Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 18th FEBRUARY, 2020
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON‟BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.08 of 2019
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited
versus
Respondent
:
Chezing Bhutia and Others
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Ms. Kesang Choden Tamang, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Mr. Nima Tshering Sherpa,
Advocate for the Respondents No.1 to 3.
Mr. Mr. K. B. Chettri, Advocate for the Respondent No.4.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
and
CO No.02 of 2019
Appellants
:
Chezing Bhutia and Others
versus
Respondents
:
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited and Another
Cross-Objection under Order XLI Rule 22(1) and (2) read
with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Mr. Nima Tshering Sherpa,
Advocate for the Appellants.
Ms. Kesang Choden Tamang, Advocate for the Respondent
No.1.
Mr. Mr. K. B. Chettri, Advocate for the Respondent No.2.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.08 of 2019 and CO No.02 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Chezing Bhutia and Others
and
Chezing Bhutia and Others vs. The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Another
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Appeal assails the Judgment of the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim, at Gangtok (for short,
“Learned Claims Tribunal”), dated 29-03-2019, in MACT Case
No.70 of 2017.
The first ground raised is that the Learned
Claims Tribunal adopted the multiplier of „18‟ for calculating loss
of income of the deceased which allegedly resulted in a miscalculation of the amount awarded
Rs.27,99,376/-
(Rupees
twenty
which was placed at
seven
lakhs,
ninety
nine
thousand, three hundred and seventy six) only. That, infact the
multiplier adopted ought to have been „11‟ and not „18‟ bearing
in mind the age of the Claimants-Respondents No.1 to 3. The
age of the deceased instead was erroneously considered by the
Learned Claims Tribunal. The second ground for assailing the
Judgment was that despite the Claimants not having established
rash and negligent driving the Learned Claims Tribunal took into
consideration
the
prayer
of
the
Claimants
and
granted
compensation.
2.
In the Cross-Objection filed by the Appellant in the
Cross-Objection No.02 of 2019 (Respondents No.1 to 3 in MAC
App. No.08 of 2019) the grievance is that the Learned Claims
Tribunal failed to calculate and include “future prospects” of the
deceased in the compensation granted in terms of the Judgment
of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the ratio of National Insurance
MAC App. No.08 of 2019 and CO No.02 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Chezing Bhutia and Others
and
Chezing Bhutia and Others vs. The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Another
Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and Others1.
No objection on
this count was raised by Learned Counsel for the Respondent
No.1 (Appellant in MAC App No.08 of 2019).
The undisputed facts are that the deceased along
3.
with four other Indian Reserve Battalion (hereinafter, IRB)
personnel were travelling in vehicle bearing registration No.SK
01 P 8693 from IRB Camp at Pipaley, West Sikkim to Rorathang,
East Sikkim, on 11-08-2017. The vehicle met with an accident
near the Sikkim Distilleries, Rangpo, East Sikkim, resulting in the
death of the deceased, son of Respondents No.1 and 2 and
brother of Respondent No.3 (MAC App No.8 of 2019). The age
of the deceased being 22 years at the time of the accident is not
disputed.
4.
Learned Counsel for the parties have been heard at
length.
Their submissions duly considered and pleadings
perused.
5.
Others
In the light of the decision in Sarla Verma (Smt) and
vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another2, it is evident
that the multiplier to be adopted is indeed „18‟ and not „11‟, as
the age of the deceased and not that of the Claimants is the
criteria for consideration for adoption of multiplier.
Sethi
In Pranay
(supra) it has clearly been spelt out by the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court that the age of the deceased should be the basis
for applying the multiplier.
Hence, the objection raised by the
Appellant, on this count has no legs to stand.
(2017) 16 SCC 680
(2009) 6 SCC 121
MAC App. No.08 of 2019 and CO No.02 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Chezing Bhutia and Others
and
Chezing Bhutia and Others vs. The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Another
6.
So far as rash and negligent driving is concerned, it
is admitted that there were five occupants in the vehicle
including the driver of whom three passed away in the
unfortunate accident.
Apart from the driver, it was contended
that one remaining person was not examined.
It would be
apposite to remark here that barring exceptional cases, it is
always not possible for the Claimant to know what precisely led
to the accident, hence the application of the maxim res ipsa
loquitur, which is but a rule of evidence. The reason being that
there are certain incidents which do not occur unless there is
negligence. In consideration of the facts placed before this Court
the negligence on the part of the driver obviously cannot be
ruled out. Hence, I find no merit in the second ground raised in
the Appeal.
