Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MACA No.1111 of 2021
2025:KER:26949
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE EASWARAN S.
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 7TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MACA NO. 1111 OF 2021
AGAINST THE AWARD DATED 05.02.2020 IN O.P.(M.V.) NO.13 OF
2017 OF THE MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, OTTAPPALAM
APPELLANTS/CLAIMANT-PETITIONER :
THE ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
K.S.E.B. ELECTRICAL SUB DIVISION,
THRITHALA, PALAKKAD.
BY ADVS.
ASOK M.CHERIAN
RIJI RAJENDRAN
ANJANA K
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS 1 TO 3 :
AROGYARAJ
AGED 33 YEARS
S/O. ARBANSWAMI, RAMANPILLA VEEDU,
MENONPARA, CHOTTOOR, PALAKKAD,
(DRIVER OF BUS BEARING REGISTRATION NO.KL-15-7306)
MANAGING DIRECTOR,
KERALA ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
(OWNER OF BUS BEARING REGISTRATION NO.KL-15-7306)
THE NEW INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.,
BRANCH OFFICE, JRJ COMPLEX, OTTAPPALAM, PIN-679101,
REPRESENTED BY BRANCH MANAGER (INSURER OF BUS BEARING
REGISTRATION NO.KL-15-7306).
BY ADVS.
P.C.CHACKO(PARATHANAM)
ALEX ANTONY SEBASTIAN P.A.
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING
ON 28.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MACA No.1111 of 2021
2025:KER:26949
JUDGMENT
This appeal is preferred by the Kerala State Electricity Board
(KSEB) aggrieved by the dismissal of O.P.(M.V.) No.13 of 2017 by the
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ottappalam on the ground that the
claim preferred by the board is a stale claim.
2. The brief facts necessary for the disposal of this appeal are as
follows:
On 28.10.2013 at about 14.25 p.m., the KSRTC bus bearing
registration No. KL-15/7306, driven by the 1st respondent in a rash and
negligent manner from Koottanad to Pattambi, hit the transformer on
the side of the road near the petrol pump at Njangattiri, and due to the
impact of the accident, the electric poles and other equipment of the
transformer were destroyed thereby causing a loss of Rs.1,55,331/- to
the appellant.
3. Claiming compensation for the damages sustained by them for
the replacement of the transformer, the appellant approached the
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ottappalam. Since the vehicle was
covered with a valid insurance policy, the 3rd respondent insurance
company was also arrayed as a party in the claim petition. On behalf of
the appellant, Exts.A1 to A10 documents were produced before the
tribunal and PW1 to PW3 were examined. No oral or documentary
evidence was adduced on the side of the respondents. The insurance
MACA No.1111 of 2021
2025:KER:26949
company, however, raised a question of the maintainability of the
application, stating that the claim was made after a period of three
years and, therefore, the same is not maintainable. The tribunal, relying
on the decision of the learned Single Bench in National Insurance
Company Limited vs. Jojo [2019 (4) KLT 127], found that the claim is
not supported by any evidence and hence the same is stale and
therefore dismissed the claim petition.
4. Heard Ms. Anjana K, the learned counsel appearing for the
appellant and Sri. Alex Antony Sebastian, the learned counsel
appearing for the K.S.R.T.C. Though notice was taken on behalf of the
3rd respondent/insurance company, when the matter was taken up,
there is no appearance. However, in the nature of the order that is to
be passed in the present appeal, this Court finds that the presence of
the insurance company is not required for adjudication.
5. The learned counsel for the appellant contended that there is
no period of limitation prescribed under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act and that the period of six months i.e., fixed in the said
provision, takes effect only from 1.4.2022. In support of her contention,
the learned counsel relied on the decision of the learned Single Bench
of this Court in Akshay Raj v. Ministry of Law and Justice [2023 (2) KHC
70]. It is further submitted that the decision of this Court in National
Insurance Company Limited vs. Jojo [2019 (4) KLT 127] will not apply
to the facts of the present case. The learned counsel, drew a distinction
MACA No.1111 of 2021
2025:KER:26949
of the decision of this Court and referred to paragraph No.8 of the
decision to point out that the said decision has to be construed as the
one rendered in the particular facts of the case and not otherwise.
6. On the other hand, the learned Standing Counsel appearing
on behalf of the KSRTC pointed out that even if it is assumed that the
claim petition is maintainable under law, the appellant has not proved
the claim based on any concrete evidence and therefore this Court
cannot grant the reliefs sought for by the appellant.
7. I have considered the rival submissions raised across the Bar.
8. Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 reads as under:
166. Application for compensation. –
(1) An application for compensation arising out of an
accident of the nature specified in sub-section (1) of section
165 may be made(a) by the person who has sustained the injury; or
(b) by the owner of the property; or
(c) where death has resulted from the accident, by all
or any of the legal representatives of the deceased; or
(d) by any agent duly authorised by the person injured
or all or any of the legal representatives of the
deceased, as the case may be:
Provided that where all the legal representatives of the
deceased have not joined in any such application for
compensation, the application shall be made on behalf of or
for the benefit of all the legal representatives of the deceased
and the legal representatives who have not so joined, shall be
impleaded as respondents to the application.
