Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED: 16.03.2019
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 06 of 2017
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company
Limited,
Gangtok Branch, East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal,
Wife of Late Thakur Prasad Dhakal.
2.
Master Abhishek Prasad Dhakal,
Son of Late Thakur Prasad Dhakal.
3.
Ms. Archana Dhakal,
Daughter of Late Thakur Prasad Dhakal.
(Residents of
Cheuribote, Duga Road,
Central Pendam,
P.O. & P.S. Rangpo, East Sikkim).
4.
Shri Bishwajit Chettri,
Son of Late Bhakta Bahadur Chettri,
P.O. Melli Gumpa, Kubinday Busty,
P.S. Melli, South Sikkim.
Appeal under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
----------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Ms. Smita Pradhan, Ms. Rubina Pradhan and Mr. Deven Rai,
Advocates for the Appellant.
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Mr. Rahul Rathi, Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa and Mr.
Aditya Makkhim, Advocates for Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3.
Mr. Ashok Pradhan, Advocate for Respondent No. 4.
-----------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J
1.
The apple of discord in this Appeal is the period of
validity shown in the Driving Licence of the driver of the illfated vehicle produced by the Claimants (Respondents No. 1,
and
herein)
which
extends
from
08.09.2006
to
07.09.2024. This, according to the Appellant, is contrary to
the extract of the office records of the issuance of Driving
Licence obtained by the Appellant from the Office of the
District Magistrate, Darjeeling Motor Vehicles Department,
Government of West Bengal which reflects the period of
validity as 08.09.2006 to 07.09.2009. The Driving Licence
(Exhibit 15) furnished thus cannot be considered as it was
ineffective on the day of the accident viz. 02.04.2015, thereby
in contravention of the terms of insurance. The other points
raised in Appeal are; the granting of 50% as future prospects
which according to the Appellant is incorrect as the deceased
was not a permanent employee. Further, disgruntlement also
ensues on account of the granting of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees
twenty five thousand) only, to the Claimants as funeral
expenses of the deceased.
2.
The above discontentment emanates in a prayer for
setting aside the judgment of the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal, East Sikkim at Gangtok (for short 'learned Tribunal')
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
being MACT Case No. 10 of 2015 (Mrs. Aruna Dhakal and two
others v. The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.
and another) dated 06.12.2016, by which a total sum of
Rs.14,03,900/- (Rupees fourteen lakhs, three thousand and
nine hundred) only, was awarded as compensation to the
three Claimants before the learned Tribunal.
3.
The Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 herein were the
Claimants No. 1, 2 and 3 and Respondent No. 4 was the
Opposite Party No. 2 before the learned Tribunal. The
Appellant herein was the Opposite Party No. 1 before the
learned Tribunal. They shall be referred to in their order of
appearance before this Court.
4.
Before the learned Tribunal, the Respondents No. 1, 2
and 3 sought compensation of an amount of Rs.15,89,800/(Rupees
fifteen
lakhs,
eighty
nine
thousand
and
eight
hundred) only, on account of the death of the husband of the
Respondent No. 1 and father of Respondents No. 2 and 3, in a
motor vehicle accident at 23:00 Hrs at Khanigaon under
Rangpo Police Station, East Sikkim on 02.04.2015, in which
the victim was travelling along with Respondent No. 2. The
accident allegedly occurred due to the inability of the driver to
control the vehicle on a curve in the road, resultant the vehicle
swerved off the road to approximately 1000 feet below
causing in the instantaneous death of the victim and injuries
on the survivor, Respondent No. 2. The learned Tribunal, on
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
careful consideration of the evidence and the documents on
record concluded that the Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 were
entitled to compensation of Rs.14,03,900/- (Rupees fourteen
lakhs, three thousand and nine hundred) only, as against the
claim of Rs.15,89,800/- (Rupees fifteen lakhs, eighty nine
thousand and eight hundred) only, put forth by them. The
Appellant was ordered to pay the compensation.
