Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:42
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 20TH APRIL, 2016
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
Appellants
:
1.
The Branch Manager,
ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd.,
Gangtok Branch,
Mundra Building, 5th Floor,
M. G. Marg,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2.
The General Manager,
ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd.,
House No.414,
Veer Savarkar Marg,
Near Sidhi Vinayak Temple,
Prabhadevi,
Mumbai – 400 025.
versus
Respondents-Claimants
:
1.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia,
S/o Late Ganden Bhutia,
Aged about 29 years
2.
Miss Karma Chemi Lhamu Bhutia,
D/o Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia,
Aged about 02 years
All residents of 8th Mile, Lingdok PW,
Sivik Lingdok Nampong GPU,
Lingdok,
P.O. 8th Mile,
P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2016:SHC:42
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
The Branch Manager, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. and Another
vs.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia and Others
Respondent-Owner
:
3.
Smt. Wongchuk Doma Bhutia,
W/o Shri Pema Namgyal Bhutia,
R/o Rongpa PW,
Near Block Administration Centre,
Kabi Tingda, GPU, Kabi,
P.O. & P.S. Phodong,
North Sikkim.
Appeal under Section 173
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance
Mr. Thupden G. Bhutia, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Ajay Rathi and Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa, Advocates for
Respondents No.1 and 2.
Mr. Ashok Pradhan, Advocate for Respondent No.3.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
This Appeal is directed against the impugned Judgment
and Award dated 28-05-2015 passed by the Learned Member, Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, North Sikkim at Mangan (for short “the
Claims Tribunal”), in MACT Case No.20 of 2014, directing the
Appellant/Insurer to pay Rs.14,99,500.52 (Rupees fourteen lakhs
ninety nine thousand five hundred and paisa fifty two) only, with
interest @ 10% per annum on the said sum to the Claimants from the
date of filing of the Claim Petition, i.e., 12-09-2014, till full and final
payment.
2016:SHC:42
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
The Branch Manager, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. and Another
vs.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia and Others
2.
The primary thrust of the arguments advanced by
Learned Counsel for the Appellants is that the Claim before the
Claims Tribunal does not stand as the accident, the onus of which
lies on the Claimants to prove, did not occur either due to rash or
negligent driving which is a sine qua non for a Claim made under
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short “the Act of
1988”), but is attributable to natural calamity, an Act of God, since it
occurred due to a landslide which crushed the occupants and the
vehicle. That the contents of the FIR, Exhibit 2, or the Final Report,
both, relied on by the Respondents do not indicate any element of
rashness or negligence on the part of the deceased driver as evident
from the fact that the case was registered only under Section 174 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short “Cr.P.C.”) and not
under Section 279 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”),
hence the Respondents cannot base their Claim on the principle of
res ipsa loquitur, which is not applicable in the present facts and
circumstances. Besides which, it is urged that the compensation
awarded is not just and the interest of 10% is exorbitant, the
impugned Judgment and Award be set aside. Learned Counsel has
placed
reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Oriental Insurance Company Limited
Others1.
1. (2007) 13 SC 476
vs.
Premlata Shukla and
2016:SHC:42
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
The Branch Manager, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. and Another
vs.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia and Others
3.
Per contra, it was the contention of Learned Counsel for
the Respondents No.1 and 2 that the facts at the site of the accident
unequivocally establish that the driver of the vehicle proceeded to
drive through the landslide despite being aware that the area was
prone to falling boulders, without application of mind which
resulted in the fatal accident, killing the victim, the driver and a
third occupant. The act of the driver was undoubtedly rash and
negligent and not the act of a prudent person who would have
considered the risks involved in driving through the landslide area,
hence the principle of res ipsa loquitur kicks into place. In view of
the facts and circumstances of the case, the finding and Award of the
Claims Tribunal requires no interference.
He has relied upon a
plethora of Judgments to buttress his arguments.
4.
Learned
Counsel
for
Respondent
No.3
had
no
submissions to put forth.
5.
I have heard the submissions of Learned Counsel at
length. I have also perused the documents and records as well as the
impugned Judgment and Award.
