Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:46
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 28th APRIL, 2016
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Appellant
:
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha,
S/o Tshering Wangdi Lepcha,
Singhik, Sentam,
Mangan,
P.O. & P.S. Singhik Mangan,
North Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
The Branch Manager,
United Insurance India Insurance Company Ltd.,
having its Branch Office at
Deorali Bazar,
NH 31A,
Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
Appeal under Section 173
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chhetri and Ms.
Malati Sharma, Advocates for the Appellant.
Mr. Thupden G. Bhutia, Advocate for the Respondent.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
This Appeal assails the Judgment dated 30-09-2014 of
the Learned Member, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, North
Sikkim at Mangan, (for short “the Claims Tribunal”), in MACT Case
No.06 of 2014, wherein the Claims Tribunal, inter alia, came to a
finding that the Appellant, owner of the vehicle, who was injured in
the accident was not a third party (as envisaged under Section 147 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988) and hence, the Respondent-Insurance
Company was not liable to pay compensation to him, other than the
liability mentioned in Exhibit 5, i.e., Insurance Certificate Policy, and
thereby dismissed the Claim Petition.
2.
Before this Court, Learned Counsel for the Appellant,
contended that the Claims Tribunal was in error in dismissing the
Claim Petition although it reached the finding that the liability of
the Opposite Party extended to the amount mentioned in the
Insurance Policy. That, the Claims Tribunal was also in error in
arriving at the finding that the Claimant did not come under the
category of “third party”. That as the Insurance Policy was a Private
Car “Package Policy”, i.e., a Comprehensive Insurance Policy, it
covered the Appellant as well, towards which reliance was placed on
the decisions of The Branch Manager, New India Assurance
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Jasu Subba and Others1; Senior Branch
Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Smt. Namita Dixit and
Others2 and National Insurance Company Limited vs. Balakrishnan
and Another3. That the Respondent was not able to prove that the
accident took place due to the rash and negligent act of the victim
and hence, the Appellant is entitled to an Award of Rs.13,37,636/(Rupees thirteen lakhs thirty seven thousand six hundred and thirty
six) only, as put forth in the Claim Petition. It was canvassed that
the Claims Tribunal is to hand out a ‘just’ compensation for which
reliance was placed on Rajesh and Others vs. Rajbir Singh and
Others4 and hence, the Judgment of the Claims Tribunal be set aside
and compensation be granted to the Appellant as prayed in the
Claim Petition.
3.
Per contra, the stand taken by the Respondent was that
in the first instance the Claim Petition was dismissed as there was no
necessity for the Claimant to have approached the Tribunal as the
liability to the extent of Rs.2,00,000/-(Rupees two lakhs) only, was
admitted by the Respondent. That the facts in National Insurance
Company Limited vs. Balakrishnan and Another3 are different from
the facts and circumstances in the instant case.
It was also
contended that in The Branch Manager, New India Assurance
1. AIR 2011 Sikkim 37
2. AIR 2010 Sikkim 50
3. (2013) 1 SCC 731
4. (2013) 9 SCC 54
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
Company Ltd. vs. Smt. Jasu Subba and Others1 relied on by the
Appellant, the matter pertained to an accident of a commercial
vehicle as opposed to a private vehicle which is in question here,
while in Senior Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Smt.
Namita Dixit and Others2 the matter dealt with a gratuitous
passenger and hence, are to be differentiated from the facts of this
case. That Section 147 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short
“the Act”) contemplates compensation to a third party and not to
the owner who does not come within such ambit, his Claim being
confined to the limits indicated in the Insurance Policy. To fortify
his submissions, Counsel has placed reliance on New India Assurance
Company Limited
vs. Prabha Devi and Others5 and Oriental
Insurance Company Limited vs. Sudhakaran K. V. and Others6.
4.
The rival contentions of both Counsel have been heard
at length and duly considered. Consideration has also been given to
documents relied on by the Appellant before the Claims Tribunal. I
have also perused the impugned Judgment.
5.