5.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant while reiterating the
averments made in his Appeal, submitted before this Court,
that the Driving Licence
(in “Category T”) of the driver
employed by the Respondent No. 4 cannot be for an extended
duration viz. 08.09.2006 to 07.09.2024 as reflected in the
Licence in view of the provisions of Section 14 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988. That Exhibit R-2 furnished by the
Appellant which is an extract of the official records kept in the
Office of the District Magistrate, Darjeeling Motor Vehicles
Department, Government of West Bengal indicates that the
Licence was in fact issued on 08.09.2006 which tallies with the
date of issue given on Exhibit 15 but the validity extends only
up to 07.09.2009 in terms of the requirement of law. That,
Exhibit R-2 was handed over to them on 19.11.2015 from the
concerned Office as detailed supra and there is no reason to
doubt the extract of the official records. Hence the only
conclusion that can be arrived at is that Exhibit 15 having
doubtful
origins
ought
not
to
be
given
consideration.
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
Consequently computation made on the assumption that the
Licence was valid amongst other considerations ought to be
set aside. It was also contended that the deceased was a
worker in a nursery and employed on Muster Roll and not
permanently, therefore, the learned Tribunal was in error in
granting 50% of monthly income of Rs.6,600/- (Rupees six
thousand and six hundred) only, as future prospects while
computing the compensation. Also that the learned Tribunal
erred in granting Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand)
only, for funeral expenses. No reason however was set forth in
support of this contention.
6.
Per contra the arguments advanced by learned Counsel
for the Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 were since the Licence was
issued for a Light Motor Vehicle, therefore, the driver was
authorized to drive any vehicle in the said category of which
the unladen weight did not exceed 7,500 kilograms. Besides
merely because Exhibit R-2 is an official record it does not
establish that Exbt. 15 the Driving Licence produced by the
Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 could not have been issued for
the period 08.09.2006 to 07.09.2024 as indicated therein.
That apart, Exhibit R-2 has not been proved by any authority
of the concerned Office thereby raising doubts with regard to
its authenticity. Placing reliance on the decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Compaq International and Anr. vs. Bajaj Allianz
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
General Insurance Company Limited and Anr.1 learned Counsel further
contended that the Licencing Authority themselves have failed
to furnish a purported copy of the true Licence of the driver,
hence the issuance of Exhibit 15 by them cannot be denied.
Reliance was also placed on the ratio of this Court in The Branch
Manager, National Insurance Company Limited v. Indra Maya Biswakarma
and Others2
to press the argument that the insurer cannot
disown its liability only for the reason that the validity of the
Licence does not tally with the alleged official records of
issuance. Learned Counsel also took the assistance of the ratio
in Mukund Dewangan vs. Oriental Insurance Company Limited with other
Special Leave Petitions3; Jagdish Kumar Sood vs. United India Insurance
Company Limited and others4; S. Iyyapan vs. M/S United India Insurance
Company Ltd. and another5; A.P.S.R.T.C. vs. P. Thirupal Reddy6 and Ashok
Gangadhar Maratha vs. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.7 to garner strength
for the contention that once a Driving Licence is issued to a
driver he is authorized to drive any vehicle in the category
mentioned in the Licence. Countering the argument of the
Appellant that the learned Tribunal erred in granting 50% as
future prospects, reliance was placed on the decision of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Shashikala and Ors. vs. Gangalakshmamma
and Anr.8 wherein it was inter alia observed that in the case of
2018 (5) Scale 46
2018 ACJ 1387
2017 AIR (SC) 3668
MANU/SC/0208/2018
2013 (7) SCC 62
2005 (12) SCC 189
(1999) 6 SCC 620
2015 (9) SCC 150
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
self-employed
or
persons
with
fixed
wages
where
the
deceased victim was below 40 years, there must be an
addition of 50% to the annual income of the deceased while
computing future prospects. That, for funeral expenses, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rajesh and Others vs. Rajbir Singh and
Others9
has
specifically
laid
down
that
an
amount
of
Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) only, is to be
computed for the said purpose.
7.
I have heard in extenso and considered the rival
submissions of learned Counsel for the parties. I have also
perused the documents and evidence on record.
8.
