Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Having its Branch Office at:N.H.-10, Opposite Tourism Department,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
.… Appellant/Insurer
versus
1.
Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba,
W/o Late Pem Tshering Lepcha,
2.
Ms. Jola Shemik Lepcha,
D/o Late Pem Tshering Lepcha,
both are resident of Marchak Busty,
P.O. & P.S. Ranipool, East Sikkim.
…. Respondents/Claimants
Shri Raj Kumar Thirani,
S/o B.D. Thirani,
R/o Thirani Building, M.G. Marg,
P.O. & P.S. Sardar,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
3.
(Owner of vehicle No. Sk-01-P-0466, Estilo LXI Zen).
…. Respondent/Owner
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988.
Appearance:
Mr. Thupden Gyatso Bhutia, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Sudha Sewa and Mr.
Nima Tshering Sherpa, Advocates for Respondent nos. 1
and 2.
Mr. Ajay Rahti, Mr. Rahul Rathi, Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa
and Ms. Renuka Chhetri, Advocates for Respondent no. 3.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
JUDGMENT
(10.06.2019)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
The Appellant is the Insurance Company. It was Opposite
Party no.2 before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Tribunal).
The Respondent no.1 and Respondent no.2 are the Claimant
no.1 i.e. the wife of the deceased-Pem Tshering Lepcha who
succumbed due to the accident and the Claimant no.2 i.e. the
minor daughter of the deceased and the Claimant no.1. The
Respondent no.3 is the owner of the vehicle which met with the
accident. The present appeal had been preferred by the Appellant
dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and the award both
dated 27.11.2017 passed by the learned Tribunal.
2.
The quantum of the award passed by the learned Tribunal
is not in dispute. The judgment of the learned Tribunal directing
the Appellant to pay the compensation is challenged. The income
certificate of the deceased (exhibit-11) dated 02.09.2016 having
not been proved by the Block Development Officer who issued it,
is contested. The Appellant also submits that the Respondent
no.3 has categorically stated that the driver had not taken due
permission/authorisation from him before taking the said
vehicle. Thus, it is argued the Appellant could not be saddled
with the compensation.
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
3.
Heard Mr. Thupden Gyatso Bhutia, learned Counsel for the
Appellant, Mr. N. Rai, learned Senior Counsel for Respondent
nos. 1 and 2 and Mr. Ajay Rahti, learned Counsel for
Respondent no.3.
4.
On the intervening night of the incident i.e. 13.04.2016 and
14.04.2016 the deceased was travelling along with other
occupants in vehicle bearing registration no. SK-01-P-0466
(Estilo LXI Zen) from Marchak to Mangan, North Sikkim driven
by its driver-late Gopal Chettri. When the vehicle reached
Rangchang Bhir, Dikchu Singtam Road, East Sikkim it fell off
the cliff resulting in the death of the deceased. The driver had a
valid license issued by the Motor Vehicle Department. The
vehicle was duly insured with the Appellant having a valid
insurance policy no. 150608/31/16/6700000049 valid from
04.04.2016 to the midnight of 03.04.2017 covering the date of
the accident.
5.
The
learned
Tribunal
relied
upon
the
certificate
of
registration (exhibit-8) to hold that the vehicle was registered in
the Motor Vehicle Division; tax was paid up to 22.06.2016
covering the date of the accident and that the Respondent no.3
was the owner of the said vehicle.
6.
The learned Tribunal came to the conclusion that the
accident had occurred on the said date on examining the
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
certified copy of the First Information Report (FIR) dated
14.04.2016 (exhibit-2). The FIR was registered against the driver
of the vehicle for rash driving on a public way (Section 279
Indian Penal Code, 1860) (IPC) and causing death by negligence
(Section 304A IPC). The learned Tribunal examined the property
seizure memo (exhibit-7) vide which the police seized the vehicle,
its key and documents.
7.
The inquest form (exhibit-4), dead body challan (exhibit-5),
autopsy/post mortem report (exhibit-15), dead body handing
and taking memo (exhibit-6), death certificate of the deceased
(exhibit-13) satisfied the learned Tribunal regarding the death of
the deceased due to the accident.
8.
The learned Tribunal came to the conclusion that the
collective appreciation of the testimony of Respondent no.1 and
the exhibited documents clearly established that the accident
occurred on the intervening night on 13.04.2016 and 14.04.2016
when the vehicle owned by the Respondent no.3 and driven by
the driver in which the deceased was travelling fell off the cliff
resulting in the death of the deceased, one Dipak Chettri and the
driver.
9.
The learned Tribunal was aware that Respondent no.1 was
not travelling in the vehicle at the relevant time although she
deposed that the driver had driven the vehicle rash and
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
negligently. However, the learned Tribunal concluded that the
driver had driven the vehicle rash and negligently after
examining the FIR and the charge-sheet (exhibit-18) implicating
him under Section 279 and 304A of the IPC. The finding in the
charge-sheet (exhibit-18) was that the motor vehicle inspection
report stated that the vehicle could have lost control due to over
speeding resulting in the accident.
