Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K. NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
FRIDAY, THE 11TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 21ST CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO.1866 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 07.11.2024 IN WP(C)NO.38597 OF 2024
OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS 4 TO 6:
THE ADVISORY BOARD TO THE EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS
OF ST. PETER'S AND ST. PAUL'S ORTHODOX SYRIAN CHURCH,
KOLENCHERY, ERNAKULAM REP.
BY ITS CHAIRMAN -FR. JACOB KURIAN, PIN - 682311
MATHEW PAUL
S/O. C.P. PAULOSE, PUTHUPPADIYIL HOUSE,
KOLENCHERY, ERNAKULAM, PIN - 682311
ST. PETER'S AND ST. PAUL'S ORTHODOX SYRIAN CHURCH,
KOLENCHERY
REP. BY ITS VICAR – FR. JACOB KURIAN, RESIDING IN
CHEMMANAM VELLAMATTATHIL HOUSE, KUNNAPPILLY KARA,
PERUVA, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 682311
BY ADVS. P.MARTIN JOSE
S.SREEKUMAR (SR.)
AJAY BEN JOSE
ANNA LINDA EDEN
HARIKRISHNAN S.
MANJUNATH MENON
P.PRIJITH
R.GITHESH
SACHIN JACOB AMBAT
THOMAS P.KURUVILLA
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS:
ST. PETER'S COLLEGE TRUST, KOLENCHERY
AIKKARANADU SOUTH VILLAGE, KOLENCHERY, ERNAKULAM, REP.
BY ITS SECRETARY -DR. VARGHESE JACOB @ DR. VIJU JACOB,
PIN - 682311
DR. VARGHESE JACOB @ DR. VIJU JACOB
AGED 64 YEARS
SECRETARY, ST. PETER’S COLLEGE TRUST, KOLENCHERY,
AIKKARANADU SOUTH VILLAGE, KOLENCHERY,
ERNAKULAM, PIN - 682311
BABU PAUL, AGED 69 YEARS
S/O. LATE PAILY PILLAI, CHAIRMAN, ST. PETER’S COLLEGE
TRUST, KOLENCHERY, AIKKARANADU SOUTH VILLAGE,
KOLENCHERY, ERNAKULAM, PIN - 682311
MAHATMA GANDHI UNIVERSITY
ATHIRAMPUZHA, PRIYADARSINI HILLS POST,
KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686560
REGISTRAR
MAHATMA GANDHI UNIVERSITY, ATHIRAMPUZHA,
PRIYADARSINI HILLS POST, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686560
DR. BINUJA JOSEPH
PRINCIPAL IN CHARGE, ST. PETER’S COLLEGE,
KOLENCHERY, ERNAKULAM, PIN - 682311
DR. JINU GEORGE
PROFESSOR, ST. PETER’S COLLEGE, KOLENCHERY,
RESIDING IN CHANTHIATHIL, KOLENCHERY, PIN - 682311
DR. K.P. JOSE
PROFESSOR, ST. PETER’S COLLEGE, KOLENCHERY,
ERNAKULAM, PIN - 682311
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 07.01.2025, THE
COURT ON 11.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
JUDGMENT
Anil K. Narendran, J.
The
appellants,
who
are
respondents
to
in
W.P.(C)No.38597 of 2024 have filed this writ appeal, invoking the
provisions under Section 5(i) of the Kerala High Court Act, 1958
challenging the interim order dated 07.11.2024 of the learned
Single Judge in that writ petition, which was one filed by
respondents 1 to 3-writ petitioners seeking a writ of certiorari to
quash Ext.P29 proceedings dated 25.10.2024 of the Registrar of
Mahatma Gandhi University, rejecting the request for the approval
of the appointment of the 6th respondent herein as Principal-incharge of St.Peter’s College, Kolenchery; and a writ of mandamus
commanding
respondents 4
and
herein
to
approve the
appointment of the 6th respondent herein as Principal-in-charge of
St.Peter’s
College,
Kolenchery,
as
sought
for
in
Ext.P20
representation dated 08.01.2024 made by St.Peter’s College Trust,
until a Principal is appointed by direct recruitment as envisaged in
the University Grants Regulations, 2018 or as per the rights of a
minority educational institution.
2.