The question that requires consideration by this Court
pertains to the allegation of the Appellant regarding the
improbability of the extended validity of the Driving Licence,
Exhibit 15 (08.09.2006 to 07.09.2024) produced by the
Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 while official records contrarily
indicate validity from 08.09.2006 to 07.09.2009. Peripheral to
these are the points regarding 50% addition as future
prospects to the loss of earnings and Rs.25,000/- (Rupees
twenty five thousand) only, as funeral expenses. In this
context, it is but essential to carefully examine the documents
and evidence furnished by both contesting parties.
(2013) 9 SCC 54
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
9.
What emerges from the evidence on record is that
Exhibit 15 is the Licence which was issued according to the
Respondent No. 1 to the driver of the vehicle. Neither of the
parties have examined the driver of the vehicle. The validity
shown on Exhibit 15 is from 08.09.2006 to 07.09.2024 and it
is not denied by the Appellant that the Licence was issued
from the Office of the District Magistrate, Motor Vehicles
Department, Darjeeling. According to Exhibit 15, the driver
was authorized to drive a Light Motor Vehicle Transport (LMVT). The Respondent No. 4 vide Exhibit 16 had authorized the
driver to drive the vehicle having employed him after perusing
the Driving Licence, Exhibit 15 which appeared to him to be
genuine as it bore the seal and signature of the Licencing
Authority. Consequently he had taken the driver for a road
test drive and on being satisfied thereof had engaged him. It
is no one‟s case that the vehicle in accident was not
maintained properly and not mechanically fit to be in service
at the time of the accident. It is also no one‟s case that the
documents
pertaining
to
the
vehicle
were
invalid
and
ineffective at the time of the accident. The Appellant has failed
to take steps with regard to Exhibit 15 inasmuch as no FIR
was lodged with the concerned Police Station alleging that the
document was fake neither was any report made to the
Licencing
Authority
seeking
clarification
concerning
the
extended validity. Admittedly no verification was made from
the said Office as to whether there was typographical error
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
committed on Exhibit 15 so far as the typing of the year
“2024” was concerned nor was any verification made with
regard to extension of dates or revalidation of the document.
The authority who had issued Exhibit R-2 has nowhere stated
that the seal or signature appearing on Exhibit 15 was fake
and in fact no steps had been initiated even by the Licencing
Authority although according to the witness of the Appellant
when they sought for Exhibit R-2 they had also submitted a
copy of Exhibit 15. The Charge-Sheet, Exhibit 30 submitted by
the Police reveals that the driver had committed offences
under Sections 279, 336, 337, 304 A of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 read with Sections 177 and 178 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988. The extract of the Driving Licence Exhibit R-2
contrarily indicates that the Licence was issued on 08.09.2006
and was valid up to 07.09.2009. This document was allegedly
issued by the Office of the District Magistrate, Darjeeling
Motor Vehicle Department, Government of West Bengal on
19.11.2015. The witness Kishore Kumar Subba failed to
establish by any evidence as to how this document was
obtained from the said Office. No letter of requisition made to
the concerned Office seeking the document was placed before
the learned Tribunal for perusal. The contents of the document
remained unproved as also the signature on the document.
The argument of the Appellant that Exhibit 15 was invalid on
the date of accident thus has no legs to stand. It is indeed
settled law that rules of Civil Procedure Code, 1908 and the
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 do not strictly apply to matters in
Motor
Accidents
Claims
requirements have
nevertheless
the
elementary
to be fulfilled inasmuch as once
a
document is furnished there must be some proof of its
authenticity.
10.
Section 35 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 require the
following conditions to be fulfilled before a document can be
held to be admissible under this Section;
(i)
The document must be in the nature of an entry in
any public or other official book, register or record;
(ii)
It must state a fact in issue or a relevant fact; and
(iii)
The entry must be made by a public servant in the
discharge of his official duties, or in performance of
his duties.
[State of Bihar vs. Radha Krishna Singh and Others10]
Such entries however must be established by necessary
evidence. In addition to which the entries must be made by or
under the direction of the person whose duty it is to make
them at the relevant time. It is essential to show that the
document was prepared by the public servant in the discharge
of his official duty.
11.