6.
The facts of the case in a nutshell are that, the deceased,
the wife of Respondent No.1 and mother of Respondent No.2, had
taken a lift while returning from work in her colleague’s vehicle on
24-06-2014, enroute the vehicle met with an accident due to a
2016:SHC:42
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
The Branch Manager, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. and Another
vs.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia and Others
landslide which crushed the vehicle, resulting in the death of the
victim, the driver and another occupant. The Respondent No.3 is
the owner of the vehicle.
7.
The Claims Tribunal in consideration of the evidence on
record decided all the four issues settled by it for determination in
favour of the Respondents No.1 and 2, accordingly the impugned
Judgment and Award was passed.
8.
It is not the case of the Respondents that they are
detracting from the facts as laid down in Exhibit 2, the FIR or for that
matter the Final Report, therefore, the authority relied on by the
Appellants in Oriental Insurance Company Limited 1, inter alia, as
extracted hereunder has no bearing to the case:“15. A party objecting to the admissibility of
a document must raise its objection at the
appropriate time. If the objection is not raised and
the document is allowed to be marked and that too at
the instance of a party which had proved the same
and wherefor consent of the other party has been
obtained, the former in our opinion cannot be
permitted to run round and raise a contention that
the contents of the documents had not been proved
and, thus, should not be relied upon. .................”
9.
Admittedly there were no eye-witnesses to the incident.
It is also not in dispute that the vehicle was insured, the documents
of the vehicle were valid and the driver had a Licence, which would,
therefore, take us to the question as to whether the accident was Vis
2016:SHC:42
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
The Branch Manager, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. and Another
vs.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia and Others
Major, as the Claimants are entitled to get compensation under
Section 166 of the Act of 1988 only if the “tort feasor”, viz., driver of
the vehicle, was driving the vehicle rashly and negligently and not
when the accident is the outcome of an Act of God.
10.
In this regard, the ratio in Divisional Controller, KSRTC
vs. Mahadeva Shetty and Another2 may be referred to profitably.
The Hon’ble Apex Court held therein, inter alia, as follows:“9. The expression “act of God” signifies the
operation of natural forces free from human
intervention, such as lightning, storm etc. It may
include such unexpected occurrences of nature as
severe gale, snowstorms, hurricanes, cyclones, tidal
waves and the like. But every unexpected wind and
storm does not operate as an excuse from liability, if
there is a reasonable possibility of anticipating their
happening. An act of God provides no excuse unless it
is so unexpected that no reasonable human foresight
could be presumed to anticipate the occurrence,
having regard to the conditions of time and place
known to be prevailing. For instance, where by
experience of a number of years, preventive action
can be taken, Lord Westbury defined the act of God
(damnum fatale in Scotch Laws) as an occurrence
which no human foresight can provide against and of
which human prudence is not bound to recognize the
possibility. This appears to be the nearest approach
to the true meaning of act of God. Lord Blancaburgh
spoke of it as “an irresistible and unsearchable
providence nullifying our human effort”.”
[emphasis supplied]
Thus, the above succinctly explains that Act of God is what no
human could have predicted in relation to the time and place known
to be prevailing, so as to enable one to take preventive action.
Negligence per contra is a specific tort and is the failure to exercise
2. (2003) 7 SCC 197
2016:SHC:42
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
The Branch Manager, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. and Another
vs.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia and Others
that care which circumstances demand, in other words, it is an
omission to do something which a reasonable man would do or to do
something which a prudent and reasonable man would not do.
Rashness, of course, tantamounts to doing an act without careful
consideration.
11.
Based on the touchstone of the principles extracted in
the Judgments supra, it can be inferred from the facts of the instant
case that the incident took place on 24-06-2014 in the midst of
Monsoons in Sikkim.
In such a situation, it was for the driver to
have taken sufficient precaution before embarking on her journey
homeward by checking the area for landslides and thereby taking
preventive action. The question of rashness and negligence is a
matter of inference to be drawn from the attendant circumstances
at the spot, the degree of care required in the particular situation
depends on the surrounding circumstances. While addressing the
matter at hand since the accident did occur and all occupants of the
vehicle are dead one has of necessity to take recourse to the
principle of res ipsa loquitur.