7.
Addressing the question in the Cross-Objection, viz.,
the Learned Claims Tribunal had failed to consider the future
prospects of the victim. In this context, in Pranay Sethi (supra)
the Supreme Court while discussing future prospects held as
hereunder extracted;
“59. In view of the aforesaid analysis, we
proceed to record our conclusions:
……………………………………………………………………….
59.3. While determining the income, an
addition of 50% of actual salary to the income of
the deceased towards future prospects, where the
deceased had a permanent job and was below the
age of 40 years, should be made. The addition
should be 30%, if the age of the deceased was
between 40 to 50 years. In case the deceased was
between the age of 50 to 60 years, the addition
should be 15%. Actual salary should be read as
actual salary less tax.
……………………………………………………………………….
MAC App. No.08 of 2019 and CO No.02 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Chezing Bhutia and Others
and
Chezing Bhutia and Others vs. The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Another
59.7. The age of the deceased should be the
basis for applying the multiplier.
59.8. Reasonable figures on conventional
heads, namely, loss of estate, loss of consortium
and funeral expenses should be Rs 15,000, Rs
40,000 and Rs 15,000 respectively. The aforesaid
amounts should be enhanced at the rate of 10% in
every three years.
[emphasis supplied]”
Since the deceased had a permanent job being an
employee in the Indian Reserve Battalion posted in Pipaley
Camp, West Sikkim, future prospects are thus due to him.
Nevertheless, as he was a bachelor there can be no computation
for “loss of consortium” as calculated by the Learned Claims
Tribunal
which
is
however
replaced
by
“Loss
of
Filial
Compensation”.
8.
In view of the aforestated discussions, the quantum
of compensation calculated by the Learned Claims Tribunal
stands re-calculated and modified as follows;
Annual income of the deceased
(Rs.25,272- x 12)
Rs.
3,03,264.00
Add 50% of Rs.3,03,264/- as Future Prospects
(+)
Rs.
Rs.
1,51,632.00
4,54,896.00
Less 50% of Rs.4,54,896/-
(−)
Rs.
2,27,448.00
Rs.
2,27,448.00
Rs.
40,94,064.00
(+)
Rs.
15,000.00
(+)
Rs.
15,000.00
(+)
Rs.
1,20,000.00
=
Rs.
42,44,064.00
[as the victim was a bachelor, in consideration
of the expenses which he would have incurred
towards maintaining himself had he been alive]
Net yearly income
Multiplier to be adopted „18‟
(Rs.2,27,448/- x 18)
[The age of the deceased at the time of death
was 22 and the relevant multiplier as per
Judgment of Sarla Verma (supra) is „18‟]
Funeral Expenses
[in terms of the Judgment of Pranay Sethi (supra)]
Loss of Estate
[in terms of the Judgment of Pranay Sethi (supra)]
Loss of Filial Consortium
(Rs.40,000/- x 3)
[in terms of the Judgment of Magma General Insurance
Co. Ltd. vs. Nanu Ram and Others : (2018) 18 SCC 130]
Total
(Rupees forty-two lakhs, forty-four thousand and sixty-four) only.
MAC App. No.08 of 2019 and CO No.02 of 2019
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited vs. Chezing Bhutia and Others
and
Chezing Bhutia and Others vs. The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Another
9.
The Appellant-Insurance Company shall pay the
compensation computed supra.
The Claimants-Respondents
shall be entitled to simple interest @ 10% per annum on the
above amount with effect from the date of filing of the Claim
Petition before the Learned Claims Tribunal, i.e., 14-09-2017,
until its full realisation.
10.
The Appellant-Insurance Company is directed to pay
the awarded amount to the Claimants-Respondents within one
month
from
today,
failing
which
the
Appellant-Insurance
Company shall pay simple interest @ 12% per annum from the
date of filing of the Claim Petition, till realisation, duly deducting
the amounts, if any, already paid by the Appellant-Insurance
Company to the Claimants-Respondents.
11.
Appeal dismissed.
Cross Objection allowed.
Both
stand disposed of accordingly.
12.
No order as to costs.
13.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Claims
Tribunal for information.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
18-02-2020
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review