Section 74 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 defines
what public documents are and reads as follows;
(1983) 3 SCC 118
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
“74. Public documents.—The following documents
are public documents:(1) Documents forming the acts, or records of
the acts—
(i) of the sovereign authority,
(ii) of official bodies and tribunals, and
(iii) of public officers, legislative, judicial and
executive, of any part of India or of the
Commonwealth, or of a foreign country;
(2) Public records kept in any State of private
documents.”
12.
In Madan Mohan Singh and Others vs. Rajni Kant and Another11
distinguishing between the admissibility of a document and its
probative value, the Hon„ble Supreme Court would explain as
follows;
“18. Therefore, a document may be admissible,
but as to whether the entry contained therein has any
probative value may still be required to be examined in
the facts and circumstances of a particular case. The
aforesaid legal proposition stands fortified by the
judgments of this Court in Ram Prasad Sharma v. State
of Bihar [(1969) 2 SCC 359 : AIR 1970 SC 326], Ram
Murti v. State of Haryana [(1970) 3 SCC 21 : 1970 SCC
(Cri) 371 : AIR 1970 SC 1029], Dayaram v.
Dawalatshah [(1971) 1 SCC 358 : AIR 1971 SC 681],
Harpal Singh v. State of H.P. [(1981) 1 SCC 560 : 1981
SCC (Cri) 208 : AIR 1981 SC 361], Ravinder Singh
Gorkhi v. State of U.P. [(2006) 5 SCC 584 : (2006) 2
SCC (Cri) 632], Babloo Pasi v. State of Jharkhand
[(2008) 13 SCC 133 : (2009) 3 SCC (Cri) 266], Desh
Raj v. Bodh Raj [(2008) 2 SCC 186 : AIR 2008 SC 632]
and Ram Suresh Singh v. Prabhat Singh [(2009) 6 SCC
681 : (2010) 2 SCC (Cri) 1194]. In these cases, it has
been held that even if the entry was made in an official
record by the official concerned in the discharge of his
official duty, it may have weight but still may require
corroboration by the person on whose information the
entry has been made and as to whether the entry so
made has been exhibited and proved. The standard of
proof required herein is the same as in other civil and
criminal cases.
19. Such entries may be in any public document
i.e. school register, voters' list or family register
prepared under the Rules and Regulations, etc. in
force, and may be admissible under Section 35 of the
Evidence Act as held in Mohd. Ikram Hussain v. State
of U.P. [AIR 1964 SC 1625 : (1964) 2 Cri LJ 590] and
Santenu Mitra v. State of W.B. [(1998) 5 SCC 697 :
1998 SCC (Cri) 1381 : AIR 1999 SC 1587].
20. So far as the entries made in the official
record by an official or person authorised in
performance of official duties are concerned, they may
be admissible under Section 35 of the Evidence
Act but the court has a right to examine their
(2010) 9 SCC 209
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
probative value. The authenticity of the entries would
depend on whose information such entries stood
recorded and what was his source of information. ......”
[emphasis supplied]
It is indeed explicit that the Indian Evidence Act, 1872
does not give licence to any party to submit and rely on any
document sans proof by any measure whatsoever. Even if the
strict rules of evidence are excluded in the instant matter, one
cannot overlook the fact that there is no proof whatsoever on
record that the Appellant had sought Exhibit R-2 from the
concerned Office or that it had in fact been issued by the said
Office. No registers or entries made were furnished to prove
the contention of the Appellant nor was any official examined
to oust the doubts that arise on its authenticity. In such
circumstances, in my considered opinion, Exhibit R-2 has no
probative value.
13.
That
having
been
said,
coming
to
Exhibit
15,
undoubtedly the authenticity of this document has remained
unchallenged save the extended validity period which was
argued by the Appellant as being an impossibility. The
provisions of Section 14 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 which
reads as follows are relevant for the present purposes;
“14. Currency of licences to drive motor vehicles.(1) A learner's licence issued under this Act shall,
subject to the other provisions of this Act, be
effective for a period of six months from the date
of issue of the licence.