12.
In Ashish Kumar Mazumdar vs. Aishi Ram Batra
Charitable Hospital Trust and Others3, the Hon’ble Apex Court while
discussing the maxim opined as follows:-
3. (2014) 9 SCC 256
2016:SHC:42
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
The Branch Manager, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. and Another
vs.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia and Others
“10. The maxim res ipsa loquitur in its classic
form has been stated by Erle, C.J.
“.... where the thing is shewn to be
under the management of the defendant or his
servants, and the accident is such as in the
ordinary course of things does not happen if
those who have the management use proper
care, it affords reasonable evidence, in the
absence of explanation by the defendants, that
the accident arose from want of care.” [Scott v.
London & St. Katherine Docks Co. : (1865) 3 H & C 596 at
601]
(emphasis supplied)
The maxim applies to a case in which certain facts
proved by the plaintiff, by itself, would call for an
explanation from the defendant without the plaintiff
having to allege and prove any specific act or
omission of the defendant.
11.
In Shyam
Sunder
v.
State
of
Rajasthan [(1974) 1 SCC 690] it has been explained that
the principal function of the maxim is to prevent
injustice which would result if the plaintiff was
invariably required to prove the precise cause of the
accident when the relevant facts are unknown to him
but are within the knowledge of the defendant. It was
also explained that the doctrine would apply to a
situation when the mere happening of the accident is
more consistent with the negligence of the defendant
than with other causes.”
[emphasis supplied]
Thus, the principle of res ipsa loquitur requires no further
explanation and while analysing the facts of the instant case indicate
that the maxim squarely applies to the facts of the case.
13.
So far as the Report under Section 174 of the Cr.P.C. is
concerned, the matter pertains to unnatural death and the Police
while invoking the Section enquires into the limited purpose of the
cause of death in unnatural circumstances, inter alia, by accident.
Obviously since all occupants of the vehicle had died it would serve
2016:SHC:42
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
The Branch Manager, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. and Another
vs.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia and Others
no purpose to submit a charge-sheet under Sections 279/304A of the
IPC as there would be no person to prosecute, the victim driver
herself having succumbed to the accident. The logic behind Section
174 Cr.P.C. has been laid down in Podda Narayana and Others vs.
State of Andhra Pradesh4 wherein it has been held that –
“11. A perusal of this provision would clearly
show that, the object of the proceedings under
Section 174 is merely to ascertain whether a person
has died under suspicious circumstances or an
unnatural death and if so what is the apparent cause
of the death. The question regarding the details as to
how the deceased was assaulted or who assaulted him
or under what circumstances he was assaulted
appears to us to be foreign to the ambit and scope of
the proceedings under S. 174. In these circumstances,
therefore, neither in practice nor in law was it
necessary for the police to have mentioned these
details in the inquest report. ..........”
The above extract soundly quells any questions with regard to
non-mentioning of details in proceedings under Section 174 Cr.P.C.
in the instant matter. It may also be clarified here that it is not
necessary for the FIR to mention minute details of the incident, a
broad picture of the incident without specific details suffices for the
purpose.
14.
In view of the discussions above, I have reached the
finding that the accident was not on account of Vis Major but due to
to the rash and negligent act of the deceased driver of the
vehicle.
4. AIR 1975 SC 1252
2016:SHC:42
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
The Branch Manager, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. and Another
vs.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia and Others
15.
Coming to the question of compensation, the Claims
Tribunal calculated the Loss of Earning as Rs.13,52,000.52 inter alia,
on grounds that income of the deceased was Rs.10,000/- (Rupees ten
thousand) only, per month and as she was working on fixed income
30% was added as Future Prospects on Rs.10,000/- (Rupees ten
thousand) only, relying on the Judgment of Rajesh and Others vs.
