Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MAC App. No. 17/ 2015
Branch Manager, NIC Ltd. vs. K.S. Tamang & Ors.
HI GH COURT OF SI KKI M , GANGTOK
(Civil Appellat e Jurisdict ion)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
HON’BLE SH RI SUNI L KUM AR SI NH A, CHI EF JUSTI CE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.17 of 20 15
1.
Th e Br an ch Man ager ,
Nat ion al In su r an ce Co. Lt d.,
31-A, Nat ion al High way,
(Opp. Tou r ism Depar t m en t ),
P.O. & P.S. Gan gt ok , East Sik k im .
2.
Th e Br an ch Man ager ,
Nat ion al In su r an ce Co. Lt d.,
Havin g it s Office at Pr at ap Nagar ,
2 n d Mile, Sevok e Road,
Siligu r i, Dist . Dar jeelin g,
West Ben gal-734 405.
…
APPELLANTS/ I NSURERS
Versus
1.
Mr . Kh ar k a Sin gh Tam an g,
Son of Par t i Man Tam an g,
Aged abou t 52 year s.
2.
Mast er Tset en Tam an g,
Son of Mr . Kar k a Sin gh Tam an g,
Aged abou t 17 year s.
Per m an en t Residen t s of Kh an am t ek PW
Near Tek Pr im ar y Sch ool,
Man ey Dar a GPU, Kh an am t ek ,
P.O. & P.S. Nam ch i, Sou t h Sik k im .
… RESPONDENTS/ CLAI M ANTS
3.
Mr . Su n il Gu r u n g,
Son of K.S. Gu r u n g,
Residen t of Bh an u Bh ak t a Sar an i,
Gu r u n g Bu st y, Siligu r i,
Dist . Dar jeelin g,
West Ben gal-734 003.
…
RESPONDENT/ OWNER
MAC App. No. 17/ 2015
Branch Manager, NIC Ltd. vs. K.S. Tamang & Ors.
Appeal under Sect ion 1 7 3 of t he M ot or Vehicles Act . 1 9 8 8
arising out of Award dat ed 1 8 .0 3 .2 0 1 5 passed in M .A.C.T . Case
No. 2 1 / 2 0 1 4 by M ACT , Gangt ok .
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance :
Mr . Th u pden G. Bh u t ia, Advocat e for t h e Appellan t .
Mr . Ajay Rat h i an d Ms. Ph u r ba Dik i Sh er pa, Advocat es
for Respon den t s 1 an d 2.
Mr . Bh u sh an Nepal, Advocat e for Respon den t No. 3.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
(02.05.2016)
SUNI L KUM AR SI NHA, CJ.
1.
Deceased, Su n it a Tam an g was a h ou se-wife. Sh e was
aged abou t 40 year s. Sh e died in a m ot or acciden t on 01.09.2014.
On a claim pet it ion filed u / S. 166 of t h e Mot or Veh icles Act , 1988,
by h er h u sban d an d m in or son (Respon den t s 1 an d 2 h er ein ), t h e
Tr ibu n al assessed h er in com e at Rs.13,275/ - per m on t h , applied
m u lt iplier of 15 an d aft er dedu ct in g 1/ 3 rd t owar ds h er per son al
expen ses assessed t h e loss of ear n in g at Rs.15,93,000/ -.
Th e
Tr ibu n al also awar ded Rs.7,96,500/ - t owar ds fu t u r e pr ospect s;
Rs.25,000/ - t owar ds fu n er al expen ses; Rs.2,500/ - t owar ds loss of
est at e;
Rs.25,000/ -
t owar ds
n on -pecu n iar y
Rs.1,00,000/ - t owar ds loss of con sor t iu m .
dam ages
an d
Th e Tr ibu n al, t h u s,
awar ded a t ot al su m of Rs.25,42,000/ - as com pen sat ion t o
Respon den t s 1 an d 2 on accou n t of deat h of deceased, Su n it a
Tam an g in t h e m ot or acciden t .
Th e Tr ibu n al also awar ded
in t er est @ 10% per an n u m fr om t h e dat e of filin g of claim pet it ion
MAC App. No. 17/ 2015
Branch Manager, NIC Ltd. vs. K.S. Tamang & Ors.
t ill r ealizat ion . Th e In su r an ce Com pan y was h eld liable t o pay t h e
afor esaid am ou n t .
2.
Mr . Th u pden G. Bh u t ia, lear n ed cou n sel appear in g on
beh alf of t h e Appellan t , r aised t wo fold ar gu m en t s.
