
substantiated
in
by
December,
any
2018,
appointed another Counsel for filing the Appeal who filed it only
in March, 2019. The grounds, in my considered opinion, cannot
qualify as “sufficient cause”.
As already pointed out the delay
lacks substantiation by documentation.
11.
General
The Supreme Court in Office of the Chief Post Master
(supra)
while
disapproving
preferential
treatment
expected by Government Departments in matters of delay held
as follows;
I.A. No.01 of 2018 in MAC App No.04 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo and Others
“13. In our view, it is the right time to
inform all the Government bodies, their agencies
and instrumentalities that unless they have
reasonable and acceptable explanation for the
delay and there was bona fide effort, there is no
need to accept the usual explanation that the file
was kept pending for several months/years due to
considerable degree or procedural red-tape in the
process. The Government departments are under
a special obligation to ensure that they perform
their duties with diligence and commitment.
Condonation of delay is an exception and should
not be used as an anticipated benefit for
Government departments.
The law shelters
everyone under the same light and should not be
swirled for the benefit of a few. Considering the
fact that there was no proper explanation offered
by the Department for the delay except mentioning
of various dates, according to us, the Department
has miserably failed to give any acceptable and
cogent reasons sufficient to condone such a huge
delay. …………………..”
The Supreme Court in the aforestated ratio has thus
observed that even Government Departments are to be treated
with the same yardstick as other litigants in matters of delay and
law cannot be tweaked for the benefit of a few. The Appellant
Company herein merely by virtue of being a Public Sector
Undertaking ought not to expect preferential treatment while
lacking the grounds required to establish “sufficient cause”.
12.
In conclusion, I am of the considered opinion that no
reason emanates for condoning the delay, apart from which it
must be borne in mind that the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, is
beneficial legislation enacted for the purposes of meting out
even-handed justice to victims of a tragedy.
The victims cannot
be made to wait endlessly on the whims and fancies of the
Company sans substantial reasons.
I.A. No.01 of 2018 in MAC App No.04 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited
13.
vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo and Others
The Application is devoid of merit and consequently
dismissed and disposed of, as also the Appeal.
14.
No order as to costs.
( Justice Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
22-07-2019
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review