10. The driving license of the driver (exhibit-9) assured the
learned Tribunal that it was valid at the time of the accident.
11. The learned Tribunal examined the insurance policy
(exhibit-10) to come to the conclusion that the vehicle was
insured w.e.f. 04.04.2016 till the midnight of 03.04.2017
covering the period of accident. The learned Tribunal also held
that there was no doubt created about the genuineness of the
documents. Hence, the learned Tribunal came to the conclusion
that the deceased while travelling in the vehicle died in the motor
accident which was duly insured.
12. The birth certificate (exhibit-12) of the deceased made the
learned Tribunal conclude that the age of the deceased was 20
years at the time of the accident.
13. The Respondent nos. 1 and 2 placed reliance on the income
certificate of the deceased issued by the Block Development
Officer reflecting his monthly income. The income certificate
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
certified that the deceased was working as a local mason which
was a skilled profession and was earning Rs.16000/- per month.
The income certificate also certified that the deceased was
earning
some
income
by
selling
organic
vegetables.
The
Appellant contested the income certificate being not proved by
the Block Development Officer. Although the Block Development
Officer was not examined the Respondent no.1 who is the wife of
the deceased deposed that the deceased was working as a local
mason and earning Rs.16000/- per month. She also deposed
that he was also earning some income by selling organic
vegetables.
The Respondent no.1 deposed that the income
certificate was issued by the Block Development Officer. The
learned Tribunal considered that the Appellant did not deny the
monthly income of the deceased.
14. Mr. Thupden Gyatso Bhutia drew the attention of this
Court to the written objection filed by the Appellant in which the
contents
of
the
income
certificate
were
contested.
The
Respondent no.1 had exhibited the income certificate issued by
the Block Development Officer. She was cross-examined by the
Appellant.
During
cross-examination
the
Respondent
no.1
accepted the suggestion that she had not filed any document to
substantiate that the deceased used to work as a mason. She
also
deposed
that
the
income
certificate
was
obtained
approximately five months from the date of the accident.
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
Obviously the income certificate was applied for and obtained
after the death of the deceased to make the claim. No fault can
be attributed to the Respondent no.1 for doing so. She also
admitted that the income certificate does not reflect on which
documents and facts and it was issued. No suggestion was made
to the Respondent no.1 that the income certificate was a false
certificate. Mr. N. Rai relied upon Notification No.25/Home/2007
dated 03.04.2007 published in the Sikkim Government Gazette
dated 17.04.2007 by which in exercise of the powers conferred
by Section 21 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.)
Block Development Officers have been appointed to be Special
Executive Magistrates for the performance of various functions
including issuance of income certificate. It is thus clear that the
Block Development Officer while issuing the income certificate
was exercising a statutory function as a public officer. Thus the
income certificate would fall under the category of public
documents. Mr. N. Rai would also draw the attention of this
Court to two judgments of this Court on this issue. In re: Smt.
Anita Sunam & Ors. v. Shri Hom Nath Timshina & Anr.1 the learned
Single Judge of this Court held, relying upon an earlier judgment
of this Court in re: Branch Manager, Oriental Insurance Company
2013 SCC OnLine Sikk 67
2012 (1) T.A.C. 444 (Sikkim)
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
Ltd. v. Smt. Meena Bania and Ors.2, that the Block Development
Officer is a competent authority under the State Government to
issue certificate of income and also a public servant and
therefore certificate issued under his seal and signature can be
judicially taken notice of under illustration (e) of Section 114 of
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. In re: Shri Silli Man Subba & Ors.
v. Shri Man Bahadur Subba & Anr.3 the learned Single Judge of
this Court once again held that there was no necessity to
examine the Block Development Officer to prove the certificate as
it would fall within the meaning of a public document under
Section 74 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 and thus judicial
notice can be taken of it under clause (6) and (7) of Section 57
thereof. The learned Single Judge also held that the Block
Development Officer being a public officer duly conferred with
the authority to issue income certificates, it would not be
mandatory to call him in the witness box to prove that he had
indeed issued the income certificate. It was held even otherwise,
it is trite that in cases filed under the provisions of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, strict rules of evidence are not applicable.
This Court sees no reason to differ from the earlier views of this
Court.
2014 SCC OnLine Sikk 198
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
15. In the judgment of the Supreme Court in re: Sunita & Ors. v.
Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation & Anr.4 relied upon by
Mr. N. Rai it has been lucidly held:
“31...... The approach in examining the evidence in accident
claim cases is not to find fault with non examination of some
“best” eye witness in the case but to analyse the evidence
already on record to ascertain whether that is sufficient to
answer the matters in issue on the touchstone of preponderance
of probability. This court, in Dulcina Fernandes (supra), faced a
similar situation where the evidence of claimant’s eyewitness
was discarded by the Tribunal and the respondent was
acquitted in the criminal case concerning the accident. This
Court, however, took the view that the material on record was
prima facie sufficient to establish that the respondent was
negligent. In the present case, therefore, the Tribunal was right
in accepting the claim of the appellants even without the
deposition of the pillion rider. Rajulal Khateek, since the other
evidence on record was good enough to prima facie establish the
manner in which the accident had occurred and the identity of
the parties involved in the accident.”