Rajbir Singh and Others5. However, on perusal of the said authority
it is, inter alia, held as follows;
“8. Since, the Court in Santosh Devi case
[(2012) 6 SCC 421] actually intended to follow the
principle in the case of salaried persons as laid
in Sarla Verma case [(2009) 6 SCC 121] and to make it
applicable also to the self-employed and persons on
fixed wages, it is clarified that the increase in the case
of those groups is not 30% always; it will also have a
reference to the age. In other words, in the case of
self-employed or persons with fixed wages, in case,
the deceased victim was below 40 years, there must
be an addition of 50% to the actual income of
the deceased while computing future prospects.
Needless to say that the actual income should be
income after paying the tax, if any. Addition should
be 30% in case the deceased was in the age group of
40 to 50 years.”
[emphasis supplied]
16.
Consequently, in view of the above extract, Future
Prospects to be added to the fixed income of the deceased would be
50% and not 30% as held by the Claims Tribunal.
Although this
issue was not raised by the Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 and 2,
however, it is settled law that compensation granted does not have
5. (2013) 9 SCC 54
2016:SHC:42
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
The Branch Manager, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. and Another
vs.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia and Others
to be confined to the Claim, it may be in excess of the Claim
with the rider that it should be ‘just’ and not arbitrary or
unjustifiable.
17.
Now, coming to the question of multiplier adopted by
the Claims Tribunal, there appears to be an error in adopting the
multiplicand of ‘13’. As per the table in Sarla Verma (Smt) and
Others
vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another6 the
multiplicand for the age of 31 to 35 years is ‘16’. In this regard, we
may usefully refer to paragraph 42 of the said Judgment wherein it
was held that –
“42. We therefore hold that the multiplier to
be used should be as mentioned in Column (4) of the
table above (prepared by applying Susamma Thomas
[(1994) 2 SCC 176], Trilok Chandra [(1996) 4 SCC 362] and
Charlie [(2005) 10 SCC 720]), which starts with an
operative multiplier of 18 (for the age groups of 15 to
20 and 21 to 25 years), reduced by one unit for every
five years, that is M-17 for 26 to 30 years, M-16 for 31
to 35 years, M-15 for 36 to 40 years, M-14 for 41 to 45
years, and M-13 for 46 to 50 years, then reduced by
two units for every five years, that is, M-11 for 51 to
55 years, M-9 for 56 to 60 years, M-7 for 61 to 65 years
and M-5 for 66 to 70 years.”
[emphasis supplied]
Since the victim was 32 years old, the correct multiplier would
be ‘16’.
18.
Hence, the total amount of compensation requires
recomputation and is calculated as follows;
6. (2009) 6 SCC 121
2016:SHC:42
MAC App. No.20 of 2015
The Branch Manager, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd. and Another
vs.
Shri Sonam Palzor Bhutia and Others
Monthly income of the deceased
Rs. 10,000.00
Future Prospects
Rs.
Annual income of the deceased (Rs.15,000 x 12 months)
Rs. 1,80,000.00
(−)
Less 1/3 of Rs.1,80,000/-
5,000.00
Rs. 60,000.00
[in consideration of the expenses which
the victim would have incurred towards
maintaining herself, had she been alive]
Net yearly income
Multiplier to be adopted ‘16’
Rs. 1,20,000.00
(Rs.1,20,000 x 16)
Rs.19,20,000.00
[as per Judgment of Sarla Verma]
(+)
Rs. 25,000.00
(+)
Rs. 1,00,000.00
Loss of Estate
(+)
Rs.
Loss of Love and Affection
(+)
Funeral expenses
[as per Judgment of Rajesh vs. Rajbir Singh]
Loss of Consortium
[as per Judgment of Rajesh vs. Rajbir Singh]
2,500.00
Rs. 20,000.00
Total - Rs.20,67,500.00
(Rupees twenty lakhs sixty seven thousand and five hundred) only
19.
The Award shall be divided in terms already fixed by the
Claims Tribunal.
20.
In the result, the Appeal is dismissed with the above
modification to the compensation.
21.
No order as to costs.
22.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Claims Tribunal
for information and compliance.
23.
Records of the Claims Tribunal be remitted forthwith.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
20-04-2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review