(2) A driving licence issued or renewed under this Act
shall,(a) in the case of a licence to drive a transport
vehicle, be effective for a period of three years:
[Provided that in the case of licence to drive a
transport vehicle carrying goods of dangerous or
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
hazardous nature be effective for a period of one
year and renewal thereof shall be subject to the
condition that the driver undergoes one day
refresher course of the prescribed syllabus; and]
(b) in the case of any other licence,(i) if
the person obtaining the licence, either
originally or on renewal thereof, has not attained
the age of fifty years on the date of issue or, as the
case may be, renewal thereof,(A) be effective for a period of twenty years from the
date of such issue or renewal; or
(B) until the date on which such person attains the
age of fifty years, whichever is earlier;
(ii) if the person referred to in sub-clause (i), has
attained the age of fifty years on the date of issue
or as the case may be, renewal thereof, be
effective, on payment of such fee as may be
prescribed, for a period of five years from the date
of such issue or renewal:
Provided
that
every
driving
licence
shall,
notwithstanding its expiry under this sub-section,
continue to be effective for a period of thirty days from
such expiry.”
14.
Section 14(2)(a) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 thus
clarifies that a Licence to drive a transport vehicle will be
effective for a period of three years. In this context, we may
revisit Exhibit 15 and the evidence of Kishore Kumar Subba,
the witness has categorically stated under cross-examination
as follows;
“...It is true that the O.P. No. 1 is only disputing
with regard to the period of validity of the
driving licence of offending driver Tek Bahadur
Chettri though the said driving licence was
issued by Licencing Authority, Darjeeling.
It is true that as per Exbt. R-2 the offending driver
is having a skill of driving with regard to light motor
vehicle (Transport).
It is true that we had not put any queries to
Licencing Authority, Darjeeling as to whether there was
any typographical mistake with regard to typing of year
of validity i.e., 2024.
It is true that the said driving licence as filed by the
claimants is tallying with Exbt. R-2 apart from the
period of validation.
It is true that in Exbt. R-2 the authority had not
said that the licence, the seal appearing on licence
or the signature on the same are fake. ...”
[emphasis supplied]
The provisions of Section 14 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 extracted hereinabove clarify that when the Driving
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
Licence is issued or renewed under the Act licencing a person
to drive a “Transport Vehicle,” the licence is to be issued for a
period of three years. It is only in the case of any other
Licence that the validity can be for a period of twenty years
from the date of either issuance or renewal provided the
person has not attained the age of 50 years. The details as to
what transpires for issuance and renewal of Licence after a
person attains the age of 50 years is not being elucidated
herein being irrelevant for the present purposes as the driver
to whom Exhibit 15 was issued was approximately 34 years at
the time of the accident as emerges from the same document.
15.
The evidence of Kishore Kumar Subba is a clear
admission of the fact that the only dispute is with regard to
the validity of the Driving Licence i.e. the period between the
date of issuance and date of expiry. This is indeed a vexed
situation since the contest is not to the genuineness of the
Licence as it is not disputed that the Driving Licence was
issued by the Licencing Authority in Darjeeling. It is also not
disputed that the offending driver had skills to drive Light
Motor Vehicle (Transport). No questions were put forth to the
Licencing Authority as to whether there was any typographical
error
with
regard
to
the
year
of
validity.
In
such
a
circumstance, considering that the Appellant has failed to
decimate the validity of Exhibit 15 it stands as a genuine
document irrespective of the fact that it does not comply with
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
the provisions of Section 14 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
This is so since no concerned authority was examined to
establish that the period of validity was wrongly entered and
neither the driver nor the Claimants or the owner can be held
to ransom for any alleged erroneous entry in the Driving
Licence made by the concerned authority. There is no
allegation that the Driving Licence was prepared by any of the
Respondents or for that matter by the driver himself.
16.
This Court in Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs.
Karma Bhutia and others12
has while placing reliance on the
decision in United India Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Lehru and others13
has United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Lehru and Others,
(2003) 1 ACC 611 (SC) held that the owner cannot be
expected to launch investigation into the genuineness of the
Licence when employing the driver. On this count, it would be
worthwhile to extract the observation of the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Lehru and others
(supra) wherein it was held as follows;
“17. When an owner is hiring a driver he will therefore
have to check whether the driver has a driving licence.