On 07.11.2024, when the writ petition came up for
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
consideration, the learned Single Judge admitted the matter on file
and issued urgent notice by speed post to the 8th respondent
herein. The learned Standing Counsel for Mahatma Gandhi
University took notice for the University and its Registrar and other
respondents entered appearance through their respective counsel.
The learned Single Judge passed an interim order dated 07.11.2024
directing the University to consider the approval of the appointment
of the 6th respondent herein as the Principal-in-charge, irrespective
of the objection of seniority noted in Ext.P29 proceedings dated
25.10.2024 of the Registrar of the University, provisionally.
3.
Feeling aggrieved, respondents 4 to 6 in the writ petition
are before this Court in this writ appeal.
4.
On 27.11.2024, when this writ appeal came up for
consideration, the learned Standing Counsel for Mahatma Gandhi
University submitted that in terms of the directions contained in the
impugned interim order dated 07.11.2024, the University had
already issued an order dated 22.11.2024, granting approval of the
appointment of the 6th respondent herein as the Principal-incharge, provisionally.
5.
Heard arguments of the learned Senior Counsel for the
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
appellants-respondents 4 to 6, the learned Senior Counsel for
respondents 1 to 3, the learned Standing Counsel for Mahatma
Gandhi University for respondents 4 and 5 and the learned counsel
for the 7th respondent.
6.
The
learned
Senior
Counsel
for
the
appellants-
respondents 4 to 6 contended that the impugned interim order
dated 07.11.2024 of the learned Single Judge is per se arbitrary,
illegal and the said order is one passed without referring to the
provisions contained in the Mahatma Gandhi University Act, 1985
and the Statutes made thereunder, the bye-laws of the corporate
educational institutions under St.Peter’s and St.Paul’s Orthodox
Syrian Church. On 08.10.2024, the appellants filed W.P.(C)No.
36339 of 2024 seeking a direction to the 4th respondent University
to take a decision on the appointment of the 7th respondent as the
Principal-in-charge of the college. The said writ petition was
admitted on 17.10.2024 and notice was issued to the respondents
therein. Respondents 1 to 3, in the meanwhile filed the present writ
petition 01.11.2024, and the learned Single Judge posted both the
writ petitions together to 07.11.2024. The learned Single Judge
then took up W.P.(C)No.38597 of 2024 alone, though the reliefs
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
claimed in both the writ petitions are rival claims seeking
appointment as Principal-in-charge of the college. The learned
Senior Counsel contended that though the appellants produced
documents in W.P.(C)No.36339 of 2024, in order to show that the
college was established by the Managing Board, based on the
permission granted to the Managing Board to establish the college,
and that Kerala University granted provisional affiliation of the
college in the name of the Managing Board, while granting the
impugned interim order dated 07.11.2024, the learned Single
Judge did not consider any of those documents, since consideration
by the learned Single Judge was limited to W.P.(C)No.38597 of
2024 alone. The learned Senior Counsel has also addressed
arguments on the merits of the matter pending consideration
before the learned Single Judge in W.P.(C)No.38597 of 2024,
placing reliance on the additional documents produced in this writ
appeal as Annexures A to O.
7.
On the other hand, the learned Senior Counsel for
respondents 1 to 3 and also the learned Standing Counsel for
Mahatma University for respondents 4 and 5 contended that the
learned Single Judge after considering the preliminary arguments
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
granted the impugned interim order, since respondents 1 to 3-writ
petitioners have made out a prima facie case for the grant of such
an interim order. The learned Senior Counsel for respondents 1 to
3 also addressed arguments on the merits of the matter pending
consideration before the learned Single Judge in W.P.(C)No.38597
of 2024.
8.
Paragraphs 4 to 8 and also the last paragraph of the
impugned order dated 07.11.2024 of the learned Single Judge
reads thus;
‘4. Today, when the writ petition came up for consideration,
W.P.(C)No.36339 of 2024 filed by the 6th respondent herein
and others was also considered along with this writ petition.
The reliefs sought therein pertain to the proposal of
appointment made by the 6th respondent to appoint the
Principal-in-Charge for the same college. There is a dispute
between the petitioner and the 6th respondent, and the
question to be decided is who is the approved Educational
Agency for St.Peter’s College. The matter was heard for some
time.
