Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED:
14th December, 2017
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Single Bench : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited,
Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 737101.
Versus
Respondents
:
1. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo,
W/o Late Santa Kumar Limboo,
2. Miss Aunsena Limboo,
D/o Late Santa Kumar Limboo,
3. Master Akrit Limboo,
S/o Late Santa Kumar Limboo,
All residents of Hee-Goan,
P.O. Hee-Gaon & P.S. Kaluk,
West Sikkim.
4. Mrs. Dik Maya Chettri,
Wife of Kumar Chettri,
Resident of Timberbong, Soreng,
P.O. & P.S. Soreng,
West Sikkim.
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------
Appearance:
Mrs. Vidya Lama, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chhetri and Ms Malati
Sharma, Advocates for the Respondents No.1 to 3.
Mr. Gulshan Lama, Advocate (Legal Aid Counsel) for the Respondent No.4.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
M.A.C. APP. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
C.O. No. 1 of 2017
:
Appellants
1. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo,
W/o Late Santa Kumar Limboo,
2. Miss Aunsena Limboo,
D/o Late Santa Kumar Limboo,
3. Master Akrit Limboo,
S/o Late Santa Kumar Limboo,
All residents of Hee-Goan,
P.O. Hee-Gaon & P.S. Kaluk,
West Sikkim.
Versus
Respondents
:
1. The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited,
Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 737101.
2. Mrs. Dik Maya Chettri,
Wife of Kumar Chettri,
Resident of Timberbong, Soreng,
P.O. & P.S. Soreng,
West Sikkim.
Cross objection under Order XLI, Rule 22(1) and (2),
read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -----------------------------
Appearance:
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chhetri and Ms Malati Sharma,
Advocates for the Appellants.
Mrs. Vidya Lama, Advocate for the Respondent No.1.
Mr. Gulshan Lama, Advocate (Legal Aid Counsel) for the Respondent No.2.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, East
District at Gangtok, East Sikkim (hereinafter „the Claims Tribunal‟)
in MACT Case No. 10 of 2016, vide the impugned Judgment dated
17.08.2016, directed the Appellant to pay to the Respondents No.
1, 2 and 3, a sum of Rs.14,23,000/- (Rupees fourteen lakhs,
twenty-three thousand) only, with interest @ 10% per annum
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
from the date of filing of the Petition before the learned Claims
Tribunal, i.e., 1.3.2016, until its full realization, duly deducting a
sum of Rs.50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand) only, paid as interim
compensation to the Respondents. The compensation was awarded
on account of the death of the husband of the Respondent No.1
and father of the Respondents No.2 and 3, in a motor vehicle
accident on 15.8.2014, at around 19:30 hours at 20th Mile,
Dentam, West Sikkim. Aggrieved by the Award, the Appellant is
assailing the same, inter alia, on grounds that the learned Claims
Tribunal has erred in adding 50% as future prospects to the yearly
income of the deceased, when it is not disputed that the deceased
was a farmer with no regular income. That, the learned Claims
Tribunal had also erroneously granted non-pecuniary damages of
Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only, on account of loss of
consortium to the Respondent No.1 and Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees
one lakh) only, on account of loss of love and affection to the
Respondents No.2 and 3.
2.
The thrust of the verbal arguments of learned Counsel
for the Appellant pivoted around the aforesaid grounds with the
prayer that the impugned Judgment and Award passed by the
learned Claims Tribunal be set aside.
3.
A Cross-Objection was filed by the Respondents No. 1,
2 and 3, submitting, inter alia, that the learned Claims Tribunal
had assessed the monthly notional income of the deceased as
Rs.6,600/-
(Rupees
six
thousand
and
six
hundred)
only,
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
consequently at Rs.79,200/- (Rupees seventy-nine thousand and
two hundred) only, per annum. To the contrary, Exhibit-13, the
Income Certificate of the deceased, revealed his monthly income
to be Rs.14,070/- (Rupees fourteen thousand and seventy) only,
from Agriculture; Rs.21,450/- (Rupees twenty-one thousand, four
hundred and fifty) only, from Other Sources and Rs.600/- (Rupees
six hundred) only, as Government Allowance for traditional
healer/”Shaman” (Jhakri). Hence, the total income of the deceased
was Rs.23,222/- (Rupees twenty-three thousand, two hundred and
twenty-two) only, per month. Despite such evidence, the learned
Claims Tribunal concluded that Exhibit-13 was confusing and
rejected
it.