If the driver produces a driving licence which on the
face of it looks genuine, the owner is not expected to
find out whether the licence has in fact been issued by
a Competent Authority or not. The owner would then
take the test of the driver. If he finds that the driver is
competent to drive the vehicle, he will hire the driver.
We find it rather strange that Insurance Companies
expect owners to make enquiries with RTOs, which are
spread all over the country, whether the driving licence
shown to them is valid or not. Thus where the owner
has satisfied himself that the driver has a licence and is
driving competently there would be no breach of
Section 149(2)(a)(ii). The Insurance Company
2016 (161) AIC 830
(2003) 1 ACC 611 (SC)
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
would not then be absolved of liability. If it
ultimately turns out that the licence was fake the
Insurance Company would continue to remain
liable unless they prove that the owner/insured
was aware or had noticed that the licence was
fake and still permitted that person to drive. More
importantly even in such a case the Insurance
Company would remain liable to the innocent third
party, but it may be able to recover from the insured.
...”
17.
Further, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court also observed in
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh and Others14 as follows;
“109. ........................
(iii) The breach of policy condition e.g., disqualification
of the driver on invalid driving licence of the driver, as
contained in Sub-section (2)(a)(ii) of Section 149, have
to be proved to have been committed by the insured
for avoiding liability by the insurer. Mere absence, fake
or invalid driving licence or disqualification of the driver
for driving at the relevant time, are not in themselves
defences available to the insurer against either the
insured or the third parties. To avoid its liability
towards the insured, the insurer has to prove that the
insured was guilty of negligence and failed to exercise
reasonable care in the matter of fulfilling the condition
of the policy regarding use of vehicles by duly licensed
driver or one who was not disqualified to drive at the
relevant time...”
Hence, in view of the aforestated observations the
question of the Licence being invalid on any account does not
arise. Section 2 (21) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 defines
Light Motor Vehicle as follows;
“(21) "light motor vehicle" means a transport vehicle
or omnibus the gross vehicle weight of either of which
or a motor car or tractor or road-roller the unladen
weight of any of which, does not exceed 7,500
kilograms;”
The vehicle in accident was described as a “C Carriage”
vehicle with unladen weight of 1720 kilograms in Exhibit 14,
the Certificate of Registration. Hence, the driver had the
requisite Licence to drive the vehicle in accident.
(2004) 1 ACC 1 (SC)
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
18.
Coming to the question of the learned Tribunal having
added 50% of the Monthly Income of Rs.6,600/- (Rupees six
thousand and six hundred) only, as future prospects, it needs
no reiteration that in Shashikala’s case (supra), the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court has specifically laid down that in the case of
self-employed or persons with fixed wages in case the
deceased victim was below forty years there must be an
addition of 50% to the actual income of the deceased while
computing future prospects. This observation was arrived at
after considering the ratio of a two Judge Bench of the same
Court in Santosh Devi vs. National Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors.15
The
relevant paragraphs as discussed by the Court is extracted as
under;
“14. We find it extremely difficult to fathom any
rationale for the observation made in para 24 of the
judgment in Sarla Verma case that where the deceased
was self-employed or was on a fixed salary without
provision for annual increment, etc., the courts will
usually take only the actual income at the time of
death and a departure from this rule should be made
only in rare and exceptional cases involving special
circumstances. In our view, it will be naive to say that
the wages or total emoluments/income of a person who
is self-employed or who is employed on a fixed salary
without provision for annual increment, etc., would
remain the same throughout his life.
15. The rise in the cost of living affects everyone
across the board. It does not make any distinction
between rich and poor. As a matter of fact, the effect of
rise in prices which directly impacts the cost of living is
minimal on the rich and maximum on those who are
self-employed or who get fixed income/ emoluments.
They are the worst affected people. Therefore, they put
in extra efforts to generate additional income necessary
for sustaining their families.
16. The salaries of those employed under the
Central
and
State
Governments
and
their
agencies/instrumentalities have been revised from time
to time to provide a cushion against the rising prices
and provisions have been made for providing security
to the families of the deceased employees. The salaries
AIR 2012 SC 2185
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
of those employed in private sectors have also
increased manifold. Till about two decades ago, nobody
could have imagined that salary of Class IV employee
of the Government would be in five figures and total
emoluments of those in higher echelons of service will
cross the figure of rupees one lakh.
