The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. In the light of the mandate stipulated under Section 3H(4) of the National Highways Act, 1956, this is a fit case for the competent authority to refer the dispute to the civil court for decision qua the entitlement and/or apportionment of the compensation amount to be paid in respect of the common village land involved in this case.
23. Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the competent authority to refer the dispute to the decision of the principal civil court of original jurisdiction within the limits of whose jurisdiction the land in question is situated as provided under Section 3H(4) of the National Highways Act, 1956, within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. Upon reference being made by the competent authority, the concerned civil court is directed to resolve the dispute on merits and in accordance with law, as expeditiously as possible. No costs. FR/NFR John Kom
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.04.06
TELEN KOM Date:
09:31:10 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.903 of 2021
Mr. Thangonlung Kamei, aged about 53 years, S/O Gaijoun Kamei, a
resident of Namthanjang Rongmei, PO Lanjing, P. S New Keithelmanbi,
Kangpokpi District, Manipur- 795113 & 53 Ors.
…Petitioners
– Versus –
1. The State of Manipur through the Commissioner(Works), Government of
Manipur, Manipur Secretariat, PO & PS Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001 & 4 Ors.
….Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Ora)
21.03.2023
1. This writ petition has been filed by the petitioners for issuance of a writ
of mandamus directing the respondents to ensure that compensation for
acquisition of the land in respect of common village land of Namthanjang Rongmei
Village for widening of Imphal-Jiribam Road (NH-37) to 4-lane is equally
distributed to the petitioners by considering the representation of the petitioners
dated 17.11.2021.
2. Heard Mr. M. Rakesh, learned counsel for the petitioners; Mr. Phungyo
Zingkhei, the learned Government Advocate for the respondents 1 to 3; Mr. S.
Vijyanand Sharma, learned Sr. PCCG the learned counsel for the fourth
respondent and Mr. D. Julius Riamei, the learned counsel for the fifth respondent.
3. The case of the petitioners is that a huge portions of land starting from
BRTF camp to Phirup Khumbi Lok comprising both individual as well as common
village land of Namthanjang Rongmei village under Kangchup Geljang SubDivision, Kangpokpi District were adversely affected by the widening of NH-37 of
Imphal-Jiribam from Km 11.522 to Km 45.785.
During the joint survey, the
respondent authorities informed the petitioners that the entire compensation
amount for acquisition of both the common village land as well as the private land
shall be transferred to the bank account of the fifth respondent, who is the ExChief/Khullakpa of Namthanjang Rongmei village and all the matters related to
compensation of land shall be deal only through the fifth respondent.
4. Further case of the petitioners is that Namthanjang Rongmei village is
comprises about 70 households with a population of more than 500.
The
petitioners comprising more than 54 households are very much aggrieved with the
proposal of the respondents 2 and 3 that the entire compensation amount for
acquisition of both common village land and private land shall be handed over to
the fifth respondent and that all matters to be communicated through the fifth
respondent without any reasonable grounds.
Aggrieved by the same, the
petitioners have submitted a representation on 17.11.2021 to the second
respondent requesting him to give the land compensation in regard to the
acquisition of common village land to the general public of the village. If the
compensation of common village land is given to the fifth respondent and their
group, the petitioners have an apprehension that they will not share the
compensation amount and dishonestly take away all the money for themselves.
Despite receipt of the representation, the same has not been considered till date.
Hence, the petitioners have filed the present writ petition.
5. Resisting the writ petition, the respondents 2 and 3 filed affidavit-inopposition stating that the respondent officials did not informed the petitioners that
the entire compensation amount for acquisition of both the common village land
as well as the private land shall be transferred to the bank account of the fifth
respondent. However, all the matters related to compensation are communicated
through the fifth respondent, as he is the Chief of the said village. Since the land
of the said village is not surveyed land, it will be convenient to give the
compensation either to the account of the Chief/Khullakpa or to the joint account
of a committee formed under the supervision of the Chief of the village. It is stated
that since the Chief is the owner of the common village land, the authority
concerned face difficulties to take action for giving compensation directly to the
villagers.
As per the official up to date record, the fifth respondent is presently
working as the Chief/Khullakpa of Namthanjang Rongmei village and there is no
fraudulent claim from his side regarding the taking of compensation. The process
of giving the compensation is done as per law of the land and not in the interest
of a private individual or group of persons. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the writ
petition.
6. The fourth respondent filed affidavit-in-opposition stating that presently
the fourth respondent is implementing 2-lane work of Imphal-Jiribam road in
Namthangjang Rongmei village named Package-II and 3D notification for the land
form Km 17.52 to Km 45.785 in Namthanjang had been approved by the MoRTH.