16. The first challenge by the Appellant about the nonexamination of the Block Development Officer to prove the
income certificate therefore, must fail.
17. Relying upon the judgment of this Court in re: The Branch
Manager, National Insurance Company Limited v. Smt. Tika Devi
Limboo & Ors.5 Mr. Thupden Gyatso Bhutia sought a remand of
this case to examine the Block Development Officer who issued
the income certificate. In the said case this Court had remanded
2019 SCC OnLine SC 195
2017 SCC OnLine Sikk 201
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
the matter in view of the anomaly in the income detailed in the
income certificate. No such anomaly could be pointed out in the
income certificate by the learned Counsel and evidently none
exist. As such the prayer for remand is liable to be rejected.
18. The second ground of challenge by Mr. Thupden Gyatso
Bhutia is regarding the unauthorised use of the vehicle by the
driver which, as submitted, was admitted by the Respondent
no.3. It is argued that the learned Tribunal failed to consider
Section 149 (2) of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 under which
violation of terms and conditions of the Insurance Policy would
be a valid ground of defence.
19. The Respondent no.3 in his evidence-on-affidavit deposed
that the vehicle was driven by a qualified driver in possession of
valid driving license issued by the licensing authority. He also
deposed that the driver was authorised to drive light motor
vehicle. The Respondent no.3 further deposed that he had taken
a road drive test of the driver before giving him employment to
make sure that his driving was good. He deposed that after the
road drive test he was satisfied with his driving skills. Thereafter,
he perused the driving licence which seemed genuine, valid and
effective. He deposed that the documents of the vehicle including
insurance policy was valid and effective at the time of the
accident and that he had not violated any of its terms and
conditions.
The
Respondent
no.3
vouched
for
the
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
trustworthiness of the driver and stated that he used to take the
vehicle to his house after duty hours in case he got late. Having
stated the above the Respondent no.3 also stated:
“11.... It is pertinent to mention here that when the said
deceased driver Late Gopal Chettri used to take the vehicle to his
home from that time he was not in duty hours of the present
Respondent No.01. I came to know that the victim driver was
proceeding towards Rangchang, Makha-Dikchu Road driving the
above mentioned vehicle i.e. bearing Registration Number SK-01P-0466 and met with an accident resulting to his death at the
place
of
occurrence.
I further
came
to
know
that
two
unauthorized occupants were inside the said vehicle as the
driver had never taken any permission to take ant (sic-any)
friends/relatives/unauthorized persons/passengers in the said
vehicle......”
20. Referring to the above quoted deposition of the Respondent
no.3 it was argued that he having admittedly not authorised the
driver to take his vehicle when it met with the accident
amounted to violation of the terms and conditions of the
insurance policy.
21. The Respondent no.3 has categorically deposed that the
driver used to take the vehicle to his house after duty hours in
case he got late. Thus the driver taking the vehicle with him
away from the Respondent no.3’s house was authorised. Section
146 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 provides that no person
shall use, except as a passenger, or cause or allow any other
person to use, a motor vehicle in a public place, unless there is
in force in relation to the use of the vehicle by that person or that
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
other person, as the case may be, a policy of insurance
complying
with
the
requirements
of
this
chapter.
The
Respondent no.3 had exhibited the insurance policy. The
Appellant cross-examined the Respondent no.3. No question was
put to the Respondent no.3 about him violating the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy in spite of the statement
quoted above. In the written objection filed by the Appellant it
was contended by him that the use of the vehicle was illegal and
therefore there was contributory negligence on the part of the
deceased in using the private vehicle for commercial purpose. It
is submitted that this tantamount to violation of terms and
conditions of the insurance policy. No evidence was led to
establish the allegation that the vehicle was used for commercial
purpose. A perusal of the insurance policy does not reflect any
such terms and condition which have been violated. The
Appellant did not rely upon or refer to any specific term or
condition of the policy in question. It is not in dispute that the
Appellant had notice through the learned Tribunal of the
bringing of the proceedings. The Appellant was made a party to
the proceedings and permitted to defend the action on any of the
grounds available. It was completely within the Appellant’s right
to defend the action specifying the breach of the condition of the
insurance policy. In spite of the opportunity no evidence was led
by the Appellant to satisfy the learned Tribunal about any
MAC Appeal No. 03 of 2018
Branch Manager v. Mrs. Dil Kumari Subba & Ors.
breach of the conditions of the insurance policy. It is evident that
there was no such breach. As such the second ground of
challenge by the Appellant also must fail.
22.
No further grounds were urged by the Appellant during the
course of the hearing. The learned Tribunal has examined the
evidence and correctly come to the conclusion that the
Respondent no.1 and 2 were entitled to compensation as
calculated. The amount of compensation granted by the learned
Tribunal not being challenged nothing further remains to be
decided.
23. The appeal fails. The judgment and award both dated
27.11.2017 passed by the learned Tribunal are upheld.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
10.06.2019
to/
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review