17. Although the wages/income of those
employed in unorganized sectors has not registered a
corresponding increase and has not kept pace with the
increase in the salaries of the government employees
and those employed in private sectors, but it cannot be
denied that there has been incremental enhancement
in the income of those who are self-employed and even
those engaged on daily basis, monthly basis or even
seasonal basis. We can take judicial notice of the fact
that with a view to meet the challenges posed by high
cost of living, the persons falling in the latter category
periodically increase the cost of their labour. In this
context, it may be useful to give an example of a tailor
who earns his livelihood by stitching clothes. If the cost
of living increases and the prices of essentials go up, it
is but natural for him to increase the cost of his labour.
So will be the cases of ordinary skilled and unskilled
labour, like, barber, blacksmith, cobbler, mason, etc.
18. Therefore, we do not think that while making
the observations in the last three lines of para 24 of
Sarla Verma judgment, the Court had intended to lay
down an absolute rule that there will be no addition in
the income of a person who is self-employed or who is
paid fixed wages. Rather, it would be reasonable to say
that a person who is self-employed or is engaged on
fixed wages will also get 30% increase in his total
income over a period of time and if he/she becomes
the victim of an accident then the same formula
deserves to be applied for calculating the amount of
compensation.”
Hence, people who are self-employed or engaged on
fixed wages are also entitled to 50% of the actual income of
the deceased to be computed as future prospects. Later in
Rajesh and Others (supra) a
three Judge Bench of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court took into consideration the decision of the case
in Sarla Verma (Smt.) and Others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and
Another16 and Santosh Devi (supra) and held as follows;
“8. Since, the Court in Santosh Devi case actually
intended to follow the principle in the case of salaried
persons as laid down in Sarla Verma case and to make
it applicable also to the self-employed and persons on
(2009) 6 SCC 121
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
fixed wages, it is clarified that the increase in the case
of those groups is not 30% always; it will also have a
reference to the age. In other words, in the case of
self-employed or persons with fixed wages, in case,
the deceased victim was below 40 years, there must
be an addition of 50% to the actual income of the
deceased
while
computing
future
prospects.
Needless to say that the actual income should be
income after paying the tax, if any. Addition should be
30% in case the deceased was in the age group of 40
to 50 years.”
[emphasis supplied]
This issue is no more res integra and in fact ought to have
brooked no discussions in view of the settled position of law.
19.
With regard to the addition of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees
twenty five thousand) only, as funeral expenses, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in Rajesh and others (supra) held as follows;
“18. We may also take judicial notice of the fact
that the Tribunals have been quite frugal with regard to
award of compensation under the head “funeral
expenses”. The “price index”, it is a fact has gone up in
that regard also. The head “funeral expenses” does not
mean the fee paid in the crematorium or fee paid for
the use of space in the cemetery. There are many
other expenses in connection with funeral and, if the
deceased is a follower of any particular religion, there
are several religious practices and conventions
pursuant to death in a family. All those are quite
expensive. Therefore, we are of the view that it will be
just, fair and equitable, under the head of “funeral
expenses”, in the absence of evidence to the contrary
for higher expenses, to award at least an amount of
Rs.25,000.”
This is therefore also settled by the aforestated ratio.
20.
Now to address the quantum of compensation. The
judgment of the learned Tribunal reveals that the Multiplier of
17 has been adopted for computing loss of earnings. It would
be relevant to point out that Section 163 A of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 contains a special provision for payment of
compensation on a structured formula basis as spelt out in the
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
table in the Second Schedule to the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
This
table
however
does
not
apply
for
computing
compensation for applications under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988. The instant Appeal arises out of a petition
filed under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. In
Sarla Verma’s
case (supra) the Hon‟ble Supreme Court while
discussing the ratio in General Manager, Kerala S.R.T.C. vs. Susamma
Thomas17, UP State Road Transport Corporation vs. Trikok Chandra 18 and
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. vs. Charlie19 for claims under Section
166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 inter alia held;
“20. Tribunals/courts adopt and apply different
operative multipliers. Some follow the multiplier with
reference to Susamma Thomas (set out in column 2 of
the table above); some follow the multiplier with
reference to Trilok Chandra, (set out in column 3 of
the table above); some follow the multiplier with
reference to Charlie (set out in column (4) of the Table
above); many follow the multiplier given in second
column of the Table in the Second Schedule of MV Act
(extracted in column 5 of the table above); and some
follow the multiplier actually adopted in the Second
Schedule
while
calculating
the
quantum
of
compensation (set out in column 6 of the table above).