The joint survey for 4-laning with paved shoulder of Imphal-Jiribam Section (Pkg1) from Km 11.522 to Km 45.785 of NH-37 in the State of Manipur vide order dated
31.5.2019 of the SDO, Kangchup Geljang had been postponed on 14.6.2019 vide
order dated 12.6.2019. The joint survey had been conducted from 18.7.2019
onwards for the said 4-laning of Imphal-Jiribam Road and later on 4-lane
alignment and bye-pass had been cancelled by the headquarter of the fourth
respondent. The fourth respondent site engineer and DPR consultant M/s.CE
Testing had attended the joint survey from 21.4.2021 and shown the required
ROW for construction of proposed 2-lane road.
As such 1.74 Ha. of land
pertaining to Namthanjang village under sub-division was affected by widening
NH-37 Imphal-Jiribam from Km 17.522 to Km 45.785. It is stated that the fourth
respondent has no role in deciding the person for the post of Chiefship/Khullakpa
of Namthanjang Rongmei village and the fourth respondent is only the project
implementation unit, but not an authority for land acquisition. Hence, prayed for
dismissal of the writ petition.
7. The fifth respondent filed affidavit-in-opposition stating that the
petitioners are not from Namthanjang village and, as such, have no locus standi
in the affairs of the Namthanjang village. The petitioners have no right whatsoever
in the lands of Namthanjang Rongmei village leave alone claiming any rights,
interest, title or compensation in respect of lands or any other properties of
Namthanjang Rongmei village. No cause of action arose for filing the present writ
petition. In the land acquisition proceedings in question, there were 16 individual
households whose properties (house structures) are affected and those
households shall be individually entitled for compensation and for other lands or
properties affected in respect of Namthanjang Rongmei village, the fifth
respondent is the sole interested party. Hence, prayed for dismissal of the writ
petition.
8. The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the lands starting
from BRTF Camp to Phirup Khumbi comprising both individual as well as the
village land of Namthanjang Rongmei village under Kangchup-Geljang subdivision was affected by widening of NH-37 of Imphal-Jiribam from Km 11.522 to
Km 45.785. The petitioners comprising 54 households are very much aggrieved
with the proposal of the respondent authorities that the entire compensation
amount for acquisition of both common village land and private land shall be
handed over to the fifth respondent, who is not even the Chief/Khullakpa of
Namthanjang Rongmei village. In this regard, the petitioners have submitted a
representation dated 17.11.2021 to the second respondent
stating
their
grievances and requested to give the land compensation in regard to the
acquisition of common village land to the general public of the village.
9. The learned counsel further submitted that if the compensation amount
of common village land is given to the fifth respondent and his group, the
petitioners have an apprehension that they will not share the compensation
amount and dishonestly take away all the money for themselves.
10. Adding further, the learned counsel submitted that earlier the fifth
respondent misappropriated the village funds, as a result of which, there was
conflicts between the villagers.
In fact, the fifth respondent left the village and
settled elsewhere and when the village authority was elected, he returned to the
village and fraudulently claiming to be the Chief/Khullakpa of Namthanjang
Rongmei village with an intention to dishonestly take away the compensation
amount. Since the petitioners have reasonable apprehension that the second
respondent may give away the compensation for acquisition of common village
land of Namthanjang Rongmei village to the fifth respondent and their party, the
petitioner has filed the present writ petition.
11. The learned Government Advocate appearing for the respondents 1 to
3 submitted that there is no proposal for handing over the entire compensation for
acquisition of both common village land and private land to the fifth respondent.
He would submit that since the Chief is the owner of the common village land, it
is very difficult for the authorities to take action for giving compensation directly to
the villagers.
12. The learned Government Advocate further submitted that as per the
record, the fifth respondent is the Chief/Khullakpa of Namthanjang Rongmei
village and there is no fraudulent claim from the fifth respondent regarding the
taking of compensation and that the process of giving compensation will be done
as per law and not in the interest of a private individual or group of persons.
13. The learned counsel for the fourth respondent submitted that the fourth
respondent has no role in deciding the person for the post of Chief/Khullakpa of
Namthangjang Rongmei village and the fourth respondent is only project
implementation unit and not an authority for land acquisition.
The payment of
land compensation is liable to be made by the concerned Deputy Commissioner
(CALA) based on the details of the beneficiaries.
14. The learned counsel for the fifth respondent submitted that the
petitioners are not villagers of Namthanjang Rongmei village and their lands are
not affected by the widening of NH-37 from Imphal to Jiribam. On the other hand,
it is the fifth respondent and his villagers lands which are affected by the widening
of the said road. The petitioners are outsiders and they had no locus standi in the
affairs of the Namthanjang Rongmei village. The petitioners are attempting to
mislead this Court by suppressing the true facts.