He fir st ly
con t en ded t h at in t h e fact s an d cir cu m st an ces of t h e case wh en t h e
deceased was a n on -ear n in g m em ber (h ou se-wife), n o am ou n t of
fu t u r e pr ospect s wou ld h ave been
awar ded.
Secon dly, h e
con t en ded t h at wh en t h e fu n er al expen ses, loss of est at e an d loss
of con sor t iu m wer e awar ded u n der separ at e h eads, t h en t h er e was
n o r eason t o awar d Rs.25,000/ - t owar ds n on -pecu n iar y dam ages
becau se all t h e said h eads wer e alr eady cover in g t h e n on -pecu n iar y
dam ages an d t h e said am ou n t is in r epet it ion .
3.
On t h e ot h er h an d, Mr . Ajay Rat h i, lear n ed cou n sel
appear in g on beh alf of Respon den t s 1 an d 2, h as opposed t h ese
ar gu m en t s an d su bm it t ed t h at t h e Tr ibu n al was r igh t in awar din g
com pen sat ion on accou n t of fu t u r e pr ospect s an d n on -pecu n iar y
dam ages. He ar gu ed t h at if t h e in com e of t h e h u sban d was li k ely
t o in cr ease in fu t u r e an d som et h in g cou ld h ave been awar ded for
h is fu t u r e pr ospect s, t h e sam e logic wou ld be applicable in case of
h ou se-wife also.
4.
beh alf
Mr . Bh u sh an Nepal, lear n ed cou n sel appear in g on
of
Respon den t
No.
3,
h as,
h owever ,
ar gu m en t s of Mr . Bh u t ia.
5.
I h ave h ear d cou n sel for t h e par t ies.
su ppor t ed
the
MAC App. No. 17/ 2015
Branch Manager, NIC Ltd. vs. K.S. Tamang & Ors.
6.
Adm it t edly, t h e deceased was a h ou se-wife.
Th e
Tr ibu n al on t h e basis of ear n in g of h er h u sban d, i.e. Rs.39,824/ per m on t h , applyin g clau se 6 (b) of t h e secon d sch edu le u / S. 163A
of t h e Mot or Veh icles Act , 1988 h eld t h at t h e in com e of t h e
deceased sh ou ld be 1/ 3 rd of t h e in com e/ ear n in g of t h e su r vivin g
spou se i.e. h er h u sban d an d it was det er m in ed at Rs.13,275/ - per
m on t h .
Th is was don e on t h e basis of t h e ju dgm en t of Ar un
Kuma r Agr a wa l a nd Anot h er vs. Na t i ona l I nsur a nce Co. Lt d.
a nd Ot her s1 .
To t h is ext en d, t h e awar d of t h e Tr ibu n al can n ot be
fau lt ed wit h .
However , vide par agr aph 24 of t h e awar d, t h e
Tr ibu n al sim ply st at ed t h at in view of t h e obser vat ion of t h e
Hon ’ble Su pr em e Cou r t in Ar un Kuma r Agr a wa l (su pr a), an
addit ion of 50% of t h e act u al in com e sh ou ld be allowed an d it
allowed a su m of Rs.7,96,500/ - t owar ds fu t u r e pr ospect s.
7.
I h ave gon e t h r ou gh t h e ju dgm en t of Ar un Kuma r
Agr a wa l .
Th ou gh , it t alk s abou t t h e in com e of t h e n on -ear n in g
h ou se-wife/ m ot h er t o be calcu lat ed in t h e way t h e Tr ibu n al h as
calcu lat ed, bu t it n ever t alk s abou t an y loss of fu t u r e pr ospect s of a
n on -ear n in g h ou se-wife/ m ot h er t o be calcu lat ed in t er m s of 50% of
t h e act u al in com e assessed.
Wh en t h e deceased was a n on -
ear n in g m em ber as sh e was a h ou se-wife, t h er e was n o qu est ion of
fu t u r e pr ospect s t o be calcu lat ed in t h e above t er m s. Th e elem en t
of t h e fu t u r e pr ospect s sh all appear for calcu lat ion wh en t h e
_________________
1 (2010) 9 SCC 218
MAC App. No. 17/ 2015
Branch Manager, NIC Ltd. vs. K.S. Tamang & Ors.
deceased was an ear n in g m em ber bu t in case wh er e deceased was
n ot an ear n in g m em ber an d was sim ply a h ou se-wife/ m ot h er , su ch
m ode of calcu lat ion sh all n ot be applied.