What falls for consideration before this Court is
whether the Appellant, the insured, being the owner of the vehicle is
a third party as envisaged under Section 147 of the Act and entitled
to the amount of Rs.13,37,636/- (Rupees thirteen lakhs thirty seven
5. (2013) 14 SCC 719
6. (2008) 7 SCC 428
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
thousand six hundred and thirty six) only, or whether he is entitled
to Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees two lakhs) only, the limit prescribed in the
Insurance Policy, as personal accident cover for the owner?
6.
In order to deal with the merits of the arguments, it
would be necessary to briefly narrate the facts of the case;
On 26-02-2014 the Appellant/victim, the owner of the vehicle
which he was driving at the relevant time was returning to his house
in Singhik, North Sikkim at around 1.40 a.m. along with his friends,
after attending a marriage at Mangan, North Sikkim. The vehicle
went off the road approximately 1000 feet below at “Sungrung Bhir”
near Singhik. Out of the five persons travelling in the vehicle, one
died on the spot, while others sustained injuries including the victim
who was taken to Mangan Hospital, then referred to Manipal
Hospital, 5th Mile, Tadong at Gangtok, thereafter taken to BLK Super
Speciality Hospital, Delhi.
He underwent an emergency major
surgery of his right thigh due to fractured femur. A Mangan P.S.
Case was registered under Sections 279/337/338/304A of the Indian
Penal Code, 1860. The victim by filing the Claim Petition sought
medical expenses including doctor and hospital charges and future
medical expenses, calculated at Rs.13,37,636/- (Rupees thirteen lakhs
thirty seven thousand six hundred and thirty six) only.
7.
Before the Tribunal, the Respondent resisted the Claim
of the Appellant, inter alia, on grounds that he was not a third party
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
and consequently not covered by the Insurance, apart from a sum of
Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees two lakhs) only, for which premium had been
paid on account of personal accident insurance.
8.
While considering the arguments placed by Learned
Counsel, it would be essential in the first instance to appreciate that
Section 147 of the Act lays down the requirements of the policies
and limits of liability in respect of the passengers and persons other
than passengers in relation to passenger vehicles and goods
carriages. It may be clarified here that a contract of insurance is a
contract of indemnity, the insurer is an indemnifier and the insured
is an indemnity holder. The essence of a contract of Insurance thus
is to indemnify the insured against the Claim of a third party. The
expression “third party” means a person who is not a party to the
Contract but is a beneficiary of the Contract and has the right to
enforce the terms thereof against the insurer and the insured.
9.
Coming to Section 163A of the Act this provision
commences with a non-obstante clause and provides for payment of
compensation on “no fault” basis. While addressing the argument of
the Appellant that the Respondent was not able to prove that the
accident took place due to the rash and negligent act of the victim,
in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Meena Variyal and Others 7, while
discussing this aspect it was held in Paragraph 27 as follows:7. (2007) 5 SCC 428
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
“27. We think that the law laid down in Minu
B. Mehta v. Balkrishna Ramchandra Nayan [(1977) 2 SCC
441] was accepted by the legislature while enacting the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 by introducing Section 163A of the Act providing for payment of compensation
notwithstanding anything contained in the Act or in
any other law for the time being in force that the
owner of a motor vehicle or the authorised insurer
shall be liable to pay in the case of death or
permanent disablement due to accident arising out of
the use of the motor vehicle, compensation, as
indicated in the Second Schedule, to the legal heirs or
the victim, as the case may be, and in a claim made
under Sub-section (1) of Section 163-A of the Act, the
claimant shall not be required to plead or establish that
the death or permanent disablement in respect of which
the claim has been made was due to any wrongful act or
neglect or default of the owner of the vehicle concerned.
