Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WA.1128 of 2023
-:1:-
2025:KER:28902
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. NITIN JAMDAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.MANU
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 1128 OF 2023
[AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 20.03.2023 IN WP(C)
NO.15568/2013]
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS IN THE WP(C):
TAHASILDAR (REVENUE RECOVERY),
VATAKARA, PIN – 673010.
THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KOZHIKODE, PIN – 673001.
BY GOVERNMENT PLEADER SMT. RESMITHA R. CHANDRAN
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER IN WP(C):
KIRAN GUPTA, PROPRIETRIX,
M/S. REVION ENTERPRISES: (NOW DEFUNCT)
4/147, AKASH DEEP, JAWAHAR NAGAR COLONY,
CALICUT., PIN – 673006.
BY ADVS. SRI. K.I.MAYANKUTTY MATHER (SENIOR)
SMT. PARVATHY
THIS WRIT
02.04.2025, THE
FOLLOWING:
APPEAL HAVING
COURT ON THE
BEEN
SAME
FINALLY HEARD ON
DAY DELIVERED THE
WA.1128 of 2023
-:2:2025:KER:28902
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 2nd day of April, 2025.
Nitin Jamdar, C. J.
By this Appeal filed under Section 5 of the Kerala High Court Act,
1958, the Appellants – State authorities seek to challenge the judgment
of the learned Single Judge directing the Appellants not to treat the
property of the Respondent – Original Petitioner as “bought-in-land”
and to drop all further proceedings in that regard.
2.
The Appellants are the Tahasildar (Revenue Recovery), Vatakara,
and the District Collector, Kozhikode. The Respondent – Original
Petitioner, has been doing business in sandalwood oil.
3.
The Petitioner was in arrears of a substantial amount of sales tax to
the tune of ₹35,96,755/-. for the assessment years 1992-93 and 199394. A demand for tax and penalty was raised. Two properties of the
Petitioner were attached by Appellant No.1 and the Tahsildar,
Kozhikode; one of them was 7.88 ½ acres of agricultural land. The
Petitioner received a notice stating that the properties would be sold in an
auction. Subsequently, a further notice was issued by the Sales Tax
authorities. The Petitioner then sought relief under the amnesty scheme.
The Petitioner was informed that the properties were already taken over
by the Appellants. The Petitioner has also filed W.P.(C) No.15 of 2011
WA.1128 of 2023
-:3:2025:KER:28902
in which this Court on 20 January 2011 directed the Assistant
Commissioner, Special Circle-1, Kozhikode, to reconsider the matter and
pass appropriate orders on the application seeking benefits under the
amnesty scheme. The Petitioner, based on the contention that she was
permitted to settle the tax arrears and that the amount demanded has
been fully paid, filed W.P.(C) No.15568 of 2013 seeking issuance of a
writ of mandamus directing the Respondents/Appellants not to treat her
properties as “bought-in land” and to drop all or any proceedings
initiated to treat her property as “bought-in land”. A counter affidavit
dated 27 September 2013 was filed by Appellant No.1 in the writ
petition, and further affidavits were filed by the Petitioner.
4.
The learned Single Judge by judgment dated 20 March 2023
recorded that the Petitioner has not cleared the dues and she has not been
able to produce the proof of the payment of 1993-94 as per the original
demand along with the penalty amount. However, the learned Single
Judge held that in order to strike equity, the Petitioner be permitted to
pay the same with interest within a period of one month, and the
Appellants were directed to release the property in favour of the
Petitioner. Challenging this judgment dated 20 March 2023, the present
Appeal was filed and by order dated 15 November 2023, the operation
and implementation of the judgment dated 20 March 2023 has been
stayed by this Court.
WA.1128 of 2023
5.
-:4:2025:KER:28902
We have heard Ms. Resmitha R. Chandran, the learned
Government Pleader for the Appellants, and Ms. Parvathy, the learned
counsel for the Respondent.
6.
The Appellants, in the counter affidavit dated 27 September 2013,
have placed on record that the revenue recovery actions were already
completed and that the landed property was now under the custody of
the Tahsildar, Koyilandy, and included in the scheme for distributing it
to the landless people. The Petitioner has not denied this assertion made
in the counter affidavit. Thus, the prayer in the writ petition for a writ of
mandamus is to direct the State to hand over possession of the property.
The property is now in the possession of the State Government and
forms part of the pool for allotment to the landless.
7.