Th e ar gu m en t of Mr .
Rat h i t h at if t h e fu t u r e pr ospect s of t h e h u sban d wou ld ear n
som et h in g, in t h e sam e logic t h e fu t u r e pr ospect s of t h e n on ear n in g wife m ay also be calcu lat ed, does n ot appear t o be logical
an d accept able.
8.
I am of t h e view t h at t h e Claim s Tr ibu n al fell in t o er r or
by awar din g a su m of Rs.7,96,500/ - t owar ds fu t u r e pr ospect s t o a
n on -ear n in g h ou se-wife, wh ose in com e was assessed on t h e basis
of st r u ct u r ed for m u la u / S. 163A of t h e Mot or Veh icles Act .
9.
So far as awar d of Rs.25,000/ - t owar ds n on -pecu n iar y
dam ages is con cer n ed, Mr . Bh u t ia h as con t en ded t h at in ligh t of
t h e ot h er n on -pecu n iar y dam ages lik e fu n er al expen ses, loss of
est at e an d loss of con sor t iu m , t h e sam e sh ou ld n ot h ave been
awar ded.
10.
Mr . Rat h i, r elyin g on t h e ju dgm en t of Ji ju Kur uvi l a
a nd ot her s vs. Kunjuja mma Moha n a nd ot her s2 , h as ar gu ed
t h at loss of con sor t iu m , in fact , was awar ded t o Respon den t No. 1,
h u sban d, on accou n t of deat h of h is wife, wh er eas, Rs.25,000/ -,
t h ou gh classified as n on -pecu n iar y dam ages, was, in fact , awar ded
_________________
(2013) 9 SCC 166
MAC App. No. 17/ 2015
Branch Manager, NIC Ltd. vs. K.S. Tamang & Ors.
t o Respon den t No. 2, m in or son , t owar ds loss of love an d affect ion ,
wh o, in fact , lost h is m ot h er at t h e age of 17. Ji ju Kur uvi l a was
r elied in Asha Ver ma n a nd ot her s vs. Ma ha r a j Si ngh a nd
Ot her s3 wh er ein separ at e am ou n t t owar ds loss of love an d
affect ion was awar ded t o t h e Appellan t ch ildr en on accou n t of
deat h of t h eir fat h er (deceased).
Adm it t edly, t h e above am ou n t of
Rs.25,000/ - was over an d above t h e am ou n t of loss of con sor t iu m ,
fu n er al expen ses an d loss of est at e an d it can n ot be said t h at aft er
awar din g t h e com pen sat ion u n der t h e above h eads, Rs.25,000/ was ju st a r epet it ion . I am of t h e view t h at it was easily awar dable
u n der loss of love an d affect ion t o Respon den t No. 2.
Th u s, t h e
ar gu m en t of Mr . Bh u t ia t h at Rs.25,000/ - awar ded as n on pecu n iar y dam ages was in cor r ect , can n ot be accept ed.
11.
For t h e above r eason s, t h e Appeal is par t ly allowed.
Respon den t s 1 an d 2/ Claim an t s wou ld be en t it led t o r eceive
com pen sat ion in t h e followin g m an n er : 1.
Loss of ear n in gs
Rs.15,93,000.00
2.
Fu n er al expen ses
Rs.
25,000.00
3.
Loss of est at e
Rs.
2,500.00
4.
Loss of love an d affect ion t o
t h e m in or son
Rs.
25,000.00
Loss of con sor t iu m
Rs. 1,00,000.00
5.
Tot al
_________________
3 (2015) 11 SCC 389
Rs.17,45,500.00
MAC App. No. 17/ 2015
Branch Manager, NIC Ltd. vs. K.S. Tamang & Ors.
12.
Respon den t s 1 an d 2/ Claim an t s, t h u s, ar e en t it led t o
r eceive a su m of Rs.17,45,500/ - as com pen sat ion on accou n t of
deat h of deceased, Su n it a Tam an g, in t h e m ot or acciden t .
Th ey
sh all also be en t it led t o r eceive in t er est @ 10 % per an n u m on t h e
said am ou n t of Rs.17,45,500/ - fr om t h e dat e of filin g t h e claim
pet it ion t ill r ealizat ion .
13.
Th e Appeal is allowed t o t h e ext en t in dicat ed above,
t h er e sh all be n o or der as t o cost s.
Chief Just ice
0 2 .0 5 .20 16
Approved for Report in g
Internet
pm / jk
: Yes/ No.
: Yes/ No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review