5.
Sri.S.Sreekumar,
the
learned
Senior
counsel
for
respondents 4 and 6 pointed out the sequence of events
which led to the formation of the college and according to
him, the same was at the instance of the 6th respondent
Church through the 4th respondent and the management of
the college still vests with them. On the other hand, the
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
contention of Sri.Mayankutty Mather, the learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner, is that, on the basis of the decision
taken as evidenced by Ext.P4, a Trust was created by
assigning independent authority and powers, and thus the 1st
petitioner was formed. Thereafter, the entire management of
the college is being done by the 1st petitioner by following the
stipulations
in
Ext.P5
Memorandum
and
Articles
of
Association. According to the petitioners, the University also
recognized the 1st petitioner as the approved Educational
Agency for the management of the college. This fact is
confirmed by the University as well, which is evident from
Ext.P25,
an
affidavit
filed
by
the
University
in
W.P.(C)No.15691 of 2024, which was a writ petition filed,
touching upon the dispute concerning the management of the
college. The relevant averments made by the University are
as follows:
“3) It is humbly submitted that, two factions are
currently disputing for the manager ship of the
College, with each group appointing their own
Principal-in-charge. It is imperative to determine the
legal authority of each individual to hold the office of
the Manager, as only the proposal submitted by the
legally appointed Manager can be considered for
approval. *It is to be noted that educational agency
by
name
Educational
St.
Paul's
Orthodox
Institution
Syrian
Advisory
Church,
Board
with
reference to the management of St. Peters College
is a total alien to the University. So far as the
University is concerned the Educational agency
managing St. Peter's College is St. Peter's College
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
Trust.
All appointments made by the said trust have been
approved by the University till date.”
(*Underlined for emphasis)
6. Besides, it is also evident from Ext.P8 that, the Direct
Payment Agreement was entered into between the 1 st
petitioner and the Government.
7. The learned Senior counsel for the 4th and 6th respondents
pointed out that the application for commencing the college
and the application for affiliation before the University were
submitted by the Chairman of the St. Peter's School Board,
which is the predecessor of the 1st petitioner herein. However,
as far as the claim of the 4th and 6th respondents are
concerned, it is a matter to be decided finally while hearing
the writ petition. As of now, Ext.P8 Direct Payment
Agreement along with Ext.P25 affidavit filed by the University
would prima facie indicate that the 1st petitioner is continuing
as
the
approved
Educational
agency.
Therefore,
the
University has to consider the proposal submitted by the 1st
petitioner, for the purpose of appointments
8. When coming to the question of rejection of the proposal
of appointment of the 3rd respondent as the Principal-incharge, apparently the same was returned merely because of
the reason that the 7th respondent is Senior to the 3rd
respondent. It is an admitted position that the St.Peter's
college is a minority institution, in which seniority by itself
may not be the sole criteria for appointment of the Head of
the institution. Therefore, there shall be an interim order
directing the University to consider the approval of the
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
appointment of the 3rd respondent as the Principal-in-charge,
irrespective of the objection of seniority, noted in Ext.P29,
provisionally.
9.
A reading of the impugned order dated 07.11.2024 in
W.P.(C)No.38597 of 2024 would show that W.P.(C)No.36339 of
2024 filed by the appellants seeking an order directing the 4 th
respondent Mahatma Gandhi University to take a decision on the
appointment of the 7th respondent as the Principal-in-charge of the
college was also listed before the learned Single Judge on
07.11.2024. The grievance of the appellants is that instead of
considering the interim reliefs sought for in both the writ petitions,
in which rival claims are made for appointment as Principal-incharge of the college, the learned Single Judge considered the
interim relief sought for in W.P.(C)No.38597 of 2024 by considering
that
writ
petition
alone,
without
passing
any
orders
in
W.P.(C)No.36339 of 2024.
10.
We notice that the above issue raised by the appellant
is no more res integra in view of the decision of a Division Bench of
this Court in Radhakrishna Panicker v. State of Kerala [2001
(3) KLT 631], which was one rendered taking note of the law laid
down by the Apex Court in Bir Bajrang Kumar v. State of Bihar
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
[AIR 1987 SC 1345].
11.