For example if the deceased is aged 38 years, the
multiplier would be 12 as per Susamma Thomas, 14 as
per Trilok Chandra, 15 as per Charlie, or 16 as per the
multiplier given in column (2) of the Second Schedule
to the MV Act or 15 as per the multiplier actually
adopted in the second Schedule to MV Act. Some
Tribunals, as in this case, apply the multiplier of 22 by
taking the balance years of service with reference to
the retiring age. It is necessary to avoid this kind of
inconsistency. We are concerned with cases falling
under Section 166 and not under Section 163A of MV
Act. In cases falling under Section 166 of the MV Act,
Davies method is applicable.
21. We therefore hold that the multiplier to be
used should be as mentioned in column (4) of the
Table above (prepared by applying Susamma Thomas,
Trilok Chandra and Charlie), which starts with an
operative multiplier of 18 (for the age groups of 15 to
20 and 21 to 25 years), reduced by one unit for every
five years, that is M-17 for 26 to 30 years, M-16 for
31 to 35 years, M-15 for 36 to 40 years, M-14 for 41
to 45 years, and M-13 for 46 to 50 years, then
(1994) 2 SCC 176
(1996) 4 SCC 362
AIR 2005 SC 2157
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
reduced by two units for every five years, that is, M11 for 51 to 55 years, M-9 for 56 to 60 years, M-7 for
61 to 65 years and M-5 for 66 to 70 years.”
In view of the speaking decision, as the deceased was
approximately 34 years at the time of accident, the correct
Multiplier that the learned Tribunal ought to have adopted
would have been 16.
21.
In conclusion, the judgment of the learned Tribunal
warrants no interference save to the extent of the choice of
Multiplier.
22.
In light of the above discussions and findings, the
compensation stands re-calculated and modified as follows;
Monthly Income of the deceased
Rs.6,600.00
Annual Income of the deceased (Rs.6600x12)
Rs.79,200.00
Add 50% of Rs.79,200.00 as future prospects
Rs.39,600.00
Yearly income of the deceased
Rs.1,18,800.00
rd
Less 1/3 of Rs. 1,18,800.00
[deducted from the said amount in consideration of
the instances which the victim would have incurred
towards maintenance had he been alive.]
Rs.39,600.00
Net yearly income
Rs.79,200.00
Multiplier of ‘16’ adopted in terms of
Sarla Verma’s case (supra) (Rs.79,200 x 16)
Rs.12,67,200.00
Add Funeral expenses
Rs.25,000.00
Add Loss of estate
Rs.2,500.00
Add Loss of consortium
Rs.5,000.00
Add Non-pecuniary damages
Rs.25,000.00
Total
Rs.13,24,700.00
(Rupees thirteen lakhs, twenty four thousand and seven hundred) only.
23.
The Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 shall be entitled to
simple interest @ 9% per annum on the above amount with
MAC App. No. 6 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Smt. Aruna Dhakal and Others
effect from the date of filing of the Claim Petition before the
learned Tribunal, until its full realisation.
24.
The Appellant is directed to pay the awarded amount to
the Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 within one month from today,
failing which, the Appellant shall pay simple interest @ 12%
per annum from the date of filing of the Claim Petition till
realisation, duly deducting the amounts, if any, already paid
by the Appellant to the Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3.
25.
The impugned Judgment and Award of the learned
Tribunal stands modified accordingly.
26.
The Appeal is dismissed.
27. No order as to costs.
28.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the learned Tribunal
for information and compliance, and its records be remitted
forthwith.
(Meenakshi Madan Rai)
Judge
16.03.2019
Approved for reporting: Yes
Internet: Yes
ml
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review