Had
the
income
reflected
in
Exhibit-13
been
considered, the compensation would have been higher. It was
further urged that there was no error in the addition of 50% as
future prospects to the annual income of the deceased as he was
below 40 years of age. However, the Multiplier of „15‟ was wrongly
adopted to calculate the loss of dependency instead of the
Multiplier of „16‟, as per the Second Schedule of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988,
in consideration of the age of the deceased Victim.
Learned Senior Counsel sought to support his submissions by
placing reliance on Commissioner of Central Excise, Mumbai vs.
Raymond Limited1,
Wasting House Saxby Farmer vs. Workmen 2,
Raghbendra Bose and Others vs. Sunil Krishna Ghose and Others3 and
(2016) 16 SCC 659
(1973) 2 SCC 150
(2005) 12 SCC 309
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
Kunjan Nair Sivaraman Nair vs. Narayanan Nair and Others 4. Hence,
the prayer for reversing the impugned Award and enhancing the
compensation granted.
4.
The rival submissions of learned Counsel were heard at
length and considered. The documents on record were carefully
perused, including the impugned Judgment. I have also perused
the citations made at the Bar.
5.
Before the learned Claims Tribunal, the Respondents
raised a claim for compensation amounting to Rs.46,93,629/(Rupees forty-six lakhs, ninety-three thousand, six hundred and
twenty-nine) only. The learned Claims Tribunal in consideration of
the entire evidence and documents on record calculated the
compensation as Rs.14,23,000/- (Rupees fourteen lakhs, twentythree thousand) only. On a careful perusal of the impugned
Judgment, the learned Claims Tribunal calculated the age of the
deceased to be 36 years old as on 15.8.2014. The learned Claims
Tribunal also concluded that Exhibit-13, the Income Certificate of
the deceased, was confusing as it showed the monthly income of
the deceased from other Sources as Rs.21,450/- (Rupees twentyone thousand, four hundred and fifty) only, while the per annum
income of Rs.14,070/- (Rupees fourteen thousand and seventy)
only, was from Agriculture but the total income “per annum” was
mentioned as Rs.35,520/- (Rupees thirty-five thousand, five
(2004) 3 SCC 277
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
hundred
and
twenty)
only.
The
anomaly
having
remained
unexplained, the learned Claims Tribunal rejected the document
and placed the notional income of the deceased at Rs.6,600/(Rupees six thousand and six hundred) only. The multiplier of „15‟
was adopted on the assumption that the age of the deceased was
36 years as on 15.8.2014, in terms of the Table in Sarla Verma
(Smt) and Others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another5. 50%
was added as future prospects, while 1/3rd was deducted towards
his personal expenses.
6.
Firstly, to address the issue of the income of the
deceased, Exhibit-13 is his Income Certificate, which reads as
follows;
“………………………………………............................................
No. 548/IC/GVK/DTM
Date: 26.11.2015
INCOME CERTIFICATE
The YEARLY/MONTHLY individual income of
Shri/Smt/Kumari Santa Kumar Limboo (Subba) S/o,
WO,/D/O Lt. Chandra Dhoj Limboo (Subba) resident of
Hee West District, Sikkim is as under:1. SALARY/PENSION
RS:_________p.m.x12
2. Agriculture
Rs.14,070/- P.A.
3. Other Sources
Rs.21,450/- P.M.
TOTAL :
RS: 35,520/- P.A.
(Rupees Thirty-five thousand five hundred twenty only)
The above income has been prepared on the basis of the
report of the Revenue Supervisor/ARS/Panchayat (tick the
relevant) and on the basis of solemn affirmation under
OATH before the GVA, Dentam on 26/11/2015.
This certificate is valid for the period of one year from the
date of issue.
………………………………..……………………..…………………..……………..”
(2009) 6 SCC 121
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
A careful examination of the document reveals an anomaly
with regard to the income at Serial No. 2, 3 and the overall
amount. The income at Serial No.2 is stated to be „per annum‟,
that at Serial No.3 „per month‟ but the total amount is shown as
„per annum‟. It is this error that learned Counsel for the
Respondents sought to draw the attention of this Court and
contended that the Respondents ought to be allowed to prove this
document afresh before the learned Tribunal, in view of the
anomalies persisting therein.
7.
The Respondent No. 1 in her evidence asserted that
the monthly income of her husband was Rs.23,222/- (Rupees
twenty-three thousand, two hundred and twenty-two) only. Under
cross-examination, she has stated as follows;
“…………………………………………………………………………………….