The learned Government Pleader submitted that the case of the
Petitioner is based on falsehood and that the petition suffers from
suppression of material facts. The learned Government Pleader
submitted that in the petition, the Petitioner asserted that she had paid
the entire arrears under the amnesty scheme. However, the Appellants, in
the counter affidavit, have pointed out that though permission was
granted to the Petitioner to settle the arrears under the amnesty scheme,
the Petitioner did not settle the arrears for the assessment year 1993-94.
Consequently, the permission granted to settle the arrears for the year
1993-94 under the amnesty scheme was cancelled by order dated 29
WA.1128 of 2023
-:5:2025:KER:28902
October 2011. The learned Government Pleader submitted that,
thereupon in an additional affidavit filed by the Petitioner, reference was
made only to the settlement of arrears for the year 1992-93. The learned
Government Pleader, relying on this position, submitted that the
Petitioner is not entitled to any relief. We find merits in the contention.
The Petitioner had specifically stated on oath in the petition that she had
cleared all the arrears under the amnesty scheme. However, when faced
with the counter affidavit filed by the Appellant – State, the Petitioner
changed her version that only a part of the amount had been paid. This
was a clear misstatement on the part of the Petitioner, which dis-entitles
her from seeking relief under the equity jurisdiction.
8.
On merits, the learned Government Pleader submitted that having
not cleared the dues, merely on equity, a writ of mandamus cannot be
issued. The learned Government Pleader relied upon the decisions of the
Supreme Court in the cases of Bihar Eastern Gangetic Fishermen Co-
operative Society Ltd. v. Sipahi Singh and Others1 and Oriental Bank of
Commerce v. Sunder Lal Jain and Another2.
9.
The learned counsel for the Respondent submitted that the learned
Single Judge has passed the impugned order in equity, permitting the
arrears to be paid with interest. It was further contended that no
prejudice would be caused to the Appellants, and therefore, the order
1 (1977) 4 SCC 145
2 (2008) 2 SCC 280
WA.1128 of 2023
-:6:-
passed by the learned Single Judge should be sustained.
2025:KER:28902
10. The Petitioner had sought for a writ of mandamus. The basic
prerequisite for issuing a writ of mandamus is the existence of a legal
right and performance of statutory duty by the Authority against whom
mandamus is sought. In the case at hand, admittedly, the Petitioner was
in arrears of a substantial amount of demand towards sales tax. The
Petitioner had received a notice on 26 February 2003 intimating that the
property would be sold in an auction on 29 March 2003. The Petitioner
took no steps in that regard. The requisition for the realization of sales
tax arrears for the years 1992-93 and 1993-94 was to the tune of
₹35,96,755/-. Since the Petitioner did not make the payment even after
receipt of the statutory notice, properties, including the landed property
to the extent of 7.88 ½ acres, were attached. Despite being permitted to
settle the dues under the amnesty scheme, the Petitioner did not do so for
the year 1993-94, and the permission was subsequently revoked. Even as
per the amended Section 50A of the Kerala Revenue Recovery Act,
1968, the period of limitation for reconveyance of “bought-in-land” is
five years from the date of confirmation of sale. The Petitioner took no
steps to settle the arrears for these years, and ultimately, after ten years,
the property was put on sale, and the sale was confirmed on 26 July
2003. Ten years thereafter, the writ petition was filed.
11. No legal right of the Petitioner has been demonstrated; neither is it
WA.1128 of 2023
-:7:2025:KER:28902
referred to in the impugned order. Merely out of sympathy, a writ of
mandamus cannot be issued to return the property after the State has
lawfully taken over the property of a tax defaulter through a completed
action. Even for the exercise of equity jurisdiction, no special
circumstances were placed on record by the Petitioner to make out a case
in that regard. Therefore, the Petitioner who neither cleared the arrears,
nor filed any statutory appeal, approached this Court after a decade with
gross laches, was not entitled to the issuance of a writ of mandamus
directing the State to hand over possession of the property vested in it.
12. Accordingly, the Appeal is allowed. The judgment dated 20 March
2023 in W.P.(C) No.15568 of 2013 is quashed and set aside and the
writ petition is dismissed.
Sd/NITIN JAMDAR,
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/S. MANU,
JUDGE
krj/-
WA.1128 of 2023
-:8:2025:KER:28902
APPENDIX OF WA 1128/2023
APPELLANTS’ ANNEXURES:ANNEX.-1
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE DATED 25/04/2003
INTIMATING THE DATE OF AUCTION AS 09/05/2003.
ANNEX.-2
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE DATED 09/05/2003
INTIMATING THE DATE OF AUCTION AS 23/05/2003.
ANNEX.-3
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO. REF. D. 5088/03
(1) DATED 26/07/2003.
RESPONDENT’S ANNEXURES:-
NIL
//TRUE COPY//
P.A. TO C.J.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review