In Bir Bajrang Kumar [AIR 1987 SC 1345], the Apex
Court took the view that if there are two writ petitions involving
identical points and one writ petition is admitted, there is no
justification for dismissing the other writ petition. The Apex Court,
therefore, set aside the order of the High Court and remanded the
matter to the High Court to be heard along with the pending matter.
Paragraph 2 of the said decision reads thus;
“2. After going through the record of the case, it appears
that one of the cases involving an identical point has already
been admitted by the High Court, but another identical
petition was dismissed by the same High Court. This,
therefore, creates a very anomalous position and there is a
clear possibility of two contradictory judgments being
rendered in the same case by the High Court. In these
circumstances, we allow this appeal and set aside the order
dismissing C.W.J.C. No. 163 of 1985.
This appeal is
remanded to the High Court to be heard along with C.W.J.C.
No.5728 of 1984 which is pending hearing.”
12.
In Radhakrishna Panicker [2001 (3) KLT 631], the
Division Bench held that, in case of writ petitions involving identical
issues, it is not justifiable when certain original petitions are
admitted, while some others are dismissed. To avoid the possibility
of a contradictory order, the court has to hear all matters together
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
and pass a common order. If writ petitions raising the same issue
are heard by different Judges on different occasions, there will be
a possibility of contradictory judgments on the same issue. That
may create an anomalous situation and create difficulties for the
administration of justice. Paragraph 2 of that decision reads thus;
‘2. We are of the view that when a similar writ petition
challenging the same order has already been admitted and
pending consideration, the learned Single Judge was not
justified in dismissing the present writ petition at the
admission stage. The learned Judge ought to have heard all
the matters together and passed a common order. We may,
in this connection, refer to the decision of the Apex Court in
Bir Bajrang Kumar v. State of Bihar [AIR 1987 SC
1345]. Apex Court took the view that if there are two
petitions involving identical points and one is admitted there
is no justification in dismissing the other writ petition. Apex
Court, therefore, set aside the order of the High Court and
remanded the matter to the High Court to be heard along
with the pending matter. ……. We are of the view that if writ
petitions raising the same issue are heard by different
Judges on different occasions, there will be a possibility of
contradictory judgments on the same issue. That may
create an anomalous situation and create difficulties for the
administration of justice. In this connection, it is appropriate
to refer to the principle laid down by this Court in Joy v.
Regional Transport Authority [1998 (2) KLT 994],
wherein this Court highlighted the necessity of consistency
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
in rendering judgments. This Court held as follows:
“Judicial discipline demands consistency in rendering
judgments. A Judicial Officer may hold different views
on various aspects.
A Judicial Officer may err and
pass contradictory orders inadvertently. But once it
is brought to the knowledge of the Judicial Officer, he
is
duty
bound
to
keep
track
of
consistency.
Inconsistent orders passed by a judicial officer almost
in the same fact situation, and that too on the same
day, would give rise to complaint of discriminatory
treatment, which will undermine the people’s faith in
judicial system and the rule of law.
It will cause
resentment and anguish and make an imprint in the
mind of the litigant that he has been discriminated. A
Judicial Officer may err and pass illegal orders, but he
shall not err in consistency.”
There may be a situation where the pendency of the original
petition might not have been brought to the knowledge of the
learned Single Judge inadvertently. It is for fitness of things
that the parties in the litigation should bring to the notice of
the Judge of the pendency of similar matters, and therefore
contradictory judgments could be avoided, as we see in the
present case. We are of the view that as and when the
pendency of an original petition concerning the same issue is
brought to the knowledge of the Court, the Court shall post
all the cases together and hear the matter. In this case, when
an original petition concerning an identical issue has already
been admitted and is pending consideration, the learned
Judge was not justified in dismissing the original petition at
the admission stage by a detailed order.’
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
13.
The principle laid down in the aforesaid decisions can
also be extended to the facts and circumstances of the case on
hand as well. When two writ petitions are pending, in which rival
claims for appointment as Principal-in-charge of St. Peters College,
Kolenchery, were raised the learned Single Judge ought to have
considered the interim relief sought for in both the writ petitions
together and passed an appropriate order, after considering the
rival contentions with reference to the pleadings and materials in
both the writ petitions, especially when such consideration by the
learned Single Judge is at the admission stage.