Therefore, the victim of an accident or his
dependants have an option either to proceed under
Section 166 of the Act or under Section 163-A of the
Act. Once they approach the Tribunal under
Section 166 of the Act, they have necessarily to take
upon themselves the burden of establishing the
negligence of the driver or owner of the vehicle
concerned. But if they proceed under Section 163-A of
the Act, the compensation will be awarded in terms of
the Schedule without calling upon the victim or his
dependants to establish any negligence or default on
the part of the owner of the vehicle or the driver of
the vehicle.”
[emphasis supplied]
10.
Hence, Section 163A of the Act was incorporated by the
Legislature in the Statute under a Welfare Scheme to provide
benefits to the family of the victim and/or injured person falling
within the income group to the extent of Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty
thousand) only, per annum. An exception clause is manifest in the
Section vide which the Claimant is not required to prove rash and
negligent driving of the offending vehicle as the cause of accident.
In other words, to quell the argument of Learned Counsel for the
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
Appellant, it is clarified here that the question of the Respondent or
for that matter the Appellant having to prove rash and negligent
driving under Section 163A of the Act does not arise at all since the
provision of Law does not contemplate so.
11.
Dealing further with the matter under Section 163A of
the Act, the Hon’ble Apex Court in Oriental Insurance Company
Limited vs. Rajni Devi and Others8 was of the view that it is now a
well-settled principle of law that in a case where third party is
involved, the liability of the insurance company would be unlimited.
Where, however, compensation is claimed for the death of the
owner or another passenger of the vehicle, the contract of insurance
being governed by the contract qua contract, the claim of the
insurance company would depend upon the terms thereof.
It
further opined that the said provisions cannot be said to have any
application in regard to an accident wherein the owner of the
vehicle himself is involved. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the said
Judgment also referred to a plethora of Judgments being as follows;
(i)
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Smt. Jhuma Saha9 wherein it
was held as hereunder;
“10. The deceased was the owner of the
vehicle. For the reasons stated in the claim petition or
otherwise, he himself was to be blamed for the
accident. The accident did not involve motor vehicle
other than the one which he was driving. The
8. (2008) 5 SCC 736
9. (2007) 9 SCC 263
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
question which arises for consideration is that the
deceased himself being negligent, the claim petition
under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
would be maintainable.
11. Liability of the insurer Company is to the
extent of indemnification of the insured against the
respondent or an injured person, a third person or in
respect of damages of property. Thus, if the insured
cannot be fastened with any liability under the
provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, the question of
the insurer being liable to indemnify the insured,
therefore, does not arise.”
(ii)
In Dhanraj vs. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. and Another10 it is
stated as follows;
“8. Thus, an insurance policy covers the
liability incurred by the insured in respect of
death of or bodily injury to any person
(including an owner of the goods or his
authorised representative) carried in the
vehicle or damage to any property of a third
party caused by or arising out of the use of the
vehicle. Section 147 does not require an
insurance company to assume risk for death or
bodily injury to the owner of the vehicle.
9. .............................................................
10. In this case, it has not been shown
that the policy covered any risk for injury to
the owner himself. We are unable to accept the
contention that the premium of Rs 4989 paid
under the heading “Own damage” is for
covering liability towards personal injury.
Under the heading “Own damage”, the words
“premium on vehicle and non-electrical
accessories” appear. It is thus clear that this
premium is towards damage to the vehicle and
not for injury to the person of the owner. An
owner of a vehicle can only claim provided a
personal accident insurance has been taken
out. In this case there is no such insurance.”
(iii)
In National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Laxmi Narain Dhut11, it has
been held that -
10. (2004) 8 SCC 553
11. (2007) 3 SCC 700
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
“21. Where the claim relates to own
damage claims, it cannot be adjudicated by the
insurance company. But it has to be decided by
another forum i.e. forum created under the
Consumer Protection Act, 1985 (in short ‘the
‘CP Act’). Before the Tribunal, there were
essentially three parties i.e. the insurer,
insured and the claimants. On the contrary,
before the Consumer Forums there were two
parties i.e. owner of the vehicle and the
insurer. The claimant does not come into the
picture. Therefore, these are cases where there
is no third party involved.