[Provided further that where a person accepts
compensation under Section 164 in accordance with the
MACA No.1111 of 2021
2025:KER:26949
procedure provided under Section 149, his claims petition
before the Claims Tribunal shall lapse.]
[(2) Every application under sub-section (1) shall be
made, at the option of the claimant, either to the Claims
Tribunal having jurisdiction over the area in which the
accident occurred or to the Claims Tribunal within the local
limits of whose jurisdiction the claimant resides or carries on
business or within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the
defendant resides, and shall be in such form and contain such
particulars as may be prescribed:
[xxxxx]
[(3)
No
application
for
compensation
shall
be
entertained unless it is made within six months of the
occurrence of the accident.]
(4) The Claims Tribunal shall treat any report of
accidents forwarded to it under [section 159] as an
application for compensation under this Act.]
[(5) Notwithstanding anything in this Act or any other
law for the time being in force, the right of a person to claim
compensation for injury in an accident shall, upon the death
of the person injured, survive to his legal representatives,
irrespective of whether the cause of death is relatable to or
had any nexus with the injury or not.]
9. On a close reading of the aforesaid provision it is clear that
the claim in respect of an accident can be set into motion even based
on the report of the investigating officer. Such being the position, is it
possible to hold that the tribunal is not bound to entertain a “Stale
claim”. If so, what could be construed as a stale claim will assume
significance. Here two instrumentalities of the State are at loggerheads
regarding the sustainability of the claim. The learned counsel
MACA No.1111 of 2021
2025:KER:26949
appearing for the K.S.E.B. contends that it was due to the rash and
negligent driving of the K.S.R.T.C. bus, that the transformer was
damaged while the learned counsel for the KSRTC was trying to avoid
the claim on the ground of delay. It is in this context this Court is called
to resolve this conflict.”
10. It is true that the Law of Limitation cannot be strictly applied
to the motor accident claim prior to 1.4.2022 when Section 166 was
amended, prescribing a 6-month period for lodging the claim. But this
Court in National Insurance Company (supra) held that stale claims
cannot be entertained by the tribunal. What would amount to a stale
claim is a question of fact to be decided in an individual case.
11. In Purohit and Company(M/s) Vs Khatoonbee and Another
[2017 (2) KHC 102], the Supreme Court held that what would be the
reasonable time for preferring the claim will depend on individual
cases. It is true that in National Insurance Company Limited (Supra),
this Court held that the tribunal cannot entertain a normal claim that is
stale as of the date of the application. However, reading the Judgment
as a whole it is clear that the court was considering a claim petition
that was filed after a period of nine years. It is in this context this Court
is of the firm view that the aforesaid decision has to be construed as
rendered on the facts of the case.
12. Coming to the facts of this case, it is pertinent to mention
that the tribunal found the claim to be stale since the same was
MACA No.1111 of 2021
2025:KER:26949
preferred after the period for filing a suit in relation to a tort. If this is
the correct view, then the Supreme Court in Khatoonbee (Supra) could
have said that the claim ought to be preferred within the period of
limitation prescribed under the Limitation Act, 1963. One must not
forget that when the Act itself does not make the provisions of the
Limitation Act, 1963 applicable, the rules governing the limitation for
initiation of proceedings cannot be made strictly applicable. Of course,
the court cannot lose sight of the fact that the claimants cannot wait
indefinitely to prefer the claim. However, when on analysis of the fact
presented before the court, if it appears that the claim is not unduly
delayed, then nothing prevents the tribunal or court from entertaining
the same. Suffice it to say that the tribunal cannot reject the claim
stating that the same has been preferred beyond the period of limitation
provided under the Act when the Act itself is not made applicable to the
proceedings before the Tribunal. Viewed in the above perspective, this
Court finds that the learned counsel for the appellant is justified in
submitting that the tribunal erred egregiously in dismissing the claim
petition.
13. In fact, it is evident that the accident took place on
28.10.2013. The nature of compensation that is sought for before the
tribunal is only with regard to the replacement costs incurred by the
K.S.E.B and also considering the fact that the appellant as well as the
owner of the offending vehicle are instrumentalities of the State, this
MACA No.1111 of 2021
2025:KER:26949
Court is of the considered view that the tribunal ought not to have
rejected the claim on the basis of the same being barred by limitation.
However, since the tribunal has found that the claim on merits is not
substantiated, this Court will not be justified in entering into the merits
of the case. In such circumstances, it is only just and proper that the
appellant be given an opportunity to adduce fresh evidence in order to
sustain the claim.
14. As an upshot of the above discussions, this Court finds that
the appellant is entitled to succeed. The appeal is allowed. The award
of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ottappalam in O.P.(M.V.)
No.13 of 2017 is set aside. The application will stand restored to the
files of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ottappalam. The parties
shall appear before the tribunal on 9.4.2025 and the tribunal will
proceed to consider the case on merits and take a decision in
accordance with law as expeditiously as possible.
Sd/-
EASWARAN S.
JUDGE
NS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review