14.
In such circumstances, we find no reason to sustain the
impugned order dated 07.11.2024 of the learned Single Judge in
W.P.(C)No.38597 of 2024 and the same is accordingly set aside, on
that sole ground, and by directing the learned Single Judge to
consider the interim relief sought for in W.P.(C)No.36339 of 2024
and W.P.(C)No.38597 of 2024 afresh, after adverting to the legal
and factual contentions raised by both sides. Since pursuant to the
impugned order dated 07.11.2024 in W.P.(C)No.38597 of 2024 the
Registrar of the Mahatma Gandhi University has issued proceedings
dated 25.10.2024, provisionally approving the appointment of the
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
6th respondent herein as Principal-in-charge of the college, status
quo as on today in respect of the post of Principal-in-charge of St.
Peter’s College, Kolenchery, shall continue till appropriate orders
are passed by the learned Single Judge in the pending writ
petitions.
The writ appeal is disposed of above; however, leaving open
the legal and factual contentions raised by both sides.
Sd/ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
bkn/-
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
APPENDIX OF WA 1866/2024
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure -A
TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO.DIS.27322/64 DATED 2210-1964 OF REGIONAL DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC
INSTRUCTION, TRIVANDRUM
Annexure -B
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DATED 11-03-1964 ISSUED
BY THE MANAGING BOARD TO THE MEMBERS OF THE
UNIVERSITY COMMISSION, TRIVANDRUM
Annexure -C
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DATED 16-04-1964 ISSUED
BY THE REGISTRAR OF KERALA UNIVERSITY TO THE
MANAGING BOARD
Annexure -D
TRUE COPY OF DOCUMENT NO.3324 OF 1964 DATED
18-12-1964
Annexure -E
TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED 20-07-2000
SUBMITTED BY SRI.P.M.PAILY PILLAI BEFORE THE
GOVERNMENT
Annexure -F
TRUE COPY OF AMENDED BYE-LAW OF THE MANAGING
BOARD
Annexure -G
TRUE COPY OF MINUTES OF THE MEETING DATED 0810-2023 OF THE 3RD APPELLANT CHURCH
Annexure -H
TRUE COPY OF MINUTES OF THE MEETING DATED 1410-2023 OF THE 1ST APPELLANT
Annexure -I
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DATED 27-10-2023 ISSUED
BY THE ADVISORY BOARD TO 1ST RESPONDENT,
MAHATMA GANDHI UNIVERSITY
Annexure -J
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 23-08-2024 OF THE 1ST
APPELLANT
Annexure -K
TRUE COPY OF PLAINT IN O.S.NO.27 OF 2023 FILED
BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT BEFORE THE SUBORDINATE
JUDGE’S COURT, PERUMBAVOOR
Annexure -L
TRUE COPY OF COMMON JUDGMENT DATED 04-08-2023
IN
W.P.(C).NOS.
15691
OF
AND
W.P.(C).NO.19554 OF 2023 OF THIS HON’BLE COURT
TRUE COPY OF COMMON JUDGMENT IN WRIT APPEAL
Annexure -M
2025:KER:31630
WA NO. 1866 OF 2024
Annexure -N
Annexure -O
NOS.1692/2023 &1985/2023 DATED 06-03-2024 OF
THIS HON’BLE COURT
TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER AFFIDAVIT DATED 2606-2024 FILED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT UNIVERSITY
IN W.P.(C).NO.15691 OF 2023 BEFORE THIS
HON’BLE COURT
TRUE COPY OF W.P.(C).NO.36339 OF 2024 (WITHOUT
EXHIBITS) FILED BY THE APPELLANTS BEFORE THIS
HON’BLE COURT ON 08-10-2024
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P4 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P7 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
Exhibit P11
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P 11 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
Exhibit P13
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P13 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
Exhibit P14
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P14 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
Exhibit P15
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P15 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
Exhibit P16
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P16 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
Exhibit P17
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P17 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
Exhibit P20
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P20 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
Exhibit P24
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P24 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
Exhibit P28
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P28 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
Exhibit P29
TRUE COPY OF THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF THE
EXHIBIT P29 IN WP(C) NO 38597 OF 2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review