The said principle has been reiterated recently
in Prem Kumari v. Prahlad Dev [(2008) 3 SCC 193]
and Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Prithvi Raj [(2008) 2
SCC 338].
11. The liability under Section 163-A of the Act
is on the owner of the vehicle as a person cannot be
both, a claimant as also a recipient. The heirs of Janak
Raj could not have maintained a claim in terms of
Section 163-A of the Act. For the said purpose only
the terms of the contract of insurance could be taken
recourse to.”
12.
In New India Assurance Company Limited vs. Prabha
Devi and Others5 relied on by the Insurance Company, the question
dealt with was extension of statutory benefits of insurance of third
parties to the owner of the vehicle when he is injured/dies in an
accident involving the insured vehicle. While discussing the matter
the Hon’ble Apex Court referred to the Judgment of Dhanraj vs. New
India Assurance Co. Ltd. and Another10 and based on its ratio, opined
in New India Assurance Company Limited
vs. Prabha Devi and
Others5 that where the vehicle had overturned resulting in the death
of the owner, the legal heirs were not entitled to the compensation
as the third party claim could not be granted to the legal
representatives of the deceased the owner.
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
13.
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
In Oriental Insurance Company Limited vs. Sudhakaran
K. V. and Others6 the deceased was travelling as a pillion-rider on a
scooter from which she fell off and succumbed to injuries sustained
by her. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal while deciding the
Claim Petition found that the accident had taken place due to rash
and negligent riding of the scooter by the Respondent No.1 to the
Claim Petition.
As regards the liability of the Appellant Insurer it
was held that as the existence of the Insurance Policy in respect of
the offending scooter was admitted it was also liable.
The High
Court dismissed the Appeal of the Insurance Company, hence the
matter reached the Hon’ble Apex Court. The question that arose
before the said Court was whether a pillion-rider on a scooter would
be a third party within the meaning of Section 147 of the Act. This
question was answered in the negative. It was held, inter alia, as
follows:“13. In terms of Section 147 of the Act only in
regard to reimbursement of the claim to a third
party, a contract of insurance must be taken by the
owners of the vehicle. It is imperative in nature.
When, however, an owner of a vehicle intends to
cover himself from other risks; it is permissible to
enter into a contract of insurance in which event the
insurer would be bound to reimburse the owner of
the vehicle strictly in terms thereof.
14. The liability of the insurer to reimburse the
owner in respect of a claim made by the third party,
thus, is statutory whereas other claims are not.”
14.
The Hon’ble Apex Court while discussing a catena of
decisions in the said matter opined in Paragraph 25 of Oriental
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
Insurance Company Limited vs. Sudhakaran K. V. and Others6 that
“The law which emerges from the said decisions, is that the liability
of the insurance company in a case of this nature is not extended to
a pillion-rider of the motor vehicle unless the requisite amount of
premium is paid for covering his/her risk; the legal obligation
arising under Section 147 of the Act cannot be extended to an injury
or death of the owner of vehicle or the pillion-rider; the pillion-rider
in a two-wheeler was not to be treated as a third party when the
accident has taken place owing to rash and negligent riding of the
scooter and not on the part of the driver of another vehicle.”
15.
From the discussions and decisions referred to above, it
is clear that Section 147 of the Act covers only a third party and does
not extend to the owner of the vehicle. Further, if the owner has
covered himself from such risks the insured would be bound to
reimburse the owner strictly in terms thereof.
16.
Later in time, however, in the judgment of National
Insurance Company Limited vs. Balakrishnan and Another3, the
Apex Court has taken into consideration a decision of the Hon’ble
Delhi High Court being Yashpal Luthra vs. United India Insurance Co.