15. The learned counsel would submit that the fifth respondent is the
hereditary Chief/Khullakpa of the village, a hill house tax paying village recognized
by the State Government of Manipur. The petitioners have no right in the lands
of Namthanjang Rongmei village. Even assuming without admitting that the
petitioners have locus standi to seek the relief prayed for the in the writ petition,
the process of land acquisition in question is under process. In the land acquisition
proceedings in question, there are 16 individual households whose properties are
affected and those households shall be individually entitled for compensation.
However, for the other lands or properties affected in respect of Namthanjang
Rongmei village, the fifth respondent is the sole interested party. Arguing so, the
learned counsel prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.
16. This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused the
materials available on record.
17. The grievance of the petitioners is that Namthanjang Rongmei village
is comprised about 70 households with a population of more than 500 and the
petitioners comprising more than 54 households are very much aggrieved by the
proposal of the respondents 2 and 3 that the entire compensation amount for
acquisition of both common village land and private land shall be handed over to
the fifth respondent, who is stated to be the Chief/Khullakpa of Namthanjang
Rongmei village. In this regard, the petitioners have submitted a representation
on 17.11.2021 and despite receipt of the said representation, the second
respondent is attempting to hand over the compensation for the common village
land to the fifth respondent and also informed that all matters are to be
communicated through the fifth respondent.
According to the petitioners, if
compensation amount in respect of the common village land is handed over to the
fifth respondent and his group, the petitioners have an apprehension that they will
not share the compensation amount and they will take away all the amount for
themselves.
18. The very apprehension expressed by the petitioners has been refuted
by the official respondents, particularly the respondents 2 and 3 by contending
that there is no proposal for handing over the entire compensation for acquisition
of both common village land and the private land to the fifth respondent. Further,
as per the record maintained, the fifth respondent is the Chief/Khullakpa of
Namthanjang Rongmei village and since the village Chief is the owner of the
common village land, the authority concerned would face difficulties for giving
compensation directly to the villagers.
19. On the other hand, the contesting fifth respondent contended that the
petitioners are not villagers of Namthanjang Rongmei village and their lands are
not affected by the widening of NH-37 from Imphal to Jiribam and that the
petitioners are outsiders and they have no locus standi in the affairs of the
Namthanjang Rongmei village. Further, in the land acquisition proceedings in
question there are 16 individual households whose properties are affected and
those households shall be individually entitled for compensation respectively.
However, for the other lands or properties affected in respect of Namthanjang
Rongmei village, the fifth respondent is the sole interested party.
20. As could be seen from the pleadings of the parties, the respondent
authorities are taking steps to acquire a huge portions of land starting from BRTF
camp to Phirup Khumbi Lok comprising both individual as well as common village
land of Namthanjang Rongmei village under Kangchup-Geljang Sub-Division,
Kangpokpi District for widening of NH-37 of Imphal-Jiribam from Km 11.522 to Km
45.785. The petitioners are claiming that in respect of the common village land,
the compensation has to be paid to them and not to the fifth respondent, who is
not at all Chief/Khullakpa of Namthanjang Rongmei village.
Further, there
appears to be a rival claim in respect of the common village land of Namthanjang
Rongmei village.
21. It is pertinent to note that since the petitioners claimed that the
compensation in respect of the common village land is to be paid to them and not
to the fifth respondent and the fifth respondent claimed that the petitioners are no
way connected with the common village land of the acquired land, this Court is of
the view that it would be appropriate to refer the dispute to the decision of the civil
court by the competent authority as mandated under Section 3H(4) of the National
Highways Act, 1956, which reads thus:
“3H. Deposit and payment of amount. –
(1) to (3) ….
(4) If any dispute arises as to the apportionment of the amount or any part
thereof or to any person to whom the same or any part thereof is payable,
the competent authority shall refer the dispute to the decision of the
principal civil court of original jurisdiction within the limits of whose
jurisdiction the land is situated.”
22. In the light of the mandate stipulated under Section 3H(4) of the
National Highways Act, 1956, this is a fit case for the competent authority to refer
the dispute to the civil court for decision qua the entitlement and/or apportionment
of the compensation amount to be paid in respect of the common village land
involved in this case.
23. Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the
competent authority to refer the dispute to the decision of the principal civil court
of original jurisdiction within the limits of whose jurisdiction the land in question is
situated as provided under Section 3H(4) of the National Highways Act, 1956,
within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. Upon
reference being made by the competent authority, the concerned civil court is
directed to resolve the dispute on merits and in accordance with law, as
expeditiously as possible. No costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review