It is not true that my late husband was not having a
monthly income of ₹ 23,222/- as per Exbt.13. It is true
that the Income certificate Exbt. 13 was issued by the
Gram Vikash Kendra, Dentam. It is true that Exbt.13 was
prepared on the basis of the report of the Revenue
Supervisor and on the basis of Affidavit filed before the
gram Vikash Kendra. It is true that in Exbt.13 the total
earning of the deceased has been mentioned as ₹35520/per annum. (Witness volunteers to say that the issuing
authority has erred by calculating jointly the monthly and
annual income. The witness further states that the
clarification in this regard has been mentioned in para-14
of her evidence on affidavit)
………………………………………………………………………………..….”
The voluntary statement of the witness ought to have
alerted the learned Tribunal that there was allegedly an error in
the document. The learned Claims Tribunal without considering her
evidence concluded that Exhibit-13 was confusing and decided to
place the notional income of the deceased at Rs.6,600/- (Rupees
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
six thousand and six hundred) only, when the correct procedure to
be adopted was to clear the air with regard to the anomalies
appearing in Exhibit-13 by examining the issuing authority. The
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Raj Rani and Ors. vs. Oriental Insurance Co.
Ltd. and Ors.6, held at Paragraph 13 as follows;
“13. …… It is not necessary in a proceeding
under the Motor Vehicles Act to go by any rules of
pleadings or evidence. Section 168 of the Act speaks
about grant of just compensation. The Court‟s duty
being to award just compensation, it will try to arrive
at the said finding irrespective of the fact as to
whether any plea in that behalf was raised by the
claimant or not.”
8.
In Rajesh and Ors. Vs. Rajbir Singh and Ors.7, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court at Paragraph 13, held as follows;
“10. …………………………………………………………
“10. Thereafter, Section 168 empowers
the Claims Tribunal to „make an award
determining
the
amount
of
compensation which appears to it to be
just‟. Therefore, only requirement for
determining the compensation is that it
must be „just‟. There is no other
limitation or restriction on its power for
awarding just compensation.””
Thus, the statutory rules of evidence do not apply to matters
in Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, clothing the Tribunal with
sufficient powers to adopt legal methods to reach the crux of the
matter and thereby to award just compensation. A claimant in a
Petition under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, which is a benevolent
legislation to offer respite to the claimant for loss of the bread
(2009) 13 SCC 654
(2013) 9 SCC 54
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
winner, should not suffer on account of any negligence on the part
of a third person, such as issuing authority of Exhibit-13, herein.
9.
The arguments put forth by the Appellant was that the
learned Claims Tribunal has erred in calculating 50% future
prospects in addition to the income of the deceased when he had
no fixed income. On this count, succour can be drawn from the
decision of the Hon‟ble Apex Court in Special Leave Petition (Civil)
No. 25590 of 2014 in the matter of National Insurance Company Limited
vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors. dated 31.10.2017. While concluding the
matter, it was held at Paragraph 61(iv), (vi) and (vii) as follows;
“61. ………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………….
(iv) In case the deceased was self-employed or on a
fixed salary, an addition of 40% of the
established income should be the warrant where
the deceased was below the age of 40 years. An
addition of 25% where the deceased was
between the age of 40 to 50 years and 10%
where the deceased was between the age of 50
to 60 years should be regarded as the necessary
method of computation. The established income
means the income minus the tax component.”
……………………………………………………….…………….
(vi) The selection of multiplier shall be as indicated in
the Table in Sarla Verma read with paragraph 42
of that judgment.
(vii)The age of the deceased should be the basis for
applying the multiplier.
……………………………………………………………………….”
The ratiocination, therefore, clearly lays down the method of
computation towards future prospects for self employed or those
with a fixed salary.
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
10.
Now coming to the choice of Multiplier which the
Respondent points out is erroneous, in the first instance, it may be
clarified that for claim petitions under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, the choice of Multiplier is to be adopted as per
the Table laid out in the Judgment of Sarla Verma (supra) and not
under the Second Schedule of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, as
erroneously stated by the Respondent, as the said Table is for
claim petitions filed under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988.
That having been said, Exhibit-8, the Birth Certificate of
Santa Kumar Limboo, reflects his Date of Birth as 26.8.1978. The
accident having occurred on 15.8.2014, the deceased was a few
days short of his 36th birthday. In Achhaibar Maurya vs State of Uttar
Pradesh & Others8, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court while considering a
service matter and discussing the retirement age of the appellant
held as follows;
“12. It was urged that the appellant was
entitled to a hearing as the matter relating to
retirement from service depended upon the statutory
provisions. A person retires automatically on the day
when he completes the age of superannuation.