Ltd. and Another12. The Apex Court referring to the said decision,
inter alia, held that –
12. MAC Appeal No.176 of 2009, Order dated 26-11-2009
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
“24. …………………………….. It had also admitted that
the “comprehensive policy” is presently called a
“package policy”. It is the admitted position, as the
decision would show, the earlier Circulars dated 18-31978 and 2-6-1986 continue to be valid and effective
and all insurance companies are bound to pay the
compensation in respect of the liability towards an
occupant in a car under the “comprehensive/package
policy” irrespective of the terms and conditions
contained in the policy. The competent authority of
the IRDA was also examined before the High Court
who stated that the Circulars dated 18-3-1978 and 26-1986 of the Tariff Advisory Committee were
incorporated in the Indian Motor Tariff effective
from 1-7-2002 and they continue to be operative and
binding on the insurance companies. Because of the
aforesaid factual position, the Circulars dated 16-112009 and 3-12-2009, that have been reproduced
hereinabove, were issued.
25. It is also worthy to note that the High
Court, after referring to individual circulars issued by
various insurance companies, eventually stated thus:
(Yashpal Luthra case [2011 ACJ 1415 (Del)], ACJ p. 1424,
para 27)
“27. In view of the aforesaid, it is clear
that the comprehensive/package policy of a
two-wheeler covers a pillion rider and
comprehensive/package policy of a private car
covers the occupants and where the vehicle is
covered under a comprehensive/package
policy, there is no need for Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal to go into the question
whether the Insurance Company is liable to
compensate for the death or injury of a pillion
rider on a two-wheeler or the occupants in a
private car. In fact, in view of the TAC's
directives and those of the IRDA, such a plea
was not permissible and ought not to have
been raised as, for instance, it was done in the
present case.”
26. In view of the aforesaid factual position,
there is no scintilla of doubt that a
“comprehensive/package policy” would cover the
liability of the insurer for payment of compensation
for the occupant in a car. There is no cavil that an
“Act Policy” stands on a different footing from a
“comprehensive/package policy". As the circulars
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
have made the position very clear and the IRDA,
which is presently the statutory authority, has
commanded the insurance companies stating that a
“comprehensive/package policy” covers the liability,
there cannot be any dispute in that regard. We may
hasten to clarify that the earlier pronouncements
were rendered in respect of the “Act Policy” which
admittedly cannot cover a third-party risk of an
occupant in a car. But, if the policy is a
“comprehensive/package policy”, the liability would
be covered. These aspects were not noticed in
Bhagyalakshmi [(2009) 7 SCC 148] and, therefore, the
matter was referred to a larger Bench. We are
disposed to think that there is no necessity to refer
the present matter to a larger Bench as the IRDA,
which is presently the statutory authority, has
clarified the position by issuing circulars which have
been reproduced in the judgment by the Delhi High
Court and we have also reproduced the same.”
[emphasis supplied]
17.
There is no further necessity to elucidate what has been
clarified above with regard to Comprehensive Policy/Package Policy,
pillion-rider and occupant, in a private vehicle. Suffice it to say that
a Comprehensive Package Policy, inter alia, covers the occupants of
a Private Car who are, therefore, to be indemnified.
18.
Bearing the decisions supra in mind, in conclusion, a
perusal of Exhibit 5, the Insurance Policy, indicates that it is a
Private Car Package Policy but the liability of the Insurance
Company to the “owner” driver who is the insured, extends to a sum
of Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees two lakhs) only. The question of the owner
being a third party is not tenable in view of the provisions of Section
147 of the Act and the plethora of Judgments cited above.
2016:SHC:46
MAC App. No.24 of 2014
Shri Tenzing Wangdi Lepcha
19.
vs.
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
Consequently, I do not find any reason to interfere with
the findings of the Learned Claims Tribunal except to the extent that
the Respondent is liable to pay the Appellant the amount of
Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees two lakhs) only, in terms laid out in Exhibit 5,
with simple interest @ 9% per annum, from the date of filing of the
Claim Petition, till full and final settlement.
The impugned
Judgment of the Claims Tribunal stands modified accordingly.
20.
In the result, the Appeal is allowed in part.
21.
No order as to costs.
22.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Claims Tribunal
for information.
23.
Records of the Claims Tribunal be remitted forthwith.
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
28-04-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review