Principles of natural justice, therefore, cannot be said
to have any application in a case of this nature. A
person attains a specified age on the day preceding
that anniversary. (See Shurey, Rs, Savory v. Shurey : LR
(1918) 1 Ch 263) and R. v. Scoffin : LR (1930) 1 KB 741)
13. This Court in Prabhu Dayal Sesma v. State
of Rajasthan [(1986) 4 SCC 59] held : (SCC pp. 63-64,
para 9)
“9. … In calculating a person‟s age, the day of
his birth must be counted as a whole day and
he attains the specified age on the day
preceding, the anniversary of his birthday.” ”
[Emphasis supplied]
(2008) 2 SCC 639
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
Thus, bearing in mind the contents of Exhibit-8 and the
ratiocination supra, the deceased was technically not 36 years of
age.
11.
Consequently, the choice of Multiplier to be adopted
for computing loss of dependency would be as laid down in the
Judgment in Sarla Verma (supra). Paragraph 42 of the aforestated
Judgment, lays down as follows;
”42. We therefore hold that the multiplier to
be used should be as mentioned in Column (4) of the
table above (prepared by applying Susamma Thomas
[(1994) 2 SCC 176], Trilok Chandra [(1996) 4 SCC 362] and
Charlie [(2005) 10 SCC 720]), which starts with an
operative multiplier of 18 (for the age groups of 15 to
20 and 21 to 25 years), reduced by one unit for
every five years, that is M-17 for 26 to 30 years, M16 for 31 to 35 years, M-15 for 36 to 40 years, M-14
for 41 to 45 years, and M-13 for 46 to 50 years, then
reduced by two units for every five years, that is, M11 for 51 to 55 years, M-9 for 56 to 60 years, M-7 for
61 to 65 years and M-5 for 66 to 70 years.”
12.
For
non-pecuniary
damages,
the
learned
Claims
Tribunal had granted Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only, for
loss of love and affection relying on M. Mansoor vs. United Indian
Insurance Co. Ltd. Anr.9.
In the said Judgment, it was held as
follows;
“17. …… Besides this amount the claimants are
entitled to get Rs.50,000/- each towards the loss of
affection of the son i.e. Rs.1,00,000/-…………….”
2013 (12) SCALE 324
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
In the said matter the deceased was the son of the
appellants. In view of the reasoning given by the learned Tribunal,
I find that there is no error in the Award of the non-pecuniary
damages.
13.
So far as the grant of Rs.1,00,000/- as consortium is
concerned, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Rajesh & Ors. vs. Rajbir &
Ors. (supra), held as follows;
“20. …………………………..In legal parlance, 'consortium'
is the right of the spouse to the company, care, help,
comfort, guidance, society, solace, affection and
sexual relations with his or her mate. That nonpecuniary head of damages has not been properly
understood
by
our
Courts.
The
loss
of
companionship, love, care and protection, etc., the
spouse is entitled to get, has to be compensated
appropriately. The concept of non-pecuniary damage
for loss of consortium is one of the major heads of
award of compensation in other parts of the world
more particularly in the United States of America,
Australia, etc. English Courts have also recognized
the right of a spouse to get compensation even
during the period of temporary disablement. By loss
of consortium, the courts have made an attempt to
compensate the loss of spouse's affection, comfort,
solace,
companionship,
society,
assistance,
protection, care and sexual relations during the
future years. Unlike the compensation awarded in
other countries and other jurisdictions, since the legal
heirs are otherwise adequately compensated for the
pecuniary loss, it would not be proper to award a
major amount under this head. Hence, we are of the
view that it would only be just and reasonable that
the courts award at least rupees one lakh for loss of
consortium.”
[Emphasis supplied]
Consequently, no error visits grant of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees
one lakh) only, for loss of consortium.
14.
Objection.
The Appeal is partly allowed, as also the Cross-
M.A.C. App. No. 11 of 2016
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors.
&
C.O. No.1 of 2017
Smt. Tika Devi Limboo & Ors vs. Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.
15.
In conclusion, the matter is remanded back to the
learned Claims Tribunal for the limited purpose of allowing the
Appellant to clarify Exhibit-13 and thereafter, make necessary
calculations with regard to future prospects depending on the
income of the deceased Victim.
The matter be readmitted to its
original number in the Register of the learned Member, Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, Gangtok, East Sikkim. The entire
exercise shall be completed within three months from today
including pronouncement of Judgment.
16.
The
impugned
Judgment
of
the
Learned
Claims
Tribunal is set aside to the afore stated extent.
17.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, East District at Gangtok, East Sikkim,
for compliance.
18.
Records be remitted forthwith.
18.
No order as to costs.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
14-12-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review